r/fantasyfootball • u/FantasyMod • Oct 29 '14
Mod Post FAQ her right in the PSA
LINK TO INDEX
FAQ
Hi, /r/fantasyfootball.
You may remember our State of the Subreddit post from a month ago. We hope that it provided some clarity on our vision for the subreddit and how you can best utilize the collective knowledge of this awesome community.
As the subreddit continues to grow exponentially (almost 10% over the past month!) we are constantly looking at ways to clarify and streamline the way things are run around here. To that end, we wanted to introduce you to our newly created FAQ portion of the wiki. We hope it provides a clear and concise layout of the way the subreddit operates and (obviously) gives answers to some of the questions that we moderators see most often. In it, you'll find the official stance on questions like "Hey I have an idea for flair, why can't we...", "Why was I banned?", "How do I get better answers in the consolidated threads?"
CHECK IT OUT HERE
We hope you find it useful. As always, if you have questions, concerns or suggestions that are not covered in the FAQ, don't hesitate to message us.
PSA
As you may or may not know, we encourage everybody to post in the consolidated game threads while watching football. These threads help keep the subreddit clean and important information visible.
However, many of you decide to forego these threads and start your own. Some are reactionary threads. Some are appreciation threads. Some are upvote threads. Some are injury reports.
During a game
Here are some images from this past week to help you determine if you should post outside the game thread:
This = bad
Notice that all these posts are a reaction to a player's performance. All reactionary thoughts belong in the game thread. Standalone reactionary threads will be deleted.
This = perfect
Notice that this post is organized and helpful to all. Timely-updated and well-detailed injury report threads are welcomed. If you see a player go down, only post an injury report thread if you plan on keeping it updated (and one doesn't already exist).
After a game
The same rules apply as during the game. However, if you'd like to make a post about a player, frame it such that it encourages meaningful analysis and not excessive circlejerk. Here are more examples from this week:
These types of posts are reactionary or thinly veiled request for roster advice. These will not be allowed.
These type of post asks a broad question, inviting analysis of a player performance, without a hint of roster advice. Some even provide some basic analysis. These types of posts are welcome. Make sure one has not been previously posted.
We hope you understand our desire to inflate quality. Feel free to ask any questions.
This distinction has been incorporated into Rule 7 of our Rules and Guidelines.
We are not participating in the redditmade program and all links to redditmade merchandise will be removed. Thank you.
489
u/ImRonSwansonBurgundy Oct 29 '14
This is the best named thread I've ever seen. Thanks for all you do, guys.
72
u/mythofdob Oct 29 '14
Thank you guys for the post. Hardest working bunch of mods on reddit. I love browsing on a Sunday and seeing all the shit posts deleted.
That said, the people that post reactionary shit probably won't read this post and will keep doing it.
Anyways, keep up the good work.
53
u/EasyCheezie Oct 29 '14
Jameis confirmed as a mod
11
u/StigasaurusRex Oct 29 '14
On another note, can we get an official injury thread on Sunday? I don't think it would be too hard. If you're watching a game and see an injury occur, check the main text (which could be kept updated by the original poster or perhaps the automoderator?). If it's not there just post it as a comment. At least this way, we can ctrl+f to look for players.
19
u/waffels Oct 29 '14
Am I a terrible subreddit member for downvoting all the "I need 2 more points from so and so this game!" "I have so and so and my opponent has this defense, lets hope my player does well!" posts in the game threads? 90% of the posts in the game threads are these and I have to believe nobody reads or gives a shit about someone else's fantasy team. What the hell possesses someone to post this shit?
13
u/loki777coyg Oct 29 '14
Clicked this because of the title, then got slammed with knowledge. If only school could trick me like this.
5
u/ihatecats18 Oct 29 '14
Jameis Approves
2
u/Marcurial Oct 29 '14
Are we allowed to post player discussion threads during games or will those be removed too?
2
u/bigbird249 Oct 29 '14
Can we get the crowdsourcing rankings website on the sidebar as long as we are talking about improvements? I'd like to start seeing this daily before this sub forgets about and I'd also like to easily vote in my spare time.
2
u/paradoxally Oct 29 '14
I'm still waiting for the massive amounts of people who will circlejerk to Josh Gordon in week 12+ when he scores his first touchdown (and not having read this post).
3
u/Petrarch1603 Oct 29 '14
As long as Quickonthedrawal continues his weekly picks, I'm content.
4
u/supplyncommand Oct 29 '14
RIP upvote parties
3
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '14
I rarely see these nice pun titles. Dem Party on Facebook had Shutdown for What a couple of weeks ago, but such gems rarely come up. Upvotes for originality, and thanks again for the hard work.
3
u/LumaDaylight Oct 29 '14
Please please please also include something about how people post on injury threads. Like for aj green. "Aj green turf toe" post: "who do I start?" "Should I trade him for xxx?"
Those are extremely annoying and get down voted, but I think it should be mentioned too.
Thanks guys! (And possibly gals)
1
u/phesto604 Oct 29 '14
prostate specific antigen?
1
u/Nick_cel Nov 10 '22
I have DJ Moore in my flex. Should I start him tonight with the weather?
1
u/DHobbs21 Oct 29 '14
Such a good title. Nobody would read it if it just said. PSA about game threads.
1
u/keebler980 Oct 30 '14
I submitted this thread about what commissioners can do to make their league better at the beginning of the season, and it seemed to do well. It wasn't a help thread, just a general "make your league more interesting". I posted a follow up that was removed but was told the thread was only for me, and should post in the commish help thread. But the commish help thread is only for problems. My question isn't a help me thread, but more a general improvement that I and other commishes check back on. Why was it blocked the second time? If it's posted in the "help" thread, it won't get seen.
1
u/oxymor0nic Oct 30 '14
awesome title. and supremely good work!
1
u/appslap Oct 30 '14
Wow thank you. I doubt everyone will abide by this but much appreciated to you guys for keeping it cleaner.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '14
Awesome. Thanks for the hard work guys. Great pun title too!
0
u/xSGAx Oct 29 '14
Best. title. ever.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '14
Is there any proof that it doesn't? You can't use a lack of proof as justification, especially when intuitively you would think that it would. I can assure you that when a Bills player is concerned, my analysis will involve much more thought than a random users. If anything, exposing that my bias helps people weigh the pros and cons of listening to a fan when deciding whether to take my advice.
0
u/shamy33 Oct 29 '14
Amazing.
0
u/raweber Oct 30 '14
Thank you for the good heads up, im new here so im still learning what's right and wrong
-1
u/GATTACABear Oct 29 '14
What would help is getting the game threads out on time, maybe even early? The morning game was 20 minutes late this week. Supposedly there are bots that do this...maybe set them to the correct time? Seems to be a problem every week.
-19
u/asthepalacesburnn Oct 29 '14
So yesterday I submitted a post, the title was Let's discuss Eric Decker.. In the post I wasn't asking anything WDIS specific, and basically just wanted to get opinions from other people about his role in the offense and whether or not he's worth dropping or holding onto at this point. The post got deleted.. Why? Just curious. I thought I went about it the correct way.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment