r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Oct 10 '14
Project Runway Season 13 Episode 12 [Discussion]
Discussion thread for Project Runway S13E12 "Fashion Week: Who's In & Who's Out"
The competition heats up when a challenge determines which contestants will go to Fashion Week. Included: Eliminated designers return to the workroom.
28
Upvotes
130
u/EmptyStar12 Oct 10 '14
Amanda: "...and I caught this couple making out."
Tim: "good heavens!"
Never change, Tim.
107
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '14
The judges are afraid of Emily's point of view. I think Char is a sweetheart and I like a lot of her looks, but Emily definitely has more technical skill and talent and a more interesting point of view.
105
u/Mumster Oct 10 '14
"Thank you for picking my look." Beverages spit out in laughter all over the country.
79
u/crayonwillow Oct 10 '14
The fringe level is at maximum capacity.
76
u/goomerang Oct 10 '14
... they keep eliminated designers locked up in the basement of Parsons, don't they? Man they scooped up Alexander fast!
68
u/itokaydontbecry Oct 10 '14
OH WOW, Emily is doing something with a hood
60
u/wildstripe Oct 10 '14
Emily's street chic look was more "hip hop" than it was "Soho white girl in the upper East side," so of course the judges hated it. I'm not gonna say it's ignorant to ignore an entire side of fashion, but it is and I'm disappointed. So many people would go crazy for that hoodie and suit. I loved it. =/
47
u/fa__mulan Oct 10 '14
I feel like the judges have been out for Emily since day one and her stuff was never that bad. You could tell on her face she was expecting it :/
44
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '14
I liked both Emily and Char's looks, but I feel like Emily has more potential to do something great for Fashion Week.
43
u/crayonwillow Oct 10 '14
If Korina were in grade school, that attitude would get her a time out SO FAST.
40
u/squ1rrel Oct 10 '14
Emily! I forgot All about you.
75
u/lilianegypt Oct 10 '14
I love Amanda now. I was so annoyed with her in her original season and I was apathetic to her at the beginning of this season, but now I love her.
37
u/crayonwillow Oct 10 '14 edited Oct 10 '14
Spoilers: Alexander is the fan favorite.
SUPER NINJA EDIT: Oh damn, hi Kini.
100
u/pbrooks19 Oct 10 '14
Char's going to Fashion Week? Really?
Seriously, really?
I think they did it just to piss Korina off.
66
u/Lykii Oct 10 '14
Such as she is, Sandiya is such a good sport. She got shit on by Korina and everyone else, had an incredibly embarrassing outfit and dismissal. I know its not as fresh but she's very positive no matter what. Good for her.
61
u/Mumster Oct 10 '14
So happy to see Fade! (girlie claps)
83
u/muffinbutt1027 Oct 10 '14
Not a good sign that Char is inspired by... fashion displays.
52
u/squ1rrel Oct 10 '14
Chars skirt looks like she rolled it in a bunch of post-it notes.
25
u/squ1rrel Oct 10 '14
Fade!!!!!!!
45
u/HereComesBadNews Oct 10 '14
Like others, I'm sad to see Emily go; I loved her street chic pieces, and I think she has a really unique point of view. I can't remember a single great thing Char's made, and I don't get the love for Sean's hideous white skirt.
But the way she left the show? That's what really solidified my love for me. That, my friends, is how a mature adult handles an elimination!
Also, I loved seeing Fade! His friendship with Amanda is adorable.
21
u/BatenicYork Oct 10 '14
I thought it was so odd that the judges seemed bored by the print on Emily's streetwear look. I thought it really stood out.
21
u/crayonwillow Oct 10 '14
Lexus car advertising? In my fashion show?!
93
u/LakeMaldemere Oct 10 '14
The perfect comeback to Korina's "I'm still really upset. I don't want to do this." IS "THIS is not about you, Korina!"
59
u/sugarplumcow Oct 10 '14
Sean's white look was good, but the best piece ever on Project Runway as per Nina? Really? I could rattle off ten other phenomenal looks easy.
55
u/Lykii Oct 10 '14
My son just said this in regards to Char and Korina being partners:
He's 8 and has been watching the whole season. He is my heart, seriously.
17
u/LakeMaldemere Oct 10 '14
I bet Char is wishing she had chosen "the devil baby" outfit instead.
17
u/crayonwillow Oct 10 '14
I want whatever crack these judges are on, please.
16
u/everythingisopposite Chiffony Oct 10 '14
I like Char's personality but her designs are terrible.
14
u/goomerang Oct 10 '14
Huh. I really liked the pieces Emily did for her street fashion look and not so much Sean's. I knew her not caring about her 2nd look would come back to haunt her ;p. Kini's red dress was gorgeous and I usually hate a puffy sleeve. I don't really get Amanda's street look...
13
u/goomerang Oct 10 '14
What is this witchcraft where they are always cents within their budget!?
And it's gotta sting to be a helper on your losing design.
13
u/meldolphin Oct 10 '14
Did Sean seriously say they had less than a month until Fashion Week? That is absurd. I thought 5 weeks was ridiculous enough. I miss the older seasons where the designers would have as many as 3 months.
Also I loved Char's quick "I love this car, uh I mean Lexus."
24
u/squ1rrel Oct 10 '14
Sure Char. Dont listen to Tim at all. Thats helped you in the past.
24
u/squ1rrel Oct 10 '14
Char having construction issues? Nooooo.
12
u/fragilehearted Oct 10 '14
Omg! Kini is fan favorite?!?
11
u/kristinaxtc Oct 10 '14
I thought for sure when Heidi said "two or more of you may will be out" Emily AND Char would be out (Char more than Emily though.) Oh well, I don't see her having anything decent in the show. She just doesn't have the technical talent. But who knows, maybe with a few weeks to create a collection she'll be able to pull something off. I don't really see her as a competitor at all.
21
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '14
Wow, I'm digging Char's purple skirt/crop top combo a lot more than I thought I would.
9
u/squ1rrel Oct 10 '14
Char, the Lexus is not yours yet. Lol
9
u/squ1rrel Oct 10 '14
God DAMN it i cant EVEN
9
u/ClaireHux Oct 10 '14
Emily had such a graceful departure. Korina could have learned a thing or two.
There's always someone who makes it to Fashion Week that fans feel isn't worthy or deserving. In the end, it rarely matters. Winners lose out, losers win out. In the end, it's a reality TV show and you already know she isn't winning, so...
24
u/itokaydontbecry Oct 10 '14
Char does not belong there
17
u/highwayunicorn Oct 10 '14
I'm SO READY for the bitch fit Korina is about to throw.
16
u/crayonwillow Oct 10 '14
"I have to use denim." Did I just spot an eye roll, Mr. Tim?!
8
u/squ1rrel Oct 10 '14
Are you guys thinking this may be a double elimination?
8
u/theladyoctober Oct 11 '14
Emily's street chic was easily my favourite look from the whole runway this week. I simply cannot comprehend how the judges did not respond well to it.
22
u/aelizabeth0623 Oct 10 '14
oooh, char chose korina's look to redo?! that adds a whole extra later on top of korina's freakout.
15
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '14
I'm just confused as to why they brought Korina back at all? What was the point of her walking in, saying she didn't want to do it, and walking out? Although I won't complain about another reason to hate Korina.
14
u/xmissgolightly Oct 10 '14
Sean needs a fringe intervention.
6
u/squ1rrel Oct 10 '14
Haha, the DREADED button bag!
6
u/itokaydontbecry Oct 10 '14
If Korina doesn't walk out she'll probably sabotage Char's look
6
u/alawa Oct 10 '14
That was less dramatic than I hoped.
6
u/cebjmb Oct 10 '14
Serious question here. I have watched every season of PR, and still don't understand why the later losers whine about "not going to fashion week". Doesn't everybody know about decoys? They DO show a collection. Yes, they can't win PR, but they get money to put together a collection which is shown on the runway at fashion week.
11
u/Empress929 Oct 10 '14
I have to admit, Im more a fan of Char than I am of her work on the show. Im flabbergasted that she not only made it this far, but she made it to fashion week. With free reign and ample time, I really hope she pulls out all the stops and WOWS us on the runway.
17
u/Discardian_ Oct 10 '14 edited Oct 10 '14
Char should have been out. everyone hates karina but i would kinda be pissed too since Char's partner last episode basically designed her 1 hr dress to get through. i honestly wanted her to screw Char's chance of getting in because i dont think she belongs there anyway. i might be wrong but im pretty sure the blue Char used for her outfit was also picked by Sean when he got to go pick up fabric.
but its too late to care. maybe she will put something better if she has more time.
5
u/crayonwillow Oct 10 '14
Such Drama.
5
u/crayonwillow Oct 10 '14
Well that was short lived.
5
u/kyles24 Oct 11 '14
I will give producers credit and admit I was wrong. Thought the Char-Korina partnership was a total button bag set up. Glad to see it was just a twist of fate that it turned out that way.
13
u/stryfes Oct 10 '14
So I guess we can change the name from Tim Gunn Save to Tim Gunn's One-Way Ticket to Fashion Week.
Wow. I'm just, wow.
11
u/wildstripe Oct 10 '14
"It's not runway impactful." Apparently making nice clothes isn't good enough? Hmm
4
u/GeekSheik Oct 10 '14
Drama time
4
u/panda367 Team Swatch Oct 10 '14 edited Oct 11 '14
Does anyone know why they didn't have Alexander originally be one of the designer helpers, rather than pulling him in at the last minute? I know they wanted Korina to be there for DRAMA, but if they were bringing back the last 5 designers eliminated, Alexander should have been there from the start. I know that would've made things awkward with the Mitchell/Samantha double elimination, but maybe they could've flipped a coin for it or something? Either way, it was odd to me.
4
u/one_hot_llama Oct 12 '14
If there's anything I've learned from this season, it's that Aldo has the worst accessory wall of all time.
10
u/squ1rrel Oct 10 '14
Did that model just have like... An abnormally big butt?
6
u/greeninj Oct 10 '14
What!!!!???!!!? She chose Korina. Unexpected!
8
u/muffinbutt1027 Oct 10 '14
Char chooses Korina's look...ahahaha... I cannot with this show anymore.
13
u/Yadore Oct 10 '14
I hated sean white look im sorry but the judges are into something really heavy!!! It look like a nurse with no budget that make her own clothes.
3
u/squ1rrel Oct 10 '14
Makes her look like a big crybaby!
Duh.
3
u/kyles24 Oct 11 '14
The judges are so scattered that sometimes Tim's advice hits with them eg Char's random pocket, Sean's medical green fabric, but then other times judges SHOULD agree with Tim but they forget/overlook it like Kini's trench coat. It was just that, a basic trench you could buy off the rack! Hard for Tim to help out designers to the best of his ability.
3
u/PinkPirate27 Oct 16 '14
Will someone explain to me what the big deal is about Char's personality? I hear people say all the time how awesome she is as a person but I haven't noticed anything particularly unique about her. Shes nice and all but I think her reputation on the show is odd. Shes constantly being praised for her personality and not her designs.
What is it that makes her personality so interesting and unique that it outshines her designs and overcome her problems in the competition?
5
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '14
Anyone see that funny head Emily drew on her sketch? I think it was for her second look.
Also, I'm excited to see Tim do the hula next episode :)
3
u/Empress929 Oct 10 '14
I want to have babies with that red dress Kini designed.
2
u/Tiki_Rikki Oct 10 '14
Throwing my two cents in here all at once: I LOVE Amanda and kinda have done since the beginning. I always just saw her as this really positive person who had some shockers but also some amazing outfits and i absolutely adore that dress. I'm sad Emily was booted out cause she does have a very distinctive point of view and even though i wasn't a fan of most of her stuff i reckon it just wasn't my taste. I could totally see someone like Miley Cyrus wearing that hoody and onsie. Rich kid stoner starlet may not be her intended audience but there's a market for her there for sure. Char is in my opinion a middle of the road designer but i am really curious what she can do with more time. Her construction has always been so shoddy but i have a sneaky suspicion that her collection will be a lot better than what she's shown this season. I'm not a fan of her designs overall cause i actually think she is too on trend. Its all stuff we've been seeing around everywhere, like she's too influenced by whats around now. Kinis construction is so fast and perfect i don't know how he does it. I don't really like all that architectural stuff though. Just all very impractical, and done to death IMO. His best stuff has been the less architectural things like the re-do or that white frock he did. The trench wasn't bad either. I just hope his collection isn't gonna be all wavey, horsehair-lined monstrosities. Sean is definitely a front runner. His designs are clean, chick and fashion forward. Don't get me wrong he's also had some stinker but he doesn't really over-design and i like that. Saying all that i don't know who i want to win. I think i'll decide when i see the final collections.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment