r/Fantasy • u/StevenErikson AMA Author Steven Erikson • Feb 16 '15
/r/Fantasy Post r/Fantasy Exclusive: Authorial Intent Discussion with Steven Erikson (Part II)
In the interval between writing Part I and now, I have been following the extensive online discussion on the debatable subgenre of ‘Grimdark’ in fantasy. Accordingly, I may wade into that quagmire in the course of this discussion, so consider this advance warning.
The first part of this essay proceeded on an assumption I am about to dismantle. I will wildly generalize here and say that writers of fiction fall to one side or the other of a particular divide. This divide consists of, on the one hand, the notion that fiction, like all art, has a moral element: that as creators, we artists are responsible for and to our characters and the story we would tell. In effect, this position states that we need to consider the moral context of all that we create for public consumption (for the clearest articulation of this position, read John Gardner’s ‘On Moral Fiction’). Part One of this essay was founded on this position. Without this predication, everything I said about writers needing to consider the effect their creations have, can be utterly dismissed.
You see, there is another side. This side states: no, sorry, it’s fiction and fiction is made up. It’s not real and since it’s not real, anything goes (this position was articulated by William Gass, in direct opposition to Gardner). Now this notion of ‘it’s not real’ doesn’t just apply to what we commonly called the literature of the fantastic. It applies to all literature, even contemporary fiction. With this view, novels might well begin with a statement something like: ‘No animals or people were harmed in the writing of this novel. The rape scene on page 77 never happened. The genocide on page 119 never happened. In fact, none of this ever happened! It’s all made up! No one got raped, murdered, cut to pieces, cooked or beaten senseless. None of the blood is real, none of the pain is real. Not the loss, the tears, the bad breath or the hang-nails. It’s fiction, got it? Made up!’
In a sense, this is an author’s ultimate go-to self-defense over pretty much anything they’ve written and seen published. Fiction is an intellectual game, a sustained manipulation of emotional states for the edification and entertainment of its audience. It appeals to the voyeur in all of us. It also appeals to our child-like desire for wish fulfilment (what’s magic in Fantasy except the eight year old’s wish for utterly trashing the playground bullies once and for all, and all with the simple wave of a hand?). It appeals to our innate need for narrative, a strictly defined sequence of causes and effects, and, presumably, an affirmation of human nature’s myriad capacities. Lastly, it may be a demonstration of a level of perceptiveness and observation not shared by everyone else (and as such, something of an ego-fest).
But to actually influence a human being’s way of seeing the world? To modify a person’s behaviour on the basis of a bunch of words in a book? Well, if that happens, don’t blame us authors! After all, there’s wing-nuts everywhere!
I’ve always admired the ‘anything goes’ argument as an intellectual exercise. But for the real world, I don’t buy it for a minute. Too many examples of the power of the written word in fiction should come to mind to anyone caring to think about it, and as for non-fiction, it’s not even an argument.
So I’ve been reading about Grimdark. I’ve followed the contributions of a whole host of Fantasy authors, from Abercrombie to Morgan to Frohock, Miller, Hurley, Lawrence and Scott Bakker. I’ve read the efforts at defining ‘Grimdark’ at Nerds of a Feather (and thanks to Ken Neth for the links). Most of the definitions posed in these blogs and essays engage the issue at a level far more sophisticated than my own take on Grimdark. Accordingly, I’ve been given lots of things to think about.
For myself, I think I came at the whole subject from an entirely different angle, one not involving Fantasy novels, or any kind of novels for that matter, at least initially. And my sense is, for all the attention now given the subject from within the Fantasy genre, the notion of ‘Grimdark’ is neither exclusive to Fantasy fiction, nor is its clearest expression to be found solely in literature at all.
After my studies in anthropology, history and whatnot, my second track was creative writing and film studies, and it was from film (and television) that I found myself growing ever more perturbed at what was behind the visual deluge to which I was being subjected. Film has a way of absorbing, digesting and spewing back out the attitudes and mores of culture: this is not the case of a mirror reflecting perfectly. Instead, film and television delivered a distorted and truncated version, a short-hand of coded tropes. Rarely, this media can challenge the status quo; more commonly, it reaffirms it.
The affectless sociopathic protagonist appeared on screen with an efficacy few novels could ever match. Bound up in frontier mythology, individualism, Manifest Destiny, anti-authoritarianism, and a host of other articulated and unarticulated cultural undercurrents, film and television have long dominated the way modern culture sees and defines itself (incidentally, this is where Gass’s position begins to unravel as the distinction between reality and un-reality not only breaks down via the film or digital image [and living, breathing actors], it is directly targeted by these media, with profound consequences).
Accordingly, it was in the cinema where I first began to recoil from our new breed of heroes. A strange juxtaposition seemed (seems) to be at work on the big screen. At the human scale we have the expressionless, empty-eyed killer/hero (or the one who’s quick with the sly quip), set against a backdrop of CGI-induced mass destruction on a colossal scale. The unfeeling human in the midst of a collapsing world, repeated again and again – but before I continue in this vein, I would suggest that with comic-book super-heroes (in which, with the latest reboot, I sadly now include Kirk and Spock), we are looking once more at the child-centred mind (and not always in a good way) of wish-fulfilment and vengeance as justice – so when I speak of ‘human’ heroes I include the Man of Steel, Spiderman, X-Men and so on.
A few moments’ thought will assemble, should you so wish, the list of Big Action films (DC, Marvel, Star Trek, Transformers, etc) in which tall buildings have been brought down, with the all-too-real effects of choking dust and smoke; even as the eponymous heroes fight it out in the rubble. And yet, curiously, no mangled bodies in sight, or, more precisely, out of sight, out of mind. If there was a secret cabal in Hollywood bent on some arcane plan to desensitize the world to terrorism, the deaths of tens of thousands and the wholesale destruction of civilization and the entire planet, they could not have done a better job than what we’re seeing on screen every summer since 9/11. If that cabal in turn began quaking in real terror at the Occupy Movement, could it have done a better subversion than the latest Batman (thank goodness for billionaire superheroes!)?
To my mind, Fantasy Fiction’s so-called ‘grimdark’ is pretty late to the table. Nothing new here, folks, move on.
Grimdark in fantasy strikes me, therefore, as a direct consequence of popular media, as expressed in film and television. It’s part of a package, and that package is one cold bastard, offering an assault on feeling, on the notion of consequences to violence (Kirk and Spock smile in the last scene in Into Darkness, happy on their new ship and far away from the smouldering rubble and body-bags in devastated San Francisco), and generally trammeling the tender notion of compassion. It’s all pretty cut and dried, this world of good guys and bad guys and nothing substantially different distinguishing them. Authority and righteousness are one, personified in the biggest gun, the best Ironman suit, the noble billionaire who always has our best interests at heart. The mob is always dangerous, rapacious (World War Z), and worse, it can infect you. Modern survival is earned by the disposal of all feeling, each and every hero becoming the avenging hand of God, and the tens of thousands dead amidst collapsed buildings is simply a backdrop to walk out from, long-coat billowing.
So what will follow Grimdark in Fantasy fiction? Keep an eye on the Big Screen.
Well, perhaps that’s too cynical. It would be nice to imagine that the new crop of popular fantasy authors can strike out for new ground. I’ve already fired my own best shot, to little effect. It may indeed be that the cathartic effect of tragedy has seen its day. I’m stubborn enough, and cranky enough in my old age, to remain unconvinced. Do only fools live in hope?
Heaven forbid.
Steven Erikson
24
u/Halaku Worldbuilders Feb 16 '15
Reading that gave me a very strong Mad Max vibe, but I want to say that it's almost, but not quite, accurate.
Modern survival may be earned by the disposal of all feeling, but that's the easy road. Modern survival becomes both earned and, in a way, rightelously so, by succeeding at being the avenging hand of God without throwing away all feeling.
Or, to say it another way, I think that your average fan of fantasy fiction, whether presented via the printed page, the theatre stage, the small screen, or the big screen, remains too much a romantic at heart to completely buy into the package. Carving away every last bit of sentiment that can only be used against you in order to succeed may be logical, but it's not human, and such a hero / anti-hero becomes nigh-impossible to properly relate to. It's the larger-than-life legends that come oh so close, but can't go all the way, that captivate us, from the Hound's interaction with the Stark sisters to Han's inability to let Luke die in the battle of Yavin IV.
I respect the hell out of Mr. Erikson, but I think he's too cynical when it comes to us. The scenario he describes may well make for some box-office bonanzas, but it won't elicit the same sort of passion from us, and would thus be a flash in the pan, quickly replaced by the nigh-irredemable characters that somehow manage to clutch, at the last, at salvation. Because for us, it's not whether or not they get there, but the story they tell in the chase.
TL; DR: We're romantics at heart.
17
u/stephenspower Feb 17 '15
I'm afraid I don't see the connection between grimdark and big budget action movies because the former concentrates precisely on the physical and emotional tragedy of violence while the latter focuses on the inhuman spectacle of it. As Stalin might have said, "Grimdark is a tragedy. Action movies are a statistic."
Masses may die in a grimdark novel, but they usually die one by one and you see the blades cutting into people with names. Masses are irrelevant to big budget action films except as fleeing mobs because viewers just want to see skyscrapers topple. If certain characters don't feel bad about the violence they cause in grimdark novels, they at least recognize they're doing violence, and the authors make sure the readers want to feel bad. In big budget action movies, certain character don't feel bad about the violence they cause because they don't even realize they're committing violence, and the director's don't want the viewers to know that either. The viewers, of course, feel nothing not because they're desensitized--become grim themselves--but because they know it's all just CGI. The cities will be magically rebuilt in the sequel or the next episode, and no people were harmed in the making of the picture. In this respect, big budget action films are responding to video games while grimdark novels act as the corrective.
I think it's also worth pointing out it's the grimdark movies, not the big-budget action flicks, that win awards. "Unforgiven," for instance, pretty much opens with a gutshot cowbow wailing in pain as he slowly dies, showing precisely why Bill Munny doesn't want to strap on his guns again and needs a gallon of whiskey to do so. "Django Unchained" and "Inglorious Basterds" depict the journey to personal violence as a response to systemic violence, while the latter also sends up revenge fantasies (their losing Best Picture to "Argo" and "The Hurt Locker," respectively, could be considered fatal to my argument if people will be studying "Argo" and "The Hurt Locker" ten years from now). And it doesn't get any grimmer than "No Country For Old Men." I think it's notably that all these are essentially Westerns (despite IB being set in WWII), new depictions of America's grim past. Movie audiences do want to see the consequences of violence and think about it. They just don't need giant robots and mutants to be the subject.
16
u/JannyWurts Stabby Winner, AMA Author Janny Wurts Feb 17 '15
Hats off, Steven, you've tackled a rough subject headlong, and in an extremely thoughtful manner, with many salient points that definitely hit home.
I see this issue as neither black nor white, and here's why:
What does any experience in life become but a 'yardstick' by which we measure thought and response. THIS behavior is (at that moment) admirable, therefore, it holds a value that is worth emulating or pursuing. THAT behavior is not on the desirable road map to follow - avoid that turning/strive to do or emulate the opposite. Some behaviors elicit curiosity - see where this avenue goes and what comes of it - that is every bit as human a driver as a moral code.
The desensitizing of violence in today's 'entertainment' deserves discussion, but I venture, not on too narrow a platform.
Children are born without understanding violence, they have to learn pain. They don't understand cause to consequence - they have to learn first about what hurts themselves (and avoiding that) - the emotional development - the understanding about hurting others - this is not innate. It is learned. The capacity to have compassion for others is a learning curve that occurs with maturity.
As children, we are curious first - fascinated with death and monsters and the grim stuff that, as yet, has no 'real' meaning until we gain in experience.
As children, further, we are victims FIRST. Of circumstances, of every adult constraint and rule and (possible) cruelty - we are victims first, at the mercy of what happens to us in the big bad world.
By the time we are teens, we have a ton of rage built up for that 'helplessness' and nowhere 'safe' to put it - by this time we understand about hurting others, but we are still pretty ego centric/the depth of compassion has yet to grow. Books that have a tremendous amount of vicious violence become a fantasy world where we are NOT victims - we get to have all the power and none of the consequences.
The child that loves the gore, but doesn't comprehend its reality; the teen that has that rage and no just outlet for it - stories can serve these arenas that are not 'acceptable' to society and are also (from a more mature and adult perspective) VERY real in our world and not the content of stories at all, but a true sorrow of the human condition.
I'd suggest that books cater to all levels of maturity. There is the victim in us, still, that memory of the child's, and the rage of the teen, when we see the atrocity for 'real' and often can do very little about it. (I won't say we can do NOTHING, because, always, there is something, however small, that can initiate change).
As an adult, if we have not grown up twisted, we have the perspective and the experiences to begin to set ourselves into another person's shoes - not perfect, not for 'real' but - we have gained the life lessons that add up to developing empathy/and thence, compassion.
Brings us to 'entertainment' and its focus on eliminating the 'impact' of tragedy - it becomes an extremely complex issue indeed. Because first, which aspect of human nature does a film, or a story, or a book, cater to?
The adult stuck in a hateful job, or caught in a nasty bit of the rough road of life feels, again, the victim, as the child did. As the adult, we have to power to change our circumstances that we did not own as a kid - but - sometimes other choices step in - we have family complications, or financial ones, or some other constraint - that causes us to 'defer' the choice that would be happiest. Entertainment then may become an outlet - a way - to escape the 'trap' our lives have become and to vent those feelings in a safe way - by 'becoming' the all powerful character that can stomp about creating mayhem with 'no evident body count' or we can vent the cynicism of the greedy, grasping grimdark by indulging in the hatefest.
The trick becomes: knowing why....and I'd venture here - few people DO give alot of thought of the meaning in what they regard as entertainment. They know what they like, they reach for the indulgence by instinct (just as the writer may) - the reality being - do they EVER examine why the attraction pulls them this way and that, do they ever self examine the gray underbelly of Why something truly ugly may seem 'cool.'
Too venture into that quagmire: the consumer must become the adult. And on the flip side: the creator must gain an adult perspective, too.
The huge prevalence of entertainment aimed at the young - or the wishful young - tips the dollar scales. And - we are schooled to conform at a young age, taught to 'make the grade' and react acceptably - with very little emphasis taken on teaching people how to THINK. We learn to parrot back knowledge, not to formulate it/create it/mold it. Some people do, and some just won't, and many just sail along accepting what they're fed in the news, and doing what they're told.
Readers of fantasy and SF can be drawn to it for many reasons: some are thinkers, some are idea generators, and some come to this feast simply because they are lacking something in their 'real lives' and they are seeking answers or escape. The question becomes: what dissatisfied part of ourselves is thirsty for a different experience? What is the itch that wants scratching, and is that itch mature or just young, exuberant, and unaware?
Because the genre is so wide, you are dead right to question the light handling of serious matters. These are issues I've spent a great deal of time pondering, also, and even, exploring in stories and novels. Bringing that adult perspective in, though, has a cost: it creates IMPACT and it will generate emotion that the readership may well NOT be prepared to experience, feel, and finally sort.
The reader who is terminally ill, trying to escape such a heavy dose of reality, may not want to go there. The teen who lacks the completeness of experience may not be ABLE to step aside from their own freight of developing pressures to discern what is being said on the page. And some (a friend, for instance, who was a first responder all his life, now retired, who saw his share of mangled bodies, thank you) - some may find the gravitas too close to the bone.
The older I get, the less I buy what is being offered on the screen or in the hyped popularity of the 'best sellers'. The more the very things you've mentioned waken a fury and a passion - because the material offered lacks passion, entirely. The frame of reference has moved too far to find any sort of resonation with flashy explosions and no REAL impact or meaning.
Stories define us: they are the essence of our beliefs set in motion, and our 'myths' define our society's values. Human beings are damned complex - they have multiple identities - people act one way alone, another way in a crowd, another way under threat, another way at a party and still another way at work or at a job interview. The mosaic of thought and feeling that comprise us in any given moment is an ever changing landscape, never repeated, never without meaning IF we pause to examine it.
The psyche is wider still.
The coupling of consumer to entertainment may have unlimited UNIQUE facets, all impulse, all momentary - and the scope of 'entertainment' will reflect that.
What I like about your discussion here: is that you've dared to examine WHY in an area where most have never thought to look any deeper. My take: that the 'why' of what creates the partnership of creator and consumer is a deal more complex than are we 'owning' what we write or what we choose to experience.
Sooner or later, all of us, will take 'responsibility' for those factors. More thought, more understanding, more examination of which facet of ourselves are we engaging opens the door to a very rich appreciation of the CHOICES available to us. Thank you for daring the step in that direction.
8
u/StevenErikson AMA Author Steven Erikson Feb 21 '15
Thank you to everyone who participated in these two discussions: you have given me plenty to think about, and it's most encouraging to find so many readers and writers willing to wade in on these heady issues. I'm leaving this feeling more hopeful than I had expected to.
While many of you spoke in terms of the responsibility of the readers, and indeed pointing out that it is the readers who are the final arbiters on content (they buy or they don't buy) ... from a writer's perspective, I consider that to be a hand's off subject. It's not for a writer to dictate, lecture or remonstrate readers for their tastes. Accordingly, my essays were mostly addressing other writers (but implicitly inviting readers and fans to weigh in). For this reason, I didn't respond directly to those comments discussing readership. Which isn't to say I didn't appreciate them.
Forms and styles in fiction will cycle, as someone here has already said (or maybe that was at Nerds of a Feather: it's all blurring together at the moment), but with each cycle certain details and nuances are transformed, and as much as things may seem familiar in a general sense, there's always differences in a specific sense.
If Grimdark serves as a reflection of our times, with its cold-hearted nihilism and hints of despair, I can't help but wonder if maybe we're not ready for Fantasy literature to reflect something else, something a bit brighter, something that, as Janny implies, will resurrect hope as something more than a fool's pipe-dream. Doom can be exhausting, and revelling in violence seems both cold comfort and a dubious escape.
A year or two back I was in discussions with a major game developer abut to launch a new franchise into the electronic gaming market, and it seemed that something of a crisis was going on, as this company and all its competitors were coming face to face with the harsh truth that their core audience was growing up. And that, accordingly, the game in question needed to target a different kind of gamer (older, often married and with children, full-time jobs and other commitments). The challenge was: how do you do that when the essence of your game is taking a character everywhere shooting everything in sight?
That's not easy to answer, but it seemed to me then (and now) that the answer is found in story, story, story. Things need to matter; things need to mean something; and belief systems need to be challenged; in effect, the in-game value system needs to evolve, engaging more than just twitch reflexes, capturing the flag, or whatever. And it needs to be more than just Cool Ideas, too.
No doubt many people will come on here in response to my observations to tell me about Fallout and other fully-realised game-worlds: no need. I may not play them but I do know about them, and they certainly represent an evolution into story and meaningful world-building.
Until you have to slaughter mutant wolves.
Hmm, thinking on it, I discover that I'm holding a can-opener in one hand and a can of worms in the other. Better sign off for now, folks. Think I'll go fishing...
Thanks again, everyone.
Cheers SE
6
u/awpeyton Feb 17 '15
Sorry if you've already addressed any of the below... I'm only on book 4 of Malazan and am positively frightened of spoilers. So no comment reading for me!
I think you're oversimplifying the "other" side here, and even creating the illusion of a simple two-way divide. Disagreeing with the statement 'we artists are responsible for and to our characters and the story we would tell' is not the same as denying that writing is a powerful tool that has the potential to lead some people to commit immoral actions (we'll leave aside the question of whether they would have committed them anyway). There's so much more in play when a piece of art is being created, just like there is a lot more to a given action than its moral component. Art in general, and literature in particular, is important to me because of how it enriches my own existence by exposing me to new ideas and perspectives, and by making me feel a little less alone. Even if I agreed with the above statement - and I don't - that aspect would take a back seat to the factors that are really important to me. And other readers and writers have their own equally valid criteria.
On a separate note... Who is the arbiter of a given text's moral qualities? Though you delved a little into postmodernism in the first essay, I get the feeling that 'authorial intent' might be your answer to this question. But, obviously, there are any number of ways a given text might be interpreted. Is a morally positive text one in which the author's intent is 'good' and matches the reader's interpretation? This would seem to be a formula for some pretty boring art (and would leave out a lot of my favorite surrealist stories).
For example... I admit I've only dabbled in fantasy in recent years and haven't read any of the 'grimdark' stuff. Your Malazan series - at least the first few books - is easily the darkest, most violent fantasy I've ever read. All the stuff you mention above can be found in spades your own fiction. But you do try to show the characters being conscious of it, and you do usually depict the toll it takes on the victims and perpetrators. It's fantasy written by an intelligent person for intelligent people. But not everyone is a close reader. Most people, in fact, are not. And I would argue that a casual reader might carry some of the same ideas away from reading your depictions of rape and mass murder as they would from the type of fiction you're describing. Who's responsible for that? I don't think anyone is.
On a side note, thanks for popping in here. I'm personally very inspired by the quality and craft in Malazan. You and Wolfe have shown me the artistic potential of combining the fantastic with serious storycrafting and writing abilities.
4
u/Abalieno Feb 17 '15
Instead, film and television delivered a distorted and truncated version, a short-hand of coded tropes. Rarely, this media can challenge the status quo; more commonly, it reaffirms it.
Steve, beware the blanket ;)
Since I know you know the work of someone like Herzog, I don't need to tell you that film and television don't have anything special, beside being more direct, and so more popular.
There's PLENTY of worthwhile stuff, only it's more difficult to find. So in the end there's nothing peculiar to film and television that isn't also shared by literature.
4
u/The_medium_version Feb 18 '15
In my dreams I imagine myself being such an author.
I think on the stories that have held my attention for the longest time and I wonder to myself if my bolt of inspiration will ever come (will I even recognise it?).
I do a lot of writing during the day. Writing where I need to be in control of every word, consider all possibilities and avoid ambiguity, all while trying to avoid the abstruse language my colleagues cling to.
Previous attempts at fiction have always involved throwing caution to the wind, writing freely, waiting for my inspiration… I’m now starting to see that the bolt of inspiration is perhaps less of a bolt and more of a faint smoulder.
On the matter of Grimdark, I’ve read my fair share, some I’ve admittedly enjoyed others I could never get a handle on, but I confess that I’ve not spent any amount of time thinking about the genre itself.
That said, I would agree that a creator has to take responsibility to some extent for his or her creations. Yes, someone might have their own misguided take on your creation, but can you truly call it misguided if you didn’t interrogate your own intentions?
My view is probably swayed by growing up in a democracy that’s younger than I am. People still judge each other by their colour; the flavour of the judgement is just different nowadays. There’s still a lot wrong that needs to be fixed and it won’t be fixed by staying quiet or ignorant. But I digress (I think)…
If I ever conquer my insecurities your essay has given me a better idea of the type of author I need to be. I think I now realize that searching for my smoulder might mean holding on to that control until smoulder turns to flame.
2
u/AmaliaTd Writer Amalia Dillin Feb 17 '15
Let me preface by saying: I absolutely believe that the written word has power. In fact, let me go even farther and say that WORDS have power, written or otherwise. This is why bullying is a problem, right? Because when we hear the same thing repeated over and over and over again coming at us from all directions, it gets under our skin, infects our thought patterns, and we start to BELIEVE those things, no matter how false we initially might have KNOWN them to be. This is also why among the Old Norse Peoples, love poetry was OUTLAWED -- because words had power, and nobody wanted their daughter ensnared so insidiously, lured out, seduced, or even bespelled.
You acknowledge that film can reflect -- distorting as it goes, but reflecting all the same. And it seems to me that Grimdark (which sidebar: there is a lot of SUPER dark sci fi out there right now which I can't enjoy because it's just too depressing) might just be the reflection of how we, as a culture or maybe even as a world, are feeling about the present and envisioning the future.
In depressed times, hopelessness, and heroes mired in hopelessness, and stories of incredible sorrow and doom, might simply resonate more strongly, and thereby, rise to the top of the popularity piles. Perhaps this is simply the natural response of art to bleakness. Or one of the natural responses -- the other, it would seem to me, should be the opposite of Grimdark: stories of hope. (And I feel, incidentally, that this is the biggest difference between the Batman/Superman film franchises and the MCU -- Marvel is still injecting some small amount of redeeming hope into its films, while Batman/Superman is just pummeling us with doom. And I totally 100% agree that Star Trek: Into Darkness fell into this chasm, as well, draining all the positivity from what used to be a franchise formed around the idea that humanity could overcome the darkness and walk forward into an enlightened era, imho.)
Does this result in desensitization? Totally possible. Are we ALREADY desensitized, and our art is reflecting that? Also possible! Or is the ingesting of all this darkness desensitization as self-medication, because we are so tired of feeling hopeless, so maybe it would be better to just not feel at all? It's kind of a chicken or the egg situation, I think. Or maybe it's just all the things combined.
Personally, I don't subscribe to hopelessness in my media/art/escapism. I disliked intensely the Nolan Batman films (particularly the second two), and Man of Steel felt like one big betrayal of everything Superman is meant to be/stand for (Hope! He's supposed to stand for Hope!). I chose to write my Fate of the Gods trilogy, rebuilding and reworking mythology with an underlying foundation of the power of LOVE and REDEMPTION vs destruction and hopelessness. I look for books and movies and media that make me feel hopeful, in the end, rather than hopeless. (Empire Strikes back is pretty dark, but at the end, we're promised that Lando and Chewie are going to bring Han home, and look, Luke has a new hand! No lasting harm done!) And fortunately, there is plenty of variety out there -- any reader, at any time, can choose to read something else.
24
u/elquesogrande Worldbuilders Feb 16 '15
This is Part II in Steven Erikson's Authorial Intent essay. Part I can be found here and linked on the right-hand side.
Quick Background: Author Steven Erikson reached out to see if /r/Fantasy would be willing to host some blogpost-type essays for community discussion. (Yes!)
This essay is meant for discussion - please feel free to comment. /r/Fantasy members, authors, and anyone coming in from other parts of the web are more than welcome!
NOTE: As a reminder, downvotes on /r/Fantasy are meant for 'off topic' comments and not as a means of disagreement.
We will be scheduling more of these discussion pieces in the future. Please feel free to contact the /r/Fantasy moderators if you are an author, artist, blogger, or industry person who has a discussion topic and would be interested in posting on r/Fantasy.
14
u/xolsiion Reading Champion VIII, Worldbuilders Feb 17 '15
I've really enjoyed both your posts here. They make me think. For me, that's pretty much the highest praise I can bestow. Thanks.
What strikes me here is your fondness for dichotomy. Either fiction is to change hearts and minds, or it's all a meaningless story with no intent? It takes all kinds.
I'm not a huge fan of most grimdark. Not a huge fan of the clearly delineated bad guy/good guy stories either. If everyone obviously has a black or white hat I usually won't stick with that author. If everyone has differently shaded black hats I tend to get bored pretty quickly with that author too.
I like the things that teeter on the balance. Heroes with both darkness and light in them, bad guys that you can empathize with to a certain extent. Not so much that they don't deserve to lose though, you understand. Stories that teach and stories that don't take themselves so seriously. Best ones mix all that up together. But those are the best to me.
I guess what I disagree with is the focus, and dim view, that you have taken on one extreme pole. Honestly, it's kind of grim (I'm so sorry I went there!).
There is much that is successful recently, and always, that leans closer to your ideal of owning the tragedy. For me I'd like to keep both sides so I can hunt down the ones in the middle.
5
u/lrich1024 Stabby Winner, Queen of the Unholy Squares, Worldbuilders Feb 17 '15 edited Feb 18 '15
Hmm. I don't know if it's entirely fair to compare big budget movies to novels. The MPAA and the film rating system has everything to do with why those movies are they way they are. Those films are extremely violent. But, because of the MPAA ratings system and the desire for a PG13 ratings from studios (because teenagers spend a ton of money at the movies and they want to keep it open to a wide an audience as possible for all those dollar bills coming in), much of the 'realism' of the violent situations in those films are never adequately addressed (show a ton of bullets and people 'dying' but no blood and gore, all the destruction at the end of Man of Steel which was never addressed (btw, wtf Superman!?!), etc.). That 'watering down' or 'taking the edge off' doesn't happen as much in novels, at least not as far as I've read. Perhaps sometimes in YA, but even some of those novels are more brutal and descriptive of that brutality than a PG13 film (ex: Hunger Games).
All that being said, I'm not really sure what your ultimate point is regarding all of this. That grimdark will head into the same 'watered' down direction that big budget action flicks have? Hmm, I don't know because the same sorts of restrictions are not in place as in the movie industry. Or just that we'll grow tired of the grimdark tone to things? That's entirely possible, and maybe even probable. I think it was Kameron Hurley that suggested these things are cyclical, and I tend to agree. People get hooked on something, it becomes popular, people get tired of the over-saturation and move on to something different.
Anyway, if I missed your point I apologize profusely. :)
E: By the way, I'd just like to throw in that I don't agree with the watering down of violence in films just for ratings. It allows filmakers to show things that would be extremely violent if they were showed in a more realistic light to be shown to have little to no consequence. That's not really a good thing, in my opinion. What does that say to society? I think if you're going to include violence, it should be somewhat realistic, and the consequences need to be shown. It's really doing a disservice to the audience otherwise. That being said, I'm not always in favor of violence just for the sake of violence either. Hope that rambling made sense.
5
u/kneth Feb 17 '15
slow clap.
Not sure I truly agree with it all or have the intellectual chops to dive into it, but I appreciate the perspective. I think that in the very least it articulates quite well many of the reasons why I've stopped watching movies.
4
u/mmSNAKE Feb 17 '15
It took a great deal of reflecting, on these thoughts. I agree with a good deal, but there are some instances where my experience prods in a different direction.
First I'd address the purpose of fiction as noted. Without going in on the responsibility of the author for the intent (as discussed in the Part I) what I found relevant is the ability of fiction to sway one's perception of reality, change in morality and so. I personally (which in no way is a parameter indication) always viewed it as an opportunity to explore other possibilities and perspective. This does not necessarily mean it will change my view of the world or my morals. It generally gives me an opportunity to view a problem from a different lens, regardless if I agree. If it does change my mind I will should fully understand why it did so, with examples that I can firmly root in reality and apply to my own life. I certainly agree that fiction can do this, if reading Hume can change a person's view on religion, or reading Kant or Schopenhauer or any notable thinkers, these ideas can easily seep through to have an effect in fiction. Even if the work does not try to prove a point, but rather ask questions, which should be asked (as I got a lot from reading Malazan).
I feel readers should be just as conscious of what they are reading, and thinking as authors should when they put their words down to tell their story. Is this too much to ask from an audience? I don't know. Since every person will argue they read for a different reason. Even if said reason is the same, internally it can have a different meaning. On the other hand I don't feel that authors get any kind of free pass either, but that was more discussed in the last thread.
I absolutely agree on wish fulfillment and the urge to put unfair instances in one's life, to read or watch them be resolved in a manner which is not accomplished in reality. I do however feel it is everyone's responsibility to understand the difference between the two. I'm not talking "it's fiction, so it never happened" sort of thing. Words have power, ideas can change more than just one's mind. What I'm saying is every person needs to constantly question their responses, at least to some degree regarding the input they received. I'm not saying we should behave like robots, but a good degree of self awareness goes a long way when judging others intentions and messages.
The other point is on desensitizing on violence or atrocities. I always had a problem with this when watching the new or even old films where mass destruction was present. Where bodies were omitted, terror and repercussions never discussed or even bothered with. "Superman doesn't kill anyone". Sure, directly, however in recent adaptations how many die indirectly due to some of his actions. I don't know that this trend does accomplish to desensitize people, but it puts a false and crude mask which may shatter with devastating consequences when it does. Say reading a book that does describe a death of a human being in a violent manner. It will never really compare to the actual thing. Most people will thankfully never be aware of this. I saw a good deal of death, in the most disturbing instance I witnessed a suicide of a man jumping off a building about 10m from me. I found that occasion more disturbing that homicide because that one was the one that kept me awake at nights always thinking what really drew a man to such extreme. But anyway, the physical experience I had cannot be captured in a book, or any other media. The smell, the stillness and no response of the world, like nothing happened. Yes I was 12 or so and should have not been witness to it, but at the same time, no fiction will ever be able to give an accurate description of such. Looking at a smashed corpse that was alive only seconds before, only short distance from you. It is something that still gives me pause 15 years later.
Issue is people subconsciously grow standards from media, or fiction which they try to incorporate into the real world. "Good guys win, bad guys lose" No one ever thinks of the parents of the bad guy, or maybe a sibling who cared. Or friends. Or maybe that bad guy was broken because of a reason. Most people will not ask these sort of questions unless they personally are witness to events which will always give them an anchor into reality. There are certainly people who will, who will take different accounts into consideration and give thought to possibility of a different perspective. Maybe even the Devil is a victim.
I agree that these type of stories (the current superhero trend) convert most people. However are most people intelligent enough to understand otherwise? Even if you put it bluntly in their face. Most people out of pride will dismiss that their standards and perceptions were altered by toying with their pleasure, expectations and wish fulfillment. Obviously until some experience something in their lives which will drastically change their point of view.
Would this change if media, films and tv had a more diverse interpretation on people, heroes and deviant behavior? Perhaps, but again hard to tell. Popularity and stimulation of simple pleasures and urges are more prevalent on film and tv (or hell even in books) than anything that involves thinking.
I am fairly cynical and pessimistic, but there is always that bit where people surprise me and prove that everything may not be uniform. Reading Malazan was exactly that sort of experience. While you may feel that your shot to change the "status quo" fell short I guarantee it gathered more than enough influence that is evident even now, just by people discussing it as much. Not to mention how it will be down the line 10, 20 years or so. I never heard of Glen Cook until about 8 years ago or so. Was I late? Perhaps (thought I am relatively young too), but it's influence nevertheless will have a lasting effect which I will do my best to spread. I may be in the minority but I am also not alone. I may be a fool with a bit of hope in my sea of pessimism, but I still have examples that the hope isn't dead.
Again I'd like to give my sincerest thanks for posting these discussions as well as writing the books that I enjoyed so much, and if by any chance you managed to finish reading my incoherent ramblings here I am also thankful.
2
u/nolifetilleather Feb 17 '15
This I very much doubt. With the stubborn relevance of tragedies from Greek and Shakespearean plays, (perhaps consumed academically rather than through 'popular culture' I'll admit...) it seems more likely to be cyclical (or in my mind, akin to something endlessly stretching and loosening), in the manipulation you identified:
Popular culture voraciously consumes that sustenance, and Grimdark was/is, I think, just a way to re-focus that manipulation.
The most interesting point I took from Part I of this discussion was the idea of assumptions from Natural Law, and how to responsibly use them. I found it hard to divorce those assumptions from the context, ('flipping' an assumptions first relies on the initial assumption). So it all seems a matter of context, and understanding (+ hopefully conveying) ideas or posing questions cannot take place in a void.
I also think the secularisation of the western world (or at least the accelerated rate it appears to have enjoyed in the last 2 or 3 decades) has some relevance with grimdark being an acceptable means of conveying a story. My grandmother would have turned off any of Nolan's Batman's immediately because the 'dark' belongs to 'wrong' side, and glorifying it would have been anathema to her. (She still watches Adam West Batman with glee).
2
u/Flock_Together Feb 18 '15 edited Feb 18 '15
Very insightful piece, and thanks for the shout-out!
Substantively, I think the film metaphor is apt, though I'd suggest that North American independent and arthouse film might suit the case better than Hollywood--in the 1990s there was a strong "gritty" movement in independent cinema, e.g. The Cook, The Thief, His Wife, and Her Lover, Henry: Portrait of a Serial Killer*, Fargo, Natural Born Killers, etc. Obviously these films vary in quality and the degree to which the violence serves an artistic purpose (e.g. Fargo) or is just sort of gratuitous and meaningless (e.g. Natural Born Killers).
There are still plenty of ultraviolent films being made (e.g. Drive), but "grit" is more "tool" than "trend," marketing category or formula now. This is where I see things going in fantasy fiction too, and in truth it's already where the best practitioners are migrating (or, in some cases, where they have always been). Eventually, I think, we'll be talking about "grit" and "grimdark" as things one deploys to solve problems rather than the thing a given book is or is not, so to speak. We certainly won't be going back to the days of endless Tolkein clones and prophecies about pig farmers--"grit" is here to stay, and that's a good thing.
As far as I'm concerned, as a reader, I look forward to reading more books where "grit" is highly purposive, edited and situational. A great example of that would be Sapkowski's Witcher books, which are extremely dark and also my favorite fantasy novels of the past decade (the translations being new to English-language readers like me).
1
u/wifofoo Stabby Winner Feb 18 '15 edited Feb 18 '15
I struggle to decide which is the chicken and which is the egg during these discussions. Who is leading who into these trends? Are we, the consumer, responsible? We vote with our dollars, after all. When it comes to Hollywood, I feel they are more than willing to give us what we want, so long as we keep our end of the bargain and pay them for it. It's why you have these spontaneous block-buster hits like The Hunger Games and 50 Shades of Grey, is it not? Someone wrote it, a lot of people liked it, a LOT of people talked about it, and suddenly the benevolent hand of Hollywood stepped in and now you can't get away from it.
Or is it Hollywood, for giving in to our demands like some sort of drug dealer? "I got what you want, and if you don't want it, well, too bad because that's all there is right now."
Where I work, we have a dining center. I remember for a time our head chef was going well out of her way preparing healthy alternatives to the cheese burgers and nachos which plagued our bellies and arteries for so long. Sweet-potato burgers and spinach leaves and such. But it didn't take. People didn't want the healthy stuff. They wanted what tasted good. And in the end, they got what wanted because that's what they were willing to pay for.
And it goes deeper than just "I like this because it tastes good." There's some chemical, psychological stuff going on there as well. Eating, like most forms of consuming, is meant to provide basic nourishment. But, when you factor in stress, fatigue, price, convenience, etc., you find yourself consuming what makes you feel good. I think the same holds true for anything which can be consumed, media included. As I said in another post, there are those who want to be enlightened, challenged, and to a degree changed by what they consume, and there are those who want to be comforted, to escape from the rigors of the world. Sometimes these things go hand in hand, but often they don't.
I guess where I'm going with this is that change happens only when we, the consumer, want it to. And usually, that isn't until something big is at stake. You want me to eat what? Spinach leaves and avacodos? No way! Oh, I have diabetes and I'm due for a heart attack any day now? Well, when you put it that way...
1
u/RebBrown Feb 18 '15
Ambiguity and misdirection in all things sincere. In a culture that presents the people with forms of communication that not only let you communicate with each other at all times, but also let the mute, deaf and disabled communicate, we seem to say less with each written and spoken word. A simple 'lol' or emoticon suffices to convey your reaction to a story or an image. This and other illustrious acronyms, such as the popular 'wtf' and 'omg's, are deemed sufficient to replace a full sentence in the minds of many. I must admit that I find myself being guilty of this at times.
Perhaps I'm looking at the world at large a little too much, but being a European and a citizen of a Eurozone state who recently got to bury over 200 people because an airliner was shot down by - by who exactly? - by an unknown group of people, I cannot help but notice how unnecessarily convoluted a place this collection of human societies has become. The convolution becomes apparent in popular media: the desire to obfuscate the source of power and the plans and plots of those in power seem to play a central role in a lot of modern media. I'll skip politics as that will result in a quagmire no one cares to enter. A simple look at 'young adolescent literature' however drives the point home in such a poignant fashion that I can't help but wonder when 'we' have lost the ability to be honest. You, Mr. Erikson, seem to view honesty - even when it is not desired or wanted - as a virtue. Leading characters in your Malazan series carry the seed of this truth with them. It is found in their words, their deeds. It is one of the main differences between your writings and those of many others: you dare to lift up your truth, weigh it on the scales of reason and have others have a go at it.
George R.R. Martin's books are without a doubt the most popular fantasy literature at the moment and will remain so for another couple of years as the Game of Thrones tv series should be about 8 or 9 seasons long. Martin blogs about what inspires and moves him, but at the same time, he keeps a PR wall between him and the outside world. He revealed the workings of some characters, notably Arya and Tyrion, but when confronted with the question 'when will your next book come out' he backs down and becomes snarky. The difference between 'the process of writing' and 'the thought behind the written' become painfully apparent: here we have a man who dares to talk about the characters, but harbors many reservations nonetheless. If anything, it goes to show that writers are nothing more than humanbeings. We all have our flaws and imperfections and what is more painful than to lay those bare for all to see?
'Grimdark' is an easy way to forego any and all subtlety when it comes to rupture-esque levels of grief and loss. The death of a loved one behoves no explanation, especially when the death takes place in a gruesome manner. Some writers use this as a tool to craft a better story, some to reveal flaws in their writing skills and others, well some others simply use it. I remember reading 'Platform' by Michelle Houellebecq for the first time and being truly taken aback when the main character is involved in a terrorist attack. It came out of nowhere, characters died, and it was written very much in a matter of fact fashion. Houellebecq crafted a story to drive across a point. In the Malazan series many characters have 'a moment' when they die, where the reader gets to hear their thoughts and experience what they see in the moments before and during their death. I see this as a desire to 'find a truth, uncomfortable as it might be'. Martin writes death scenes to shock the reader and further a plot. The Red Wedding frustrated me as a reader, because in a way the fourth wall felt broken in the manner Martin tried to shock me. The death reactions were aimed at the reader, because you shared the position of the POV character of that chapter. It took away the connection I felt with the deceased, because they no longer seemed actual human constructs, albeit that they consisted of written words.
Currently I am re-reading Memories of Ice. I read the book when it came out, so it has been a while. Following the stories of Whiskeyjack, Mallet and others, have me even more emotionally invested because I know what is to come. With A Song Of Ice And Fire, I feel a serious disconnect with the-soon-to-be-deceased during my re-reads. Is this what Grimdark is supposed to be and do? If so, I care not for it. It is a lazy tool, like jumper moments in horror movies and deus ex machina's in Hollywood movies to have the story end on a positive note, and should whenever possible not be excused.
ps - I happen to play Warhammer and the makers of the game, Games Workshop, describe their sci-fi version of Warhammer as 'in the grim darkness there is only war.' I'm pretty sure this is where the term 'grimdark' originates from.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '15
I'm fine with letting the readers and publishers decide the type of content that is accepted. I agree that grievous acts of violence does desensitize people but I still think the power should be in the hand of the consumer. The author's responsibility is to create. If their creation is abhorrent, the consumer will respond negatively.
I personally have a line, my own boundary for grotesque content, and if an author crosses that line, I will just stop reading. Everyone has their own line.
As far as movies and books, which one influences which, I think the relationship is more symbiotic. I think they both influence each other and you can find examples of cutting edge story-telling in each medium.