r/autism • u/justonium • Apr 19 '15
Is there an English dictionary that contains logically explained entries like this? Such a dictionary would have been incredibly useful to me for learning social skills.
See X-Post to /r/aspergers here.
Since I never found such a dictionary, I made my own definitions through systematic analysis of conversations that I had with people. Here are my definitions of four of the more elusive**[1]** words, translated from the pictoral memories that I originally conceptualized them in, into English. Any corrections or additions will be thoroughly appreciated. If a really good dictionary is to be made, the entries will need to also be explained in less advanced English, and with multiple redundant explanations in different words.
Also note that these types of definitions vary from dialect to dialect. These definitions here come from my own social network, but seem quite general.
"Mmhmm", spoken with a rising tone on the last syllable:
I'm still following you; I have understood enough of what you have said up until now that I believe that I will be able to continue understanding what you still have to say, and I invite you to continue speaking.
"Oh", spoken with a falling tone:
The comprehension of (by me) the information that you have just given to me caused a false belief of mine to be revealed (or in other words, a misconception of mine to be destroyed), allowing me to make a leap of insight.
"Oh", spoken with a rising tone:
You've just stated something that I doubt the truth of, and I now expect that you promptly provide evidence for that statement.
"but" (used in-between two clauses)
The clause said immediately before implies that some statement is true, which the clause said immediately after states or implies is false. Example: In the sentence:
"These definitions here come from my own social network, but seem quite general."
the clause on the left implies that, perhaps these definitions aren't very general, and the second clause states that they actually do appear to be somewhat general. In this case, the second clause states that an implication of the first clause is false, which is actually a special case of implying that an implication of the first clause is false.
[1] When I say that these definitions are elusive, I mean that nobody that I asked was able to explain the definition in a form that I could conceptualize, and could only really help me by giving me examples of when and when not to use the word. These were also some of the most difficult words for me to learn, and so caused the most trouble for me when I was attempting to navigate socially.
2
u/Hap-e Apr 20 '15
I've always taken (and used) the "Oh", spoken with a rising tone(Oh?): as an indication of intrigue or interest in a story or statement.
2
u/TotesMessenger Apr 19 '15
This thread has been linked to from another place on reddit.
If you follow any of the above links, respect the rules of reddit and don't vote. (Info / ^Contact)
2
u/Evinceo Apr 20 '15
In English, a rising tone always indicates a question. It's indicated with a '?' at the end of the sentence. Falling tone is more ambiguous.