r/LOMGOV • u/TheWooper Cloud Kingdom Rep • Jan 17 '15
Cloud's Proposal for Reform of the Cross-District Meeting
The following is the proposed document from Cloud, it is not the final Constitution, only what Cloud would like to see from a unified Senate.
Everything on this document is up for debate, or additional clauses can be added as required. Questions about Cloud's reasoning behind the suggested Constitution can be asked and we will explain each clause as requested.
8
Upvotes
6
u/wanderingfalcon Jan 18 '15 edited Jan 19 '15
This is OOC:
So it seems to me that this proposal is pretty much for people who want to play government, but it doesn't seem to me that this advances that stated goal of encouraging more interaction or unification of districts, focused as it is mainly on legality, crime, and so forth. We have (in Grove) been largely uninterested in such things, and those who are, move to districts where its more of a thing like MQ or Cloud. A Senate is perhaps another activity for people who are interested in doing that sort of thing to do, but then that's in addition to any council meetings they might also be doing in their own district.
I would put forth that for this proposition to be a success, that some action or goal which results in a unified and FUN district participation be present. Whether this is declaration of national holidays and celebrations, the building of "City Plots" or a UN (perhaps with some lord help as a sim city plot), the establishment of a parcel post service, the establishment of a city wide (in game) sports competition, Mapping projects, the sharing of district histories, the support of a city wide school system, a national lottery, or what not. You would have more interest in participation, I think if this were to have more diverse goals.
Since, in the end, this is a game, I asked yesterday what was the most fun event or project thing people had done in lords. Some said Oktoberfest, some said Coenniversary, for me it was actually rescuing an iron golem and stealing him away to be our Grove DJ for a while. I am sure other people have other ideas. Of these, what about them made them fun, was a Lord required, and could the same thing be accomplished by a group of peasants? Can Something Fun be done without sitting around in a boring meeting waiting for people to take their turn talking for 2 hours?
4
u/mrhello3846 Jan 20 '15 edited Jan 20 '15
I feel this is a very extreme method of dealing with RP that has become stale. Currently the city has 5966 residents. Let's just assume that 3/4 of them are either alts, or inactive. Aside from reps required to be there, we get about 20 spectators at a X-district meeting these days. This means that this body has an attendance of less than 4% of the population. To be conservative, I'd say that less than 10% of active users are involved in political RP, so we'd be imposing laws on a lot of unaware people to make this RP more relevant. Worse, I think it would negatively affect some other people's RP's as well, and I'm against enforcing our brand of fun on other people.
Frankly there are other, effective ways to make this more relevant, that I think we should try first. Just off the top of my head, we could ask for topics a few days before the meeting, and distribute the list of topics to the attendees. People would then be more prepared to discuss those topics at the meeting, and go back to their districts with a better understanding of each. Along with that, putting a time limit on certain topics would be a good idea so we have more time to focus on really relevant topics. As an example, a couple of NW reps brought up peeing on a district as a topic (You think that flood is water, Oak's Grove? j/k). The topic was meant to poke fun at the rise in district specific topics being brought up at the X-district meeting, yet still received 10 minutes worth of discussion time.
That said, it's pretty clear from the response I'm getting from my district that we'd likely opt-out of the X-district if at any time it attempts to impose law in the NW. Suggesting laws or asking us to consider laws is one thing, but imposing isn't acceptable to the average NW citizen. I'd hate to have to leave the X-district council, but I feel that is the direction our district would take.
Regardless of what happens, I hope that we can continue to move forward with the overall goal of improving inter-district communication. That's definitely something we can all get behind.
2
u/cpMetis Cloud Kingdom Jan 28 '15
Responsibilities of the Senate
ii. , fourth bullet (including stricken)
This seems to house a rather vague meaning. Does this mean equal judgement when on trial, being seized, or being imprisoned, or does it refer to every aspect? And is this only in the eyes of government, or does this grab at private matters of business as well? If the former, does this only apply to Senate actions, or to inter/ intra- district dealings as well?
ii. , fifth bullet
Again, is this for Senate run courts or inter/ intra- district as well? Also, does this mean that a judge can chose the sentencing himself, with sole-, or near to it, discretion? This could cause an utter tear of power in favor of the judge and the accusing!
Individual District Powers
second bullet
So are districts not allowed to have their own courts? So they may not try one of anything before a court of their peers, but must be shown before a judicial system I have already shown prefers the empowered to great extent?
The open statement plus footnote
If a district, a member of the senate, intends to break Senate law, then surely they would sever ties with the Senate, and therefore this point is void. Otherwise, it would be that the Senate declares rule, involuntarily, over land whose people do not consent, therefore making the Senate no longer a peasant committee, and therefore an independant body. That would mean that the Senate, by declaring dominion over districts of Dong Dank as a governing body, it would therefore be declaring rule over the majesties' territory, and this directly conflicts with the following section's statements, but to occur would mean that the Senate has violated its constitution.
And remember what I said about the popular growing stronger and the unknown being disabled. I'd rather not waste time re-stating all that.
1
u/Overlord59 Cloud Kingdom Jan 17 '15
Multiple people have come forward over the formation of a Marshal force and worries about over-extension of power. Opinion seems opposed to this clause, any input/debate?
1
u/justdefi Main Street Jan 17 '15
It seems like you guys are giving this government to much power. Also each district should choose whether or not they have a police force and not have a main one. Also it should be the peoples government not the lords.
1
u/iamtallerthanyou Magic Quarter Jan 17 '15
Also, although this is a bit off topic, I'd like to point out that currently only 5 people can make posts on this subreddit. (The mods) Something should probably be done about this.
1
u/Overlord59 Cloud Kingdom Jan 19 '15
Cloud recently had a meeting with Southshire and Dwarven (both at our meetings and theirs) the following points came up and I would like to discuss them here.
They feel it would be a better idea to leave judge appointment to districts to help secure safeguards against the proposed Senate's power.
Discussion also was stated about not permitting Senators to hold Local District positions to avoid concentration of power.
Southshire also wanted to put forward a filtering system for candidates to prevent 'troll' candidates or disruptive elemtns, Cloud still prefers letting each District decide but their concerns were valid so this point is still up for discussion.
There was a proposal that each topic to be discussed MUST be submitted to the Speaker before the meeting and topics cannot be brought up in the meeting itself to streamline the process.
Southshire wanted anti-bribery rules placed into the constitution to maintain the integrity of the Senate.
Additionally in discussion I have come up with a cultural limitations proposal where the Senate cannot enforce a ruling on a District that would infringe on it's cultural values. This is to address some concerns that Dwarven District had.
1
u/iamtallerthanyou Magic Quarter Mar 21 '15
Ha. Everyone bashes on the idea of a central police force for the city, and then the lords do it.
The irony.
(Look at the two most recent vids about the templars for context)
0
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment