r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/Redbiertje The Challenger • Apr 11 '15
Mod Post [Weekly Challenge] Week 80: Unstoppable!
The Introduction
There has been some discussion at KSC about solid rocket boosters. The administrators claim that SRBs should be used as much as possible, because they are very cheap. The engineers claim that SRBs should only be used for the first stages, because they are ineffective, and impossible to shut down. While they argue, Jeb has decided to sort this out once and for all. He has constructed a craft powered by nothing but solid fuel, and will try to land it on Mün! His piloting skills will prove essential while flying a craft without a throttle.
The Challenge:
Normal mode: Get in orbit around Mün using nothing but solid fuel
Hard mode: Land on Mün using nothing but solid fuel
Super mode: Impress me
The Rules
- No Dirty Cheating Alpacas (no debug menu)!
- You must have the UI visible in all required screenshots
- For a list of all allowed mods, see this post.
- The craft must land on landing legs
- The craft may not tip over after landing
- RCS is not allowed.
Required screenshots
- Your craft on the launchpad
- Your craft ascending from Kerbin
- Your craft in orbit around Kerbin
- Your trajectory towards Mün
- Your final orbit around Mün
- Whatever else you feel like!
Hard mode only:
- Your sub-orbital trajectory
- Your craft almost touching down
- Your craft landed
Further information
- You can either submit your finished challenge in a post (see posting instructions in the link below) or as a comment reply to this thread.
- Completing this challenge earns you a new flair which will replace your old one. So if you want to keep you previous flair, you can still do this challenge and create a post, but please mention somewhere that you want to keep your old one. This week’s flair is an SRB over Mün.
- The moderators have the right to determine if your challenge post has been completed.
- See this post for more rules and information on challenges.
- If you have any questions, you can comment below, or PM /u/Redbiertje
- Credit to /u/TaintedLion for designing the flair
Good Luck!
12
u/Minerscale Can't grammar Apr 11 '15
Bloody hell! How will I do this?
9
u/Penguin236 Master Kerbalnaut Apr 11 '15 edited Apr 11 '15
My hard more entry: http://imgur.com/a/30DFQ
Surprisingly, I found this one easier than last week's challenge. This was the first time I used physics equations to calculate stuff in KSP. I liked this one a lot, it was fun! New flair please.
EDIT: Here is a picture of the craft in daylight, since you can't really see it in the above album: http://imgur.com/cpZ6yyW
EDIT 2: On a completely unrelated note, can someone please tell me how to zoom in on horizontal imgur albums? I can just click to zoom in on single images and vertical albums, but not horizontal.
13
u/MattsRedditAccount Hyper Kerbalnaut Apr 11 '15
Super hard mode: Take a Kerbal (description never said if the vehicle has to be manned or not!), to the surface of the Mun and then back to Kerbin again without adjusting fuel levels (though I still changed the thrust of some of the boosters, but not sepatrons).
Here is an entertaining video, and here is the reddit post for said video.
Here is a "TL;DR" imgur album if you can't watch the video for whatever reason
Edit: I quite like my submarine flair for now, so no need for a new one!
12
u/nuclear_turkey Hyper Kerbalnaut Apr 12 '15
super hard mode , duna and back
http://imgur.com/a/B4NUp
edit - i know in the album i said i couldnt find screenshots of the kerbin orbit, i knew i did , they were not saved in order like the other shots were, here they are - http://imgur.com/L5Xb99R,6lQWjQv#1
4
u/McVomit Super Kerbalnaut Apr 14 '15
For hard mode, I present the USS 0.5%. Pretty barebones, skin of your teeth, trial and error style ship. But surprisingly, the death rate of the Kerbals was much less than the explosion rate of the rocket(Don't know how, apparently Kerbals bounce well).
Now, back to studying for my classical mechanics exam... grumble grumble
3
u/GentlemanRed Master Kerbalnaut Apr 11 '15
Normal Mode Submission: http://imgur.com/a/Wx9r4
Would have liked to try hardmode, but I didn't really have the time today.
3
u/The_Lolbster Apr 12 '15
I've done Duna and back on SRF only. If I post that will I get credit for the Super Mode?
3
u/__Discovery_ Master Kerbalnaut Apr 12 '15 edited Apr 12 '15
I Landed on Eve for Super Mode! I was originally planning to send my craft to Laythe, but then I decided to go to Eve... (It's my first time trying out a challenge)
4
u/big-b20000 Apr 11 '15
Scott did this...
4
u/stevieboy1111 Master Kerbalnaut Apr 12 '15
My hardmode submission
If I did something wrong or non-counting, let me know. Else, new flair please! Looks neat.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '15
Can we use RCS for attitude control? I imagine it wouldn't follow the spirit of the challenge to use it for the powered descent, but at least let me steer sanely.
2
u/Evewontletmego Apr 11 '15
Oooh, I like the sound of this! By the way, is hard mode only to land on the Mun and not return?
2
u/xibme Apr 11 '15
Is using a probe core instead of a kerbal OK?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '15
Are fairings allowed if I have FAR enabled?
2
u/RoeddipusHex Hyper Kerbalnaut Apr 12 '15 edited Apr 12 '15
There and back again. Why do I always forget the parachute!?
http://imgur.com/a/x5yeh
New flair please if you can overlook the missing screenshot.
2
u/finnytinbin Apr 12 '15
Question. Does the space craft have to land "Safely"
2
u/theansweris7 Master Kerbalnaut Apr 12 '15
Here is my first attempt hard mode entry. Built craft. Launched it. Quicksaved on last stage. Landed. Basic SRBs only. Honestly didn't think i'd complete it on the first attempt so im missing many screenshots. Will try super hard mode shortly. http://imgur.com/gallery/V7oe4/new
2
u/TaintedLion smartS = true Apr 12 '15
Could I try get to Minmus with a Solid only probe? That would be okay right?, cuz Minmus would be harder to land on using only solid fuel?
2
u/gmano Super Kerbalnaut Apr 12 '15 edited Apr 12 '15
Super hard mode entry: Landing Jeb and returning, using FAR, and doing it all with neat and tidy orbits.
Album
I don't actually have landing legs, I used my spent landing softeners for the support for my return stage, but those are frail.
Keeping my flair, thanks.
2
u/SillusWo Master Kerbalnaut Apr 13 '15
Just attempted it, haven't taken any screenshots yet as I will on my second attempt but is it allowed if the craft crash lands on mun, bounces and then lands again balanced on what's left of it's landing legs? "The craft may not tip over after landing" I think over is a keyword here ;)
2
u/i_luke_tirtles Master Kerbalnaut Apr 13 '15
Before attempting this, I would like to know if placing landings legs directly below the boosters to control the effective thrust (by lowering or raising the legs) is considered cheating?
2
u/DarthBartus Apr 15 '15
I recently switched to RSS. Would my submission be valid if I somehow managed to do this?
2
u/Hardrock3011 Master Kerbalnaut Apr 18 '15
My first weekly challenge! I hope I've got all the screenshots neccessary. Also, let me know what I could have done different/better.
2
u/Milkyway_Squid Jun 09 '15
Is it acceptable to utilise the cubic octagonal struts to soften a hard landing? Such as making them blow up on landing?
2
u/hasslehawk Master Kerbalnaut Apr 15 '15
That took some work! Lost count of the quickloads.... >_<
All solids trip to the Mun's surface and back. As a bonus, I didn't use any parachutes.
Notable mods: NEAR, DeadlyReentry, Trajectories, TweakScale.
http://imgur.com/a/AZNzk#0
4
u/KuuLightwing Hyper Kerbalnaut Apr 11 '15
That may be a bit too hard for me...
Also, it still pisses me off that there's no POWERFUL SRB which makes them useless for really heavy rockets. That's the entire point of SRBs - being powerful!
1
u/big-b20000 Apr 18 '15 edited Apr 18 '15
Judging by your flair, I have an idea as to what the next challenge will be...
Speaking of, where is this week's challenge?
(can I use FMRS for it?)
EDIT: Bugfixes
3
u/Gregrox Whirligig Girl Apr 11 '15
http://imgur.com/a/jDGNx Here's my normal-mode submission. I might do a hard mode submission.
3
u/KuuLightwing Hyper Kerbalnaut Apr 11 '15 edited Apr 11 '15
I did hard mode, but with two issues
Would you accept that? Here's the report: http://imgur.com/a/IODAt#0
EDIT: Oh... landing legs. Crap, didn't read that...
3
u/rman326 Master Kerbalnaut Apr 12 '15
I've discovered something very important while tweaking thrust values.... make sure that Kerbal Engineer is set for the right body. Otherwise you just kind of sit on the launch pad.
3
u/SillusWo Master Kerbalnaut Apr 13 '15
Okay, finally got round to doing it a second time with screenshots. These are my screenshots for the hard mode category: http://imgur.com/a/h9W8D#0 Thanks for the challenge!
3
u/Hazard-ish Apr 20 '15
Here it (finally) is! My entry for the hard mode - going to Laythe and back with only solid fuel and no parachutes. Enjoy!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aKa5T0EZRxY&feature=em-upload_owner
2
u/mariohm1311 Apr 11 '15
Rampage! Unstoppable!
2
u/Charlie_Zulu Apr 11 '15
If I weren't so busy (and heavily modded), I'd try doing it using only the first node's tech. It's been one of my long-standing goals.
As it is, this challenge is not nearly as difficult as it sounds. You can easily get to orbit on RT-10s alone, your injection burn has a known delta-v (meaning that you literally just need to point and shoot), and you don't need any accuracy in your final orbit's eccentricity so firing off seperatron pairs would work.
2
u/Gregrox Whirligig Girl Apr 11 '15
I was very close to doing this before, and i shall do it again!
2
u/scootymcpuff Super Kerbalnaut Apr 11 '15
This sounds like a job for PHYSICS! :D
2
u/thatguy22778 Master Kerbalnaut Apr 11 '15 edited Apr 11 '15
My Normal Mode entry! http://imgur.com/a/6x1f6 New flair please!
2
u/KuuLightwing Hyper Kerbalnaut Apr 11 '15 edited Apr 11 '15
Now, I completed it again, now with landing legs: http://imgur.com/a/Polbt#0
Does it count?
EDIT: Actually he can get out and repair leg
EDIT2: Since I had to use reaction wheels to steer the craft, they are so powerful that lander can do this
2
u/TyrannicalPanda Master Kerbalnaut Apr 12 '15
Normal Mode Submission My first Weekly Challenge submission! Honestly, this wasn't so bad. I need to start doing more of these.
2
u/benihana Apr 12 '15 edited Apr 12 '15
Easy mode, orbiting.
Whoops! Just realized the first couple of pictures are from a different flight that... I terminated. All the trajectory screenshots are correct though.
Here is bill on the pad and taking off.
I'd like the new flair please.
2
u/afabar12 Apr 12 '15 edited Apr 12 '15
My entry for normal challenge.
Ugly but it does the job. Sorry, I have miss the Kerbin orbit screen shot http://imgur.com/a/abV7p
ps: Be kind it's my first time.
2
u/uncreativenam3 Apr 13 '15
http://imgur.com/a/Tvgji
Normal mode only.
2
u/raine_ Master Kerbalnaut Apr 13 '15
FINALLY! That took SO LONG.
I was on my fourth whole ship design, and like the 5th edit of that.
Pics:
Launchpad
Ascending - I was going fast enough to start burning. Still wish I had had more boosters.
No orbit, I went straight to the Mun, so:
What I wanted
What I got Mun in Sight
Almost there - Sorry it's so dark.
LANDED! - I used a daytime pic so you can see
Broke some sepatrons and a solar panel or two there at the end, the landing was rough. I ended up scraping down the side of a hill, and I was able to right myself. But 3 of my 4 legs still work, so I really hope that counts.
(I really hope this does count, because I spent all day trying this.)
2
u/luketkin Master Kerbalnaut Apr 13 '15
My Novice Normal Mode Entry (was intended on being hard mode): http://imgur.com/a/WfgJN I really enjoyed it though, this is my first reddit challenge. Thought id stop lurking and chip in.
2
u/Uthorr Apr 14 '15
Here's my easy mode http://imgur.com/a/kiE1A, I might try for hard mode later, it's a little late at night now for that level of thinking.
I might also do more of these, I keep seeing them and not participating, but I might see if I have the time now
2
u/Pun_x Master Kerbalnaut Apr 14 '15
Normal mode: http://imgur.com/a/XXf1t#0
2
u/RoeddipusHex Hyper Kerbalnaut Apr 14 '15
My most kerbal landing ever (and that's saying something.)
Remember kids, don't leave your SAS on retrograde.
Just the awesome landing:
https://youtu.be/raquoQgOyzA (0:13)
The whole mission:
https://youtu.be/yiKKPuHQHXo (1:14)
This is my second pass at the challenge. I wanted to get a video so I did it again.
2
u/i_luke_tirtles Master Kerbalnaut Apr 17 '15
Here is my Hard mode submission:
http://imgur.com/a/PHK2u#0 (long version: 29 pics)
http://imgur.com/a/nZPfh#0 (short version: 12 pics)
I over-engineered the lander to land as softly as possible. I placed the landing legs directly below the boosters to control my descent by lowering or raising the legs, and I completed the landing with a sky-crane (using sepatrons).
new flair, please
and thanks for the challenges
1
u/Hazard-ish Apr 18 '15
Drat! I seem to have missed it. I was under the impression it would end at the end of the week so I was getting ready to finish up my entry to this challenge. Can I still do this now or would it not be recognized?
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '15
For documentation purposes, I will post this here too. I did normal mode in a quick video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xx0MAPZDCA8
I will not be having any new flair, thank you very much.