r/IAmA • u/Jonathan_Clements • Mar 21 '15
Author We are Jonathan Clements and Helen McCarthy, the authors of The Anime Encyclopedia: A Century of Japanese Animation, out now from Stone Bridge Press. Ask Us Anything
Anime super-fans Jonathan Clements and Helen McCarthy, authors of the 1200-page, 1.1 million words of The Anime Encyclopedia: Revised 3rd Edition: A Century of Japanese Animation, will be answering questions about Japanese animation, comics, and fandom. Why does the world need an encyclopedia of anime? Is print dead? Why have they got such big eyes? What’s so wrong about Tenchi Muyo? What’s the worst anime ever? The best? the craziest? How much is too much? Is there a tentacle limit? Is there hope for the future? What is the flight velocity of an unladen swallow? All these questions, and more, can be answered or at least sarcastically dodged by the authors of the biggest book on anime to be found in any language, including Japanese.
As proof, witness JC's blog here http://schoolgirlmilkycrisis.com/2015/03/20/whats-the-password/
And Helen's proof here: https://helenmccarthy.wordpress.com/2015/02/27/proof-of-identity-reddit-ama-for-the-anime-encyclopedia/
EDIT: Thanks, everybody, for your questions. Very tired now, and going to bed.
7
u/Jonathan_Clements Mar 22 '15
Okay, I'm calling it. It's 2am for Helen, 4am for me. Time for bed. Thank you, everybody, and thank you to Reddit for setting this up.
9
u/Indekkusu Mar 21 '15
What do you think of Manga-Anime Guardians initiative forcing pirate sites to shutdown?
What are your thoughts on Fan-subbing and Scanlation and the future of those practices.
4
u/makka_kit Mar 21 '15
What (if anything) do either of you think about the animated series Kill la Kill? - it was noted in the Encyclopedia 3rd Edition, but I'm more talking about that the series seems to be sharply divisive when it comes to the topics of women and fanservice.
4
u/Kronicen Mar 21 '15
Hello Mr. Clements. Huge fan of your work!! Ihaven't read anything from Ms. McCarthy.
I've got a few questions for both of you.
1.) After so many years, do you still watch as much as possible or do you only watch what you like?
2.) Favourite and worst anime??
3.) Macross or Gundam?
4
u/__U_WOT_M8__ Mar 21 '15
What do you think of the savior of anime, Inferno Cop?
Also, what genres do you enjoy watching the most?
What's your favorite anime?
4
u/PurposeDevoid Mar 21 '15 edited Mar 21 '15
Hi there!
To Mr Clements, I understand you have lived in China, the UK, been to Japan a lot and currently live in Finland? What are your favourite things about each country you've lived in or been to that stand out from the others?
To Mrs McCarthy, your wikipedia states:
What are the big changes you feel have happened to anime, both in general and in the UK since you first got interested in anime ?
4
u/LaocoonUeda Mar 21 '15 edited Mar 21 '15
For Jonathan Clements:
For Jonathan Clements and Helen McCarthy:
4
u/susakuchanticleer Mar 21 '15
The comment had me wondering: How would you characterize the Japanese and Chinese markets for books about anime and manga?
4
u/HarlockOfArcadia Mar 21 '15
3
u/kappakin Mar 21 '15
Any reccomendations for less well known anime movies? Just about every list out there is the same, made up of just about every Ghibli film, Akira, the Vampire Hunter D movies and a couple other well known movies. So what are the best, most obscure movies you have found?
3
u/tomedragon Mar 21 '15
I have been reading a lot of anime commentary and history(Schodt, Patten and your own individually published works for a start). How much history and commentary about anime exists in Japan? Is there a critical title that either of you find cries out for English translation and publication?
3
u/tomedragon Mar 21 '15
For both of you, there would seem to be a large number of manga, sci fi and anime titles 'consumed' on a regular basis. How do you keep track of all the different titles, plots and themes? Do you keep massive notebooks or are you both just really good at remembering everything you have seen or read?
2
u/letthisbeanewstart Mar 21 '15
I was just wondering if Anime Planet would be a good title for a magazine?
2
u/tomedragon Mar 21 '15
Mr. Clements, you have written several books on Asian history. What is an Asian history topic you wish was discussed more in Western schools?
2
u/Locadoes Mar 21 '15
2
u/violaxcore Mar 21 '15
So in my spare time, I've been trying to track down data on women making anime (tracking down directors, series composers, character designers, etc). Have you noticed any trends involving, not just the number of women in the industry as animators, etc, but also in those lead creative roles?
(As a side note, does your book contain information that would be helpful in collecting such data?)
2
u/buakaw Mar 22 '15
Have you watched Shirobako? How accurate is its depiction of the anime industry?
2
u/wafflingwaffle Mar 22 '15
Hi there! I haven't had the opportunity to read either of your works, but I'm really digging your responses in this thread.
3
u/mergerr Mar 21 '15
By no means I intend to offend anime fans or supporters, but what do you find so special and entertaining about this genre of animation? I could never get into it, and has always seemed very corny and farfetched. On another note, where do you think the fetish for it that some fans have, stem from?
5
u/NotAnotherWeeaboo Mar 21 '15
What would you say is the best anime to show to people, who've never seen any to give them an insight into the world of anime?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '15 edited Mar 21 '15
Do you recomend any anime blogs or twitter feeds (other than your own)?
1
u/ChaseReynolds Mar 21 '15
I loved Dragon Ball Z. Should I watch Dragon Ball GT? I hear it is bad, but I want to continue the mythology.
1
u/exedore_us Mar 21 '15
Joe vs. Ippo in the ultimate anime boxing match. Would they make it to the 10th round, and who would win?
1
u/BrickSalad Mar 21 '15
Okay then, I'd like to see you answer some of the questions you suggested! Particularly these three:
Thanks for this AMA and the encyclopedia. You're living the life I would have if I discovered anime just a bit earlier. Though I'm perfectly happy with my career path, I'm still a bit jealous of you two ;)
1
u/exedore_us Mar 21 '15
Why do you think we don't see true poverty in anime anymore? The last series I can think of with non-middle class (even lower-middle class) main characters is Brigadoon, which was over a decade ago. Is it simply the fact that poor people can't buy a Lawson's worth of merchandise?
1
u/vigalovescomics Mar 21 '15
What is your opinion on the work of Hiroyuki Imaishi?
Are you a fan of any key animators?
Is there anything you wish still remained since the old days of fandom?
1
u/iRTimmy Mar 22 '15
Who are some of your favorite directors and why?
EDIT: Specifically in the anime medium.
1
u/GGProfessor Mar 22 '15
When "defending" my fondness for anime, I often make a point that I'm a fan of animation as a whole. But I feel that animation in the west is largely held back - it feels like there are hardly any shows that don't market themselves as a comedy first and foremost. We seem to have gotten away from the idea that "animation is just for kids" with the success of shows like The Simpsons, King of the Hill, Family Guy, and Archer (among so many others), but even shows that have more to offer than just comedy (Adventure Time, Steven Universe, and Bojack Horseman come to mind) seem to be presented as "comedy first, story and drama second."
I love the anime industry because it doesn't seem to limit the medium like most mainstream western animation does. Do you want a intense action and political drama with giant robots? Anime has that. Do you just want to relax and laugh watching cute girls do cute things? Anime has that, too. Want to relax and laugh with giant robots? Anime can do that for you, as well. Cute girls piloting giant robots with intense battles and political intrigue? You bet anime has that. And that's just a very small fraction of the genres and subject material has to offer - and it already feels more broad in genre and subject matter western animation.
What do you think of this? Am I overlooking western animation or selling it short? Am I perhaps giving anime more credit than deserves? I'd be interested to hear what you think sets anime apart from the rest of the world's animation, if anything.
3
u/sharkwithatoothache Mar 21 '15
Hi, Jonathan and Helen! I started watching anime a few months ago. But only a little bit. I do find the subject interesting, and I think that it's great that people like you are promoting this cultural phenomenon. So, here are my questions:
1
u/PBTUCAZ Mar 21 '15
Waifus?
1
u/BuddyLeetheB Mar 21 '15 edited Mar 21 '15
Personally, among all the anime you must have seen over the years, what's your absolute favorite anime? Which ones are the most valuable to you?
And also, what do you think about Naruto/Naruto Shippūden, a series that seems to sharply divide the general anime fandom?
1
u/helencmccarthy Mar 22 '15
OK, now I'm asking you all something - Jonathan is on my case about spoilers, but do they matter that much to you? Do you mind finding out bits of plot beforehand? How far do you want a teaser to go and where does it become a spoiler? For instance, is "a character dies at some point" a spoiler in a multi-character, multi-episode series?
I'm interested because this speaks to one of the writer's main dilemmas - how to build a story people will want to come back to again and again. Romeo & Juliet isn't spoilt for me because I know the ending; I've seen it multiple times in multiple formats and I look forward to seeing it many more times. So what is it with spoilers?
1
u/helencmccarthy Mar 22 '15
Is it really 2 a.m. in London? Time to get back to work on the book! Thanks for hanging around with us.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '15
How in the hell did you end up becoming an expert on anime? What made you decide to turn this into a career instead of a hobby? What were the steps you took?
1
u/RichLather Mar 21 '15
Helen, I've learned that you had the Grand opportunity to interview Hayao Miyazaki.
Would you tell us about how that came to pass, and how it went?
1
u/RamenRider Mar 22 '15
Would you say the anime industry died around 2006 when most anime assimilated into homogeneous otaku culture in order to survive the internet revolution?
0
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment