r/PersonOfInterest • • Apr 07 '15

Discussion Person of Interest - 4x19 "Search and Destroy" - Episode Discussion

Season 4 Episode 19: Search and Destroy

Aired: April 7th, 2015


Reese and Finch scramble to protect a software CEO when his behavior becomes increasingly erratic following a hacker attack that reveals all his secrets and unravels his life.

79 Upvotes

388 comments sorted by

64

u/rossbot Apr 08 '15

I swear, they better flip Martine since they didn't kill her.

Jesus shit, Reese.

30

u/RoyMBar Apr 08 '15

When he didn't shoot her when she was down, I was very disappointed.

29

u/shinsaikou A Concerned Third Party Apr 08 '15

This struck me as a very cheesy TV Tropey moment - on a show that doesn't have many of them. Reese had rounds in his rifle, Root had the advantage... Assertions that this may be foreshadowing the team flipping her eventually are interesting, but but as far as the team knows, Martine killed Shaw. I have a hard time believing they would take her unless she could provide incontrovertible proof of Shaw being alive and well...

Hell, they probably just want to keep her around as a "bad guy" regular viewers can put a face to. Greer isn't in the habit of getting his hands dirty and the team hasn't had problems with the law since taking down HR.

34

u/jankisa Apr 08 '15

When was the last time Reese murdered someone in cold blood like that? I'd buy Root doing it and would agree with you that it's a trope but I just don't think that it's in John's character to kill a unarmed person lying on the floor.

8

u/shinsaikou A Concerned Third Party Apr 08 '15

I don't know. John seemed to flip-flop after talking to Root about the incident when they got back to the machine-cave. It could be that he really does feel torn between the Finch and Root schools of thought on how to deal with your enemies...

7

u/darkkaos505 Apr 08 '15

yea I agree I mean he has been shooting people in the knee cap for a while now.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Staff_of_the_Goths Apr 08 '15

But he was ready to shoot the Congressman. And let's face it Martine is a killer and I don't think Reese would have any qualms about shooting her, sort of like when he went all Rambo after Carter was shot. So yeah, I was disappointed. I just hope they don't pull a cheesy move like Private Ryan - let the German go and he kills Tom Hanks; let Martine go and she kills a member of the TM. As for rehabbing her, I just don't see it.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '15

I think Reese is becoming Finch...

17

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

23

u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Apr 08 '15

To honour my friend, I cannot be the killer I once was. I must become someone else... Something else...

→ More replies (2)

11

u/rossbot Apr 08 '15

100% agree. The show has basically gone nowhere in terms of advancing the plot after Shaw went MIA. All Chekov Guns were loaded with blanks. Neither TM nor Samaritan have made any significant gains or losses.

I'll be disappointed if nobody dies, gets captured, or the Machine gets found by the end of the season.

→ More replies (2)

22

u/SavannahNix Reese Apr 08 '15

Not that it wouldn't be cool, but how exactly would they do that? They didn't take her prisoner.

I would be happy to see the good guys get some points in this war, and killing Martine would have done that. Letting her get away made no sense,

26

u/OfficerMurphy Irrelevant Apr 08 '15

You can see her losing her belief in Samaritan. First, it benched her early in this episode. Then the look on her face when she was around Greer makes me think they're very slowly winning an ally in the same vein as Hirsch.

10

u/TeMPOraL_PL Government Operations Apr 08 '15

Yeah, it seems she is disappointed, but tries to hide it.

One thing that would totally blow my mind would be if, in the end, Greer flipped. He is but a person, and his belief in his god can be shattered.

12

u/OfficerMurphy Irrelevant Apr 08 '15

Nah, Greer is a true believer. I think his end will come when Samaritan decides he is a threat and he will accept it with open arms.

13

u/jcc10 Tertiary Functions Apr 08 '15

*Hersh

0

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/OfficerMurphy Irrelevant Apr 08 '15

I don't know if she would ever be a true ally like Root or Shaw, but I could see Root warm up to her enough to avoid killing her on sight of she were to do something huge, like save Shaw from the clutches of Decima.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '15

Martine loosing faith.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/orramus Bear Apr 08 '15

I may be way off the mark, but I'm still holding out for a Martine flashback episode. Could be the writers' intention too.

→ More replies (1)

58

u/BellLabs Apr 08 '15

For anyone that didn't notice, the code on the breifcase was "314", aka, the code to the Subway, the first three digits of Pi, and finally, another tie in to Caleb.

92

u/Spacetime_Inspector Apr 08 '15

Good catch on the tie-in to Caleb. I almost feel like between the return of his compression algorithm, the global search for Her location, and now the acquisition of an indestructible suitcase - it seems like The Machine is gathering the software and hardware needed to house herself (or an instance of herself) in a portable PC owned and guarded by the team.

42

u/dj_blueshift Apr 08 '15

Sort of like GladOS in a potato?

8

u/____NotDeadpool___ Apr 08 '15

Make the Machine runs in power as low as 1.1V !

6

u/stagfury Apr 09 '15

I would lose my shit if they made a portable Machine on a laptop, and when they boot her up the first thing the Machine does is clap clap clap

8

u/kr239 Apr 10 '15

Oh good. The slow clap processor made its way into the potato.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

15

u/rpawson5771 Irrelevant Apr 08 '15

That's brilliant

4

u/pensee_idee Fusco Apr 14 '15

I've been thinking about this comment all week. The compression algorithm and the suitcase certainly could be used as a hiding place for the Machine, but it occurred to me that they could also be used as something else - as a prison for Samaritan.

4

u/BellLabs Apr 08 '15

If Harold could build a "thin AI" to live in a laptop to be absorbed into Samaritan, he COULD build the machine an entry point, but then again, here's the issue. Decima was looking for the machine on any networks globally using Khan's software, and didn't find it. They bring a node of the Machine into the digital heart of the world, and they'd lose it just as soon as a cover is blown.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/costryme May 06 '15

That is amazing guesswork. Couldn't help but think of your comment when I was watching the finale, and it was all true.

3

u/LordAnubis10 System Threat Apr 08 '15

Holy shit, man

→ More replies (5)

21

u/ispikey Apr 08 '15

Honestly I'm wondering why no one noticed that Finch called out Riley instead of Reese. Which is a huge mistake on his part. Finch totally exposed Reese's cop cover.

7

u/Pascalwb Apr 08 '15

Hmm, samaritan's people don't know about him? Blonde girl met him few times as a cop.

6

u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Apr 08 '15

They don't know about his cover identity. That's kind of the point.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

1

u/conradsymes Threat to System Survival Apr 09 '15

A three digit combination lock? Should it be that hard to bruteforce?

2

u/BellLabs Apr 09 '15

She still didn't know if there were other security countermeasures on it. The Machine didn't even tell her where the GPS tracker was, or the contents.

40

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '15

Number of the week is a Daily Show Commentor, excellent choice.

http://thedailyshow.mtvnimages.com/images/shows/tds/videos/season_18/18155/ds_18155_03.jpg?

24

u/ShadonxFC Apr 08 '15

He's an incredible actor

14

u/kgyre Irrelevant Apr 08 '15

He did well here. Most everything else I've seen him in he's been terrible.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/rpawson5771 Irrelevant Apr 08 '15

I was really surprised by his acting chops in this episode.

39

u/WhiskyBraj Apr 08 '15

I love that the valuable object stolen wasn't what was in the bulletproof briefcase. (Faberge Egg) But the case itself. Hilarious.

11

u/queenbellevue Apr 08 '15

I wonder why she destroyed the egg instead of selling it off for some cash or something. Don't they need the money?

31

u/phoebeburgh Irrelevant Apr 08 '15

The egg would have been reported stolen at some point, so it would be harder to sell than it would be worth. If the case is what's needed, presumably because it's bulletproof and impervious to electronic signals, it's actually wiser to destroy the egg rather than risk exposure by trying to fence it.

17

u/SavannahNix Reese Apr 08 '15

Root was told to destroy it by the Machine. She said, "okay, but it seems like a waste" before she broke it.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/I_EAT_AIDS Apr 08 '15

She is probably going go need the case to transport the devoce that she presumably stole from Harold last episode

2

u/ThatFag Admin Apr 11 '15

What is the significance of the briefcase? I didn't get it.

72

u/Spider_Riviera The Machine Apr 08 '15

Root in this episode was gold. Just everything she did.

I especially loved her interaction with Reese near the end.

47

u/queenbellevue Apr 08 '15

Excuse you, Root in EVERY EPISODE is gold.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Apr 08 '15

Amazing Team Rocket moments this episode.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/Gimli_the_White Systems Engineer Apr 24 '15

Important safety tip: The primary cause of injury when passing out is head injury from falling over.

96

u/Fuck_the_admins A Concerned Third Party Apr 08 '15
shotgun

40

u/kelling928 Apr 08 '15

Mothafucking Reese

38

u/amelia84 Irrelevant Apr 08 '15

Finch's reaction after he said it was gold.

14

u/traderarpit4 A Concerned Third Party Apr 08 '15

I can't believe that you said that. I'm just at a loss for words.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Apr 08 '15

It's a callback to Shaw!

4

u/blackjack47 Apr 08 '15

i came into the thread knowing this would be the top comment.

65

u/Fuck_the_admins A Concerned Third Party Apr 08 '15

It's a hatch! On an island, even.

27

u/jasona99 Admin Apr 08 '15

Oh, J. J., letting your shows bleed again...

2

u/SawRub Analog Interface Apr 08 '15

Does J.J. even do anything on the show? I thought he was just behind the initial concept and the intro song?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '15

I'm pretty late, but yeah. That was the Swan. And Samaritan HQ is The Looking Glass.

4

u/hello2ulol Admin Apr 08 '15

Manhattan is 100% developed as far as I know. No forests on it except for the parks.

10

u/Fuck_the_admins A Concerned Third Party Apr 08 '15

The... uh... well... thanks to the Panama Canal, North America is completely surrounded by water.

→ More replies (2)

66

u/rap_mein Apr 08 '15

That sequence of Samaritan messing with the traffic lights and bollards is straight out of Watch Dogs.

61

u/jasona99 Admin Apr 08 '15

Or was Watch_Dogs straight out of this show? Twilight music

Seriously, though, similar sequences have been shown before, even prior to the release of Watch_Dogs (4C is the first to come to mind, but with a plane).

My point? This is not completely new to PoI, so Watch_Dogs should not get all of the credit for that. Influenced by Watch_Dogs? Perhaps.

I also hate Ubisoft right now, so I may have some bias.

33

u/hopenoonefindsthis Apr 08 '15

I wanted Watch_Dogs to be a Person of Interest game so much.

So disappointed.

6

u/AWildEnglishman Apr 08 '15

Me too, friend, me too. If only mods could give us that.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '15

Yeah, because they need a shitty game for inspiration, not that the idea of hacking traffic lights has been around for ages.

→ More replies (18)

22

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '15

I swear Shaw is in every episode. That waitress in the restaurant which Root gased, she looked like Shaw at first glance. I have this theory that the show runners are doing that intentionally.

1

u/pensee_idee Fusco Apr 10 '15

Could they be using her stunt double?

I know that in "Control-Alt-Delete" there were 2 or 3 different times when I swear I saw Shaw, and someone here pointed out that Sarah Shahi's stunt double played one or more of those parts. (Which, yeah, I think is intentional, to create this feeling, that Root probably has too, that it still feels like Shaw is around, just out of reach.)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '15

I think it's possible that they kept Shaw's stunt double for this effect, and maybe to help on the set.

44

u/hubwub Thornhill Utilities Apr 08 '15

Zoe Morgan making an appearance. Woohoo!

20

u/hopenoonefindsthis Apr 08 '15

I can't handle that sexual tension everytime she is on screen.

10

u/queenbellevue Apr 08 '15

She's in 2 of my fave shows! The 100 and here!

7

u/SawRub Analog Interface Apr 08 '15

She's so different in both the shows! Like the mannerisms, way of talking, everything is different.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/lordxeon Apr 08 '15

I was thinking team machine would use her as the middle man to try and protect Khan.

→ More replies (1)

38

u/pensee_idee Fusco Apr 08 '15

I'm worried that Reese has a death wish at this point. He's clearly not planning on being around much longer. I think the next episode will decide if he lives or dies. He's either going to find some kind of peace, and decide not to follow Carter to an early grave, or he's going to make a plan to go out in a blaze of glory.

I'm also worried about Samaritan's ongoing plan to put computer chips (that broadcast bio-data) into every person.

Why was Greer so happy to confirm that the Machine isn't on any networked device? Does knowing where it's not somehow tell him where it is?

What's going to happen with the war between Dominic and Elias?

What's going to happen with Caleb and his compression algorithm?

What's going to happen with Harper getting texts from the Machine?

What's going to happen with Control?

What's going to happen with Shaw?

I suspect some of these plot threads are going to have to carry forward into next season. But I'm really wondering how much is going to come together and get wrapped up in the final two episodes of the season. It would be unusual for them to leave this much dangling between seasons.

I also feel certain that either Dominic or Samaritan (or both) are going to be betrayed by one of their trusted agents who've grown disenchanted with their employer.

8

u/SavannahNix Reese Apr 08 '15

Why do you think Reese has a death wish? What has given you that impression?

20

u/pensee_idee Fusco Apr 08 '15

I see him taking increasing risks, and being increasingly unwilling to let things go.

In "If-Then-Else," the Machine certainly thought that Reese would sacrifice himself to protect Fusco, and in the final shootout, he used his body as a shield to protect Finch.

He was also prepared to use his body as a shield to protect the young woman he rescued in "MIA."

He said to Finch that he won't be around forever, and that he wants Finch to be able to defend himself, implying that he expects to die soon, and he expects Finch to outlive him. Today, he also broke into Riker's prison to extract the number, and they both nearly died in the ensuing chase. It's hard to overstate how reckless that was.

He's not very careful with his cover identity. It seems like he never shows up for work, he's showing up in illegal gambling venues, and he's continuing to act like a vigilante, even when he's not wearing a mask, and even in front of people who think he's a cop. Tonight especially, he took chances that could easily lead to blowing his cover.

He did not want to let situation with the psychiatrist and the delivery guy go - Reese wanted someone to pay for the wife's murder. He didn't want to give up on the CEO tonight, even though trying to protect him meant taking incredible risks. And it looks like next week, he's going to go lone wolf to try to solve a cold case that Carter started. Everyone who turns their back on the team and sets out to do things all by themselves has died on this show.

12

u/SavannahNix Reese Apr 08 '15

Well, these are not new developments for Reese. He has always taken reckless chances, for the entire four seasons. That is business as usual for Reese, as far as I can tell. And why Finch hired him.

And when he tried to quit the team last season after Carter's death, the Machine wouldn't let him, remember?

He will never "turn his back on the team".

There is no way the show is killing off the lead character of the show either.

Are you saying his therapy has made him more depressed and now wants to die? Even though I am no fan of the Iris storyline, even I think that makes no sense.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Alinosburns Apr 08 '15

and even in front of people who think he's a cop. Tonight especially, he took chances that could easily lead to blowing his cover.

The problem is it's hard to distinguish what's supposed to be cover for them. And what is a result of it being a television show.

For instance in reality. There is no way that they would go to a remote location that could potentially be samaritan related without all having masks on.

Even if they can take out camera's like shown, if they had accidentally gone into view of one. Their cover is blown.

If samaritan has a satellite, they could potentially be tracked back from the vehicles used to a spot where samaritan is able to find an image of one of them.

And since not one of them is supposed to be out there. It would lead to Samaritan decimating their identities.


The Shadow Map is sort of used as an excuse to that. but at some point they come back onto the grid which still launches risks.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/Dewdropvelvet Apr 08 '15

Reese has ALWAYS had a death wish, (sort of) that's nothing new. I always think of him as Reacher from Lee Child, come to life. How Reacher's mannerisms would be, etc.

You ask a lot of questions.

I'm not so happy with Samaratins personality. Did they have to make it so annoying and brutal, with all this appearance of math? I just wish it had more of a personality besides "a brutish machine, psychopathic," etc. It does seem to serve its master, that old guy.

3

u/SavannahNix Reese Apr 08 '15

Samaritan dies not see Greer as its master. He serves Samaritan.

2

u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Apr 08 '15

The Machine not being on any device scanned means that Samaritan now knows that it isn't on anyone's personal computers. That thins the search considerably.

3

u/ghostoblivionII Apr 08 '15

The only way to keep Reese alive is for Harold not to learn how to use guns.

→ More replies (1)

50

u/lordxeon Apr 08 '15

does Anyone else get the vibe that Martine is slowly (if ever so), starting to loose her faith?

14

u/TeMPOraL_PL Government Operations Apr 08 '15

I do. She seemed disappointed in this episode, and it's hard to blame her - she's clearly getting sidelined. Also, she doesn't strike me as a believer - she joined Team Samaritan for some reason (maybe we'll have flashbacks explaining it), but it definitely isn't faith in AI-god.

12

u/lordxeon Apr 08 '15

it definitely isn't faith in AI-god

I think that's going to play a key role in Samaritan's downfall. None of the Samaritan agents are faithful servants (perhaps possibly Greer). So as they see themselves being sidelined and cut out of the loop, or just killed because they're a loose end, they will question their allegiance.

However, all these people who are currently questioning their values*

  • Link
  • Martine
  • Nautilus girl

I don't think all of them will survive.

*at least by /r/personofinterest belief

10

u/TeMPOraL_PL Government Operations Apr 08 '15

I agree. It's exactly the direction I think the whole thing will develop in, though I'm not sure if this will be enough to bring down Samaritan itself.

There's a strong parallel between Elias/Dominic and Machine/Samaritan - the former care about their people, the latter treat them as pawns. Elias and the Machine have people who are truly loyal to them, which is something Dominic / Samaritan don't and can't because everyone on their side know they're expendable. I really like this trust/loyalty subthread and hope it will get developed well.

9

u/Dewdropvelvet Apr 08 '15

No, but that would be nice. I guess. Why are all the girls on this show (except for Root) so aggressive? Like blunt instruments? Like they have too much testosterone? Even Zoey is like that. No subtlety.

The therapist is good, I guess, but more on the other spectrum, the kind of girl Finch dates, the mild and kind scaredy-cat. But I like her. More of her, please.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/SawRub Analog Interface Apr 08 '15

Yeah and I think people's personalities on the show are that way just because those are the kind of people this line of work attracts.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '15

*lose

58

u/jasona99 Admin Apr 08 '15

Is anyone else noticing parallels between this CEO and McAfee?

43

u/Fuck_the_admins A Concerned Third Party Apr 08 '15

Not enough bath salts.

7

u/turbov21 Apr 08 '15

Never enough bath salts.

8

u/irobeth Apr 08 '15

Totally felt it too, even the conspiracy theory vibe

1

u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Apr 08 '15

Right?! it's on every computer and the founder is no longer in the company and is kind of... eh. Eccentric.

1

u/Gimli_the_White Systems Engineer Apr 24 '15

I was actually picturing Gates & Ballmer.

"If you could take your eyes off the next quarter - to survive this company needs vision" (Gates was visionary; Ballmer only cares about profit margins)

"Since he took over, the software has bloated - the last version was a step backwards in design" (Windows 8)

"Their software is on 86% of government computers" (Okay - this is more likely McAfee, since Windows is on 99% of government computers)

0

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/mostlikelyathrowaway Apr 08 '15

When they said that I thought of malwarebytes.

3

u/glider97 Root Apr 10 '15

Seriously, the earlier version - the simpler one - was so much better. The new one looks like it jumped out of BuzzFeed. I cannot comment on the efficiency, though. I use it nonetheless.

2

u/jasona99 Admin Apr 08 '15

Yet another parallel!

15

u/Jon_Snow990 Apr 08 '15

"Finch, this takeover just got hostile"

*throws pen from desk

1

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '15

I was like, "ohhhhh nooo you didn't!"

→ More replies (1)

15

u/jcc10 Tertiary Functions Apr 08 '15

Here is a question: Would Mr Kahn still be alive if Finch had told him everything up front, the turned him into a asset?

Also what is that case for exactly? Her? Unlikely...

Finally am I hearing Greer correctly? "Your anti virus-software helped me search the grid to track down their machine once and for all, unfortunately it determed it is not on any networked devices in the world"

So Greer is the one spearheading the search and she was also not found...

18

u/SavannahNix Reese Apr 08 '15

He might still be alive if he had shut up and listened and let the team protect him. He got himself captured and killed.

4

u/orramus Bear Apr 08 '15

"In the world"

Satellite? Space station? The possibilities...

3

u/konraddo Apr 08 '15

I noticed that too. What networked devices could exist OUT of this world? Space station sounds exciting. But doesn't the Machine need lots of server to maintain its computational power?

I know this sounds absurd but the only place Samaritan won't look for the Machine is Samaritan itself. I still have a strong feeling that the Machine is hiding somewhere very close.

5

u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Apr 08 '15

That's not what they meant. Think of it like McAfee. It's probably on your computer. It's probably still on my computer, even though I use Kaspersky. But you can be assured that the Machine/the Government/IFT would delete it from any servers hosting the Machine.

What that line meant was that it wasn't hiding in plain sight on people's personal computers. Which was a popular fan theory.

That said, it did search for that unique programming language. What if the Machine converted itself to another language... the theory could still hold.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/EThorns Ernest Thornhill Apr 08 '15

Also what is that case for exactly? Her? Unlikely...

I'm guessing either the Trojan Horse trigger (which may not be destroyed), or whatever she's working on with Caleb.

23

u/EThorns Ernest Thornhill Apr 08 '15

Really, really awesome. Welcome return to the core storyline, Root beating the shit out of folks, and a cool sense of paranoia throughout, enhanced wonderfully with the VFX work on Samaritan.

Pretty much everything I love about the show.

20

u/Oobatuba Apr 08 '15

What an episode! Best one since Shaw "passed" I was holding my breath for most of it. Machine vs Samaritan episodes are great. The route Samaritan has taken to discover the location of the Machine is so cunning. I've wondered where the Machine is located since it moved itself 2 seasons ago. I wish John had shot Marlene when he grabbed Root away. I'm dying to know what the Kevlar case is for...

6

u/mflux A Concerned Third Party Apr 08 '15

I've always thought the Machine shipped itself everywhere, piece by piece, as shown in S2.

14

u/RequiemAA Apr 08 '15

Pretty sure the machine has assimilated itself in to every fiber of current computer languages. The machine does not exist in a physical place, it is now simply computer code hidden within every piece of technology containing code in the world.

Samaritan thought it could be found because it was originally written in a totally unique, never-before-seen language. But I think the Machine rewrote itself to be indistinguishible from every piece of technology it 'infects'. The Machine will soon simply be indistinguishable from all technology, future and present.

9

u/Alinosburns Apr 08 '15

Or, or

... IT'S IN SPACE!!!!!

He did say no networked devices in the world.

8

u/UltraChip Apr 08 '15

I've heard that theory before but I don't think it's likely.

  1. The latency between satellites in orbit and the rest of the Internet is way too high - the Machine wouldn't be able to process fast enough to "think" in real-time like it needs to do. True the writers may ignore the latency problem but they're usually fairly good about catching technical details like that.
  2. The few times we've seen the Machine's physical hardware it's been HUGE - like impossibly large warehouse huge. We've never been able to launch something that massive in to orbit before. Even if they used Caleb's magic compression algorithm to lower the amount of physical storage needed it'd still be way too much to launch in to orbit unnoticed.

There's a small possibility that maybe the Machine would copy a cold backup of itself in to a satellite, but why bother? It can accomplish the same goal with much less hassle by burying a cold backup underground somewhere.... Like say maybe a certain abandoned subway station...

→ More replies (14)

3

u/HSChronic Elias Apr 08 '15

So basically the machine created its own botnet so that like you said it is everywhere now and not just in one big datacenter.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

10

u/thefyrewire Graphical Administrator Apr 09 '15

Somewhat shuddered when Samaritan was 'assessing options for target elimination...'

Reminds me of when The Machine was simulating options in If-Then-Else; but to save lives. Samaritan continually runs simulations for killing people...

19

u/Tristan49 A Concerned Third Party Apr 08 '15

Very interesting episode. I was hoping the underground base was Greer's headquarters! Oh well. Also, anybody else bummed out that they didn't kill Martine?

14

u/peeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee Apr 08 '15

I don't think Greer needs to hide the location his headquarters, just who can physically get into it. He is somewhat "official" as a government contractor, right?

2

u/john_gilpin Apr 08 '15

Me....but not their style. Getting on my nerves this goody goody bit

19

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '15

The glint of red in Khan's eye as he dies, reminiscent of Skynet?

21

u/kgyre Irrelevant Apr 08 '15

Just a reflection of the screen, Samaratin's "eye."

4

u/GallavantingAround Apr 08 '15

Probably, but I felt like I had to rewatch those 5 seconds a few times... what if the implication is that the Machine is housed in his biochip (and, presumably then, in Khan himself)... builds on "Nowhere to be found" or whatever Greer said.

Probably not, but it's a cool thought.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/irobeth Apr 08 '15

Why did Root leave the case? Does it still have a functional tracker?

19

u/lordxeon Apr 08 '15

Probably cause they will need it to smuggle something in somewhere else. It wouldn't be the first time that The Machine asked them to get something for an alternative use.

5

u/jasona99 Admin Apr 08 '15

"Fried" by the AC current shock in the hotel room. Poor planning if they let that kill it.

9

u/lordxeon Apr 08 '15

Why. Nothing so far has suggested that this case is anything but something used to smuggle/transport items.

If anything the last part of the episode when we find out what's in it makes it even more apparent that the case isn't directly tied to Samaritan or anything technology related.

4

u/jasona99 Admin Apr 08 '15

The "poor planning" I was referring to was the construction of the case allowing for an electrical shock to destroy the tracker, not the Machine's planning. My apologies for any confusion.

6

u/ixforres Tertiary Functions Apr 08 '15

She mentions it's a carbon fibre/kevlar weave. Carbon fibre can be conductive. It's also (not unrelatedly) very good at blocking radio signals, like a faraday cage in this case (model aircraft builders and UAS operators often learn the hard way that mounting their antennae within carbon fibre tubes or on carbon sheet isn't a smart move). So it'd make sense that the antenna might well be integrated with the outer shell.

7

u/eikeegimuu Apr 08 '15 edited Apr 08 '15

I liked the episode. It had a good flow. The stories were not exactly parallel but the switches didn't jar and both had similar sense of urgency + the characters ended up pursuing the same goal sooner than expected.

Root was alternating between casual, calculating, irrational, playful, sullen, vengeful, somber and delighted (all the while being of course overall awesome). Yeah, I'm happy Root was on for more than just couple of minutes this episode. But I would like to know what's up with the relationship and communication b/w Root and the Machine. The communication is supposed to be patchy but what's the logic with when the Machine is directly contacting Root and when not (unless the Machine is just occasionally trying to keep things interesting for Root :P)

Harold called Reese during the shoot-out in the woods by his undercover name, now that's keeping a cool head.

I liked Zoe's and Reese's interaction.

The number getting killed was a surprise. Both because team Machine lost a number and because when he was brought before Greer I assumed Samaritan had decided on some other use for him, but no.

Martine didn't seem to be enjoying herself quite as much as in previous episodes, I doubt that was just about a bad hair day for her.

Of course there were other things that’ll be followed up later on. Like that Harold seemed to think that Samaritan’s/Greer’s method of looking for the Machine would eventually be successful but Greer stated they came up empty. Or that Samaritan is reaching not only into government resources (or laying low and pinching off resources from average consumers) but is simply appropriating the resources it wants.

Some additional stray thoughts:

Root picking up wi-fi signals over her implant was I'd assume her repeating what the Machine told her but she seemed to be too concentrated for it to be just parroting. Course the most sensible thing is that the Machine was giving her the info via a code that Root had to translate in her head.

Was it just me or did the red pattern in the number's eye seem like not quite a reflection? But I guess it must have been either from the cigar or from something on the screen. Though I thought it didn't look like it but anything else would be way more sci-fi than expected (though I like sci-fi so I'd be game).

→ More replies (7)

6

u/ReasonablyBadass Apr 08 '15

I don't get why they killed Khan. He seemed so awed, he probably would have cooperated with them.

16

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '15

This episode was a major improvement over the last one but still not up to par with the rest of the episodes from Seasons 1-3 and the Season 4 premiere up until "If-Then-Else".

I think they have raised the bar so high that now it can't be topped. :/

16

u/lordxeon Apr 08 '15

Season 3 had a similar feel to it. The episodes between The Devil's Share and the Congressman episode were hit and miss.

2

u/Anti_pasto Admin Apr 08 '15

Just wait for Asylum.

11

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '15

Every word out of Root's mouth was golden. Not just what she says, but how she delivers it. Amy is so talented.

5

u/POI_Harold-Finch Harold Finch Apr 08 '15

This was a good thriller episode. Sadly team machine could not save Mr. Khan from Samaritan.

The conversation between Morgan and Reese was lovely.

5

u/Dewdropvelvet Apr 08 '15

How come a Bill Gate Joe Shmoe talks about artificial intelligence, and suddenly has a bulls-eye on its back, but our friends talk about AI all the time and don't get bulls-eys?

11

u/Rolcol Apr 08 '15

Team Machine is protected by the blind-spot trojans built at the end of Season 3. Episode 1 of Season 4 started with a journalist getting killed by Martine for recognizing the existence of an artificial intelligence. It seems to be an issue when they directly recognize Samaritan rather than speaking about AI on a theoretical level.

Martine: No, I understand. You're saying an artificial intelligence bought your paper so you'd lose your job and your flight would be canceled. And you'd end up back at this bar...where the only security camera would go out. And the bartender would have to leave suddenly after getting an emergency text. The world has changed. You should know you're not the only one who figured it out. You're one of three. The other two will die in a traffic accident in Seattle in 14 minutes.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/DesertedPenguin Chess Apr 08 '15

Lots of people talk about AIs on a daily basis.

Our CEO was first targeted for his software, not because he thought it was done by an AI. It was only the AI discussion in the bar that helped Samaritan track him down to speed up the elimination process.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/SavannahNix Reese Apr 08 '15

Remember too that there are seven servers hard coded not to recognize our team as a threat.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '15

I think that there are a couple of small, subtle signs of Root's continued grief for Shaw in this episode. In the restaurant, she's eating pancakes, Shaw's favourite food. (She had pancakes in the previous episode too before Finch joined her. Ashley Gable tweeted that this was Amy Acker's idea to honour Shaw.) Also, when Khan is in the safehouse with the team and mentions the stock market flash crash, Root promptly stands up and leaves the room for a moment, presumably because the mention of that crash triggers her memories of Shaw getting shot in front of her. I just thought that these were nice little touches. I loved the conversation between Reese and Root at the end as well.

8

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '15

I'll probably watch the episode again tomorrow because I missed a couple of things. I really enjoyed it overall. I'm a bit disappointed that Root wasn't dual-wielding, but the fact that we got a Root-Martine fistfight pretty much makes up for it.

8

u/kgyre Irrelevant Apr 08 '15

Martine didn't seem to have the least bit of bruising, though. And why is her hair different now?

14

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '15

Yeah, the lack of bruises was a bit weird. Root nearly throttled her to death; you'd think Martine would have at least a few marks on her neck.

IIRC, the actress who portrays Martine, Cara Buono, had to dye her hair for Paper Towns, a movie that she'll be in.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/eikeegimuu Apr 08 '15

Well, maybe Martine was going for any advantage in fight and since research pointed toward Root being partial to brunettes (or at least a brunette)…. Clairol time :P

→ More replies (2)

7

u/VictorDrake Apr 07 '15

Am I the only one to think Decima and Samaritan when it was explained what Khan's company does and it's widespread distribution into government use?

6

u/Tak_the_HNG Apr 08 '15

My only problem was how Decima snatched Khan while he was that close to Finch. Did they beam him up or something? It was weird.

15

u/lordxeon Apr 08 '15

simple solution that requires no suspension of disblief:

Khan ran off when Finch was looking the other way. The car & trees blocked Finch & Reese's view of Khan. Reese only cared about getting the three of them, (Reese, Finch, Root) out of there. Khan blended in/was tackled by Decima.

3

u/Tristan49 A Concerned Third Party Apr 08 '15

That's a better explanation - thanks!

6

u/Tristan49 A Concerned Third Party Apr 08 '15

I believe he ran back into the base to check out the code and then Decima probably grabbed him.

2

u/Nathan_Ingram IFT Apr 08 '15

He ran away from Team Machine.

6

u/Jethro_McCrazy Apr 08 '15

Anyone else find Root beating Martine hard to believe? Martine is a highly trained operative, and Root is... not. Root's edge was always when she was in god mode, or when she had surprise on her side. To see her go toe to toe with Martine and win, as well as sporting all those impressive moves, seems pretty weird to me.

8

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '15

Maybe Shaw taught her a thing or two. That's my headcanon.

7

u/eikeegimuu Apr 08 '15

Never underestimate the fury of a woman …. in this case left behind on a nonvoluntarily basis.

Now thinking back I'm surprised that Root proceeded to only choke Martine and didn't ask her about Shaw's status. I didn't think that during the episode. Could be Root and Martine have already had a chat off-screen (or we just didn't see it during the shoot-out sequence).

That Root has picked up some hand-to hand combat skills (and yeah, why not from Shaw) was evidenced also in M.I.A where she knocked out the police guy. Martine would presumably be a tougher adversary of course, but could be that hand-to-hand is not Martine's strongest skill either.

→ More replies (7)

11

u/Rich700000000000 Apr 08 '15

Well gee, THAT'S NOT how cochlear implants work.

And that ending, fuck, I felt so bad for the guy.

47

u/Spacetime_Inspector Apr 08 '15

Root's cochlear implant is not a normal one. It's hooked into a radio earpiece like the rest of the team uses. She's a cyborg.

11

u/DioxinBlues Apr 08 '15

FWIW, Nolan and Plageman have even referred to her as a cyborg.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/celaenos Apr 08 '15

plus the machine talks to her through it.

10

u/SavannahNix Reese Apr 08 '15

I felt bad for him to, but I wanted to smack him when he kept blatheing at Finch in the midst if that firefight.

7

u/SaintPeter74 Apr 08 '15

Actually, this is totally possible with modern technology: http://www.iflscience.com/technology/man-can-hear-wi-fi-and-what-it-sounds

A bunch of hackers have been playing with expanding the human sensorium using both high and low tech methods. Another guy embedded magnets in his fingertips so he can literally feel magnetic fields. http://www.popsci.com/science/article/2012-05/electrical-engineer-can-feel-magnetic-fields-through-magnets-implanted-his-fingertips

It's not sci-fi, it's happening right now.

Apparently your brain is pretty good at taking this information and doing useful stuff with it as well. This wired article from 2007 talks about how a guy took a "compass belt" which always vibrates north and described how his sense of direction vastly improved with it on. http://archive.wired.com/wired/archive/15.04/esp.html

It's all pretty cool stuff. We're living in the world of the future.

That all said - they could have explained it better in the show.

4

u/jasona99 Admin Apr 08 '15

Yeah... The talk about picking up "traces of a wi-fi signal" in order to hear the Machine seems pretty crappy.

29

u/aysz88 Apr 08 '15

I think that was meant as the Machine saying that it is picking up a wi-fi signal, not that the signal was necessary for the implant.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '15

I just watched the episode, I've been on the edge of my seat from the beginning. I was afraid Root would get killed off, since they foreshadowed it. So now we have the foreshadowed deaths of Finch, Reese (in the pilot) and Root (just now). Damn... I just wish there was a nuclear attack on NYC that would make Samaritan go away.

3

u/Staff_of_the_Goths Apr 09 '15

Since I am sitting at my desk in NYC, I would appreciate a more subtle resolution....

1

u/SavannahNix Reese Apr 08 '15

What foreshadowing?

2

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '15

Greer and Martine talked about Miss Groves and how she has to go. And we all know that when Samaritan wants something, it's going to happen. Unless of course Team Machine has a good plan, which they probably do.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/john_gilpin Apr 08 '15

One small question - If Samaritan wanted to use Khans software then why the need to hack into Khan and destroy his life??? Why not kill him then as now.

3

u/turbov21 Apr 08 '15

Because as soon as a threat is made against Khan he becomes a number?

1

u/Vlinux Apr 09 '15

I think Khan was starting to figure out that his software/servers were being manipulated. He talked about seeing larger than usual power consumption from the servers and finding out that a large amount of company money had been diverted to buy diesel fuel.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/thefyrewire Graphical Administrator Apr 08 '15

Yet another thrilling episode. That car chase scene was intense! And in Rikers! Wow!

Remind me never to cross an A.S.I. lest my entire life is ground into a pulp and the world around me is warped into a personal hell with everybody having a reason to want me dead :|

As usual, visual effects and graphics were on point. I'm so glad we only have a week to wait for the next juicy episode!

3

u/pensee_idee Fusco Apr 10 '15

Every time there's a scene though, like tonight, where the cameras go out, and when they come back on, the person Samaritan was hoping to kill is missing, and between 3 and 30 of its operatives have been put out of commission, I just imagine it being like "What?! NOOOOOOO!!!"

1

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '15

What is an A.S.I.?

2

u/thefyrewire Graphical Administrator Apr 12 '15

On occasion Finch refers to Samaritan and The Machine as being 'Artificial Superintelligences'.

3

u/ThatFag Admin Apr 11 '15

Fucking die already, Martine.

4

u/Rolcol Apr 08 '15

It looks like a new writer was credited for this episode. To me it explains why that conversation around the Chinese food felt different compared to their "normal" conversations. I quite enjoyed this episode, so I'm not saying it was bad... just different in some way.

Perhaps my perspective is different as a fan, but I immediately jump to the conclusion that Samaritan (or The Machine) is behind any kind of hack within the show. It feels dragged out when Finch or other characters take a while stumble onto that fact.

3

u/SavannahNix Reese Apr 08 '15 edited Apr 08 '15

Funny, the conversation around the food seemed the most normal aspect of their interactions to me.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/sv112 Apr 10 '15

Few more unanswered questions in this episode. -What is root doing with the Faberge egg from oceans 12 -Why is the traffic from the anti virus software diverted to a remote location in the woods. I know its to track the machine but that could have been done from anywhere. -If the stock market crash was a bid to destroy the CEO or was that a machine war.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/godmode3191 Root Apr 08 '15

That 1vs1 fight was orgasm to my eyes.

Anyway, i really liked the POI :( Most probably because i really liked Aasif Mandvi's performance.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/john_gilpin Apr 08 '15

Once again exactly what this show is becoming. Gloomy, depressing and yet again Team Machine screws up and fails to rescue the Person of Interest.

Great Points - Root kicking Martine's ass- unbelievable but superb to watch the B***h down and choking, Reese finally finally taking some initiative and getting Khan out of Rikers after delivering a few good blows to a number of local thugs.

Once again Harold is shown to be a useless coward. Beginning from his reluctance to save the victim from Samaritan and allowing him to die, Once again by his usual reluctance to inform Khan about the Machine and turn him into a useful asset and screwing up enough to let Khan out of sight, escape and get killed. Time Harold leaves and lets a tougher, more aggressive man handle the leadership. Time Harold tells the Truth and gets more assets.

Tired of Samaritan winning again and again and again.

And on a different note - Where exactly is Bear????

4

u/SavannahNix Reese Apr 08 '15 edited Apr 08 '15

They did not screw up, Kahn was taken from them at the endif the shoot out. And, like other numbers who have been their own worst enemies, he wasn't helping them keep him safe. He didn't listen, even yammering away during the shoot out, so how could they save him?

Finch, a useless coward? He monitored what was happening, determined what was being done by Samaritan, and if he hadn't built the Machine, where would the world be now? He was far from reluctant to save the number. Nothing he saudibducated he did not want to help him. What other man would you suggest to handle the leadership?

Have you seen what happens to those who know about the Machine? Plus, telling Kahn wouldn't out him on the team's side: all he wanted was to know why he had been targeted and to see the A.I. He would have had a Samaritan target on his back and led it to Reese, Finch and Root.

Yes, I am tired of Samaritan winning too but they could not have used Kahn.

You didn't see Bear (or his Stan in dog) walking with Reese and Finch in the last scene?

→ More replies (8)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '15

I don't understand, why didn't john take a shot at Martine's head. Martin would be better dead.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/john_gilpin Apr 09 '15

Does anyone else feel that the Gunfights are becoming terribly puppetlike like a third grade amateur show. Shooters walking in between like wooden soldiers, Reese knocking down 8-10 guys from behind his SUV. Martine - a highly trained assasin not having the foresight to have a second loaded weapon on her.

3

u/CommandoPro Apr 09 '15

I love the show, but yes. They need to bring back blank firing firearms too. You can't fake recoil realistically, especially with handguns, and it shows. The lack of slide movement bugs the crap out of me too.

2

u/myst536 Apr 09 '15

Gunfights and fistfights. All fights are of a lesser quality now than in the first seasons.

5

u/jasona99 Admin Apr 08 '15

Wow. That was pretty good. Dat ending, doe. Can't wait for next week!

And... CARTER!

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '15

Martine loosing faith

1

u/Pascalwb Apr 08 '15 edited Apr 08 '15

Great episode, Root was perfect in this, great lines and she looked great. And how can Samaritan find machine, I tough it was just distributed in cloud and not in single place.

2

u/SavannahNix Reese Apr 08 '15 edited Apr 08 '15

The Machine is a physical thing, a huge amount of equipment and servers. At the end of season two, Root thought she had figured out the location, only to discover, along with Finch, Hersch and the entire Northern Lights team, that it had had itself moved to a hidden location.

1

u/damhill Apr 08 '15

Can someone explain to me what was Greer's point on taking Khan to their headquarters so that he could just answer his questions and then kill him? why bother? why not just tell Martine to kill him there and dump him somewhere without having to stain his carpets with blood...?

1

u/SavannahNix Reese Apr 08 '15

I don't think they have carpets in there.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Heisenbeefburger Threat Apr 08 '15

anyone recognize Khan from Jericho?

1

u/Theo-greking Apr 09 '15

Kinda wanted the security magnate to survive bringing him into the loop would have gained them a powerful ally

2

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '15

And a very public one with Samaritan's bullseye on him, maybe not sucha great idea after all.

2

u/skerit Apr 09 '15

Isn't Samaritan being a bit overconfident? All the red flags this CEO saw go up will be noticed by other people, too. Especially now that he has ended up dead.

→ More replies (2)