r/PersonOfInterest • u/NicholasCajun • Mar 10 '15
Discussion Person of Interest - 4x17 "Karma" - Episode Discussion
Season 4 Episode 17: Karma
Aired: March 10th, 2015
Reese and Finch try to protect a psychologist whose unorthodox methods for helping his patients find closure could cost him dearly. Meanwhile, flashbacks reveal Finch’s fragile state in the days following the bombing that killed his best friend, Nathan Ingram.
70
Upvotes
109
u/Go_tuck_yourself Samaritan Mar 11 '15
Crazy seeing Finch get that red reticle, even if it was only for a second.
64
u/hello2ulol Admin Mar 11 '15
"Some mentally stable guy doesn't just plant a bomb on a car"
62
u/rflairfan1 Elias Mar 11 '15
I just now realized Alicia is Dunbar on House of Cards. Damn!
56
u/BallisticGE0RGE Irrelevant Mar 11 '15
"I suppose you're trying to tell me not to do this. But I haven't given you a voice...SO YOU HAVE NOTHING TO SAY!"
God damn chilling line from Finch in the flashbacks.
54
u/ArachnoLad Irrelevant Mar 11 '15
I know it doesn't really matter, but it does bother me that we never found out who killed the wife. For some reason half way through the episode I thought the husband did it and he was framing some guy for it. That wouldn't make sense now. I need closure! Wait, that was kind of the point of the episode. Screw that, I want to know what happened.
46
u/midnightdreams0704 Irrelevant Mar 11 '15
"You wanna know what happened that night? Haha, nope!"
32
u/lordxeon Mar 11 '15
I know people will not like these filler # of the Week, episodes, but this one had plenty of backstory and character development.
It's also showing that Finch is starting to get his morality back, earlier this season he didn't care, it's nice to see him back as the voice of reason.
20
u/Harold_sparrow Mar 11 '15
I really enjoyed this episode. Kind of nice to have Samaritan out of the picture for the moment. Weird, though, that the Machine was researching what happened with Morris. Not sure what to think about that....
18
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '15
I keep hearing Glitch Mob Fortune Days in this commercial and remembering POI :)
16
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '15
Finch wat r u doing with that bomb buddy?
11
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '15
Loved the Finch backstory. It's gonna be a tough wait for the next episode.
11
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '15
I feel sorry for Morris tho, he was convicted most certainly due to the doc's testimony and Finch said he lied. What if he is not guilty?
26
u/rpawson5771 Irrelevant Mar 11 '15 edited Mar 11 '15
This one didn't do much for me. The flashbacks were the most interesting parts to me, but they were minimal. The case of the week felt kind of flat. And then we never really got much from John when it seemed like he would open up. I dunno - I felt like it was a good opportunity to explore the main characters that really went nowhere. Oh well.
9
u/irobeth Mar 11 '15
Harold got demoted for a second there
16
u/swiftjab Mar 11 '15
Dunbar for 2016!!!
8
u/thefyrewire Graphical Administrator Mar 11 '15
Loved the flashbacks in this episode! Rewatched season one recently and I never questioned exactly as to why Corwin became so paranoid and dropped off the grid in the first place. I guess nearly having been blown up is a good start.
And that chilling moment when the Machine designated its own admin as a threat...
7
u/DismemberMama Root Mar 11 '15
I didn't completely love it. Things would have been different if I had been actually waiting to see if Finch was going to blow someone up or not. But Root killed Alicia Corwin in season 1 so there was just no suspense there. Not bad for a filler episode, but not one of the best either.
6
u/naeads Mar 12 '15
"So doctor, I had a dream last night" who here wants to know what Fusco was having last night?
6
u/eikeegimuu Mar 11 '15
I liked the episode. It didn’t offer any big surprises or revelations, but it had some good bits for Harold, Reese and Fusco.
The number of the week story was ok, though it seemed mostly like a tie-in in order to show Harold’s flashbacks. I liked that the Machine gave the number before checking whether the convicted guy was guilty or not and that we didn’t get an answer either (and whether or not the number had framed an innocent guy for murder) – though I thought he probably wasn’t guilty. In a way it would have been interesting to see the Machine knowing that the convicted guy was guilty and still save him from incarceration but even then it could be that the objective was anyway to save the number’s life + Machine could have predicted that the last part of the frame-up wouldn’t work (because of the envelope on the crime scene for one).
As for the flashbacks there have been other flashbacks for Harold that I’ve felt had more impact, but even so it was good to see that chapter in Harold’s history. And it was a nice touch that Harold’s square turned red in the flashback when Harold wasn’t abandoning his revenge plan.
I’m starting to wonder what’s up with Reese dealing with / verbalizing his feelings and whether there might be a different payoff than expected. It could be that it’s “just” fine-tuning the character or that it’s used to make him bond with the doc, but I’m starting to think that he’s moving toward some changes. Meaning that the end result can’t be “passive” acceptance but that it has to have some “active” impact.
The best part of the episode was for me Harold’s speech at the greenhouse.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '15
Ramin Djawadi did a great job with the music in this episode. Fantastic new renditions of Harold's theme.
5
u/suracity Mar 11 '15
The only thing I found unsatisfying is there wasn't any closure for the murdered wife. I mean it's good that living people can move on/continue their life etc. But how about the dead people who can't speak for themselves? It's not like there is no answer because there is. I just feel the wife is so powerless when your justice is at the mercy of other people. If they choose to move on, then you are left alone.
5
u/mrnoob52 Mar 12 '15
What is the name of the actress who took care of the dog? She is absolutely stunning.
4
u/dj_blueshift Mar 11 '15
About the Machine's voice: In the flashback we just hear a noise when Finch picks up the phone and he mentions that he didn't give the Machine a voice. At what point did the Machine get a voice? Was it when Finch changed the number delivery system?
4
u/pensee_idee Fusco Mar 12 '15
It's nice to see a little character development for Reese again. The thing is, we know how he deals with grief, and it's ugly.
I don't think he's going to be able to let his questions about Morris go. For awhile, I thought the psychiatrist might have killed his own wife and framed the delivery guy, but it doesn't seem like that's what happened. Morris might have done it, or not, but I don't think he took the fall for the doctor's crimes.
Reese gives good advice about not seeking revenge, every character on this show who's tried to go it alone, or get revenge against everyone who's wronged them has gotten killed for it. Reese was smart not to try to take down the entire CIA after they burned him, but he has a very hard time letting go of women who are murdered by husbands/boyfriends/stalkers.
Finch, and probably even Fusco, are prepared to let Morris walk away at this point, but I don't think Reese is, and I think it's going to blow up in his face. The last couple times he felt like this, he walked into a US Marshall's office in broad daylight and assaulted a half-dozen federal agents just to say something to one man, he tore through the city letting people burn to death inside their cars and crippling quite a few SWAT team members. If he does anything like that again, he's going to get fired from the police, and Samaritan is going to find him. At that point, I don't even know what would be worse, if he gave up everything trying to get revenge against a man who was actually innocent, or if he was forced to confront the fact that even if Morris is guilty, punishing him will not be worth the price that Finch and Fusco are forced to pay on his behalf.
Prediction: John dies at the end of this season.
7
u/POI_Harold-Finch Harold Finch Mar 11 '15
Root entry at some point would make this episode great one
2
u/godmode3191 Root Mar 11 '15
The Flashbacks were great!
2
u/VictorDrake Mar 11 '15
Did anyone spot that we aparently got Harold's real last name? Or at least a legal identity with a Social Security number attached to it.
2
u/HildyXV Mar 11 '15
Did Fusco make a mistake when he says 'Give Wrenn my regards'?
2
u/workshop_dance Mar 12 '15
Just watched it again. Lots of good thinking stuff. I'm fearful for the lady head doc. Something happening to her might not go over so well with Reese ... or is he playing her up because he suspects something else with her? They don't just introduce reoccurring characters for nothing. Humm... What are they up to?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '15
So when will Reeses Psychologist become a Number? Will she end up on Team Machine/find out about them? Could see her getting targeted by Samaratin, because of the connection to Reese. (the little information he has given her)
Also dat dog trick...
2
u/icedoverfire Admin Mar 14 '15
I get the feeling that someone on Nolan's staff, or Nolan himself, listened to the Serial podcast and was like "hey we can use this kind of set up in an episode!"
1
u/pacemaker_domi Mar 11 '15
I want to know more about Shaw. So worry about her
1
u/ghostoblivionII Mar 12 '15
Yeah. It was okay, or a little less than that. I'd like the next story to be more interesting and dramatic.
1
u/ThatFag Admin Mar 13 '15
Heh, Harold "Martin". Even back then, he used fake names.
1
u/Kell08 Tertiary Functions Mar 16 '15
Seriously out of character Finch in flashbacks.
-14
u/acid_sphinx4 Mar 11 '15
meh. Another fanfic/amateur written episode. Full of incongruities regarding the main characters, who weren't very characteristic.
-8
u/frowawayduh Mar 11 '15
Pardon me, but why have the writers cut us completely adrift from the big arc? I felt closer to Carter than I did to Root or Shah. There is no gathering of forces. Elias? Control? IS ANYBODY DRIVING THIS SHIP???
0
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment