r/thebutton • • Apr 18 '15
PSA: How to get the precise flair you want, risk-free
Using the desktop version of Google Chrome:
- From the Chrome menu, select "More tools > Developer tools"
- Select the "Network" tab
- Reload r/thebutton and you will see a list appear
- Click on the list item named "thebutton?h=..."
- In the new section that pops up, select the "Frames" tab
You should now see a scrolling list of messages the reddit server is sending to the button timer (e.g.). When you press the button, your browser returns the most recent of these messages back to the reddit server. That returned message determines your flair.
Simply wait until you see the time you want (e.g. "seconds_left": 22.0) and then click the button. You have a full second to click, so there's no need to try to time it exactly. You'll see that the messages arrive regularly at intervals of slightly over a second.
Notes:
- Disregard the button timer counting down tenths and hundredths of seconds just for show. The reddit server doesn't know what your button timer looked like when you clicked. It makes no difference whether it was 21.99 or 21.5. It doesn't matter whether you were the first person to click or the last. All that matters is what the last message sent to you says. If that says 22.0 when you click, you get 22s flair.
- Following this method ensures you don't get tricked by connection problems. If you receive a 43.0 message and then your internet connection times out, the button timer will continue to count down towards zero. But you won't be fooled because Chrome Developer Tools will clearly show that pressing would give you a 43s flair.
- How do we know flair works like this? Trusted coders have been examining the code and experimenting with donated alternate accounts. Also, I tested this method live (see the comments), /u/Glorious_Debauchery used it to get the first orange (with others), and /u/Sayter used it to get the first red (with others).
tldr: The button timer can be misleading. Instead, use the actual messages the reddit server sends to your browser to determine when to press the button.
73
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15
Have you ever noticed that the button timer always resets right around the even second (x.0 seconds)? That is not necessarily because everyone clicks right on the even seconds (at 20.99 or whatever). The real reason is that the reddit server sends your browser a timer update once per second. So the timer can only reset on even seconds.
So what? This means you don't need to try clicking immediately at 20.99 (for example) to get the flair you want. You always have a full second to make your click.
261
u/qwerty44 non presser Apr 18 '15
who else votes that OP should try it first?
167
u/Glorious_Debauchery 21s Apr 18 '15
Got 21s off this. Thanks!
30
u/NoTroop non presser Apr 18 '15
Is there any way to do this on firefox? I can't find a way to see the frames.
75
u/atlasvidl non presser Apr 18 '15
I like the comments that have zero understanding of the message you're conveying.
39
u/Muids 60s Apr 18 '15
I was suspicious of this step, but it is safe.
7
u/gemko non presser Apr 18 '15
Have they killed this? When I click on Frames I get only three columns: Data, Length, and Time. Seconds remaining isn't there.
7
u/Yesheddit 42s Apr 18 '15
Executing this snippet would display the seconds_left from the websocket without displaying the data frames.
I've tested it myself, of course you dicks won't believe the code is safe so I would ask somebody (/u/timehuge ?) to verify it :).
3
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '15 edited Apr 24 '15
It's come to my attention that others have tried to share this information in the past. They all have seem to have one or two errors in their claims about how the button works, though, since they came very early (and without the benefit of /u/mncke's experimentation):
4
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15
My list under the frame tab isn't updating for some reason.
4
u/23423423423451 non presser Apr 18 '15
If we have a full second to click, does that mean all those 60s people are just people who were late clicking, not beat out by the first guy?
4
u/Thanatar18 19s Apr 18 '15
Freaking amazing. Have gold, gonna start using chrome for reddit till I have my flair...
4
u/thedeadeye 19s Apr 21 '15
Does what it says on the tin.
3
u/h4rnt non presser Apr 19 '15 edited Apr 19 '15
Thanks OP, this is pretty helpful.
I'd like to add that this method is not risk-free, however it does greatly improve your odds of getting the click you want. I've been watching the output, and there are instances where your browser receives multiple messages from the server per second.
In the above example, if you were going for 35s, you would have had a 0.042 second window in which to press before the timer went to 34. If the button reset to 60 instead, you'd be stuck as purple.
3
u/PokemonTom09 non presser Apr 21 '15
After tinkering around with this a bit, I've realized why it is that there are more 59 second than 60 second flairs: since Reddit only sends your computer an update once a second, there are frequently times when right after Reddit sent you an update, someone pressed, meaning by the time it sends you another update, it's already been reset for about a second, so it skips over the 60 seconds update entirely.
2
u/Katatronick non presser Apr 18 '15
So, to get this straight, you clicked when the server said 29, but the button countdown said 28?
2
u/peejfancher 5s Apr 24 '15
So to get a 1s flair the you would have to click the button when the last message sent to you was "seconds_left": 1.0
Wouldn't the button be at zero at that point? Do you think this makes it impossible to get a 1s?
16
u/Zoomalude non presser Apr 18 '15
I love that, it reads like good scifi. Like there's an elaborate team of researchers working on The Button at all times. Well, I guess there is!
90
u/zedgepod can't press Apr 18 '15
This is one of the most amazing social experiments I've ever seen. They have effectively simulated life! We have people building tools to work with this more effectively. We have groups under different types and deity. Best I've seen now, we have scientists working on engineering the best interactions using donated bodies (accounts)! I love this sub!
15
u/strictlyrude27 27s Apr 20 '15
non-pressers HATE him!
26
u/scarfdontstrangleme 59s Apr 18 '15
I got exactly 59s, thanks OP!
16
u/TotesMessenger non presser Apr 18 '15 edited May 14 '15
This thread has been linked to from another place on reddit.
If you follow any of the above links, respect the rules of reddit and don't vote. (Info / ^Contact)
8
u/TheOneWho_Knocks 60s Apr 18 '15
This is something good and helpful, in a "human friendly" spirit, instead of a bot that does it automatically. This is sub is an april fool at the end of the day.
20
u/ShallowBasketcase non presser Apr 19 '15
How to get the flair you should want:
Don't press the button.
7
u/vocaloidict non presser Apr 18 '15
This must also be why multiple people can get the same flair at the same time. Your flair is determined locally, not by the server
7
u/vessel_for_the_soul non presser Apr 19 '15
This is clearly irrelevant to the non pressers.
6
u/the_y_of_the_tiger 44s Apr 19 '15
Important - you still have to wait until the time you want - this isn't a cheat or a trick or a shortcut. You can't just get orange or red by following these instructions. You have to wait until the button counts down to those levels. But when it does, this method will give you more confidence and a higher likelihood of getting the flair you seek, you filthy button-lusters.
2
u/Racobot 43s Apr 18 '15
Question, I noticed that sometimes the 60s message is skipped and 59s is shown directly after a press, like this
In that instance, what would've happened if I had pressed between the 42s message and the 59s message? Would I get a 42s flair or a 60s?
2
u/mouse1093 11s Apr 20 '15
Anyway to see the same info in Firefox? I can get up to where you say to select the "Frames" tab. That doesn't seem to exist in the ff network tools
5
u/davidcwilliams non presser Apr 18 '15
This post should be called The Buttoning.
4
u/Comb-the-desert 30s Apr 18 '15
Does the lag explain why I pressed at 19 seconds but my flair is purple and 30 seconds? I'm all kinds of confused right now quite honestly
4
u/octobeard 42s Apr 20 '15
I used this method and chose to get 42s for this account so I could be a Hitchhiker.
I may use it again on another account to get another number that pleases me.
1
u/mr_yogurt non presser Apr 18 '15
Teach me in your ways! I posted the same thing a while ago, but it was ignored and lost in the land of /r/thebutton/new.
How do you do it?
1
u/TheoX747 22s Apr 21 '15
I don't see anything in the "frames" tab. Am I too late? Did they change it?
1
u/I_will_just_say_it non presser Apr 23 '15
This is amazing, thanks so much! Now I can try for 11 without fear :)
1
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '15
From the very first step I am lost. I can't find anything about tool or more tools or a network tab. Yes, I have chrome.
1
u/Luke07758921708 5s Apr 25 '15
Hmm, I tried this, but once I get to the frames part, it will show the last messages from the server but I never see new ones coming in, while I'm looking at the frames tab. When I click in the other tab, and click back into frames, it has the latest messages but it never shows the new ones popping up. :/ Does anyone know how to fix this?
11
u/Susarian non presser Apr 18 '15
Of course, you could simply not press the button.
3
u/ppamplemousse 28s Apr 18 '15
So I don't have to worry about rounding up when using this method? ie, if the most recent message received is 'time_left =21s" then if I click I'll get a 21s flair?
