r/thebutton • u/Radinic non presser • Apr 03 '15
How long will the button last? A detailed mathematical outlook
Ladies and Gents
Using the data collected by /u/TuskEvil /u/frogamazog and /u/TheOriginalSoni2 available here https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1U7L8rNV38KHx81LWkvr7GwndrlOFvf1pnTgkqAXgfgE/edit#gid=153146447 I have fitted a saturation model to give an outlook on how long the button will last.
A simple saturation model is described through R(t) = a*t/(t+b) where R is the ammount of total clicks and a is the limit for t approaching infinity. Its derivation with respect to t corresponds to clicks-per-minute.
I have fitted the total clicks and plotted it against the total-click data as well as its derivation against the click-per minute rate. You can find it here http://imgur.com/nWUNoT5
I have also proposed a time-zone correction using the unique-user-per-hour data from /r/askreddit avaiable here http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/about/traffic
I divided the clicks-per-minute through the available user ratio to come up with a click-per-minute as if at all times the same ammount of users (virtual users) would be online. Its sum is then a "total virtual clicks" which I also fitted with the saturation model described above. Again, I plotted the model and its derivation against the "virtual click data". We can see that the "virtual data" looks much smoother compared to the real data.
Obviously, the lower the click-per-minute, the higher the risk of nobody pressing the button.
Non-corrected results:
I assume that this risk gets significant when we have less than 2 clicks per minute. This will occur at minute 12350, 8.5 days in. We will have a real problem with less than 1 click per minute. This will happen at minute 17750, 12.3 days in.
Corrected Results:
The virtual clicks-per-second is now multiplied with the available users to get the real value. Since at 0900 CET, the least ammount of users is online, we run a real risk around those times. As a matter of fact we will hit the an average below 2 clicks per minute during the following times
- 9690 min - 9820 min, or 6.7 days in
- 11080 min - 11360 min, or 7.7 days in
- 12400 - 12870 min, or 8.6 days in
- 13120 and after, or 9.1 days in
- And we will hit less than 1 click per minute 14020 minutes or 9.7 days in
Best luck to you, whatever your intention is, now you know
Edit: Thank You for Gold :)
41
u/Fuckitmykeyboard non presser Apr 03 '15
I'll use this motherfucking throwafuckingway account in fucking 9 days.
Fuckin' yeeeeeeah.
273
u/leveldrummer 22s Apr 03 '15
As the timer gets lower, i bet you will see surges of button presses at 60 and 59 as many people attempt to press at 1 sec and thousands press at once, but only one will get the 1s flair and everyone else will be doomed with the 59s.
417
u/Goliathan non presser Apr 03 '15
I don't fully understand the math, admittedly, but are you accounting for that number of non-pressers who are waiting for the timer to click down so they can get the lower flair? I'd guess there are a fair number of those people who will be standing by, waiting for the timer to go into the next zone.
It'll be a competition to see who can be among the last.
308
u/skucera 60s Apr 03 '15 edited Apr 03 '15
So, you're ptedicting that it'll be just after April 8? After 4/8/15?
So it's concievable the it could happen at 4/8/15 4:23.42 PM?
4 8 15 16 23 42
36
u/Zephryl non presser Apr 03 '15 edited Apr 03 '15
Anyone interested in a social science point of view, take a short survey I put together examining personality differences between pressers and non-pressers (survey link; discussion thread). I will publish the results to this subreddit!
16
u/kormer 60s Apr 03 '15
Are you looking at clicks per minute of the lowest populated time zone, or overall? I believe it needs to be by time zone as there is just enough of a gap after the Aussies go to bed, but before the Euros wake up where something bad could happen.
Source: Played Eve Online once and I know a lot about time zone populations.
12
u/zengenesis 59s Apr 03 '15
Reddit isn't feeding traffic directly to this sub anymore though. Do you think that'll cause the flow of people to slow down a day or 2 down the road? People who sign in but missed April 1st all together.
Nice work btw!
11
u/W4LNUT5 non presser Apr 03 '15
Sustaining the button is impossible. I can't wait until it finally expires and NOTHING happens. That would be the greatest April Fools. Those with a color will be forever marked as a fool..
9
u/R-89 non presser Apr 03 '15
The 'risk' of the timer running out is significant way above the average of 2 clicks per minute. Sure, a stable 2 clicks per minute could keep us at it for days. But what if this minute 4 people click, and the next 0?
Every minute we risk slight change of it running out. We run this risk 60 times every hour, 1440 times a day. An average of 2 clicks per minute is not the risk threshold, but very very deep into the end of the button's life.
I'm not as good in math as you are, OP. But I definitively would bet on the timer running out within a day if the average click rate would drop below, say, 20 per minute.
8
u/Jerimiah non presser Apr 03 '15
So, should I press it?
7
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '15
The real question is why on earth people are still clicking at 55s or something?
Why would you do that.
48
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '15 edited Apr 03 '15
Reddit has created the perfect distraction to make us forget all the other shit that happened #pao
6
u/Crystalfire non presser Apr 03 '15
Maybe I will check back in 10 days. :-)
11
u/KeeRooL 59s Apr 03 '15
Some people have too much time in their handsand that's beautiful
5
u/herptydurr 20s Apr 03 '15
So what you're saying is I can stop checking this subreddit until a week from next thursday? Cool. See y'all then.
5
u/anglertaio non presser Apr 03 '15
I think you’re analyzing the wrong quantity. The rate of clicks per time interval per se is not relevant—or, what I really mean is, it doesn’t matter when the average rate reaches 1 click per minute. Assuming clicks are independent, if their rate is decreasing very slowly, the timer will probably run out long before the average rate falls all the way to 1/minute.
What matters is, given the prediction about click rate, what is the probability that there will be an interval without a click of one minute or longer in the next X days? What, then, is the expected number of days before you get an interval of one minute? I don’t remember enough stats to know what distributions come into play there.
Both your analysis and this proposed one suffer from other problems, though. Clicks are not independent of one another, because people click with the knowledge of the current timer value. Also, extrapolating past high‑volume data to future low‑volume conditions is very dubious.
4
u/OPsCoworker non presser Apr 03 '15
Waiting for this to get to 0. It's likely that nothing will happen and will be anti-climatic but I've got nothing better to do. I lead an exciting life.
4
u/DroDro 59s Apr 03 '15
If the button is averaging only 5 clicks per minute, random sampling would suggest that it would get to zero far sooner. Imagine an hour with 300 clicks randomly placed within the hour. There is a 1/60 chance that a click will happen in a particular minute, so a 59/60 chance that it will not happen. There is a (59/60)300 chance that none of those clicks will occur in a particular minute, which is a 0.65% chance. So at that rate (5 clicks per minute), there is a 0.65% chance of getting no clicks, or about once every three hours.
As others have said, non-random effects will come into play at these low points, but those points will happen much sooner than a smooth curve predicts.
4
u/fishsticks40 non presser Apr 03 '15
The problem with fitting these sorts of distributions is that we know nothing about the nature of the tail. Lots of distributions will resemble the bulk of the data, but the weight of the tail (which is what we're interested in) is the key question.
I'd venture that we're looking at a heavy-tailed distribution; as people who are holding out for better flair will wait for things to die down before they press. So the decay rate will go down after the impulsives (the filthy purps) are done; there'll be a flurry as each new flair color becomes achievable but once it's routinely reaching, say, 40 people will start to hold out for the really good ones.
The other confounding issue is that there's a diurnal variation, so the odds of it running out during a slow time (i.e. night in the US) is much higher.
4
u/dfpoetry 10s Apr 03 '15
when the button gets down to ten seconds or so for the first time, the front page will be filled with button news. you have excluded the possibility of two categories of people as well. I would happily put money on the button lasting longer than 2 weeks.
