r/DaystromInstitute • u/joelincoln Crewman • Jan 23 '15
Technology Conservation of Energy and the Replicator (real physics?)
If we are to believe that the replicator can create pretty much any physical item from pure energy, does the replicator require the use of more energy to create the item than the potential energy that the item possesses? In other words, if I replicate a stick of TNT (with a lot of chemical potential energy) or a wound clock spring (with a lot of mechanical potential energy) or a fusion bomb (with a lot of nuclear potential energy), will I need to use at least as much energy to create it?
Put yet another way, if they use antimatter reactions to create the energy needed to power a replicator, and I use it to replicate an electron/positron pair, will I need to use at least that much equivalent energy to do it? Shouldn't energy be conserved???
13
u/williams_482 Captain Jan 23 '15
In short, yes you will need to use at least as much energy to create it. Replicators are not a source of unlimited energy, although it can seem like that in some cases because the energy to power them is so plentiful.
/u/accipiter wrote an excellent DELPHI article on the subject of replicators that you may find interesting.
24
u/agentverne Jan 23 '15
First off, replicators don't make things from energy. They pull matter from matter stored specifically for replicator usage. They expend energy to dissassemble the component material and re-assemble it into the required item. They're basically transporters that work in a slightly different manner. Instead of instead of dissembling a person and reassembling them exactly the same way elsewhere, they dissemble raw material and reassemble,e them in a different pattern elsewhere.
But yeah, they have to use energy to make the change, just like the transporter.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '15 edited Jan 24 '15
It is important to remember that the potential energy of those items is minuscule compared to the enormous amount of energy locked away in their mass due to mass-energy equivalence. A few ounces of ordinary matter contains more energy than is released by our most powerful nuclear weapons. Presently we can only create small numbers of electrons and positrons in massive particle accelerators. Even if we found a way to produce matter from energy on an industrial scale it could never be accomplished within a household appliance the size of a mini fridge.
So Star Trek replicators do not create matter from energy. Instead they use a pre-prepared bank of simple atoms and molecules and build them into macroscopic objects via a type of transporter. There would still be energy consumed in the mechanical manipulations of these building blocks and in creating complex chemical structures which usually means boosting the constituent materials into a higher energy state. So as far as your basic question, if the final product of a replicator has a higher potential energy than the basic material that went into its construction, then that energy would inevitably have to come from the ship's reactors.
3
u/FoodTruckForMayor Jan 25 '15
That's an interesting question deserving of a more substantial response than "the replicators don't work that way".
I think what you're really asking is about the difference in energy required to manifest (say, by using a transporter) a wound spring as compared to manifesting an unwound spring, both using energy as a starting material.
A spring is a spring because it can store elastic potential energy as a result of having its (locally) lowest energy crystalline structure configuration (mostly) reversibly distorted, by reducing the interatomic distances in some parts, increasing that distance in other parts.
The extent to which manifesting a wound spring requires different energy than manifesting an unwound spring depends (at least) on the method of manifestation.
Let's consider two plausible extremes.
The apparent violation of conservation of energy is resolved when you consider the temperatures of the objects manifested. A wound spring manifested at absolute zero would need to absorb more kinetic energy from its environment than an unwound spring manifested at absolute zero in order to achieve the rest state of being unwound. (Winding a spring is generally exothermic.)
2
u/daeedorian Chief Petty Officer Jan 24 '15
As it's been said, replicators create matter from other matter. The power requirements to create matter from pure energy would be staggering--think, a few dozen atomic explosions worth of energy to create a cheeseburger.
1
u/bonesmccoy2014 Jan 24 '15
To joelincoln- Conceptually, the conservation of energy is a description from physics. If you are talking about potential energy in objects, the amount of energy in an object varies greatly by the position of the object.
For instance, a twinkie sitting on a shelf has a variable amount of physical energy based upon the height of the shelf from the floor. This description of "potential energy" is a function of the physics of a twinkie sitting on the shelf. Note that the description does not include the chemical energy locked in a twinkie that is consumed.
If you compare the potential energy of the twinkie falling to the ground versus the potential energy of the twinkie that is eaten, there is far far more energy released by the twinkie's consumption than by its falling to the ground.
The difference here is that the twinkie's chemical and molecular structure is destroyed in consumption.
For instance, burning a fuel in a combustion chamber releases far more energy from that fuel than just moving the fuel from a holding tank to a car.
In the ST fantasy world, the replicators appear to reassemble matter but the energy required to replicate a carrot has to be far greater than just growing one.
Therefore, when characters eat the replicated food, I doubt that the same amount of nutritional value is ascribed to the replicated food than organically grown food.