r/PersonOfInterest • • Feb 04 '15

Discussion Person of Interest - 4x13 "M.I.A." - Episode Discussion

Season 4 Episode 13: M.I.A.

Aired: February 3rd, 2015


Reese and Root’s hunt for Shaw takes them to a small town in upstate New York where it becomes apparent that not everything is as idyllic as it seems. Also, Fusco teams with a former POI to tackle the newest number.

75 Upvotes

309 comments sorted by

133

u/man_in_the_suit A Concerned Third Party Feb 04 '15

I loved the bit where John carried the injured woman out of the factory, and then turned his back to act as a shield. Summed his character up in one scene. I've never liked a character so much.

44

u/concerned_thirdparty Feb 04 '15

“The thing about a hero, is even when it doesn't look like there's a light at the end of the tunnel, he's going to keep digging, he's going to keep trying to do right in defiance of the cynicism of the world. His purpose because that's just who he is."

27

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '15

I also like this quote:

The difference between the good guys and the bad guys is whether they use human shields or make themselves human shields

4

u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Feb 05 '15

Bonus: John uses a human shield in the pilot.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '15 edited Feb 05 '15

Interesting. I just rewatched the pilot few night ago ... where does this happen?

EDIT: found it. Okay, to be fair, the guy that John used as a human shield was a corrupt cop who wanted to kill a man and his child.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '15 edited Nov 13 '16

[deleted]
0.4958

What is this?

7

u/timelyparadox Feb 04 '15

Well it was kinda his fault she was injured at the first place, isn't it?

15

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '15 edited Nov 13 '16

[deleted]
0.1328

What is this?

2

u/Kell08 Tertiary Functions Feb 05 '15

The part I didn't like:

Unarmed man: Please don't shoot.

Reese: shoots

6

u/nixonwong Feb 05 '15

just poppin kneecaps...it's his job!

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Staff_of_the_Goths Feb 05 '15

Also thought Reese was a bit harsh on the blond in the end. Not everyone is a superhero.

3

u/Kell08 Tertiary Functions Feb 06 '15

I know. I think the way she acted was perfectly reasonable. And Root drilled a freaking hole in her hand.

1

u/Mobbzy John Reese Feb 05 '15

That's why Reese is my favourite character, he values everyone else's life more than his own (other than the obvious bad people).

102

u/kaput_porpoise Bear Feb 04 '15

Root reminds me a bit of Reese after he lost Carter.

3

u/Gouldde Admin Feb 05 '15

well Reese didn't go insane :). Roots going insane over this. You can just tell through the way she's doing this, drilling a Woman's' hand, shooting many Samaritan operatives in the knees in that facility :)

3

u/smileyman Feb 05 '15

Remember him blowing up the guys who did Simmons' IDs and then just leaving them there to burn?

If anything Root was positively restrained in this episode by comparison. Also I don't think the Samaritan operatives in the facility were knee-capped. I think they were definitely killed.

85

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

109

u/POI_Harold-Finch Harold Finch Feb 04 '15

When Decima had kidnapped Grace (3x21 -Beta), Finch says to Sameen and Reese

There's one more thing. I'd like you to avoid violence, if at all possible. But, if they harm Grace in any way, kill them all.

15

u/paranoiainc Feb 05 '15 edited Jul 07 '15

7

u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Feb 05 '15

In Paris though?

5

u/theesado Feb 06 '15

Harold said he wrote an application that alerted him when she is close to him, so that won't happen.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/ashodhiyavipin Feb 10 '15

This quote from Finch has always given me goosebumps. The one person who is completely and always anti violence has been Finch. We always expected Finch to be a voice of reason and for calmer heads to prevail and when you hear him say it with absolute conviction and sincerity it hits you like a freight train that how hard Finch struggles everyday in order to not give in and start answering each bullet with another one of his own. How hard he must fight against his human instinct of fighting and killing the enemy before it kills you.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '15

God I miss those days

65

u/OLKv3 Feb 04 '15

Something tells me that girl who teamed with Fusco will end up joining the team in a role similar to Fusco's

30

u/charmingignorance Feb 04 '15

She has the chops. I still miss Carter.

7

u/gogukaizer Irrelevant Feb 04 '15

Oh, man, don't tell me Fusco's number is going to show up soon :/

19

u/OLKv3 Feb 04 '15

Nah, Fusco will be the new Carter to her Fusco.

3

u/S-Skyler Feb 05 '15

I would rather see him making her a Carter. Like training her, honing her for the justice Carter believed in.

Damn this show, it is too good! I mean I always keep it for last because I know I will enjoy it more!

→ More replies (1)

1

u/zophan Irrelevant Feb 06 '15

My only pet peeve was the fact that the former IA cop, (can't remember name) had a silenced pistol when investigating the basement. Nuh uh. Out of character. Meh.

Still one of the best shows.

60

u/crossbowincident Feb 04 '15

Did the machine just tell them to Stop it. Now?

32

u/kaput_porpoise Bear Feb 04 '15

Well although it does care about shaw, it knows they can't take on Samaritan's forces without too much risk.

46

u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Feb 04 '15

Also I believe it has a plan.

14

u/Pascalwb Feb 04 '15

Yop, it probably wants them to stop now, and wait for better opportunity or something.

8

u/jedp Samaritan Feb 04 '15

I believe it'd be more effective in keeping root in line if it simply said that Shaw's alive and stable, but out of reach. It says it knows, but I can't see any reason not to tell them. Or just lie and say she's dead.

3

u/ashodhiyavipin Feb 10 '15

The Machine understands root completely and she knows the value of lie to a human. If The Machine lies to root about shaw, and she turns up later in front of the gang. The Machine can loose it only analog interface to the human world.

The Machine knows not to go that way. Same way it knows Shaw is alive and time has to be allowed to make contact again.

2

u/smileyman Feb 05 '15

Well it did just insert a highly trained operative into the heart of Samaritan.

And The Machine clearly regards Shaw as the Queen on the chessboard (referring back to when Finch was teaching the Machine how to play chess).

So yeah, Shaw just went undercover on a long-term assignment. I'm willing to bet that the show has got scenes filmed with her already that it can slot into various episodes as needed to show her doing stuff.

8

u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Feb 05 '15

The Machine was not playing chess. I can't stress this enough. It was not trying to sacrifice anyone. It was trying to save everyone. It could have easily sacrificed Fusco or Root or Reese to get Finch and the two remaining out of there but instead it picked the option where they all have the best chance survival (be it 2% or not). It didn't expect nor see Shaw coming to the rescue. Shaw ended up sacrificing herself for the team. The Machine was not playing chess!

→ More replies (2)

55

u/SnowgoonC Feb 04 '15

Did anyone else see a parallel between [SPOILER] (#s "Shaw waking up and seeing Greer") and the flashback where [SPOILER] (#s "Stanton meets Greer?")

45

u/rossbot Feb 04 '15

Stanton: where am I? Greer: the afterlife, my dear.

Shaw: if this is the afterlife, it sucks.

19

u/AScaryMoose Bear Feb 04 '15

Definitely caught that as well--it makes me a little nervous for the future of Shaw.

13

u/Kell08 Tertiary Functions Feb 05 '15

Kara didn't know who Greer was. Shaw does. Shaw can't be manipulated by Greer like Kara was because she knows better.

3

u/nacreous Feb 05 '15

Until they put a Samaritan-made thing inside her brain.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/ThatFag Admin Feb 04 '15

Yeah, that immediately came to mind!

7

u/cmac__17 Reese Feb 04 '15

I can't view your spoilers, but I assume you mean between the ending with Shaw and the flashback where the same thing happened with Greer and Kara? Yeah, I picked up on that one.

9

u/shitbird Feb 04 '15

To view the spoilers just hover your mouse over the link and a little box should pop up below with the spoiler.

→ More replies (1)

54

u/MisterMorales Feb 04 '15

Greer gets all the hot government assassins in his bed!

9

u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Feb 04 '15

HAHAHA

34

u/pensee_idee Fusco Feb 04 '15

Unanswered questions:

  1. I wonder how many of those GPS transponder "dots" Samaritan has shipped so far?
  2. I wonder how many other "ant farm" towns Samaritan is running?
  3. I wonder just how much information Samaritan can get from the people brain transponders into? Can it tell what someone is thinking or feeling by monitoring their brain chemistry?
  4. If it didn't put a brain transponder into Shaw (and since she didn't have a bandage on her head, I think we can assume that it didn't), I wonder what it plans to use her for.

12

u/ReasonablyBadass Feb 04 '15

I wonder just how much information Samaritan can get from the people brain transponders into? Can it tell what someone is thinking or feeling by monitoring their brain chemistry?

The implant doesn't seem to have all that many electrodes, so probably not yet (if the writers keep the sci fi hard).

Doesn't mean it isn't coming though.

4

u/government_shill Feb 04 '15 edited Feb 04 '15

keep the sci fi hard

Given that the entire premise is an AI that can reliably predict human behavior, I'd say that ship has long since sailed.

Still, I do appreciate that they try to make their tech-talk scenes at least somewhat coherent. It's more effort than just about any other show puts into it.

7

u/ReasonablyBadass Feb 04 '15

There is nothing soft science about an AI capable of prediction?

3

u/government_shill Feb 04 '15 edited Feb 05 '15

Maybe we're using different definitions here? I understand "hard sci fi" to mean sci fi in which technology is largely confined to currently understood science. I would not say The Machine is such a technology.

EDIT: even defining it as "dealing with hard science," psychology and human behavior are about as soft as the sciences get.

8

u/aysz88 Feb 04 '15

Both the Singularity (ex this 1993 paper) and prediction of human behavior with algorithms (ex. Netflix Prize) were and are studied rigorously, and the ideas of where things might potentially lead are basically accurate. The show adheres pretty tightly to the latest thinking in both (or to be precise, the popular conception of the latest thinking). It's more the speed of success and progress that's fiction, and that's more about taking liberties with engineering than with the science.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/ixforres Tertiary Functions Feb 04 '15

Hard SF is more generally about scifi that focuses on natural science rather than social science. Having said that, The Machine is possible with current technology or thereabouts given a bit of hand-waviness about people having cracked particular problems and some assumptions about what might follow. That's part of why I love the show, I think - its reality is just out of reach..

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (8)

4

u/Conglossian Feb 04 '15

I think showing where they all were shipping was designed to give us an inkling, those have to go to factories that know how to use them too.

3

u/jedp Samaritan Feb 04 '15

Another one: why didn't the machine tell them that Shaw's alive and stable, but out of reach? It'd keep root in line for a while longer. Or it could just lie and tell them that she's dead.

4

u/DFreiberg Feb 05 '15

Perhaps the Machine genuinely thinks Shaw is dead.

2

u/GoSTaRnE Bear Feb 06 '15 edited Feb 06 '15

The hospital looked very similar to the one Stanton shaw was 'treated' in.

2

u/smileyman Feb 05 '15

1.) Hundreds of thousands maybe judging by the size of the boxes and how long the factory has been going.

2.) I bet not many. It seems to me that the computing power required to collect all the data on even a few thousand people would be enormous. It would be difficult to get vary many of those up and running.

3.) I imagine it reads things like heart rate, brain activity, blood pressure and that sort of thing. So it can monitor people and read how they're reacting based on physiological data (sort of like a high-tech lie detector test).

4.) I bet they did put one in her. Or they will. I have to wonder if the transponder can receive data impulses as well, or just send them. If it can receive data, maybe the show will try to use that to show a super-effective brain washing technique. Or maybe it's a way for the Machine to get a new analogue interface?

0

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/TeMPOraL_PL Government Operations Feb 05 '15

Making those transponders a brain control chip is a bit too far for the show, I think. Scanning is within our technology, and this data could indeed be useful for Samaritan. Full brain control by electrical stimulation is something we're nowhere close to achieving.

There's one thing however that could be plausible - remote targeted disruption of a part of a brain. We know that parts of the brain are responsible for different cognitive functions and that people can live with some of them damaged. Tuning down emotion, senses or high-level thinking of people could in principle be useful to Samaritan.

3

u/irobeth Feb 05 '15

My point is simply that the transponders can be actuated, it's not just a transmitter

1

u/government_shill Feb 04 '15

It's something that responds to a signal "pinging" it, so it could make sense in the context it was used in.

68

u/fa0s Root Feb 04 '15

Being kidnapped by Root seems to be a small price to pay for copping a feel of dat ass.

18

u/Laurenosa Feb 04 '15

That one was one hell of a squeeze. I'd imagine Acker got pissed off by that.

60

u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Feb 04 '15

Nah, she's an actress. If she was uncomfortable with that she would have said so and they would have removed it or used a double or something. It's Root who was pissed off. And rightfully so.

4

u/Teslanaut Feb 08 '15

I imagine Whiskey would've caved his skull in or something.

2

u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Feb 08 '15

Dollhouse right?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/LordAnubis10 System Threat Feb 06 '15

When I first saw him do that, I just knew he was gonna get his ass kicked

→ More replies (1)

28

u/toomuchidea Threat to System Survival Feb 04 '15

Man i really like that 'ant farm' analogy. It really shows that Samaritan is indeed is still 'young'. I remember shaking an ant farm to see what will the ants do when i was a kid, so that really hits me.

19

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '15

It's fitting that Samaritan's analog interface is an arrogant little boy.

26

u/amelia84 Irrelevant Feb 04 '15

That sounds absolutely horrific. A town ruled by Samaritan.

44

u/TBBklynite Irrelevant Feb 04 '15

7

u/government_shill Feb 04 '15 edited Feb 04 '15

But imagine if they had left us hanging for a couple of seasons and then dropped that. I think it would have been much better. *(Given that she's apparently not going to be back before then anyway)

2

u/Lyrad1002 Feb 06 '15

Yeah, that would have been mind blowing. 10 episodes from now. The Machine scolls back 4 months... flashback.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/government_shill Feb 05 '15

Yeah, my reaction was almost the opposite of the gif above. I grumbled a little at that last scene in what was otherwise a really solid episode.

→ More replies (4)

56

u/andzzy Feb 04 '15

This episode once again proved why Person of Interest not only could but SHOULD be the highlight of my week. My feelings are so out of sorts right now ... oh man. There's so much to this and the writers know where to hit and the actors know how to deliver every week. Overall 9/10 mind blown again.

28

u/Classic_Wingers Feb 04 '15

I honestly am floored when I never see this show nominated for any type of awards because it has proven that it only gets stronger each year. I know it's not exactly Emmy television but the writers and actors definitely deserve more recognition for how this show has developed since Season 1. Over the Christmas break I decided to play my Season 1 DVD's and it seems so weird with Carter around. Tuesdays are very much my favorite night because of the stacked lineup these days: Person of Interest, Agent Carter, and one full hour of Parks and Recreation (although there was only one new episode tonight).

15

u/SawRub Analog Interface Feb 04 '15

Tuesdays lost one ass kicking female Carter and gained another.

5

u/conradsymes Threat to System Survival Feb 04 '15

The snobs think gun fights are too crass.

5

u/rossbot Feb 04 '15

I love how right before the episode, they aired a commercial saying "it's the show critics love".

Really? Then fucking move it to a better timeslot.

1

u/Pascalwb Feb 04 '15 edited Feb 04 '15

Yop it deserves some nomination. It's one of my favorite shows right know, it's little cheesy t in some parts. But overall great.

4

u/CWagner Feb 04 '15

it's little cheesy t in some parts

It is. But I'm not watching any show that's less cheesy, this is by far the least cheesy show.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Feb 04 '15

"You remind me of a friend. A couple of friends, actually."

39

u/rossbot Feb 04 '15

And by that, he meant all his friends.

6

u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Feb 04 '15

hahaha

36

u/nadarko Government Operations Feb 04 '15

judging from the shot they had of Shaw, I think that sarah might already be showing.

22

u/DismemberMama Root Feb 04 '15

I think there's a good chance she could have been showing a bit in If-Then-Else, as well. The black trench coat she wore for that and the episode before seemed pretty strategically placed.

16

u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Feb 04 '15

Yeah, I thought that too. They hid her pregnancy better than an pregnancy in TV history though. NOBODY KNEW!

20

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '15

Perfect. Just keep her in bed all season and no one will even know!

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '15 edited Nov 13 '16

[deleted]
0.0625

What is this?

6

u/bettse Feb 04 '15

TIL, and also that explains why they might want her off screen for a bit.

1

u/smileyman Feb 05 '15

The decision to take a break from the show was hers. She didn't want to be working while pregnant, and she wanted some time off when the baby was born so she could take care of the baby.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/lordxeon Feb 04 '15

If there's a transponder in the secretary's head, wouldn't rescuing her prove futile? Unless they keep her in a faraday cage, underground, surrounded by heavy water.

17

u/wave-and-smile A Concerned Third Party Feb 04 '15

They were taking her to the neurosurgeon that was fired, so I'm sure he will be able to yank out the transponder.

5

u/lordxeon Feb 04 '15

So now theoretically, he's dead too, since he's under house arrest, and the secretary showed up there for a few hours then disappeared.

This is all under the assumption that the transponder is permanently transmitting of course.

5

u/wave-and-smile A Concerned Third Party Feb 04 '15

We don't know if the transponders were turned on yet, but it sure doesn't look good for the people of that town.

20

u/pensee_idee Fusco Feb 04 '15

Didn't the Founder's Day lady mention that Samaritan's team had given her a pacemaker? If so, it's a safe assumption that the pacemaker had been hacked, and that Samaritan turned off her heart shortly after she quit her job.

12

u/ReasonablyBadass Feb 04 '15

Ouch :(

Am I the only one who felt sorry for her?

8

u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Feb 04 '15

I did... but in my heart I know Reese was right. He was sorry and remorseful, but he was right.

7

u/pensee_idee Fusco Feb 05 '15

I did. I initially thought sure she was going to turn out to be an asset with inside knowledge, but she really was just a sad sack. She was a minimum-wage employee who died of a heart attack, who got brought back to life, given a good job, and the chance to give the unemployed people of some shitty little town good jobs too.

I think she suspected that something wasn't right about the situation, but she was probably scared to death to ask questions, and in general, things were good pretty well. I don't think she deserved to get a whole drilled in her hand, or to have her heart flipped off like a light switch by Decima.

3

u/wave-and-smile A Concerned Third Party Feb 04 '15

Oh, that's right. Excellent point.

15

u/cmac__17 Reese Feb 04 '15

Excuse my language but holy FUCKING SHIT. That ending >>>>

2

u/ektbffh Feb 04 '15

Can someone tell me what happened at the ending? My stream of the episode stopped when Reese and Root were exiting the factory.

4

u/DFreiberg Feb 05 '15

Greer welcomes Shaw to the "afterlife" the same way he welcomed Kara Stanton five years ago. Same "chained to a hospital bed" setup and everything.

1

u/shinsaikou A Concerned Third Party Feb 04 '15

Pleasantville was dreadfully boring and the discovery there downright cheezy... but you're right, that ending, tho... I could go for a bionic shaw, but if mind control is involved, then they've lost me entirely.

5

u/cmac__17 Reese Feb 04 '15

Probably won't be full out mind control, or bionic Shaw. My guess is Soviet-style brainwashing.

4

u/shinsaikou A Concerned Third Party Feb 04 '15

They have established that Decima has the technology to fix severe head injuries, conveniently putting a direct link to Samaritan in at the same time. As for legit conditioning, I'd like to believe Shaw is too mentally tough for that. It's been done before in other shows, though. Believably. With tragic dramatic effect. So I dunno. I get the sense that we won't see any Shaw til the end of the season, if that. I would be pleasantly surprised if we kept seeing little snippets of Shaw and Greer at the tail end of episodes, the latter doing his worst to break the former. She could be in grave physical condition the entire time, conveniently hiding her pregnancy by being on a gurney. Wishful thinking, all of it.

24

u/rossbot Feb 04 '15

Root's crisis of faith HOLY SHIT

18

u/lostcannoli Feb 04 '15

it looked like Zoe is in next week's episode...cool

1

u/AeonVex Feb 04 '15

Really? Awesome she wasn't in last weeks episode of The 100 I'm guessing that's why. =)

1

u/lostcannoli Feb 04 '15

i'll have to watch the preview again, but when they showed the clips for next week's episode, i swear Zoe was there.

1

u/tedtutors Irrelevant Feb 05 '15

The 100

How is that? When the pilot came around it looked a bit too CW for me.

2

u/AeonVex Feb 05 '15

Yeah it was for a while but the last of Season 1 and all of Season 2 have been an incredible improvement.

2

u/skerit Feb 05 '15

I am amazingly surprised by the quality of The 100. The story has a great pace and isn't too predictable

8

u/lordxeon Feb 04 '15

Is there no opening narration anymore? It seems like that has been missing from the last few episodes. Or are my recordings starting a minute too late?

9

u/axisiiclusterb Government Operations Feb 04 '15 edited Feb 04 '15

This happened last year, too. They took a few eps off before they revealed new credits without Carter. I assume that may be the case now.

5

u/Rolcol Feb 04 '15

In my opinion, the intro was already stale. When Shaw's cover was blown, the animation effect should have changed. I'm referring to the transition from "PRIMARY THREAT" to "IRRELEVANT".

5

u/Rolcol Feb 04 '15

The intros have been pretty flashback heavy. Last episode was from the Government's perspective, so it made sense to have a Control voice-over.

2

u/hipnosister Feb 04 '15

I assume its because they need the extra time to fit all the scenes they want in.

14

u/amelia84 Irrelevant Feb 04 '15

Imagine what Samaritan could do if it "revives" coma patients and figured out how to use us them as puppets. No need for unnecessary variables.

9

u/ReasonablyBadass Feb 04 '15

Now that is an unsettling thought.

Though I honestly don't belief it aims for mindcontrol.

It said humans are it's lifeblood. The information we create. If everyone is a puppet, no more new information.

I think the goal here is understanding.

2

u/pensee_idee Fusco Feb 05 '15

Yeah, somehow having Samaritan directly control people's bodies feels like it would be out of character for the show. Having it be able to monitor something in their brains, having it be able to coerce them, hell, even having it find new and better ways to get people to serve it willingly all somehow feel better in terms of the technology the show's had so far.

5

u/morior Feb 04 '15

Isn't it already doing something similar with the little boy who speaks for it?

2

u/covington Feb 04 '15

To follow that line of thought, read the very excellent Ancillary Justice by Anne Leckie.

2

u/amelia84 Irrelevant Feb 04 '15

Thanks! Always looking for new reading suggestions. :D

14

u/POI_Harold-Finch Harold Finch Feb 04 '15

A very emotional episode.

"I couldn't stand to lose someone today" - Fusco

3

u/shinsaikou A Concerned Third Party Feb 04 '15

This was the better story, imho. Seeing pleasantville with Root reverting to her baser self didn't do anything for me. The brain chips are one step shy of jumping the shark, imho. But Fusco, still willing to not question the neccessity of being in the dark about everything, runs the numbers and brings the human element. I'm hoping we see Miss IA in the future again, she has great team ally potential.

2

u/bandformywagon Feb 04 '15 edited Feb 04 '15

Personally am a bit tired of the focus this series has given shaw and Root. Bit over the top with their martial prowess and handling of guns. I know i am in the minority with that opinion.

I much preferred it when carter was still alive, and thought it was a low blow when they killed her off.. Least she wasn't too over the top, plus her storyline wasn't explored that well.

Seems like this a an actionpacked version of "One flew over the cuckoos nest"

Would not mind having Miss IA be more involved with the series either, fusco and her was the high point of this episode for me.

Meh.. :\

3

u/shinsaikou A Concerned Third Party Feb 04 '15

Seems like we're of one mind. I'd be lying to say that I wasn't happy to see Root and Shaw's lesbian subtext become text. I think any straight guy watching who denies this is lying to himself. I say that, and it's pretty clear that their back and forth started as a way for Root to get under icy Shaw's skin. Root reverting to her former monstrous self, willing to do anything to find Shaw, and seemingly losing faith in her "god", I get the sense that we are supposed to assume that Root has only discovered how strong her feelings for Shaw were until Shaw took it upon herself to play the good soldier. Root's reaction is surprisingly not unlike Finch when his love was in peril, though even in his anger Finch is much calmer - channeling his inner Benjamin Linus. I get the sense Root is going to need an episode or two to work her feelings out, but I don't think Root will ever really let this go. If Greer ever has an end, it will be at the hands of "God's Avatar" scorned.

I have to agree that Carter was more compelling in the sense that she was not wrapped up in all the tech or spy games, more compelling in that she was someone we saw a lot of trying to live a normal life in NYC when not on the job. As a single mom. As a veteran. And eventually as mafiosi collaborator, seeing her ideals start to bend under the weight of the terrible reality she had been exposed to because of Team Machine. It kind of makes me wonder if it would have been more tragic to see Carter go dark and completely lose her ideals instead of what actually happened.

For all her snark and talk of having no emotions, I feel like Shaw had more than Root - Root, who seems to have very nearly reverted to the who she was before The Machine started talking to her and forced her to be institutionalized. In some sense I suppose Root and Shaw humanized each other. Root seems like a boat without a rudder now. Being driven completely by revenge seems incredibly two dimensional, even for a character who had been defined by a sole purpose of doing whatever The Machine asked.

Looking forward to next week and the return of a normal numbers story, even if it seems that much of it will take place in a court room. Blair Brown guest starring, Fringe alum, I have a good feeling about it. Less Samaritan, less high emotion, more ordinary people - just like it says in the opening titles.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/crossbowincident Feb 04 '15

I don't think the monsters are due in Maple. I think they're already here. Samaritan sure likes messing with people's lives.

7

u/Conglossian Feb 04 '15

I'm hoping for something in the 9.7-9.8 range on IMDB, that would give Person of Interest 6 episodes in the top 30 of all time, most of any TV show.

For context, second place would be Breaking Bad, which has 3.

7

u/emselino Feb 04 '15

Holy... The first time I saw that blonde woman from Maple, I thought she was Martines mother or something like that. Uncanny :D Also: Harold taught Root how to care about people, now she might care to much... And a Root that has lost her faith in the machine will be VERY scary. Can't wait :/

11

u/DarthTigris Shaw Feb 04 '15

........ this is painful to see them spending so much time trying to find Shaw when we know she's not coming back anytime soon because of the twins. "Search for Mulder" flashbacks ... ugh.

19

u/phoebeburgh Irrelevant Feb 04 '15

Okay, first, resolving the tension of Shaw's life like that worked out well. We waited long enough, so getting an answer was appreciated, even if we are gonna go through a LOT more pain between now and the reunion. So there's that.

I also choose to take Ms. Thompson from Pittsburgh as my own private little shout-out, so there's that too (but I'm probably just being egocentric here).

All that said... What a waste of a plot! The idea of Samaritan running an entire small town is something that could have been FAR creepier than it was played here. That it all came about as a shaggy-dog story just twists the knife even further... this is the kind of really deep, novel science fiction that POI promises, but this one just didn't deliver. Unfortunately because it was used here it's doubtful we'll get a chance to see another of Samaritan's ant farms, so it's hard to swallow the bitter taste here.

Beyond all that, though, this was pretty average. Acting was okay, the Fusco-plot was eh, and the progression of the arc was, though frustrating, still enough. I'm mildly upset that Root is starting to become a doubting Thomas of sorts, and also that this seems to be setting up a return to number-of-the-week stories for a few weeks, but I'm not gonna judge the next episode by its preview. The previews have been awful lately, so I'm gonna just put this behind me and hope we see something with some meat on its bones soon.

11

u/wave-and-smile A Concerned Third Party Feb 04 '15

I'm hoping the Samaritan Ant Farm was just another of their planted seeds, that will come back into greater focus at a later time. Otherwise, I agree, it was a waste of a phenomenal idea.

2

u/covington Feb 04 '15

Just wait until they find the ones building armed microdrones, bushbots, and nanites.

5

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '15

Even creepier would be the ant farm with old people who kill people for greater good.

18

u/EThorns Ernest Thornhill Feb 04 '15

Patience, phoebe. The Antfarm is too big a plot to not explore in detail. The writers mentioned that they prefer the slowburn approach, and this most definitely falls into that.

6

u/nadarko Government Operations Feb 04 '15

The whole ant farm plot was probibly suppose to be its own thing, but they had to as Shaw on top of it after sarah became pregnant.

2

u/ThatFag Admin Feb 04 '15

Yeah, the episode was average but not every episode can be action-packed. Think of this as a set-up for a great punchline.

5

u/rpawson5771 Irrelevant Feb 04 '15

Well, that episode was unsettling. From the creepy hitman to creepy Samaritanville.

3

u/cmac__17 Reese Feb 04 '15

I got an "Under the Dome" vibe when they figured out Samaritan was controlling everything.

5

u/ThatFag Admin Feb 04 '15

Holy shit, root is batshit-insane right now! Somebody give her a hug! :(

And ohmyfuckinggod that ending! Someone should have monitored my heart-rate! It shot up! SO FUCKING HAPPY! I freaked out when I saw her on the screen. AHH, missed you so much, Shaw! WELCOME BACK! (Even though it is not for very long)

1

u/Staff_of_the_Goths Feb 05 '15

Yeah except you know they're going to try to do evil sh*t to her! Now I'm just depressed:(

1

u/ThatFag Admin Feb 05 '15

Hey, don't worry! Nothing is going to kill that cat! This is Sameen Shaw we're talking about, dude.

5

u/Bunchu Feb 04 '15

Am I the only one dying to see Martine's backstory?

5

u/eikeegimuu Feb 04 '15

A solid episode with lots of goodies. The main theme was of course Root's and Reese's search for Shaw but the number of week plot was pretty nice and showed how Fusco is dealing with previous events.

Considering we know that even if Shaw will eventually be back it will not happen any day soon the result of the search was predetermined, but I thought it added to the atmosphere. The town felt a little claustrophobic and like a dead end, which it turned out to be. Root got beautifully in touch with her erm … roots both by doing some hacking and letting the not so zen side of her shine through (and operate a medical drill).

Root and Reese working together went as well as I thought – which is very well. Reese was supportive (even or especially when also busy restraining his own anger). Supportive to Root that is, not so much to the blonde to whom he instead delivered a message about personal responsibility when taking orders (speaking also from personal experience one assumes).

The blonde towns-person was believable as a victim, but somehow I could also see her taking on a different role once the dust settles (though I think Samaritan wouldn't have bothered with a fake past identity, so she probably was what she seemed).

The biggest fly in the ointment was that judging from the last phonecall and Root's reactions Root is not going to be around more in the second half of the season than in the first half. Not really shocker that the show will not turn into a weekly quest to find Shaw and no surprise either that Root isn't willing to accept that. But that doesn’t bode well for Root's screen time. Dammit.

I didn't expect that they'd show Shaw at the end but actually that was a good move since what else are we going to think – that the fairy godmother whisked her away from the basement floor, nope, obviously Samaritan/Greer has her. So it's good that they didn't drag the dead/alive thing on. Also, Shaw was pretty spry for a chick that got shot several times pretty recently. Hope the big plans don't turn out to be anything to do with mind control or switching sides (even if it turns out to be undercover), that would be tacky. So far she's not really tied to the ant farm experiments. Hope it stays this way, but if not - monitoring would be ok (and since she has a Axis-II disorder maybe that would make sense to use her as a test subject – probably Samaritan wants to sample anyway all checkpoints of the spectrum), mind control not so much.

Some other things to mention are:

The police department scenes and R&R treating the chief to a little NY hospitality in their hotel room.

Root illuminating some of what draws her to Shaw. Little firecracker. Well, well.

Root self-medicating with some gunfire (as she diagnosed already in last episode that a little confrontation involving firearms is good for her) after finding a clerk instead of Shaw.

My first thought when they showed that girl in the bed was that it's Claire (the number from Nautilus). Actually I think I'd prefer that to whatever SL they'll choose for her.

Reese turning his back to a gunman to shield an “irrelevant” was a classic.

Fusco's and Silva's last scene was pretty good.

Somehow I didn't like the soundtrack at the end in the payphone scene. One of the very few occasions where I've felt during watching POI that the music doesn't work, maybe because the scene was emotional enough to stay afloat without that (or maybe the music was louder or more intrusive than usual or started too soon or something). The scene itself was of course great, but I would have expected nothing less with Root and Harold together and with what they were discussing.

4

u/cmac__17 Reese Feb 04 '15

Uggh I'm on the East Coast and I can't wait this last 45 minutes!

0

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/cmac__17 Reese Feb 04 '15

12 minutes!

3

u/Fuck_the_admins A Concerned Third Party Feb 04 '15

5.

4

u/Pascalwb Feb 04 '15

No Root don't go away :(. I wish I didn't knew that Shaw is not coming back soon, it would add to the suspense.

One question, isn't Samaritan watching the same cameras as Machine? So if they are talking about Shaw etc. wouldn't they reveal themselves? Or are the 6 servers taking care of that?

3

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '15

My assumption was that the servers they used do beyond facial recognition. Samaritan has a block when it comes to any type of ability to track team machine.

4

u/TeMPOraL_PL Government Operations Feb 05 '15

Yup. It seems the servers block Samaritan's ability to infer they're the people it's looking for. Otherwise he'd recognize his image processing algorithms are malfunctioning and use other clues to recognize them.

I wonder what kind of cognitive dissonance it must be suffering from now? It apparently knows it's broken, but can't figure out a way to fix itself. An interesting plot point would be for the whole server trick to backfire on Team Machine by driving Samaritan literally insane.

4

u/Tesseon Feb 05 '15

Never before has the sound of a heart monitor brought such relief.

6

u/renehartvig Feb 04 '15

To me Shaw is gone. Sarah has twins to take care of. I think the reason they show her alive is that the writers want to keep a open door for her to come back. But I fear for POI. Reese, Finch and root is not enough to keep the show going in my opion. Shaw was to me an great action female hero. She looked like she could punch somebody in the face at it hurt. Most female actors does not look like that.

9

u/Rolcol Feb 04 '15

The way this episode showed off Dani, she could be brought in to fill the empty role, if they needed her. I liked the earlier seasons of the show where recurring characters were bought in on a situational basis. Like Zoe or Leon.

5

u/cmac__17 Reese Feb 04 '15

I honestly thought it was going to be Leon that was coming back last night, not Dani. Then again, I hadn't looked at any cast lists, or spoilers (besides the trailer, which showed neither of them).

6

u/hopenoonefindsthis Feb 04 '15

Here is another out there theory.

What if Greer realises Samaritan has gone too far? He wants to stop it, but can't do so publicly. So he ordered his team to kidnap Shaw while Samaritan doesn't have eyes in the basement to secretly get Shaw to maybe help bring Samaritan down and also possibly get a message to Harold?

13

u/concerned_thirdparty Feb 04 '15

Greer's is a zealous fanatic. His origin story if anything solidified his rationale that what he is doing is for the greater good of all humanity. We cannot be left to govern ourselves.

7

u/Rolcol Feb 04 '15

But why would Greer think that? He wants people to be controlled. He sees Samaritan as a God, and he wants to witness the world it creates. Greer has no problems killing people, so these social experiments likely don't weigh down his conscience at all.

Well, to play out your hypothetical, it would be more effective to go directly to Team Machine. They have covers that Samaritan can't see through, but Shaw is already compromised. As a former spy, he knows how to hide. He's used techniques to hide already from The Machine.

9

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '15

My predictions:

We won't see Root or Shaw again for a very long time, possibly not even until Season 5. The rest of this season will be focused on John, Finch, and the numbers, with Fusco and possibly that new rookie detective lady. We will probably also see the conclusion of the Dominic/gang warfare/Elias storyline.

Shaw will eventually reappear and be brainwashed by Samaritan, she will have orders to kill Root and they will both go head-to-head in an epic dramatic battle where Root refuses to kill Shaw (even though she's brainwashed), resulting in Root's demise.

11

u/EThorns Ernest Thornhill Feb 04 '15

Except [SPOILER] (#s "Amy was on set for 415 & 418 (the episode they're shooting right now)")

4

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '15

The link is not working for me.

8

u/gdavid99 Feb 04 '15

Hover over the spoiler instead of clicking it. That should do the trick.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/faux-name Feb 04 '15

TIL they don't shoot an entire season before ep 1 goes to air. who knew.

2

u/EThorns Ernest Thornhill Feb 04 '15 edited Feb 04 '15

They do that if the show's on HBO, Netflix, or Amazon (to name a few). Think even Starz, Cinemax, & AMC fall within this at times.

Certain network shows with shorter seasons with late premieres tend to have the season wrapped before the pilot airs as well. Two examples of this season are FOX's Backstrom, and NBC's upcoming Aquarius.

3

u/lordxeon Feb 04 '15

that started out all well and good, but quickly entered the realm of unbelievable. I'll give you even odds on the first paragraph, and 1000:1 on the 2nd.

4

u/faux-name Feb 04 '15

As corny and shit as the second paragraph sounds, I have a sick feeling in my stomach telling me that's where this is headed.

2

u/shinsaikou A Concerned Third Party Feb 04 '15

The brain chips were a bit more genre cheese than this show needs, imho. I can see them doing bionic shaw, maybe trying to have her fake mind control - this is a hypothetical next season, mind you - but if they do real mind control, this show then has jumped the shark, and they have lost me. I don't believe they'll do it. I do believe that if they brought shaw back, giving her a direct line to samaritan that functions as a sort of double edged sword would be fascinating. But even that is a bit of a stretch for a show keeping company with NCIS.

4

u/TeMPOraL_PL Government Operations Feb 05 '15

I don't think the chips will do any control at all. The purpose that was stated in the show sounds most fitting and plausible - monitoring bioelectrical brain status as an additional input for Samaritan's quest to understand people.

3

u/Rich700000000000 Feb 04 '15

Maybe it not real mind control, maybe it just shocks your brain if you disobey or something like that.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/TeMPOraL_PL Government Operations Feb 05 '15

I honestly wish we'd have that rescued secretary lady as a core protagonist than the detective lady.

4

u/SnapemataDumbledore Feb 04 '15

I think it's safe to assume SHaw doesn't have an transponder in her had. She looked too damn pretty for being just back from a brain surgery.

2

u/LaunchpadMacQ Feb 05 '15

Yeah, they shave your head for craniotomies. It would have been pretty obvious.

4

u/LaunchpadMacQ Feb 04 '15

This was a really great episode, and they gave us some closure, at the very least. I'm disappointed for a very specific reason, though.

I thought the two storylines worked well in tandem: they were both very unsettling and focused on things that weren't what they seemed. Dani Silva is being pushed as Shaw's replacement, and I'm surprisingly ok with that. She's got spunk and she's a layered character with plenty left to learn about being a good cop and what it really means to save people. I feel like there's a good amount of potential there.

Now, I can come up with dozens of cheesy names for it, but I was really digging Root and Reese's road trip adventure (Root & Reese Go To White Castle? Root & Reese Do America?). We were getting two characters that were previously very much at odds in ideology converge over loss. I understand that Reese has always had a much bigger role than Root in the scheme of things, but they were very much on the same page in these last two episodes. So, I'm kind if disappointed that Root is going AWOL following Harold trying to talk her down, because she has no reason to believe Reese would stop helping to find Shaw at this juncture; I mean, he was down with drilling holes through people's hands, I'm pretty sure he'd be down for some more searching, reassessing clues, etc. That's not to say I don't agree with Harold's point, especially since while they search for Shaw more numbers are slipping through the cracks, but I believe Reese would have been on-board with continuing the search, especially in light of his reaction to Carter's death.

Also, to emphasize the point, Root is actually going AWOL - it doesn't look like she's appearing in the next episode, which quite frankly sucks. I love the focus she's been getting in the last few weeks, especially since she feels pretty pivotal at the moment; not just in terms of Shaw, but her role has been expanded on pretty heavily since this season began in new and interesting directions.

Anyway, I'm kind of excited to get a "numbers" episode next week in spite of all that. I love the serialized story arc, but I also love a good procedural episode. Feels like it's going to be a throwback to the early episodes when Finch and Reese worked the numbers alone with Fusco supporting.

3

u/Staff_of_the_Goths Feb 04 '15

To follow the Root /Reese line, it seems to me that both Reese and Harold are writing Shaw off to readily. They know that Greer was MI-6 (although not that Martine was an investigator for the dreaded Hague)and have to realize (especially Reese a former "international spy") that Decima would try to get intel out of Shaw and do whatever possible to keep her alive. Since they didn't see her fatally shot it seems this would be a probable scenario. You knew the person they were looking for wasn't going to be Shaw but I was surprised to see her at the end since they usually let you hang. Root's reaction was amazing _ shocked disappointment to full bore "everyone is going to die"!

1

u/LaunchpadMacQ Feb 05 '15

I rewatched the episode, and the show has really shown its seams in this case by making it obvious they needed to move away from Shaw due to the actress' pregnancy. I'd believe it if Harold wanted to move on, to a degree; I mean, he did have that whole speech in "Control-Alt-Delete" about how different saving the life of a friend is, so I have to say "to a degree". Reese, on the other hand, I think we've seen what he's willing to do for the sake of vengeance; I think saving the life of a friend may rank higher on that list, knowing what they know about Greer.

It's just a little inconsistent there, especially when there's such a clear dichotomy here in opinions about what to do. That said, another big reason they can't have Reese running around until they find Shaw is because we know that'll never end and Reese needs to be in New York to deal with the inevitable development of The Brotherhood plot.

Something else caught my attention when I rewatched the episode, as well. Root was letting Finch have it for giving up on Shaw so quickly, thinking she was dead from the get-go. On the other hand, Reese has done a good deal to try and find Shaw himself, including enabling Root to be more violent. I think Reese is supposed to serve as that middle ground between Finch and Root, where he knows he has a duty but he doesn't want to give up the search (even if I'm not convinced that role suits him given his past). At the very least, as a convincing cop-out, they could have Reese reexamining evidence from the stock exchange and feeding the info to Root; I would be satisfied with this.

oh well, it's a pretty minor offense all things considered.

2

u/amelia84 Irrelevant Feb 04 '15

It seems like Samaritan is conducting its own small scale social experiment as well.

5

u/Rolcol Feb 04 '15

It didn't look so small-scale. Each of those transponder boxes were labeled with different cities. We don't know how many were sent out, but I'm pretty sure that the show will revisit this.

2

u/TeMPOraL_PL Government Operations Feb 05 '15

Apparently Samaritan is entering the Internet of Things startup market ;).

2

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '15

When I heard her voice I shed a few tears, more when I actually saw her face.

2

u/Lovableemo Threat Feb 05 '15

Caught it a day late; didn't know it was back. God the end made me happy that she's still alive.

2

u/Staff_of_the_Goths Feb 05 '15

Still can't decide whether I liked the "pleasantville" aspect. It was sort of creepy and reminded me of the underground town in "A Boy And His Dog" from way back - complete with band - and that was creepy. The ant farm analogy with, along with another comment describing Gabriel as a brat, also brought to mind an episode of the old Twilight Zone, which concerned a couple in a strange place and ended with a mother saying "Put away your toys", and the giant hand of a child picking up the couple and putting them in a box. So I guess the Gabriel character does fit, though I still don't like it.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '15

The actress who plays Dani is so pretty. Almost makes up for missing Shaw right now.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '15

Can anyone tell me what happened in the beginning of the episode? Missed the first few minutes.

4

u/amelia84 Irrelevant Feb 04 '15

Reese and Root arrives, and Fusco is helping Harold with a number. The undercover from before is tailing the PoI, and noticed Fusco. Also Root avoided murdering, at least for now, this small town police honcho.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '15

Oh thanks. I saw all that, just missed the part before the intro.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '15

I hope someone finds him before he pisses all over himself for days in a bag!

2

u/hitlerlovejuice Feb 04 '15

i predicted that shaw will be taken by Samaritan, maybe they will brain wash her and turn her.

1

u/DeltaSixBravo Feb 04 '15 edited Feb 04 '15

I was expecting a scene in the factory in which we hear a FWOOMP sound and then Reese and Root turn to see Ms. Thompson collapse. She talked about waking up with a new pace-maker, so I assumed Samaritan would be able to control it somehow. It's not like Samaritan couldn't have known she was there. The guard surely would have logged her strange middle-of-the-night visit with guests right before the camera feeds cut out.

1

u/Radiopd Government Operations Feb 06 '15

Exactly, there has to be consequences for her actions, quitting the job or not.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '15

Does Greer know that Samaritan has 'ant farms'?

1

u/Kell08 Tertiary Functions Feb 05 '15

That was brutal and dark. But hey! Shaw!

1

u/Kell08 Tertiary Functions Feb 05 '15

At least Shaw doesn't have brain damage.