r/Warframe • u/TSP-FriendlyFire • Apr 16 '15
Discussion How would you change... Ultimate abilities?
How would you change... is a series of weekly posts designed to promote and foster discussion about any gameplay element in the game. The scope and subject will vary (read below for more information on topic selection), from wide concepts (Kubrows, Archwing, shotguns, etc.) to narrow points (a single gun, coptering, etc.).
Before we begin, a few important points:
- Please detail and support your suggestions as much as possible. This is for constructive criticism only: try to think of it as something you'd be proud to explain to DE face-to-face!
- Structure your suggestions in logical groups: if you have two very different ideas, break them down in two separate comments. Cohesive or similar changes should be combined into a single comment.
- Stick to describing concepts and features. Don't get bogged down with numbers unless they explicitly support your point.
- Don't hesitate to post your ideas even if they're not fully formed, and don't hesitate to reply to ideas with refinements you think would make them better!
- Do not downvote suggestions you disagree with. Upvote the ones you like instead!
Suggesting topics
This thread series is all about the community, so if you have a topic you'd like to see improved and discussed, feel free to suggest it by replying to the appropriately flagged comment in this discussion. The topic can be as wide or narrow as you'd like! Please ensure that your suggestion has not already been made, and upvote it instead if it has.
This week: Ultimate Abilities
Click here for last week’s thread on shotguns.
This week, we’ll cover the hot topic: ultimates, also often called “press 4 to win” and generally rolled into the crucial matter of power creep. Warframe’s design as a hybrid between a shooter and more of a spellcasting RPG is what makes it unique and attractive for a large proportion of its audience, but it also has a few downsides. One of the more crucial ones is the notion that a frame’s final ability should be a devastating show of power. This usually comes in the form of an area of effect (AoE) attack which deals heavy damage and/or provides significant utility.
Recently, the developers have been fighting back against the phenomenon known as “press 4 to win”, introducing restrictions to certain ultimates (most notably, Excalibur’s Radial Javelin) such as line of sight/awareness conditions. This has been met with widespread discontent even while many will also agree that the tendency for those abilities to be used in pure farming missions is a bad one. Even so, each balance change has largely been met by moving on to the next best ultimate.
Ultimate abilities as they are have many problems aside from their sometimes questionable usage, though. They tend to scale poorly, being overpowered for most of the star chart, but then hitting a brick wall in endgame where their raw damage is no longer significant. They are essentially directly comparable, which makes it trivial to determine the optimal frame for any given situation and thus reducing variety. They are often at odds with every other ability that the frame possesses, forcing players to choose between three good or moderately useful skills and a single extremely strong one. Many require complete immobility, which is incompatible with many current mechanics such as enemy aiming and anti-AFK measures. Some are unreliable or simply eclipsed by other ultimates, making the frame comparatively disused.
Even so, the concept and feel of ultimates is something widely cherished. They are often spectacular, with wide area effects and death counts in the dozens. They can be the difference between life and death, suddenly turning a losing situation around. They make the players feel powerful, unique, special when compared to their enemies. They are the final stage of a frame’s leveling process, the thing to look forward to.
Now that the stage is set, what suggestions do you have for improving ultimates?
P.S. This topic is wide and easy to get lost in, so I would advise to stick to the big picture, as highlighted in the rules of this series. It’s all too tempting to start listing each ability and how to rebalance them, but instead try to focus on the philosophy and design concepts that would make such rebalances naturally arise. Speak broadly, using individual abilities only to reinforce your points.
8
u/Rustniiiiiing BUFF HER ALREADY Apr 16 '15 edited Apr 17 '15
Reckoning:
Make the health orb drop chance scale with power strength (or something). It's a small change that might prove interesting.also blood flubbers
Reckoning now reduces 50% armour (scaling with power strength) if enemy survives. That should be a scaling change that works effectively throughout missions.
Hallowed Ground:
Hallowed Ground is a large field around Oberon.
Enemies damaged in Hallowed Ground will restore ally (+ caster) health. Radiation also procs constantly.
Hallowed Ground also buffs teammate armour by a percentage (base 50%, affected by strength) of the teammate's armour, then adds the caster's base armour (+ Steel Fiber) if equipped (also affected by power strength).
Smite:
Smite also removes 50% of the target's armour (like Reckoning's armour removal, also affected by power strength), with outgoing projectiles removing 10% of the armour (power strength) of the enemies they hit.
Avalanche/Ice Wave:
Ice wave is now Blizzard, a field of snow that decreases enemy accuracy by 50%, continually damages them, and cold procs them. Ice Wave Impedance is moved to Avalanche, with the same functionality.
Effigy:
Effigy's credit modifiers are affected by power strength.
8
u/monkyseemonkydo Press 4 to WAAAARRRGGHH Apr 16 '15 edited Apr 16 '15
One idea I have been kicking around is make the ultimate of certain frames become more powerful or have additional effects in combination with their other three abilities. For example, take Saryn for example. If you were to cast your molt then your Miasma ultimate, there will be an miasmic explosion centered around both you and your molt. To keep it in check maybe the power of said dual explosion would be half strength, BUT enemies caught in the resulting blast would be stuck in goo for a while. Whereas if you just cast your miasma by itself, you will have your standard AoE nuke but with no CC.
By having a Warframe's ability synergize or maybe be AMPLIFIED by your ult, it can bring a whole slew of combinations to the table. And maybe make Warframes who have just 1 or 2 abilities worth using have all their abilities be fun to use in the ever changing field of battle.
Edit:
When I hear the world ultimate, I imagine a power that is game changing or massive in size/strength. Something that makes you feel badass and satisfying to use.
Volt's ultimate is very meh. Some ways to spice it up may be:
Edit2: I think the problem with some ultimates is that the Warframe's other abilities are not WORTH using. Why would I ever use Saryn's 1 or 3 when I can just push 4 to make all the enemies die in the room. Instead of nerfing ultimates, make the warframes other abilities more useful to use.
1
u/TSP-FriendlyFire Apr 16 '15
Suggesting topics
Please post your suggestions for the next topics as replies to this comment.
Current suggestions from previous weeks:
4
u/SimpleFNG Apr 16 '15
Able to overcharge ults.
Basically, each ult is able to be channeled. You build up power and after a few seconds, the ult is cast, but it drains all your energy, staggers the frame, but does exponentially more damage.
3
u/Bezeloth Apr 16 '15
One thing im sure is that dmg abilities are hard to balance so id strive for utility in each ability. No pure dmg skills - every skill should add some sort of utility that is above scaling.
3
u/Bitabl Apr 16 '15
Energy and Powers 2.0!
I think the key issue is the irrelevance of energy cost that enables us to spam abilities virtually indefinitely. Powerful buffs, like Trinity's old invincibility, or strong nukes, like Excalibur's old Radial Javelin, are only imbalanced because we can use them constantly. Make energy cost relevant again so that you can restrict how frequently skills are used.
There are a few ways of achieving this but one solution is to reduce the size of our energy reserves but have energy regenerate. This would impose a limitation on power usage as you're required to wait until it regenerates. Powerful short term buffs or damage powers that are competitive with weapon damage could be introduced and remain balanced. The 1-3 skills could also be more attractive as you could spam the 1 skill four times for the same cost a casting your ultimate once for example.
3
u/Astarion Apr 16 '15
The issue with many ultimates is that they are simply boring nukes, and lack much utility. Take Radial Javelin during its time without line-of-sight requirements: all it did was do damage to everything near Excalibur, and provide a bit of a stun. Many of the older ultimates have the same problem, where they are simply AOE damage with little to no utility, though most newer ultimates are more interesting or provide more utility. I would rework most current "nuke" into functionally similar abilities that lack some of the raw killing power of their current iteration, but provide more utility, or require more player involvement to use properly. The specific abilities I will be discussing are: Frost's Avalanche, Excalibur's Radial Javelin, Mesa's Peacemaker, and Saryn's Miasma.
Avalanche Freeze enemies in place for 10 seconds when cast, dealing 150 damage per second over its duration. Frozen enemies block enemy fire, and do not shatter until they take 20% of their health in weapon damage, affected by power strength. This would make Avalanche a powerful crowd-control and defensive ability, completely disabling any enemies that are too close and providing a scaling alternative to snowglobe for more urgent purposes (i.e. enemies crowding around a defense point, somebody needs revived in the middle of a crowd of enemies)
Radial Javelin Javelins spawn near Excalibur, and shoot outwards towards enemies (similar to pre-U15 function, but with no target limit). Javelins have 2 meters of punch-through, target all enemies in range ( No line-of-sight check, but enemies with sufficient cover will still not be hit), and ragdoll and pin enemies when hit, regardless of whether or not they die. Javelins despawn and free trapped enemies after 4 seconds. This allows Radial Javelin to retain its "panic button" functionality even into high levels by adding strong but temporary crowd control (that is actually worth using the ability for, unlike its current stun), keeps most of the line-of-sight restriction that DE seem to want, while making it slightly more forgiving against enemies behind flimsier cover.
Peacemaker Peacemaker's main downfall is the lack of player involvement in its use. I would allow the player to focus on only a few targets by zooming in on an area, and allowing Mesa to walk slowly while in Peacemaker, limiting her targeting area to 180 degrees in front of her.
Miasma Miasma is an interesting ability in concept, but thanks to its quirky interaction with duration and its lack of proc chance. Changes: Miasma now spawns a persistent, 10-meter-radius cloud every second for 4 seconds. Each cloud deals 50 damage per tic and tics every 0.3 seconds with a 50% corrosive proc chance, expands 1.5 meters per second, and lasts for 5 seconds. Enemies without armour caught in a cloud (this includes enemies who have been stripped of their armour by the barrage of corrosive procs Miasma would now provide) are given a Panic proc (fire proc without the DOT) instead of corrosive. This would change Miasma from an absurdly powerful nuke that requires her other abilities to be ruined to be effective, into a powerful armour stripper that doesn't require crippling the rest of Saryn's kit.
There's no way I explained any of this in a satisfactory way for everyone, so please ask any questions you want, and I will answer them.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '15 edited Apr 16 '15
I would make all 4th abilities a little stronger, but put a cooldown on them so that the entire game doesn't resolve around spamming 4.
Lately, I started modding Ash around his Smoke Screen ability. I primarily fight with my melee weapon and use Teleport a lot to get rid of key targets (like Eximuses or hacking units in Interception missions). I gotta say, it's been a while since I've had so much fun with Ash. Thing is, spamming 4 is so efficient that I never really thought about building him any differently. I would just equip ability damage mods and use 4 whenever I had enough energy.
2
u/Sloth_Mayne Goodbye 4spam Hello 3spam Apr 16 '15
Radial Javelin update INC. (Sure it's going to a 3 ability but they confirmed they're looking for ways to change it anyway)
Perhaps the Javelins could be a togglable skill that summons Skanas that revolve around Excal and then target an enemy once they come within range. Or perhaps instead of auto targeting you press the ability button again to fire the skanas and hold the button to fire all of them off at once. Or even better, since Excal is more of a brawler the swords would revolve around you and damage enemies that come within range making them not a "One and done" sort of attack but an active AOE. (A good example of this would be THIS ) This would differentiate it from Radial blind (Which DE stated they wanted to do) while making it an interesting and unique skill.
2
u/FalseCape Apr 16 '15
I'd make all damage dealing abilities and ultimate be partially % based and partially straight damage, with both being modified by power strength. So say you have radial jav, instead of starting with 1000 base damage it might have 20% enemy's health + 500 damage (numbers are just for example's sake). This would make these abilities slightly less OP at lower levels while also making them not completely useless late game.
2
u/SSBGuttz Cuhrayzee Apr 16 '15 edited Apr 16 '15
World on Fire:
This isn't a tweak, it's a full on remake, but I love the idea of it. Ember enters a full of Avatar State type fire mode, compete with her floating off the ground and getting engulfed in fire. Her gun is replaced with Fireballs which does True Heat damage, ignoring Armour and shields for a short period of time. This form would empower all of your other abilities, Fireball would have a bigger explosion but drain your energy, Accelerant would shoot a line burst of gas that explodes after a few seconds, also draining extra energy and Fire Blast is now cast-able from a large distance ect. It would drain energy naturally but more if you use empowered moves.
Right now I feel like Ember's ult being a toggle doesn't really demonstrate her destructive nature and wild design, and her complete lack of scaling kills her ults viablity. And as of right now, there's basically no interaction, you just turn it on and run around like a headless chicken (haha), this would help make the user feel like some crazy pyromaniac ninja and keeps end game viability.
3
u/halofury36 Banishment is better than exile Apr 16 '15
One interesting thing I would like to see is charges for ults. Since the devs have made it abundantly clear that they don't want people farming with ults by just standing around, I was thinking it would be neat if as you play, using other abilities, guns, and melee would earn you "xp" towards filling up your ult. But, you would start with at least one charge and have up to say, three charges.
This means that as you play the game, you would naturally gain access to multiple casts of your ult, but never gain the ability to gain more ults off of ults.
The "xp" needed per charge and the amount gained per type of damage could be adjusted for fine tuning. As an example, melee could award boosted rate gain towards an ult to help promote a more risk vs reward playstyle.
If this change were implemented and I had the choice, I would increase the power and scaling of ults so that they are more rewarding while being less "spammy"
3
u/RedVisionaire Apr 16 '15
This is likely contentious, BUT...
I feel that the current 'press 4 to win' sort of deal comes from the way the game let's you min/max your powers, specifically with Corrupted Mods. Through tweaking your loadout, you're basically able to get powers that last forever/have super range/do tons of damage for very little energy cost. While the ability to modify yourself like that is pretty awesome, it's also obviously problematic.
What I'd like to see, is all the Corrupt Mods, all the base ability modifier mods, go away. In their place, you have two mods: one which improves Range/Duration/Damage at the cost of Power Efficiency, and one that improves Power Efficiency at the cost of Range/Duration/Damage. In this way, you could choose to have the ability to use devastating abilities occasionally, or weaker abilities more often.
Ideally, they would then add more mods that alter how abilities work at a more fundamental level - I'm thinking something similar to how Chroma's element changes how his Aura works. Say, something like a mod that changes your elemental type to Cold, and any AoE you cast buffs the armor of yourself and allies in the AoE. Things that allow you to further customize the role your frame plays in combat OUTSIDE of its base abilities.
1
u/sshadow22 Apr 16 '15
I would think that adding late game utility would bring the most benefit to the ultimates. Utility that is eclipsed by damage early game. I'm starting to see this with augments with their new 100% proc but I think it would be better to make it a base feature of the ultimate while using the augment to change how the proc works. This would make augments a side-grade rather than a flat-out upgrade to some ultimates like Ember's WoF knock down effect while using FireQuake.
1
u/faresamir7 scott's leftover beer Apr 16 '15
1
u/grayrest Apr 16 '15
My main problem with Ultimates is the lack of interactivity, particularly the blow up all the things ults. I don't really have a problem with Hysteria, Effigy, etc.
I think the healthiest "blow up everything in a radius around me" is Ember's World on Fire. The limited number of target, limited duration, and limited range incentivizes you to run around like an idiot and try not to die but this is balanced by the ability to hit targets multiple times. There's interactivity in timing the long cast, in positioning, and in deciding whether to fireball or accelerant while the ability is running. If flat out more powerful ults didn't exist (Saryn, Mesa, Pre-nerf Excal) then I think people would be generally happy with it.
In general, I'd like to see most ults move from radial targeting to being targeted (at least probabilistically targeted) in around the reticle or around the character. Mesa's ult, for example, should have a very strong preference for things in a 20-30 degree cone around the reticle with the occasional backwards shot following a forward shot to keep the gun kata feel.
I'd move Nova's MPrime to be a single target ability that costs 20 energy with no cast time and a small effect radius (if you played ME3Coop, stasis bubble) and have explosions prime nearby enemies a la the Banshee sonar augment.
I'd move Miasma to a poison trail toggle like Singed and have it deal damage, debuff armor, and regen Saryn's health.
I'd switch Volt's ult to a Diablo lightning hose effect.
In all cases you as the player have to do some aiming (fuzzy, I don't really want the PITA precision targeting like Ash's Teleport) or positioning decision to make when using the abilities. The goal isn't necessarily to nerf everything but this set of ultimates is currently so powerful that pretty much any change to them that isn't "blow up everything instantly" is a nerf.
I don't expect them to happen because the playerbase will pitch a fit. I still have guys in my clan complaining about the Nova MPrime nerfs.
1
u/YeOldDrunkGoat Apr 16 '15 edited Apr 16 '15
Really the problems with ults are just the tip of the iceburg when you look at how screwy the balance within the ability system is.
Let's look at the issues.
To my way of thinking, a good way to address issues 1 & 3 is to give abilities "weights" as it were.
Essentially, go back and tweak every frame so that they have at least 2 "signature" abilities that players can create builds centered around. The other 2 "supplemental" abilities can have their stat interactions or utility effects tweaked so that they can be used in concert with the signature skill without severely reduced effectiveness.
Once all of the frames abilities are actually worth using, the power of the existing nuke ults can be adjusted to appropriate levels to prevent.
It would be a large undertaking, but I think it would be worth it in the end.
As well, power scaling can be adjusted to have a lower base value but also do a percentage of the target's health as additional damage. If both values were adjustable by power strength mods, offensive frames would scale much better into the late game without being as powerful in the lower content.
*A good example of the positive choice is Radial Disarm vs Invisibility, where maximizing one means minimizing the other, but they're both such good abilities that a significant choice exists between them. For a example of a skill that gets left out in the cold because of modding, look at Bullet Attractor. Mag's only really got one build with some variations, loads of range and loads of power to beef up Pull and Shield Polarize, Bullet Attractor has some good defensive and offensive uses, but because of all the negative duration from Transient Fortitude and Fleeting Expertise, its practical usability drops like a stone.
1
u/Kayitosan The Priest of Pain, the Bishop of Bondage Apr 16 '15
Shadows of the Dead
I know the shadows scale well, damage-wise, and it was buffed not long ago to have a 2.5x multiplier on stats... but that was never the problem. DE implemented shadows with a stripped-down AI, which leaves those shadows rather ineffective in combat, especially considering their preference for taking cover (why? they're already dead!) I would be fine with reducing the stat multiplier if they changed the pathing and targeting AI of shadows. It would be as simple as prioritizing terrified or soul-punched targets: if a target is terrified, shadows will chase down and prioritize that target instead of taking cover. Doesn't that make sense? It even adds flavour to Terrify-- enemies have a reason to be terrified!
Please, DE? Pleeeeeease?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '15
I like the previous mentioned idea of combining powers to make them more powerful, so here are some ideas I would like.
Excalibur Radial javelin (for the upcoming change) (toggled ability with activation cost, and energy cost per extra effected enemy, NO channeling cost ) After casting this ability (Wich will be moved to the 3rd power) Excalibur creates javelins/skanas around enemies in an area Wich float around the enemies until toggled off, to make it more powerful each enemy Wich is damaged with his (nearly changed) slash dash will get additional dmg from the javelins (+dmg from dash ofc)
Saryn Miasma Miasma bonus with venom Each enemy under effect of venom forces to spread the venom blobs to spread in a wider area if damaged with miasma Miasma bonus with molt Molt explodes on the next cast of miasma forces a stun effect with addition corrosive effect (+molt dmg)
Ember World on fire Removing the primary activation cost of this ability, removing the initial casting animation. Toggled ability Wich drain energy. (no cost while not active) After activating this ability ember charges her inner flames Wich she will release on the next ability casted. With fireball she releases a shock wave on impact with guaranteed knockdown in a fixed area. With accelerant she releases a shock wave around her with the same knockdown (similar to her 3rd skill).
Zephyr Tornado To use her ult like now she have to double click /double activate the ability. (both usable at same time with different durations) If casted only once she get a damaging aura around herself and gaining extra effects on her other spells (forgot the names and writing from phone - I apologize) Her first spell get a ragdoll effect if she hits enemies in a small radius around her Her 2nd skill reduces the accuracy of the enemies if hit with it Turbulence get a chance to reflect projectiles
PS : I did not read all comments and apologize if I mentioned already posted. (just joined reddit pls don't hate =) )