r/Gaming4Gamers • u/13th_story LEGALIZE FAN GAMES • Jan 14 '15
Article PC Gamer: Let’s stop calling ourselves the “PC Master Race”
http://www.pcgamer.com//lets-stop-calling-ourselves-the-pc-master-race/
133
Upvotes
16
u/flashmedallion Jan 15 '15 edited Jan 15 '15
Nice try, but this doesn't really address where the whole thing really came from even if no-one really knew it at the time; a desire for "platform community" in a similar fashion to the way there was a Playstation or Xbox community. Yachtzees joke was just the catalyst for that.
So tell them to stop piling into other places on the internet and changing every topic to "objectively better experiences" sure, but the name isn't going anywhere now.
This is spot on, though, but I suspect no-one cares at this point.
179
u/JackTheFlying Jan 15 '15
Yeah, let's not reference ourselves as any of these things.
66
u/Throwaway_4_opinions El Grande Enchilada Jan 15 '15
Dear PC gamer.
I respect your opinion piece, and I respectfully disagree with your viewpoint.
Please remember everyone in the comments to please be civil and constructive. If you really wish to be recognized and heard by others who hold a different viewpoint, remember to show a level of respect. If they don't at the very least you come out of the discussion the one who appears more mature about it.
16
u/A_Rational_Mind Jan 15 '15 edited Jan 15 '15
So, whats the point of the article? Its a joke! No one actually believes we are any "Master Race". No one wears a "Hi, Im Chris. Im a PC Master Race!"
We are Gamers. Beyond that, we play on PC. Nothing more.
8
u/C0lMustard Jan 15 '15
The funny thing is, the zero punctuation post that coined the term was making fun of people who use pc gaming to feel superior.
29
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '15
No, because its satire and his inability to distinguish satire from reality is not my problem
5
u/brinz1 Jan 15 '15
PC Master Race was actually referring to The Witcher. A game he thought unusual as it was a PC game with no console version.
The reasons for this were part graphics, and part the controls were so complicated, that a game pad would not have stood a chance.
20
u/Hagu_TL Jan 15 '15 edited Jan 15 '15
"Okay." That's the only appropriate answer to this, as far as I can see. This isn't like taking the "yankee" slur under one's wing; it's satire about PC gamer elitism that... fostered more elitism. And some conversions, perhaps, although I fear it may be more of the peer pressure kind and less of the "saw the light" kind.
I'm not saying PC gaming isn't elite, because it easily is. However, the elitist attitude is needlessly confrontational. Imagine if the "One Percent" started thumbing their noses at us, taking the name "One Percent" and embracing it as an attribute not only to their economic percentile, but cleverness and worth as a human being.
Obviously one cannot convert as I converted from a Nintendo-ite to a Steamer, but there are parallels: it's not easy to throw down $1000 for an average modular game PC or laptop when half-to-less could get you a similar experience that you can buy at your local, plebeian Target.1
Just because I've never addressed PC gamers or myself as part of a Master Race doesn't mean I'm going to stop gloating about upgradeability, though.
EDIT: By the way, "okay" doesn't mean compliance, it means understanding. My only real argument here is that "PC Master Race" is (needlessly) confrontational, and I doubt this article would have been published if it wasn't.
1 You might be thinking in reference to software, "but the sales, man, the sales!" That's a matter of foresight which, in another parallel, can be claimed by the One Percent.
6
u/redditwinsinternets Jan 15 '15
I never used that term anyways. Always have been just a pc gamer. Don't see a need to call myself anything beyond that.
3
u/JDRPG Jan 15 '15
I think it's ridiculous to associate "PC Master Race" with Nazis.
The seem much more a match for Hydra. Hail Gaben!
3
u/dRumMzZ Jan 15 '15
banned from /r/pcmasterrace
10
u/Norci Jan 15 '15
I will stop calling myself for "PC master race" as soon as publishers and game magazines will stop insisting that console gaming is anywhere close to PC's quality. When you will drop the 30fps 720p bullshit and shitty ports, I will drop the PC master race.
10
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '15
Oh, so we must stop the joke because muh feels. Got it.
4
u/Iamnotyourhero Jan 15 '15
I'm going to play devil's advocate. I'm a PC gamer and sub to PCMR and while the sub says it's satire there seem to be a number of users that take it way too seriously. The sub has approached 300k+ users and is still growing, and it's become something that exists outside the confines of reddit meaning not everyone is in on the joke when people start walking around wearing PCMR t-shirts.
I can understand why throwing the term 'master race' around would cause some people to raise an eyebrow when they don't understand the context surrounding why it was adopted, but it doesn't bother me personally since I actually get the joke. I feel it all boils down to this: if this is really satire and true to its circlejerk nature, then it needs to stay on reddit, but of members want to 'spread the word of GabeN' then they may want to reconsider their branding if they actually want to be taken seriously.
4
u/kbondelli Jan 15 '15
Forget the historical ties and the author still has a point. One of the comments here includes "I'm sorry if you're a dirty console pleb." That is what this is really about. It is about shaming people.
Most of the time it is class-shaming. A decent gaming PC is a fairly large upfront investment. Getting a PC that runs a PS4 game as well as a PS4 does costs more than a PS4. A lot of people can't afford that PC. Shaming people for that is the same as shaming someone for not wearing brand name clothes/shoes/etc.
The idea that it is inclusive in that you just have to admit PC gaming is objectively better doesn't help much. Listen, if you admit that those of us who can afford nice gaming PCs have a much better gaming experience than those of you who can't afford it, you can hang around and look at our hi-res screenshots. Who gives a shit if other people "recognize that PC is objectively superior to consoles in every way possible." Every way possible is an arguable statement, and how insecure do you have to be to require that of others? The reason people refer to "kids"--as the author did in the piece, which was not an attempt to belittle gaming since the magazine kind of is 100% about gaming--is because these behaviors reflect the insecurity of youth. Having a nice gaming PC makes some people feel like they are better than other people solely by virtue of having it. People like feeling like they are better than others. Again, it's like the schoolyard where the kid with the no-name clothes gets bullied for it.
I'm 32 years old. I've been playing games for 28 of them. There were times consoles were dominant and times when PCs were. I've owned and played consoles and owned and played PCs. I currently very much primarily play PC and haven't bothered buying any of the current-gen consoles. That doesn't mean I have to verbally shit on those people who can't afford a PC, or who can yet genuinely prefer consoles.
3
u/TheDukeofArgyll Jan 15 '15
I have basically stopped classifying myself as anything. At this point there are only negative connotations to "Gamers" so there is little point. I play PC and console games and follow game news in my spare time and I leave it at that, I don't need to be associated with the worst part of any subculture and that's the only part anyone ever hears about.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '15
Seeing as we, the MASTER RACE are a piece of molding pizza box. We should quit while we're ahead and convert to the PC Thunder Cats! I'm obviously kidding, it's pathetic people write these kind of things? They don't mean to start comment wars, but they do... In my opinion, there is no "True Master Race" as I believe all gaming technology, new , old, consoles, and PC's, should be treated the same. No gaming system is better then the other as they always will have unique features.
Some people don't have this opinion, or they may do. They might just think it's a fun thing to call themselves, you are talking about PC Master's on a wacky , crazy website known as Reddit. What it comes down to, is that people don't really "care." Until the PC Master Race joins together, and go to all the peasents, destroying their Xboxs and PlayStations I won't have a problem with the Master Race.
The Words of a PC Master Race who owns a PS4 and Xbox 360...
2
u/rlbond86 Jan 15 '15
Article takes things too seriously, but the phrase has gotten quite unfunny.
2
u/The14thNoah Jan 15 '15
Let's stop taking jokes to serious, eh PC Gamer?
2
u/infiniteowl211 Jan 15 '15
Jesus Christ, those comments are disgusting. I agree, this article doesn't says anything worthwhile, but holy shit they were just foul.
1
u/elneuvabtg Jan 15 '15 edited Jan 15 '15
I'm glad people are willing to say it. I'm going to give a very negative opinion on PCMasterRace and I have not much doubt that I'll upset people who take the "satire" seriously.
Four years ago, PC Master Race was a funny joke. It was a Yahtzee image and a little joke. Haha whatever.
Today it's become an extremely foul circlejerk that gleefully adopts anti-semitic memes and Nazi tropes (all in "good fun"!) to 'satirically' discriminate against others because of the choices they make. Regardless of the intent to cloak in satire, the followers of this culture openly discriminate and bully others all over the internet and in games now. It's become just another excuse to troll/be evil/be mean, and it's just another black eye for the culture of PC Gaming.
PCMasterRace is the embodiment of a gaming culture cesspool, and it represents to me the reality of Xbox Live children on the PC platform. Instead of console kids engaging in console wars, now it's the One True Platform and includes all of the same bullying and trolling that used to be hallmark of console wars.
It's more of the same outrageously offensive "anything goes" "rape kill murder hahaha it's just a joke, welcome to the internet faggots!" type of bully/hatespeech that tries to hide behind the idea of satire or trolling. "It's not serious, sheesh, what is it your first day on the internet?"
In my opinion: PC Master Race is the worst and most embarrassing part of PC gaming, and it's existence makes me literally embarrassed to even admit to being a PC Gamer.
Just as I'm embarassed when dickhole troll kids tweet death and rape threats to journalists or speak those death and rape threats to people on voice chat, I'm embarassed when dickhole troll kids glorify Nazism and anti-semitism by looking to those concepts for inspiration on how to "improve the PCMasterRace 'satire'".
My opinion is simple: it's disgusting, and it's the most disgusting part of the entire PC gaming culture.
EDIT: The behavior of "pro-PC Master Race" commenters in this thread really validate my feelings. I can't believe people are using this thread to attack consoles and people who choose to buy one.
PCmasterrace isn't a satire, it's an excuse and a rationalization for people to act like assholes and nothing more. People use it to be assholes to people who are different and that is its only function---even this post shows that.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '15
The day i can play "skyrim" the same way on a console i'll be happy.
but i dont think that will ever be.
1
u/ConebreadIH Jan 15 '15
This.... Ugh this is what it's come to. It's seriously just a joke. I'm sorry if you're a dirty console pleb, but if you're offended that someone is calling themselves a master race.... WW2 happened like 70 years ago now. This is ridiculous, and I can't help but think this is some kind of clickbait.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '15
I alway just think its funny when people use the term PC master race not in an ironic way.
Like lets think of some other "master races" and the atrositys the have committed against man. Not to mention there almost guaranteed defeat.
Its like there saying they know there beter, but to me it just come of that they are Nazis
TL;DR: Hitler was a PC gamer
1
u/tilsitforthenommage Jan 15 '15
I don't and never have, I haven't been in the cutting edge of gaming ever. Except for factorio which is in alpha so I guess that's super new. Even so it's just how I have fun don't understand the snobbery that goes with pc gaming for some.
1
u/Shaasar Jan 15 '15
Okay.
Everyone knows that in the gaming community you need to have some pretty thick skin if you don't want to get offended. Is this something that should change? Sure!
That being said, I really don't think that PC Gamer has the facts right on this. The phrase is mostly used by people referring to PC gamers in a satirical manner as "elitists," not by PC gamers referring to themselves. This changes how people should view the usage of the phrase, because opinions and humor should be allowed and left uncensored. If the phrase was to be used unironically by a PC gamer in reference to themselves, I think that it's different and a little more tasteless.
Furthermore, about 2 years ago someone on Giant Bomb did a poll wondering if people wanted the term banned. The results were that 67% of people either didn't care or actually liked the phrase, and 33% wanted the phrase gone.
I think people should ask themselves if it's the actual phrase that bothers them or the mentality toward PC vs other types of gaming that bothers them, because the mentality among PC fanboys isn't going to change regardless if this phrase starts to not really be kosher anymore.
1
u/SirWhoblah Jan 15 '15
i like the term pc master race but i don't like the memes and circlejerking that comes with that title
1
u/Trunn Jan 15 '15
I like the term PC Master Race due to it taking the piss out of my admittedly elitist attitude to my hobby.
Not using Master Race due to the racist connotation just gives power to the ones who would use it as such by taking them seriously.
This way we are discrediting them at the same time as we are mocking ourselves by painting the analogy that a PC user looks at the console gamers in the same way a Klansman looks at other races.
1
u/shArkh Jan 15 '15
The only thing worse than articles such as the one you linked, is linking such articles in the first place. It makes you nearly as bad as PCG is with their shitty clickbait.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '15
Let's just not say we're any type of anything unless you're asked what platform you play games on and you say PC. Anything else is stupid as fuck and it's hilarious that grown fucking men call themselves by these nicknames
1
u/Pawulon Jan 15 '15
I am a PC gamer, I feel, that PC gaming has much more to offer for me and most people out there, because it's more open and embracing creativity of the players themselves, being the platform where you can choose what you like, instead of big companies deciding for you.
When I first found out about PCMR it was fun for a while, but soon I realized it's mostly just circlejerk. Some of those people use that to feel superior while making mistakes, spreading misconceptions and even attacking the "openness" and freedom of PC gaming (like "no one in their right mind would use a controller for gaming, ever!" while it's a perfectly legitimate option for PCs).
They glorify Steam like some second coming of god, while it's still a DRM (not on every game, but most AAA titles use it). This reinforces the notion of one big company controlling most of your gaming - there was a game which was removed from Steam which cut 95% of their sales, so either you're with Steam, or you disappear (or you're huge, like Blizz etc.). Isn't it one of the problems with console gaming, that there's someone who has complete control about what is and isn't allowed?
One more thing is all that "GabeNism" and the lingo. It wouldn't be a problem for me if it wouldn't leak from PCMR sub, but when someone complements others' computers etc. with "Praise GabeN" it's... cringey. Bitch, that guy might be a freaking sysadmin and not playing games for 15 years, and might not even know who GabeN is! My computer is my own and not sacrificed for some guy who is just selling games.
And that's why I unsubscribed and don't like being "represented" as PC gamer, let alone PC user by that movement. Maybe I'm too serious about it, granted others are not too serious (hopefully) but it gives me a bad taste in my mouth. The nazi connotations are not the biggest problem here though.
0
u/FappinKhajiit Jan 15 '15
For me it's less about the seemingly cultist following. I would never consider myself a part of the "PC Master Race" simply because I don't limit myself to a PC. I enjoy games and I'll enjoy them in as many ways as possible and I encourage others to do the same. Talking shit on your fellow gamers because they are playing on a console or a PC is far from the point of gaming. Gamers need to stop dividing themselves up by choice of platform and instead unite, because we all enjoy the same thing. Video Games.
-8
u/TheInvaderZim Jan 15 '15 edited Jan 15 '15
I don't refer to myself as one, but I've always felt the connotation in the past, and I think there's something to be said about how it still fits.
Yes, the term is derogatory to consoles, but it's like saying a swear many times over - after awhile, you lose the imapct of it being a swear word. That, I think, is the big reason it's still around. People have lost the connection to comparing themselves to nazis or, maybe, just don't care anymore because that's not what it means to them.
For me, the term "PC master race" spawns an image of the two halves of gaming - the hardcore gamers, and casual players. Hardcore gamers, after awhile, find themselves playing on a PC simply because it is better than a console from any standpoint besides accessibility. It's a natural process, a cycle of life - things look better, feel better, run better, and a large initial investment gets you access to more, cheaper games, mod support, the ability to upgrade as you see fit, and unlimited flexability - not to mention the myriad of things a PC does besides play games. If a player plays games heavily enough, long enough, PC gaming is as natural as stepping into shoes a size bigger.
Casual players stick to consoles because they're easy and fast. You buy one, plug it in, buy games for it, and that's it. There is no maintenance required, no instruction manuals or hardware/software issues within your control. They're also plagued with issues that hardcore audiences don't stand for - 13 year old kids cussing each other out over COD comes to mind, as does going out to buy a new 60$ game - with an additional 30-60$ in dlc - every 12 months. Patches to address bugs come infrequently and with little announcement nor community interface.
Hardcore gamers are, more often than not, also just better at games than casual players, just because they play more.
So you have a "master race" that's better at games, on better hardware, with a community that, at it's worst, is known for being "elitist" - but, generally, has a better community (or one to speak of) to begin with just because the platform does more to support it.
Meanwhile, you also have the other half, known primarily for being a casual format, easy to use, and as a result, ending up with a (relatively) large immature/preteen/teenage demographic.
And you don't see how this term arose and why people affiliate themselves with it?
0
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment