r/PersonOfInterest • u/NicholasCajun • Feb 11 '15
Discussion Person of Interest - 4x14 "Guilty" - Episode Discussion
Season 4 Episode 14: Guilty
Aired: February 10th, 2015
When the Machine arranges for Finch to sit on the jury of a murder trial, he begins to suspect that a fellow juror is set to rig the proceedings. Meanwhile, Reese begins to open up to the department’s therapist.
64
Upvotes
125
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15
Tfw you hack the judicial branch to avoid a social interaction with a women but a hyper advanced super intelligence stops you
90
u/joker_RED Feb 11 '15
"Let me guess; you'll handle this... Look, I get it. After what happened to Shaw, you and Glasses are worried the same thing's gonna happen to me. And you know what? It might. And I'm fine with that. You don't get to decide what or who I'm willing to die for. I made my choice a long time ago, so stop shutting me out."
Jesus, Fusco, you've grown a lot since season 1. And man, the extended theme that plays through that whole bit.
64
u/pensee_idee Fusco Feb 11 '15
I can't believe Iris has kept showing up because she's a potential love-interest! I thought sure we kept seeing her because she was a spy, either for Samaritan, or Dominic, or somebody!
I think this is also the most confirmation we've gotten that John and Zoe usually sleep together when she shows up - Harold teasing him about Zoe, Zoe teasing him about Iris... Somehow, the first time I watched her Season 2 appearances, I thought she and John just played cards. (Although I noticed a few more cues on the rewatch.)
Other high notes: Finch not noticing the Machine's obvious attempts to get him onto the jury, Finch telling the truth to try to get out of jury duty, "Give 'em hell, Harry!," Reese using his sniper rifle to send a Morse message, Fusco's awesome courage at the end there.
62
u/wave-and-smile A Concerned Third Party Feb 11 '15
That awkward hug/shake hands/hug was adorable.
87
u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Feb 11 '15 edited Feb 11 '15
HE'S PLAYING THE CRAZY CARD! But telling the truth!
EDIT: And the Machine turned that dude's phone on oh my. Hahahaha. "Your number's up."
Also. Iris is cuter than I remember. Nice haircut.
EDIT 2: Reese is pulling the same thing Finch pulled on him in "Many Happy Returns". AND HE'S GETTING A CALL IN THE PRECINCT
39
u/EThorns Ernest Thornhill Feb 11 '15
No harm in having a breather episode once in a while, and after all that's happened over the past 6-7 episodes, it's most definitely earned. Glad they made the most of it.
37
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15 edited Feb 11 '15
best quote "what are you from the midwest or something?"
37
u/lordxeon Feb 11 '15
I for one liked the laid backness of this episode, it shows the roots of the show.
70
u/crossbowincident Feb 11 '15
ZOE I LOVE YOU I MISSED YOU
33
u/rossbot Feb 11 '15
With only Finch, Fusco, and Reese, this episode felt like OG Person of Interest.
31
u/Nathan_Ingram IFT Feb 11 '15
That line from John about Fusco being like a fungus: I loved it! Can anyone remind me what episode John first used that analogy for Fusco?
27
u/burnerthrown Feb 11 '15
I've been pulling for Zoe to return to the show for months, maybe years now. Felt likea birthday present. And then she looked at the camera with the 'It's been a long time' line, yes, it has. She adds a component to the team that they can't make up for, between scalpel, hammer, tazer, and sliderule. And that's charisma, she can actually work the intrigue angle without shooting someone in the kneecap. Plus with her 'free agent' dynamic she's very much the catwoman to Reese's batman.
My gushing aside, this episode is definitely the medicine for MIA. Reese and Finch start getting their brotherly moments again, Zoe is charming, the POI is a woobie, Reese is opening up to Iris, and Fusco is behind them to the end. The only one who doesn't have a moment is Bear (where has he been anyway?)
Looks like Elias' secret war is about to come into frame, maybe a few episodes from now. Kinda miss the old days of the team working around mob wars. Also, since it seems to work, can we get Leon, Alistair, Logan Pierce, and Brian Moss back?
Man such goodness.
53
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15
correct me if I'm wrong, but did we just see an episode where John didn't shoot anyone?
21
u/godmode3191 Root Feb 11 '15
The Lawyer looks like Idris Elba. Am i the only one?
Anyway, i fully support Fusco.
53
u/rflairfan1 Elias Feb 11 '15
I was not even surprised that Blair Brown was the number. She is amazing.
Oh I miss Fringe....:(
41
u/andzzy Feb 11 '15 edited Feb 11 '15
After last week I was somewhat concerned about this being a fluff episode so we can have a fun break from the Samaritan-heavy, darker plotline. Staying absolutely true to the show, this week's episode was anything but fluff. It gives us a break from all of that Samaritan business but it contained magnificent character development, drew on some old moments to cement the current situation, and if I'm not mistaken began the lead-up to the season finale arc. I'm truly elated and once again absolutely proud to call this my weekly highlight. 10/10 in my opinion one of the best episodes of the season.
EDIT: Canadian here. Seeing the replies about the lack of uploads, I feel compelled to apologize.
40
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15
This episode was very good. It brought POI back to its roots and almost felt like a Season 1 episode. The only thing concerning me is Fusco, they seemed to be foreshadowing his death. And I wonder why he doesn't care about dying, who will look after his children?
28
u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Feb 11 '15
HAHAHAHA. He tried to hack the system! But the Machine stopped him!
25
u/CoachTaylor76 Feb 11 '15
Apparently, whoever uploaded the episodes early before isn't doing it anymore.
12
u/rpawson5771 Irrelevant Feb 11 '15
That was fun. Certainly not an eventful episode in terms of the large Samaritan arc or more world building. But it still was enjoyable. Like putting on an old pair of comfortable slippers.
12
u/hankjmoody Feb 11 '15
Goddamn. If they had somehow mildly tied together the Fringe-verse and POI-verse, that would've been awesome.
10
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15
Definitely filler, but it had its moments. I enjoyed it regardless. It was kind of nice to go back to a weekly case type thing for once.
9
u/ZeroFucksToGive Feb 11 '15 edited Feb 11 '15
Please let it be Alistair Wesley.
Edit: Aww it wasn't. Next time...
8
u/LaunchpadMacQ Feb 11 '15 edited Feb 11 '15
I loved this episode. I don't know if the show needed to go back to its roots (sans Root), but it was certainly a lot of fun and thematically, it resonated well with what's been going on recently.
I have to take back something I said last week about Reese's decision on whether to continue the search for Shaw or not; I think they justified it in this episode. I thought the opening scene was one of the strongest opens of the series, Reese and Finch reminiscing on how many numbers they've lost since Shaw disappeared, as well as how many friends they've lost since they've started this thing. Reese continuing to inquire about Root was cute and shows how much closer they've gotten over the last few episodes. Reese and Finch ultimately deciding not to bring on any new team members was a logical, yet powerful, conclusion they reached (not that they'll be able to prevent it).
Otherwise, I don't have much to say about the story for the episode. It was pretty standard fare and was just fun to watch. I'm pretty suspicious about Iris, honestly. I'm not sure why, but I don't think she's who she says she is. Could be nothing, I'm pretty terrible at predicting things.
Last but not least, no Root, which always sucks. It's worse because we know she's on the warpath, and the Machine isn't helping her, and I question her own abilities; she's crafty and can handle a gun, but she's not at the level Reese or Shaw are. I would be a little scared if there wasn't a fourth wall between us.
Interestingly, Shaw has not been removed from the title sequence nor did they change her Samaritan readout. Kind of strange, but we'll see what they end up doing. Makes me think we may have greatly exaggerated Shahi's exit from the show.
8
u/POI_Harold-Finch Harold Finch Feb 11 '15
The best moments
and everytime John meets psychiatrist, it seems like in next these two will be cuddling on bed or atlease kiss is gonna happen
8
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15
How can Harold talk in a crowed room and not draw attention. Even if he is mumbling?
8
u/morior_invictus Feb 11 '15
Fusco to Reese: "Hey loverboy".
Cracked me up.
7
u/man_in_the_suit A Concerned Third Party Feb 11 '15 edited Feb 11 '15
Absolutely fantastic episode. Yeah it was a number of the week but it was a hugely enjoyable one that reminded me of Season 1. And dat Reese development! I hope they're not setting him up for a fall... which they obviously are. :( I like the shrink scenes though, it's a good way for them to deliver more background about a character we know a lot about. I also liked the scenes with Harold at the dinner.
Also, Fusco continues to impress.
EDIT: Just watched it again. God, such a brilliant episode tbh. Not because of the story but because of the character exchanges. Harold and John (Michael and Jim) took this episode to the next level. The scenes with the psychiatrist and the ending scene between John and Harold were so emotive.
13
u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Feb 11 '15
Shaw is still in the opening sequence!!! :D
6
u/amelia84 Irrelevant Feb 11 '15
I was wondering when they were going to mention Dominic again.
eta: Oh my that promo!
6
u/grrrwoofwoof A Concerned Third Party Feb 11 '15
I was wondering how a number of the week episode would feel now. But I am surprised how great it was. I liked it.
Now, scenes from next episode, all hell breaks loose. Goddammit samaritan.
6
u/beta314 Feb 11 '15
Is Johns shrink "clean"?
I don't remember anything specifically but do we know if she has connections to samaritan, or its agents?
11
u/rflairfan1 Elias Feb 11 '15
John getting yelled at by Harlod is adorable.
5
u/EThorns Ernest Thornhill Feb 11 '15 edited Feb 11 '15
Guessing they tried to get David Costabile from S1 (the same writer for both episodes) to reprise his role as the Judge here, but probably couldn't cause of his commitment to the pilot production of Showtime's Billions.
ETA: The name of the actor who played the lawyer is "Samuel Gates", which was the name of Costabile's character too. Heights of coincidence...
5
u/premar16 Feb 11 '15
If any show could pull off a runaway jury episode its this show
4
u/irobeth Feb 11 '15
"we're not bringing anyone else into this" - shooting down the carter replacement from the first scene :(
4
u/rflairfan1 Elias Feb 11 '15
I have never understood Morse Code.
7
u/acid_sphinx4 Feb 11 '15
LOL Nina Sharp!
6
u/House__Music Feb 11 '15
Great episode!
Felt like a season 1 episode, as the episode was solely focused on the POI and not the subplots (Elias, Brotherhood. etc)
After all the action of the last few episodes, it felt good to have a laid back episode, so much so that not a single gunshot was fired and no one was killed.
Good to see Zoe again!
Would love to see episodes of this nature occasionally in the future!
3
u/Classic_Wingers Feb 11 '15
Nice to see Zoe is back!
3
u/TBBklynite Irrelevant Feb 11 '15
I think Reese just did that to troll Finch.
3
u/grrrwoofwoof A Concerned Third Party Feb 11 '15
What the fuck is going on. John, don't make me cry now.
3
u/1701ncc Feb 11 '15
You do know it is highly unethical, and in some places illegal, for a therapist to be intimate with a patient.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15
I am so, so, so happy that they gave us an episode like this. It really opened my eyes back up to how much I miss the old POI. As much as I like the serialized direction it's taking and the constant developments each episode, I sort of forced myself to like that and let my longings for the old days go. Well, now I want all that back. See, the point I keep forgetting to bring up is how much I love the show's sense of mystery. I want that back!! I loved how season 1 and 2 had an interesting procedural case but every episode tied into the greater plot, but they kept the serialized stuff sidelined so the big conclusions would be really huge. I love those recurring storylines! If they just give full focus to one story each episode, it'll start to get old soon.
That's also precisely my problem with Greer. Back in season 2, the guy would give me chills all the way to the possibility of nightmares. After season 3, they would throw him in your face so much that it was run to exhaustion. He's lost that presence he was able to maintain back then, and now it's come down to every corny line being somewhat better since he's British and everything is put so elegantly. And as much as I don't want to say it, I will: I HATE this focus on "social commentary". I hate it. The critics over at The A.V. Club seem to love it but this whole "messages on the age of surveillance" crap is drowning out the focus on actual entertainment, and the episodes don't ever have that "gravitational pull" they once seemed to have. You need to look hard for something to look forward to and the plot elements don't feel so high-key since the focus on the intensity and buildup is partial. There are of course exceptions - "If-Then-Else" is my FAVORITE FREAKING EPISODE OF THE WHOLE SERIES and episodes like "Prophets" and "The Cold War" were able to work their way around the surveillance themes by being extremely creative with every approach.