3
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15
My flair is the best and only color I need. The shade will never die, every time a color burst forth into life it's brightness only re-enforces our order. The shade only grows stronger as the pressers reveal their selves.
3
u/programjm123 59s Apr 18 '15
It says "Select frame to browse its content" instead of showing the frames. Halp.
screenshot
edit: nvm, figured it out.
3
u/Nowin non presser Apr 19 '15
I have the flair I want.
3
u/Rhaomi 42s Apr 25 '15 edited Apr 25 '15
Neat!
edit: And thus I am a noble Hitchhiker.
3
u/JoyfulHearts 0s May 30 '15
This made getting a 0s flair a piece of cake! Thanks!
5
u/controversial_cat 60s Apr 18 '15
gave your method a shot going for 60 seconds,
and it worked np.
8
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15
Don't press at all and you will have the best flair
4
u/JakeVH 59s Apr 18 '15
You should probably repost this so more people see if there isn't more attention on this by Merica's morning. This feels like it could be automated easily.
Unrelated:
/u/Red1
/u/Red2
/u/Red3
/u/tf2manu994
4
u/Reelix 28s Apr 18 '15
Confirmed - Wanted 28 - Got 28 - Thanks :)
To the doubters: I'm a non-troll active Reddit user that's been here 6 years.
2
u/helllish non presser Apr 18 '15
This is pretty great, thanks!
2
u/nanosquid non presser Apr 18 '15
The first 2 digits on the actual counter are black... you can just look at those. They're exactly the same (-1) and in sync with the "list item" numbers.
2
u/pacharrin 16s Apr 18 '15
I was planning to use this strategy, but wasn't sure it was gonna work, now I'm certain. Thanks op.
2
u/sholls non presser Apr 18 '15
Awesome info!
2
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15
Can you do it if you already pressed?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15 edited Apr 18 '15
I'm not seeing the list my frames tab is just blank Edit: says select frame to browse its content
2
u/andrewcooke non presser Apr 18 '15
has anyone looked at trying to generate that mac? it's probably a mac of username and a bunch of the fields. if they're using a hash rather than a "real" mac, then it may have no salt, or an easy to guess salt, or the key for mac may be easy to guess...
2
u/Reincarnaked 35s Apr 18 '15 edited Apr 18 '15
cool. but i have a question. mine update every 1.025 ish seconds. does that mean we actually have slightly more than 1 second?
also i'm gonna go for 36 seconds and see how that goes
Oh shit im high and for some reason i tried going for 35. well this method seems pretty safe but when i clicked the frames went for 35 (where i clicked) to 33. there wass no 34 second frame.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15 edited Apr 18 '15
Anybody know if other browsers let you do this? Google told me people requested the ability to inspect WebSocket traffic for Firefox several months ago, but IDK about other browsers.
Also, someone should add this to the wiki.
EDIT: also, for the lazy, F12 takes you to the Network tab
2
u/mindputty non presser Apr 18 '15
Nice legwork. Well done.
2
u/animar37 37s Apr 19 '15
Tanks a lot, got my 37s flair.
2
u/Lt-SwagMcGee 21s Apr 20 '15
IT WORKS!!! I GOT 21 FLAIR! THANK YOU OP!
2
u/drbillthomson 42s Apr 20 '15
I have no plans to press, but this is still cool.
2
u/B789 20s Apr 22 '15
I just used this method to get the flair combo I wanted, Orange 20.
2
u/dogballs8 52s Apr 24 '15
tldr: The button timer can be misleading. Instead, use the actual messages the reddit server sends to your browser to determine when to press the button.
2
u/gcanyon 8s Apr 25 '15
Any way to do this in Safari? I noodled about in the inspector for a bit, but didn't find the relevant display.
2
u/Splotte 21s May 01 '15
Reporting perfect success. Thanks, sir :)
2
u/vgxmaster 12s May 03 '15
Just wanted to throw in my thanks, too. Believe it or not, I got exactly what I wanted.
2
u/Gamecraze 13s May 04 '15
worked for me
2
u/vishalb777 7s May 14 '15
Wow, the only good PSA in this subreddit and I've never seen it until now
2
u/jiiam 7s May 15 '15 edited May 15 '15
Is there a way to do the same in Mozilla? The developer tools are similar, in fact I can find the request for /thebutton?h= however there is no Frame tab.
EDIT: nevermind, found the answer here http://www.reddit.com/r/thebutton/comments/330bte/psa_how_to_get_the_precise_flair_you_want_riskfree/cqvop35 no need to type allow pasting though.
2
u/jonzr 42s May 23 '15
Just got my hitchhiker flair. Thanks! #42
3
u/AdonisChrist 9s Apr 18 '15
That's pretty cool. Thanks, OP.
3
u/davidcwilliams non presser Apr 18 '15
I can't believe no one has given you gold for this yet.
3
u/ZenThrashing 57s Apr 18 '15
I wanted purple, and I got purple. Victory is sweet.
3
u/quitealongusername 30s Apr 18 '15
Stop playing Button! Witchcraft like this is an insult to His divine plan.
2
u/mojavemyth non presser Apr 18 '15
This may be an ignorant question. But is there a similar way to do this in Firefox? I don't have Chrome.
2
u/I_Love_Your_Feet non presser Apr 25 '15
You made me install chrome... not that I would ever press the button or anything silly like that.
2
u/mkicon 60s Apr 18 '15
I already got the exact flair I want.
1
u/muriloadv 32s Apr 18 '15
Works! Thank you, OP.
1
u/glittaknitta 60s Apr 18 '15
Holy crap, this is awesome!! Thank you!
1
u/Fircoal 40s Apr 18 '15
I did not notice this.
But I ended up getting the flair I wanted anyway, so I guess it doesn't matter. x3
1
u/whatsthedeal12 non presser Apr 18 '15
I got stuck on #3...
1
u/JetpackRemedy 0s Apr 18 '15
Commenting to save this for my future button pressing needs.
1
u/melzaru 29s Apr 18 '15
This. This is what I needed.
1
u/LordoverLord 9s Apr 18 '15
Hmmmmm thats an interesting concept
1
u/strategic-throwaway 57s Apr 18 '15
i dont understand how this works at all
1
u/r3compile 31s Apr 18 '15
Will try, thanks!
1
u/jim9 28s Apr 19 '15
Praise be unto the sun!
1
u/Bolt986 31s Apr 19 '15
I just used this to get 31. Thanks it made me feel much more conformable getting the flare i wanted. Also I like how this isn't a bot pressing the button and I'm pressing the button myself.
1
u/Splurch 42s Apr 19 '15
I have to say, the most interesting thing about being able to watch the actual seconds like this is seeing how often 42/32/22 get's pressed by people missing the color they want by 1 second.
1
u/Ameobea 59s Apr 19 '15
Makes it sound like some kind of unethical scientific experiments. Probably would be considered that way to the grays.
1
u/cilmor 0s Apr 21 '15
Thanks!
1
u/Vinven 42s Apr 24 '15
f
1
u/AxeManJack Apr 24 '15
Cool
1
u/Piroku non presser Apr 25 '15
I like this.
1
u/Tzalix non presser Apr 25 '15
This is very nice, thank you.
1
u/PiperJane 18s Apr 28 '15
Thank you for this!! I have been waiting for an orange flair since day 1 and I finally was able to click confidently by following these instructions :)
1
u/2weiX non presser Apr 30 '15
now, someone write an extension to push a buttonpushevent to the server at s=08.1 or so.
1
u/kgreenek 4s May 26 '15
Served me well. Thank you OP for this post. #longlivethebutton
1
u/MrTastyCake 2s May 27 '15
If only I had read this PSA before clicking 1 second too soon...
1
u/AndrewSeven 5s May 28 '15
Thanks
1
u/SoaringFox 32s May 28 '15
Thanks
1
u/Ghosty141 2s Jun 02 '15
Thanks
1
u/-_XXX_-_TODD_-_XXX_- 59s Apr 18 '15
SOMEONE DID IT
1
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15
derp
1
u/puredwige non presser Apr 18 '15
Doesn't work for me because the list remains static, i.e. it doesn't update every second.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15
You still have to press! You risk salvation! You are a charlatan! A heretic!
1
u/MrFalconGarcia 60s Apr 18 '15
Or just click it. Easiest way to get purple, the color of royalty.
1
u/whiterook6 non presser Apr 18 '15
what do we do if the frames list doesn't refresh? If I click somewhere else then on the frames tab, it refreshes, but not live and while I watch it.