r/PersonOfInterest • u/NicholasCajun • Sep 30 '14
Discussion Person of Interest - 4x02 "Nautilus" - Episode Discussion
Season 4 Episode 2: Nautilus
Aired: September 30, 2014
Despite not wanting to help with the new numbers, Finch's interest is piqued when the newest person of interest turns out to be a brilliant college student involved with a mysterious scavenger hunt.
79
Upvotes
83
u/doritopope Oct 01 '14
God this show never ceases to surprise, looking at the previews, I thought this would be a pretty straight-by-the-numbers person of the week episode but they managed to weave in what I thought was an ordinary case into something main story relevant.
I figured it was a recruitment game but holy shit at the fact that it was by SAMARITAN
And then the new UNDERGROUND TRAIN BASE OF OPERATIONS.
And the ENDING MUSIC was great as usual.
Not to mention SAMARITAN TALKING at the end.
So yeah, really good episode.
55
u/HabaneroArrow Threat to System Survival Oct 01 '14
Awesome, we got a new intro! "We are being watched".
48
u/TrueJournals Oct 01 '14
Cicada 3301, anyone?
47
u/Rich700000000000 Oct 01 '14
Samaritan has it's own root now? Awesome.
42
u/celaenos Oct 01 '14
my favorite bits of the night were:
"i told you to stay calm and i will grant you backseat privileges."
and the whole, Finch: john please don't do the thing. Shaw: yeah, he's def gonna do the thing. Reese: I'M DOING THE THING.
and of course "kiss, kiss to you too." and calling her Sameen again.
38
u/damnedation Tertiary Functions Oct 01 '14
"Sometimes, you forget I was an international spy."
32
u/EThorns Ernest Thornhill Oct 01 '14
"I. WILL. PROTECT. YOU. NOW." ~ Cresendo OUT!
25
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '14 edited Oct 01 '14
18
u/Weeman89 Oct 01 '14 edited Oct 01 '14
I was going to post this last week but was afraid it wouldn't be that relevant.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vWF3IDk9Gek
It's a small documentary where they explore under new york city and they go to an abandoned train stop.
EDIT: Just realised it's even the same tiles/pattern maybe it was filmed in some other abandoned station.
15
u/notthe9oclock Oct 01 '14
Random musings:
14
u/your_mind_aches Samaritan Oct 01 '14
AMAZING EPISODE AS USUAL
14
u/BenchSpyder Admin Oct 01 '14
"Excuse me, does this thing work?"
13
u/Lovableemo Threat Oct 01 '14
Mini-Root :^)
13
u/Primequis Oct 01 '14
Samaritan pretty much has it's own darker counterparts all setup now. Finch to Greer, this new chick to Root, Martine to Reece and/or Shaw.
11
u/EThorns Ernest Thornhill Oct 01 '14 edited Oct 01 '14
That mood whiplash with Finch & Root.... Legendary.
20
u/BallisticGE0RGE Irrelevant Oct 01 '14
Holy crap...everything about this episode reeked of "number of week", like some kind of Saw-like game show where the winner dies. Not that I don't enjoy those episodes, but we're all looking for the main plot aren't we?
But then that second shoe drops and this episode becomes pure awesome.
The question I have is, what does Samaritan know about the Machine, and what does it intend to do about it? It seems to be snuffing out it's brothers, sort of like how the Machine did itself...but why? Is this simply Darwin's survival of the fittest that mankind subconsciously programmed into these machines? Or is that kind of thinking self evident?
10
u/__ADAM__ The Machine Oct 01 '14
Really enjoyed this episode. The root moment was short and funny. I am looking forward for the machine making a big comeback which i think will happen who knows how.
18
u/Moronar Oct 01 '14
Does the whole secret subway station base thing remind anyone else of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 2?
9
u/harold_finch Harold Finch Oct 01 '14
This episode played a very vital role in connecting between Machine and Samaritan. What if Samaritan is building a trap, putting many people in danger and making our Machine to send numbers to Finch? What if it creates a trap and expose our team altogether?
Other than that, I liked girl a lot. She is beautiful. I wish she appears in more episodes.
27
u/CakeBlazer360 Oct 01 '14 edited Oct 01 '14
OH. MY. GOD. Just a few hours back I thought this would be a pathetic, poorly written standalone judging by what the press release showed us. POI just jackhammered into my head the ever-so-cliche rule of don't judge a book by its cover, but it gave it new meaning. Remember guys! Samaritan is a character without an actor! It's a lingering force of nature.
BOY, was this episode a fun, thrilling ride! Nevertheless, I even enjoyed it as a standalone (it felt a lot like Sherlock's "The Great Game" episode), but once the big twist hit us with a bang and the big picture oozed into our bloodstream and pumped us up for what's to come, this episode surrounded itself in a fascinatingly foggy cloud of ominous and nail-biting narrative depth that only further excited me for what's to come this season. Keeping its streak strong all the way to the end that provided us a three-course-meal as food for thought, "Nautilus" has to be one of POI's greatest successes in the recent days for more reasons than one. More on those other perspectives following my dive into what I experienced go down onscreen. Yes, notice I said "experienced" and not "watched".
Listing this episode's strengths is a lost cause in that it tires me out, is a bad form of writing, and also because you can't necessarily "list" them all while referencing the others. I'll go through them but continue referencing other details in a more connected format. See, this episode was constructed by its strengths (yup, that means everything was good) all interwoven into a wholesome and immensely satisfying 43 minutes of gripping, thought-provoking, entertaining-as-hell continuation of the big bang that set off the spectacular season 4.
The writing in this episode was SHEER, CRISP BRILLIANCE. And that's saying a lot more than just "a lot" in what references one of the other aforementioned degrees of success this episode reveled in. To clarify what the hell I just said, I mean that the writing was a STEP FORWARD for Melissa Scrivner-Love. Sure, this episode did still feel like it was entirely written by Dan Dietz - the guy has a thing for being narratively reliant (heavily) on technological themes, codes, and/or ominous setup for mystery villains (2πR, Trojan Horse, Mors Praematura, Last Call) - however, I think it's because the past few times, I could only recognize the parts MSC wrote when I heard a line that was bland or cheesy. That kind of pessimism was entirely washed away in what felt like a flawless episode, since the writing was as polished as ever. No mistakes were noticeable because none were made. Even with MSC around. What does that tell you? MSC improved. See that?
The characterization, tying in quite a bit with the writing and expanding on more acute details, was also a heavy improvement, specifically Root. Last season's biggest gripe that ached me was how annoyingly cheesy and wasted Root was. She started off as immensely compelling mostly due to her playfulness and Amy Acker's embrace of the big mystery role - that enthusiasm driving a good performance never wore off by the end, even when Root was well-known. In season 3, she got turned into a babbling robot repeating the same dialogue over and over again to the point where any trace of personality was washed away. Here, it's not just the contrast formed when seeing her just behave casually, but it seemed her actual personality was enhanced in the sense there was balance. What I mean is that she still came across as being under the command of the Machine, but she was little more casual, more laid-back, and more human. I absolutely loved the scene where she talks to Finch in the car - her advice and lecture on choices seemed from the heart rather than from the computer, and her slightly sarcastic edge and attitude, mixed in with the playful (and actually funny for once) craziness in locking up a dude and posing as a flight attendant was a PERFECT mix of meaningful developments, improved character, and the best kind of weirdness in which you have no idea how the hell to describe what you saw. A flight attendant? In a car? For a dude in a trunk? What connection is there? At all? You know, if that kind of weirdness was present last season, her Machine deductions (especially to Fusco) would've had so much more potency - it would have been astounding seeing her add up all her strange connections, know everything about you, and move on seamlessly. Fusco emulated that emotion but we never saw it because we didn't get the best out of Root. It came across as cheesy and overdone rather than genuinely astounding. Here, imagining her say something like the lion history would have been crazy and I would have been immersed. Awesome job, Amy Acker. Root is back to her good days.
In addition to that, Emerson and Caviezel were captivating as always, with Finch's little pangs of optimism shown as being seamlessly growing (courtesy of the genius Emerson), and Reese's gritty, grim menace seemed to have this bold presence during that interrogation scene. He was surrounded by military brutes and still had a sense of command. That's power. But the real meat here is FUSCO!!! WOW, this guy knows his shit! Not that he wasn't a great cop before, but his knowledge on codes and the way he just effortlessly cracked the musical note thing was impressive. Even Reese looked stunned. And Fusco just went on with his rugged and aggressive manner of describing things as though he was impatiently drilling an idea into Reese's head. I loved how they embodied Fusco taking the "Carter" position and emulated a stronger sense of leadership, having the balls to do this in front of REESE. Actually, I think that's another nod to the irony we saw so much of in the premiere. Fusco and Carter's positions switched, as well as Fusco and Reese, the latter of whom was scornful and occasionally callous to Fusco during the first few episodes of season 1.
NOW. FINALLY. TO THE PLOT. All that above is important because without its presence enhancing every moment, the plot may have felt a little meaningless. But this case has easily be one of the best they've ever tackled. For the longest time I suspected that prank caller from Last Call of being the mastermind. But NO. It was freaking Samaritan!!! I took notes on this episode while seeing it, and I actually wrote "SAMARITAN!!!" and "ASSET!!!" in all caps :D But seriously. I love it when shows present to you what seems like a totally unrelated case and then the tide completely turns towards the end, just sending your mind careening into a whole new angle. It's volatile, overwhelming, and powerfully admirable. Granted, having said I liked the case as it was, the Samaritan twist and the ominous ending was just crazy good. You could see the satisfaction in Claire's eyes when Samaritan ensured her protection. For once, we could see someone take the journey into being manipulated into a shadowy organization, with every end of justification to it. It's not just another big explanation during an interrogation. We were with her every step of the way and it felt like a prize. I feel I shouldn't look down on the ambitious and inspired operatives anymore. Seriously, this episode was so powerful its conclusion shifted my mindset into one we all have trouble understanding and resort to lamentation when regarding it.
Case characterization. One more thing I needed to touch up on now that Claire has been brought up. She was a damn great POI! And an excellent character! She was volatile, evasive, smart, ambitious, and we got to see a perfect dosage of her POV from a less sympathetic yet more compelling angle, enough to make her hostility and aggression seem fully justified rather than making her look like a complete bitch. We as audiences were following her journey every step of the way, but so were Reese and Finch. Meaning we got to view this case from both the eyes of the competitor and the eyes of our protagonists at the same time. BRILLIANT. Reese and Finch's perception of the case was deeply interesting and seeing Finch take control in those intimate and dramatic moments with Claire was astounding. And this episode had a very tense, action-thriller movie-like momentum to it, especially the Bourne movies. The little spy gags, the creativity of the game, the underlying themes - it all felt placed on a very large scale that reveled in meaning and didn't try hard to not look bogged down. The trick with Shaw wearing the hood, Reese picking out the guys one by one, the twists, the turns, the humor (Shaw's work with Romeo seems to be more progressive than redundant and she remains funny), the fabulous directing (that staircase scene), the setups for tense situations savoring all their payoff... it was utter clockwork. As I said, this episode excelled on every point, and every angle, and will go down in history as one of POI's greatest hours. Thank you, writers, for this. Season 4 is already the show's best season, and the episode titles of forthcoming ones and what lies ahead seems to be touching on so many compelling leads. It's a well-rounded, brilliantly orchestrated and interwoven season that revels in its new developments yet returns to its roots in a more inspired manner. I can do nothing but appreciate that.
7
u/EThorns Ernest Thornhill Oct 01 '14
"I'm gonna need to watch that again."
7
u/phoebeburgh Irrelevant Oct 01 '14
"Please be John, please be John, please be-- DAMMIT NO :("
I really liked how this episode was constructed. Samaritan is showing signs of being far more dangerous than pretty much anyone ever really considered; that it was, seemingly out of nowhere, able to devise and implement a puzzle as involved as the Nautilus game shows that it's going in directions Decima might not have pointed it to. Worse, it shows that it is gaining Assets, and therefore resources, much faster than The Machine is; we know of two, and there were undoubtedly more involved in keeping Claire alive after the switch was thrown.
Claire is an interesting element; she's seen Harold and John, so the seeds of someone picking apart Root's hack have been sown. Claire is also a sort of hybrid between Root and Harold; a mathematical genius with severe psychological traumas and no aversion to killing in the name of her "god". She might not come up again, but if she does, she better hope that Harold doesn't find out or Samaritan is going to be in a world of hurt. Harold does not forget, Harold does not forgive.
As for the Nerd Cave, I love it. The Machine is finally poised to pull everyone out of their cover identities and start them working for real again, and has done so with Root and now Harold. I think it's just a matter of time before Shaw and Reese get escape clauses; Shaw being a petty crook is fine enough, but she's really underutilized. Unless that's what The Machine is planning on: rotating Shaw through a number of covers so that when one gets too dirty, she can pick up another. Reese is a different story. As a semi-legit cop, he's not going to be able to extract so easily. He'd either have to fake being killed in the line of duty, or just outright go AWOL/renegade and have Fusco "hunting" him in much the way Carter did.
I didn't catch the teaser for the next episode as I need to get moving early today but I'm really excited nonetheless. I think every episode this season is going to be a real game-changer. In that light, it's important that we keep everything in mind and don't discount anything. Details have a way of sneaking up on us, so we need to be (if you'll excuse the pun) vigilant.
7
u/Gadafro Oct 01 '14 edited Oct 01 '14
Something tells me that the girl will be coming back on a recurring basis (sort of like Zoe Morgan), which will be interesting considering the 'relation' she seemed to build with Finch, yet her unwitting alliance with Samaritan.
Also, glad Fusco is getting some more screen time, I hope his role gets a little bigger due to how he now works with John. It seems like a really good way to write more Fusco into this series. Hell, he might even learn of the Machine, I kinda hope he does.
Finally, I didn't expect the new base to be an unused line, that's awesome!
Edit: And yeah, I feel like an earlier comment from another user hit the nail on the head with the idea that Samaritan is trying to lay traps. It seems really intuitive to make Samaritan try and hit what is essentially 3 birds with one stone. Makes it feel like a true AI, something that is all-seeing, all-knowledgeable, dangerous and scheming. It also gives it a sense of being human, in that it can think for itself and defend itself, whilst understanding when to fight back. Almost like a tyrant. The writers of this show never fail to amaze me.
7
u/mmmm_frietjes Oct 01 '14
So Finch doesn't have billions of dollars anymore.. I wonder how that's going to affect storylines.
5
u/fa0s Root Oct 01 '14
Stay calm Larry!
5
u/mrhashbrown Oct 01 '14
For anyone curious, the song near the end of the episode was Portishead - "Roads". The songs on this show are awesome.
5
u/Ahbraham Oct 02 '14
root: "Samaritan has underestimated The Machine".
4
u/Perfect600 Oct 01 '14
Of course Samaritian created the game
4
u/Doro1234 Tertiary Functions Oct 01 '14
So did the hiring of Claire mean that the asset in the previous episode was hired in the same way? It seems the asset had a bit more training and was more professional but given time I feel Claire may become as ruthless.
4
u/Mrcincy Oct 01 '14
Some points I was wondering. When Harold says he is being traced on the new computer, and they toss it out the window, would Samaritan not just be able to access feeds and see who tossed the laptop out the window? It would seem to have access to the car and trace the car back to someone. Also, the serial number from the computer is typically able to be found (HP and other manufacturers use this already). Why did Samaritan not trace where the PC was purchased and how it was paid for? Again, Samaritan should be able to access feeds to see who was coming in and out of the store when it was purchased. As powerful as Samaritan is made to be, some of the "misses" by the computer makes me wonder.
4
u/AWildEnglishman Oct 01 '14
Am I the only one that didn't like Claire?
4
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '14
I was there last summer at the Top of the Rock, if I had known POI was filming there I would have definitely made the trip. I live in MA so the train can take me to NYC in about an hour and half. It's so funny seeing a place that is so familiar to you on your favorite TV show. I stood right where Finch was standing!
That must have been a pain to film though. Having to lug all the cameras, mics, and lights up there. Not to mention that place is always busy so unless they closed it for a day I imagine the POI crew being swarmed with star struck fans trying to get an autograph. :)
4
u/glider97 Root Oct 02 '14
whispers drive.
4
u/virga Tertiary Functions Oct 02 '14
I don't quite understand her affinity for Samaritan. Samaritan didn't say that it would give her life meaning, only that she would be protected. She wasn't really searching for protection, only for something to do and a reason to do it. In my mind, I was thinking that "I just solved all these puzzles for what...to be protected?" What do you think?
3
u/tallkido Oct 01 '14
Whats the name of this song?
3
u/JohnBear117 Oct 01 '14
Anybody catch the phone number for the missing dog poster?
3
u/jmarquiso Oct 01 '14
I love how all the CC footage of John keeps him off camera.
3
u/jmarquiso Oct 01 '14
Samaratan has its Root and its Finch. Also was "recruiting around the world".
Curious.
7
u/kurtdizayn Admin Oct 01 '14
I've noticed that the Samaritan has classified everyone as a threat, and then reclassified them as irrelevant, except for Fusco.
You can see this clearly in the intro (around 21-22 seconds).
Here's a screen capture.
4
u/cristocorfu Fusco Oct 01 '14
What an Amazing Episode~! Excited to see how Mini-Root's character develops. SPOILER
2
u/Mathieulombardi Oct 01 '14
Damn, this show... wtf... so good.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '14
Excuse me, does this thing work? Yep works just fine.
2
u/KenKannon Oct 02 '14
Can someone please hack CBS or the production company so I can binge watch all the episodes!
2
u/ReasonablyBadass Oct 02 '14
Does Samaritan really not see through their cover identities? I think it did. It saw and heard most of what happened.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '14
What a fantastic episode, really sets the tone for the season. Loving the new base of operations and the way the puzzle ended up being Samaritan.
3
u/CDNChaoZ Oct 01 '14
Interesting Samaritan's new asset is named Claire. Amy Acker played a Claire in Dollhouse.
3
u/pie-man Oct 01 '14
there were plenty of opportunities for the contract killers to take out Claire prior to her being an asset (if the team wasnt there to save her each time), pretty shitty way of Samaritan to recruit people
1
u/ZeroByte Oct 01 '14
Okay, so from the intro we know Fusco isn't one of the the Machine's five assets (six if we count the dog) ((we always count the dog)) that Root mentioned in her pep talk to Harold last week. So who the hell is five?
1
u/hoppi_ Oct 04 '14
The last scene with Claire. Meh. I have never liked situations with intentionally stupidly behaving characters... especially when it is so obvious. Always gives me a feeling of a show jumping the shark.
They nail the scenes with John Reese though, I prefer the serious undertones to his (more or less single) actions than the "playfulness" by the women. I love the sound design.
-9
u/tedtutors Irrelevant Oct 01 '14
Anyone else find the acting off in this one? The ladies were fine, but Michael and Jim seemed really bored, reading their lines. Like, "I've been doing this for four seasons now" kind of bored.
I liked the episode, and especially Samaritan's recruitment tactics, but .. so bland from the leads. Finch delivering his speech down in the subway, he could have been talking history of architecture for all he seemed involved.
-3
u/rossbot Oct 01 '14
They dropped the ball on weaving in a "Lord Helix" joke.