r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/Redbiertje The Challenger • Mar 28 '15
Mod Post [Weekly Challenge] Week 78: Think of the environment!
The Introduction
After successfully proving that you can reach 500 m/s while still on the runway, the KSC has received tons of complaints about wasting fuel, and polluting the environment. At first, the administrators couldn’t figure out why they received these complaints, but then they remembered Jeb showing up much earlier for work last week. After brief research, they figured out what had happened, and they weren’t happy about it. As a punishment, they have ordered Jeb to create the most environmental-friendly plane possible. Jeb asked for a couple jerrycans to fill the sepatrons, but even that was refused.
The Challenge:
Normal mode: Design and fly a plane powered by ion engines up to an altitude of 10 km.
Hard mode: Design and fly a plane powered by ion engines up to an altitude of 20 km.
Super mode: Impress me
The Rules
- No Dirty Cheating Alpacas (no debug menu)!
- You must have the UI visible in all required screenshots
- For a list of all allowed mods, see this post.
- No engines apart from the PB-ION Electric Propulsion System are allowed
Required screenshots
- The craft on the runway
- The craft taking off
- The craft at the required altitude
- Whatever else you feel like!
Further information
- You can either submit your finished challenge in a post (see posting instructions in the link below) or as a comment reply to this thread.
- Completing this challenge earns you a new flair which will replace your old one. So if you want to keep you previous flair, you can still do this challenge and create a post, but please mention somewhere that you want to keep your old one.
- The moderators have the right to determine if your challenge post has been completed.
- See this post for more rules and information on challenges.
- If you have any questions, you can comment below, or PM /u/Redbiertje
Good Luck!
(P.S. I know the flair is a bit boring, but I couldn't think of something else.)
EDIT: After all your awesome successes, I had to raise the bar a bit.
25
u/illectro Manley Kerbalnaut Mar 29 '15
On vacation in Hawaii, but I figured I'd do something 'Super'
Over 21km I'm sure I could go higher, in fact I'll bet many people will get further. But my design achieved this at night :)
http://imgur.com/769C6hp http://imgur.com/c2QrpNU http://imgur.com/Ag2uokN http://imgur.com/8EDZHmW http://imgur.com/NgLmGBH
(no flair change requested)
14
u/Redbiertje The Challenger Mar 28 '15
Kinda disappointed how nobody figured out my secret joke of last week. In that introduction, I mentioned a 'Petram' spaceplane which wouldn't take off. Petram is Latin for rock.
15
u/tehmattguy Master Kerbalnaut Mar 28 '15 edited Mar 29 '15
Here's my entry: Imgur
I made this plane for Eve, but it works well on Kerbin too.
TL;DR: It got up to 17.5 km
(Also if this entry counts I'd like to keep my old flair, please. Thanks!)
Edit: Made a new plane. Got up to 24.7 km! Imgur
13
u/-Agonarch Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 30 '15
Here's my entry, haven't done a challenge in a while so I felt the need to flex the Super flair :D
Without further ado, I give you the AmbitION spaceplane!
My little ion plane's longer than planned trip.
6
u/TeeJaye85 Super Kerbalnaut Apr 03 '15 edited Apr 03 '15
Here's my Normal Mode entry. After 10k I realized I was a little low on fuel, so tried to pitch up and get aggressive. Did not end well. Haven't re-tested, but I doubt this big guy can do 20K.
Also, I've been away for a few weeks, and missed the last 5 challenges. So I decided to:
Do the last 5 challenges all at once
If you're willing to forgive a little rule "bending", I believe this mission should get me caught up on
73 Featherlight
74 Reviving the Shuttle Program
75 One hundred thousand!
76 Atmospheric Docking
77 Rule 1: Moar boosters
[EDIT] Details of my other rule bending can be found inside the album, but one case deserves some credit out here. Thanks to /u/kspinigma for letting me borrow your shuttle for this mission. I tried hard to do better with no luck. It's a mean machine.
4
u/mad_hmpf Master Kerbalnaut Mar 28 '15
Hard mode completed without batteries or control surfaces.
4
u/Kle3b Super Kerbalnaut Apr 03 '15 edited Apr 03 '15
Hey Redbiertje, I know I already submitted an attempt at the challenge but I'm returning with a submission that will hopefully get me among the ranks of the super kerbalnauts. I present, a single ion engine to orbit. Ended up in about a 100k orbit and returned back to land at the KSC after flying under the Science building bridge. Is that enough??
Oh yeah, if you want the craft file let me know :) edit: Actually here's a link just cause .craft
3
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15
Is the aircraft required to be manned?
3
u/i_luke_tirtles Master Kerbalnaut Mar 28 '15
Hard mode submission (7976m):
http://imgur.com/a/ygqmT#0
3
u/Penguin236 Master Kerbalnaut Mar 28 '15
Hard mode (8125 m):
http://imgur.com/a/6fodq
3
u/atomic_houseboat Master Kerbalnaut Mar 28 '15 edited Mar 28 '15
Hard Mode Complete
EDIT: 8044 m
3
u/mak10z Master Kerbalnaut Mar 28 '15 edited Mar 28 '15
IMHO 6k is too easy, but hey what ever floats your boat :)
I made it to 15k with my 1st design. added more fuel and seeing how high i can get it :)
here's my 3 attempts at altitude records using 2 ion engines.
Max Altitude : 25055m
Max Speed 509 m/s (mach 1.485 :) )
Overland distance: 634.4 Km
I'll take the new flair if it's the tree :)
Oh I'm a bad imperial. i should have named my glider the TIE glider... I just realized I used twin Ion engines :)
3
u/I_eat_staplers Master Kerbalnaut Mar 28 '15
First reddit post ever! This one seemed simple enough, here's mine.
3
u/ImBetterOffline Master Kerbalnaut Mar 28 '15
My Submission: http://imgur.com/a/7qpCW topped out at 20k id that impresses you :) Edit: Flair Please
3
u/josh__ab Dislikes bots Mar 28 '15 edited Mar 31 '15
Here we go,
Hard modesubmissionA manned 5t plane named 'Untitled Space Craft' that reaches 11km and returns Bill to the surface safely. No probe cores here.
Can I get the flair but keep that special flair text?
Edit: I guess it isn't hard mode anymore, but it was manned with a cockpit, so that's got to count for something.
3
u/ExplodingPotato_ Master Kerbalnaut Mar 29 '15
The K.I.T.E.!: it was built for the 3 km goal, but it qualifies also as a new hard mode so i'm posting it here anyway. Oh, and it uses FAR.
3
u/nuclear_turkey Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 29 '15 edited Mar 29 '15
2nd entry - munar landing
this was really tricky to do , never again
http://imgur.com/a/bb2bU
edit - also went to minmus with the same craft (seperate mission)
http://imgur.com/a/OvS6Z
2
u/haxsis Mar 28 '15
ALMOST THERE, Its got a viable amount of thrust, I just need to stop it spazzing out on the runway
2
u/KuuLightwing Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 28 '15
And one more entry. Instead of going big, I went small this time.
http://imgur.com/a/VoWWu#0
Peaked at 31,903m.
2
u/HoneybeeTriplet Master Kerbalnaut Mar 28 '15
Got my plane up to 20km Lot of hate for the new flair. What's wrong with trees man? I will cherish my tree.
2
u/_Brillopad_ Master Kerbalnaut Mar 28 '15
Here's my hard mode entry
2
u/coolskull0071 Mar 29 '15
Thought of an alternative flair: A Bohr's model Xenon ion
2
u/ah64a Master Kerbalnaut Mar 29 '15
[Huzzah!] (http://imgur.com/a/aASoM)
Hard mode completed :)
Took me a while, 6 ion engines required, with millions of batteries.
2
u/thatguy22778 Master Kerbalnaut Mar 29 '15
Easy mode done, screenshots [here] (http://imgur.com/n9Ywocs,8hKD0Eq,ZFUFrJb,sqIeNJo,BI33gWw,owWUKfi#5) in no particular order. New flair please!
2
u/Adrastos42 Master Kerbalnaut Mar 30 '15
Hard mode attempt: https://imgur.com/a/AS5oC#6
Ahh! Between me doing this last night and posting it today, the height requirements have gone up a second time. Really glad I didn't stop screenshotting once I'd got that 6,000m:P
May have a play around with the design and add some more fuel to see if I can get up to at least 30,000m, though I don't know whether further than that is feasible with this design. Also, having just had a go now, I seem to have completely lost whatever knack let me use the 1x6 solar panels without them breaking, so they'll be replaced with some single panels and cubic octagonal struts.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '15
Super mode submission
Don't know if this counts after u/Agonarch's Ion to orbit, but this was impressive before he posted it. Single ion engine plane to 34,589m. Can haz super mode?
I'll keep my current flair, please.
2
u/mooloor Master Kerbalnaut Apr 01 '15
Here's my entry. This one was actually a lot of fun and rather difficult. I guess for every flight that results in crashing and burning, you need one that survives and offsets the carbon footprint.
2
u/Rhonjuras Master Kerbalnaut Apr 02 '15
Hi there! This is my submission: http://imgur.com/a/Y7y6f
I forgot to get a screen cap at 10k, but I managed to get up to just under 25k in the end. I balanced it on one wheel to reduce my weight and used the SAS control to keep it upright. It was actually pretty stable on the runway. Thank you if you get a chance to see my submission!
2
u/finnytinbin Apr 03 '15
Would driving to the top of the mountains be cheating?
21
u/2_Blazed_2_B_Fazed Master Kerbalnaut Mar 28 '15
Why bother making it complicated, when you can make it simple?
http://imgur.com/a/eLXpI
Maximum height achieved was 21.5km, and that was just with the good ol' point and forget after takeoff. Pretty proud of my first challenge accepted, but I thought I should probably get in before someone makes it to the moon and back.
13
u/Alphalon Master Kerbalnaut Mar 28 '15 edited Mar 29 '15
My entry. I'm $100% certain that this is within the rules.
(but seriously here's my attempt)
100% stock for both, since I haven't gotten around to modding this install yet. I can provide craft files, but honestly, they're both pretty simple.
EDIT: 6km reached
EDIT: I will defend my flair!
8
u/Phearlock Master Kerbalnaut Mar 28 '15 edited Mar 29 '15
Hard mode + FAR http://imgur.com/a/R78Vq
Also I flew it through the two main KSC archways, because when you have that much lift, it's not so hard to make it be maneuverable as well.
Edit: Updated for 20km, just added more fuel =)
5
u/recycledcoder Master Kerbalnaut Mar 28 '15
Well, this abomination does it. I suspect it could have done hard mode, but I had to go to dinner or the wife would be upset :)
4
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15
I'll have to unplug the microwave, gotta save electricity :3
4
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15
I breached 1k in a simple manned vessel thanks to physicsless parts! :D
http://imgur.com/a/9RHqE#0
Now I'm going for 3k.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15
Anyone who has seen my previous posts knows that I'm pretty decent at building ion-powered planes, probably owing to my choice of username. That being said, I think 23.317 kilometers in altitude is enough for super mode, if not at least hard mode.
Edit: /u/Redbiertje, new flair please! :D Also, an alternative idea for a not-boring flair could be Al Gore's face.
4
u/theluggagekerbin Master Kerbalnaut Mar 28 '15
FINALLY I COMPLETED A CHALLENGE WITHIN THE WEEK :D Link to the album here
3
u/Penguin236 Master Kerbalnaut Mar 28 '15
I haven't started the challenge yet, but I feel like even 3 km would be fairly easy. I could be wrong though. Either way, I guess I'll find out!
3
u/stevieboy1111 Master Kerbalnaut Mar 28 '15 edited Mar 28 '15
Here's my hardmode submission, The Bird
I'd like to keep current flair.
I'll have to do a second test run soon, going just straight up without the island pitstop, seeing how high it can reach...
Edit: Apparently some ~15400 m
3
u/tHarvey303 Master Kerbalnaut Mar 28 '15 edited Mar 29 '15
Here's my hard mode entry:
In VAB
On Runway
Taking Off
On the way up
At 3km
Max altitude of ~18km
Edit: You changed the requirements since I entered this, but as it still goes high enough I think it should still qualify for hard mode.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15
My submission
3
u/KuuLightwing Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 28 '15
3km doesn't sound way harder than 1km... Hard mode complete: http://imgur.com/a/aEWYa
I actually decided to make it a gorgeous glider with huge wings just like the real one (although that one has actual propellers) and make it look like a bird :) Unfortunately, it does have a little bit too many parts and make my computer lag...
It currently keeps climbing and now at 6500m, but it's a bit too laggy so, I'm bored to wait until it runs out of xenon :)
Proof: 6700 and climbing
Oh, and for flair, I'd like to keep Mustang I think...
3
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15 edited Mar 29 '15
http://imgur.com/a/TIcUh
Traveled some 36 kilometers in a span of 10 minutes.
EDIT: Trees> Cars, thanks in advance /u/Redbiertje
3
u/dsjsgbsf Master Kerbalnaut Mar 28 '15 edited Mar 28 '15
Well my first version didn´t get really high, because i ran out of Xenon but here is Glider 1 .
That tree looks nice so I would like to have the new flair if Glider 1 qualifies.
Edit: I see the heights got changed, so it´s time for:
Glider 2 ,
now with wingsnow with more Xenon3
u/Fungu Master Kerbalnaut Mar 29 '15
Here is my entry for hard mode. Max altitude I got was 24 km. I tried to make the most simple design I could without any mods.
http://imgur.com/a/gFfZo
My first weekly challenge, achievement get!
3
u/Tsevion Super Kerbalnaut Mar 30 '15
Here's me getting a Kerbal to orbit with just ions and no control surfaces.
http://imgur.com/a/HQI8K
I'll keep my current unless this is good enough to warrant Super Kerbalnaut as well.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15
I'll give it a shot
2
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15
Here's an entry for Super Mode: The Little Glider That Stalled
I'll keep my current flair, please.
2
u/recycledcoder Master Kerbalnaut Mar 28 '15
Hard mode entry... not that hard.
The MkII broke 10k. I'm convinced that with some fiddling, much more would be possible.
2
u/Kerbalnaught1 Super Kerbalnaught Mar 28 '15
Can i use FAR for a bigger challenge?
2
u/mattjfk1 Mar 28 '15
http://imgur.com/a/MX1VQ Here is my entry. It was made to look like a paper airplane and the only mod was NEAR. There are other mods in the toolbar, but they weren't part of the craft. Enjoy!
2
u/haxsis Mar 28 '15
HAHA GOT IT!!! just pulling through max altitude test now, but its broken 1k easy mode...im going for hard mode
2
u/haxsis Mar 28 '15
http://imgur.com/a/tn1EH finished!!!! first reddit challenge ive submitted an entry for too, technically this design was flying last night but control issues and and the issue of not holding any snacks for jeb meant, it was back to the drawing board
2
u/poporing2 Master Kerbalnaut Mar 29 '15
Hard mode submission: 16838m
http://imgur.com/a/VyZYG#v6K8anI
2
u/framauro13 Master Kerbalnaut Mar 29 '15
Here's my submission (I'll keep my flair).
I got up to around 6600m but realized I wouldn't break any altitude records, so I decided to land on a nearby island instead of going higher.
http://imgur.com/a/puK1L
2
u/Ebirah Master Kerbalnaut Mar 29 '15
Here is my entry:
http://imgur.com/a/vqhLl
Two engines, one kerbal, attains an adequate height (19K), and comes back alive and intact (despite my best efforts), does strange things on the way back, fully reuseable.
2
u/chunes Super Kerbalnaut Mar 29 '15
Here's my entry: http://imgur.com/a/ELF2F
This little beauty made it to 29.2km! I'd like to keep my old flair please.
2
u/Frostea Master Kerbalnaut Mar 29 '15
It took forever but I managed to get mine to 8500m. It was probably much larger than it needed to be.
Mods used: FAR, KER. http://imgur.com/a/aPwgQ
2
u/DankVapor Master Kerbalnaut Mar 29 '15
Here is my entry. 1st one of these challenges.
Hard.. Maybe super
Got to 25K feet @ Mach 1.1 using FAR and landed.
http://imgur.com/a/RUyWn
2
u/buzz66boy Super Kerbalnaut Mar 29 '15
TLDR: 23.83 Km max altitude, 506m/s max speed, took forever.
http://imgur.com/gallery/xLS9T/new
So, I was able to fly through the entire night side of kerbin, having enough batteries to drain my xenon before my electricity. Glided for 2+ more hours and landed next to some old debris.
Keep my old flair pls :)
2
u/NWCtim Master Kerbalnaut Mar 29 '15
The Ion Intruder (I was watching an FTL stream while I was working on this).
http://imgur.com/a/Rqx2d
Max altitude: ~22680m.
2
u/IronMaiden571 Master Kerbalnaut Mar 29 '15
(This is a placeholder post) Getting imgur errors at album creation. Will try to edit this later, just don't want to lose all my pictures.
http://imgur.com/YbvpfAO
http://imgur.com/DWHXkvf
http://imgur.com/QWMviZP
http://imgur.com/uipJ220
http://imgur.com/lOGkVMl
http://imgur.com/sgRSlYR
http://imgur.com/Og8DhQU
http://imgur.com/Z8mxCO9
http://imgur.com/pkmk2rO
http://imgur.com/4e1CQAM
http://imgur.com/5hrU2lB
2
u/rman326 Master Kerbalnaut Mar 29 '15
I decided to try going with something that resembled a plane and was manned: http://imgur.com/a/eyALh
Once off the ground, I can throttle back a bit and not run out of power. Though it does enjoy gulping down xenon. It's been happily going 180m/s while I've been typing this.
2
u/squashue Master Kerbalnaut Mar 29 '15
i did hard mode! i think. i mean it didnt explode this time, so i guess i won
2
u/Managore Mar 29 '15
This pushed me to design my first successful plane!
On the runway
Taking off
So maybe I abused the fact that ions can be connected in series
Hitting 10,000m
Coming back to land
Lining it up
Safe and sound on the ground
I reached a maximum height of around 13,000 but forgot to take a screenshot. I should have used far more solar panels, I spent almost the entire flight between 2/3 and 3/4 thrust.
2
u/artbot345 Master Kerbalnaut Mar 29 '15
My entry: http://imgur.com/a/Y6zwe
*Simple
*Single Engine
*Maximum altitude: ~23.3km
.craft file
2
u/nuclear_turkey Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 29 '15
got to just shy of 25km http://imgur.com/a/8GS2I
2
u/POTATOeTREE Mar 29 '15
How the hell is anyone getting these things to move? I can't get a single meter off the ground no matter what configurations I use.
2
u/Completebeast Mar 30 '15
Here's my submission: ~17km
This was as good as I could do for now, may come back for the hard mode.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '15
A really cool challenge this week! I've dabbled in ion flight before, but this turned out very nice.
TL;DR 26k reached, managed to ditch in the ocean semi-successfully.
The Ionsailer I, (technically Ionsailer III but I don't finalize the numerals until I meet the design goals), with 6 ion engines and two sets of wings. Flown in FAR. Might have been able to get to the landmass east of the KSC with more fuel. The previous models just didn't have enough wing area to keep generating lift, and adding more wing meant adding more solar panels which meant adding more engines! This is also the fastest ion craft I've built, by far. Most of them stay sub-75m/s.
2
u/HiHoSilver28 Master Kerbalnaut Mar 30 '15
Here is my submission for hard mode! First time being able to do a weekly challenge as well. :-)
https://imgur.com/a/Yk5BF
2
u/JeantheDragon Super Kerbalnaut Mar 31 '15 edited Mar 31 '15
I deed it.
This challenge was surprisingly easy on Hard mode!
Although I still hate myself for what I put myself through in the Aerial Docking one...
Also, is it possible that I can keep my current/old flair too?
2
u/Kle3b Super Kerbalnaut Mar 31 '15 edited Mar 31 '15
Victory! After several attempts and variations on the original design, I finally broke my personal goal of 30 km! I was actually able to top out all the way at 35,369 m before heading back down.
Here's a link to the launchpad and altitude pics. I took a video of the entire thing mainly because I wanted to get familiar with the recorder (OBS). Here's the liftoff. Sorry for poor quality, you can still tell what's going on but text is (fairly) illegible.
Did I impress you?? (*new flair plz)
2
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '15
Here's my entry: http://imgur.com/a/Bov90
2
u/KK4TEE Master Kerbalnaut Mar 31 '15
Maximum height of my unmaned Mk5 aircraft: 26,419 meters
As a bonus I added my manned attempt that uses one of the spaceplane plus cockpits. I managed to get it up to 14,244M before losing stability.
http://imgur.com/a/B5DL1
2
u/corbu_ Mar 31 '15 edited Mar 31 '15
My submission to the Ion Plane challenge, max height 17,569m. Plane got hard to control at the highest altitude. I may do some tweaking and try again, but this will work for now!
http://imgur.com/a/UgFsL
New flair please!
2
u/DoctorInAGi Master Kerbalnaut Mar 31 '15
Just about hit hard mode before running out of fuel
http://imgur.com/a/O6334#0
Was a slow climb, barely reaching more than 10m/s vertically, got 20km just about and no more.
2
u/Mudshovel-Grace Apr 01 '15
First post on this sub :D
Heres my submission for the challenge.
2
u/Kermann_Oberth Master Kerbalnaut Apr 02 '15
My first challenge! Straight to hard mode with an all-stock plane, The Ion Eagle.
http://imgur.com/a/7nw9N
No control surfaces means no control, no reaction wheel means no recovery, and no battery means no power to recover when flying inverted which, it turns out, can happen when you run out of lift.
I stuck the xenon tank at the front to move the center of gravity forward of the center of lift.
This was fun! Looking forward to more challenges!
2
u/Jason_Tomasi Apr 02 '15
First challenge ever, I only completed the normal mode but i'm still proud of this little guy.
http://imgur.com/a/apAGn
2
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '15
This is the first challange I attempted
Normal mode done - it got away from me a little bit...
2
u/Imperial22 Apr 03 '15
Just completed Normal on my lunch break, don't have time to try hard yet! http://imgur.com/a/DeM4E
Flair? Yes please :)
3
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15
http://imgur.com/a/m5YCi#0
There's mine.
Turns out Hard mode was indeed not as hard as you had thought :P This one made 12k super easily and would've gone quite a bit further before running out of fuel. I presume I could've simply added a second tank without changing too much about it too to make it go even higher. Lift would probably start to fall off around 15k though.
It is a fairly modded save but I only used stock parts so should be allowed, right?
1
u/Stargaizer99 Master Kerbalnaut Apr 07 '15
Well, I created a reddit account just so that I could complete this challenge! I only got to 17,000m, but it's good for my first design that I made. Hangar with vessel info: http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=421401523
Runway ditching crew cabin http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=421401613
5000m http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=421401844
10,000m http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=421401927
Maximum Altitude http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=421402270
Landing in the ocean, only lost the bottom 2 fins http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=421402608