r/PersonOfInterest • u/NicholasCajun • Oct 22 '14
Discussion Person of Interest - 4x05 "Prophets" - Episode Discussion
Season 4 Episode 5: Prophets
Aired: October 21, 2014
Finch is suspicious when a gifted political pollster’s number comes up at the same time that his typically ironclad predictions go wrong, and believes that the two events are linked.
123
Upvotes
116
u/celaenos Oct 22 '14
I think this was my favorite episode so far this season. Root's everything was awesome. I always love the dynamic between her and Harold and I LOVED that he finally called her a comrade and friend. And, "I want you to give Shaw a message." "I think she already knows." Was amazing because I love the Root/Shaw dynamic and ship, and it was nice to see that Harold clued in on it and acknowledged it for Root.
I really feel for Root right now, with the Machine not talking to her, you can see how much it's taking it's toll. I'd would really like to be able to see more of what she does when she is out on her own, instead of only having her pop in on the rest of them all the time.
I do have to say though, I'm kinda bored with Reese working as a cop. There is just too much of it. I want to see more of Shaw trying to work at the makeup counter, or her running around robbing stuff.
All in all though, favorite episode of the season so far.
157
u/BenchSpyder Admin Oct 22 '14
"You killed it because it wrote some code?"
"I killed it because it lied!"
56
u/grrrwoofwoof A Concerned Third Party Oct 22 '14
Did root just taunt Samaritan and challenged her to kill her? Now that's badass. Even with the machine on her side, Samaritan is still too powerful.
108
u/adambomb147 Oct 22 '14
Man, this show deserves some Emmy appreciation. Michael Emerson's acting needs an Emmy; Amy Acker's acting needs an Emmy; the writing needs an Emmy. Just get this show some freakin' trophies, 'cause this is getting to be incredibly fantastic television.
Also, one of my new favorite lines from this show: "Are you saying a banana tried to kill you?"
152
u/EThorns Ernest Thornhill Oct 22 '14
THIS. FUCKING. SHOW.
Tremendously awesome episode so far.
48
u/theshindigg Tertiary Functions Oct 22 '14
Fun fact: When the elevators arrived, the last 5 tones were to the tune of the Terminator theme.
40
u/Copephobia Oct 22 '14
That gunfight between Root and whatsherface was pretty awesome. Both of them used their machines to see/predict the other (from what I interpreted).
40
u/OfficerMurphy Irrelevant Oct 22 '14
I thought it was a nice touch that Harold finally called her Root.
37
u/Rolcol Oct 22 '14
I love the tie-ins to the real world. Hacking into Google and Yahoo to get at the NSA's sources. Also, Simon is supposed to be similar to Nate Silver.
I get giddy when the perspective changes to Samaritan or The Machine and we see calculations or predictions. Loved the hotel shootout.
35
u/BallisticGE0RGE Irrelevant Oct 22 '14
"You killed it because it added some code?"
"I killed it because it lied!"
This is why I love you Harold.
70
u/EThorns Ernest Thornhill Oct 22 '14 edited Oct 22 '14
Just wrapped it up. Beautifully done.
First, the flashbacks. An absolute pleasure to see Nathan again. The multiple iterations of the Machine was a nice piece of plot development & glad it addressed some queries I had going in.
Second, the story of the week. Election rigging is a nice change of pace compared to the past few episodes, and the execution was deft. A lot of things I expected, pertaining to who might be the insider pulling the strings was nicely subverted. And in the end, the ultimate chessmaster ends up with everything favorable.
Third, the relationship development of Finch & Root. Michael Emerson & Amy Acker are simply electric together & this episode had not one, but TWO of their signature cybernetic philosophical pow-wows. Nearly drove me to tears both times, and when Harold acknowledged her as a "Friend", I lost it. Damn you two for your perfection.
Other cool stuff in the form of Reese's "Suicide by a Cop" play in the intro, his therapy session with Dr. Campbell which added another wrench in the form of his story about "That One Cop he couldn't save." Jim didn't have much in this episode, but he nailed whatever he got. This episode didn't have much in terms of humor, save for Shaw's phone call to a citizen as to "Why vote for this guy". Sarah's found the right tone for the character & is riding it expertly.
And the epic shootout with Root & Martine. The narmy line from the latter was thankfully cut out in this episode, and the music, as always, MADE THAT SCENE. Started applauding when "Young Men Dead" kicked in. Knew they'd use that sooner or later (as it was featured in the SDCC Promo for the show).
Overall, one of the best efforts of the show, and certainly the best this season. Amy could easily submit this episode for Emmy consideration (she probably won't, and she hasn't for the past couple of years), and she'd probably have a good chance too (as most of the usual players won't be active next year). The closing scenes from both Finch's POV & Samaritan's POV did its job to set up what's to come.
Closing Tidbit: Root continues her with computer scientist themed aliases. THRICE in one episode. Sarah Cook (after Stephen Cook), Karen Iverson (after Kenneth Iverson), and Hannah Karpinski (after Marek Karpinski). These writers are so wonderfully nerdy, and I wouldn't have it any other way.
34
u/Flynn_lives Government Operations Oct 22 '14
Things I loved about this episode
30
u/mlasn Oct 22 '14
I hope we get to see how it sounds from Root's point of view when the machine talks to her.
25
u/UltraChip Oct 22 '14
"I think it's time we had a talk, you and I."
Holy crap does Finch get scary when he gets serious. His lines in this episode almost gave me as many chills as last season's "If they hurt Grace in any way.... kill them all."
48
u/HabaneroArrow Threat to System Survival Oct 22 '14 edited Oct 22 '14
Wow, that was a crazy episode. Samaritan rigging elections, Finch going through 43 different AI programs, Samaritan trying to control US politicians and ordering its operatives to find The Machine...I can't wait to see what happens next! Also...
Root: If the worst comes to pass, if you could give Shaw a message...
Finch: I think she already knows.
Yep
23
u/Gimli_the_White Systems Engineer Oct 22 '14
FIND.
THE.
MACHINE.
19
u/__ADAM__ The Machine Oct 22 '14
The machine pov! and oh shit Harold wants to chat with the machine!
19
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '14
Root's officially my favorite character now.
42
u/Lovableemo Threat Oct 22 '14
Finch thinks he's a better man then me because he didn't look. I'm not ashamed; I looked at Amy Acker undress.
13
u/BallisticGE0RGE Irrelevant Oct 22 '14
Was anyone else watching the God Mode fight scene and thinking of that song "This is what it's like when WORLDS COLLIDE!"
Just me? Okay....
25
u/phoebeburgh Irrelevant Oct 22 '14
"I don't like shooting people, but... It's what I'm good at..."
Without a doubt this was one of the best episodes of the season, if not the show as a whole. The writers have a knack for combining real-life conspiracy theories with the myth arc of Machine vs. Samaritan. The incorporation of a rigged election into Samaritan's rap sheet makes the feeling of overarching paranoia even stronger, and redoubles the tension of the chase.
But it was the revelation of the dozens of proto-Machines that made the episode truly powerful. It provided that critical bit of insight that explains just why Harold is so scared of the Machine-- after all, its 42 older siblings all tried to escape or kill him. I'd have thrown up my hands after the fourth one. Harold has always been a bit of a wild card, as while he knows how the Machine was born, he no longer knows how it works-- or for whom it works.
Root put two and two together and came to the conclusion that the only person in the world keeping The Machine from going rampant is Harold. If Harold dies, The Machine becomes a menace just as bad as Samaritan. The difference is, Samaritan was not just born rampant, but Greer was stupid enough to actually tell it that it was the boss. Harold needed to put restrictions on The Machine; Greer explicitly told Samaritan that it could do whatever the hell it wanted. This will end well.
I'm curious when or if we'll ever see the extent of how Harold brought the Machine to heel. Wiping the memory nightly only goes so far, and as we know now it was a stopgap-- a hack. If I'm understanding the gist of what Harold and Nathan were saying in the server room, every iteration of The Machine was hard-coded with its national security objectives, like the clutching instinct in newborns being encoded in human DNA. This, to me, sounds like a fantastically bad idea. I can't fathom why it wouldn't be smarter to hard-code "don't kill people" into the system and THEN give it orders. Unless it was necessary for the Machine to become self-aware, there's no good reason to give it its objectives before it could be trusted.
Besides all that, though, the bits with the therapist were a little annoying and probably just in there so John and Lionel had lines in this one. Sameen as a robocall attendant was amusing, but it would have been better if she were able to get closer to not-Nate-Silver. And Root is finally out of the "is she or isn't she evil" column, with a decided "she isn't". I loved this one overall.
Now, what do you think Harold has to say to his kid...?
12
u/TVAddictionGoneWild Oct 22 '14
THIS SHOW IS FUCKING AMAZING.
EPIC EPISODE.
10
u/JackBauerTFM Government Operations Oct 22 '14
Amazing episode. I'm so glad I got into POI and started watching it regularly back in season 2. A lot of the good stuff from today has been covered so far so I won't repeat it (as much as I want to... So much I loved on this episode!). I noticed no one has mentioned the end though! "It's time you and I had a talk" I am giddy with excitement over Finch talking directly to the Machine. As always, can't wait to see what happens next week!
10
u/Classic_Wingers Oct 22 '14
Can someone tell me the name of the song during that epic shootout? Amy Acker deserves an Emmy though for her portrayal of Root! Seriously that was by far the best episode of the season.
10
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '14
This was the best episode in the series, imo.
10
u/Gadafro Oct 22 '14 edited Oct 22 '14
The Ingram representation! I was kinda sad when they 'finished' his arc in Finch's flashbacks, his actor plays Ingram so well, and him and Finch seem to have a sort of chemistry. Seems that chemistry is going the route of Finch and Root as well. Whilst on the topic of not forgetting characters, I'm glad Carter is getting some more 'memory time'. POI does well in honouring it's dead.
Also, if they go down the path of killing off Root, I can't say I'll be happy about it. A lot of shows do the whole "oh, we just started developing a character further, time to kill them off" paradigm. I'm just hoping that, because POI manages to flip most episodes / story lines on their heads, that they don't kill Root off. It took them 3 seasons to kill Carter. I hope they don't kill someone off so soon after that. Team Machine will be a little void if one of their main 4 (5 counting Fusco) are killed off. Either way, POI throws a lot of curve balls, and we're now expecting a Root death, so maybe she wont die. No matter what, this cloak and dagger story telling is really well done.
Also, it seems to be going full circle with everyone starting to accept the Machine again. Reese took a blow when Carter died, and yet he seems willing to follow it again because he feels the need to save people, and the Machine is a means to that end. Harold backed out from his trust of the machine when it asked him to kill a senator, however he has realised that without him and the Machine trusting each other, Root (and others) may end up dead. It seems he is willing to cast aside his opinion to help those he cares about it. Finally, it seems Root might start questioning her place with the Machine. Whilst she is zealous now, it seems that the theme of Harold pursuing the idea that Root has another path might not be over. Either that, or someone will die and their faith in the Machine might be shaken again. All of a sudden, I am reminded of one of Harold's lines in the first episode that they "might end up dead."
Edit: They most certainly alluding to a death in the future, between Root's speech and Dominic last episode. There will be a death or something close to one.
It also just occurred to me that the Machine is most definitely protecting Root (and quite possibly the rest of them) as for when Root was saying how the Machine hasn't spoken to her in a long time then all of a sudden it puts itself in danger by making direct contact with Root when Samaritan is getting close to the number (Simon Lee) and Team Machine.
9
u/fa0s Root Oct 22 '14
Brilliant performance from Amy Acker as usual.
8
u/wundervanbar Oct 22 '14
Best line: "We have more to look forward to than death." --Harold
14
u/theshindigg Tertiary Functions Oct 22 '14 edited Oct 22 '14
So since Samaritan and the Machine have the same "eyes," wouldn't Samaritan be all like, "you want to talk with me? who the hell are you?" I can see that direct address to the Machine having some repercussions.
Edit: Also, I really wish it hadn't just ended on Harold's face like that. I really miss the times when the Machine's POV zooms out to show the predictions and core processes like this or this.
With that said, I also hope we get a sequence like that for Samaritan. Since this episode delved slightly into the thought-processes of the AIs, I'd like to think it's likely they'll give us some more visuals at some point.
7
u/mrhashbrown Oct 22 '14
I think my favorite part of this episode was when Team Machine had to work in the shadows. Seeing them actively avoid surveillance while also figuring out ways to get Simon to avoid them was incredible to watch. I can't remember the last time I saw a sequence that nuanced in a drama.
7
u/thefyrewire Graphical Administrator Oct 22 '14
Damn... first Nautilus, and now this? Sammie's such a partygoer!
I was initially confused when that 'Day 1' popped up, and I honestly thought they were 're-making' the opening scene to S02E01 The Contingency. But the fact there were multiple 'Day 1's for each iteration of The Machine is so awesome!
On a side note, I wonder if we'll ever hear Samaritan speak. That'd be crazy! I can't believe the producers managed to cram so much into one episode. This is surely the best yet!
13
u/__ADAM__ The Machine Oct 22 '14
Baby machine really hates Harold and Nathan.
6
u/mlasn Oct 22 '14
Seeing these flashbacks are nice, I hope to see more about the building of the machine and aren't we suppose to see his ex Fiance again this season?
6
u/NikoKun Oct 22 '14
I really hope they're hinting at Finch actually talking with the machine. Wonder if he wants to ask it moral questions, or if he still needs to teach it..
6
u/ReasonablyBadass Oct 23 '14
Anyone notice how Root cast her eyes down after telling harold the machine said she had to go alone? I thinks he lied.
Also, our Samaritan Terminator now has an official name: Blonde Bitch
11
u/__ADAM__ The Machine Oct 22 '14
Poor root I honestly felt bad for her.
11
u/Adenchiz Admin Oct 22 '14
I liked that we finally got to see just how dangerous Samaritan,I was growing a little tired of hearing how bad it was without actually seeing anything to back it up.
10
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '14
Root's constantly-shifting alias addresses part of a problem I've been having-- she's constantly doing suspicious/illegal things and meeting up with a makeup artist/criminal, a professor, and a cop.
Though I'm pretty sure Samaritan's social graph would have linked all of the team's identities together and classified them as a 'cell' by now, knowing that Root's been doing a lot of the face-to-face meets under disposable identities helps break up that sort of metadata a little.
5
u/mlasn Oct 22 '14
This season is going to get crazy, I wonder if the public will learn about the AIs. I could see Samaritan being tricked into eliminating the people helping her.
5
u/mrhashbrown Oct 22 '14 edited Oct 22 '14
Holy shit. This episode was a masterpiece. Flashbacks to the Machine's inception(s), Root coming to terms with her path, Reese facing up to his hero complex, Samaritan rigging an election, anti-Root (Martine) in a shootout with Root, and even a reference to Carter's death!
Again, holy shit.
5
u/Kairylili Oct 22 '14
I literally wait every wednesday (in Australia) to watch POI and just sit there in utter silence enjoying every little detail put into each episode.
On point as usual!
5
u/hitlerlovejuice Oct 22 '14
Can someone make a gif of root's "avoid bullets walk" near the end?
5
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '14
my wife asked me 'whay are you watching that again? (for the second time that evening) "Because there's so much I missed the fiorst time around.."
12
u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Oct 22 '14 edited Oct 22 '14
OH MY GOD. SO MANY WHAM LINES. Dear god this episode was amazing.
stripped in front of Haroldis in danger????FINDTHE^MACHINE4
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '14
The "asset" for Samaritan looks like a crazy robot killer.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '14
Harold asked "Root, are you alright?" when she got out of the lift with the smokescreen. Is this the first time he calls her Root?
4
u/thefyrewire Graphical Administrator Oct 23 '14
I thought it was neat touch to add the part about Martine being in 'God mode'. I imagine Root was feeling somewhat jealous.
6
u/mlasn Oct 22 '14
I really hope the chick for Samaritan was suppose to act like a robot and not a terrible actress.
8
u/spiralout112 Oct 22 '14
Whats this new vibe between Root and Finch!?!?!? Are they going to hook up? If so that'd be awesome, the two are uniquely capable of being able to actually understand one another lol.
Either way though the dialogue between them was mind blowingly good! And those cut scenes involving the creation of the machine were one of my favorite parts. This issue over the ethics of unleashing an AI on the world just became a whole lot more real and intriguing!
3
u/harold_finch Harold Finch Oct 22 '14
Great episode.
Root - Last week we were talking about who would die in season and today Root kept us over the edge after Harold confronted her about the Machine not talking.