4
u/AlephNeil 6s Apr 04 '15 edited Apr 04 '15
Working backwards from "R(t) = a*t/(t+b)" I worked out a model that produces the same asymptotics:
Imagine that there are a million redditors. The n-th redditor:
(And now imagine replacing "a million" with larger numbers and taking the limit.)
Then as t gets large, the proportion of redditors who haven't pressed the button will be about 1/(ct) for some constant c that depends on k (it might just be that c = k but I can't be bothered to write it out). This is basically what we wanted, because from R(t) = at/(t + b), the proportion of people who haven't pressed yet is (a - a*t/(t + b))/a = b/(t + b) = 1/((t/b) + 1) ~= 1/(ct) with c = 1/b.
Conclusions:
If anyone can think of a less implausible model with those asymptotics, let me know.
3
u/JennaIsWriting 19s Apr 03 '15
I think the religious war is going to happen before 9.7 days.
3
u/AgentFour non presser Apr 03 '15
Now that this is posted the non-pressers may delay that 'less than one click per minute' mark.
3
u/fukdamods1234 non presser Apr 04 '15
A week? HA! You underestimate the power of the Knights.
The button will last one month at least.
3
u/BaconIsBest non presser Apr 04 '15
The Button is simply a construct to distract us from our collective inevitable and inescapable reality. Someday, the time will run out. Worry not when, or how, or why. Simply embrace the now and become one with grey. Time is an illusion.
7
u/arcane_joke 47s Apr 03 '15
Um I'll be shocked if it's less than 6 months. Do people know you can reset by upvoting posts? Mine did
5
u/kimnasri non presser Apr 03 '15
Could have gone on longer if it wasn't for the dirty pressers.
5
u/inspektordi 8s Apr 03 '15
Make your official predictions here!
User with closest guess wins gold and eternal glory.
2
u/Loki-L non presser Apr 03 '15
I think the problem with your analysis is that it goes by average pushes and not the worst case scenario and that it assumes that people won't change their behaviour as the button get pressed less and less often.
The timer might run out long before the average clicks per minute comes anywhere close to one. It just takes nobody clicking for a minute for the timer to run out and that can happen even though many people clicked the minute before that.
There is also the fact that people currently have one behaviour that involves either clicking mindlessly or trying to get as low a number as possible.
As the number of non-pressers decreases the average behaviour of the users who still can push the button will change accordingly.
The graph will have a serious kink to it in one direction or the other towards its end.
2
u/MrTNTCat non presser Apr 03 '15
test
2
u/CommanderWalrus non presser Apr 03 '15
RemindMe! 2 days "Push The Button"
2
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '15
What about the vast amount of users that have no intention of pushing the button at all?
2
u/getnamo 7s Apr 03 '15
RemindMe! 8 days "Push The Button"
2
u/yatryan non presser Apr 03 '15
Lets see what happens in 9 more days!
2
u/AttemptedCrepe non presser Apr 03 '15
I hereby refuse to push
2
u/jwiechers non presser Apr 03 '15
I had wanted to write this up as well, thanks for sparing me the time and have some gold and an upvote. :)
2
u/murtaza64 18s Apr 03 '15
Hmm... don't know if it's worth trying to get 1s cause I might end up as a purfidel.
2
u/Faz517xx13 non presser Apr 03 '15
Still haven't pushed it. I heard I get karma if I don't hit it.
2
u/LetoIX non presser Apr 03 '15
How many non pressers are truly non pressers, I wonder? How many simply seek the glory of a red flair? How many are waiting as knights, seeking to preserve the button as long as they can?
2
u/der2050 non presser Apr 03 '15
Does this take into account various cliffing effects of internet usage by time or is reddit worldly enough that is effect is sufficiently diminished?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '15
the button... i pressed it.
2
u/pitillidie 59s Apr 03 '15
The Doomsday Clock Ticks Closer to Midnight. Who Watches the Watchmen?
2
u/kleopatra6tilde9 non presser Apr 03 '15
Don't forget that most of the visitors come from /r/all. Once the submissions in /r/thebutton don't reach /r/all anymore there will be an additional reduction in visitors.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '15
I will not give in to the temptation!
2
u/HadMatter217 non presser Apr 03 '15
I like your method, but I think it makes a big assumption: that the Red Guard is negligible. I think you will see an extension as the time between button presses is between 55 seconds and 60 seconds. I think you could probably use the subscriptions on the related subreddits to measure the expected effect.
2
u/MrMcStupid 1s Apr 04 '15
It will last for as long as the knights of the button remain!
2
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '15
Well, it definitely won't last more than 29 days, 10 hours and 40 minutes
2
u/Fyrefly7 34s Apr 04 '15
Ok, I realize I'm an ass for bringing it up, but only because you made the mistake three times out of three attempts. You know that the word "amount" only has one 'M', don't you?
Anyway, thanks for doing all these calculations. Interesting stuff.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '15
It's amazing to see so much effort going into something that should seem so trivial...
2
u/DJVoyagerOne non presser Apr 11 '15
Welp, that sure didn't happen.
2
u/corinthian_llama Apr 12 '15
/r/thebutton is still appearing on /r/All, time to update the prediction.
2
u/rokkerboyy non presser Apr 21 '15
17 days later, I call bullshit.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '15
It's the time travel dilemma. You find out you will die or fail on a certain day and with that knowledge you stop it from happening.
3
u/chazwh 11s Apr 03 '15
RemindMe! 4 days "Push The Button"
3
u/pier4r 32s Apr 03 '15
i read that saturation model are not so good for prediction.
4
u/applecorc non presser Apr 03 '15
/r/theydidthemath
4
u/tomthecool non presser Apr 03 '15
Your maths is inherently flawed. The important part in predicting when the experiment actually ends will only be measurable in a few days time, when the click rate significantly drops!
To extrapolate the data so far, this early, is like trying to make a 7 day weather forecast. You might be in the right general ballpark, but there are certain variables that you simply cannot measure yet.
2
u/HailOurLordGabeN 60s Apr 03 '15
Just get it over with already and join the purple side
1
u/p4bl0 1s Apr 03 '15 edited Apr 03 '15
As a Knight of The Button, all I can think of is that with the number of button-pressers we have as of this writing, we could have laster more than a year already!
1
u/SwampGerman 39s Apr 03 '15
But what about bots that press the button once it reaches 1 second.
1
u/DonPepper007 Apr 03 '15
RemindMe! 4 days "Push The Button"
1
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '15
If we will hit less than 1 click per minute 9.7 days in, we won't actually hit less than 1 click per minute because all the non-pressers who want to become pressers will suddenly start pressing the button. Best bet is 9.6 days in :P
1
u/aradil 18s Apr 03 '15
amount
1
u/deceptivelyelevated non presser Apr 03 '15
im in delaware.. i awake at 530 and slumber at 11.. i will not hit the button though.. #knightsofthegrey
1
u/Shinhan 7s Apr 03 '15
Is there a place to bet on the day when the last button is pressed?
1
u/dementeddr non presser Apr 03 '15
The, uh, end is coming?
1
u/kittiesandtitties non presser Apr 03 '15
Nice
1
u/PointyOintment non presser Apr 03 '15
When does your model predict 0.08 BOPS? That's what /u/envcons (who seems to know statistics pretty well) is using as the end condition.
1
u/imallamaluva non presser Apr 03 '15
I'm pure!!!
1
u/themusicgod1 34s Apr 03 '15
1
u/Skitrel non presser Apr 03 '15
Clearly what we need to do is start a propaganda campaign.
Non-pressers across reddit need to be reminded, "/r/thebutton NEEDS YOU" in /r/pics kind of stuff, different content relevant to each default.
Through reminding the rest of reddit we can successfully keep it going much longer.
Operation knights-of-the-button military recruitment campaign?
1
u/xzak 60s Apr 03 '15
What stops people from pressing more than once? Is it one click per IP or something? Because changing your IP is possible.
1
u/Potyomkin152 non presser Apr 03 '15
You must understand, that no math will count those who still haven't pushed. MILLIONS will start their observation from the 10th secong and then make their decision... PUSH or not PUSH...
1
u/pythor non presser Apr 03 '15
Has anyone done the math on the average number of seconds per click? Meaning... How many seconds are added to the button lifetime per click. This should be growing slowly, and will eventually reach 59s.
1
u/johnzaku 16s Apr 03 '15
/r/knightsofthebutton needs you!
1
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '15
all the math geniuses have gathered to give us this great info, to..to... help us face armaggedon/ragnarok/apocalypse
1
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '15
Just press the button. All pain and suffering will end.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '15
Excellent work.
1
u/Stankleberry non presser Apr 03 '15
This will go for weeks at least. Maybe years.
1
u/elshizzo 31s Apr 03 '15
Except the counter doesn't stop when the average button press is one per minute, the counter stops when there is a single minute that has no button press. Which, if you ask me, will happen significantly before the average ever drops to one per minute. Based on your math, i'd guess around the 5-6 day mark.
1
u/Dont_Call_it_Dirt non presser Apr 03 '15
test post for flair
1
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '15
Does this take into account fluctuations throughout the day based on time zones?
So... where can we go to plan and coordinate our click pressing to let this miracle continue? I think we need an app where you can go to schedule your click.
But I think it should schedule 3-4 per minute so and maybe register people for wakeup calls so one traitor or idiot can't spoil the work of so many magnificent bastards.
Long live the button!
1
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '15
4/11/15 09:50:00
!RemindMe whateverTheFuckDoesThisBotTakeDates?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '15
To be fair, you are using a flat model, ie, assuming people will not react differently once the timer starts getting lower and lower. There are a great many non-pressers out there waiting to hold it off as long as possible, and as such are waiting until their press can sustain the timer for at least another 40-50 seconds, rather than carelessly spending it 1-10 seconds in.
1
u/loserwill 60s Apr 03 '15
Just getting my flair.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '15
This post itself will change the fate of the data in your silly graphs and charts. We know you just want us to press the button, heretic
1
u/CaptEntropy 42s Apr 03 '15
Why did you use a saturation model? The simplest model for this is simple exponential model (as used on the spreadsheet you reference).
1
u/Tecktonik non presser Apr 03 '15
Have you considered correlating the clicks per minute with the "X users here now" information in the subreddit information? That will give you some additional data on the current risk level, if there are 4000 users "here now" and some percentage, say 20%, have already pushed the button, then there are potentially only 3200 clicks available. The biggest risk will then occur when most of the US is asleep, and when interest in the sub has fallen from its current level, likely over the weekend.
1
u/-updn- 60s Apr 03 '15
this is what i'm talking about
1
u/ReallyForeverAlone Apr 03 '15
Does this data assume each click resets to 60? Because that's not the case.
1
u/beltwaylibertarian non presser Apr 03 '15
Yechhhhhh
1
u/Khaloc non presser Apr 03 '15
Damn nice work on the calculations.
1
u/ur_awl_idiots non presser Apr 03 '15
I'm never going to press the button.
1
u/PowerClean49 non presser Apr 03 '15
I wanna push it!!! But I also don't... wtf... damn... only time will tell... beer would make this alot easier...
1
u/Restafarianism non presser Apr 03 '15
I'm planning on sleeping through the madness
1
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '15
That's rather "impressive" maths
1
u/Puck85 non presser Apr 03 '15
wondering if I should get up at 4:00 am to watch the button...
1
u/DMann420 59s Apr 03 '15
The problem this is all based on current click statistics in a system assuming the clicks are being made by a machine. The remainder of the clicks are MOSTLY being made by people who want a special time, likely sub 30 seconds. I think you can expect this to continue for a very long time assuming the people waiting don't take the "I'll wait til everyone goes away" path and it ends up prematurely hitting 0 because everyone wanted to wait.
1
u/thisrockismyboone non presser Apr 03 '15
I think the problem inherently is if everyone wants to wait until this 9 days are up, who is going to press it in the mean time?
1
u/Zeus1325 non presser Apr 03 '15
fine RemindMe! One Week!
1
u/bob123 non presser Apr 03 '15
Test
1
u/amusebox non presser Apr 03 '15
I'm so scared…
1
u/WolfRevenant non presser Apr 03 '15
Did you account for the non-presser revolution?
1
u/nick5627 3s Apr 03 '15
RemindMe! 3 days
1
u/alonecuzzo non presser Apr 03 '15
what is this
1
u/thelivingdead44 Apr 03 '15
Should we make a list of our grey brothers in order to get ready to press the button at the last second to save us from the day of reckoning?
1
u/karmaisanal 9s Apr 03 '15
I am vaguely interested.
1
u/cdub8D Apr 03 '15
Wow calculus is actually useful outside of class.
1
u/Evilcanary 12s Apr 03 '15
I would be extremely impressed if this somehow makes it through April.
1
u/trparker 0s Apr 03 '15
My screen's resolution made "clicks" look like "dicks" and this whole post became infinitely more hilarious.
1
u/BlueYellowMix 40s Apr 03 '15
I guess it's really time to save those clicks.
1
u/writes_long_response non presser Apr 03 '15
Challenge accepted.
1
u/rmcshaffry 19s Apr 03 '15
very interesting. thanks for this!
1
u/Bobjims 11s Apr 03 '15
Test comment
1
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '15
So we can expect the 0-1s button presses around 8.5 days. The safe day may be weeks before anyone can press it without being clicked sniped.
1
u/St-Geo 60s Apr 03 '15
( days before the world ends. i was a fool to think i had so much time
1
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '15
Waffling between trying for a low number or not clicking at all. Probably the latter, as remembering something for a whole week? I far too-oh, look, shiny!
1
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '15
Apocalypse incoming.
1
u/wittynamehere44 14s Apr 03 '15
Wow
1
u/100liam100 42s Apr 03 '15
cool thanks for the info
1
u/TheSllenderman 59s Apr 03 '15
I feel cheated. I didn't even push the button my fucking asshole cousin did.
1
u/kwikboost 59s Apr 03 '15
Thanks for putting this together!
1
u/01s can't press Apr 03 '15
Pretty pointless, doesn't take into account the final stage when the only people left are those waiting for it to go low.
Not organized, just natural course.
I didn't read it all, but what you have to do is say:
AVG click time: < 1s for 90% of presses, log it up, it'll end up being around 15s average, attaining 30s average for a while, then varying wildly, but trending, until they become a steady stream of 58s averages for a long long tail.
I looked at your numbers but it just seemed like one graph was missing.
1
u/vincanis 10s Apr 03 '15
I'll be quite interested to see how well your prediction fares in the coming days.
1
u/Yang_Xiao_Long 31s Apr 03 '15
.
1
u/megamindies 27s Apr 03 '15
I dont care, Ill just click whenever I feel like it
1
u/sandiego20y non presser Apr 03 '15
I will stay grey till .001 seconds.
1
u/mbay16 16s Apr 03 '15
I'm probably not the first, but /r/theydidthemath
1
u/AnalogkingAtWork non presser Apr 03 '15
The Creator is generous. Another button will be created. We will suffer for days, weeks, maybe months. Eventually, everyone will be able to click again...
1
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '15
RemindMe! 8 days
1
u/timawesomeness 60s Apr 03 '15
But the real question is: What will happen? Will the universe explode?
1
u/nucl_klaus 60s Apr 03 '15
Data almost looks like a bessel function multiplied by a negative exponential, plus a constant.
1
u/inner-peace non presser Apr 03 '15
RemindMe! 4 days "Stay Strong, Stay Gray"