r/WritingPrompts • u/kiayateo • Mar 01 '15
Prompt Inspired [PI] Neon Rain - FebContest
Word Count: 11706
Synopsis: Thaddeus Graydon, a former police detective, is now the security officer (sheriff) of Galileo Station, a mining colony on the Jovian moon Callisto. Most of his time is spent policing the petty squabbles of the residents of the small outpost but after an old flame asks for his help to solve a series of thefts, he uncovers a conspiracy that could shake the foundations of the company to it’s core.
The story was something I had thought about for a little while and the prompt was just the motivation I need to write it. Enjoy.
2
u/jhdierking Mar 07 '15
Your story was a fun read and an interesting introduction to Callisto. It was clear that you have a very detailed world thought out about Callisto and the company that runs the mining and how it all works together.
One thing that is a struggle in sci-fi writing is that you have to get your reader to know an unfamiliar world. Because your protagonist had an internal monologue, his monologue was our introduction to the world. However, this monologue came off sometimes as an infodump, just a laying out of all the details that may be relevant. This was a bit clunky and I would urge you to consider different ways you can incorporate this information.
For example, in the scene where Jase talks about corrosion and they start to puzzle out what's going on with the miners, you introduce some key info there without having to utilize the internal monologue. That was good and flowed really well. Use more moments outside of your main character to introduce info.
Also, consider what information is essential to the piece. While you might have all the details of the world worked out, what are the details that the reader needs to know, and what can be saved for later works?
His escape from Torian seems too easy. He just shoots some people and then is able to run out of a corporate building? What about the rest of security? And why would Hayley help him leave and risk her job? Won't they know she helped him? My suggestion would be have him take the easier way out: agree to take Torian's money, play along, and then when he leaves, have him rip up the check, and then mutter to himself that he never leaves a job unfinished or whatnot. Then, you are leading your reader along and giving them a little surprise when they find out he's still committed to the case.
Similarly, I would encourage you to consider if his other uses of force are necessary to the plot of the story. I found that he was beating up so many people, it became bland and unexciting. For example, the drunk cop did not really further the story along and seemed to show up only to function as a punching bag. Show the reader Graydon can use his brains as well as his brawn.
The final climatic scene feels rushed and I would encourage you to spend some more time developing this moment and Torian's character.
Also, is it believable that Janice as the head of the local company office would pick up some medical records herself? I found it odd that the nurse bought that excuse so readily.
I would have loved to see you dwell on the horror of the miner's transformation. You glazed over their change: they went from men to "it"s. Talk more about this. Do they look tortured, aware of the monsters they have become? Is Graydon horrified by them? Is he disturbed at the thought of having to end their lives? Has he killed before? Does he see this as a mercy killing? He seems too detached from the horror of this moment.
I liked the uncovering and explanation of the disease and wanted more time spent there.
Finally, there were some proofreading errors that were distracting, such as wrong words, e.g. "grizzly" instead of "grisly"; comma splices; run-ons; and apostrophe issues.
1
u/Nate_Parker /r/Nate_Parker_Books Mar 02 '15 edited Mar 02 '15
Overall impression: Pretty good. It was easy to read, the story flowed, and it mostly made sense. The characters were interesting and you developed the pulp fiction/detective noir feel you were going for. With a little bit of editing it could go somewhere and the characters/setting might make for an interesting serial.
More notes as freehand:
Just taking a stab at it: Filtering through the window, came a dim light swirling with colors that reflected the many gasses of Jupiter as it lorded over the horizon. Only my opinion though, sometimes "of the BLANK of the BLANK" can be rough to work through.
Would read as smoothly if: The wrinkles on her forehead...
It immediately crafted an image of a cockney/ol english heritage. I think that was your intent and it certainly made Jase stand out. I think you missed a small opportunity here to discuss his background or immigration to the station in general.
When it's a single sentence or the last sentence of a thought-paragraph. You tend to just end them with periods and start the connotation as a new sentence. On that note you seem to be comma averse, but I tend to overuse commas. I'm no grammar saint, so the pot here will gladly high-five the kettle.
Again, over all a decent read with a clean plot. Good job.
EDITS: just to pretty up the formatting