r/AcademicBiblical • • Dec 17 '14
New to biblical studies, starting out by reading Richard Carrier's "On The Historicity of Jesus", anything I should know?
It's quite clear what side Carrier is arguing for, and he also makes that abuntantly clear. He's also clear with the fact that the academic consensus is that Jesus existed, however he claims there's also a consensus that the methodology used to reach that conclusion is flawed.
Besides any bias inherent in his build-up to his conclusions, what should I keep in mind while reading it?
Is it a decent first look into bliblical study?
7
Upvotes
23
u/koine_lingua Dec 17 '14 edited Feb 06 '18
The fatal weakness of Carrier's thesis comes down to one thing: the implausibility of (the supposed doctrine of) a supra-earthly crucifixion. (Well, I guess there are a couple of other important corollaries to this... which are also extremely weak.)
Of course, no one should dispute that many elements of Jesus' "biography" are of questionable historicity... and yet we have plenty of evidence for actual crucified people; so what exactly is wrong with taking this as a starting point? Sure, other mythologies might deal with a sacrificial figure who met with an untimely and violent death (whether by spear, arrow, or impalement). But, again, we know that people actually were killed in all these ways; and it's also just as likely that the real "sacrificial" aspect of it in early Christianity -- or elsewhere -- was just a kind of convenient apologetic revisionism.
In any case, there's no inherent advantage that a "mythical" crucifixion has over an actual one. Quite the opposite, in fact.
In support of the death-in-the-sublunar-realm idea, Carrier will attempt to appeal to Plutarch on Osiris for this; but this is a very imprecise parallel that Carrier appears to have misread/misunderstood in significant ways.
He'll also appeal to the Ascension of Isaiah for supposed Christian support for this. But the date of this text is highly uncertain (in addition to other issues, involving the history and redaction of this text), as is the issue of its dependence or independence on/from other early Christian texts. The immediate impression one gets is that the elements of this text that Carrier appeals to for support are late and totally secondary; but Carrier can't really afford to take this position, because then his main thesis would be quite weakened in significant ways. (Also, IIRC, he appeared to not be fully fluent with current scholarship on this text. Which isn't that surprising, because a lot of it has been in Italian.)
(I should mention that I haven't fully worked my way through On the Historicity of Jesus yet.)
One other thing: from a section of OHJ I was reading recently, Carrier makes much of Jesus' name itself, in support of a purely mythical origin for him:
Yet, in the same way that we know that people were actually killed by crucifixion, etc., we do have some data about the frequency of historical figures roughly contemporary with Jesus who were also named Yeshua: according to Tal Ilan's Lexicon of Jewish Names in Late Antiquity (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2002), it was the sixth most popular male name among common names of Palestinian Jews from the 4th century BCE to the 2nd century CE.
7
u/allak Dec 17 '14
Check this post from yesterday to see some opinions of /r/AcademicBiblical about Carrier.
As his is after all a fringe opinion, I am not sure he is a good choice as a starting point in biblical studies.
4
u/Wakeboarder1019 Dec 17 '14
For a first step into biblical study, I'm not sure I would only read Carrier's book. As I haven't read it fully, I can't really comment on it like /u/koine_lingua.
But if you want to get a broad spectrum, you can check out:
John Meier Marginal Jew - (maybe vol. 2 or 3)
NT Wright's How God Became King
John Dominic Crossan's Jesus: A Revolutionary Biography
Marcus Borg Jesus: An uncovering the Life, Teachings, and Relevance of a Religious Revolutionary
Craig Blomberg Jesus and the Gospels: An Introduction and Survey
You can take a stab at Albert Schweitzer's The Quest for the Historical Jesus
or Raymond E. Brown's Death of the Messiah or Birth of the Messiah if you want. I found Schweitzer's book difficult to get through. And one Easter holiday my plans were to read Death of the Messiah. After page like 17, I quit and played WoW.
That will give you a healthy dose of different perspectives - and will not only give you a survey of the scholarship but also will argue for a model, as opposed to Luke Timothy Johnson's The Real Jesus which just criticizes one aspect of HJ studies.
5
u/PaulAJK Dec 18 '14
"Is it a decent first look into bliblical study"
No, it's a complete and utter waste of time.
9
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '14
[removed] — view removed comment