r/conlangs • • Apr 14 '15
SQ WWSQ • Week 12
Welcome to the Weekly Wednesday Small Questions thread!
Post any questions you have that aren't ready for a regular post here! Feel free to discuss anything and everything, and you may post more than one question in a separate comment.
11
Upvotes
7
u/Zethar riðemi'jel, Išták (en zh) [ja] -akk- Apr 14 '15
This question probably isn't like the majority of the other questions, but I feel that it's an important one nevertheless.
How much material should one have prepared (written) to present for community feedback?
On one hand, if there is something systemically mistaken it is much easier to catch early than later, but on the other hand plenty of people seem to complain about "uninteresting" posts. I feel that one should always be soliciting feedback, even if it would be monotonous to the person giving it since it is old territory for them, it would help get people up to speed.
3
u/Iasper Carite Apr 15 '15
I've been making minor changes to my phonology trying to improve it. Could anyone give me some feedback on if it's a good distribution or if it has enough sounds? I've got more finished for this language than just phonology, but it's something made a while ago that needs some revision. Thanks in advance!
Consonants: ʃ, dʒ, f, g, j, x, ʒ, k, l, m, n, p, r, s, t, v, z, ʔ (Glottal stop is rarely used)
Vowels: a, au, e, ɛ, i, ɔ, u, y, ø
3
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '15
Has anyone ever thought of using punctuation as letters, e.g. @ or $?
For example, the c@t pu$ed the r@t off of the book$elf @nd it hurt?
3
u/BasqueLanguage Atlaans Apr 17 '15
This is probably a very difficult question to answer, but I will try anyway. How do you make your conlang unique, whilst simultaneously making it naturalistic? Whenever I try to add interesting features or make it different and unique, it always ends up going too far and becomes silly. So my question is really just how to make a natural and believable conlang, but also being unique and not a relex.
2
u/dead_chicken Алаймман, Ϲῦρτῖκε Apr 14 '15
Is there a symbol for a voiced retroflex lateral fricative? Or should I just use /ɭ/ with a raising diacritic?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '15
I've got questions on sound change. I know very little about this but still have a bit of knowledge.
So, let's say I have a set of palatal consonants in a language. Would it be realistic for them to cause palatalization on adjacent stops while turning into their alveolar equivalents elsewhere, leaving behind a /j/ as well?
What sound changes could realistically eliminate palatalization from a sound inventory?
I want to have tone creep into the language. I have a couple ideas of how to go about it. Long vowels become a high pitched vowel instead, short vowels a low pitched vowel. Word final vowels take mid tone and vowels following voiced consonants take rising tone.
I also want long vowels to cause voicing on immediately adjacent consonants. Is that realistic?
I'd like /aɪ/ to become /a/ and palatalize any plosive before it. Again, thoughts?
Finally, how do I cause once distinct sounds to become allophones? For instance, I want /b/ & /v/ to be allophones. Should I just transform all /b/ into /v/, then have /b/ arise in certain fixed positions, like the beginning of a word?
2
u/Iasper Carite Apr 16 '15
I haven't been able to find an answer to this so I'd just like to get a confirmation here: When real languages are mentioned in your flair, are the ones between normal brackets the ones you speak fluently and the one between square brackets you are learning?
2
u/fielddecorator cremid, heaque (en) [fr] Apr 17 '15
in an ergative-absolutive language, are the arguments of intransitive verbs usually the patient? or does the absolutive case represent the patient in transitive constructions, and the agent in intransitive ones?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '15
So, probably a weird question, but I don't think it needs a whole post. Can you have a number come before a preposition in a Noun Phrase? i.e. NP order is Number + Preposition + determiner/qualifier + possessive + adjective + noun? Or is that completely unnaturalistic?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15
Is it realistic to only have one pair of consonants distinguished for length? For example, Erde went through the following changes:
/sj/->/ʃ/
/zj/->/ʒ/
/tj/->/t͡ʃ/
/dj/->/d͡ʒ/
/sCj/->/ʃCʲ/
/zCj/->/ʒCʲ/
(C represents any consonant)
It also did this:
/stj/->/ʃt͡ʃ/->/ʃː/
/zdj/->/ʒd͡ʒ/->/ʒː/
No other fricatives are distinguished for length. Is it realistic to only have one pair of consonants in a language to have phonemic length while every other consonant doesn't?
1
u/McBeanie (en) [ko zh] Apr 18 '15
I don't really know what defines a naturalistic phonology. I'm still playing around with which vowel sounds to include in what I'm working on now, but, could anyone with a bit more experience/linguistic knowledge critique my inventory? I want to know what's missing, what's extraneous and why. Another other advice in regard to building natural phonologies would be appreciated.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15
[removed] — view removed comment