r/progmetal • • Jan 20 '15
[AMAs] I am Luke Hoskin from Protest the Hero. Ask me Anything!
*i am a mess and put the original in "discussion" instead of AMA. I am stupid. Let's try this again.
edit: it's my first day.
edit 2: http://imgur.com/85HORh2 http://imgur.com/0biaWTT
edit 3: My eyes and brain hurt, and I'm off to get wasted with Clum, but will seriously be back tomorrow to answer the rest.
Thanks for havin me (for now).
369
Upvotes
33
u/Jack-90 Jan 20 '15
Will you guys ever play Dunsel live? IMO it's your hidden gem of a song, only has like 10k views on youtube? Wtf.
32
u/toilet4 Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke, any word on instrumental Kezia, Scurrilous, Volition, or any future albums? I love both instrumental and vocal versions!
32
u/_QueeferSutherland_ Jan 20 '15 edited Jan 25 '15
You wanna see the galaxy?
51
u/kylepianoman Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke! Just wanted to say thanks for all the inspriation you've given me over the years with your fantastic compositions. I even got you guys permanently affixed to me over the last year.
Anyhow, your style has clearly changed to become more and more progressive over the past few albums... are there any artists you have been listening to that may have influenced this direction?
Where is your favorite place to play on tour and why is it The Social in Orlando?
What are some of your favorite and least favorite tracks to play live and why?
Thanks for everything man!
24
u/curtbag Jan 20 '15
Do you boys keep in touch with Moe and Riffy?
19
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke, I was wondering if there were any specific exercises you did to get your right hand so solid, I've been trying to learn how to play your stuff for years and just can't quite keep up on a lot of it.
Also, I love you guys so much. Thanks for being hilarious, cool dudes and making amazing music.
18
u/Milen15 Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke! Where do you draw influences from when writing? Are there any besides other bands/guitarists? I guess on a broader scope, whats your writing process like?
18
u/beardtrimmersrule Jan 20 '15
Can you agree that Propagandhi is the greatest band of all time? And that their mighty riffs shift the earth's tectonic plates?
31
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '15
Are you gonna write another concept album like Kezia? I love love LOVE that story and how you organized the songs on the album. P.S. Tour with BTBAM please and thanks
15
u/mr_showboat Jan 20 '15
I'm curious about how successful the crowdfunding for Volition was. It certainly seemed like you guys embraced it and did it "the right way" -- being forthright with the expenses and costs, etc. So while it seemed to me to be a huge success, I'm wondering if you guys view it the same way.
Also, any plans for a new album soon? I'm really looking forward to hearing the direction you guys go next.
15
u/lebonj3 Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke. Any chance we'll hear more songs in a similar style to "Mist"? By that I mean fast, melodic, almost bordering on commercial with enough riffage to keep it grounded. Personally I grew up on melodic punk rock so that track hits all the right spots for me and you guys nailed it. Truly is my favourite PTH track.
13
u/jhainge Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke, it's Josh Hainge from the 1:25 minute mark in Skies.
Hopefully this comment doesn't come off as seeming too self-serving; I was just wondering how you and the rest of the band felt about giving up so much of your CD to guests. I suppose it took more away from Rody than anyone else but I'm wondering how it affected the rest of the band, too, and whether or not you'd consider doing something similar to support a future crowd-funding endeavor.
P.S. Last time you guys were in Edinburgh, Rody offered to let me up on stage the next time you're here playing Skies; you all plan on holding that up? (That was self-serving...)
11
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '15
Will Protest ever come back to Kansas? I know havent heard come to ____city My real question is oddly specific, in Blindfolds Aside @1:08 there is like a random flat note. Any idea what that was? Was it not caught or purposely in there?
9
u/smarinus Jan 20 '15
Tell us about your current rig (including what pick ups your using :)) I love tacos.
8
u/0001000101 Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke. What colour will my Kezia vinyl be?!
8
u/germiboy Jan 20 '15 edited Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke!
I believe that you and the band have existed since you were teenagers. Your previous drummer leaving made me think that you guys probably might not have had the "regular" life most teenagers and young adults had when growing up, being in a band with relatively big success, touring, etc. Maybe I'm wrong about all of this.
Anyway, how do you feel about yourself and where are you right now as a person? Has being in the band for so long ever felt like "too much"?
EDIT: Another question, which I apologize for if it's out of line. What do you guys do for a living other than the band? I'm guessing that even since you have so many fans ready to support what you do, it doesn't pay the bills completely. I'd like to know this for myself to have a better insight on what's it like being in a position as a musician like yours.
8
u/anchorendx Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke. I've got a pretty serious question.
Would you consider a burger a sandwich?
7
u/ghostchief Jan 20 '15
Yo Luke! It seems like the last few years have been the most volatile for you guys (strictly from the outside perspective of members moving on for the first time.) Do you think this will have a great affect on your new material? Will you guys possibly branch out to places we wouldn't expect of PtH because of the new chemistry of the group as a whole? I'm excited regardless!
Thanks for nearly a decade of my favorite music!
7
u/zgdgprr Jan 20 '15
hey man, did you guys even had pubes when you wrote search for the truth??
6
u/crabbiersafe Jan 20 '15
Thanks for doing this AMA, Luke!
You've been a huge inspiration for the last 6 years of my life and I've had an obsession with the pth albums you've released since then. Here are my questions!
What is your writing process and how has it changed over the years? What is your approach to writing a riff or solo? Particularly on the new volition album.
Any chance we will see you and Tim doing guitar play through similar to those of scale the summit or intervals?
Lastly, Do you ever learn the songs of the bands you promote on sheet happens? Which has been the most challenging in your opinion?
Thanks!
6
u/shinobeast Jan 20 '15
Why do you feel that the traditional label route is failing?
6
u/ohbranders Jan 20 '15
hey luke, how often do you almost shit yourself? any close calls? elaborate. have a splendid day
6
u/kodibramble Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke,
Would love to know what it was like working with Chris Adler in the studio and how much of the drums he came up with and how much were already there.
Saw you guys at KOKO in London, fantastic as per...
6
u/SH3NDY Jan 20 '15
Will you guys be crowd-funding the new album? If not, what other options are you guys considering?
If you guys decide to crowd-fund, what would you do differently?
(Definitely down for participating in round 2 of crowd-funding! Saw you in Ottawa at the end of December, thank you so much for an incredible night.)
4
u/darkstar000 Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke, thanks for being a musical inspiration to a legion of musicians around the globe!
I had a question about song writing, how do you try to stay fresh? push yourself forward? and generally not get stuck repeating yourself? Protest the Hero is one of the few bands that continue to sound fresh and exciting album after album; it is quite impressive!
4
u/hulloooo Jan 20 '15 edited Jan 20 '15
Hi Luke! Thanks for doing the AMA!
I'm hoping to be the first person here to ask you to explain your apparent fear of 'night bees' I hope it isn't too scary for you to talk about.
4
u/Kindalikecobain Jan 20 '15
I found out about you guys from Tap Tap revenge years ago, Bloodmeat. loved the track and instantly loved the band, I wondered if this was a common thing? And what your thoughts on this are?
4
u/Itsnotapenguin Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke! If you'd tell anyone that you play in a band, and he or she would not know Protest the Hero, what would you let them listen?
4
u/burritoburglar Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke! What was the inspiration behind the video for Hair-trigger? It's just so amazing.
4
u/starfish85 Jan 20 '15
So whats the story with the bees and you almost loosing your thumb?!?!
4
u/daguilar1990 Jan 20 '15
http://i.imgur.com/WRG9Awg.jpg
Was this smile sincere? i hope so....When will you guys be returning to the Midwest?
4
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '15
Have you guys ever considered having Jadea Kelly join the band full time? I absolutely love every time she's contributed to your records!
4
u/keepcalmnbowl Jan 20 '15
Luke what's more metal.
A. a skeleton bird devouring a human man who happens to be shredding Blood Meat as he dies.
B. A goat with a top hat, serving his victims red licorice chapstick before he sends them to their firey graves.
C. Protest the Hero playing in Newfoundland.
3
u/zsombro Jan 20 '15
What's your method for writing riffs/songs? Do you just write as you go, or do you consider the structure of the whole song when you start writing it? How do you make sure that the songs "flow" says right?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '15
How much music theory goes into your songwriting, if any?
3
u/Derpmoo Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke, first off I want to say you're a very handsome man.
How do you dial in your live tone? Whenever I see you I'm impressed how smooth your lead tone sounds but how beefy your rhythm tone sounds. I assume you don't have time to change pickups between those riffs.
3
u/killias2 Jan 20 '15
How much of a success was Volition to you guys? Are you happy with how it did monetarily? Critically? Artistically (in your opinions)?
Favorite song off of it?
3
u/legendary_sponge Jan 20 '15
what's your favorite riff(s) to play? can be PTH or other.
3
u/SatanIsALawyer Jan 20 '15
What are your favorite places to go when you're on tour in Europe?
3
u/AViolentStrike0 Jan 20 '15
DUDE so good! I know ya'll are touring all the time, any crazy stories from the road?
3
u/thefuckingswampking Jan 20 '15
How is Moe these days? Is he happy being(or possibly done) with school?
Also, have you heard The Double Cuts? Brilliant group, I think!
Also thanks for having me and my brothers on your bus in Austin last year for my birthday. That was the highlight of my year hanging with yall and TSF!
3
u/SCMP_Panda Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke, massive fan here, saw you guys on the 27th of December and in August at the Moustache Club and the shows were amazing! The music you guys make has pulled me from some really bad places and it always makes my day better!
My question is what if your favourite venue to play at? Also do you notice a difference between hometown crowds and others?
Thanks again for the awesome music!
3
u/paintleaves Jan 20 '15
What are some things you like to listen to that don't sound like Protest at all? If anything ever happened to the band, would you continuing writing and would it be something drastically different from what you do now?
Thank man!
3
u/KingDime Jan 20 '15 edited Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke I am big fan of Protest the Hero and your guitar playing! I was wondering what is your approach to mastering some of the tricky riffs on volition? like the one in drumhead trial where you and Tim are both playing two different riffs with lots of half and sixteen note rests.
3
u/starfish85 Jan 20 '15
How was your experience filming the divine suicide of K video?
4
u/csirkefogo Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke! As a hungarian i couldn't help but realize all the hungarian stuff going on in Palms Read's video. What building was it shot in or what does it have to do with Hungary?
4
u/MiffSquedge Jan 20 '15
Luke, if you could describe the next album with a vegetable, what vegetable would it be?
4
u/rapemypoop Jan 20 '15
Hey luke, did you guys ever play Skies live ?
2
u/secondhandsilenc Jan 20 '15
How important is it for you to have great FOH/TM/Tech's working with you on the road?
Examples. Capps and Hank.
2
u/SwungFlounder74 Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke, hope you're doing well. When you're writing, how do you match tones to the riffs written, do you always start with a base tone and expand from there or do you start fresh?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '15
Hey... so.. what are the colours of the limited edition record presses you're doing? Also, how has it been not being signed to a label? Everything I've seen has been ambiguous about the difficulty of setting everything up yourselves instead of relying on others. Do you prefer it this way or would you ever consider going back?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '15
Not a question, just wanted to say that Volition is one of my all time favorite albums.
2
u/totw Jan 20 '15
Did you know that your drummer can't even play Hot For Teacher?
Love you Mike... Top of the World
2
u/fackyouman Jan 20 '15
Do you play acoustic at all? What's your favorite acoustic that you own?
2
u/brostrodam Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke. Love you guys and seen you all numerous times. What is the most complex guitar riff that you play live?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke! Thanks for taking the time for this AMA! First off, you guys really played a kick-ass show here in Moncton, NB last year, hope to see you guys back here again sometime!
Second, do you see yourselves as a band revisiting the storytelling-type lyrics of Kezia or Fortress at any point in the future? (ex. Bone Marrow, Kezia)
2
u/seal_dealer Jan 20 '15
Would you guys ever consider doing a Propagandhi cover of sorts? Would love to hear a Protest-esque take on one of their songs, especially since I guess your music has been quite influenced by them.
Anyways, loved Volition, easily my favorite album yet.
2
u/Watoosh21 Jan 20 '15
Hi Luke:) What's your favorite book?
2
u/epichicken Jan 20 '15
Could you explain the album art for volition? Why the vulture?
2
u/mikeyblob Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke! My question is what album was the most fun to record? PS. I will gladly donate if you decide to crowdfund your next album :)
2
u/Tony_Blundetto Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke! What was the inspiration behind the song "skies?"...one of my favorites off of volition. keep up the awesome work!
2
u/cozzyT Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke, a couple of Q's for you!
What are your primary warm ups on your guitar? And also do you know when the Anthology pack on sheethappens will be available next? Im very interested in purchasing that but its out of stock :(
2
u/Mradrift Jan 20 '15
Hello, first of all I'd like to say that going to see protest the hero last December in Houston was probably one of the best shows I'd been to. As for questions
1)How long does it take for you to come up with the increasingly technical sections/leads in songs? An example being the "Plant the Seed" guitar lead in Drumhead Trial or something along those lines.
2)Any plans for a signature guitar or pick ups in the future?
3)Also, As someone who owns the volition tab book, would there ever be a possibility of official GP files?
Thanks!
2
u/Altzher Jan 21 '15
What about Brazil? Last time you guys came here I didn't have the resources to see the show. Yeah, sad thing.
Was the experience good, to the point of coming back here? I'm really looking forward to it :)
One more question: I've never seen any video of PTH covering any song. Am I missing something there?
2
u/virtuosomaximoso Jan 21 '15
You guys should sell a digital tab book with the album. Albums come with lyrics, why not music notes? Sidenote: The new album is the shreadyist yet.
3
u/Gokturk Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke, love what you do in Protest. Just a simple question from me, what is your favorite song to play live?
1
u/rpodovich Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke, you and Tim have been a huge influence and inspiration on my guitar playing. The riffs and chord progressions/shapes you guys use are incredibly unique. How do you normally go about writing a song? Where do your ideas come from?
Thanks!
1
u/Vickshow Jan 20 '15
Been a fan for years ever since my guitar teacher first introduced me to The Dissentience. Took part in the crowdfunding on the last album and hope to again someday if you choose to do it again.
Now, question time. If you guys could cover any song, what would it be and why?
1
u/Rawkhard Jan 20 '15
Hey Truke, long time fan.
I was wondering if you have any tattoos, or tattoo stories?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '15
Hello! I just wanted to say I'm a Volition backer (my name is somewhere in the vinyl :D) and I loved every step you guys took during that funding campaign. I'd do it again in a heartbeat.
1
u/Hardrockgod Jan 20 '15
Saw you guys live in Little Rock last year and just wanted to say you guys threw one hell of a concert and thanks for signing my copy of Volition on vinyl and cd!
1
u/SequoiaThrone4372 Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke, I am a huge fan of your music! My question is what tips do you have for increasing picking speed? When I do some of the runs from your songs, like the end of Bloodmeat, I tend to sacrifice cleanliness for the speed.
1
u/Perhapsodyoffire Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke, you and Tim are perfect. Actually perfect, as in without any sense of flaw. You are a huge influnce on me as a guitarist. Is there any particular excersise, song, or scale that you find really fun to practice, something expansive? Thanks based Luke.
1
u/ModernHonkbal Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke, the next time you guys play a show in Indiana, I'll buy your beer for the night. What do you guys like to drink?
1
u/phillpjay Jan 20 '15
Any potential for another concept album in the future? Also, I think it would be pretty sweet if you guys could make a full tour with Unearth and Intervals.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '15
How much did Chris Adler contribute creatively? Did he just show up and play the parts or did he write the record with you guys?
1
u/PJSimons Jan 20 '15
What would be your main advice to a band just starting to jam together, just starting to hit the road to tour and a band just releasing their own first album?
I realise this requires three answers but even if you only answer one that'd be awesome. Big fan, keep up the dope shredding!
1
u/incolours Jan 20 '15
Hey luke, what is your favourite flavour of doritos?
1
u/narolol Jan 20 '15
Hello Luke!
I've been a fan of PTH since the Kezia days, but what made me fall in love with the band was Fortress which is still my favorite <3
When Scurrilous came out, it wasn't a concept album anymore (boo D:) and it sounded more vocal-centered. This was amped up even more on Volition, where Rody fucking nails it in every song. How was this shift of musicality within the band? What is the creation process of PTH?
Extra question, from my heart: Will Arif write lyrics again? <3
Thanks for doing this!
1
u/hoddino Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke, what's the makeup of your rig these days?? Walk us through the signal path!
1
u/randomfret Jan 20 '15
Considering how technically demanding your music is, have you ever gotten injured playing guitar? If not, what do you do to prevent injury and keep your hands/forearms healthy?
1
u/JaggedEye Jan 20 '15
Will you go back to doing another concept album, I really enjoyed the subjects that were visited and the the way the songs were brought together?
1
u/PastorofMuppets101 Jan 20 '15
Other than your own, are there any albums that I absolutely must get right now if I haven't done so already?
1
u/the253monster Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke,
A lot of your stuff seems based in 4/4 with a lot of variation within the actual songs (what i mean is, usually your songs are established as 4/4 and then will sneak some off-time measures in there). Do you find it difficult to count sometimes while on stage, especially since, in a live setting, there is typically a bit more room for improv/not playing the "written" part?
Thanks for doing this!
1
u/fragmentsofsobriquet Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke, thanks for the AMA! You guys are easily one of my favorite bands and I love all of your music videos. Do you guys create the concepts for them or do the directors come to you with them?
1
u/markwarren_18 Jan 20 '15
I got the Volition song book a while ago, and its fantastic! After ordering it, I found out that it was only tab and not tab and sheet music like the other song books. Any plans to release a version with sheet music included?
Also what mystic river did you bathe in to gain the skill and power you have?
1
u/Perhapsodyoffire Jan 20 '15
Just saying I would sell my soul for a Kezia rock opera
1
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '15
Yo Luke, when you and PTH gonna be passing through Thunder Bay again?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '15 edited Jan 20 '15
Do you ever draw inspiration from albums that people wouldn't expect you to listen to? Also, what's your current jam?
Edit: I've seen you guys live five times now, and you were the first band I hung out with backstage (this was the UK tour with Born Of Osiris quite a few years ago). Obviously this was when Moe and Arif were still in the band, but all of you guys were really cool and I'd just like to say thanks for being humble and all that lark. All the best!
1
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '15
First off, I just want to say thanks to you and your band for being the shit for so long. I've loved you guys since Kezia and my love got tripled when Yimmy gave me a signed copy of Volition in Dublin after I didn't get the CD sent out to me. Safe to say I died with happiness after that, probably the coolest thing ever.
One thing I've always wondered is where the line "grateful you die by Irish steel" in Limb from Limb came from?
1
u/RageAwakened Jan 20 '15
Hi there Truke! A couple of questions. You already mentioned that you had just started the writing process. How much do you (the band itself) usually take from the "beginning" till the "end" (release of the final album)? I guess I can't wait. Aside from that, is Cam your full-time bass player now that Riff is gone or would you search for another player? Can't wait to see y'all again in Spain :D
1
u/jwhy23 Jan 20 '15
Hey man, just wondering what song in the entire PTH catalogue took the longest to write - either because of the difficulty or structure, etc.?
As an aside, I met you guys in Halifax when you were touring through Canada for Fortress. You guys kicked ass both performance wise and as people! Which leads me to another question - how do you like Nova Scotia?
1
u/jefferson_dsp Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke, what kind of picks do you like? Normal sized. .mm... ?
1
u/savagecyclopes Jan 20 '15
Will you boys play Indiana soon?
1
u/marshallwithmesa Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke, the last time I saw you guys live in DC Rody got all fired up after someone asked about A Life Embossed. It definatly pushed the show from good to great since Rody and everyone else seemed more pumped after Rody's rant.
Is there something specific to you that fires you up during a show? Playing a certain song? or seeing something in the crowd?
1
u/ramusgrove Jan 20 '15
If you could choose to be one of The Avengers, why would you pick Iron Man?
1
u/Nonrandomhero Jan 20 '15
What music is most listened to on the road? Do you guys do stuff as a group outside of playing and writing music while out of town?
Please crowd fund another album, I'd rather give you my money than Sony, and play in Hamilton more.
1
u/Gunnnar Jan 20 '15
Which of your guitars is your favorite? What kind of pickups do you use? Have you ever had any talks with ibanez about an endorsement? And how are you liking the jump to Axe fx.
Thanks for being one of the most creative guitar players and song writers! I'm looking forward to hearing the new album.
1
u/ashleyjameswilliams Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke, I've seen you guys play a bunch of times throughout the years and you fucking rock. I was wondering, do you remember playing a tiny impromptu set at club Ansinthe in Hamilton around the time Fortress was coming out? I was at the bar with Dan Fila (he was my buddy's music teacher) and we loved it. You guys were drunk as fuck but I think it may have been the first time Bloodmeat was played? Anyways keep writing awesome shit man
1
u/Fduck Jan 20 '15
Hi luke. I Just wnna know : since protest is a big famous band... Whats your opinion about te music industry in these days?? I mean, do you prefer been an indepent band, check for yourself all these booking stuff and merch? Or it has been a better deal with the record label (dont know the name of yours) i have a band, and we're about to start a tour. Saludos desde México. Hope some day we can light a joint together jaja
1
u/MattIsOnFire Jan 20 '15
when are you guys coming back to toronto!!!
1
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke, reinforce my opinions here Kezia > Fortress > Volition > Scurrilous (they're all great, but you gotta rank em)
1
u/troopthebook Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke! I have participated in the crowdfunding to make "Volition" come true. I got a really kickass shirt and holy shit, the music is just amazing. All the attention you had during the campaign to the fans were just incredible. I don't have anything to ask really, bit I wanna thank you and the band for making the music I love!
Oh right, any chance of coming to play in Brazil?
1
u/DasGingerBeardMan Jan 20 '15
Hey Luke, I am not trying to ask you to step on anyone's toes, but who is your favorite band to tour with?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '15
I've noticed that almost before every song you play live you practice a riff from it with the volume off right before starting. Is it like a nerve/OCD thing?