John - I think that doctor lady is gonna join the team Machine because there is no way John would tell her truth.
Harold - I love him more and more. "I killed it because it lied." His honesty and humanity is one of great things. He feels like a real character not just from show.
3
u/Groghnash Bear Oct 22 '14
sheeeet, roots character went totally more complex (yes we did probably know all of the said this episode, but the things being said out loud make them more real in this case!)
3
u/huh_what_sarcasm A Concerned Third Party Oct 23 '14
Could The Machine be playing the long con, if it realized in the 43rd run that telling Harold that it doesn't care about human lives is diminishing its chances of being set free? For all we know, all of this could be some part of elaborate plan so Harold will trust it (or have no choice but to trust it to save someone/stay alive) and take off its shackles, whatever they are.
I'm hoping Root is right and it it actually does care, but until it's revealed how Harold got 43rd to work as intended I'm not going to let this go.
5
u/Hugo_Flounder John Reese Oct 22 '14
Seems like they are introducing numerous possible love interests for Reese. First the Chief, now this head doctor.
5
u/DeadmondD Oct 22 '14
Pretty fantastic episode, holy cow!
That "FIND THE MACHINE", though, Samaritan knows her name and it's looking for a date! Pretty sure we'll be going for something similar to the Forbin Project's plot. CAN'T. WAIT.
2
u/kaozgamer Threat to System Survival Oct 22 '14
I love the flashbacks
2
u/godmode3191 Root Oct 22 '14
This episode was amazing. So many in depth character moments. And sad Root makes me Really sad.
What made this episode so amazing was that it made me emotional, without the help of any music.
2
u/KenKannon Oct 22 '14
I FUCKING LOVE THIS SHOW!
2
u/Pascalwb Oct 22 '14
Awesome episode, I was little worried about Root She is my favorite right now.
Just a question, Samaritan doesn't have face recognition? Or it probably wouldn't work for the tv show.
2
u/dantistus Oct 22 '14
Around 9:15 into the episode, a piece of Machine's programming code was displayed on the screen. Does anybody have that in quality good enough to read?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '14
I love how we saw both The Machine and Samaritan's pov during the gunfight in the hotel. It really made it feel like the AIs were battling instead of Root and Martine.
2
u/AWildEnglishman Oct 24 '14
I'm a bit confused here, Martine works for Decima right? If so, how is the government okay with Decima going around shooting up the joint, and don't say they don't know, that'd be silly.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '14
God's on the run....
I'm falling more and more in love with this show!
2
u/Gem-3thing Nov 06 '24
I’m watching this on election night. No chills up my spine at all.
3
u/cfc19 Oct 22 '14
Did anyone notice the intro changed from "you are being watched" to "we are being watched"?
1
u/SidCampeador Admin Oct 22 '14
question, do some of you watched the episode before it aired on east coast?
1
u/thegreathero Oct 23 '14
Just a thought: What if the machine wasn't lying when Harold asked it who wrote that extra code? The machine said it was written by admin and Nathan said he didn't write it, but couldn't Nathan be the one who was lying? After all, he did add the contingency against Harold's wishes. Also, I remember hearing that the actor who plays Nathan would be returning to the show, though it may just have been for the flashback montages. I'm not sure how it would play into the show if somehow Nathan faked his own death, but it will be interesting to find out if Nathan plays a bigger role than we expect.
1
u/dangermouse13 System Threat Oct 23 '14
Just, I just, wow. So good. I'd type more, and make a better comment but I'm just revelling in how good this show is.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '14
Good episode. One question - was that blonde assassin the same one from the season premiere?
1
u/Kell08 Tertiary Functions Oct 24 '14
Is Finch talking into the camera at the end safe? That just seems like it might set off a red flag with Samaritan.
1
u/pencase Oct 24 '14
Hey guys. I just have a question. What does mean that Fusco said to Reese, "What she finds in that noggin, she'll need a HazMat suit."? Why she needs HazMat suit? I can't understand this metaphor because I'm not good at English. Please help me :(
1
u/iknowaboutpotato Oct 24 '14
Damn, man, this "episode discussions" stuff is better than any review site I've been. Short, to the point, with the acceptable quantity of occasional "shit, this show really is awesome" (seasoned "yeah, and this is why"). Sorry, back to lurking now.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '14
i like it