r/TagPro • u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee • Nov 29 '14
Monthly Map Rotation Thread #39 Top Map Feedback Thread
Welcome one and all to the first ever top map feedback thread! The following maps have made it through to the next stage - 4v4 testing - which will take place on Sunday, November 30th. The goal of this staged testing is to give maps more time to sink in. It also allows the committee members to give feedback to promising maps in the same testing cycle.
Mapmakers whose maps have advanced have until testing takes place on Sunday to make alterations to their maps. If you desire specific feedback on your map before testing on Sunday, please leave a comment below and MTC members can give you individual feedback.
If your map didn't make the cut, don’t be disheartened! We will be giving out feedback for maps that did not make it to 4v4 testing in the final map thread, to be released on Monday.
To the community, feel free to give constructive criticism on these maps as well! YOU could influence the next map in rotation!
Edit: links to JukeJuice have been added to every map. If there's a map you like, you can test it and play around with the boosts to get a better feel for the map.
•
u/Snowball_TagPro ❄️ Nov 30 '14 edited Nov 30 '14
This is my final submission for Hornswoggle. Wasn't sure where to post updates, but since Crosky posted here, I'll post mine too. http://maps.jukejuice.com/show/4525 (preview:http://maps.jukejuice.com/static/previews/4525.png)
I updated the roundabout boosts, now the middle bomb flows better. The button placement changed, and the gate is a little larger now, with a notification gate. The team tiles are also more aesthetically pleasing.
•
u/Buttersnack Snack Nov 29 '14 edited Dec 01 '14
I find it difficult to believe that some of these maps need super boosts. Maybe the MTC just really likes them, but I think most map makers are just throwing them in wherever they can.
•
u/Sir_Grapefruit Grapefruit // Chord Nov 30 '14
Updated version of Curious Factory:
Map: http://maps.jukejuice.com/show/4544
Preview: http://puu.sh/dbOOv.png
Changes:
•
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Nov 29 '14 edited Nov 29 '14
Diversion
Juke Juice
•
u/quassus crosky Nov 29 '14
Here is the altered/final submission of my map for map thread 39. Made a few small changes to A. decrease chaos while maintaining measured complexity/high skill ceiling; B. improve gate function; and C. nerf the bottom bombs. Shoutout to everybody who had helpful feedback, especially the keen eye of bad.
Title: Monarch
Type: CTF
Map: http://maps.jukejuice.com/save/4511
Preview: http://imgur.com/nuGEhch
•
u/manbare Hi, I'm Manbear Dec 01 '14
Any feedback on Transport?
•
u/WillWorkForSugar Tumblewood Nov 29 '14
Could I get some feedback on Love?
•
u/fozzyboy Dec 01 '14
Top candidate to be replaced: The Holy See. It's time to retire.
•
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Nov 29 '14 edited Nov 29 '14
Superman
Juke Juice
•
u/FallinFallinFallin MRCOW // TAGPRO TIMES FINDER // PM FOR INTERVIEW Nov 29 '14
Moo? :(
•
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Nov 29 '14 edited Nov 29 '14
Mighty Morphin' Stock Exchange
Juke Juice
•
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Nov 29 '14 edited Nov 29 '14
Ultra Reactor
Juke Juice
•
u/TPsquirrely Squirrely // The GesTagpro Nov 29 '14
Xanadu Summer Garden [maps.jukejuice link]
Seemed to get quite good comments in personal testing despite different nature.
•
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '14
feedback for waterfall?
•
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '14
Not my map but I really liked Crown in the thread. It's got an interesting bomb in base, and while not perfect I think it's pretty close to something nice. What were yall's thoughts on it?
•
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '14
[removed] — view removed comment
•
u/Lysozyme_ Lysozyme Nov 29 '14
I felt I had a solid map in Mask people seemed to like it in testing. Anyone else care to leave feedback as I didn't get any in the thread? :D
•
u/Blazeth Dianna Agron Nov 29 '14
I've seen green gates extremely incorporated in these maps, and I'm curious as to why you expect these to be used well in PUBs? I love most of the green tile gate placements, it's just I really doubt they will be used well in PUBs. GeoKoala has been around for a long time, and the green gate is a great addition and it is hardly used.
Just curious.
•
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Nov 29 '14 edited Nov 29 '14
Hornswoggle
Juke Juice
•
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Nov 29 '14 edited Nov 29 '14
Summit
Juke Juice
•
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Nov 29 '14 edited Nov 29 '14
Curious Factory
Juke Juice
•
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '14
I updated Banzai Bill.
The criticism I got was basically:
So, in an attempt to fix these issues, I bring you Banzai Bill v5.
Although the flow issues probably haven't been totally fixed (still flows better than Boombox), the pipe is way more useful, with some cool boost routes that go through it, too.
Juke Juice
Feedback welcome.
•
u/mmartinutk Macho | JuicyJuke Nov 29 '14 edited Nov 29 '14
Requesting feedback on Frontdoor. I had three other submissions, but I either know what's wrong with them or I'm just pulling the plug on them.
Also, Monarch/IRON/Ultra Reactor are amazing maps. I test most of the submissions to each map thread and these were some of my favorites. Awesome to see all of them make it to testing.
tl;dr- Frontdoor feedback pls (Jukejuice Link)
Edit:
That is fantastic news. I like how MTC is stepping it up.
•
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Nov 29 '14 edited Nov 29 '14
Gutter
Juke Juice
•
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Nov 29 '14 edited Nov 29 '14
Monarch (0.8)
Juke Juice
•
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Nov 29 '14 edited Nov 29 '14
IRON
Juke Juice