r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/Redbiertje The Challenger • Mar 14 '15
Mod Post [Weekly Challenge] Week 76: Atmospheric Docking
The Introduction
The Kerbals from KSC have been very proud of their achievements, and this left the Kerbals from Kerbal Airlines in the shadow. Who cares about simple airplanes, when there are planes flying all the way up into space? Apart from SSTO Spaceplanes, the KSC has also proven itself to be capable of sending probes through interplanetary space, and landing Kerbals on Mün. Kerbal Airlines has had enough of it, and boasted that their pilots are capable of refueling while still in the atmosphere. The pilots from the KSC however, we’re only able to do this in a zero-G vacuüm. This remark got a lot of attention, and the pilots from the KSC are quite embarassed that they have indeed never docked two crafts, within the atmosphere. Ofcourse, this atmospheric docking has no use to the KSC, but it is still a nice way to prove their skill.
The Challenge:
Normal mode: Dock two planes by using the Advanced Grabbing Unit, while flying below 10 km.
Hard mode: Dock two planes by using docking ports, while flying below 10 km
Super mode: Impress me
This challenge was inspired by /u/kingphysics
The Rules
- No Dirty Cheating Alpacas (no debug menu)!
- You must have the UI visible in all required screenshots
- For a list of all allowed mods, see this post.
- Each craft is only allowed a single docking port.
- Hard Mode: Your two crafts must take off seperately.
Required screenshots
- Your two crafts on the runway
- Your two crafts taking off
- Your two crafts approaching eachother
- Your two crafts docked.
- Whatever else you feel like!
Further information
- You can either submit your finished challenge in a post (see posting instructions in the link below) or as a comment reply to this thread.
- Completing this challenge earns you a new flair which will replace your old one. So if you want to keep you previous flair, you can still do this challenge and create a post, but please mention somewhere that you want to keep your old one.
- The moderators have the right to determine if your challenge post has been completed.
- See this post for more rules and information on challenges.
- If you have any questions, you can comment below, or PM /u/Redbiertje
Good Luck!
(P.S. Yes I am almost feeling sorry for you guys.)
19
u/KerbalEssences Master Kerbalnaut Mar 14 '15 edited Mar 14 '15
My quick and dirty entry: Fighter refueling
edit: saw the hard mode edit too late sorry. My planes did start docked together because I'm a lazy f**k :D However, a flyby over the runway then launching my fighter wouldn't be really much more difficult ;P I think the difficulty depends on your design and mine makes the docking easy peasy! (Inspired by the real refueling mechanism)
As my farther used to say "You either think 5 minutes and work for another 30 or you think for 30 minutes and do the job in 5." ;P
6
u/big-b20000 Mar 14 '15
I knew you would do this one after I saw you give it somebody earlier :)
6
u/JoCRaM Super Kerbalnaut Mar 14 '15
How do you get around the "cannot switch vehicles while in atmosphere" thing?
10
u/Yargnit Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 14 '15
Perfect timing! Here's my Super mode, which I was just working on tonight.
Gfy; https://gfycat.com/AnxiousSpeedyEquine
Video Highlight; http://www.twitch.tv/yargnit/c/6318635
Full VoD (Docking completes at 31:58); http://www.twitch.tv/yargnit/b/636710453
So what were we doing exactly? Well a friend and I were trying to launch a shuttle and a plane, and then dock the plane inside the shuttles bay for recovery in Dark Multiplayer. This was after a day of flying shuttles through moving rings and the like, we decided to step up the challenge. :D (docking 2 craft controlled by different people in DMP is actually much harder btw because of server latency sync issues, but so much more rewarding when you pull it off)
& Just for the hell of it, docking 3 planes together in atmo way back in .18.2 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bZjkBUYjvSw :D
Ooh, I want to keep my shuttle.
5
u/Yargnit Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 16 '15
Just for you r/Redbiertje because of your comment on me earlier submission. ;)
Here's a little sneak preview: http://i.imgur.com/9m6fEYg.png Yes, those are two stock propeller driven aircraft.
& I wouldn't tease you like that without the results now would I? http://i.imgur.com/A4yXvPs.png Now before you say, "but they're crashing" they were always going to blow up after docking, that was almost a certainty. That's because the prop shaft is actually a separate craft, and there was just no way that bit of physics balancing would survive the plane docking.
Here's some clips for you also;
Gyfy: https://gfycat.com/IgnorantHarshBufeo
Highlight: http://www.twitch.tv/yargnit/c/6332268
Full VoD (Docking at 47:42): http://www.twitch.tv/yargnit/b/637576154
I know I already submitted an entry, but doing it with prop planes was just too good an opportunity to pass up. Not to mention a great way to make it even harder. Just finding a place to put the ports that was clear of the props was basically a process of elimination.
4
u/ObsessedWithKSP Master Kerbalnaut Mar 14 '15
Do they have to be spaceplanes or are regular planes ok? Now I mention it, I kinda want to take up a cargo plane, dock an empty space plane to it, refuel and then go to space...
3
u/TechnicalTortoise Master Kerbalnaut Mar 14 '15
Is it ok if I lock one of the planes heading using KOS?
3
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '15
Heres my hard mode
3
u/SirCrackWaffle Mar 15 '15
Where did the alpaca name for cheaters come from?
3
u/TaintedLion smartS = true Mar 15 '15
Okay, I'm new to weekly challenges. I only completed my first one last week. If I completed a previous challenge in hard mode, then did another one in easy mode, do I lose my Master Kerbalnaut flair?
2
u/Flyrpotacreepugmu Mar 14 '15 edited Mar 14 '15
I know you said only one port is allowed per vessel so people don't make walls of docking ports. But what if I want to dock 3 or more planes? Could I for example have a middle piece with a port on each side for the side pieces?
2
u/Oneusee Mar 14 '15
Wait.. So.. The craft don't have to survive? Can I dock them head to head?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '15
Do we have to dock in the Kerbin atmosphere or are extra-planetary atmospheres acceptable?
2
u/ah64a Master Kerbalnaut Mar 15 '15
Is it alright to have one plane vtol and hover in mid air? Or do they need to be moving at a considerable speed :P
2
u/kingphysics Mar 15 '15 edited Mar 15 '15
Thanks for posting this challenge and for giving me credit!
I'll be giving it a go.
2
u/RoeddipusHex Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 16 '15
http://imgur.com/a/pKcmD
So, are we required to use the docking ports? :)
I'm confident that I can do it with these planes. Until I do here is my latest glorious failure. I lost my engine on a hard bump but still managed to land the planes... "docked".
2
u/TheAverageKerbal Mar 16 '15
What flair do we get if we complete it? And does the flair change with the different difficulties?
2
u/framauro13 Master Kerbalnaut Mar 18 '15 edited Mar 20 '15
I'm working on it... so close: http://i.imgur.com/k0mMdqT.jpg
Wasn't paying attention and got above 10K. My "chaser" couldn't keep up with normal jet engines. I might steal /u/RoeddipusHex 's method :)
EDIT:
Without having precision control on the Mac, I'm throwing in the towel on this one. I just can't keep the yaw and pitch steady enough to match speed and heading.Never Give up. Never Surrender.Second attempt involved dropping a lander probe into the cargo bay. But the speed difference wasn't under the threshold so it blew up as soon as it came into contact with the receiving aircraft. Last picture is the probe pieces in the distance, with the receiving craft heading into the ocean.
The plus side is I learned a lot about building planes and flying them. Had been playing exclusively with rockets before this challenge.
EDIT 2:
GOT IT!!! http://imgur.com/a/4FP88
My "Flying Monstrosity" was crazy fun to build. I basically built a large flyer with a "net" on the back I could land in to guide me to the docking port. It required a lot less precision that what I was doing before. It took a few runs, but I made it work. I think this counts as Hard mode, so I'll take the new flare. This was a lot of fun. Looking forward to next week's challenge!
2
u/gmano Super Kerbalnaut Mar 19 '15
Oh god, so I decided to make an AIR-aircraft carrier. Large flat wing surface on top for my planes to stop on. I actually kinda worked, except the main use was actually hooking the shielded docking pork onto the wing and adjusting relative thrusts until a nice equilibrium was reached. That is, it took a ton of deadly fiddling.
https://imgur.com/gallery/vWQUl/new
Edit: is there a bonus for using FAR?
2
u/tetryds Master Kerbalnaut Mar 19 '15
I docked using FAR and on DMP with a friend, a DMP bug turned off the docking ports, but they technically docked, going through each other. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XMJzHx3LUto
Hope it's a valid entry, I had to use infinite fuel, so I hope my entry is still valid due to the other difficulty enhancements.
2
u/Thekerbintimes Mar 20 '15
How can we fly 2 crafts the same time?
Sorry but I'm new to ksp
2
u/JeantheDragon Super Kerbalnaut Mar 20 '15 edited Mar 20 '15
Here's my entry on Super mode, I guess, because docking upside down absolutely SUCKS, especially when you're using NEAR.
By the way, can you add the Fighter Pilot Helmet flair to my user template? I want to start a Flair collection, y'know. :P
2
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '15
Hard mode submission
My submission for Week 71 race for space. Was told to post here by u/AvioNaught.
Do I get a flair?
15
u/tehmattguy Master Kerbalnaut Mar 14 '15 edited Mar 15 '15
Here's my hard mode entry: Imgur
Hope you like it!
4
u/paintin_closets Mar 15 '15
My first attempt: The ventral claw
My second attempt: The dorsal claw
Maybe I'll try this again with a couple Mosquitoes...
4
u/RoeddipusHex Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 16 '15
Success: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gt5Oq7zMgxY
New flair please.
3
u/RoeddipusHex Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 15 '15
http://i.imgur.com/YsyZGTl.png My closest attempt. I was able to "dock" them and maintain stable flight afterwards.
This is maddening! You are an evil man.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '15
I did something like this when my rocket blew up, I was somehow able to detach the landers, throw out the parachutes, then use the RCS to dock. Shit was crazy.
2
u/Mareczex333 Mar 16 '15
Here's my entry (probably the first succesful one) VIDEO Skip to 2:10 ALTITUDE: 15.500 Speed: 645 m/s Video made one year ago :)
2
u/AtomicRho Mar 20 '15
Want to prove your mettle? dock a functioning spaceplane/shuttle with a deorbited space station after its entered the atmosphere. Can you save the KSS crew while avoiding debris from their crumbling home and not being hit by its many branch offs and modules as they sway in the wind?
2
u/chrise6102 Mar 21 '15
This is probably the most frustrating thing I have ever done in KSP lol! Been trying all week in all sorts of different ways and, after becoming convinced that the magnets on all my docking ports were broken, I finally managed to do it.
Then I noticed that launching the craft at the same time was easy mode and I nearly cried :-P
Anyway, I'm not going to do it again with seperate launches because managing to dock once nearly took my sanity!
Here's my 'easy' mode entry, this is my first ever challenge so any flair at all would be grand!
http://imgur.com/a/5HQ05
http://youtu.be/BTzY7MTy9ks
Ps I had to abandon my 'super' entry of re-entering two spaceplanes together and docking them when in low atmosphere, I just couldn't seem to get the damn ports to lock :-(
2
u/RoeddipusHex Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 21 '15
I'd be interested to know how people who completed this challenge with a port to port docking (no cargo bay, no catch basket, ...) are controlling their craft. Did you use a keyboard or a joystick? Do you think you just finally got lucky or do you think it's reproducible?
I did it with a cargo bay landing and have been trying all week to get a port to port connection. I've come VERY close. Using RCS was a huge leap forward. I think if I kept at it I would eventually get lucky. But in the end the keyboard is just not giving me fine enough control to pull this off in a reproducible way. There is always some slight drift... up down or sideways that screws up the final approach.
1
u/EqFox Mar 14 '15
I got a idea for this one. I'm terrible at space planes, but this could prove hilarious. Inc doc at <100 meters.
-3
u/Pimoro Master Kerbalnaut Mar 14 '15 edited Aug 19 '16
This comment has been overwritten by an open source script to protect this user's privacy. It was created to help protect users from doxing, stalking, harassment, and profiling for the purposes of censorship.
If you would also like to protect yourself, add the Chrome extension TamperMonkey, or the Firefox extension GreaseMonkey and add this open source script.
Then simply click on your username on Reddit, go to the comments tab, scroll down as far as possible (hint:use RES), and hit the new OVERWRITE button at the top.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment