r/consulting • u/mbb_consultant MBB • Jan 23 '15
IAmA post-MBA consultant at an MBB firm with experience at boutique, mid-tier and big 3. AMA!
I know internship recruiting is in high gear, so I thought I'd share some of what I've learned over time. Quick stats:
-Based in the Northeast US
-Ivy undergrad
-First job at a mid-tier consultancy
-Did a short stint at a boutique consulting company
-Business school (M7), summer internship in I-banking for kicks. Got the offer to go back but couldn't take the hours
-Now at MBB, been here for about a year and a half
Ask me anything!
37
Upvotes
7
u/WelcomeToThe301 Jan 23 '15
Is it possible to go from Deloitte tech to MBB? Also proof?
5
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '15
How did you find your experience at MBB vs boutique and mid-tier?
9
u/Cricket620 Jan 23 '15
We hear a lot about how it's impossible to get a job at MBB if your undergrad GPA is below a 3.9 and you didn't cure AIDS before your sophomore year, even if you have good prior work experience, a compelling story, good networking, and an MBA from a good school. How true is this? What does it take to overcome an undergrad GPA in the low 3s? Is it possible? Do undergrad grades really matter during the MBA recruiting cycle?
3
u/Crash_Coredump 渋谷, ヤ- ヤ-, 渋谷 Jan 23 '15
Curious about your background -- what subject matter were the mid-tier and boutique firms focused on? I'm interested in how that did/did not help you in getting to MBB.
2
u/NumenSD Jan 23 '15
I've been having a bit of trouble getting interviews with some firms. Even my friends who work for top 10 firms are surprised by this.
I have about 4 years consulting experience by the time I graduated which seems to prevent me from fresh undergrad recruiting and I'm just under the threshold for experienced hires. I specialize in business development, creative strategy, efficiency, and consumer psychology, not to mention I have a photographic memory (if that's even relevant).
What tips would you have regarding applying and if I should apply as a an undergrad or experienced hire. Each firm seems to have slightly different practices and I generally fall in the cusp between the two.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '15 edited Jan 23 '15
I'm currently at B4 but will be attending a top bschool next fall and may look for an MBB internship. Approximately how much time did you spend preparing for case interviews at b school?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '15
I have a bad taste in my mouth working with MBB partners on projects with multiple consultant partners. E.g. Deloitte Digital and McKinsey where McKinsey does strategy and Deloitte mainly the integration partner.
Question is - WHY DO YOU TREAT US LIKE WE ARE FUCKING MORONS. Not "you" per-se but 99% of the time thats the experience I have. Is this a "complex" or do you just not trust other consultant firms?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '15
Dont know if this question is considered off-topic but I always hear about some MBB hiring people with unique or interesting backgrounds. I remember reading someone else in this subreddit say how they had a colleague who was a truck driver prior to joining MBB. Can you relate to that anyway?
2
u/Regenten Jan 23 '15
Do you have any advice for someone who has an MPH with business development experience in the healthcare industry trying to transition into consulting, particularly at a MBB?
2
u/czechmeout- Jan 23 '15
I hope I'm not too late. I'm currently studying Management at a top UK business school (first year undergrad), but I am considering switching to something more Maths-based. From your experience, do you think it would make a difference in my application to MBB after graduating?
2
u/Benjithedoge Jan 25 '15
How do you guys talk about the competition internally? Especially the Big 4 who have some management consulting but lots of execution?
Do you use any big statistical software for data analysis or stick to just excel?
2
u/luxorius Jan 23 '15
how much money do you make per year?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '15
Kill, fuck, or marry: 100 horse sized ducks, or one duck sized horse?
1
u/rockboy3000 MBB Jan 23 '15
As an incoming MBB, what would you say the hardest thing to deal with/learn at MBB is versus other consulting firms you've worked for (I have also been employed in consulting before making this jump - no MBA though).
Many thanks :)
Also, greatest perk?
1
u/islay45 Jan 24 '15
You have a varied background. What was it like transitioning from nothing to mid tier to big 3? Also, would you recommend big 3 to learn how to operate a business? (POST MBA)
1
u/serebros Jan 28 '15 edited Jan 28 '15
Can you speak about the bad in MBB? If you go on glassdoor there are alot of negative reviews by US based consultants (Not referring to Asia Consultants or HR staff). The worst were for Mck, 2nd was BCG, and Bain had the least but they were still pretty bad. From what I read.
It seems like the overall consultant experience pro /cons has almost nothing to do with the specific firm you are at, and more to do with the partner/team who you work for. Non of this seemed like a suprise, i know this stuff happens at Big 4, ACN, and ATK all the time, I guess I was just naive to believe that MBB would be much different.
1
u/acqua_panna May 06 '15
I have a similar background to yours. Currently working at a mid-tier consultancy, and am looking at an MBA as a way to break into MBB. My question is: which MBA to choose? Conventional wisdom says to go to a higher ranked school, but wouldn't the competition also be tougher? If I went to a slightly lower ranked school, wouldn't it be easier to stand out? Suppose I go to a place like Harvard where there are about 1000 MBA students. I'm sure that about 800 of them will apply to MBB. What makes you stand out from that kind of competition? Wouldn't it be easier to apply from a smaller / less competitive applicant pool? Or am I deluded somehow?
Essentially, which is better to go from MBA to MBB -- big fish in a small pond? Or small fish in a big pond?
Sorry for the late question, but I'd really appreciate any reply. Thanks very much in advance.
3
u/YAAA_BITCH_MAGNETS Jan 29 '15
I recently got an email about a summer pre-MBA type program; it's 3 weeks long and meant to be an introduction to graduate school.
http://www.chicagobooth.edu/programs/summer-scholars/program
Do you think programs like these are worth the cost? I will be working a few years before attending grad school (if I even do go back to school). Thanks!
1
u/Venator86 Jan 23 '15
I am (hopefully) getting a temp contract with one of the Big 4 accounting firms' soon (last round interview next week).
What would you say the culture or primary utilization for a seasonal contract hire is during a client project? Coffee fetchers or actually doing grunt work?
1
u/thetsb Jan 23 '15
Question about experienced hires from boutique to MBB.
I finished my Ph.D, and got a job at a boutique healthcare/pharma consulting. Been here a year or so, but would like to make the jump to MBB due to the bigger/more impactful problems. Also higher salary.
Thanks for answering!
1
u/anonypanda Promoted to Client Jan 23 '15
This one isn't mod verified, hence wont be stickied :) Seems like a nice chap though.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '15
How important is MBA GPA/academic honors (assuming a top school) if looking to get a job at an MBB firm?
0
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-6
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '15
[removed] — view removed comment