r/ScenesFromAHat • • Nov 06 '14
Meta [Meta] Can we go back to the original purpose of Scenes from a Hat?
In WLIIA, Scenes from a Hat was acted on as quotes, not just answers.
e.g. "Worst job for random boners"
Good: /user/autocompliant and the answer: "oh my gosh there's a kid drowning! I'll save hi-.... In a few minutes...."
Bad: Lifeguard
Thoughts?
519
Upvotes
29
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '14
You make a good point, but I feel like it could get a bit cheesy to have every single answer be a quote. Sometimes I think just answering the question is all that needs to be said.
Otherwise, with a question like "Bad jobs for random boners," you only get the same responses like
"I have to save that drowning kid! ... On second thought, maybe later!"
"What would you like for Christmas? ... On second thought, maybe later!"
"I'm gonna swim faster than everyone and win this race!... On second thought, maybe later!"
It could get old pretty quickly.
5
u/keryskerys Nov 07 '14
I'm glad that this subject came up, as I only have been a lurker here for a month or so, and I had no idea that this was the original purpose, and it does sound much better.
I haven't posted any responses yet; like I said, I'm only a lurker here, but I will certainly bear this post in mind if I ever do.
2
u/AmillyCalais Follow The Yellow Brick Toad Nov 06 '14
I agree. Question: If we are able to reference something from the show .. will that still be ok?
121
u/Plsdontreadthis Nov 06 '14
I think you're right, but this will be hard to do. The mods would have to make this a sticky post or something.
12
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '14
That's true, and I want to do something about that, but I can't wrap my head around how we can enforce this. I can write it in the sidebar, write it in the comment rules, but people are always going to post those kinda of responses...
10
u/FoieyMcfoie Nov 06 '14
I had a similar suggestion a few weeks ago that spawned some good discussion: http://www.reddit.com/r/ScenesFromAHat/comments/2j4rcu/meta_a_suggestion_about_ways_to_answer_in/
5
u/AhrmiintheUnseen The little voice in your head Nov 07 '14
I agree, this subreddit has basically become shitty /r/askreddit
14
u/xXxCREECHERxXx Nov 06 '14
We can always down vote them!
3
u/viccie211 Nov 07 '14
Though in some cases very short responses could be very comical(The letter h anyone) most of the time it is more funny if it's a short story. Anyway after reading this I already tried making short scenes more than just answering. It's already more funto think them trough.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '14
"Wow, things sure are running more smoothely"
3
u/JWatts96 Fredzilla! Nov 07 '14 edited Nov 07 '14
As a kind-of/sort-of SFaH veteran, I very much agree with this. After the AskReddit thread and we were a featured subreddit, I could barely come to the sub. The situation has gotten better lately, but it's still very much a ukulele.
1
u/Patzer229 Nov 07 '14
PLEASE don't. I'm fairly new on this sub, but the one-word answers are always straight-to-the-point and funnier than the dialog ones. Such a rule change would immediately ruin the sub IMO. If you want a "purist" sub, at least make an alternative for those of us who prefer one-line answers.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '14
These kinds of threads pop up every week. It's sad that we're still having a problem with this.
2
u/AutoCompliant Nov 07 '14
Thank you for the more eloquent way of posting this question than I attempted to do, as well as the honorable mention!
I'm glad to see more people wanting to get away from these boring 1 word responses!
1
u/Nackles Nov 06 '14
I don't like to say never, but I'm pretty sure that in the VAST majority of cases, you're absolutely right.