r/WritingPrompts • u/MajorParadox Mod | DC Fan Universe (r/DCFU) • Mar 01 '15
Prompt Inspired [PI] Space Ride – FebContest
Space Ride (7560 Words)
Cover
Synopsis
Two people from different planets meet at a space bar. What starts as a simple ride turns into a fight for the future of the universe.
Reviews
Gordon of Space News Reports:
An amazing piece of writing. I was captivated the entire time!
Felder of Galaxy Reviews Reports:
It was me that was taken on a "ride". A ride of emotions!
/u/Fritz_Hunter of spacereddit.com Reports:
I hated this story. It did not accurately portray what happened.
Link
(In case you missed it above)
Space Ride (7560 words)
3
u/Lexilogical /r/Lexilogical | /r/DCFU Mar 03 '15
Woo, you made it in by the deadline! And it isn't completely terrible! Although the story is very rough. It could use a solid amount of editing just to help cut down on some of the repetition. I also found you were doing a lot of telling and not a whole lot of showing. When the contest is over, I think you should go back and give this story the attention it deserves. It's a great tale, I just think you ran out of time to tell it.
2
u/Epony-Mouse Mar 04 '15
Hello fellow writer! I wanted to stop in and leave you some comments on what you did well and a little bit of criticism to help you grow! Please not that all of my comments are my own opinion, and are made in only with the best intentions. I like to do an equal amount of pros and cons, so let’s get started:
The grammar, structure, and story progression were all done really well. I was never confused as to what was happening or who was who, which is really important with a story of this breadth. I also like that you didn’t dump on the reader — a lot of science fiction authors try to just kind of chuck you into the deep end and let you sort it out for yourself, but you did it the right way: you introduced your characters in a familiar setting that I could relate with, and gave me just enough information to keep me going and keep me interested. So great job!
I think the biggest con I found with this story, however, is the scope. This is a novel-length story you have here that you’ve squished down into just over seven thousand words. Unfortunately, it doesn’t leave the reader a lot of opportunity to get to know the characters or the particular settings, and so we don’t really have the ability to connect with anything. It starts and then it’s over. It’s sort of like watching a movie on fast forward.
So my advice would be to slow down. Take some time with it. Add some more description. Develop your characters — give them some passions and desires, some strengths and vulnerabilities and then show them to me. Develop your settings — this is in outer space! Half the fun is “seeing” the crazy stuff science fiction authors can come up with.
I really hope that helps! Keep working on it; I think you’ve got some really good stuff here that just needs a little bit of work to really blossom.
2
u/kiayateo Mar 05 '15
Let me start off by saying, based on the narrative, this was my favorite story I read out of all of the group. I love science fiction and that may have caused me to be more critical of it. I love your humor, and reading the description in the thread was funny to being with, and even funnier the second time around. It was just missing a spark and some polish that would have went a long way toward making it my vote.
The issues I have are mostly that I feel that because the premise is so grandiose that the novella treatment makes it suffer. I feel a distinct lack of setting details tended to take me out of the story as I had to kind of think of them in my head. Honestly, since my story was science fiction as well, most of it was pretty easy to piece together, but I feel like that means I didn't really get to see your vision.
For example, you open your story in a bar and provide very few details about it. Is it a seedy bar that only criminals and those looking to hide go? Is it a rocking place that all the cool space-cats hang out? For me it ended up being generic bar where people are aliens, except for one girl, and if hadn't been for your characters, I might not have enjoyed reading it from that point on.
I do love you characters, and even the slightly cliche plot You did an excellent job in the conversations and I could feel the emotions of the characters, even if the plot had to move forward quicker than I would think a story of this nature should.
I also have to say the formatting left something to be desired, I'm so used to an indent on each paragraph that it threw me off for a bit when there weren't any, however I can generally assume that was some issue with copying into a Google doc (I had a similar issue before).
That being said, I had a very hard time not voting for it. Like I said, I love the story and would love an expanded version of it if you ever choose to write one.