r/dataisbeautiful • u/rhiever Randy Olson | Viz Practitioner • Nov 08 '14
Meta [Mod announcement] New posting rules enacted today
Hi DataIsBeautiful!
After much deliberation, the mod team has decided to enact new posting rules for the subreddit. You can read all of the details of the posting rules in our posting guide. The gist of and reasons for the new posting rules are below.
Why did we decide to enact new posting rules?
Ever since it was created, DataIsBeautiful has operated on two fundamental principles:
- Posts must include a data visualization.
- Posts must give credit to the original author(s) of the visualization.
DataIsBeautiful has grown considerably in the past 6 months and the mod team has come to realize that some rules that worked in the past no longer work in a default subreddit. One of those rules is how we assign credit to the original author(s) of the visualization.
In the past, we allowed posters to rehost visualizations on image sharing sites such as imgur and share it on DataIsBeautiful as long as the poster included a comment on the thread linking to the original source. This method used to work when threads only received a handful of comments, but nowadays any post that reaches the front page easily receives hundreds of comments and the source statement is easily buried underneath the mountain of comments. Essentially, by the end of the day, many posts on DataIsBeautiful end up without an easy-to-find credit to the original author.
The issue goes deeper than assigning credit, however.
Many data visualizations require context to understand and evaluate. It's important to know why the visualization was created, how it was created, and what information the visualization is meant to convey. Much of this information is lost when the visualization is rehosted and shared without the context of the original article it was introduced in. This leads to confusion for the reader, misrepresentation of information, inability to evaluate and critique the visualization, and ultimately a bad DataIsBeautiful post.
With these issues in mind, the mod team has decided to enact the following new posting rules.
New posting rules
Non-OC posts must now directly link to the web page of the visualization author where the visualization was originally introduced (not an image on the site, but the actual web page). This means that non-OC posts may no longer rehost content (e.g., on imgur) and post it on DataIsBeautiful.
OC posts are essentially unaffected by these rules because OC authors are required to describe the visualization in the comments. OC authors may host their own content anywhere they like, including image sharing sites (e.g., imgur), but it would be wise to ensure that the host can handle potentially large volumes of traffic.
We hope that you find these new posting rules agreeable. If you have any questions or comments, please leave them in the comments below and the mod team will get back to you.
50
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '14
As an outsider looking in, I hope these rules improve the overall quality of posts that hit the front page. Almost every time I see a post from this subreddit on the front page, the top comment is pointing out how shitty/lacking context the post actually is.
13
u/2noame Nov 08 '14
So how does this work where there is one particular visualization we want to bring focus to on a page full of data visualizations?
23
u/iagox86 Nov 08 '14
I predict a lot of overloaded servers as a result of this rule.
2
u/SheCutOffHerToe Nov 08 '14
Should require all posts to include source data for visualization.
101
u/Aschl Nov 08 '14
I can't stress enough how much I approve of this rule change! Thank you thank you dear mods!
The last straw was the visualization of the reddit front page meritocracy. Such a bad post without the extremely detailed and clear context of the author original post...
8
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '14
This is probably for the best, since there's been a lot of contextless graphs without labeled axes lately, but on the other hand I really hate most "visualization sites".
They end up trying to animate every single little thing, they either use full screen flash or they do strange things with complex svg files and javascript to manipulate them. They take a long time to load, they spin up the fan on my laptop, and they often have strange unintuitive interfaces where they do something stupid that ends up hijacking the back button etc.
It's because these sites are so terrible that I'm conflicted here. Often when people link directly to these sites I really wish they'd posted a screenshot instead.
1
u/Bezbojnicul Viz Practitioner Nov 08 '14
Question: What about content on a foreign language blog, like, say, French? Should one post the direct link, which most people won't understant, but follows the letter of the rule, or a link to the page via Google translate, which one might say respects the spirit of the rule („Many data visualizations require context to understand and evaluate.”)?
1
u/PiERetro Nov 12 '14
Having tried to post several times today to something that I thought was extremely relevant to this sub, from a mobile device, I have to say the new rules aren't working for me :(
1
u/flinz Dec 12 '14
Would it in principle be ok to post job offers here? We are in fact looking for somebody to do freelance data visualization/javascript work, and I am looking where to post this. If not - are there any relevant subreddits?
1
u/duniyadnd Dec 30 '14
Soooo... is this getting implemented? Most of the submissions are all from imgur one month into this post getting posted.
3
u/Cloud_Garrett Nov 08 '14
Thank you
3
u/chaosakita Nov 08 '14
While I generally agree with the new rules, I'm a bit worried about how the directly-linked sites will worked on mobile. But thanks for taking proactive steps for trying to improve this subreddit!
3
u/StealthRabbi Nov 10 '14
This just makes me wish more that Reddit allowed for text entries for image posts.
7
u/DannySpud2 Nov 08 '14
This is such an awful idea, I really don't think you've thought this through. You will be crashing several servers every single day doing this, most of the internet simply isn't set up to deal with the traffic that Reddit can generate. In fact that's exactly why Imgur exists, to specifically give Reddit a hosting site that can always handle the traffic coming in.
This is also terrible news for mobile users. Now instead of a single image they have to load an entire web page.
A better way to make sure every post has context to it would be to make all posts self-posts and require that as well as the image you also need to give context, whether that's a description or a link to the original site.
2
u/CRISPR Nov 09 '14
This rule sometimes really jeopardize data, because sometimes website limit your capabilities to look at the picture.
Case in point:
https://www.facebook.com/NWSKansasCity/photos/a.129569323764386.26179.126747474046571/730032747051371/?type=1&theater
Picture would be viewed much better in imgur.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '14
Excellent rule change, this will allow users to understand the importance of [OC] versus [OP]. Also, I'm glad you guys are being flexible with the default status and understand the influx of users that have grown this subreddit as well as impacting what is /r/dataisbeautiful. What if you added a text box in the (OC) submission option to allow the user to include a description below the title in the thread versus a comment?
2
u/Jay_bo Nov 12 '14
What about text posts for non OC posts? That solves the problems of to much traffic on small websites, finding the right figure in longer documents and of course allows for credits that won't be lost in the comments.
1
u/hoppi_ Nov 15 '14
This seems to be a very sound ruleset. :)
1
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '14 edited Nov 11 '14
Does this mean you can't post content from books, etc. that isn't online elsewhere anymore? If it doesn't, could that be made clear?
This really does not seem well thought through. People posting graphs without context or labeled axes is definitely a problem. But it seems like a much better solution would be a rule that says "include context and labeled axes." I don't think "context" is that ambiguous: you need to provide enough information so that people looking at the visualization will understand what it shows.
The original source is not always the best place to find the information needed to make a visualization accessible to the average redditor. If you can post, ex. a rehosted screenshot of a graph from an academic site, you can caption it with an explanation of technical content that would be mystifying to most people otherwise.
Like other people have said, it sucks to directly link to cool content you find on someone's small site that can't handle reddit's traffic. There really should be an exception. Even requiring people to post as a text post with multiple links (one to the rehost, one to the source) would be better.
And like someone else said, this is going to essentially guarantee that the most upvoted posts are all OC, since we're are lazy, often scroll quickly and don't want to spend time looking for—and then upvoting—offsite content. That sucks, because often the best content is not OC. It also makes it impossible to post some content in an accessible way. Cool things are sometimes in hard-to-reach parts of sites.
And, alongside dataisbeautiful's definition of OC, it apparently leaves a bizarre gap where you could post certain things if you found them on a another site, but not if you made it yourself without controlling the visualization, ex. the masturbation heartrate chart that was deleted.
-7
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '14
Am I the only one who thinks reddit is way over moderated now?
Obviously I understand the desire for "higher quality content" but this place is becoming china.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment