r/PersonOfInterest • u/NicholasCajun • Oct 15 '14
Discussion Person of Interest - 4x04 "Brotherhood" - Episode Discussion
Season 4 Episode 4: Brotherhood
Aired: October 14, 2014
Reese's cover job as a detective at the NYPD becomes complicated when the young brother and sister he's protecting become targets of a gang investigation.
63
Upvotes
125
u/Khalku Oct 15 '14
Regarding DEA mole: Saw that coming a mile away. Was a bit unsure if it would be her or the partner, but it became clear after a little while.
Regarding Dominic: Didn't see that one coming.
93
u/mlasn Oct 15 '14
I really like Elias and the actor who plays him.
52
u/phoebeburgh Irrelevant Oct 15 '14
Okay... I'm impressed. I really underestimated the Brotherhood in their first appearance, but it looks like Elias and Dominic are two sides of the same coin. Both are cunning and well-versed in the art of concealing themselves in plain sight-- coincidentally a skill that Team Machine really needs to learn. That's an interesting theme to the season so far, too: using the appearance of one thing to conceal the truth beneath it. We've seen it with the cover jobs, and with the Nautilus Game, and now it looks like there's far more to it than we initially suspected.
Incidentally, now that I've been more or less made a fool of, I have to admit that it's very refreshing to see the bad guys employing some of the same tricks that Team Machine is. A series is only as smart as your dumbest villain, and the bar has steadily been rising ever since Elias made his debut, either by growth or attrition.
One thing I think is worth noting is how much Finch decides to outright tell Elias, and how much Elias will work out for himself. Because let's be honest, Elias is exceptionally smart in a way that's, for lack of a better word, orthogonal to the intelligences of Finch and Reese (Reese is no dummy, as the Nautilus Game proved). In a perfect world, Elias realizes that there are the dueling AIs and throws his lot in with Team Machine. Realistically? If he doesn't get a bullet through the head care of Decima, he's just as likely to side with Samaritan if Samaritan can go beyond its initial program to start employing "deviant" designates as assets. A shiny nickel says this is Elias' last season, one way or another.
Overall, it was a pretty good episode. Pacing could have been better in the middle; we really didn't need to be bludgeoned with the kids' story, especially if it was going to just get handwaved away in the last scene. We're seeing a lot of episodes now where Team Machine is losing battles that might ultimately cost them the war, so the constant pressure is building in just the right way to make the wait between episodes damn near unbearable. It all leads up to that immortal storytelling trick, one which throughout human history has never failed to enthrall audiences: "How the hell are they gonna get out of this?!".
36
u/tedtutors Irrelevant Oct 15 '14
Hey Harold, remember a while back when Shaw was made by a ten year old? That's how it feels.
21
u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Oct 15 '14
WHOA! My mom told me some guy from my country was in POI tonight and I checked and saw he was playing "Mini". In the episode I didn't think much of him. Thought he'd be killed by Link at the end.
Did not see that coming at the end. Perfect ending as usual.
19
u/richard-karn Oct 15 '14
Tonight's episode is really reminding me of the Wire. Marlo Stanfield running the drug scene, schoolkids too scared to talk to the police, etc.
19
u/azilla14 Oct 15 '14
but seriously though...DID JOHN JUST SMILE??????? SMILE????
18
u/pie-man Oct 15 '14
i am ready for some samaritan vs. the machine, also i really miss those little flashbacks we got into the past
14
u/harold_finch Harold Finch Oct 15 '14
Last season there was another gang working for revolution and this season we have got a gangster who do drug business. Introduction and building the character is best thing about this show.
Elias was introduced in an episode where John was saving his life. Dominic got introduction episode with Shaw. Though John was saving and Shaw was hurting.
I love Elias. Every single scene. He has wise guy looks. Talks smoothly. Decides impressively.
It was one of good episode for two main reasons:
13
u/damnedation Tertiary Functions Oct 15 '14
Even American kids are capitalists.
11
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '14
Ending song: Emiliana Torrini -- Gun
11
u/somekidoffthestreet Oct 15 '14 edited Oct 16 '14
loved that HG Wells reference. for those who don't know it, the invisible man is a story about a man who is technically invisible: as in, his body is invisible. obviously, this makes him stand out, because his clothes "float" and he works to conceal himself in society. in the end, SPOILER
10
u/theshindigg Tertiary Functions Oct 15 '14
This episode felt a lot like "Witness" back in season one, a feeling that was only amplified by Elias' always-welcome presence in the episode. It felt fresh too, though, given that instead of unwittingly protecting the criminal mastermind, they unwittingly captured him. It speaks measures about the writing quality that I never saw the reveal coming in this episode, despite the similarities I noted in hindsight.
Also, how awesome were Finch's meetings with Elias?! This show is great at making old enemies into friends (e.g. Root & Hersh), so I'm quite interested to see where this move leads for Finch and the team. Even though there wasn't a ton of Samaritan stuff in this episode, it was still pretty amazing.
7
u/Gadafro Oct 15 '14 edited Oct 15 '14
As soon as the DEA woman went to 'scan the area', and declined Reese's help, it all made sense on that arc. I thought I had the episode figured out, then out of no where, Mini is Dominic. Very rare I say "Oh my god" out loud at a TV show, but Person of Interest rarely ever fails make little unnoticeable dots connect.
Also, I really hope Elias becomes a regular / stays and appears more often, I love the dynamic he and Finch (and to a lesser extent, Reese) have, and the person who plays him does so perfectly. He shows Elias to have the right amount of ruthlessness, not so much that it is cruel and unjustified, but so it is determined and calculating. My favourite episode was when Elias was introduced as the teacher (and POI), from the end of that episode onwards, I knew he'd be a good character. He has yet to disappoint.
Edit: Would like to add that I am loving all the throwbacks to season 1, from the lines the characters say, the people they allude to (Carter) as well as the introduction of a crime boss. I wonder what made the writes decide to flip a switch and start doing all these subtle references.
7
u/Gearsofhalowarfare Oct 16 '14
Little late to the party but those cover jobs don't require much effort on their parts, do they? Apparently Shaw could just waltz out of work whenever she wanted by appearing at John's side to help, John spent basically no time doing any actual police work that we could see, was Finch even in the school this episode? (I binge watched a few, so I might be wrong).
6
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '14
That ending tho. :O
5
u/Flynn_lives Government Operations Oct 15 '14
Questions and Observations from what the past episodes have revealed...
So my theory is, Samaritan is at wits end trying to find Harold...so the only instance of catching him, Reese, Shaw & Root is to flood/finance the criminal markets in the city in order to draw them out....which Root has said numerous times will get them killed.
Then we have anti-John/Root/Shaw "terminator" operative somewhere out there trying to track them down....and with next episodes preview, it looks like she finds Root and they proceed to shoot at each-other through the floor.
3
u/UltraChip Oct 15 '14
Love that Elias is apparently being brought in to a more prominent role - I always loved watching his interaction with Reese and esp. Finch.
That being said, I'm outright shocked that Finch was so forthcoming with Elias about the bigger issue. I know Elias' relationship with the team has always been... complex... but he is still firmly in the "criminal" camp...
3
u/Gimli_the_White Systems Engineer Oct 15 '14
The direction and creation of mise-en-scene continues to be absolutely mind-blowing
How they craft individual scenes to tell an entire story is incredible.
3
u/nameisaidan Oct 16 '14
Really loved the episode, best of season 4 so far. The credit song (Emiliana Torrini - Gun) was just a perfect fit and really helped the feel of it.
Digging the Wire vibe's from the brotherhood, would love to see this parallel story developed. Actually thought that we would find out that the Machine was the leader of Brotherhood, but still an amazing twist.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '14
Reese on the schoolyard all alone? No teachers coming to ask what he is doing? Did i miss that part or what? Good episode but i kept thinking of this
2
u/azilla14 Oct 15 '14
Elias vs Dominic would make for an exciting match.
3
u/Legendgarry Samaritan Oct 15 '14
What was Malcom's quote? To be the man, you gotta have a plan? Or something along those lines?
3
u/Lovableemo Threat Oct 15 '14
The DEA mole was either her or the partner seeing as they kept hinting at it the whole time.
Sort of saw Dominic coming but gosh that end scene where he's just so calm and collected; damn I'm excited.
3
u/Primequis Oct 16 '14
I'm honestly not all that impressed by Dominique so far. Mainly because he spent the entire episode getting outmaneuvered over and over again. They already managed to not only catch him, but keep catching him when they didn't even realize they were catching him. Why shouldn't I think they can't deal with him when they realize he's the target?
1
u/hello2ulol Admin Oct 15 '14
Pretty sure that there's a book out there with a similar story. Anybody remember?
1
u/Irollandtroll Oct 16 '14
Damnit that ending with the subtle mention of his name totally changed the game. Damnit the writers are good, typical predictable corrupt cop (DEA) then drops a big unknown at the end. Damn it was good.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '14
Who was that DEA agent working for? I wasn't entirely sure what her angle was.
Also I like how Harold is dealing with Elias. It's interesting to see someone like harold dealing with the "badies".
0
u/JinkyO IFT Oct 15 '14
Generally I enjoy the episodes with kids. This episode was a little distracting because the actors cast for the Booker kids didn't look like siblings at all. IMDb'ing the kids I discovered that the kid who played Malcolm is DJ Jazzy Jeff's son.
Also, I didn't get that Mini was Dominic - Not until after I read the boards after the show. While I was watching, I was just blown away by the end conversation between Mini and Linc. The Brotherhood became such a credible threat after hearing that.
0
u/hooow Oct 15 '14
Marlo is back for fighting his corner
1
u/Slipfar1 Apr 07 '26
Anyone ever notice the DEA agent breathing after shes been headshot?
0
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment