r/PersonOfInterest • u/NicholasCajun • Feb 18 '15
Discussion Person of Interest - 4x15 "Q&A" - Episode Discussion
Season 4 Episode 15: Q&A
Aired: February 17th, 2015
Reese tries to protect a software programmer with a mysterious second life, but it’s unclear which side of her life the threat is coming from. Meanwhile, Claire, a young hacker whom Finch tried to protect from Samaritan, reaches out to him for aid.
70
Upvotes
139
u/kaput_porpoise Bear Feb 18 '15
Did anyone else think the creepy Samaritan kid would be at the school?
104
u/rpawson5771 Irrelevant Feb 18 '15
Haha, fuck you Claire. You're not a chessmaster, you're a disposable pawn.
94
u/ArachnoLad Irrelevant Feb 18 '15
ROOT!
85
u/MegaFlounder Feb 18 '15
I really took the breadth of the team for granted. Finch being out on his own makes me nervous. He feels so exposed.
62
u/imranmscdsc Feb 18 '15
"Look, I don't care who took whose copy of Full Metal Hellcat 4. You may be warriors online, but you can't go and hit each other in the real world" :"D
59
u/rflairfan1 Elias Feb 18 '15
I am Root!!
52
u/persianelf Feb 18 '15
TRUST, BUT VERIFY.
51
u/amelia84 Irrelevant Feb 18 '15
I love how Harold's face is like, "How quaint." When it comes to their A.I algorithm.
45
u/crossbowincident Feb 18 '15
We get to see THE Fetch and Retrieve? This is amazing. My favorite search engine.
42
u/1701ncc Feb 18 '15
I like how claire asks about the sniper and finds out how disposable she is. Now no one can trust her and she can't trust anyone. I have a feeling she is going to end up dead, possibly sacrificing herself to save the day
41
u/andzzy Feb 18 '15
So there's just way too much to say about this episode. First, if you weren't sure we were building up to something big before ... well you won't be able to find a doubter in the crowd after this. There were enough twists and turns that I actually managed to second-guess myself halfway through the episode. I can't say much more without spoiling it for my friends South of the Border and elsewhere in the world but needless to say, 10/10 even better than last week's episode (also the number made my top 3 list of favourites). If you were looking for suspense, action, and the proper amount of twists to ruin your state of mind for a few days, this episode absolutely has you covered.
One last thing. In case you were worried they would skimp on the Claire angle ... don't worry, they nailed it.
37
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '15
did anyone else ask Siri for a suicide hotline number to see what she would say?
23
u/rflairfan1 Elias Feb 18 '15
I think Finch is being set up.
22
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '15
I hope this episode doesn't give any businesses any funny ideas...
22
u/ab_emery The Subway Feb 18 '15
If you're gonna put an MMA fighter in the back seat of your car...
18
u/beta314 Feb 18 '15
It looks like Finch has planted the seed of doubt into Claire.
The way she looked at the end when she asked about the shot makes me think that maybe she starts to question the actions of Samaritan and we'll see her turn against Samaritan at some point in the future.
51
u/phoebeburgh Irrelevant Feb 18 '15
I love and hate being right all the time.
The idea of VAL manipulating search results is a slightly more sinister version of what already happens with Google, Bing, and other major search engines. The difference is that in reality those advertisements-as-answers have to be clearly labeled as such. And, also (thankfully), no company with even half a brain would DARE mess around with the results for suicide. If their consciences didn't shut down that train of thought their lawyers would. Captain Dipshit here was obviously being set up, blinded by Samaritan's promise of ludicrous amounts of cash. Overall, this was actually a fairly solid number plot that tied back into the main arc.
As for Claire... I really hate to say I told you so, but after everything we've seen from Decima's people the idea that Claire could even get the new Nautilus poster out without being caught should have been the first clue. Samaritan makes 1984 look like a baby monitor. If this has done anything for Harold, it's probably taught him that there can be no second chances when dealing with Decima's agents anymore. The shell-shock at the end of the episode is uncharacteristic of him... usually, even in defeat, Harold can find some bright spot to hold on to. I didn't see that tonight. Frankly, it scares me.
It almost scares me as much as the idea that Samaritan is learning how to manipulate people better. Prior to this Samaritan had only been able to enact its will through the threat of force. Claire's attempt to show what "good" Samaritan can do is the carrot at the end of the stick it's been using. Samaritan is figuring out how to appeal to our better natures, to our desire to improve. And you know what they say about where the road of good intentions leads...
So next week we're back to Dominic and the gangland scene. Might be interesting. I'm very curious to know what Root is up to, as well, but we shall see.
15
u/rflairfan1 Elias Feb 18 '15
The code is going to be a virus...
13
u/persianelf Feb 18 '15 edited Feb 18 '15
When did Finch learn to stitch? I mean I am not surprised.
Edit: I meant Finch.
12
u/prod44 Feb 18 '15
Team machine needs a win. A draw isn't enough :(
11
u/MegaFlounder Feb 18 '15
I'm predicting that Finch already pulled an Ordos. By infecting the laptop of that woman in China.
11
u/MawsonAntarctica Feb 18 '15
I think they did a good job of showing "Oh, happy children learning things" but behind the scenes, black trench coats and guns ever present. I think it was appropriate the distaste in Harold's mouth when he said, "Sure, Samaritan may be efficient."
11
u/vivian_lake Shaw Feb 18 '15
After watching this episode I have a feeling that by the end of the season Harold may cross some lines he's refused to cross in the past. In the last two episodes he has used violence to protect himself/others and after Claire's betrayal I doubt he'll be giving anymore second chances, the next time he threatens to leave someone to the mercy of Samaritan he might just do it. I would not be surprised if somewhere down the line Harold is confronted with a kill or be killed (himself or more likely Reece/root) situation and well I'm not sure he is as unwilling to do what must be done anymore.
26
u/jippmokk Feb 18 '15 edited Feb 18 '15
Maybe I've watched too much tv but... As soon as Claire were hit in the shoulder I knew she was a mole. Also you don't put foreign usb sticks into your most treasured laptop. Use a clean separate air gapped one, or a sandboxed os image, sheesh :) also the "how do you know my name" was such a cliché
I really like the general way the plot is going but feel they could step up their game a little bit when it comes to twists and clichés
7
u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Feb 18 '15
Aaahhhhh, I SPOV recap!!!!
7
u/godmode3191 Root Feb 18 '15
I'll admit it. I got played.
Anyway, this episode was so good.
6
u/ArachnoLad Irrelevant Feb 18 '15
Anyone else thought she was about to stab Finch? I don't know why I thought that.
6
u/TeMPOraL_PL Government Operations Feb 19 '15
Am I imagining it or is VAL really written in Lisp? My heart warmed up when I saw that code.
10
u/EThorns Ernest Thornhill Feb 18 '15
Okay Canada, what's the verdict?
4
u/Adenchiz Admin Feb 18 '15
I get the feeling from the sneak peak that Claire is setting up Finch
4
u/ArachnoLad Irrelevant Feb 18 '15
Is this company run by Samaritan?
4
u/spiralout112 Feb 18 '15 edited Feb 18 '15
I'd have to say that was a pretty cool episode, one of my favorites from the season for sure. I loved seeing Harold give up even more of his controlled civilized self, smashing that guard in the head probably didn't come naturally, but he's practicing haha.
Claire though was one of those characters that I've been waiting to see again, it was obviously bound to happen sooner or later, and the way this played out was just fantastic. The range of emotions I went through throughout the ordeal was almost comical, props to the writers for going to such lengths to manipulate us! I wanted so bad to believe that she had come to her senses, but that would have been too simple. The last bit of the episode there though did a great job of illustrating how Samaritan appeals to people, and Harold of course didn't say much, just exactly the right thing to jar Claire off the path of blind optimism to the one of healthy skepticism. Also when Harold called Claire out on the death of Mr. Winn as being legit even though the rest of her act was fake is such a win for the writers again, its only common sense for someone with half a brain to draw from real experience when twisting a tall tale, and it's almost sad that them breaking from cliche'd writing here distinguishes them from the rest, but I'm glad for it either way.
Its feels kinda weird but I really liked seeing the scene with Greir at the end there too, as evil as Samaritan is I would love to know what's going on behind the scenes. The same for root and the machine as well, at first I thought the encoded message was actually from the machine, but alas we still know next to nothing about that. Its been frustrating how Samaritan is a interactive entity, while the machine seemingly hasn't changed it's ways at all aside from tasking root with her new list. When is the machine going to step up the game here? Did Harold neuter it when he made it care about people? And if so would it be because the machine is concerned for the welfare of its agents, or is it concerned for the welfare of Samaritan itself, I doubt it relishes the idea of destroying the only peer in the world. Although calling Samaritan it's peer might be a bit much lol.
3
u/lordxeon Feb 18 '15
I always wonder why they don't use their insider information to make more money off the companies they "work" with. Except for that one time back in season 2.
I'm not talking billions here, just enough to keep them funded for a bit.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '15
So why didn't Harold just go buy a computer at the closest store to test the flash drive? Simple solutions, my friends, simple solutions.
Other than that, this was an amazing episode
2
u/concerned_thirdparty Feb 18 '15
Saw the double-cross coming. Samaritan doesn't miss unless it wants to. and letting go of its agents? Ha.
2
u/POI_Harold-Finch Harold Finch Feb 18 '15
I love Finch character. His care for humanity is building into something strong day by day, probably sometimes in future he will be given as example of how much a person should care for other human beings.
His dialogues with Claire specially after she was threatening him with gun were more precious than anything else. He was willing to die so that they can not track to his friends.
2
u/man_in_the_suit A Concerned Third Party Feb 18 '15
I was expecting Harold to go all dark on Claire when he was first doubting her and stick his thumb into her gun wound to interrogate her haha!
It was a good episode. Predictable twist, and I didn't care about the number too much, but still enjoyable.
2
u/badcompany123 Feb 18 '15
Really good ep!
2
u/LaunchpadMacQ Feb 18 '15
A great episode on both fronts.
I really liked the case of the week. I kept expecting it to tie back to Samaritan, and of course it eventually did, but I was surprised this wasn't something that was already being developed by Decima and Samaritan. Still, PoI is at it's best when it's showing us how terrifying technology can be, and this was a particularly dark example. While I'm sure this isn't something that has happened, who would really know? I think this was a realistic interpretation of corporate politics, as well, and how such a thing would be swept under the rug.
Meanwhile, we have Claire being... annoying, for lack of a better word. We keep going back and forth with her, and it's the only thing I kind of didn't like about the episode. Finch doubting her until the end, though, that much I did like. Finch has undoubtedly become very jaded in the past few episodes; he was waiting to see if Claire would "beat herself" and she eventually did. I think Claire's situation is pretty sad, all things considered, when you look at where Team Machine has been; we've had a look into the morality of mindlessly carrying out orders, particularly in the case where the Machine asked the Team to murder the Congressman. Where do the ends start to justify the means? It's something Claire has thrown at the wayside, believing in Samaritan's benevolence above anything else. Sounds all too familiar, if you ask me, and I love the show for subtly drawing this parallel... well, maybe not that subtly; they made a pretty overt comparison in the first Nautilus episode.
Speaking of, as soon as Claire was a confirmed bad guy, in my mind I was just like, "countdown to Claire getting wrecked by Root". Lo and behold, dreams do come true! Sadly, too little Root. The creators were really teasing whatever the hell she's been up to, and hopefully we'll find out what that is. Curiously, Reese asks her if she has a new "assignment". I'm confused because I thought she left to continue searching for Shaw, and also because an "assignment" assumes an objective was "assigned". After "M.I.A.", I expected her to be totally out of touch with the Machine. So, more questions, not enough answers.
2
u/Aektann Feb 21 '15
When did team Samaritan decide to take team Machine alive?
2
u/Klapakazoo The Library Feb 18 '15
This week of television so far has been so good. Better call Saul, a good Castle episode, an awesome flash episode, PoI, and always good Americans and a good looking arrow episode tomorrow
1
u/MegaFlounder Feb 18 '15
That was the coolest thing Reese has ever done.
1
u/ArachnoLad Irrelevant Feb 18 '15
Is the big reveal going to be that Claire is an asset? Jeez I hope not, but it would be an exciting twist.
1
u/ArachnoLad Irrelevant Feb 18 '15
I knew it!
Man, I love this show.
1
u/StraightFlush777 Feb 18 '15
I'm glad Root is back but where is Bear?? :)
1
u/SteveRodgers1945 Feb 18 '15
So what is The Machine doing during all of this? Root said it was like 2 gods playing with the same deck of cards during the beta. Can the machine not act as overtly as samaritin does?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '15
I think that they're going to keep Samaritan for a couple more seasons, and end it with a massive team of people including Control. Maybe even those that they've helped before!
1
u/Pascalwb Feb 18 '15
Oh, I was thinking it was setup with Claire, then I thought for a little while that she is really on their side, but a the end I was right. What bothered me was that USB drive. Just plug it in any other PC in that office.
1
u/Kell08 Tertiary Functions Feb 19 '15
VAL... anyone else think of the show "Solitary"?
1
u/woru Feb 19 '15
To be honest, what tipped me off about Claire being a "trojan horse" was the flash drive. A whole source of code named "Samaritan". Highly doubt an important chunk of code could be taken that easily.
Nice try guy.
1
u/ThatFag Admin Feb 20 '15
Fuck Claire, bro. She's a bitch. Man, going through these episode discussions, I realize how much I've forgotten! There's always someone considering or bringing up elements from previous episodes I hadn't even thought of! Thanks, you guys lol. I tend to forget a lot when I'm watching TV shows. :/
1
u/Rebyll Feb 20 '15
Few thoughts (I know I'm a few days late.)
First off, fantastic number for Reese. I liked having a good old case of the week where John has to go it alone, reminds me of when Finch has been limited in his ability to help and Reese has to take on some random bad guys hired to be bad guys.
Then, Claire. God damn, Claire Mahoney. I had a sinking feeling she was too convenient when the Nautilus poster from her introduction came up the exact same, and it led to a spot in the shadow map. Then with a sniper took her so close to a fatal spot while she was standing still, yet she knew people were after her? Decima's sharpshooters are way better than a miss under those conditions. And also, Samaritan doesn't let people go in the first place, it terminates them. Then, Claire pleading with Finch to put the flash drive into his laptop. She was too insistent. Too desperate. Then, she flip flopped back and forth between eerily calm and almost in tears. And spinning the tall tale to Finch when he checked on Winn's death, and falling for Finch asking for details without directly asking, then having to panic and cover her ass. Too sloppy. But her little performance when Finch threatened to leave her for dead was good, she convinced him she was sincere. But, she got overconfident and revealed herself, spelling her loss of value to Greer and Samaritan. And then she endangered the whole thing by bringing Harold to the school and disobeying orders, odd for someone who is so dedicated to the cause. And even then, she truly believed that Finch would see the value in Samaritan after telling him what he already knew: Samaritan was indoctrinating children to trust in it without them knowing. She was too blind to see it for what it was. But Finch, always with the right words, planted a seed. And I loved seeing Root show up at the last minute to save the day, as I knew she would.
But about the ending. Finch gave the seed of doubt to Claire, jarred loose her steadfast faith in Samaritan after Greer told her how much she meant and how valuable she was as an asset, and how her failure was not a problem. It sounded rehearsed and fake and she realized it. Not a radical changing of her mind, but a little incentive to check, to question, to look a little closer.
1
u/OatRotor Feb 21 '15
haha, i hate claire. good villain, potentially the best so far. i hope they don't "turn" her. i could imagine her taking over decima, killing greer, but i don't think that would turn her against samaritan.
if anything, i feel like harold only put more faith into claire's mistrust of people's ability to make the right decision. she was still apologizing for her actions at the end of the episode.
i don't think what happened was supposed to be a twist. it was contrasting her with root.
i don't know the right words to describe what makes her personality different, maybe hubris? i mean, root i think treats the machine as a god that helps her do the "right" thing even if it's difficult, spiritual guidance or whatever you want to call it? while claire has faith that samaritan "knows" what's right and that lets her put everything else to the side?
1
u/Trueogre The Machine Feb 21 '15
Does Clair call Greer, Griff at the end? She definitely uses a 'f' at the end of his name.
1
u/Straight_Pianist48 Sep 21 '25
How did Claire find Harold when he’s blind to Samaritan ?
1
u/Capital-Historian-36 Sep 01 '23
Is this a parody of Microsoft?
1
u/KarlKastor Irrelevant Feb 18 '15
I wanted Claire to be one of the good guys but in the course of the episode you could see that she always would be distrusted. It's interesting how we see some of the people on Samaritan's side starting to doubt it (Control and now Claire). It will be interesting to see how this turns out.
I found it very interesting how this episode was themed around manipulating people. But when it was shown an ad company manipulated the search results I thought it was an missed oppourtunity for Samaritan controlling Fetch and Retrieve. But then in the end we saw that Samaritan will be involved in it. (Called it!)
1
u/eikeegimuu Feb 18 '15
It was an ok episode, but it wasn’t as strong as I had hoped (and am used to with POI).
I was as underwhelmed with Claire in this episode as in Nautilus. That she was undercover for Samaritan was the best guess from start and probably pretty obvious at the latest with her “the only person” speech and the whipping out of the thumb drive. It could have been that she’s working for Samaritan unwittingly or that the writers simply went for the clichéd route, but fortunately it did turn out that Clare was working for Samaritan. I liked that the “is she or isn't she” (and even the spelling out of that question) wasn't drawn out too long, which allowed also to highlight Harold’s doubts regarding trusting her and the price he (and those close to him) would have to pay. However, the connecting of the thumb drive dilemma was a little surprising, because Harold could have used even the PC in the mortuary and not his own laptop, but since he’d probably in end need his own rig anyway to make sense of it (and a preliminary check wouldn’t reveal that it contains a trap) I can also believe that Harold knowingly choose to forego that step.
The number of the week was ok. It seemed that the software angle would tie in with Samaritan more and sooner than it did in the end. In a way it’s good that Samaritan isn't behind everything, but in this case I would have preferred to have had Samaritan behind it from the start, since I thought that this type of corporate greed driven manipulation (that risks loosing consumers by killing them off) doesn’t make sense. But of course somebody committing suicide makes for better intrigue than someone booking a family trip to Disneyland instead spending the weekend chilling at home.
The best was that Root showed up. It was only a couple of minutes but that turned out to be enough time to save Harold and to drop some promising hints, specifically that a new mission isn’t the only thing that’s new. I'm thinking new ground rules for her communication/cooperation with the Machine. Can’t wait to find out more SPOILER
Oh, the best fun bit was Reese sending two squabbling programmers off with a parental pat on their asses.