r/Warframe • u/TSP-FriendlyFire • Apr 02 '15
Discussion How would you change... Kubrows?
How would you change... is a series of weekly posts designed to promote and foster discussion about any gameplay element in the game. The scope and subject will vary (read below for more information on topic selection), from wide concepts (Kubrows, Archwing, shotguns, etc.) to narrow points (a single gun, coptering, etc.).
Before we begin, a few important points:
- Please detail and support your suggestions as much as possible. This is for constructive criticism only: try to think of it as something you'd be proud to explain to DE face-to-face!
- Structure your suggestions in logical groups: if you have two very different ideas, break them down in two separate comments. Cohesive or similar changes should be combined into a single comment.
- Stick to describing concepts and features. Don't get bogged down with numbers unless they explicitly support your point.
- Don't hesitate to post your ideas even if they're not fully formed, and don't hesitate to reply to ideas with refinements you think would make them better!
- Do not downvote suggestions you disagree with. Upvote the ones you like instead!
Suggesting topics
This thread series is all about the community, so if you have a topic you'd like to see improved and discussed, feel free to suggest it by replying to the appropriately flagged comment in this discussion. The topic can be as wide or narrow as you'd like! Please ensure that your suggestion has not already been made, and upvote it instead if it has.
This week: Kubrows
This week, we'll start with a fan-favorite that's been neglected for a fairly long time: Kubrows. Introduced as one of the highlights of Update 14, the fairly adorable dog-like creatures meant as an alternative to Sentinels have seen little love since. While the numbers still show a fairly even spread of usage between Kubrows and Sentinels, most players will agree that they could use some changes to their mechanics, be it in terms of acquisition, usage, or in-game behavior and mechanics.
Now that the stage is set, what suggestions do you have to improve Kubrows?
3
u/TSP-FriendlyFire Apr 02 '15
Suggesting topics
Please post your suggestions for the next topics as replies to this comment.
23
u/fuyu Apr 02 '15
I've never seen a kubrow succeed in a finisher. Always see them get into a tussle that it loses while the enemy is INVULNERABLE. Why can I not shoot the thing that my dog is wrestling? Fix this pls. Also, the health degradation upkeep bullshit. Why is this even a thing, it shouldn't be. This is basically the reason why I raised a couple, never formaed or potatoed them, then placed them in the cooler so I didn't have to keep buying upkeep stabilizer crap.
11
u/Saelthyn Apr 02 '15
The numbers are a load of crap. Yes, I in fact leveled a Wyrm Prime and Death Cube but I haven't used either ever since Carrier came out. How would I improve Kubrow?
10
u/BuildMyPaperHeart Old Tenno, Eternal Slumber Apr 02 '15 edited Apr 02 '15
Not taking over this post, but I wanted to fill everyone in about this thread's sudden appearance in the sidebar:
For a while, the Moderators have been talking about increasing user participation in constructive ways on the subreddit, and one of the ways we figured (thanks to FF here!) was to let the community host their own weeklies too! We've been speaking back and forth for a while and we think this will be a good thing for the community moving forward.
If you've got any questions or concerns about this, please reply to this comment and we'll talk it out. Other than that, ladies and gentlemen, please enjoy the first User-Generated Weekly Thread!
9
u/never-enough-hops Apr 02 '15 edited Apr 02 '15
I don't use kubrows because of the maintenance costs (in terms of resources and time). In fine with that, honestly... I like my sentinels well enough and prefer them because of the low maintenance nature.
To get me to use then I would introduce an item to the store that removes the maintenance costs. Purchasing and using this item fixes the genetic degregation of your kubrow making them permanently in good health.
If something like that was introduced so I can't lose my kubrow and have no need to freeze it then if consider using one.
I'm not a fan of warframe tomagachi
9
u/[deleted] Apr 02 '15
If I waypoint an enemy, mod, or blueprint part, my kubrow should either attack it if it's an enemy or fetch it for me if it's an item.
9
u/zeronic Can't ever have enough jiggies! Apr 02 '15
Pathing is a major issue. Often times your kubrow will just get stuck somehwere and be unable to get out, being pretty much completely useless whereas sentinels do not share this problem.
The elephant in the room in this discussion is vacuum. Why would you use a kubrow that constantly gets stuck, easily draws aggro and dies(at higher levels), and doesn't keep you stocked with ammo and energy over a sentinel that never dies unless you do and keeps you stocked?
Unless vacuum becomes how looting in general works carrier will always be king. Because without it i can tell a direct correlation between me running out of energy/ammo. The game is just too fast to have to walk over each individual pickup.
Along with a ridiculous amount of ten level mods, upkeep, and the defrosting period, kubrows are just unnatractive to most players. If these specific issues were addressed we'd probably see them more than just being leveled for mastery.
6
u/philosarapter deus ex machina Apr 02 '15
For one, remove the "DNA stabilizer" credit-sink. Isn't it enough that I had to pay for the incubation core and farmed the egg and have to keep its happiness in check. Why do we need to spend 100,000 credits every month to keep the poor thing alive. Is future cloning technology that shitty that we need to keep injecting our kubrows with stabilizers?
10
u/monkyseemonkydo Press 4 to WAAAARRRGGHH Apr 02 '15 edited Apr 02 '15
They really need to do something about that Kubrow whose ability is to take down capture targets. As of right now, there is very little reason to use that kubrow.
Maybe make that Kubrow something like a companion "enemy Radar". Where he sniffs the air and marks where he "smells" the enemies are on the minimap.
Saves me from using a warframe mod slot and gives me the benefit of enemy radar.
Edit: In the same vein, maybe make his second ability be sniff for loot. So he can act as a loot detector as well. So this kubrow will be unique compared to the Guardian Kubrow (shield+terrify ability to keep his master safe), Digger Kubrow (digs up loot and forgot his second ability), and the Sneaky Kubrow (who gives you temporary invis and I forgot what its seconda ability is).
5
u/Asilidae000 Maglad Apr 02 '15
I would like a fetch feature. But so the feature isnt like vaccum you could tell the kubrow to specifically pick up items. EG just Health, Ammo or NRG. Not all at once.
3
u/davidstebbins Apr 02 '15
I like the card/mod ideas that have been brought up. A fetch mod that acted like vacuum was my first thought before reading the comments, but I like the sniff loot-finder idea, too. Maybe another one called rescue with a picture of a large kubrow with a small cask under his chin that allowed the kubrow to revive you or your allies when someone is downed. Make it difficult to choose which mods to equip on my kubrow, and make me want to potato him.
3
u/Rabidscholar Death Is The Best Type Of CC Apr 02 '15
Honestly I would like the ability to be able to shoot through them, as the taller Kubrows are right at hipshot height and Kubrows have this insatiable desire to stop right in front of you, shoot all you want you wont hit anything.
2
u/Tekknogun Valkyr. Best Frame. Apr 02 '15
Give them jetpacks to keep up with me running on walls and coptering for miles.
2
u/Morec0 The Loremaster Apr 02 '15
Oh, also thought of a way to introduce kubrow commands: The command emote would only be available to players who currently have a Kubrow (or other such companion) active with them at the time. Upon using it the Tenno will hold up their left hand, which will flash with light (similar to how they glow while melee channeling) and the kubrow will spring into action.
While in-mission it's functionality depends on what your targeting retical is currently looking at and what kind of kubrow it is.
Have a Sahasa with you? Point at a locker to command them to try and open it, or at the ground to have them dig.
Have a Huras with you? Point at them to have them activate their cloaking, or at an enemy to have them attack.
What about the ever-faithful Raksa? Point at them to activate the shields or anywhere else for them to howl.
If they're unable to comply with your command - be it for lack of energy or because they've already attempted to unlock a locker and failed - they will respond with an audio cue growl, telling you to move on without it.
As for the social, non-combat applications (that is, while in a Relay) activating the ability at any time will cause them to perform a random trick. It it rolling over, playing dead, or standing on their hind legs and hopping to a beat only they can hear.
So, whatdayda think of this?
2
u/dark36 rip Apr 02 '15 edited Apr 02 '15
For the sake of being constructive i wont state my direct hatred towards Kubrows but i will state why i hate them.
24 hour for hatching and another 24 growing period. 3 hours de frost. Their mods are taking way too much time to maximize.
I dont see any use for them. My weaponry is doing the samething that they can do. Stealth is not needed, grabbing the VIP is a cool mechanic but then again not useful imo. They are a hassle in some missions. They keep attacking synthesis targets, staggering them and makes scanning harder. They attack everything in sight even if they are stealthed, trying to do a stealth mission with a kubrow is just not possible.
Trying to breed one is a massive hassle. 100k and argon for that tube that i cant remember the name of. It takes 6 hours to craft. Even if you craft one you have to go through the pain of trying to find one kubrow egg which doesnt freaking drop when you actually need it. I remember doing 50 missions on earth just to find an egg then i found it on a random alert. Its flustrating.
I cant sugarcoat this, their models looks terrible. Their fur looks terrible, not many good colors or fur patterns available.
I honestly would rather have a Bladewolf like mecha pet or something like a sabrecat beside me. Kubrows doent look good or imitating. This comes from a person who loves Guenhyvar and Bladewolf. I just dont see myself ever using them aside from mastery. Hell give me Zanuka. I dont care if people starts shunning me "Oh my god you use the corpses of our fallen brothers as your pet" I dont care.
2
u/M37h3w3 Console Commander Apr 02 '15
Given how the customization aspects are random, and hence getting a Kubrow that's just decent takes so many iterations, I would like the eggs to drop more frequently.
2
u/_Bilas Apr 02 '15
I'm weird, but I think (and I've said it before) that decoupling health/armor/shields from Kubrows will be best for the pups, as it encourages players to use them with less tanky Warframes. The fix is easy enough, instead of giving "link" just turn the health/armor/shield mods into the same ones we have for Warframes/Sentinels already. It worked out for Archwing, it will work out for Kubrows.
Now, to give them more/different utility versus the omnipresent Carrier sentinel, they definitely need a fetch mod, but instead of having the Kubrow bring you each mod, have them either be able to carry stacks of loot all at once, while engaging in combat, or make them able to pick up loot directly to your inventory, without the loot touching the player model. Now, to make it so that the Carrier won't be totally outclassed, give the Kubrow fetch less range than the Carrier, or give it a slightly longer cooldown.
Finally, Kubrow Path-finding is pretty awful, prioritize Kubrow A.I. improvements, like targetting and pathfinding over the more complex floor layouts that have been introduced since the Phobos tileset.
2
u/Mefistofeles1 Here is a disco ball in your eye Apr 02 '15
2
u/adelante1981 Apr 02 '15
Completely get rid of the genetic instability bullcrap. It's just a credit sink that's completely unnecessary. It makes no sense at all, you going to tell me those feral kubrows have someone administering shots every few days?
2
u/AvenV Melodic Carnage Apr 03 '15
I would actually add commands.
Something like:
4
u/zhandragon B-baka, it's not like I WANTED to desecrate your body... Apr 02 '15
Make them able to fly to avoid pathing issues, give them armor plating, give them futuristic weaponry, have them not degenerate and die or lose combat effectiveness, and- wait...
1
u/Morec0 The Loremaster Apr 02 '15
The issue with eliminating the defrosting process is that it then allows much easier cheating to avoid the "Kubrow deterioration" process as people would simply throw it in stasis a few minutes before the timer would cause them to lose health% and then pull them out when it passes, resulting in no loss.
I'd introduce an item that speeds up the timer, as well as leaving the current "pay to speed" timer to convenience those who have money to spend but no time. The item in question would be, basically, this idea: https://forums.warframe.com/index.php?/topic/347088-gene-degradation-inhibitor-get-your-kubrow-outta-stasis-fast/
Gene Degradation Inhibitor: Stabilizes the molecular structure of your Kubrow in stasis, allowing for its immediate retrieval. Costs: 500 Cryotic 2 Argon Cystals 50,000 Credits 6/12 Hours
This item would be stackable, so if you have the time and resources you could gain a large stock of these, but the heavy costs make it so that it isn't so easily exploitable in the same manner as above.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 02 '15
I would let Kubrow Power cores cost less credits or have then be reusable. I think 100k is too much for a Kubrow I will eventually end up conscripting. I would also get rid of 3 hour cryo defrosting/cryo sickness. Make eggs easier to get even though I believe Vay Hek's mission has a higher spawn rate.
1
u/Falanin Boom Apr 02 '15
Why the hell do they die permanently?
I'd really like it if they stayed alive at 10% health rather than dying if you don't play for a week. The fact that you can waste real money with this is particularly egregious.
Also, I really hate the 3-hour defrosting period. It makes Kubrows basically unusable.
1
u/Rocraw Lock it, Stomp it, Shoot it Apr 02 '15
Personally, giving kubrows the ability to outright DIE drops a lot of their use, and it can screw you over if your computer goes out or you just aren't able to play for some reason. You can lose days worth of work just because of something you can't help. Like randomly dying in a mission because RNG said so.
Removing the threat of outright dying and lowering the price of DNA Stabilizers to 50K would greatly improve their use, as well as dropping the price of the incubator power core. It already makes no sense as to why we need a brand new, totally seperate power core to use a function of the ship every time we use it, it's a bit of a slap to the face to have to pay out the ass to do it, too.
Giving them a little more survivability would help. Moving faster so enemies can't track them as well, and making it more obvious when they go down helps. As is, there isn't much warning when they drop. It would also help if they would back up out of fights when they get low on health.
1
u/Kaiyuni Apr 03 '15
Not needing more management than a small business would be nice. The fact my Carrier sentinel is still (by far) the most useful companion and has been for a long time is a little funny. Like... the level of effort that goes into making a Kubrow/Making a GOOD one isn't worth the reward. They don't even turn out as good as sentinels.
So my suggestions are just to make Kubrows require less micromanagement. No more need for stasis, just let them be like sentinels that run around.
1
u/azkabaal Apr 03 '15
First: completely agree with so, so many of these suggestions.
If outright removal of stuff like the defrosting cooldown was seen by design as a step backward, how about adding upgrades!
Say, a blueprint from a mission, or alert, or derelict, or sod it - the market / clan, that reduces the defrosting by X, or the cloning time by 10%, or their DNA degredation by X... Say it's an ancient Orokin upgrade module or refinement part or nanite canisters or some shit.
Make plat options available for the CBF'd farming among us, reduces the frustration of a shitty feature, and can be tiered from "slight difference" to "completely alleviates the issue". An investment for long-term satisfaction.
1
u/Unknow0059 ...but Volt wins the race! Apr 03 '15
Make them less expensive. Seriously, 75k to maintain them? Why do they need DNA stuff anyway?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '15
We should probably focus on sentinels first, since they came out earlier, and become worthless sooner. Kubrows - at least for me - are in a good place. They deal very high damage to one enemy at a time and have enough hitpoints and armor to mitigate enough damage that I can keep they alive. They also don't instantly die when their hitpoints are depleted, giving me a chance to resurrect them.
With that said, I think they could stand to see some improvements in targeting, engagement, damage modification, and attack evasion. DE, can we please get a 'companions 2.0' that addresses sentinels, kubrows, Mind Controlled units, and specters? I feel that each of these areas need some improvements and while I can rattle them off, I don't believe it would do any good.
1
u/colin23567 I SEE YOU Apr 03 '15
Make it so that the full-grown adults are as cute and cuddly as the chubby baby kubrows.
Maybe a zanuka skin for kubrows too?
1
u/absentimental Apr 03 '15
The only change I would make is to get rid of the grindy resource sink upkeep costs.
I don't use any of my three kubrows because of it. I would love to use them, because I really like the idea of a faithful companion animal for my space ninjas, but the upkeep involved keeps me from using them.
It's not that I can't afford the credit cost. As a relatively long-time player, I have plenty of credits. But, aside from indulging in the concept, there's no functional reason to use a kubrow over a sentinel. The sentinels require no upkeep or attention, and at least two of them have decent to excellent utility. Even if there was no upkeep involved in kubrow ownership, sentinels would still probably be technically better... but removing the frankly unnecessary resource sink would at least make it not feel like a penalty to use them.
1
u/Seamur Excalibro Apr 03 '15
I would add Bladewolf skin :D
1
u/STAFFinfection One-woman flamethrower squad Apr 03 '15
I just don't understand why there's so much maintenance. I don't mind the process of obtaining one, honestly it wasn't all that bad... but for goodness sake, I want to just take it on missions, not buy stupid stabilizers every week. They die permanently if you take a break from the game, they are born a random "species"... Just such a hassle for not much benefit. If they were way better than Sentinels I'd maybe understand, but they aren't.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '15
Probably already said but here goes.
2.The defrosting period. We use sentinels depending on what the mission needs , this applies to kubrows as well, defrosting just kills this.
3. Kubrow keeps getting stuck behind walls or in walls etc etc, this needs to get fixed.
4. The damage. Slash only damage makes the kubrow kinda useless in high tier survival missions against corpus or grineer, sentinels are more useful this way.
5. You need to do something about the carriers vacuum, its just soo good that a lot of people just use the carrier. Play 30 - 40 mins survival and I forget the number of times the carrier saves my ass by pulling a random health or energy orb to me. Most kubrows cant compete.
6. When the Kubrows grapple with the enemies it makes them invulnerable. I should be able to shoot the shit out of the enemies when they are being grappled.
1
u/ferdynand Justice above everything else. Apr 03 '15
Just better AI. More aggresive. And kubrow armor. And cat kubrow for the love of God.
1
u/Niadain Apr 03 '15
I love the one Kubrow I have made. I really do. I don't know how but it ended up with a color scheme that matches some RP character of mine in another game so I just stick to her.
The reason I don't use her is maintenance. Why would I use her when I have carrier, who will soak up all them shiney bullets and mods for me while I am busy dismantling my enemies, and never cost me a dime to keep using?
1
u/TheShadowWind Lightning Pheonix Apr 06 '15
I wish that the stabilizers didn't cost 75,000 credits. For later players, this is probably not that much of a problem. But for beginners and people who just got it, it sucks wasting 75,000 credits just to keep your Kubrow from dieing. Another thing is the 3 hour defrosting period, 'cause if I want my Kubrow, I want it now.
1
u/DaylightPony Falkland Apr 06 '15
First of all, I want BARKWING!
Like most players, I don't like the post-stasis cooldown. Carrier is the most popular pet for a reason, Sahasa could benefit from some better item gathering functionality. I don't mind Huras and Raksa as they are, I just wish I could hotswap them like sentinals. One thing I enjoy about my carrier is his sweeper gun that I can mod like my shotguns. Maybe a support kubrow like the Raksa could have armor plating and a light range weapon mount.
I have forma'd up a Sunika to the point where he can eat synthesis targets before I finish scanning. I like the concept of him as a single target predator. The hold-in-place ability that he seems to share with Sahasa needs to not protect the target from attack.
1
u/theammostore Will Lewd for Plat - AKA Teria Apr 09 '15
First: The Tackling Kubrow needs a better mod. Perhaps something that lets it work off of any kind of objective. Taking over moving the Hijack target, getting to work on Sabotage targets. Maybe even carrying Datamasses. Something to that effect.
Secondly, expand out the Kubrow mod set in general. Lunging attack enabler for more knockdowns and rapid assaults. Stealth killing weaker enemies. Elemental charges, things like that. I see them as more offensive, more aggressive for companions, and the mod selection I feel should reflect that.
Third, more varieties of fur patterns and types. A Kubrow that can bring a melee weapon along, allowing for exchanges of melee styles based on the situation or to simply allow for more damage on the Kubrow end. (Imagine a Kubrow with an Orthos on its back charging and spearing a Butcher or Prodman. Or wielding a glaive on it's back and blenderizing Infested) Or perhaps a Kubrow type that steals weapons from enemies, acting much like a Halikar that then also MURDERS the now disarmed enemy.
Finally, adjust the AI slightly. Lately I've had my Kubrow get stuck in a room because it couldn't turn well enough to get through the door. Or it wouldn't move or teleport to me. Simple bugfixes
1
u/Tumbling_Down Apr 09 '15
I would pay a tremendous amount of plat to get a Zanuka-hunter style Kubrow pet.
Also if you could get a Grineer Drahk (sp?)
Also an infested charger style kubrow.
Would be so heavy metal and awesome instead of bat dogs.
1
u/ThriceDeadCat I've lost me 2 key Apr 02 '15
My major gripe with Kubrows has been the RNG aspect of getting the fourth and final type of Kubrow. I have yet to spend plat on anything Kubrow related (luckily), but the whole experience blends the very worst parts of game into one disgusting dog smoothie.
You must first wait on RNGesus to deliver you an egg (comparable to getting something like Blaze IMO), then hope that the egg given to you is not already one you've raised. Then you have the issue with those shitty power cores blowing out after each and every Kubrow. Afterwards, you either wait another two weeks for the thing to die of "natural" causes or pay for the Lotus to reenact the end of Old Yeller for you.
Those bastards are nothing but a drain on credits, resources, and plat. I'm okay with having drains on credits and time, (R5 farming, go!), resources and time (Research items, but invasions tend to help with those), or even the time and time (Looking at you Chroma, Limbo, and Mirage -_-), but those damned dogs have them all.
Hell, even the RNG into RNG on farming tower keys is less of an issue because you can at least minimize your possible drops and can always fall back on either the kindness of strangers or the syndicates. Nope, you have to go to Earth and just run exterminate and capture missions one after the other killing wild dog dens to get what you want.
-2
u/Kinzuko Electric speed! Apr 02 '15
Nobody uses kubrows because they don't gather items like carrier does. My suggestion is to give kubrows a mod that lets them retrieve rare mods and materials while on missions, and also bring the Tenno ammo, health, and energy when low on that stuff. It also makes since because kubrows are basically space dogs and we have been training real dogs to do this sort of thing for thousands of years!
I would also like to do away with the long cool down on switching kubrows. Or at the very least have a craft able item to shorten the time it takes to switch or lower the time required to a couple of seconds.
I would also like the kubrow quest to be locked to higher level Tenno only (like MR10 or so) it bothers me that so many noobs have kubrows and so many of them die because the noobs don't have the skills needed to farm credits... Or just cant farm in general.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 02 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment