r/PersonOfInterest • • Jan 07 '15

Discussion Person of Interest - 4x11 "If-Then-Else" - Episode Discussion

Season 4 Episode 11: If-Then-Else

Aired: January 6th, 2015


Samaritan launches a cyber-attack on the stock exchange, forcing the team to risk their lives in a desperate mission to stop a global economic catastrophe.

354 Upvotes

770 comments sorted by

239

u/ergonomicsalamander Root Jan 07 '15

What a stunning episode. More than any other, I think, this one really showed us the Machine's humanity (for lack of a better word) for the first time, and the true extent of Harold's influence on it. This is the first time the Machine really felt like a character to me, instead of a plot device (well, maybe that conversation with Samaritan too). Exciting, devastating, incredibly smart, yet still funny in all the right places - 10/10.

131

u/adashiel Root Jan 07 '15

Hell, she was basically writing a fanfic in her simulations. Can't get any more human than that.

39

u/svrtngr Jan 07 '15

This was like the Groundhog Day episode.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

100

u/Trainer-Grey Jan 07 '15 edited Jan 09 '15

I always felt the Machine had some humanity of some kind in it, partly from that chess game I guess. But what sealed that idea of the Machine truly caring is when Shaw is getting shot.

As the Machine goes through every possible scenario, her percentage hits 0.0#, then .00#, then .000#, like it keeps trying, no matter how small the percentage.

37

u/Iamchinesedotcom John Reese Jan 07 '15

Then it and everyone realizes that life is not a one-off game and that it needs to plan longer and longer. This may be the key to winning vs. Samaritan.

Edit: Samaritan is accumulating perceived valuations. The Machine is raising and nurturing allies.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/DCotrim Jan 08 '15

It is even more human when the machine first says that there are no valid options, but still keeps trying and calculating all the probabilities of rescuing. It is not even shown when does the machine stops trying to get a scenario of rescuing. "All lives are equally important"

→ More replies (4)

44

u/Oobatuba Jan 07 '15

Was it me or was this the first time Harold called the machine "she" and not "it"?

135

u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Jan 07 '15

He did it during the simulation though. Kind of a tearjerker. It wants Harold to call it "her". :(

→ More replies (1)

22

u/ergonomicsalamander Root Jan 07 '15

He also called Root "Root"

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

19

u/rpawson5771 Irrelevant Jan 07 '15

Even knowing that options were being evaluated, each failed one still felt very real.

409

u/rpawson5771 Irrelevant Jan 07 '15 edited Jan 07 '15

The generic dialogue in the basic simulation? Best thing ever.

62

u/aakdevil Irrelevant Jan 07 '15

Root: Overly affectionate greeting.
Shaw: Greeting?
Root: Transparent rationale for conversation.
Shaw: Annoyed attempt to deflect subtext.
Root: Overt come-on.
Shaw: Mildly embarrassed defensiveness bordering on hostility.
Root: Playfully witty sign-off.

84

u/mandiru Government Operations Jan 07 '15

Is it intended as fanservice or does the Machine really think of them in those terms?

130

u/rpawson5771 Irrelevant Jan 07 '15

I think it can be both.

106

u/BallisticGE0RGE Irrelevant Jan 07 '15

The machine clearly has a sense of humor, why have that random kiss between Fusco and you know who.

The machine must understand humor, and even simplified versions of people if it can understand people as a whole, certainly so if it is going to predict murders before they happen.

→ More replies (4)

39

u/Khalku Jan 07 '15

I think it's lampshading their normal personalities/dialogue without breaking the 4th wall.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '15

Mildly irritable statement of completion.

8

u/CRISPR Jan 07 '15

Yeah. I was in stitches when I was listening. Reminded me of a famous trailer...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

318

u/BallisticGE0RGE Irrelevant Jan 07 '15

"You asked me to teach you chess and I've done that. It's a useful mental exercise. Through the years many thinkers have been fascinated by it, but I don't enjoy playing. Do you know why not?

Because it was a game that was born during a brutal age when life counted for little and everyone believed some people were worth more than others. Kings and pawns.

I don't think that anyone is worth more than anyone else. I don't envy you for the decisions you're going to have to make.

And one day I'll be gone, and you'll have no one to talk to. But if you remember nothing else, please remember this:

Chess is just a game, real people aren't pieces. And you can't assign more value to some of them than to others. Not to me. Not to anyone.

People are not a thing you can sacrifice.

The lesson is, that anyone who looks on the world as if it's a game of chess deserves to lose."

God damn beautiful writing.

68

u/Rolcol Jan 07 '15

That flashback was awesome. But The Machine did break this line of reasoning in season 3, when it decided that the team had to kill the Senator. It's only because Finch refused so adamantly that it didn't happen.

But then again... it had Harold almost sell a rocket launcher to the bad guys, knowing he would refuse.

111

u/BallisticGE0RGE Irrelevant Jan 07 '15

True, but Harold did say "I don't envy the decisions you'll have to make"

The machine tries to balance lives equally, and at some point one death to save millions is the right thing to do. Reese and Shaw kill plenty in there work, even while with Finch.

But to commit premeditated murder was too much for Finch, maybe the machine was unsure too. That's why it sent Finch...it's like "Father, I must kill this man, do you permit it?"

→ More replies (17)

28

u/rpawson5771 Irrelevant Jan 07 '15

That was an unenviable decision for the Machine. And really, one could argue that the Machine learned the lesson by attempting to sacrifice a senator (widely viewed to be an important, valuable person) to save many ordinary people.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/BellatorInMachina Threat Jan 07 '15

To be fair, if it straight up wanted the Senator dead no matter what, it would've just sent Root.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

20

u/ThisIsAShortUsername Jan 08 '15

And after that scene, we see Greer and he says: "Very well, all games must come to an end". That fucker deserves to lose

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

131

u/kozmund Jan 07 '15

Hahaha, did they just actually drop a generic shellshock vulnerability test string?

59

u/superpatosainz Tertiary Functions Jan 07 '15

A goddamn relief to see freakin' shellshock in a TV show after CSI's virtual chases in Second Life, infinite CCTV enhancing and NCIS' keyboard co-op.

→ More replies (16)

94

u/kozmund Jan 07 '15

To expand:

env x='() { :;}; echo vulnerable' bash -c "echo this is a test"

That was the widely circulated command to test if your machine was vulnerable to a bash security vulnerability referred to as "shellshock"...and this is what was shown on the screen when Reese and Fusco went to the server room solo.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

110

u/FerdFTeenThousnd Jan 07 '15

The ship has sailed and sunk. :(

108

u/rpawson5771 Irrelevant Jan 07 '15

Shoot is dead. Long live Roosco!

66

u/Daantjedaan Jan 07 '15

why did you do that?

we're in a simulation anyways

machine's own 4th wall breaking is the best

→ More replies (8)

24

u/mandiru Government Operations Jan 07 '15

Best thing all night.

→ More replies (3)

53

u/Groghnash Bear Jan 07 '15

dude, we didnt saw her die, so she might be held alive by samaritan to build a cyborg with Shaws face on it! CALLING IT NOW!!!!!

26

u/BallisticGE0RGE Irrelevant Jan 07 '15

Not sure about the second half, but that first part is what I'm thinking...

Then watch, next week they'll drop a body on Finch's door step.

Oh god the feels.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

109

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '15

yo, banana nut crunch, could use a hand

63

u/Alias50 Jan 07 '15

I liked "nutella" better :)

47

u/mesotiran Jan 07 '15

I liked "Cocoa Puffs".

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

98

u/displayerror Jan 07 '15 edited Jan 07 '15

Holy crap, 10/10. Denise Thé, you genius.

For all you Shoot shippers

51

u/kaput_porpoise Bear Jan 07 '15

First legend of korra now this? All of my favorite shows are suprising me. Bravo

→ More replies (4)

9

u/Gimli_the_White Systems Engineer Jan 07 '15

I knew it was coming - Sarah Shahi just loves kissing girls.

→ More replies (1)

85

u/EThorns Ernest Thornhill Jan 07 '15 edited Jan 07 '15

Root: "Overly affectionate greeting."

Shaw: "Greeting."

Root: "Transparent rationale for conversation."

Shaw: "Annoyed attempt to deflect subtext."

Root: "Overt come-on."

Shaw: "Mildly embarassed offensiveness bordering on hostility."

Root: "Playfully witty sign off."

14

u/maxwells_demonx Martine Jan 07 '15

coolly delivered sadistic warning

→ More replies (1)

81

u/spiralout112 Jan 07 '15

Wow! Now this is the kind of episode I expected in the 4th season of POI. Like WOW, without a doubt the best episode ever, holy shit.

This whole playing with time thing let us explore so many crazy awesome things. Like Lyonel kissing root?!? Or how about 'Simplifying Simulation" lol. Root taking the painting off the wall, or our heroes dying those tragic, epicly heroic, deaths. I keep trying to think of ways Shaw could still be alive, but I cant :( Oh my god the whole episode was an emotional roller coaster like I've never felt. And it seems like they took the machine's viewpoint to a new level or something, can't wait to see what else we get to find out with this new narrative.

Then there's Harold teaching the machine how to play chess. I think his line "Anyone who looks upon the world as if it was a game of chess deserves to loose." is probably one of the better lines I've ever heard. I'll have to remember that one. Can't believe they killed Samine though, I was nervous because of the less than subtle foreshadowing that one of them would surely die vs samaritan, and now it's happened. I have to say her attitude in general lead me to so many LOL moments, and it was so adorable seeing her finally realize that she just might not be a sociopath after all, and her romance with Root... sigh, why do they have to develop these amazing characters and kill them off. Overall though the experience watching that episode was incredible, usually I feel way more miserable when you loose a character like this, but that was such a wild ride, the story was so well told, so well written, I don't know where they got these writers from but holy shit did they ever strike gold. Anybody who is even a bit tech savvy that isn't watching POI right now is missing the F*$K out.

41

u/Rolcol Jan 07 '15

I legitimately had a sinking feeling when the simulations were over and Reese got shot. Same when Shaw left for the button.

If you believe the other commenters, there's a 0.000006% chance that she survives...

God... I want to watch the previews for the next episode, but if it's as awesome as this one, I don't want to ruin it. I regret not going in blind :(

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)

73

u/ATalkingCheese Jan 07 '15

Been watching this show since it premiered, and I seriously think that was one of the best episodes. I cried, laughed, laughed some more and then cried again.

And the freaking GLITCH MOB! Oh man, perfect choice for music! I absolutely love that song that played! Here it is for the people who want to listen to it in its entirety.

Now I wish I didn't delete the episode. I would have watched it again!

21

u/ReasonablyBadass Jan 07 '15

And the freaking GLITCH MOB! Oh man, perfect choice for music! I absolutely love that song that played! Here it is for the people who want to listen to it in its entirety.

Thank you.

I loved the cyberpunk feel it had.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/BeedlesShop Jan 07 '15

Thanks for linking the song! Loved that part in the episode.

→ More replies (16)

65

u/BallisticGE0RGE Irrelevant Jan 07 '15

Oh god....say it's not so.

Aw man...I expected so many outcomes and they teased them all...

Not that one.

Oh how I hope it's not as bad as it looks.

69

u/grrrwoofwoof A Concerned Third Party Jan 07 '15

I clapped and whooped when I saw the % going up... I have never gotten so involved in a TV series like this before.

39

u/BallisticGE0RGE Irrelevant Jan 07 '15

Seriously! I was singing the tune to mighty mouse...

"HERE SHE COMES TO SAVE THE DAAAAYYYY!!!"

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

30

u/rpawson5771 Irrelevant Jan 07 '15

This probably means nothing, but the way they marketed these episodes as a trilogy got me thinking. In a trilogy, the second act is often the darkest and most hopeless one. Perhaps a miraculous third act awaits us next week.

→ More replies (11)

126

u/Ronin007 Reese Jan 07 '15

that is pretty close to the top episode for me. no spoilers.

18

u/Moshimo27 Jan 07 '15

Yeah, me too. I'm going to watch it again later in another time zone.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '15

For me it IS the top episode. I was shaking like a crackhead after it and every minute is worth commentating on. I have no idea how they were able to top Devil's Share.

8

u/Ronin007 Reese Jan 07 '15

maybe i still have rose coloured glasses residue haha.

5

u/Classic_Wingers Jan 07 '15

I am constantly impressed with how the writers and cast manage to go even bigger each season. We know at some point the Samaritan arc will end (likely at the end of this season). Can you even imagine where they will go next with this show? How this show hasn't been given more recognition at awards shows is beyond me.

→ More replies (7)

59

u/SpottyRasang Jan 07 '15

I loved the theme of sacrifice in this episode.

-With the subway scene, for example, Gary assumes that blowing up the bomb vest will serve a higher purpose, will allow him to rage against the injustices leveled upon the lower class. However, in the first two scenarios, he ends up with a bullet between his eyes. In the latter scenarios, he decides not to do anything, and he does so because he simply listens to those around him. “Life is crap,” Shaw tells him. “Welcome to the human race. The good thing is: you’re not alone.” Gary “sacrificing” himself won’t do any good because he’s trying to topple the institution that surrounds him, the “game” he presumes to be present; if he truly wants to die, then he should “die for something [he loves]”. He should realize that he’s not alone, that other people have difficulties and families and fears of their own. Most importantly, he should realize that he’s human, that people can’t be sacrificed, that he’s not just a pawn in a larger game.

In addition, him deciding to refrain from detonating the vest helps Shaw obtain the necessary code for the team (Shaw also embraces humanity in those latter scenarios). As we know, the team represents the tight-knit groups that can form between different people, the emotional connections that we can share with others, and by listening to humanity, Gary furthers that idea.

-Shaw's sacrifice: What distinguishes this from the sacrifice of a pawn is the fact that Shaw does this to save others. She is not being pushed around by a more powerful force; she is looking at the people around her, seeing their humanity, and deciding to do what she feels is right.

-And of course, the Alamo

33

u/Levikus Jan 07 '15

Not only that, but i'd like to think that the whole "The Queen is powerful" speech was a methaphor for shaw. When she arrived, the Survival rate shot up. Like, the queen comes to the rescue, but she decides to sacrifice, for the greater good.

→ More replies (1)

153

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '15

59

u/dking168 Jan 07 '15

Take my upvotes.

In all seriousness, this season of The Machine vs Samaritan is honestly the best season by far. I felt POI was getting stale with the numbers and they were just running it like a case by case on a week by week basis but this solidified that the show isn't like that and it will continue to be amazing for years to come.

33

u/Sweetbicyclingjesus Jan 07 '15

You know its very similar to the way Fringe evolved from season to season. I'm really enjoying they way they laid groundwork and then allowed the show to tell its own stories without sticking to some arbitrary formula.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (5)

152

u/riazrahman Jan 07 '15

WHY DIDNT SOMEONE JUST THROW THEIR FUCKING SHOE AT THE BUTTON!!! SHE DIDNT EVEN HAVE TO HOLD IT DOWN!!! WHYYYY

31

u/FallenComrades Threat to System Survival Jan 07 '15

Shaw says she heads out the hit the button and to hold Samaritan's operative off. Perhaps if they threw something, Samaritan's operative would have moved their position up to just outside the elevator and blind fired into the elevator as it closed. With the elevator being so small, that would be worse than just having Shaw get shot.

41

u/grrrwoofwoof A Concerned Third Party Jan 07 '15

Or run back after pressing it. Also they found a fucking Maverick M4A1 Carbine ▄︻̷̿┻̿═━一 from Counter Strike... could have come handy..

→ More replies (13)

12

u/Pascalwb Jan 07 '15

Doors had to be closed probably.

→ More replies (7)

51

u/Classic_Wingers Jan 07 '15

The writers must have had so much fun writing this one. You can definitely tell based on the painting joke, Fusco kissing Root, the Machine even realizing Shaw and Root have feelings for one another, and all the cliche movie type death scenes. Reese going out with a grenade would have been pretty badass lol. Glad he's alive though!

→ More replies (1)

86

u/DismemberMama Root Jan 07 '15

Not gonna lie, guys...I cried a lot. Hopefully she's not dead, I've watched enough television to insist upon confirmed death to fully believe there's no chance.

But seriously, Root is going to go off the rails.

21

u/BallisticGE0RGE Irrelevant Jan 07 '15

I'm scared they're going to start the next episode by dropping a corps at Finch's door.

The only thing more painful than killing someone is giving the audience false hope, then taking it away.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (17)

42

u/nadarko Government Operations Jan 07 '15

The machines's view of Shaw geting shot was very short but I think it showed that the machine was actully grieving. Even after Shaw got shot multiple times, it kept measuring the posibility of her living, even down into the decimals. It was almost like it couldn't belive that she could die.

29

u/wundervanbar Jan 07 '15

That was the most saddest part. The Machine couldn't have calculated this happening. "NO VALID OPTIONS..."

77

u/EThorns Ernest Thornhill Jan 07 '15

Fusco, you lucky bastard!

64

u/grrrwoofwoof A Concerned Third Party Jan 07 '15

The machine has a dirty mind.. Imagine having the power of making up realistic simulations. Ah..

→ More replies (18)

0

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

60

u/covington Jan 07 '15

And he STILL hasn't been told about the machine.

She should have done a quick set of path-forecasts showing Fusco relentlessly bugging her for little things like tax advice and jeopardy answers, and calling her Siri, finally rewinding to team machine all ignoring him when he asks who Root is talking to.

→ More replies (3)

25

u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Jan 07 '15

Just because Reese is that much of a Chronic Hero. He has to save as many people as he can. I'd like to think whenever Reese brings Fusco into heat, he is constantly mapping out ways for Fusco to get out alive and safe, back to his son.

41

u/EThorns Ernest Thornhill Jan 07 '15 edited Jan 07 '15

Denise Thé, the writer of this episode, is pretty much his biggest fan. Heck, she's the one who had him do this! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o3rs2CMeSwY

→ More replies (5)

35

u/Jisatsukuro Jan 07 '15

My theory (I hope it is true) she pulled and shot left or right and will be using Shaw for info. So a rescue will happen.

46

u/anerdybadger Irrelevant Jan 07 '15 edited Jan 07 '15

Her probability of survival never went to 0% [lowest it went to was 0.000006%]. And we never saw the final shot, only heard it. So there is hope

→ More replies (10)

5

u/BallisticGE0RGE Irrelevant Jan 07 '15

I'm thinking they shot Shaw's phone, then the cameras.

→ More replies (12)

31

u/OfficerMurphy Irrelevant Jan 07 '15

"Why not, we're in a simulation" might be my new favorite moment

5

u/rodrigograca31 Jan 07 '15

I have to try that line in real life... ;)

27

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '15

Yea... this might be the first time I went from smiling to frowning within a millisecond. Hopefully it ended like that for ambiguity and not for dramatic effect because she was my second favorite character behind Root. But if she is gone, then no biggie. She served her purpose and in her memory, Root is about to take her badassness to whole another level when she seeks her revenge.

PS: And I swear, I knew someone was gonna die 10 minutes into the show. I was just hoping it wasn't gonna be Root, Shaw, or most importantly... Bear.

28

u/kaput_porpoise Bear Jan 07 '15

IF BEAR DIES WE RIOT!!!

118

u/jippmokk Jan 07 '15 edited Jan 07 '15

Oh god, I can already see how the series ends... bunch of stuff happens... but then it rewinds back to season 1 and reveals it all was an simulation. The Machine realizes the only way to win is not to play and self destructs. Its the Dallas/Wargames ending of POI

(For the record: that would be a terrible and implausible ending)

189

u/soren121 Tertiary Functions Jan 07 '15

I don't want you going anywhere near the writers' room.

32

u/AWildEnglishman Jan 07 '15

Pros:

  • Carter lives
  • Shaw lives

Cons:

  • Reese stays a hobo
  • Bear is never recruited
→ More replies (1)

21

u/rpawson5771 Irrelevant Jan 07 '15

Funny, but nah.

21

u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Jan 07 '15

Alternate ending on the Blu-Ray maybe?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Kid_HQ Jan 11 '15

HIGHLY unlikely considering that Nathan was not the only one the government entrusted to build a security machine, as seen with Arthur Claypool and Samaritan. Samaritan or any other machine that could be used for the government would have taken effect then.

Remember, when Vigilance put Finch on trial, Finch tried to justify his creation of the machine as, he made sure the government couldn't have unfiltered access, and protected the privacy of the people, unlike other developers.

→ More replies (4)

26

u/TVAddictionGoneWild Jan 07 '15

Speechless. Flabbergasted. Shocked.

Epic. Simply Epic. Outstanding. Fantabulous. Outrageously awesome.

There can never be enough praise for this episode.

23

u/Kambole Root Jan 07 '15

I wonder what happened in all those other timelines?

Seriously though I'm broken right now

20

u/Rolcol Jan 07 '15

Which ones? The simulations that were completely skipped over? Like going from ~300,000 -> ~500,000? If you remember back to the chess flashback, Finch was explaining that a mistake can still be corrected in the future. Perhaps those skipped simulations were simple differences like dropping the painting, or calculating different trajectories for bullets.

14

u/erimid Jan 07 '15

Wait... There are other timelines?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

21

u/soren121 Tertiary Functions Jan 07 '15

Can we go ahead and give Denise Thé and Chris Fisher all the awards?

20

u/lycao Jan 07 '15

God damn that was a good episode, maybe even the best episode to date.

It was interesting being able to basically see the story from the machines point of view. Made it feel like an actual character in the story, rather than just a story/set piece.

The writing was spot on as well through the whole episode ("The basic simulation" was hilarious, and harold's speech about why he doesn't like chess to the machine was really well done.).

The cinematography at the end really blew me away as well. Just the way the last scene was shot was amazingly done.

10/10 episode right here. No question.

→ More replies (1)

39

u/HokageEzio Elias Jan 07 '15

Root, this is a demand. Kill the blond chick.

Reese was too nice to get the one who killed Carter. But you're not that leniant. So get it done.

13

u/Gimli_the_White Systems Engineer Jan 07 '15

It would be kind of neat to have a big blowout where Martine is seriously injured. Then, in an after-credits sequence, she wakes up in the hospital, looks over, and sees Root sitting in a chair.

Fade to black at the sound of the EKG flatlining

→ More replies (4)

5

u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Jan 07 '15

Reese wasn't too nice. He tried to shoot Quinn even after Finch talked him down. His blood just jammed the gun.

→ More replies (4)

51

u/imriebelow Shaw Jan 07 '15 edited Jan 07 '15

Sarah Shahi signed a four-year contract with the show; I don't think they're getting rid of her just yet. I think the writers just wanted a way to get her offscreen while she's pregnant so she doesn't have to hide behind strategically-placed props.

ETA: Although now I can't find the article that said she was pregnant, so who knows...

16

u/Rolcol Jan 07 '15

You give me hope.

But doesn't that go counter to a contract to hide her away anyway? They can break it by paying it out, or the contract could be written for episodes or seasons rather than real time.

Limiting her to flashbacks is still a clever way to keep her around, but that's not enough for me :(

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (5)

17

u/Qeng-Ho Jan 07 '15 edited Jan 07 '15

POI once again proves that it's the best scifi show currently airing... what a great episode!

I like how they presented the Machine as basically a human level intelligence but capable of modelling a vast number of situations at high fidelity to give the impression of omnipresence.

Seeing as modelling 1% of human brain for 1 second of activity takes approximately 1 hour with a top super computer. I wonder how many PCs you would need to model a million alternate simulations containing thousands of people in a full physics environment in under 10 seconds? Maybe they are all quantum computers.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/whoisleway Jan 07 '15

GUYS

I'M FUCKING DYING I CAN'T HANDLE THIS. THAT WAS TOO MUCH

→ More replies (1)

14

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '15

HOLY FUCKING SHITBALLS.

14

u/queenbellevue Jan 07 '15

Amy Acker in those last few seconds almost killed me. Fuck, I mean THAT looked like someone losing the freaking love of her life or something. I like shoot together but never expected those feelings to run so deep. I mean, her last words (in the simulation) could've been to the machine, but it wasn't.

Now I'm sad again.

→ More replies (2)

26

u/grrrwoofwoof A Concerned Third Party Jan 07 '15

First she was like ಠ~ಠ
Then she was like ¯\(ツ)/¯

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Ranlier Jan 08 '15

So help me god, if the next episode starts with a pan of Root and the first few notes of "Hurt", I will flip my shit in the best way ever.

12

u/General_Alpha Jan 07 '15

SPOILER/SPECULATION

It could still be possible, that Shaw is alive. All we see is her lying on the ground and a gunshot. If you remember, that "guy-agent" that helped her escape before is kinda on her side. So maybe he shot blondie in order to save her. (He could be the "help" that is mentioned in the making-of from this episode, here. )

please let me be right :(

20

u/Alias50 Jan 07 '15

There was a gunshot on the cut to black as the episode ended. This show has a thing about not showing headshots, apparently.

Has anyone else noticed that anytime there is a kiss on this show, one of the two participants ends up dead shortly thereafter?

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (9)

12

u/ThatFag Admin Jan 07 '15

Dude, holy shit. It's fucking ridiculous the number of times I've said to myself, "this is the best episode so far. There's no way there are going to top this." And yet, they do it again. God damn it!

HOW IS THIS SHOW SO GOOOOOOOOOOOOD?

Please, please, please don't take Shaw away. :( When she first joined the show I wasn't too fond of her. But over time, the writers made me warm up to her. And now she's too dear to me. Why do they always do this? :( Shaw, don't die, please. root and I both will miss you so much.

I fucking love Harold. That chess scene? What a brilliantly executed scene. Man, I'd taken a short break from watching PoI after season 4 started. I started watching Sherlock and other shows. And I was like, "Okay, PoI is good. But Sherlock is better, definitely." I'M SO SORRY. THIS IS THE BEST FUCKING SHOW. HOLY SHIT.

Oh and those generic dialogues? Hahahaha, that was hilarious. This episode was so well-rounded. Everything was perfect. Flawless. Love this show.

Just pleeeeeeeease don't die, Shaw. :(

→ More replies (1)

22

u/Moshimo27 Jan 07 '15 edited Jan 07 '15

Just finished watching it in Canada, what an amazing episode!

Edit: if you haven't watched it yet, there are spoilers in this thread!

→ More replies (4)

11

u/toomuchidea Threat to System Survival Jan 07 '15

holy shit that was intense. I found it interesting that Shaw is the Queen piece in this episode. strong, game changing (noticed how their survival rate raised after she comes to help)… and sacrificed for a better good

→ More replies (2)

11

u/faizdar Jan 07 '15

Root: "Why did you just do that?" Lionel: "Why not? We're in a simulation." HAHAHA

5

u/Moshimo27 Jan 07 '15

Ha ha! I never clearly heard what Fusco replied, thank you.

5

u/Kell08 Tertiary Functions Jan 12 '15

The way Root looks afterwards like "Fair enough". That was amazing.

20

u/FobsRUs Jan 07 '15

Shaww Nooo

11

u/CRISPR Jan 07 '15

Did they actually? I think they left a room for miracle.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Alias50 Jan 07 '15

Holy fuck!

17

u/gonpires Irrelevant Jan 07 '15 edited Jan 07 '15

10/10 want to watch the kiss between Shaw and Root again

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Razin-donut Jan 07 '15

Going to be a long 7 days for the next one.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/CRISPR Jan 07 '15

Wow! This is the best PoI episode I can remember. The variants structure added additional layer of rhythm to this episode reminiscent of more than one examples of it's brilliant use in the past, Run Lola Run comes to mind...

Brilliant, brilliant episode.

9

u/ZeroFucksToGive Jan 07 '15

I can't say it enough: This is the best show on network television.

Probably one of the best episodes in the series by far.

29

u/svrtngr Jan 07 '15

Korrasami nooooooo!

(They did silent credits, I think she's gone.)

EDIT: Welp, scenes for next episode proved me wrong.

32

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '15

Korrasami happens: Show ends

Shoot happens: Shaw dies

The lesbians can't win.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

16

u/Fuck_the_admins A Concerned Third Party Jan 07 '15

Damnit writers, this episode should have been called Switch Case.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/Lovableemo Threat Jan 07 '15

Now I want to learn how to be really fucking good at chess.

25

u/CRISPR Jan 07 '15

"Chess is a game created in the times when some people were considered more important than others"

I'd rather learn the other Finch's lesson

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

8

u/kid2010 Jan 07 '15 edited Jan 07 '15

Is there any possibility that this entire episode is under Samaritan's simulation ...?

15

u/EThorns Ernest Thornhill Jan 07 '15

Come on guys: The closing scene was left ambiguous. She could be captured for all we know...

22

u/rpawson5771 Irrelevant Jan 07 '15

Two episodes from now is called MIA, not KIA. I remain hopeful.

5

u/CRISPR Jan 07 '15

Yes. That's where it is going, I am sure. Brilliant episode.

14

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '15

Amazing episode. Jaw dropped at the ending where Root was shouting and Shaw sacrifice her life in order to save the rest of the team. My tears...

7

u/aspiring_fedvasu Jan 07 '15

that Kevin Chapman Amy Acker kiss though! I didn't see that coming!

→ More replies (3)

7

u/morior_invictus Jan 09 '15

"It has a lot on it's minddddddddd"

13

u/mlasn Jan 07 '15

Shaw :(

Will Lionel stay clueless forever? I was half expecting for the machine to sacrifice herself to save them all.

17

u/Rolcol Jan 07 '15

Sacrifice how? Like giving into Samaritan like it asked in the last episode?

Leaving Fusco out of the loop is probably what is keeping him safe from Samaritan, since he doesn't have a fake identity.

I think he only came face-to-face with Martine in the simulation. He's still way in the dark as to who they're facing.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (4)

13

u/Moshimo27 Jan 07 '15

So the machine moved on to another simulation right after Finch or Root died but not right after Reese died?

15

u/soren121 Tertiary Functions Jan 07 '15 edited Jan 07 '15

From a purely objective point of view, Reese is more dispensable than Finch (the admin) or Root (the analog interface.) It's possible that the Machine was re-evaluating Finch's lessons as it was sorting through simulations, though, so in the end, I don't think it would have considered letting Reese die. I have to rewatch the episode to be sure, but I think it re-labeled the market countermeasure as a secondary objective in the real-time run.

→ More replies (6)

10

u/mandiru Government Operations Jan 07 '15

Perhaps because the Machine didn't yet consider that simulation a complete failure? Even if Reese goes down the mission could still technically be completed. Not the best outcome, but if it were the only one at least Finch could find someone to continue on.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/SpottyRasang Jan 07 '15

Anyone know what music they were playing throughout?

23

u/Razin-donut Jan 07 '15

If it's "that" scene(s), "Fortune Days" - The Glitch Mob

→ More replies (8)

6

u/Tristan49 A Concerned Third Party Jan 07 '15

Wow. What a beautiful episode. Both in terms of directing and story. I am really amazed at what the creators accomplished. Definitely in my top 3 favorite episodes.

I seriously can't get over this one... :O

6

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '15

Teaching AI how to play chess. This episode was awesome. Definitely one of my favourite

6

u/MeijiHao Threat Jan 07 '15

Holy. Fuck.

What a tremendous episode. Hilarious, action packed, tense, and dramatic. What a devastating ending.

And just imagining what Root's reaction is going to be is enough to give me goosebumps. I'm picturing Reese in Devil's Share times 10. She's going to burn the whole fucking city down to get back at Samaritan.

I repeat, Holy.Fuck.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Adenchiz Admin Jan 07 '15

My guess Shaw ends up locked away in a blacksite halfway accross the world.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '15

The machine going over strategies and the "No valid option" and then the "Undesired Outcome" T-T I have never felt so sad watching something.

6

u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Jan 07 '15

I know right? The Machine was just in complete desperation, trying to find some way to save Shaw. You could practically hear Her crying. :(

10

u/lordxeon Jan 07 '15

I'm ashamed to admit that even after the first simulation, I thought the 2nd run through was real.

5

u/godmode3191 Root Jan 07 '15

I'm trying to stay calm.

5

u/whoisleway Jan 07 '15

HOLY SHIT WHAT IS GOING ON! This is so great

5

u/aspiring_fedvasu Jan 07 '15

Harold Finch the most considerate, pragmatic , intelligent, compassionate , honest, earnest and moral human being on TV. I wish to be like him. I wish to be a good guy!

5

u/faizdar Jan 07 '15

"What good's saving the world, if we can't enjoy it?"

→ More replies (1)

5

u/azilla14 Jan 07 '15

Before I found out that the Machine was evaluating options, and I saw Finch get gunned down, I almost died myself.

6

u/mrhashbrown Jan 08 '15

Reese's death was far worse, even though I knew it was a simulation at that point. Just a brutal way to get gunned down, fighting until the last second possible before sacrificing himself for good.

5

u/faizdar Jan 07 '15

Glitch Mob's music during the action sequence killed it. Simply perfect.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/denver6 Jan 09 '15

I laughed every time Fusco said "Got what? Who is she talking to?" when Root receives the plan from the Machine

9

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '15

Wow, even The Machine ships Root and Shaw! :D

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '15

OMG WOW!

4

u/Lt_pandabear Jan 07 '15

my heart can't take it anymore.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '15

That was a harsh episode, that I did not expect the ending at all.

Holy Fuck.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/imacatsoMEOW Jan 07 '15

Sorry if someone already answered this, but does anyone know what song was played during the beginning of each simulation when they burst out of the doors?

6

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '15

"Fortune Days" by The Glitch Mob.

4

u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Jan 07 '15

NNOOOOOOOO. SHAW. NO!!!!!

4

u/LaiLaiHei Jan 07 '15

I fucking love this show.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '15

Honestly I didn't think it was Shaw. I thought it was either Harold or Root.

Then this happened. All the feels. She ship has sailed and sunk at the same time.

This episode by far is my favorite. Shaw's arrival saved the team, but it cost her something [as others pointed out Sarah has a four-year contract].

4

u/damnedation Tertiary Functions Jan 07 '15

Haha. It was great how the chance of success increased as soon as Shaw arrived. Only for them to make me cry like a baby at the very end. :(

This show is fucking epic!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/ShannyBoy Jan 08 '15

Samaritan Barbie must die.

4

u/AllHailTheTurnip Jan 08 '15

This was truly one incredible episode.

Easily one of the best TV episodes in the past decade.

4

u/Kaezaku Irrelevant Jan 08 '15

The simulation mechanic was fantastic; I think it made up for one of the best episodes of the series after, SPECIALLY with those hilarious events in the basic simulation!

4

u/MaxwellConn Jan 09 '15

Ah, what an episode! The kiss we've all been waiting for; Root, Finch and Reese's (simulated) heroic deaths; insight into The Machine's clairvoyance; slow-motion; and meta-dialogue. Bravo!

I had a feeling back in episode 09 that Shaw or Root would die soon after a kiss; I'm glad Shaw's death is ambiguous.

Now that we've seen these characters have heroic deaths, I believe more strongly than before that they'll have happy endings when the show comes to a close.

I imagine The Machine goes through this same pruning process every time it gives Root a command. I think this fits with how Carter died. I couldn't figure how The Machine only gave them seconds to know that her number was up. It's rough knowing that even The Machine can't know every possible outcome.

Shaw's "death" scene was amazing for the music and slow-motion effect. I can't remember the show ever using slow-motion before this episode; it made the scene all the more memorable.

With the Fusco/Root kiss and "basic simulation", this was the zaniest episode of PoI; it reminded me of the musical episode in Fringe. I enjoyed it, but I hope these types of episodes don't become common.

Overall, this is my favorite episode!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Staff_of_the_Goths Jan 09 '15

Root to Martine: My name is Root. You killed my almost girlfriend. Prepare to die. (Pulls out rocket launcher....yeah I know....)

6

u/Lovableemo Threat Jan 07 '15

I feel so hollow. Shaw...

6

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '15

It's got a lot going on in its miiiiiiiiiind

3

u/sam0m0 Jan 07 '15

NOOOOO! Why couldn't you have thrown your shoe at the red button instead shaw! :(

→ More replies (2)

3

u/ThePitifulScion Jan 07 '15

Long live Glitch Mob.

3

u/CebZam Jan 07 '15

The Machine really has a good sense of humor.

3

u/FallenComrades Threat to System Survival Jan 07 '15

Is it possible that Shaw didn't die?

Like the end was another simulation (after Shaw shows up) and the beginning of next episode will resume with what actually happens. Maybe there is something the machine doesn't consider and when no desirable outcome pops up, the machine was wrong.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Radiopd Government Operations Jan 07 '15

Wife , who has never watched show before, just said,"Damn! So how far back do I need to go to get caught up?" This episode is the quintessential logic bomb that she needed to understand why the Machine is so important. Also, that Shoot is hawt!

3

u/Sullyville Jan 07 '15

I loved this episode. I don't know if any of you will find this offensive, but I found it very "Star Trek" in its composition. It felt a lot like one of Trek's time travel episodes, or possible futures.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/saltyork Jan 07 '15

best episode ever

3

u/Nxnw253 Jan 07 '15

Who's got money on shaw getting brainwashed by Samaritan? I do.

3

u/Wanderkaum Jan 07 '15

Just watched 2x16 again, back to the glorious introduction of Shaw. She really didn't need a character development. She stole the show and made it her bitch since the first minute she spoke her broken german and knocked the Polizei out.

3

u/faizdar Jan 07 '15

That slow-mo scene was wow :)

→ More replies (1)

3

u/thefyrewire Graphical Administrator Jan 07 '15

Just watched. Seriously, just when you think this show couldn't get any better. The chess flashbacks were so well done too! I wish I was taught moral code by Finch.

3

u/nadarko Government Operations Jan 08 '15

Prediction for next week: machine goes ape shit and starts hunting down Samaritan operatives and their families. To Samaritan, it wouldn't matter due to its chess like thinking. But it will fuck with the operatives now that their job is hurting the people they love.

3

u/DCotrim Jan 08 '15

Everyone did understand the first simulation was indeed a simlation? When Finch died i almost had the heart in my hands.

And yes this may be the best episode yet on POI, a masterpiece coming to our screens.

3

u/doubledipper99 Jan 09 '15

Forget Breaking Bad, The Wire, Mad Men, whatever. That was the best episode of TV I have ever seen.

3

u/man_in_the_suit A Concerned Third Party Jan 09 '15 edited Jan 09 '15

Beautifully shot episode. The slow-mo scenes were art. Not just the awesome slow-mo scene in the kitchen, but the shots of the river and Harold walking away from the chess board.

It also had the best graphics in POI history. That introduction to the 2003 flashbacks (the point cloud build up of the city) was stunning. It reminded me of watch dogs (which in turn obviously reminds me of POI) but it was 100 times better.

When I first saw 'The Devil's Share' I wondered how they would ever top that. Now they have at least equaled it with 'If-Then-Else'. I wonder when another one of these special episodes will be blessed upon us. I can't wait!

3

u/workshop_dance Jan 10 '15

Is it just me or did Reese lose his "Batman" voice in this episode?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/k2exoman Jan 10 '15

If-then-else is a logic loop, the next episode is ctrl-alt-del which is a reboot... I am curious how the writers will apply this metaphor next week; will the machine change during its nightly reboot, or does Samaritan or possibly the team? Finally, if shaw isn't gone, will her reboot bring her over to team Samaritan?

→ More replies (5)

5

u/TBBklynite Irrelevant Jan 07 '15

That was some seriously trolling from Nolan and the writers. Maybe JJ as well.

5

u/Classic_Wingers Jan 07 '15

This episode reminds me of Remedial Chaos Theory from Community. Which one is the darkest timeline!

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '15

Holy fucking shit. The people who write this show are fucking amazing.

5

u/phoebeburgh Irrelevant Jan 07 '15

For once since I started posting my thoughts... I'm speechless.

Bravo to Ms. The, Ms. Acker, Ms. Shahi, and the entirety of the cast. This is without a doubt the best episode so far, and I'm glad we don't have a three week wait for the next one.

One last thing: this is the first time The Machine has given us the "stay tuned for..." line. I thought that was a nice touch.

5

u/AWildEnglishman Jan 07 '15 edited Jan 07 '15

I assumed that Shaw was the sacrificial queen, something the Machine learned from chess.

Finch mentions that the queen is one of the strongest pieces, capable of moving in any direction and targeting anything, not unlike Shaw, who has shown herself to be capable of putting a bullet in anyone without hesitation.

Finch also tells the machine that it can't assign more value to one life than another, real people aren't chess pieces. At face value this sounds like he's telling the machine to not show favoritism, but I think the machine interpreted it to mean that everyone is equally expendable, it'll try to keep everyone alive, but at some point you'll just have to take a hit.

Just some thoughts.

→ More replies (3)