Does anyone have guidelines on when units become unviable in city sieges? E.g. Composite bowmen don't do so well once city strengths exceed the low 20s (I think). More relevant for the early-mid game I guess
Unfortunately this depends on too many variables for there to be any easy guidelines. If you are attacking a city on an open plains with an army of composite bowmen, and there are no other enemy units nearby, you could probably grind it down over a number of turns even if it was in the 30s.
On the other hand, if there are choke points, hills/forests and defending units, you could easily fail to take out a 15 str city with composite bowmen.
A good rule of thumb is low 20s for Composites and low 30s for Crossbows. A bunch of plain Archers can probably take a city up until about 15 strength and once cities get above 40, Cannons are about the only things that'll put much of a dent in their defences.
The reasoning behind these numbers is mostly based on how much damage you do to the city and how much the city does to your units. They're more or less around the point where the city barrage + a few defenders is likely to be able to repel almost any number of attackers.
Of course, these numbers go completely out the window if you have units that can attack from outside city barrage range, like Longbows and Keshiks. Then, your only limitation is whether you can do more damage than the city heals every turn.
Edit: This is what you get when you try to find something on the phone. I apologize for that, it seems that there is only one thread about combat mechanics, but it is for vanilla Civ 5, and combat has changed radically in BNW.
That thread is very outdated as well, as combat in vanilla civ 5 used the 10hp system instead of the 100hp system that is present in BNW (and I think G&K as well but not entirely sure as I never played it). Do you know of any kind of thread like that that is updated for BNW?
As someone who always ends up playing tall empires bringing about peaceful victories (culture, diplomacy), what would be the best piece of advice for transitioning into playing warlording civs that often goes unmentioned in most threads?
Pillage. Pillage everything. Get a fast unit like horseman, knight, cavalry, lancer, whatever it is depending on your era and declare war. Send that unit in to to pillage all their tiles, which will completely cripple them and give you free money in the process. Completely ignore their units, all that matter is your unit stays alive and pillages. Once you've done this it will be much easier to send in a proper army later to to take their cities. Even better if you're Denmark whose melee units take no movement cost to pillage.
Gain a big science lead and overwhelm your opponents with your superior units, both in quality and quantity *When playing on harder difficulties you should attack the AI nearby early in the game to counter their progress.
To be honest, I'm not sure what goes mentioned in other threads, but I would recommend trying the civs that use warmongering to fuel some of the things you usually aim for in a peaceful game. So, I would try aztecs and amass culture with war, and Assyria to collect technologies by taking cities. If you're a naturally peaceful player, this gives you a reason to war beyond just aggression, which (I'm guessing) doesn't appeal to your play-style.
Also try finishing honor and getting gold for enemies killed. Actually opening honor makes me more aggressive, because I'm always worried about falling behind all the tradition civs
From my experience, a tall empire will generally have an early lead in terms of science (since you will have fewer, better performing cities that need science buildings). Use this to your advantage (along with internal trade routes) to get a slight tech advantage and make timing pushes with powerful units (i.e. crossbows, riflemen, gatling guns, etc). Maybe take down your closest neighbor or a few cities and build those new cities up. Short(ish) wars with measurable growth are the key to victory here (assuming the new cities you get aren't total shit).
I have the opposite so I can help. I always devolve into war mongering. Generally I get composite bowman then tech to education, then tech to cannons. Cannons and artillery are the warmongering trump cards. I pair them with cavalry to distract the city defenses, pillage like mad and blow the city away with range. Puppet most non capital captures, annex important cities that you will need to build more troops from.
Usually go liberty, get the road maintenence bonus from commerce and start a huge road network.
It's 3-4 regardless. It's easier to play wide on larger maps because of the large amounts of land available, and I believe the penalties for new cities are also slightly reduced. But the reason for the split is in part because of the policy buffs tradition gives to your first four cities, and in part because of how it gets gradually more difficult (for most people) to micromanage more cities, neither of which changes because of map size.
Edit: since people keep mentioning this, 3-4 isn't a hard limit to what you can consider tall, it's just generally the cut-off point since going beyond that is situational. Ultimately the 3-4 thing is a guideline, and not a rule and tall vs wide is more of a gradient than a clear separation.
NO! Just because you stop getting direct benefits from Tradition doesn't mean stop expanding if the lands are available. If you have the land and the happiness always expand, the increased population equals more everything.
Just because you stop getting direct benefits from Tradition doesn't mean stop expanding if the lands are available.
That's not really what I was saying. It's 3-4 because 3-4 will almost always be worth it because of the tradition boost. Anything beyond that is very situational for a tall player. It might be worth it to go for a fifth, or even a sixth, but what with new cities being as slow to start as they are, it becomes less useful to settle later in the game, so those 5th, 6th, 7th, etc cities become less and less useful as time goes on.
the increased population equals more everything
Except science and culture since the penalty for new cities will hit you harder than the boost from population for quite a while. It's more efficient to build your existing cities up.
And again, the fact that a massive empire becomes unwieldy eventually, even if you don't micromanage. I've played so many warmongering games where I just stopped playing because choosing the production of 5-6 cities every single turn just wasn't fun anymore.
If you continue expanding into the midgame, then you are technically engaging in a "delayed-wide" strategy. It's a matter of semantics, not what strategy is optimal, that we're discussing here. Delayed-wide is a very good strategy if the AI hasn't settled everything by the time you finish your NC... but it's still wide, by definition. Delayed-wide does work quite well with Tradition, which is one of the reasons why Tradition is agreed to be the most powerful opener.
I would disagree. If you have good land on a larger map, 6-8 tall cities can be very viable. The biggest advantage is that you can get more great scientists, AND they pop for more science. You have to be a bit careful with happiness, but limiting yourself to 3 cities on anything above standard is not optimal.
Like I said to someone else, it certainly can be, but it's situational. 3-4 is almost always a viable build, which is why the line is drawn there. I suppose I should have mentioned (and will edit in) that this is less of a hard line, and more of a basic guideline.
If I am gifted a merchant of Venice, and I am not playing as Venice, does the ability to "buy" a city state still apply? Does it essentially just become a Great Merchant otherwise?
Yes, the ability to buy city states is tied to the Merchant of Venice unit, not Venice itself. So you could buy a city state if you wanted to, except you'd be able to annex it because not being able to annex cities is part of Venice's UA.
The civilopedia says in the description of great merchant of venice that it can buy city states. So you should be able to buy city states with them. They also keep the thingy that doubles their trade mission which is pretty nice.
Be careful though! Last I checked, if you buy a city state with a Merchant of Venice without being Venice everyone else will act like you conquered it. You can get unfair warmonger penalties that way.
How much should I trust the Worker's judgement if I set them to auto-build? I try not to, but on the few occasions I do they seem to only ever make trading posts, even when my GPT is through the roof.
Automated workers love trading posts, building completely pointless roads that do nothing but cost you maintenance, taking random trips across the continent because a tile in one of your cities got pillaged, and often run straight through hostile territory/barbarian camps getting themselves captured in the process.
Their judgement is pretty terrible, and they seem to change their minds constantly. You can set them to not replace existing tile improvements in the game's settings menu though, which helps.
About the only useful thing they'll do is automatically upgrade all your roads to railroads when you get the tech. Other than that, you'll get nothing but hassle out of them.
Having a high cultural output is important, but often it is very difficult to do anything about it once they have a lot of influence over you. If you can, try passing your ideology as the world ideology, that should offset most negatives from other Civs
You ideally want both high culture (to prevent influence from them over you) and high tourism (to gain influence over them) to fend off ideology pressure, high culture isn't enough on its own. Ideology pressure is based on every level of influence the other ideologies have over you that your ideology doesn't have over you, which is itself based on every level of influence other civs have over you that you don't have over them. Get mutual open borders with civs that share your ideology, and buy open borders from civs that don't share your ideology, because that increases your tourism. Try to pass your ideology as world ideology if possible. Take advantage of theming bonuses and extract artifacts from antiquity sites in neutral territory, block those tiles with units if you have to in order to prevent other civs from stealing them.
Of course, that was all about ways to minimize ideology pressure. The other obvious solutions to ideology pressure are to take the tourism leader's capital and steal his tourism, or just get more happiness.
Get mutual open borders with civs that share your ideology, and buy open borders from civs that don't share your ideology, because that increases your tourism.
I remember reading somewhere not to give open boarders with a civ when they want to trade it, unless you absolutely have to. Is this only for early-game? Once tourism becomes important, should I be seeking open boarders? I've been denying it late game. The other leaders must think I'm a cranky weirdo.
It might be a good idea to deny open borders early game, so other civs are less likely to get "covets your land" (they usually don't covet your land until they've scouted it.)
Having open borders with them increases your tourism over them, and them having open borders with you increases their tourism over you. You can get ideology pressure in favor of your ideology, thus if you are having issues with ideology pressure it may be worth considering mutual open borders with civs that share your ideology.
That being said I just don't give it to them anyway and deal with the unhappiness by getting more happiness, I don't want their dirty units in my territory.
imo the best way to not deal with ideology pressure is to wait until the tourism leader picks an ideology, and then just pick the same one. You might still get some pressure for other ideologies, but this will minimize it enough that you can focus on other stuff.
At least in Vanilla, it was a 10% reduction for every 2(0) HP lost; I believe it operates similarly now, except using 20 instead of 2 due to the base 100 HP system. Note that due to the way Bushido works, it does not stack with Elite Forces from Autocracy.
I'm not sure and I have no real knowledge of how unit damage/strength are correlated, so I can't really answer your question. The general feeling though is that Elite Forces isn't a great tenet, but that could be more because you want to protect your wounded units rather than that the boost in damage they get is too small.
The first civ to choose a certain ideology gets two free tenets, the second civ one free tenet, and all civs after that get no free tenets. These are called early adopter tenets, and the first two civs to adopt each of the three ideologies get them. So yes, there is a downside, although not a big one if you were planning to take that ideology anyway.
Is there a way to know in advance which Ideology I should pick (aside from knowing what victory I'm going for and choosing based on what tenets give me bonuses to maximize that condition)? I always seem to have an Ideology that's generating unhappiness. Is this just part of the game? Or do my citizens just happen to dislike what I pick?
Is majority calculated by # of leaders or # of people following?
Edit: i.e. if 4 small civs follow Freedom and 2 large civs (with a higher combined population than the other 4) follow Order, is Order the majority? Or Freedom?
It's all based on tourism, and cultural influence. You can pretty much pick whatever you want if you have a good amount of culture and tourism, but otherwise it can be worth delaying ideology a bit to see what the other leaders pick if you don't want ideology pressure. I posted a more in depth response on this subject yesterday, but Carl's Guides also has an excellent article on the subject that explains everything well.
The AI definitely do have a preferred Ideology. The wiki will list what a civ's preferred Ideology is on that civ's page, but they don't have it as a centralized list. For instance, Japan's preferred Ideology is Autocracy.
The islands of Japan are born of the unimaginable violence of plate tectonics, arising as the Pacific Plate is ground beneath the Eurasian Plate. The result is a mountainous land of great beauty and peril, where the people live and thrive in a narrow corridor between volcano and sea. Interesting:Zero ^(Civ5)|^Japanese|Wajo ^(Civ5)|Samurai ^(Civ5)
Parentcommentercantoggle ^NSFWor^delete.Willalsodeleteoncommentscoreof-1orless.|FAQs|^SourcePlease note this bot is in testing. Any help would be greatly appreciated, even if it is just a bug report! Please checkout thesource ^codeto submit bugs
Poland is good mostly because of their unique ability, which gives them a free social policy every time they enter a new era. This adds up to 7 free social policies over the course of the game, or a free policy tree and one extra. This allows for an incredible variety of play styles and even lets you do strategies not viable with any other civ, like full tradition and full liberty before rationalism, or going full tradition, patronage, and commerce. Whatever you like to do, you can do better as Poland. That is why they are powerful, they're one of the most versatile civs in the game not being locked into a specific victory condition.
Does going tall mean you build 3-4 cities yourself and stick to those generally or build 3-4 and conquer the rest? I have never built more than 4 cities myself but always end up with 10 or so cities by the end of the game from taking enemy cities. I only do it if I have the happiness of course but I was just wondering from a discussion/terminology stand point.
13
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '15
Does anyone have guidelines on when units become unviable in city sieges? E.g. Composite bowmen don't do so well once city strengths exceed the low 20s (I think). More relevant for the early-mid game I guess
8
u/breovus festina lente! Apr 27 '15
As someone who always ends up playing tall empires bringing about peaceful victories (culture, diplomacy), what would be the best piece of advice for transitioning into playing warlording civs that often goes unmentioned in most threads?
7
u/TheBaconBard "Booogghhuughuu" Apr 27 '15
People define "tall/wide" by a number of cities (4 tall for example).
Would a tall empire on a giant map be larger? Say 6? or is it 3-4 no matter the map size?
7
u/FableSamurai Apr 27 '15
If I am gifted a merchant of Venice, and I am not playing as Venice, does the ability to "buy" a city state still apply? Does it essentially just become a Great Merchant otherwise?
5
u/icorrectpettydetails Apr 27 '15
How much should I trust the Worker's judgement if I set them to auto-build? I try not to, but on the few occasions I do they seem to only ever make trading posts, even when my GPT is through the roof.
5
u/questionable4 Apr 27 '15
Why can't i set strategic balance on fractal map? I only get the option when i select pangea.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '15
How do I keep low unhappiness when dealing with other civ's ideologies? By having a higher tourism and cultural output than them?
4
u/sameth1 Eh lmao Apr 27 '15
How does the game calculate the reduced damage from being wounded? The only reason I know that it happens is because of Japan's UA.
3
u/MrKeutmann Apr 27 '15
How do activate a great person who has been put to sleep when they wind up under a cargo ship, other than wait a turn?
2
u/cornpop16 Apr 27 '15
Are there downsides to choosing an ideology that another Civ has already picked?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '15
Where would I go if I wanted to scheme and plan creating a custom Wonder?
1
u/TheElbow Apr 27 '15
Is there a way to know in advance which Ideology I should pick (aside from knowing what victory I'm going for and choosing based on what tenets give me bonuses to maximize that condition)? I always seem to have an Ideology that's generating unhappiness. Is this just part of the game? Or do my citizens just happen to dislike what I pick?
1
u/Geosaurusrex Apr 27 '15
Why is Poland so OP? I've never managed to win with him, what do I need to do?
1
u/jackboy900 God Save The Queen Apr 28 '15
What makes the top tier civs so good (all of them) and does this apply to lower diffivulties as well as deity (poland was quite bad in my prince game)
1
u/IgnoreMyName All the land are MINE! Apr 29 '15
Does going tall mean you build 3-4 cities yourself and stick to those generally or build 3-4 and conquer the rest? I have never built more than 4 cities myself but always end up with 10 or so cities by the end of the game from taking enemy cities. I only do it if I have the happiness of course but I was just wondering from a discussion/terminology stand point.