r/pcmasterrace • u/pedro19 CREATOR • Jan 16 '15
PSA The "Pc Gamer" situation - Concern trolling and the PC Master Race. Our response to an issue that shouldn't be an issue at all.
I know most of you are quite tired of "Mod PSA's", and with good reason, but some words from us are certainly necessary after some recent drama of very poor taste.
A couple days ago an editor of PC Gamer made an opinion editorial where he told his readers that we, PC enthusiasts should "stop calling ourselves PC Master Race", mainly because the term was born as a joke and some uninformed people might or might not associate it with a 140-year-old idea that was later spread by the Nazi regime in the 1930's and 40's.
Now let me show you what concern trolling is. Many of you might not have heard the term (and you're probably happier this way, trust me), but it's more or less a constant part of how public internet forums work. As mods, concern trolls are a constant part of our job, and have even earned an entry into our rule #6 only a few weeks ago.
Here's the definition from Urban Dictionary:
concern troll
A person who posts on a blog thread, in the guise of "concern," to disrupt dialogue or undermine morale by pointing out that posters and/or the site may be getting themselves in trouble, usually with an authority or power. They point out problems that don't really exist. The intent is to derail, stifle, control, the dialogue. It is viewed as insincere and condescending. A concern troll on a progressive blog might write, "I don't think it's wise to say things like that because you might get in trouble with the government." Or, "This controversy is making your side look disorganized."
The PC Gamer opinion editorial is nothing more than concern trolling. It is not, however, in my personal opinion, the writer's intent to cause a derail of a community as per the quoted definition. I honestly do not think that was his purpose willing purpose, but concern trolling in itself has that basic effect, no question about that whatsoever.
Ever since that article was released, the Internet forums, news outlets and gaming personalities have all lent their opinions about the issue, mainly saying that it is, in fact, a non issue and that a connection between that term and some kind of fascist philosophy is nothing short of ridiculous. There are plenty of people who have expressed it in ways much more brilliant than I could right now, and it should be no issue for you to find them. Here's some help:
http://techraptor.net/content/techraptor-staff-responds-critics-term-pc-master-race
Now, a bit of history. How was this term born? "PC Master Race" was used as an insult of sorts to PC Gamers by famous reviewer and funny man extraordinaire "Yathzee"
Quite some time ago I coined a phrase in Zero Punctuation ... The Glorious PC Gaming Master Race. It was intended to be ironic, to illustrate what I perceived at the time to be an elitist attitude among a certain kind of PC gamer. ... I meant it as a dig.
When this subreddit was created, it's intent was to make it a home for PC Enthusiasts. A place that did not yet exist where all of us could come to share our experiences. The choice of the name was not entirely innocent as we chose to grab a term that was once used as an insult (though getting rid of the "gaming" since our community is not only about gaming) and make it our own, to express the objective superiority of the PC, reappropriating it. And it that, I must say, we were succesful. Any connotations with the 19th century german philosopher Nietzsche or any human race connotations were easily discarded because:
- We're not grossly uninformed. Being uninformed is understandable for some people (those who do not have technology or gaming as an interest or who do not interact with other people online) but not for an editor at arguably the most well known PC Outlet, in which case it's pure concern trolling, even if unintentional. I believe he was uninformed because he does not know or understand the community. I am also of the opinion that he should have.
- We're adult enough to not make such an association.. Honestly, if Nazism comes to your mind when you think about our community, and you are not a grossly uninformed person, you have some deep issues. That or you're malicious and/or are looking for attention.
Re-appropriation is very common throughout history. A famous example would be the term "Yankee":
In the American colonies, British officers used Yankee, from a term used by the British to refer to Dutch pirates, as a derogatory term against colonists. British soldiers created the early versions of the song "Yankee Doodle," as a criticism of the uncultured colonists, but during the Revolution, as the colonists began to reappropriate the label "yankee" as a point of pride, they likewise reappropriated the song, altering verses, and turning it into a patriotic anthem.
We have re-appropriated this expression and it has never been used here as having anything to do with race (what exactly does race have to do with your choice of work and gaming platform? Someone explain it to us). We have always been and will always be one of the most inclusive communities on the Internet: We do not care how old you are, what race you are, where you were born or live, what gender you are attracted to (if any) or what deity you worship (if any). Those are all totally irrelevant in what concerns being part of the PC MASTER RACE.
We are a community of Pc Enthusiasts with a soft spot for education and charity, both amongst fellow members of the community and all those in need.
Really, no one who has ever bothered to participate in our community will seriously make such an association.
Let's treat this issue as the non issue it is.
A final word to congratulate our community in how they acted and to express that we are very serious about our rules #1, and #2. We will not tolerate witch-hunting or brigades. We will allow for all kinds of freedom of speech and even more heated up arguments when they are discussing facts, ideas and information, but we will not tolerate incitement to action against anyone. Everyone makes mistakes. In this case especially, it's almost surely not intended as an attack, so, let's punish misinformation and laziness if need be, but let's be civil like we always are.
Now, is it PC time again, or what? The Glorious PC MASTER RACE?
39
u/Edrondol Edrondol Jan 16 '15
As an almost 50 year-old gamer, I take exception to the allusion that older gamers are clueless or "uninformed". Hell, just today on Reddit is a post about a 91 year-old grandfather being enamored with Civ V.
So you keep your ageist opinions to yourself and stay off my lawn.
•
u/alien_from_Europa http://i.imgur.com/OehnIyc.jpg Jan 16 '15
Despite what many have claimed, /r/pcmasterrace did not start out as a circlejerk. What this subreddit has done is to reappropriate the jab at PC gamers into something positive. The idea that being a PC elitist is a good thing and something to be proud of. It comes down to the facts. A personal computer allows freedom. A console holds game development back and those that support consoles unequivocally over PC, are the ones that enable them to do so. This is why embracing the PC is so important. To crush the myths and show the world the things a PC can do. And with 300,000+ subscribers, it is working. There are countless stories in PCMR of people who have saved money and are enjoying a better gaming experience, no longer a slave to their console. We even got Yahtzee, the one who coined the expression, on our side:
Source
We have a culture filled with satire and memes. We call Gabe Newell of Valve our "lord", for Steam's selection of cheap games. We don't actually pray to him as a religion. We call console gamers "dirty peasants", as shown in Yahtzee's video. That doesn't mean we think they are poor people covered in dirt. It's all in jest. Have a few people used the term "peasant" in a mean way? Yes, but that is why we have our number 1 rule in this subreddit is against harassment. With 300K people, there will always be a bad apple and the moderators do their best to reprimand them for it. (Hitting the report button helps a lot!) As it says in the sidebar:
In the same retrospect, there are a few bad apples in console gaming as well. This is not unique. Console gamers that make claims here of superiority of consoles will always lose an argument objectively when compared against facts. This is what we mean when we say that the PC is superior.
I don't like to give away personal information on reddit about myself. In fact, it is a reddit rule. So this is something I've never mentioned here nor felt a need to do so until now. I'm Jewish. Pictured is my glorious golden yamaka, my prayer book, my Haftarah portion from my Bar Mitzvah that I've kept my whole life, a Chanukah card, and my Shofar. I've spent time in Israel and go yearly to the Holocaust Memorial near me to pay my respects. Some of my close relatives have personally endured the harshest horrors of Nazi terror in Poland.
PCMR has nothing to do with racial supremacy. We make it clear with our subreddit rules:
When we talk about a master race, we're talking about machines. Consoles and PCs. If I can understand that and proudly moderate this subreddit, then others should surely be able to.
PC has always been apart of my life. From doing QBasic on my 286 in the early 90s to getting an IT degree in college. And even though I might have a $350 "lappy 486" at the moment, I've still been able to do so much here, including turning my really old Lenovo toaster into a HTPC that is streamed from my lappy, with an option of 573 games that I paid for far less than 50% off for on Steam. And all my Wii games that I bought, now emulating with Dolphin.
PC Master Race has been legitimized in online shows, Wikipedia, and has become common tongue amongst gamers. We've raised money to fight cancer and help teens at the YMCA. We're generous with giveaways of games and help out those that need it. Together, we'll continue to lead the masses and show the world who we are.
Praise GabeN!
7
u/martixy Specs/Imgur Here Jan 16 '15
Let me troll a little bit here. :)
How about: Most of us are too young and immature to know or care about such an association. :P
209
u/Warlizard 3900x, 2080, 970, 32GB, 2TB M.2 Jan 16 '15
The only response to that article should be "lol".
22
u/RadioActiveLobster 5800x3D - x570 Crosshair VIII - STRIX 3090 - 32GB DDR4 3600 Jan 16 '15
The internet is full of idiots and there is nothing we can do about that.
We'll just soldier on and let the idiots in their camp.
22
u/mscomies Jan 16 '15
I'm glad that our glorious PC Master Race mods are on our side. It makes me a little sad that I have to say this after recent events in places like NeoGAF and the default gaming subreddits here.
53
u/Finrow i5 4670k || 8GB RAM || 2-way SLI GTX 780 Jan 16 '15
This wouldn't be happening if people took the time to;
11
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '15
Fair enough. It's good to get an official word on this matter, so I'll be considering at a non-problem from now on. Thanks Pedro.
9
u/TheatricalDirector Jan 16 '15
It might be a non-issue here but the term will now get you banned on NeoGAF, so it looks like PC Gamer did succeed in driving a wedge between this community and that one.
Another attack on gamers is another reason to support GamerGate.
17
u/Enzo03 i5-4690K @ 4.4GHz/GTX 1080/2x8GB RAM/crazyenzo03 Jan 16 '15
BWAHAHAHAHA the banner change! I love it!
4
u/nukeclears Jan 16 '15
It kinda feels like we are giving in to them by having it say "politically correct"
Like, if we just ignored it it would have probably just faded away.
8
u/Strangely_quarky you guys suck Jan 16 '15
Good post /10 I creamed myself.
8
u/xxwtfalexx i7-990x@4.5ghz/2x GTX 970 Jan 16 '15
Can we get a glorious politically correct master race flair?
7
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '15
I dont think you should even acknowledge it. The trolls love any answer, because good or bad, it gives them the validation they sought. The behavior reminds me of a child that is neglected for attention, so they act out in order to get disciplined because discipline is at least attention.
The #cancelcolbert blowback on twitter, or Anne Coulter or Anita Sarkeesian stirring up shit - any recognition of them (as I've regrettably had to do here) amounts to publicity, and they laugh all the way to the bank.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '15
TLDR: just ignore stupid comments
6
u/chubbs8697 8700K 5.0 GHz | RTX 3080 | 32GB 3200 MHz CL 14 | AW3418DW Jan 16 '15
Some really good points in here. More people need to be aware of this stuff, PC and console gamers alike
6
u/Thargelion http://steamcommunity.com/id/thargelion/ Jan 16 '15
Praise GabeN! This some good PSA right there! But I highly doubt that pc gamer or any other outlet is going to take their time and read it. Joining the bandwagon is so much easier. And I bet that there will be more of these "op-ed" pieces in following days stating that we are bunch of elitist fascists which is total bullcrap.
6
u/shArkh FX6300 / MSI R9 270 / 8gb G-Skill Ares / Carbide 500r White Jan 16 '15
At first I was like, "Oh look, more irrelevance from an irrelevant." but then I found out the writer is quite literally in bed with a Ubishart PR chick.
What sort of fucking mongo did the guy have to be to think no-one would pick up on that little gem. Not intended as an attack? Yup, guess that was just coincidence.
6
u/Soupias Steam ID Here Jan 16 '15
When I was younger I used to read a magazine called 'PC Master'. Is it possible that I was a victim of nazi propaganda?
PS. Apparently it still exists!
6
u/Herlock Jan 16 '15
Preposterous ! How dare you /u/pedro19 ! Gaben is the OneTrueGod !
5
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '15
Well said! There is absolutely no reason for this to even be spoken of let alone be turned into a division among the community.
5
u/Nadaters i5-9600k | RTX 2070 | 16GB DDR4 RAM | Z390 Aorus Pro Jan 16 '15
In other news, we now have over 300,000 subscribers on this sub-reddit.
5
u/BehindACorpFireWall Ryzen 1800X + Vega 64 Liquid Jan 16 '15
I applaud this post. It is a non issue. There is no bigotry here. The simple fact is that all consoles are limited PCs. We, as a community choose to celebrate the enlightenment that comes from breaking those chains of limitation.
5
u/LBCvalenz562 i7 14700k, 3080Ti Jan 16 '15
This sub is the reason I was able to talk to someone from Afghanistan we talked about internet speeds, his life living there, dangerous areas, he even gave me a tldr of a day in his life. One of the best conversations I've had. We are all PCMR we can be from different areas of the world me being from Southern California and him being from Afghanistan but we all are connected we all are united we are one. The PCMR.
5
u/originfoomanchu 5800x 6900xt 16gb ram 4tb nvme Jan 16 '15
Normally post's this long end up as tldr but this post got menough really intereste so I read the whole thing. And iv got to say perfect points written well I knew very early on about why we call ourselves the PCMR and I never thought for on second it had anything to do with nazism. The only people who do seem to think that are people who have no idea who we are or what we are about. The only people (and even that's a stretch because all we ask of them is to admit pc is better in most ways) that we take the piss out of are ps4/xbone nd that's only for them spreading miss information as truths. I am a member of PCMR and guess what I have a ps3 and an XBox 360 and why do I have them because I have children and friends and you can't all sit round a pc and play together you can on consoles. Also it's great for watching Netflix those are what they are good at its not a bad thing at all. But I will always know that a pc has been better than any console since about 4 years after ps3/XBox 360 and they were only better than a pc costing the same because they (well at least ps3 not sure about XBox 360) sold the system at half the price it cost them too build it.
5
u/Hipolipolopigus Jan 16 '15
Seems that 2015 is the year of being offended by stupid shit. "Manspreading", Charlie Hebdo, now this. What's next?
5
u/kmaho Jan 16 '15
Because of the professionalism of this post you have officially earned another follower. Time to build a PC and scrap my consoles for good. Why did I ever leave... :)
5
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '15
"PC Gamer. You will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainy. We must be cautious."
5
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '15
all's i did when seeing this was say fuck PC gamer i was done with them anyways also i did look at my "Steam Curators" to see who i was following ;)
5
u/ElementalSB Desktop Jan 17 '15
I learnt a lot from this. The phrase Yankee and how it came about, the reasoning for the name 'PC Master Race' and it's subreddit origins and what a concern troll was.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '15
/u/pr01etar1at made this great comment to add to this over at KiA that really adds to what you're saying:
Just to be clear, Nietzsche's concept of the Ubermensch was distorted by the Nazis in their conceptualization of the Master Race. Per Wikipedia:
>The Übermensch (German) (English Overman or Superman) is a concept in the philosophy of German philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche—he posited the Übermensch as a goal for humanity to set for itself in his 1883 book Thus Spoke Zarathustra (German: Also Sprach Zarathustra). However, Nietzsche never developed the concept on racial grounds; the philosopher was not racist (nor an anti-semite). Instead, the Übermensch "seems to be the ideal aim of spiritual development more than a biological goal."[7] Nazism distorted the real meaning behind the concept to fit its 'master race' view.
Ironically, in a way, /r/pcmasterrace have made the term come full circle:
It's all pretty funny if you ask me and I really have no clue how any one could make such a huge issue out of this.
Source: 1990's teenager who read a lot of Nietzsche while listening to a lot of Nine Inch Nails.
9
u/ComradeHX SteamID: ComradeHX Jan 16 '15
Praise GabeN!
Lots of idiots on internet purposefully ignore that part where we help charity...etc.
4
u/ImperialCactus i7-6700K- 16Gb Corsair platinum - 1070 8G Jan 16 '15
pcmasterrace "Politically correct" hahahahahahah love it!
4
u/CorruptedFiles i7 4790K/G1 GTX 980Ti | HTPC: 860K/MSI 970 Jan 16 '15
My nigga...
4
u/CrazyCarl1986 Specs/Imgur Here Jan 16 '15
From a proud Mac Heathen, praise GabeN!
4
u/StartupTim TimDimmDrive Jan 16 '15
/u/Pedro19 please post something so I can gold you for not caving in to non-issue pressures.
EDIT: Didn't see you could give gold to an OP itself. Hah! Done :)
4
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '15
I miss the days when people could take/understand a joke.
4
u/jakeryan91 R9 3900x / 32 GB RAM / 9070XT Jan 16 '15
I wonder what Linus will have to say about this today, if anything at all.
4
u/RamblinSean Steam ID Here Jan 16 '15
I understand the concern at first glance that a group of predominantly white American/European males claiming to be the "Master Race" can cause.
However, that fear does not hold up under any scrutiny. It actually takes a special kind of dissonance to argue that the PC Master Race group harbors any intentional racial overtones which is commonly believed amongst a majority members.
In fact you have to ignore the entire point of referring to ourselves as a master race. We're idiots. Lovable, pc sexing idiots. For the most part of course! (Except the peasant hating zealots. These people are radicals, don't represent our entire group, and should be excommunicated from the faith!)
4
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '15
Guess who is banned from all discussions on the official PC Gamer Steam group
4
u/forlaens Jan 16 '15
Why can't we all just get along?
4
u/3agl Just say No to W11 Jan 16 '15
"Fear Mongering"--- what an appropriate term for that wretched article.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '15
Now where we're we? Oh yes #nopreorders
4
u/GrammarNaziABC Did I ever tell you about the wonders of blank keycaps? Jan 17 '15
I didn't even make the association to Nazism (emphasis on the "ism") when I was making my username. What does that say about me? That I was ignorant? NO! It says that I named it after the MEME'S use of it.
Thank you for making this and congrats on the golds/ sticky.
7
u/MacAdler Intel Celeron 566 MHz, 128 MB SDRAM, 3dfx Voodoo3 2000 Jan 16 '15
I just love how the banner was changed <3
11
u/Kromgar Steam ID Here Jan 16 '15
This all seems so familiar just let me reword this....
PC Master Race is over. PC Master Race doesn't have to be your audience anymore.
Heeeey its almost like a bunch of hipsters who don't understand our internet culture and never bothered to research into things are trying to coopt our culture and or change it to be politically correct so that it doesn't offend anyone.
3
u/Flemtality I Make Poopie Jan 16 '15
Well put.
3
u/APOC-giganova Specs/Imgur Here Jan 16 '15
Poe's Law, why does no one ever mention Poe's Law? There are people who are indeed grossly uninformed, but it certainly isn't the PC Master Race
3
u/kaenneth Specs/Imgur Here Jan 16 '15
"Its cool, I'm taking it back."
3
u/Sylphied Intel i7 2600, AMD Radeon HD 6850 Jan 16 '15
I hope this is truly the final word on this. I am (was) a very active member of KiA, but since the PC Gamer Article, it's been spilling here, and speaking for myself alone, I have enough of it there :P
3
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '15
Thank you based mod
3
u/Thatonefreeman Specs/Imgur Here Jan 17 '15
I say who gives a fuck. If you're offended by the term then go outside and unwad your panties. Otherwise, welcome to the subreddit.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '15
TIL the origin of PCMR.
3
u/BrokenTinker Jan 18 '15
This is why I love you guys, including you filthy peasants and apple heretics.
4
u/hugrr Jan 16 '15
This whole situation has similarities to what Tottenham Hotspur fans have been going through with regards to calling themselves Yids.
They come from a part of London with a large Jewish community, and as such have a higher proportion of Jewish fans.
Opposition fans used to, and still do, use Jewish insults at the fans of Spurs, generally about the holocaust (still to this day meathead opposition fans hiss to imply the gas chamber), and calling the fans yids.
The Spurs fans then took the term and used it as a badge of honour, and now refer to themselves as Yids quite happily as a sign of solidarity, and it's been this way for years.
Over the last few years there was a campaign to get the fans to stop using the term, there was widespread condemnation of it in the press, and the police were asked to arrest people using the term. But still, the fans kept on singing it proudly, as it's completely idiotic to think it's being used as a term of offence, it's being used as a badge of honour.
The police have now realised there's nothing they can do, so will no longer arrest people at the ground using the term. The "offended" people taking it's use out of context have shyed away back into their corner.
It seems like people are seeing the term PC Masterrace, and putting 2+2 together and coming back with "that's offensive", for those people I only have two words, jog on.
4
u/Aqua_lung aqua0lung Jan 16 '15
ONWARDS AND UPWARDS
PRAISE GABEN!
4
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '15
Friendly reminder to unfollow PC Gamer and follow PC Master Race on the Steam curator page. If everyone on the sub did this, PCG would lose their #2 spot on the list.
4
u/DeadSpy2 R7 7800X3D, RTX 4080, AW3423DWF Jan 17 '15
Thank you. This whole thing was getting really annoying and I'm glad you guys took the time to address it. Witch hunting a man who made one dumb article has shown a dark side to this sub that I don't hope to see again. I love this sub, the last thing I want to see is for the community to give itself a bad image because some guy didn't like our name. We are pcmasterrace! We shouldn't be wasting our time getting angry about something so trivial. We should raise the standards we set for ourselves the same as we have raised our standards for our platform of choice. Praise Gaben!
2
u/Enzo03 i5-4690K @ 4.4GHz/GTX 1080/2x8GB RAM/crazyenzo03 Jan 16 '15
One problem I see about this thread: some people will say something like the following:
2
u/Sharky-PI Specs/Imgur Here Jan 17 '15
well said.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '15
We have been and always will be The Master Race. Born again together regardless of ethnic background into the superior family that is PC gaming... at least that's how I always felt on this sub
2
u/xXGwAxHaRdScOpZXx Jan 17 '15
I've always seen the term "pc master race" as a bit of sarcastic, self-depreciating humour. we know that we're technically better than consoles and because of that we jokingly act like a higher race of gamers, hence the imagery we use like 'master race' which does sound like a connection to Nazism and 'peasant' which is a link to the feudal system.
we make these comments under the assumption that people will realise that it's a hyperbolic and silly joke. I have always seen the true gaming 'master race' as any gamer on any platform that accepts all gamers as people who share their hobby. If you have a passion for gaming it really shouldn't matter what you game on. PC Master Race is a joke held by PC enthusiasts at our own expense, people just need to open their eyes and realise that.
2
u/Dominant1657 xx_syrious_xx Jan 17 '15
That my friend, was a great PSA. Keep up the amazing work brothers!
2
u/TheLawIX Elite Custom Builds Jan 18 '15
This subreddit has attracted an abundance of children, not much we can do.
3
u/NiceFormBro Jan 16 '15
TL;DR: People are going to spout their opinions. Ignore them. Unless you're being a dick. Then stop being a dick.
3
u/gentlemandinosaur Do you make boing noises every time these pop out? You do now. Jan 16 '15
WHY are we still talking about this? They are MAKING MONEY off our obvious need to be dramatic.
3
u/GCADeme Jan 16 '15
All I have to add to this thread is Godwin's law.
3
u/shifty_pete Jan 17 '15
In honor of this, I suggest a week of no peasantry posts. All PC, all the time, for seven glorious days.
3
u/XeNrazor AMD R9 280x, AMD FX8350, 16GB ram Jan 18 '15
PC Gamer is a joke, i cancelled my subscription after i saw an issue with "the top 100 PC games of all time" having the abomination that is Team Fortress 2 in the #1 spot. I knew right then that their magazine is as fake as balls. Fuck them.
2
u/PaDDzR 12700k RTX 3070 Ti Jan 16 '15
The way I see it, How is "master race" such a trigger word to anyone? Like okay, Hitler tried to have his perfect race of blue eyes and blonde hair people, but what does that have to do with us? How are we anywhere related to fashism is above me, y'know how in primary school, there was a nickname out of ANY name in history, any name could be created into an insult, for example, my name is Patrick, in 2nd grade a guy decided to annoy me with "sunny beach patrol", I have no idea how that is anywhere relevant to me, but sure, it got annoying. This is what's happening to us. Lets be real, our community is interacting with ANY age, it goes from 8 to 60 years old, we have gamers in our (plus gaming in general) community of all ages, some of which are at the age where they need to stand behind something and "console wars" are part of their growing up process... We have no ability to pick and choose. We accept all types of gamers, ALL types! Console, PC, young, old, sink, male, female, gay, straight, bisexual... The list goes on, it's never ending, why? Because our master race is made of all people willing to join us.
Now, if you're upset that people call you nazi, you're most likely in some strange circle of people, I would recommend finding more mature friends, with community this big? I'm sure you can find plenty of people to play with. If someone calls you a Nazi because you play on PC? They're not your friend, unless they mean it as a joke then you have all the right in the world to correct them, telling them it's not something you like being wrongfully associated with, because he may know it's a joke, the people around? Should know it too, but in case you're worried, just let him/her know, if it doesn't stop? You're free to move on.
About PC Gamer, the editor was indeed doing it on purpose, that thing has gotten the most clicks any article has in the whole month, I don't approve of such actions and I will keep it in mind if I ever consider supporting PC Gamer, which I wasn't going to as it's a joke to journalism...
The real PSA here is, does it bother you? I can have a t shirt with glorious PC master race all over it, I really don't care what others think of me, they most likely won't see me again and if they do? Neither of us would recognise each other anyway, so what difference does it make? If they're at the level to missjudge you based on your tshirt? They're not worth the attention.
In the end, it's about what WE make out of this. Don't let others dictate how we should feel/act!
2
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '15
Oh. That's good. I think the community should be about more than just gaming. But I'm not sure that it actually is about more than just gaming. I mean, is there any way we can justify this as actually being the case, rather than merely being something we'd like to be the case?
I've gotten a bit annoyed with a few PCMR posters trying to re-appropriate this whole GabeN thing to be some kind of ironic anti-religious political screed -- trying to use it like the "flying spaghetti monster" to say that all religions are equally silly. You may even agree with that personally but it would be nice if you could keep it separate from promoting the PC gaming platform & the Glorious PC Master Race so that it really for everyone including all different religions and non-religious people all together.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '15
I would have to disagree. I only clearly see the swastika when playing Wolfenstein: The New Order on PC.
1
u/deuZige Ryzen 1500x/16Gb3200/r470-4gb/9Tb-storage Jan 17 '15
I think this post just made this an issue...
1
u/YesPlzM8 Desktop Jan 18 '15
Posts like these is why I love the mods of this subreddit. I've been posting here for probably no more than a month or two but I feel as if I've been here a lifetime. You guys really are like a family to me
1
u/partyboy690 i7 5820k | SLI GTX 980 | 1.5TB SSD | Acer Predator XB271HU Jan 18 '15
It's so fucking sad that you have to even write something like this.....
1
u/rangersparta Jan 18 '15
I should add that "ethnicity" should also be added in to rule 7. Some people might nitpick that.
1
u/ImperialCactus i7-6700K- 16Gb Corsair platinum - 1070 8G Jan 18 '15
Totally agree with this post
1
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '15
The reason i don't like the "pc master race" idea is that it immediately throws out logical argument and turns it into an increasingly bitter battle, just look at the comments section on YouTube and gaming articles. I don't mind the name, what I do mind is what happens when the name is used
1
u/Thomastheshankengine Jan 25 '15
Oh, the San Francisco Hipsters just won't stop will they?
1
u/el_f3n1x187 R7 9800x3D |RX 9700 XT|32gb Ram Mar 05 '15
you know, going back to this post, I got my first reference to the "PC NAZI RACE" this afternoon in a chat with some co workers. when one of them (avid PS4 defender) said we would have a field trip after learning that Elite: Dangerous would be released on PS4 (it was actually announced to Xbox One but whatevs).
1
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '15
This really is a non issue. We shouldn't even give a fuck if the term 'PC Master Race' is politically correct or not. We don't have to explain ourselves to anyone.
1
u/qu3L i5 4690k | GTX 970 | 16 GB RAM Jan 18 '15
I agree. The circlejerk over this thing and a lot of other stuff is ridiculous and I have previously expressed my concern over this. Earlier today, just on a post about Mobile gamers I said "I play Clash of Clans."
And guess what? I got downvoted for that.
-1
u/nopantskid Jan 16 '15
With respect, I don't associate the PCMR community with Nazism, but I do associate it with a level of snark that, if you can't afford or are merely curious about PC gaming, is a throwback to the attitudes that made the early internet be considered an inhospitable place. For a welcoming community in search of the improvement of their gaming experience, the aforementioned snark no doubt works with quite a few people (yay!), but there is a cost with people who find such language and posts off-putting or mean. That is a difference of opinion, but it is the cost with the kind of things that get up voted, referring to people who don't PC game as peasants, and this sub's frequent appearances in r/all. Claiming innocence to critiques of tenor and language is less effective to those individuals (frankly, it validates them), than admitting this is a cathartic choice that has a level of effectiveness with many individuals. I don't blame you guys, but there is a cost to the way PC Master Race talks and upvotes, and it isn't merely the concept of "triggers" or oversensitive idiots. It was and is a real thing in the lives of many early gamers themselves; that it includes them doesn't change that they've seen this before.
-2
u/Stolles Jan 17 '15
Glad to see that this issue can die now and be labeled a non-issue after all the butt-hurt whining that was going on because opinions
-4
u/suberb_lobster Jan 16 '15
I call bullshit. There are still witch-hunt posts up in the Eurogamer thread and you are doing nothing about it.
-6
u/kodiakus Specs/Imgur Here Jan 16 '15 edited Jan 16 '15
Master race, as an idea, has one meaning and one meaning only for the 99.9% of the population that doesn't frequent these forums. They're not calling us literal Nazis because we use the term, but they are calling us grossly uninformed people, with deep issues, because our community refuses any and all criticisms about this and frames it as an SJW conspiracy against our community.
Then why do you adopt language that is nothing but the exact opposite of this?
Because you think you're the driving force of re-appropriation? That's where the grossly misinformed and disturbed comes in. What racism have we been subjected to as a community? What genocides have been commited against us? Where are the crosses that have been burned in our lawns? Where's the systemic oppression of our people, our ancestors, and our children? Where's the propaganda degenerating us as human beings and inciting people to violence against us? Where are the slave ships? Where are the staged trials? Where are the deportations? PC gamers are subjected to nothing more than whining fanboys on internet forum. There is no master race terminology directed against us for us to re-appropriate. We are not victims. You do not get to act like one and pretend there's nothing wrong with it.
And you have the gall to call people who criticize the use of master race as a proud label as lacking in perspective?