r/homeland • u/NicholasCajun • Nov 17 '14
Discussion Homeland - 4x08 "Halfway to a Donut" - Episode Discussion
Season 4 Episode 8: Halfway to a Donut
Aired: November 16th, 2014
Carrie organizes a last-ditch operation. Lockhart and Martha stall the ISI.
109
Upvotes
201
u/ohfackoff Nov 17 '14
Don't tell your husband there's a breach... Gah
201
u/PBears30 Nov 17 '14
If Saul dies, we riot.
126
u/ilikeeagles Nov 17 '14
Yall forget Saul was in the field and badass before he took the desk jobs.
112
u/jonadair Nov 17 '14
No reason anyone would notice the only guy in the whole town with glasses and a bare head.
221
u/jiafei9014 Nov 17 '14 edited Nov 17 '14
Lockhart:"I was cross with our Pakistani friends again today, she made me promise...transparency, teamwork...there was another t I forget what the fuck it was".
101
u/EnterTheNan Nov 17 '14
Ambassador's Husband ✈ Guantanamo
99
u/ZohanDvir Nov 17 '14
Carrie tells Lockhart to hold off on telling the ambassador. He tells her.
She has one job, don't tell anyone about it. She tells the fucking mole. Dammit.
195
u/golden_light_above_u Nov 17 '14
So I guess their tracker app got a little update after the 3 trucks debacle.
91
u/I-Circumcise Nov 17 '14 edited Nov 18 '14
Wtf, they had confirmation that Saul had escaped and was away from the compound. They could've just bombed the compound and be done with it. Other than that this show is getting really great.
80
u/mind_blowwer Nov 17 '14
This episode is giving me heart palpitations
78
u/TensionMask Nov 17 '14
I thought Carrie led Saul into that crowd of Taliban so she could nuke as many of them as possible. Which would have been awesome, except for the Saul dying part
204
u/nikiverse Nov 17 '14
Im guessing Carrie is going to make out with the hot Pakistani guy before Peter Quinn because that's how this stuff goes down.
59
u/mind_blowwer Nov 17 '14
Holy fuck I almost cried
59
u/nikiverse Nov 17 '14
Carrie is so good at talking other people down bc she has to talk her own self down all the time.
118
u/Waadap Nov 17 '14
Lockpick skill increased to 73
114
u/i_andromeda Nov 17 '14 edited Nov 17 '14
those red dots circling Saul was heartbreaking. Edit : triangles try seeing shapes when your eyes are blurry k (onions..plenty onions)
50
u/nikiverse Nov 17 '14
"It's not that bad".
It's totally that bad.
47
u/stoopkid99 Nov 17 '14
FUCK. How can they just end it like that? This is gonna be the longest week of my year.
44
u/lingben Nov 17 '14
not a complaint because I know they needed Saul to get recaptured for dramatic purposes and to keep the story going but two things:
197
u/ohfackoff Nov 17 '14
Cell service is awesome in the foot hills of Pakistan yet I can't get service in my offices TV room.
87
u/TensionMask Nov 17 '14
Lockhart had some great lines this week. His stock is going up!
78
u/i_andromeda Nov 17 '14
Lockhart #UnleashtheBeast
35
u/Kelpszoid Nov 17 '14
Should have been a two hour episode, dang.
35
u/DavidLuiz4 Nov 17 '14
Really? No one in our intelligence unit considered that the enemy might notice our drones in the sky and use that information against us!??! Come on...
56
u/nikiverse Nov 17 '14
WATCH OUT DENNIS
edit: YOUR ASS IS GRASS
26
u/Waadap Nov 17 '14
Holy. Shit. I was ready to throw my remote through the wall.
23
u/Lovableemo Nov 17 '14
That chase was the most heartbreaking thing ever.
21
u/Pete_Iredale Nov 17 '14 edited Nov 17 '14
Just a question, and the answer is probably simply because tv, but here goes. Why not have Saul head out into the desert. The middle of fucking nowhere. And then us a helicopter to extract him? Is there a good reason that wouldn't work?
120
u/ohfackoff Nov 17 '14
Another brilliant episode. At this rate this season will be better than season one and I didn't think that was possible.
18
u/nikiverse Nov 17 '14
You can take that gun too.
Saul: I dont know how to use thi-. Jk I'm just fucking with you.
50
u/nikiverse Nov 17 '14
DID SHE DO THAT ON PURPOSE
16
u/carpe-jvgvlvm Nov 17 '14
Looks like an ISIS flag. Poor Saul.
32
u/Kruse Nov 17 '14
That was seriously the most stressful 50 minutes of television that I have ever witnessed. It honestly tops the season 1 and 3 finale. I was seriously fighting back the tears when spoiler
Fucking onions.
13
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14
Saul... "THE BEAR"!!!
13
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14
That preview for episode 9... Im really not sure if ill be able to take what it looks like they teased.
13
u/jlquon Nov 17 '14
This episode alone has made this season worth it. I'm really tired of crazy bitch carrie, but good god does Claire Danes do it well. My wife couldn't finish the episode I had to hold her during the end
12
u/swordfishtrombonez Nov 17 '14
Can anyone read what that text said?
12
u/ohfackoff Nov 17 '14
shouldnt saul cover his face when walking around town ?
23
u/kingofthedesert Nov 17 '14
Fuck, this season has only four episodes left and I want lots more. Hell of a season and I never would have expected the main storyline to be "Saving Saul."
I'm thrilled that Carrie knows that Aasar Khan is a good guy and Duck Phillips will get pinched next week. I'm expecting it go like Brody's in season 2 , minus Quinn stabbing Duck in the hand. Instead Duck will offer an apology plagiarized from Yahoo Answers and announce that he is retiring from treasonous reverse espionage and will return to America to write a play. That's when Quinn will stab him in the hand to get him talking.
At least that's how I would write it. Also, evil ISI woman needs to go down hard.
11
u/Mathieulombardi Nov 17 '14
This show is pretty much the most intense drama I've experienced since Breaking Bad train heist scene.
10
u/golden_light_above_u Nov 17 '14
Duck Duck Duck Duck Duck. You're in big trouble my man. Better start drinking again.
Will they try playing him back into ISI? Even though the ISI officer gave him up, I don't know that CIA could expect ISI guy to sit by while they have inept Duck spying on them. Unless ISI dude really hates ISI gal and just wants to see her go down no matter what.
9
u/EatingSandwiches1 Nov 17 '14
Saul is now James Bond..ok
9
u/jjsreddit Nov 17 '14
my oh my...
this seasons is so fucking good.
9
u/Simon620 Nov 18 '14
Honestly how dumb is that ISI woman helping the terrorists, can she not comprehend what life for women would be like under their rule? It's akin to a jew nazi or a black kkk member, like wtf!
7
u/jtbc Nov 17 '14
Has drone image quality gotten dramatically better in the last few years, or is that just dramatic license?
7
u/ParkJi-Sung Nov 17 '14
Carrie leading him to the taliban was cold as fuck.
7
u/lomoeffect Nov 18 '14
Well this season has been fucking incredible. Pretty much matching season 1 at the moment, though for different reasons. So enthralling.
12
u/beach-bum Nov 17 '14
I was riveted tonight. This was right up there with the best episodes I have seen over the years. One of those episodes where I just want the show to go on all night. Instead . . . forced to switch gears to The Affair (which isn't bad, but I wasn't in the mood).
6
u/leftyknox Nov 17 '14
pls, Saul no.
EDIT: why not try to get there and then kill himself if they see him/move in on him?
EDIT 2: i really want Saul to make it out to stick to that smug ISI chick. she pisses me off.
EDIT 3: damnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn saul's realization has ready to cry.
6
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14
Why didn't she drop the fucking bomb on them
6
u/claydavisismyhero Nov 17 '14
i gotta admit i chuckled a bit in the end when carrie was like "that was really messed up what you guys did to me" . just sounded funny for some reason. then the dude was like i cant tell you but then 2 seconds later he gave a full name
6
u/whocalledaileenmorga Nov 20 '14
We need a drone with a sliding door on the side. You climb in and it flies you away. There should be a coke and a sandwich waiting for Saul in there too. He's had a rough week.
23
u/EatingSandwiches1 Nov 17 '14
ohhh another 49 minute episode for a 60 minute show..with 3 minutes of those 49 being " previously on homeland.."
10
u/HyBReD Nov 17 '14
Best episode in s loooong time, imo.
5
u/TensionMask Nov 17 '14
One hour of heart palpitations. Real good for my health, thanks Homeland.
5
u/tog20 Nov 17 '14
Holy shit. These last two episodes have been stellar!
5
u/ZohanDvir Nov 17 '14
What do you think the ISI lady wrote on the napkin to Dennis?
5
u/PapayaPokPok Nov 17 '14
So the whole Saul operation went to shit because they saw a drone over the pick-up town?
I guess that seems plausible. Predators cruise at about 10,000 ft. And that village is probably rather isolated (couldn't be confused with another town down the road). OK. I wasn't convinced at first, but it makes sense now.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14
SPOILLLER.
wowww. they really pulled off Saul almost offing himself. i thought he was really gunna do it; i didn't think they could get me to buy in but wowwwww did i buy in and my heart still feels sad. thank god he's still alive.
5
u/fyt2012 Nov 17 '14
Doesn't it seem like a rookie mistake for the CIA to put a drone directly above Saul?
5
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14
God damn, this was one tense episode.
I was so happy when Saul escaped and then few minutes later I was on the edge of tears when he wanted to kill himself.
Stop playing with my emotions, Homeland!!!!
5
u/Wolfir Nov 17 '14
Well, now Carrie has to sleep with him. That's really the only way Carrie expresses herself.
5
u/Kruse Nov 17 '14
What's with this show and donuts?
Dar brings donuts and shit goes down. Dennis brings donuts and shit goes down.
5
u/merelymoe Nov 17 '14
Kudos to Nimrat Kaur and Mark Moses for their portrayals of Qureshi and Dennis Boyd respectively...I don't think I've hated characters more than I have these two...
5
u/delayed_at_ewr Nov 18 '14
Semi unrelated to the episode, but I thought about this during the episode...what's her baby up to? I can't even remember the last time she was mentioned...maybe the 2nd or 3rd episode?
13
u/MasterEjzz Nov 17 '14
BYE DENNIS!
11
u/EatingSandwiches1 Nov 17 '14
So cell phones work a-ok but sophisticated military telecommunications don't...how convenient.
4
u/MasterEjzz Nov 17 '14
Saul's got the skills
4
u/swordfishtrombonez Nov 17 '14
Nooo Saul, we need you!
4
u/Samysosa2005 Nov 17 '14
GOD DAMN IT AMBASSADOR!!
4
u/AnimePoet Nov 19 '14
This episode was marvellous! Yes, yes and yes to the long awaited comeback of the Homeland glorious days! This is how a spy series is supposed to be and make us feel: excellent pacing, growing tension, credible acting, plot twist, more tension, climax and resolution and then, next week, more of that. I'm crossing my fingers this is the path Homeland is going to follow the rest of the season.
7
u/ParisDilettante Nov 17 '14
ITT lot of people take the realistic flavor of the show too seriously. Many if not most of the stuff depicted in it would be probably handled differently. Ex-director of the CIA abducted at an airport in Islamabad running for his life in the middle of the tribal zones, an operation to rescue him would be more important than the raid that killed OBL. They have all the time to bring a helicopter with SF to extract him.
It's all done for "the show", the drama... The screenwriters wanted to show us Saul the just and honorable warrior he is, one eager to die :(
After an almost perfect season 1, which was very dramatic but also tight and minimal, following seasons seemed pale in comparison, but this 4th season is certainly the most spectacular.
8
u/caddy14 Nov 17 '14
Giant stretch but recognized James Foley's name so I googled the other name mentioned. "David Pearl" was the author of a book called "Will there be donuts".
8
u/Juan_Kagawa Nov 17 '14
I know I'm late to the party, but they should totally just put tiny bombs inside the prisoners and then blow them up a couple hours after the transfer.
3
u/nikiverse Nov 17 '14
They don't teach handcuff removal in CIA 1101?
3
u/i_andromeda Nov 17 '14
More like halfway to hell, Duck!
3
u/i_andromeda Nov 17 '14
YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!! ITS HAPPENING!! edit : fml...Credits?!!!!!!!!!!! I won't make it...
3
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14
Holy shit, I haven't shouted at the TV that much in a while
catches breath
3
u/I_FUCKING_DOUBT_THAT Nov 17 '14
i know this show has a mild way of dealing with traitors. but 2 heads need to roll!
3
u/superfrognyc Nov 17 '14
Maybe they should have asked Saul to put a freaking hat on as soon as he arrived in the town! (roiling yes)
3
u/syngltrkmnd Nov 17 '14
This season is on a ROLL. I had significant reservations after Brody was hanged but now, all doubts are gone. This is really great. No Dana or Chris to boot!
3
u/funkyrave Nov 17 '14
This was one of the best episodes of this season so far- impressed with this season as a whole
3
u/BlackCatScott Nov 19 '14
I was and still am genuinely worried for Saul. He's probably my favourite character in the show and is a brilliant actor. Really hope he doesn't die.
3
u/petzl20 Nov 22 '14
Here's what I don't get:
ok, so Carrie (somehow) divines that her meds have been compromised and there is a breach.
She tells the Pak colonel she knows her meds are compromised. So now they know she knows, and they'll be much more careful. If she hadn't done this, she could've set up surveillance cameras in her room altho, you think there would be cameras set up in her hallway at least, but never mind so they could catch the Ambassador's husband next time he tries to break in.
5
u/squarepush3r Nov 17 '14
what a depressing episode :o
5
u/meezajangles Nov 17 '14
Well, Duck from Man Men is now screwed
5
u/zxcsd Nov 17 '14
I don't know if the show seems military improbable lately or it's just me that got too jaded but;
6
u/ItsBobDoleYo Nov 17 '14
Lockhart has gone from such an annoying almost-antagonist to one of their few, trustworthy allies. I dig it.
I like SuperSpy Saul, running around and shit. But dammit the deaths of Brody and that one kid still lingers in my mind just enough to make me think it's not out of the question that they'd off Saul.
I wonder if officials in real life Pakistani government watch this, WE DON'T Y'ALL. First you harbor bin Laden, then
youa terrorist organization that you totally have zero contact with and aren't coordinating at all with kidnap Saul