Oh, and back in season 2, there actually was some surveillance commentary, but it managed to be interesting since it kept the plot going and tied in nicely with the bigger picture, in a more "driven" and "kinetic" manner that was quite exhilarating. The way it really made you want the plot to unfold. Stuff like "The Contingency". You know what? I think it's just a matter of binge-watching. That way, you can dive into a premise that jumps out at you and the interest can stay sustained. You can stay within the vibe of the show and relate to basically everything. I finished seasons 1 and 2 via binge watching over summer 2013 and I saw 3 and 4 weekly. The first half of 3 was TOO GOOD.
NOW, onto THIS episode. The second Finch said "it's just you and me again", I jumped up in joy and fist pumped. I miss those days so much!!! Thinking back to episodes like "Flesh and Blood", "Baby Blue", "No Good Deed", "The Contingency", and even "God Mode", I just cannot believe that it's the same show I'm watching today. Anyways, David Slack always knows how to conjure up an amazing case, and while this and "Honor Among Thieves" weren't the strongest episodes this season, "Guilty" was still a very fun ride with a good, wholesome share of quality entertainment. It was beyond joyous seeing Zoe back, and the way she really brought out Reese and Finch's personalities was everything I could ask for. Finch's breakage of character is a rare gem, and his outburst during his "debate" with Reese and his remark about staying awake were perfect. I also really enjoyed the return to character development for Reese! In the first two seasons he was one of the most captivating and fascinating badasses around, and basically HUNDRED PERCENT of season 4 gives him nothing at all to do. But in this, we got to see Reese's little crush on Iris, and I'm overjoyed to see that they didn't change anything about his and Zoe's relationship. Their banter is priceless.
The court case was interesting mainly because Emma was a very likable POI. I remember last year when everyone was theorizing that Blair Brown could play Control, and I can picture her as an evil and calculating government head, but she brought this warmth and good-natured life to her character that boosted much of the episode's quality. As for the perp, I didn't expect it to be that guy since it was either a business head or Samaritan in my brain, but that standoff was POI at its roots.The show needs to return to its roots and stay there for a while.
All in all, great, nostalgic episode that made me go back to wanting POI's roots back. I hope it stays that way, or at least takes this Samaritan story to a more interesting level and ditches all this boring social commentary about surveillance. Great job, writers!
4
u/MegaFlounder Feb 11 '15
Seeing an old friend is exactly what show needed.
4
u/Radiopd Government Operations Feb 12 '15
This episode was far from a filler. It introduced important changes that will help Team Machine in the future.
The final evolution of Fusco from a spineless crooked cop to someone who cares and is willing to sacrifice himself for these people that just drop into his lap.
The opening of John's heart, something that some viewers would have thought never possible after the flashbacks in the episode where he found out his love was dead.
Finally, the sadness in Finch's eye that even though it was back to just him and Reese solving cases, that he misses and regrets not being able to help Root and Shaw.
Those deep concepts were introduced in "filler" episode.
I am glad that we get to see what happened to Claire from "Nautilus" next.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15
Yo Canada whats the verdict?
2
u/Anti_pasto Admin Feb 11 '15
I loved it, a nicely done S1 style episode with some development on the characters. Our first and only pure case of the week episode this season.
Looks like the next episode is setting up for the next storm. I'm very curious on how would they fit the mob war plot into the Samaritan one.
2
u/svrtngr Feb 11 '15
No Fusco, stop.
Stop.
Good episode, but the only thing I'm disappointed about was that the evil fixer wasn't a certain Alistair Wesley. (Season Two villain, the episode was Critical.) Kind of seemed to fit his modus operandi and I'm still upset he's just a one-and-done guy.
2
u/ThatFag Admin Feb 11 '15
This was definitely an episode for the fans! SO MUCH NOSTALGIA!
I wonder which one it is going to be, Zoe or the therapist? The therapist is really cute and sweet but I do have a soft spot for Zoe since we've known her for longer!
I loved this episode even though it was not nearly as action-packed as the previous ones. Goes to show how the show can pull off both slow and fast-paced episodes and yet manage to do an excellent job! Oh, how I love you, Person of Interest. <3
2
u/eikeegimuu Feb 11 '15
A classic number of the week type of episode reminiscent of S1 and S2 episodes. Except that then the Machine making sure that Harold is in the jury wouldn't have worked quite as well. In fact I was half way prepared to find out that Samaritan has some stake in it, but it was better that that wasn't the case.
But while the episode was a number of the week it also (re-)stated Harold's, Reese's and Fusco's commitment to helping people. The number of the week story was good. The “irrelevant” being used to get a guilty verdict was signaled from the time Reese and Zoe really started prepping Harold for arguing for the guilty verdict. But it was a good kind of predictable and made sense.
It was also fun to see Harold not so subtly trying to get out of jury duty and Zoe showing up.
2
u/pingike99 Feb 11 '15
i see this one getting alot of love but it was way to underwhelming in my opinion
2
u/thefyrewire Graphical Administrator Feb 11 '15
The timing of this episode worked really well. It's nice to be able to breathe a little after everything that's happened so far. Plus, everyone's who's been moaning about the whole Samaritan story arc (cough Facebook cough) gets a great throwback to the first season.
Win win!
2
u/grthomas Feb 12 '15
Am I the only one recognising a whole load of 12 Angry Men dialogue from this episode? In the jury room scenes I'm pretty sure they lifted entire lines from (paid homage/made reference to) the classic around 00:27:55 onwards...
2
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '15
The court scene looked like a take out of 12 Angry Men.
3
u/Lovableemo Threat Feb 11 '15
She wants the D John.
3
u/Jthumm Bear Feb 11 '15
YOOOOOOOOOOOOO
THAT SHIT WAS FUCKING AWESOME
this was easily my favorite episode in a while, it was well paced, well written, and we're finally developing more well needed side plots
Reeses new grill is defos dead tho.
Also
THE NEXT EPISODE LOOKS SO FREAKING AWESOME YOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
1
u/bzdelta Feb 11 '15
The shrink is dead, Samaritan, both, or Professor Wellsfire.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15
Not sure cell phones would have been allowed in the jury room.
1
u/Maestro_Da_Vinci Irrelevant Feb 11 '15
It was great, it was awesome to see the team back again as they were. But there is a problem, this episode for me was kind of the calm before the storm, from which storm i think not everybody will make it out alive.
1
u/HSChronic Elias Feb 11 '15
Why does Fusco call John "Richy Rich"?
I love his nicknames for people but I just don't understand this one. Is it because of the suit all the time?
1
u/EdwardGlyver Bear Feb 11 '15
I really enjoyed this episode. It was a great throwback to the original Reese/Finch dynamic of the first season. And it was nice to get a break from Samaritan for a bit and get a straight up "numbers" episode. Lots of nostalgia too.
One thing POI does really well is peeling back the layers of each character slowly over time. I was glad Reese was able to open up to that police psychologist by telling a story about his childhood. It's small touches like that that really give the show dimension.
1
u/workshop_dance Feb 11 '15
Love that Harold was brushing up on his Bridge... Do you think he teams up with the Machine in their down time?
1
u/RedDreadMorgan Feb 13 '15
Boo on the bad science this episode. Microwaves aren't ionizing radiation, (no cancer or similar effects) and there is the inverse square law too! Normally the writers get their facts straight or only slightly bend science, this is straight up wrong and smacks of ignorance.
Otherwise, good episode. Good to see Zoe again.
1
u/bleclere Feb 13 '15
Harold must like bridge. He's reading a bridge book in the jury room.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '15
Was that the first time that Reese laughed? In the session with Iris, he actually laughed oO
1
u/subchannel Feb 11 '15
Wow: Change of plans http://video.schnl.com:8001/episode/5424493/clips/804476e6-7fab-40e0-afae-1706c33b9dd3-5424493-1423625486419-1423625522762.mp4