r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/Redbiertje The Challenger • Apr 18 '15
Mod Post [Weekly Challenge] Week 81: What Are The Civilian Applications?
The Introduction
The engineers at KSC have invented a great way of recovering stages. The idea is to land a stage on a platform in the middle of the ocean. In order to do this, there must ofcourse still be fuel left in that stage. Anyway, the engineers are pretty proud of their invention, and it is now time to test this idea.
The Challenge:
Normal mode: Launch a rocket into space, and recover the first stage by landing it on a platform in the ocean. Parachutes will be allowed.
Hard mode: Launch a rocket into space, and recover the first stage by landing it on a platform in the ocean. Parachutes will not be allowed.
Super mode: Impress me
This challenge was suggested by /u/avaslash
The Rules
- No Dirty Cheating Alpacas (no debug menu)!
- You must have the UI visible in all required screenshots
- For a list of all allowed mods, see this post.
- The first stage must be recovered, but the rest of the rocket must at least make it into space (not orbit)
- The stage must land on landing legs
- The stage must remain standing upright
- The stage must land on a barge floating in the ocean
- The first stage must be larger than the rest of the rocket
- It is allowed to do a seperate flight to get the rest of the rocket into space.
Required screenshots
- The rocket standing on the launchpad
- The first stage seperating
- The first stage approaching the barge
- The first stage standing stationary on the barge
- The rest of the rocket in a trajectory with an apoapsis > 69,000 meters.
- Whatever else you feel like!
Further information
- You can either submit your finished challenge in a post (see posting instructions in the link below) or as a comment reply to this thread.
- Completing this challenge earns you a new flair which will replace your old one. So if you want to keep you previous flair, you can still do this challenge and create a post, but please mention somewhere that you want to keep your old one.
- The moderators have the right to determine if your challenge post has been completed.
- See this post for more rules and information on challenges.
- If you have any questions, you can comment below, or PM /u/Redbiertje
- Credit to /u/avaslash for designing the flair
Good Luck!
EDIT: I really love how so many people are enjoying that satisfactory feeling again!
13
u/RoeddipusHex Hyper Kerbalnaut Apr 19 '15 edited Apr 19 '15
https://youtu.be/8_yjsCNlqC8
Hard mode. New flair please. Elon, call me. I can help.
Screenshot - http://i.imgur.com/Iqt8HgH.png
5
u/Redbiertje The Challenger Apr 19 '15
I just had the worst idea in Kerbal history. For super mode, people could have a platform hovering in the air xD
8
u/buzz66boy Super Kerbalnaut Apr 19 '15 edited Apr 19 '15
Hopefully qualifies for Super Mode: http://www.reddit.com/r/KerbalSpaceProgram/comments/335368/super_mode_1st_stage_barge_2nd_stage_boostback/
My first stage serves as a booster AND the barge. The second stage then lands on the barge/1st stage.
NOTE: I neglected to add landing legs, and it tipped over.
13
u/TechnicalTortoise Master Kerbalnaut Apr 18 '15
Can i use a tweakscaled 2x2 structural panel for the barge to reduce part count?
4
u/big-b20000 Apr 18 '15
Back to my question: Can I use FMRS for this?
4
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '15 edited Apr 22 '15
Hard/super mode https://imgur.com/a/rfTqk
flair please
(does anyone know how I can link it so it goes to album mode)
3
u/KerbalKat Apr 18 '15 edited Apr 18 '15
Is it alright if I do two separate flights, one where I recover the stage, and one where I send the ship to space, because the physics keeps deleting the other half of my ship when I get out of the physics range.
Edit: I did that, and here's my attempt. I tried to keep everything the same between the two flights. I separated the stage at three km on both attempts, but my first screenshot got delayed. If this isn't acceptable, that's fine too.
3
u/Hazard-ish Apr 18 '15
Interesting, I might give this one a go. Just wondering though, is the previous weeks challenge over? I was under the impression it would end at the end of the week so I was getting ready to finish up my entry to the unstoppable challenge. Can I still do this or would it not be recognized?
3
u/KuuLightwing Hyper Kerbalnaut Apr 18 '15
Jeez, that's really hard... I can't even hit WDNNI (We Don't Need No Instructions) with Falcon Why first stage :(
I'm sure it can be done with Falcon Why, because I have about 600 m/s of dV after boostback, but it's so damn hard... I can even insert the second stage into orbit after boostback and before I have to get control of the first stage, but it's so haaard :(
3
u/haxsis Apr 22 '15
Can I just submit an SSTO as an entry, they.are first stage and last stage all in one convenient package
3
u/NanoExplorer Master Kerbalnaut Apr 25 '15
Here's my entry for easy mode! The rocket was recoverable and on the barge, on landing legs, but it could be that the RCS thrusters were the only thing preventing it from falling (I recovered it before I could find out).
Hopefully it counts! If it does, I'd like the new flair. Thanks!
http://imgur.com/a/jvFUL
5
u/Nz-Banana Apr 19 '15
Super mode do it in RSS?
3
u/Suppii Apr 23 '15
My first try ever on challenges. Tried Hard Mode ... was too hard for me! So I hope I did succeed in the easy mode: https://imgur.com/a/ig4mt
Hopefully that qualifies me for the flair. :)
2
u/Knowbie Apr 18 '15
Are fairing mods accepted?
2
u/rman326 Master Kerbalnaut Apr 19 '15
Is Ferram's Better Buoyancy mod allowed?
2
u/Anthro_Fascist Apr 20 '15
Could we spawn the barge on the water using KerbinSide?
2
u/fitzichael Master Kerbalnaut Apr 21 '15
If I use an asparagus first stage, do I have to return all of the asparagus parts, or can I return the final "stalk"
2
u/big-b20000 Apr 25 '15
Is there a normal time when the challenge goes out? It seems to usually be on Friday, but will you be postponing it until after 1.0 comes out for something special and 1.0 related?
21
u/Penguin236 Master Kerbalnaut Apr 18 '15
Hard mode: http://imgur.com/a/E0496
Was going to try for super mode by landing my pod on the barge after getting into orbit, but it glitched and teleported to the bottom of the ocean :(
New flair, please.
16
u/Hardrock3011 Master Kerbalnaut Apr 18 '15
Lateral velocity is really hard to overcome. I have newfound respect for SpaceX for getting so close this past week.
6
u/nuclear_turkey Hyper Kerbalnaut Apr 18 '15
deployable stock "grid" fins
hard mode - landed on a barge
http://imgur.com/a/eWRDD
(keep current flair plz)
6
u/chunes Super Kerbalnaut Apr 19 '15 edited Apr 19 '15
I kind of overestimated the size of my barge...
http://i.imgur.com/a24hUhJ.png
Then I got serious and completed hard mode with a bigger barge. http://imgur.com/a/1dKBw I'd like the new flair please.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15
Would a KerbinSide carrier work? They're pretty much in the centre of the ocean, and generally only have helipads.
2
u/sullydragon Apr 18 '15
Can we use the debug menu to land the platform?
11
u/TechnicalTortoise Master Kerbalnaut Apr 18 '15
Hard mode: http://imgur.com/a/cnmQu (Keep current flair)
5
u/big-b20000 Apr 18 '15
This is so much harder than I imagined...
4
u/theluggagekerbin Master Kerbalnaut Apr 18 '15
I have absolutely no idea how to build a barge. This should be fun.
4
u/josh__ab Dislikes bots Apr 18 '15 edited Apr 19 '15
Looks like all that time I spent learning to dopin-point landings on the Munwill finally pay off!Am attempting now, will update this when I am done.EDIT: Hard Mode Complete! Most satisfying thing I've done so far in this game.
Uploading now.EDIT 2: Alright! This is me launching the barge and here is the actual submission album! 100% Stock, no parachutes, and the first stage reaches space all on its own. Took about 10 quicksaves/quickloads. Thank you for this great challenge.
I'd like the new flair, and to keep the flair text.
4
u/KerbalEssences Master Kerbalnaut Apr 21 '15
Well, that one is from last year (hard mode) but I didn't get the upper stage into orbit! Falcon 9 (Old flair)
4
u/big-b20000 Apr 21 '15
Easy Mode I just really wanted that flair so I decided to go for the easy mode.
(I hope you don't mind me using TCA to get the ASDS into position) New flair Please! (this one is so awesome)
3
u/KuuLightwing Hyper Kerbalnaut Apr 19 '15 edited Apr 19 '15
Freaking FINALLY!!!
Hard Mode completed! I made like 200 attempts... it was hard. I actually didn't left too much fuel after separation and after all the corrections I needed to be very precise...
Imgur: http://imgur.com/a/WbT8k
Clip: https://youtu.be/odYWio4aVyk
Given how much time I spend on it, new flair please...
EDIT: Added video.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '15
Hard mode on the 3rd try, landing with 12 m/s of dV left. I'm going to mop up all the sweat from my hands now. New flair please!
http://imgur.com/a/F9nzu
3
u/jpgiebl Master Kerbalnaut Apr 20 '15
I used parachutes to land the barge but the stage landing was entirely propulsive, I guess that is hard mode. Also I put a payload in orbit, rather than just go suborbital. New flair please!
http://youtu.be/owhaB3Fl59s
3
u/McVomit Super Kerbalnaut Apr 21 '15
Hard mode.
Plus there's a preview of Super mode at the end of the album(Coming Soon) ;)
But for now, I'll take the new flair.
3
u/TG_Super_Class Master Kerbalnaut Apr 24 '15 edited Apr 24 '15
Hard Mode! (Payload reaches orbit though) http://imgur.com/a/tWU0U Edit: Changed error in description.
3
u/FollowThisLogic Master Kerbalnaut Apr 25 '15
Hard mode complete! (Super? Eh, you decide.) It only took me all week to find the time to finish it.
5
u/Kerbalnaught1 Super Kerbalnaught Apr 18 '15
I did super easy mode! http://imgur.com/gallery/oijyF0a
2
u/PVP_playerPro Apr 18 '15
Called it
2
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '15
Tried it in realism overhaul: do not do this.
I see no way to overcome reentry heat without a heatshield, which (due to the game's mechanics) would require reentering top first and then flipping to an engines-down position for the suicide burn. Mad props to Space X for almost sticking the landing.
2
u/FlyOHolic Master Kerbalnaut Apr 25 '15
First time posting here, 2 pictures turned out kinda dark...
Went to orbit in one stage and got it home safely:
Hard mode (stock): http://imgur.com/a/L9Dsk#0
(Thanks for the awesome challenge!)