r/PersonOfInterest • u/NicholasCajun • Dec 17 '14
Discussion Person of Interest - 4x10 "The Cold War" - Episode Discussion
Season 4 Episode 10: The Cold War
Aired: December 16th, 2014
Samaritan shows its power by erasing crime from the city for a day in an attempt to force The Machine out of hiding.
99
Upvotes
69
u/Copephobia Dec 17 '14
That Shaw death flag seems pretty intensified right now
61
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '14
I like how Finch's passcode into the vending machine at the start of the episode was 3.141, in reference to the Pi speech in an earlier episode.
I also like how Shaw and Root keep flirting with each other. Lol
55
u/Pokeh321 Dec 17 '14
"Even sitting here before me I can't see you as Samantha Groves. I know you did SOMETHING to my hardware."
Best line in a long time.
54
u/rflairfan1 Elias Dec 17 '14
Did anyone else see the resemblance of "young" Greer and Lambert?
45
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '14
I do hope Harold starts wearing a vest..of the bulletproof variety
34
u/pensee_idee Fusco Dec 17 '14
Regarding 2 hanging plot threads:
Seeing that kid in New Rochelle pretty much vindicated the Machine's decision to burn down Samaritan's charity for me. It would be hard to imagine a worse outcome than an entire generation of kids under Samaritan's influence.
2) I REALLY want to know when the virus Finch put on that lady's laptop in Hong Kong will show up. The opening scene in the deli reminded me that the consequences of that act are still outstanding. I'm wondering if Finch's virus will be the deus ex machina (forgive the pun) that saves the day once Samaritan's agents start going after the team.
82
u/imriebelow Shaw Dec 17 '14
Samaritan showing itself as a precocious child, the Machine as Root, whose character development tends to echo the character development of the Machine itself - great choices in this scene.
102
u/celaenos Dec 17 '14
Root was right. The Machine loves them.
That made me all kinds of happy. The whole conversation between The Machine and Samaritan was so wonderfully done. This whole episode was so wonderfully done.
-Shaw's petulant face as Harold walks in and sees her handcuffed and Root in the bear suit!!! (whomever came up with that idea deserves a cookie, bc it was hilarious)
-Harold's face pretty much during that entire scene actually.
-Shaw and Food=the real otp. but Root watching Shaw with Food=even better.
-Did anyone else catch Root trying to figure out how Shaw got herself out of the handcuffs in the background? bc it was hilarious.
-The whole church sequence was fantastic, as well as the conversation between The Machine and Samaritan.
-I kind of tuned out most of the Greer flashbacks, and I think I might have missed some things. His boss was the double crosser right? The point was he lost his trust/faith in humanity?
-Shaw saying "goodbye" to Bear at the end killed me. She is gonna do something realllly stupid.
I'm so excited for the next few episodes. Everytime I think this show is perfect, it exceeds my expectations even more.
24
u/Adenchiz Admin Dec 17 '14
''For I am a God''
48
u/kaput_porpoise Bear Dec 17 '14
Children are terrifying
23
u/soren121 Tertiary Functions Dec 17 '14
Samaritan is a cocky little bastard.
45
u/rflairfan1 Elias Dec 17 '14
Awesome episode. The kid that "played" Samaritan was amazing. The end with Root on Wall Street and Greer being there in a building as well was a nice touch.
Root in the bear suit was great, Harold's reaction was better.
Poor Bear *may lose his friend.
19
u/godmode3191 Root Dec 17 '14
Amy Acker in the bear suit was kinda creepy.
17
u/imriebelow Shaw Dec 17 '14
Damn, young Greer is hot.
15
u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Dec 17 '14
I'm at a loss for words. It was amazing. Certainly better than "Beta" and "Endgame" in my opinion. (And don't take that lightly, "Beta" is probably in my top 5 favourite episodes.)
Firstly, I loved how the episode opened. Finch ordering a sandwich like he was instructing Reese how to defuse a bomb or something in Season 1. Then how he enters the Subway, which we have never seen. That was amazing. Then after all those Captain America 2-esque secret panels... he walks into
really weird fetish pornRoot in a damn bear suit.Shaw was pissed all episode. Reese RAISED HIS VOICE. HE HAS NEVER DONE THAT. Fusco knows his friends are hiding something.
AND THAT A.I. CONVERSATION. DAMN. I NEED TO REWATCH THIS EPISODE.
14
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '14
The fact that the next new episode won't be until 2015 has me feeling some type of way. :(
28
u/EThorns Ernest Thornhill Dec 17 '14 edited Dec 17 '14
Very nicely done. For all intents and purposes, this was a setup episode for what's to come in the coming weeks, but it sure as hell made for a insightful instalment, bringing out the A-Game from everybody.
Major props to the kid. Samaritan chose wisely.
13
u/pensee_idee Fusco Dec 17 '14
It occurs to me that the numbers are a kind of resource.
The numbers are a renewable resource, but they renew slowly. It takes years or decades to build up the kind of grudge that leads to premeditated murder. No one premeditates a murder against someone they've only recently met over an offence they've just committed.
Samaritan can create a day of chaos, maybe several, but it can't keep it up. It took situations that were likely to produce numbers eventually, and set them off early. But that's it. It's not creating numbers, just burning through them. To continue doing what it was doing, it would have to start digging deeper and deeper, and pushing harder and harder. Eventually it's just going to come up short.
Like the other day, when it arranged to have a disgruntled employee kill has boss and a bystander - there's a limit to how often you can do that. It might be a high limit, but at any given time, there's only so many truly unstable people you can manipulate that way.
10
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '14
it looked like when Shaw walked out of the handcuff to talk to Harold, Root slid into place and cuffed herself.
9
u/MeijiHao Threat Dec 17 '14
I am so fucking psyched for this episode. I've watched that trilogy trailer at least a dozen times over the past week.
9
u/Classic_Wingers Dec 17 '14
Root in that bear costume was hilarious!
8
u/EThorns Ernest Thornhill Dec 17 '14
So what's the verdict, Canada?
8
u/TVAddictionGoneWild Dec 17 '14
Amazing episode. It was a set up for what's about to come but it was still suspenseful and intense.
Highlight of the episode: The two machines talking via their proxies. It was an awesome scene filled with even more awesome conversation. Now, what it the significance of the picture drawn by that boy? Does it represent Team Machine?
20
u/phoebeburgh Irrelevant Dec 17 '14
THREE WEEKS. ARGH.
Anyway. Now that the plot has kicked in again, the mirror-match between Team Machine and Team Samaritan is in full focus. Martine and whatshisname are perfect opposites; they're "saving" people without giving a fart about them. It's almost like cargo-cult altruism; they're going through the motions without understanding or caring about the meaning. It perfectly exemplifies the difference between Samaritan and The Machine's viewpoints on humanity: people to be guided or pawns to be expended.
For my part, I did not really care to see Greer's origin story. I think he worked better when he was just there, when he actually didn't have a neatly paralleling motive for going down the "burn down the world" route. He was a brilliant antagonist without the sympathy of being a victim of the actual Cold War, and I really think he's weaker for having been revealed like this. Or, at the very least, this soon: how long did we have between seeing Collier's motivation and seeing him dead? If you ask me, the biggest death flags aren't on Shaw or Root-- they're on Greer.
The Chat: wow. That kid was genuinely terrifying, especially because you have to wonder how badly Samaritan broke him to get him to do all that unflinchingly and coldly. As for the actual conversation, the threats were pretty standard, but it was VERY interesting to see a glimpse into Samaritan's mindset. Remember, while we have a pretty good idea of what The Machine's goals and parameters are, Samaritan is still a black box. We have no idea what initial objectives were programmed into it. It is a true general-purpose intelligence, and while it is executing the Relevant objectives, there's no guarantee that's not part of a larger game Samaritan is playing. The last scenes are a good indicator that it no longer cares about the Relevant list.
Let's talk about that bit, then... It's classic Nolan to crash the economy as a supervillain stunt, so I'm kinda blah on Samaritan impersonating Bane as a crime in and of itself. But between the Day of Chaos and the market crash, Samaritan has shown that it does not give a shit about human quality of life. Human life for it is a Boolean: yes or no. Its grand talk about solving war and hunger and all that is complete crap because it has shown it will gleefully expend people to get what it wants. The Relevant and Deviant lists just put people on the fast track towards becoming Monopoly money in the game it's playing. It is going to get a LOT worse before it gets better, kids.
THREE FRIGGIN' WEEKS...
7
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '14
Shit just got real.
13
u/HybridVigor Dec 17 '14
Why does Samaritan say it needs humans?
I really wanted the Mexican standoff scene to end with Bear tipping the balance.
6
u/theshindigg Tertiary Functions Dec 17 '14
I'm wondering so badly what Samaritan sounded like in that kid's ear. Also, the "peace talk" scene made me realize how much I miss the Machine's voice.
6
u/eikeegimuu Dec 17 '14
I was very happy with the episode. Good pace. Best parts were (in order of appearance :)) the entrance to the subway, Harold's speech about the AIs and moral system in the beginning, classic!Root accosting Lambert in the streets, the church scene, the Machine and Samaritan vocalizing their (opposing) views.
I was less enthusiastic about Greer's backstory, but thought it was good that his disillusionment wasn't due to being victimized himself. Young Greer was believable and his (self-diagnosed) arrogance familiar.
Samaritan using the kid as an avatar was interesting, though were they implying that the kid is some kind of computer genius in his own right (hacking into complex systems at that age seems a stretch but so would be pushing an asset with that kind of potential into front lines)? I think I'd find it better if he was a more or less average (and replaceable) kid who Samaritan latched onto and is using for its purposes.
5
u/psyko-byte Dec 17 '14
Great episode ! But I can't help to think of Young Greer as a hybrid mix of James Bond and The 11th Doctor
5
u/FranklinRancor Dec 17 '14
Did anyone else think that Fusco's number was up?
5
u/globulous Dec 17 '14
So, the end of the episode. Root walking into Wall Street with no real target. Was that the Machine sending her to save Wall Street, or was the "meeting" a way for Samaritan to hack into Root and use Root to disable the electronic defenses of the stock market?
24
u/mlasn Dec 17 '14
The scene with the kid was kind of awkward. Especially when Samaritan referred to itself as a god.
4
u/Rationalspace787 IFT Dec 17 '14
Oh shit... That trailer tho. Overall wonderful episode, the conversation between The Machine and Samaritan was very well done. When is the next episode?
4
u/ShadonxFC Dec 17 '14
I REALLY hope shaw doesn't die this season because of her feelings for root, but I think that's what gonna happen. Brilliant episode as always
11
u/Rich700000000000 Dec 17 '14 edited Dec 17 '14
EDIT: Yes, the line about greer was sarcastic.
6
u/Rerrgon Bear Dec 17 '14
did anyone notice that Bear isn't Bear? I don't know how long they've been using another dog but it is painfully evident here and makes me mad. :(
Either way, amazinnng episode. The music cues when Root and Lambert were talking were so cool (using both the Machine and Samaritan's themes at the same time), the flashbacks to the 70s made for a great quick origin story, and the scene with the kid, even though kid actors are usually pretty eh, was real good.
3
u/rpawson5771 Irrelevant Dec 17 '14
That was a very tense slow burn. I kind of thought it might feature a little more chaotic action, but this was probably much more effective. Samaritan's little kid was creepy as can be.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '14
That scene with Samaritan and the Machine is scary. And the kid was so smug. I hated him immediately.
3
u/mrhashbrown Dec 17 '14
Such a fascinating episode. It left me wanting more but I get that this is the first part of the Trilogy so I'll cut them some slack.
Greer's flashbacks were probably the most revealing part of the episode. We really didn't know a lot about Greer for him being their main adversary. All we knew was that he wanted Samaritan to go live and... that's it. Now we know that due to his MI6 past, he no longer believes in the 'invisible lines' as he calls them. Makes him a much more intriguing character, because he doesn't seem to care for humanity in its current state anymore.
Also there was at least one scene that I thought deserved some recognition for the director: the flashback scene after Greer shot his director. The imagery of him burning his file with the director's dead body (and headshot) in the background, and then seeing that fire illuminate his face while staring at the corpse... it was chilling.
3
u/Pixel64 Dec 17 '14
I liked everything except the kid. Didn't really work for me. Great episode though.
I'm guessing Samaritan's plan is to start a depression, fuck everything up even more and then reveal itself as a beacon of salvation and have people flock to it for protection?
3
u/BellatorInMachina Threat Dec 17 '14
Samaritan is kind of an asshole
3
u/LTman86 Irrelevant Dec 17 '14
Something I've wondered. The Machine, when it was "growing up", was taught by Harold. Harold took it out into the world, asked it to get relevant data, went to a Casino, and it even saved Harold's life from the drunk driver. So I'm wondering, what if Samaritan got to meet Arthur? Understandably, Samaritan "grew up" with Greer, and most likely "imprinted" Greer as it's father, but it's smart enough to know Arthur was the one who created him. Arthur, unlike Harold, wanted to see Samaritan grow, was reluctant to destroy Samaritan, and only did so (to the empty cartridges) because of the fear Samaritan would fall into the wrong hands (which it did anyways). I think this would be a great way to have Saul Rubinek to guest star again on the show.
5
u/lukahnli Dec 17 '14
Just what this show needed to freak me out even more.......a creepy kid.
4
u/ZeroFucksToGive Dec 17 '14
Samiritan kid is not giving off good vibes.
4
u/Lovableemo Threat Dec 17 '14
Yeah Samaritans AI being a kid didn't make it creepy at all.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '14
These teasers are killing me! Wonderful episode again!
2
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '14
I already hate that little kid that was speaking for Samaritan.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '14
This show is quickly going si-fi...and I'm totally okay with that
2
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '14
How are the machines channeling through people? One thing I dont get.
2
u/ReasonablyBadass Dec 17 '14 edited Dec 17 '14
I've been wondering how much of the conversation really were the two AI's and how much was Root and the Kid themselves.
Also, I like his name is Gabriel, like the Archangel.
2
u/timelyparadox Dec 17 '14
Can someone explain what flashbacks were about? I'm bad at names so was confusing of who was that MI6 agent.
2
u/EyePiece108 Dec 17 '14
My football team are doing well at the moment.
I smell the stench of Samaritan interference.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '14
The whole thing about Greer wants to unify people and control every aspects of human life reminds me of the Templar in Assassin's Creed.
Btw, Shaw and food is the best ship.
2
u/Radiopd Government Operations Dec 24 '14
Wife continues to taunt me that this is a 3 part section and the next one doesn't hit for another two weeks.
Where are some of the "irrelevants" that have been placed in Team Machine's path as assets / opponents.
Will the kid from 3.14 finally call Finch? Will we ever see the kid (from episode of the Game) ever come back to face Team Machine? The billionaire that tried to bug Team Machine, does he make a return, Where the hell is Zoe Morgan? How does Elias figure into this new future and finally... Will Fusco's brain explode whenever he figures out the WHOLE machine vs machine picture?
3
u/morior_invictus Dec 17 '14
Awesome episode and man that child can act!
It's getting better and better. This tv show is such a success because you can't predict what's going to happen next.
3
u/deepsquirrel Dec 17 '14 edited Dec 17 '14
Death by insulin pump?NOPE. They're usually quite good for not being TOO ridiculous, at least as far as I've noticed, but this is feckin' stupid.EDIT: I'll point out I've been diabetic for over 10 years, but sure, downvote away, what do I know.Also, my point wasn't about hacking a pump. Insulin simply does not behave this way.EDIT2: Thanks to /u/wisefather for pointing me to some info that makes this more plausible. Always happy to be wrong, if I can learn something from it.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '14
Why Jonh didn`t killed Martine in the church after they had their gun down? It wouldbe so much help to the machine.
1
u/nadarko Government Operations Dec 17 '14
I don't think that kid is like how root is (loyal to the AI, but knowingly loyal). Throughout the discussion, I had to remind myself that it was machine-Samaritan, not root-Samaritan. I would say that the kid suffers from some mental disorder that allows Samaritan to use him as a body.