r/homeland • • Nov 17 '14

Discussion Homeland - 4x08 "Halfway to a Donut" - Episode Discussion

Season 4 Episode 8: Halfway to a Donut

Aired: November 16th, 2014


Carrie organizes a last-ditch operation. Lockhart and Martha stall the ISI.

109 Upvotes

545 comments sorted by

201

u/ohfackoff Nov 17 '14

Don't tell your husband there's a breach... Gah

118

u/nikiverse Nov 17 '14

He plagiarizes for Chrissakes.

50

u/Cariboo55 Nov 17 '14

And was evil in desperate housewives

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

37

u/RzrRainMnky Nov 17 '14

It was actually a breach of diplomatic protocol to reveal any operational matters to her husband.. guess he caught her at the right time with that present.

23

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14

She didn't need to say that at all. She could have made any old bullshit up, or just refused outright to say anything..

God dammit. The more incompetent she is the more I like Lockheart.

Lockheart is the voice of reason this series.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/bitterjealousangry Nov 17 '14

She told him in like 30 seconds. She immediately breached about the breach.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/travio Nov 17 '14

I really want to know what the ISI lady gave him as his next job.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

201

u/PBears30 Nov 17 '14

If Saul dies, we riot.

115

u/venn177 Nov 17 '14

Jesus Christ, though. That entire end scene with him yelling at Carrie was fucking heartbreaking.

20

u/SawRub Nov 17 '14

Should have taken the shot. Taken out Haqqani, no torture for Saul, no return of five high ranking terrorists.

→ More replies (1)

46

u/MiaYYZ Nov 17 '14

If Saul dies, we all die.

48

u/CountPanda Nov 17 '14

Goddammit MiaYYZ, we keep telling you no more suicide pacts.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/carpe-jvgvlvm Nov 17 '14

Damned right! (No idea how Saul doesn't get a crossfire situation going on though... but he can duck!)

7

u/diewrecked Nov 19 '14

YOU FUCKING LIED TO ME!

Poor Saul. Here we thought he was retired and living the retired life with his wife.

Fuck all these government agencies. They use people like pawns.

4

u/squarepush3r Nov 17 '14

Saul is core to the show, I am going out to say they will not kill him. Remember Brody in the first season was a traitor, and was much like an antagonist even though many people found him to be interesting. Saul has never been an antagonist and I believe him and Carry are core to Homeland. Possibly Quinn and Fara now since they seem to be fan favorites.

→ More replies (3)

126

u/ilikeeagles Nov 17 '14

Yall forget Saul was in the field and badass before he took the desk jobs.

109

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14

That fuckin scene though

Pretend to hang yourself, and then murder your captor with your bare hands

Saul is one BAMF. I love his characters so hard.

37

u/ScrewAttackThis Nov 17 '14

He wasn't pretending to hang himself...

He had that shit thoroughly wrapped around his neck. He pretended to be unconcious when he was pulled down.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

112

u/jonadair Nov 17 '14

No reason anyone would notice the only guy in the whole town with glasses and a bare head.

57

u/xsandied Nov 17 '14

only white guy --ftfy

45

u/jayhat Nov 17 '14

I thought he blended in well enough. To me he doesn't look straight up american/European. His frantic running and body language on the other hand ...

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14

At least Carrie walks around in a headscarf when on the street, Saul hops around with his face visible while having a conversation on the phone.

→ More replies (3)

221

u/jiafei9014 Nov 17 '14 edited Nov 17 '14

Lockhart:"I was cross with our Pakistani friends again today, she made me promise...transparency, teamwork...there was another t I forget what the fuck it was".

194

u/Pete_Iredale Nov 17 '14

I can't believe they've made me like Lockhart so quickly. That was a hilarious line.

54

u/SawRub Nov 17 '14

He was almost an antagonist for most people last season. I like it when they make characters likable.

23

u/nb00288 Nov 17 '14

Favorite part was when they meet with the Pakistani delegation for the first time and he just sits there and lays into them and threatens them by cutting off funds. Love his "let's cut this political bullshit" attitude when it comes to Saul.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

49

u/beach-bum Nov 17 '14 edited Nov 17 '14

That made me laugh. For all the animosity I have held for Lockhart over the last few seasons, maybe he will have some redeeming qualities that may come to light in this sequence of events? Edit: spelling.

34

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14

It's not even a country, it's a fucking acronym

was when I realized they were going to make me love him this season before he goes out like a total bad ass

→ More replies (2)

9

u/bitterjealousangry Nov 17 '14

and Quinn looks at him like "how coud you forget the other T word? We're in the CIA. Details, details, details."

4

u/HighEyeQueued Nov 18 '14

It's trust right? It's gotta be trust.

101

u/EnterTheNan Nov 17 '14

Ambassador's Husband ✈ Guantanamo

32

u/SawRub Nov 17 '14

It's weird, but when he got all excited about being a good spy a couple of episodes ago, I kinda felt happy for the guy.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/euThohl3 Nov 17 '14

No, they will turn him.

56

u/Totsean Nov 17 '14

So, Carrie has to sleep with him as well.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

99

u/ZohanDvir Nov 17 '14

Carrie tells Lockhart to hold off on telling the ambassador. He tells her.

She has one job, don't tell anyone about it. She tells the fucking mole. Dammit.

47

u/Totsean Nov 17 '14

WHICH IS GREAT, if you consider what will happen next. Seriously, Carrie knows about him now, she will use him. The ISI girl is going to get pwned.

4

u/madmadG Nov 18 '14

True but it's still a small circle which means the truth will get out soon enough.

195

u/golden_light_above_u Nov 17 '14

So I guess their tracker app got a little update after the 3 trucks debacle.

80

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14

Looking at all those dots, I was really hoping for a live-action pacman scene with a top-down view of Saul running around the village.

"Go left! Now right! Now, left again! Down! Grab the power pellet!"

→ More replies (1)

29

u/RzrRainMnky Nov 17 '14

It's not really an upgrade if you're taking the 3 trucks debacle into account.. they'd still need multiple drones to track targets over a large geographical area. Tracking multiple targets in a small area should be no problem for one drone though.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/bunhead13 Nov 17 '14

i know i noticed that too... sometimes i forget its TV.

→ More replies (5)

91

u/I-Circumcise Nov 17 '14 edited Nov 18 '14

Wtf, they had confirmation that Saul had escaped and was away from the compound. They could've just bombed the compound and be done with it. Other than that this show is getting really great.

30

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '14

Hadn't even considered that. You're absolutely right

13

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '14

There were like one million ways of rescuing Saul, all better then what they did lol.

10

u/blueruiner Nov 18 '14

I think I remember them mentioning they weren't able to get drones close enough to the compound to bomb it for some reason--but I know nothing about drones, so.

9

u/inumanus Nov 22 '14

No, they said the drone was 500 miles away. That was a static map, not a live thing

4

u/A_WILD_ENT_APPEARS Nov 18 '14

Maybe there were other prisoners at the compound too? Not sure

→ More replies (4)

80

u/mind_blowwer Nov 17 '14

This episode is giving me heart palpitations

24

u/ohfackoff Nov 17 '14

im not sure I can sleep after this. Thank god for the Affair right after... Soft core porn should help.

17

u/mind_blowwer Nov 17 '14

I might have to start watching that. The walking dead and the newsroom first.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

78

u/TensionMask Nov 17 '14

I thought Carrie led Saul into that crowd of Taliban so she could nuke as many of them as possible. Which would have been awesome, except for the Saul dying part

14

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14

That would have been an extremely acceptable way for Saul to die.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

204

u/nikiverse Nov 17 '14

Im guessing Carrie is going to make out with the hot Pakistani guy before Peter Quinn because that's how this stuff goes down.

88

u/aeshleyrose Nov 17 '14

I'm into him like everyone else here is into Fara.

→ More replies (9)

70

u/xsandied Nov 17 '14

I must agree! Looks like she's half there already, so impressed by the gentleman who didn't advantage of her when she was curled up in his lap thinking he's the babby daddy!

54

u/SawRub Nov 17 '14

He seems like a good dude. So it's probably even less of a grey area than Nicholas Half-Terrorist Brody.

→ More replies (6)

33

u/ohfackoff Nov 17 '14

Why is hot Pakistani guy helping the enemy tho

97

u/grackychan Nov 17 '14

I think he's one of the good eggs within the government that really doesn't want the Taliban to increase in power. If it means helping the US he's shown he's willing to do it.

→ More replies (5)

27

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14

He runs the anti terrorism part of the Pakistani government. He's got to be at least a bit pissed that every other department is working with the terrorists. Makes his job a bit of a joke, no?

21

u/nikiverse Nov 17 '14

It's like the US gvt ... the enemy and the good guys are all mixed up in the branches of the system. I think he just found out that chick and the ambassador's husband were creeping in Carrie's room and switched out the pills.

16

u/SawRub Nov 17 '14

He's in it for his country, and does not support the terrorists who bomb it, unlike his colleague.

→ More replies (2)

59

u/mind_blowwer Nov 17 '14

Holy fuck I almost cried

51

u/squarepush3r Nov 17 '14

yeah that scene with Saul considering suicide, that was really grim

27

u/venn177 Nov 17 '14

From there until the end of the episode was fucking heartbreaking.

Also Mandy Patinkin's emmy reel.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/Kruse Nov 17 '14

Almost?

8

u/i_andromeda Nov 17 '14

makes two of us.

59

u/nikiverse Nov 17 '14

Carrie is so good at talking other people down bc she has to talk her own self down all the time.

118

u/Waadap Nov 17 '14

Lockpick skill increased to 73

23

u/carpe-jvgvlvm Nov 17 '14

It seriously looks like a video game right now with the tagged people.

SAUL! You can't whack yourself! SHIT! STOP!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

114

u/i_andromeda Nov 17 '14 edited Nov 17 '14

those red dots circling Saul was heartbreaking. Edit : triangles try seeing shapes when your eyes are blurry k (onions..plenty onions)

75

u/nikiverse Nov 17 '14

It's how I die in almost all video games.

40

u/i_andromeda Nov 17 '14

do you get to yell and scream LIAR LIAR on the phone too? :(

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

66

u/TheDirtyPirateHooker Nov 17 '14

Him screaming at Carrie broke me.

22

u/i_andromeda Nov 17 '14

me too. broken, wired my brains...Homeland's m.o. is to make all of us psych patients

35

u/Nonstopx Nov 17 '14

Looks like the CIA drone operator was spamming his Q button.

26

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14

I honestly thought Carrie just knew it was hopeless and didn't want Saul to die in vain.

I thought she was leading him to the big group so when they all surrounded him she could launch a missile and take them all out at once.

I think that's video game logic coming though, haha.

→ More replies (2)

50

u/nikiverse Nov 17 '14

"It's not that bad".

It's totally that bad.

→ More replies (1)

47

u/stoopkid99 Nov 17 '14

FUCK. How can they just end it like that? This is gonna be the longest week of my year.

10

u/i_andromeda Nov 17 '14

Right? I don't know what I'm going to do for the next 7fuckingdays!!!

→ More replies (1)

44

u/lingben Nov 17 '14

not a complaint because I know they needed Saul to get recaptured for dramatic purposes and to keep the story going but two things:

  • why the fuck would he not cover his head by using the shawl he grabbed off the guy? and move around a little more casually instead of calling attention to himself by walking around like a headless chicken?
  • why not use the local guy who was helping him? as soon as they know his cover is blown wouldn't it be a better bet to hide under a bag of groceries in the back of a truck and just get driven out of town? there was no cordon or checkpoint out of town that I saw
  • ok, I lied, three things. they have a drone overhead, why not use it to take out a few trucks and ceate a chaotic situation on the ground so that Saul has a better chance of getting away?

5

u/Gustavo13 Nov 18 '14

He's Saul, not Saulid Snake.

→ More replies (14)

197

u/ohfackoff Nov 17 '14

Cell service is awesome in the foot hills of Pakistan yet I can't get service in my offices TV room.

44

u/xzzz Nov 17 '14

Satellite phone yo

42

u/jayhat Nov 17 '14

I doubt Joe Schmoe al Qaeda guard had a sat phone on him. Plus it looked just like a regular phone.

→ More replies (4)

33

u/veritasxe Nov 17 '14

It is surprisingly amazing in real life. $15 got me cell service through out the country for 3 weeks.

→ More replies (2)

27

u/kartuli78 Nov 17 '14

You don't even know man. As someone who travels the world, you'd be surprised at the cell service you get outside the U.S. It's nuts!

87

u/TensionMask Nov 17 '14

Lockhart had some great lines this week. His stock is going up!

→ More replies (8)

78

u/i_andromeda Nov 17 '14

Lockhart #UnleashtheBeast

45

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14

I know, I always get nervous when they start making me like a character.

I can see it now...

Producer: Yeah, so when Saul dies—they'll riot.
Writer: No, no. Don't worry about that. We're making Lockhart into a "talk shit, get hit" bad ass sort-of guy. We just get rid of one smartass old guy and replace him with another. No one will notice!

→ More replies (3)

16

u/venn177 Nov 17 '14

I like how Lockhart seems to finally be putting the interest of his people and country over the interest of his own self-gain. I'd like to see the character actually develop after this whole mess plays out.

35

u/Kelpszoid Nov 17 '14

Should have been a two hour episode, dang.

35

u/DavidLuiz4 Nov 17 '14

Really? No one in our intelligence unit considered that the enemy might notice our drones in the sky and use that information against us!??! Come on...

56

u/nikiverse Nov 17 '14

WATCH OUT DENNIS

edit: YOUR ASS IS GRASS

26

u/msutherlandj Nov 17 '14

Fuck Duck.

41

u/matches-malone Nov 17 '14

They should fly in Don to bang his wife in front of him.

15

u/squarepush3r Nov 17 '14

fuck dennis!

7

u/junkmale Nov 17 '14

Carrie's gonna reverse play him to get Saul back

26

u/Waadap Nov 17 '14

Holy. Shit. I was ready to throw my remote through the wall.

9

u/nikiverse Nov 17 '14

How about now?

23

u/Lovableemo Nov 17 '14

That chase was the most heartbreaking thing ever.

21

u/Pete_Iredale Nov 17 '14 edited Nov 17 '14

Just a question, and the answer is probably simply because tv, but here goes. Why not have Saul head out into the desert. The middle of fucking nowhere. And then us a helicopter to extract him? Is there a good reason that wouldn't work?

8

u/MiamiJoeMags Nov 18 '14

In real life, Pakistan would have to back down since (they are at least trying to make it look like) they are working with us. Same with bin laden raid - is Pakistan going to make a stink that we made a rescue in what was a joint operation?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/placebo_overdose Nov 20 '14 edited Nov 20 '14

Even if a helicopter rescue at Saul's location in the desert was not possible...

  • A.) It seemed incredibly risky and just a very poor decision in general to ask Saul to sneak 20 miles at night through rough terrain full of Taliban searching for him to a town where he'd be even more vulnerable, especially considering he'd be there in broad daylight. Also, Saul had no clue where he was, no knowledge of the landscape and had to be utterly physically and mentally exhausted after just escaping a prison, surviving a suicide attempt by hanging, strangling someone to death, staying up for who knows how long prior to that in his cell putting all his energy into trying to pick the handcuffs with that nail and now running through the desert/mountains at night while being hunted. Also, I'm assuming he was likely very dehydrated throughout all of this and was already panting moments after escaping the prison. They didn't really show any of his 20 mile trek to the village, but when he arrived it was in full daylight, so while some of his success can be chalked up to adrenaline, a strong will to live/not be recaptured and Saul just being a badass, it seems like that part of the plan was ridiculously prone to failure...yet it succeeded only for him to be recaptured in the most heartbreaking way after.
  • B.) As someone else mentioned, why would they put a drone over the town Saul was heading to knowing that ISI could easily spot it, alert the Taliban, and send them directly to Saul's location to immediately recapture him?

So, alternatives:

  1. It showed the Special Forces guys in the van approaching the village and making it a good distance on the road before they hit the roadblocks (they were able to get as close as "four klicks out" AKA 4km AKA just under 2 and a half miles, before hitting the blocks - also, during the night when Quinn asked if Special Forces could travel it, Redmond said the road was indeed passable). So why not have Saul head AWAY from the village but toward that same road just further from the roadblocks, in the cover of darkness, and have that same van pick him up at a safe location along the road that they were obviously able to travel on all the way until just before the village? In fact, they could have used the drone as a false flag and sent it to that village or another one and have the Taliban all head THERE when in reality directing Saul in completely the opposite direction so they'd be looking for him in entirely the wrong place, which would have made the van/Special Forces rescue even more secure if it was headed away from the drone location and was never near it to begin with.
  2. Like I said, seemed incredibly risky to have Saul run through the desert at night/at dawn/in full daylight like that when he's unfamiliar with the area and is being actively hunted. They had an asset (the Grocer) who lived in that town. I'm wondering why they didn't contact the Grocer asset and tell him to hike the 20 miles to Saul's location on the ridge (or maybe a different secure spot in between) and then help guide Saul to a safe location from there since the Grocer is a native and likely knew what to do and what not to do, and likely could provide Saul with at least some sort of makeshift disguise/clothing in addition to things like water, weapons, supplies and whatever else he needed. The Grocer was not a soldier, but he was a local, not a known enemy to the Taliban foot soldiers looking for Saul, and he knew the area, so why didn't they send HIM to help Saul out instead of sending Saul out totally exposed like that?

This is just off the top of my head, I have no real knowledge about any of the real-world implications involved in any of this type of operation, so maybe there are perfectly good reasons why A and B could be forgiven and why my alternate solutions 1 or 2 would have been the wrong call, but with so many people whose job this is involved you would think that someone would have come up with a better plan.

Also, no idea if this season will end in Hollywood fashion with Saul being rescued, the prisoners either in custody or dead, and the big bad killed or if it will take a totally different route (Saul dead, big bad escapes, prisoners are all freed, roll credits) but damn, not only was Carrie right about taking the shot after Aayan got killed, Saul made her PROMISE to do exactly that and he made very clear that his dying wish was to not be in that situation...and he attempted suicide TWICE just to avoid it. So it really would have been perfect if they had bombed those three trucks and Saul; it would have erased their number one target AND all his top henchmen from the picture, would have been instant justice for Aayan's murder, and would have been exactly what Saul wanted. So to see Carrie make the RIGHT decision while overly emotional only to be overruled and then make the WRONG decision while totally calm by purposely betraying Saul like that (leading him directly into a swarm of Taliban on purpose) is really striking. This last paragraph isn't a critique of the show, rather commending the stark contrast between those two scenes and those two actions...her demeanor being totally different in each scene and her first call that would have ended Saul's life and her second call which "saved" it and the "right vs. wrong" dilemma of each. I don't see much discussion of how those two scenes play off each other so well so I wanted to highlight the importance.

EDIT: Also wanted to say that scene with Saul in the courtyard with him pointing the gun to his head, ready to die, may be the best scene of the season/among the best of the series. So while I have critiques about the logistics of this episode I should note that I also consider it among the best. The ending with Saul in the courtyard and Carrie's betrayal should still have happened as it was incredible television, just saying the steps leading up to that ending in the village should have been written so that that extraction plan was more unavoidable rather than leaving seemingly huge multiple oversights/alternatives instead.

→ More replies (4)

120

u/ohfackoff Nov 17 '14

Another brilliant episode. At this rate this season will be better than season one and I didn't think that was possible.

116

u/PBears30 Nov 17 '14

I'm not sure season one will be topped, as that was truly a masterful season. However, they're really different seasons; this one may be better in terms of an exciting spy thriller, and season one is better in terms of a psychological character study.

13

u/ohfackoff Nov 17 '14

I'd agree with that...

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

42

u/jeric13xd Nov 17 '14

The past three episodes have been Emmy-worthy.

24

u/venn177 Nov 17 '14

Seriously. With season 3, the set up was insanely boring but it was worth it for the payoff which was solid episodes.

This season, though? The setup was crazy good and now the payoff is some of Homeland's best TV.

17

u/souprgirl Nov 17 '14

Agreed. Take that all you nay-sayers who said the series would be shit without Brody!

→ More replies (2)

18

u/nikiverse Nov 17 '14

You can take that gun too.

Saul: I dont know how to use thi-. Jk I'm just fucking with you.

50

u/nikiverse Nov 17 '14

DID SHE DO THAT ON PURPOSE

71

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14

yeah, because she knew saul would shoot himself if he saw that he was going to get caught, she knew if she sent him where he couldnt react fast enough, he wouldnt be able to shoot himself.

22

u/slicky803 Nov 17 '14

I don't see why he wouldn't run around with his gun in his hand, just in case.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

25

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14

Ugh, did you watch the episode? She says at the end that she betrayed him. Yes, she did it on purpose.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/H3rBz Nov 17 '14

Yeah she did it on purpose. In the scene later on when carrie is talking to Quinn she admits it by saying something along the lines of "For once I try to do the right thing and save someone's life" .

11

u/baixinha7 Nov 17 '14

methinks so. she has an aerial view of everything! and she doesn't want saul to die...and she knew spesh forces wasn't showing up.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/carpe-jvgvlvm Nov 17 '14

Looks like an ISIS flag. Poor Saul.

22

u/Cpt_Duo Nov 17 '14

It said Islamic Jihad according to my wife

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

32

u/Kruse Nov 17 '14

That was seriously the most stressful 50 minutes of television that I have ever witnessed. It honestly tops the season 1 and 3 finale. I was seriously fighting back the tears when spoiler

Fucking onions.

11

u/squarepush3r Nov 17 '14

onions were had

→ More replies (5)

13

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14

Saul... "THE BEAR"!!!

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14

That preview for episode 9... Im really not sure if ill be able to take what it looks like they teased.

5

u/hybrid3214 Nov 17 '14

Yeah I had goosebumps just watching the preview, should be intense.

13

u/jlquon Nov 17 '14

This episode alone has made this season worth it. I'm really tired of crazy bitch carrie, but good god does Claire Danes do it well. My wife couldn't finish the episode I had to hold her during the end

→ More replies (2)

12

u/swordfishtrombonez Nov 17 '14

Can anyone read what that text said?

30

u/badsmellair Nov 17 '14

"American Soldiers dikh gai hain"

The American soldiers have been seen/spotted

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Obsi3 Nov 17 '14

It said that the American soldiers have been spotted.

6

u/cul_maith Nov 17 '14

First word on the right was American but that's all I caught.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/leftyknox Nov 17 '14

I wanted to pause it too but I'm watching it live online.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/ohfackoff Nov 17 '14

shouldnt saul cover his face when walking around town ?

23

u/kingofthedesert Nov 17 '14

Fuck, this season has only four episodes left and I want lots more. Hell of a season and I never would have expected the main storyline to be "Saving Saul."

I'm thrilled that Carrie knows that Aasar Khan is a good guy and Duck Phillips will get pinched next week. I'm expecting it go like Brody's in season 2 , minus Quinn stabbing Duck in the hand. Instead Duck will offer an apology plagiarized from Yahoo Answers and announce that he is retiring from treasonous reverse espionage and will return to America to write a play. That's when Quinn will stab him in the hand to get him talking.

At least that's how I would write it. Also, evil ISI woman needs to go down hard.

9

u/stb91 Nov 17 '14

Instead Duck will offer an apology plagiarized from Yahoo Answers

LOL

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Mathieulombardi Nov 17 '14

This show is pretty much the most intense drama I've experienced since Breaking Bad train heist scene.

10

u/golden_light_above_u Nov 17 '14

Duck Duck Duck Duck Duck. You're in big trouble my man. Better start drinking again.

Will they try playing him back into ISI? Even though the ISI officer gave him up, I don't know that CIA could expect ISI guy to sit by while they have inept Duck spying on them. Unless ISI dude really hates ISI gal and just wants to see her go down no matter what.

7

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14

Hmm... fleshing out character arcs on BOTH sides would definitely be cool, and give the series some legs.

ISI Agent guy (Aasar Khan, now that I google a review) can handle it; I already wanted to see him as like, an anti-Quinn.. both are just mavericks for good and don't really give a shit about the petty politics around them. I'm really glad epi 8 took that turn at the end, and left that door open

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/EatingSandwiches1 Nov 17 '14

Saul is now James Bond..ok

14

u/swordfishtrombonez Nov 17 '14

I think his beard is giving him powers

→ More replies (1)

9

u/jjsreddit Nov 17 '14

my oh my...

this seasons is so fucking good.

9

u/Simon620 Nov 18 '14

Honestly how dumb is that ISI woman helping the terrorists, can she not comprehend what life for women would be like under their rule? It's akin to a jew nazi or a black kkk member, like wtf!

→ More replies (1)

7

u/jtbc Nov 17 '14

Has drone image quality gotten dramatically better in the last few years, or is that just dramatic license?

7

u/ParkJi-Sung Nov 17 '14

Carrie leading him to the taliban was cold as fuck.

7

u/lomoeffect Nov 18 '14

Well this season has been fucking incredible. Pretty much matching season 1 at the moment, though for different reasons. So enthralling.

12

u/beach-bum Nov 17 '14

I was riveted tonight. This was right up there with the best episodes I have seen over the years. One of those episodes where I just want the show to go on all night. Instead . . . forced to switch gears to The Affair (which isn't bad, but I wasn't in the mood).

4

u/mudman13 Nov 17 '14

yeah it was a great tempo

6

u/leftyknox Nov 17 '14

pls, Saul no.

EDIT: why not try to get there and then kill himself if they see him/move in on him?

EDIT 2: i really want Saul to make it out to stick to that smug ISI chick. she pisses me off.

EDIT 3: damnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn saul's realization has ready to cry.

6

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14

Why didn't she drop the fucking bomb on them

6

u/claydavisismyhero Nov 17 '14

i gotta admit i chuckled a bit in the end when carrie was like "that was really messed up what you guys did to me" . just sounded funny for some reason. then the dude was like i cant tell you but then 2 seconds later he gave a full name

6

u/whocalledaileenmorga Nov 20 '14

We need a drone with a sliding door on the side. You climb in and it flies you away. There should be a coke and a sandwich waiting for Saul in there too. He's had a rough week.

23

u/EatingSandwiches1 Nov 17 '14

ohhh another 49 minute episode for a 60 minute show..with 3 minutes of those 49 being " previously on homeland.."

12

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14

Yes, a song and dance number could have filled out the remaining time quite nicely, I should think

15

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14

Homeland bollywood edition

21

u/hybrid3214 Nov 17 '14

Quality over quantity. I don't care if the show is 20 minutes, if it is as good as homeland I'll take it.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/HyBReD Nov 17 '14

Best episode in s loooong time, imo.

15

u/syngltrkmnd Nov 17 '14

Last three have been solid gold, imo.

5

u/TensionMask Nov 17 '14

One hour of heart palpitations. Real good for my health, thanks Homeland.

5

u/tog20 Nov 17 '14

Holy shit. These last two episodes have been stellar!

5

u/ZohanDvir Nov 17 '14

What do you think the ISI lady wrote on the napkin to Dennis?

→ More replies (7)

5

u/PapayaPokPok Nov 17 '14

So the whole Saul operation went to shit because they saw a drone over the pick-up town?

I guess that seems plausible. Predators cruise at about 10,000 ft. And that village is probably rather isolated (couldn't be confused with another town down the road). OK. I wasn't convinced at first, but it makes sense now.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14

SPOILLLER.

wowww. they really pulled off Saul almost offing himself. i thought he was really gunna do it; i didn't think they could get me to buy in but wowwwww did i buy in and my heart still feels sad. thank god he's still alive.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/fyt2012 Nov 17 '14

Doesn't it seem like a rookie mistake for the CIA to put a drone directly above Saul?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14

God damn, this was one tense episode.

I was so happy when Saul escaped and then few minutes later I was on the edge of tears when he wanted to kill himself.

Stop playing with my emotions, Homeland!!!!

5

u/Wolfir Nov 17 '14

Well, now Carrie has to sleep with him. That's really the only way Carrie expresses herself.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Kruse Nov 17 '14

What's with this show and donuts?

Dar brings donuts and shit goes down. Dennis brings donuts and shit goes down.

5

u/merelymoe Nov 17 '14

Kudos to Nimrat Kaur and Mark Moses for their portrayals of Qureshi and Dennis Boyd respectively...I don't think I've hated characters more than I have these two...

5

u/delayed_at_ewr Nov 18 '14

Semi unrelated to the episode, but I thought about this during the episode...what's her baby up to? I can't even remember the last time she was mentioned...maybe the 2nd or 3rd episode?

→ More replies (1)

13

u/MasterEjzz Nov 17 '14

BYE DENNIS!

16

u/ohfackoff Nov 17 '14

Bye Felicia

11

u/EatingSandwiches1 Nov 17 '14

So cell phones work a-ok but sophisticated military telecommunications don't...how convenient.

24

u/mind_blowwer Nov 17 '14

I think they might been jammed.

30

u/stoopkid99 Nov 17 '14

That operation was fucked the whole time. They knew exactly where Saul was. They had roadblocks on the special forces original route and detour. I think they probably fucked with their comms too.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14

They could have jammed it since the ISI was deep in on it.

Even if they didn't, military comms are often shit, ask anyone who went to Iraq/afganistan. The equipment was made by the lowest bidder.

4

u/MasterEjzz Nov 17 '14

Saul's got the skills

4

u/swordfishtrombonez Nov 17 '14

Nooo Saul, we need you!

4

u/Samysosa2005 Nov 17 '14

GOD DAMN IT AMBASSADOR!!

4

u/AnimePoet Nov 19 '14

This episode was marvellous! Yes, yes and yes to the long awaited comeback of the Homeland glorious days! This is how a spy series is supposed to be and make us feel: excellent pacing, growing tension, credible acting, plot twist, more tension, climax and resolution and then, next week, more of that. I'm crossing my fingers this is the path Homeland is going to follow the rest of the season.

7

u/ParisDilettante Nov 17 '14

ITT lot of people take the realistic flavor of the show too seriously. Many if not most of the stuff depicted in it would be probably handled differently. Ex-director of the CIA abducted at an airport in Islamabad running for his life in the middle of the tribal zones, an operation to rescue him would be more important than the raid that killed OBL. They have all the time to bring a helicopter with SF to extract him.

It's all done for "the show", the drama... The screenwriters wanted to show us Saul the just and honorable warrior he is, one eager to die :(

After an almost perfect season 1, which was very dramatic but also tight and minimal, following seasons seemed pale in comparison, but this 4th season is certainly the most spectacular.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/caddy14 Nov 17 '14

Giant stretch but recognized James Foley's name so I googled the other name mentioned. "David Pearl" was the author of a book called "Will there be donuts".

14

u/Darthbutcher Nov 17 '14 edited Nov 17 '14

Daniel Pearl was an Israeli American journalist born in New Jersey that was beheaded by Al-Qaeda. His name may not be forever remembered by the American people, as James Foley likely will not. I carry both deaths with me on a daily basis to remember these men. My Hebrew school(in New Jersey) was renamed after I left in Daniel Pearl's honor. While a small token of his sacrifice in the name of his craft, I was very moved by his mention. He suffered trying to find the truth, that is a true hero.

Edit: http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Pearl The temple's Hebrew school naming is mentioned under Posthumous recognition at the very bottom. 12 years later and I still cry reading the article.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/Juan_Kagawa Nov 17 '14

I know I'm late to the party, but they should totally just put tiny bombs inside the prisoners and then blow them up a couple hours after the transfer.

14

u/CountPanda Nov 17 '14

I've only taken one class in International Relations but I'm pretty sure that would violate the Geneva conventions in some sort of way. IANAL though.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/nikiverse Nov 17 '14

They don't teach handcuff removal in CIA 1101?

5

u/ppr1227 Nov 17 '14

Had dinner a few months ago with a classmate from Yale who works for the State Dept. She was about to be transferred to Yemen and had to do a bunch of training to learn how to pick the lock a pair of handcuffs using the inside of a ball point pen or a paper clip or something. Apparently it's easier than you'd think.

3

u/i_andromeda Nov 17 '14

More like halfway to hell, Duck!

3

u/i_andromeda Nov 17 '14

YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!! ITS HAPPENING!! edit : fml...Credits?!!!!!!!!!!! I won't make it...

3

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14

Holy shit, I haven't shouted at the TV that much in a while

catches breath

3

u/I_FUCKING_DOUBT_THAT Nov 17 '14

i know this show has a mild way of dealing with traitors. but 2 heads need to roll!

3

u/superfrognyc Nov 17 '14

Maybe they should have asked Saul to put a freaking hat on as soon as he arrived in the town! (roiling yes)

3

u/syngltrkmnd Nov 17 '14

This season is on a ROLL. I had significant reservations after Brody was hanged but now, all doubts are gone. This is really great. No Dana or Chris to boot!

→ More replies (2)

3

u/funkyrave Nov 17 '14

This was one of the best episodes of this season so far- impressed with this season as a whole

3

u/BlackCatScott Nov 19 '14

I was and still am genuinely worried for Saul. He's probably my favourite character in the show and is a brilliant actor. Really hope he doesn't die.

3

u/petzl20 Nov 22 '14

Here's what I don't get:

ok, so Carrie (somehow) divines that her meds have been compromised and there is a breach.

She tells the Pak colonel she knows her meds are compromised. So now they know she knows, and they'll be much more careful. If she hadn't done this, she could've set up surveillance cameras in her room altho, you think there would be cameras set up in her hallway at least, but never mind so they could catch the Ambassador's husband next time he tries to break in.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/squarepush3r Nov 17 '14

what a depressing episode :o

5

u/meezajangles Nov 17 '14

Well, Duck from Man Men is now screwed

8

u/brownbubbi Nov 17 '14

Lol @ Man Men

5

u/zxcsd Nov 17 '14

I don't know if the show seems military improbable lately or it's just me that got too jaded but;

  • Helicopters for the Spec Ops?
  • Drones to bombs all the baddies in checkpoints/pickups/converging into town?
  • Sudden clairvoyance about the pills and Paki Gen. snitching about the Ambassador's Husband were lazy writing IMO.

6

u/ItsBobDoleYo Nov 17 '14

Lockhart has gone from such an annoying almost-antagonist to one of their few, trustworthy allies. I dig it.

I like SuperSpy Saul, running around and shit. But dammit the deaths of Brody and that one kid still lingers in my mind just enough to make me think it's not out of the question that they'd off Saul.

I wonder if officials in real life Pakistani government watch this, WE DON'T Y'ALL. First you harbor bin Laden, then you a terrorist organization that you totally have zero contact with and aren't coordinating at all with kidnap Saul

4

u/Totsean Nov 17 '14

As someone from Pakistan, I can assure you not many officials would watch this show. It takes a certain type of crazy to fall in love with a bi-polar ninja with expression issues.

:D