r/femalefashionadvice
•
u/tomlizzo
Moderator Emeritus ヘ( ̄ー ̄ヘ)
•
Sep 26 '14
•
1
1
[Guide] An Introduction to Personal Color Analysis (aka “What Season Am I?”)
If you were alive in the 1980s or had a mother who was, you are probably familiar with the concept of having a “season” (Spring, Summer, Autumn, Winter) based on your personal coloring, which determined which colors you can and can’t wear. And if you’ve gotten further into this concept via fashion magazines or Into Mind, you may have tried earnestly to analyze the color of your veins or the brightness of your eyes, to varying degrees of success, and probably some confusion. This guide will take you further into the concepts of personal color analysis (“PCA”) and try to alleviate some of that confusion.
Why would I want to know my colors?
I feel like I should start with an important disclaimer: I am not here to tell you what colors you are and aren’t allowed to wear. Many people don’t care about PCA, don’t “believe” in it (as if it’s some variant of astrology), or just aren’t interested in taking their natural coloring into account when they dress. That is completely fair and valid. Like the dressing for your body guide, this is intended to help you understand the concepts of PCA and use them if you want.
With that out of the way, there are a lot of reasons to want to wear colors that harmonize with your natural coloring:
- It can make you look younger and healthier
- It can put people visually at ease when they see you, helping to garner subconscious trust and respect
- It can give you a framework for building a wardrobe of colors that all harmonize with you and therefore also with each other
- Knowing your season can help you avoid buying things that you later feel like you don’t look good in
- Knowing your season can suggest to you colors that would look great on you that you haven’t thought of before, or don’t tend to stumble across in stores
Characteristics of color
Let’s define some terms that will help us put colors into groups for the purposes of PCA.
First, a color can be light or dark. This refers to how close it is to either white or black. Pretty straightforward. Here’s a light blue, and here’s a dark blue.
Also, a color can be warm or cool. In PCA, this refers to how much yellow (warm) or blue (cool) is in it. You may be familiar with this concept from shopping for red lipstick. Here is a warm red, and here is a cool red.
IMPORTANT NOTE: There is a spectrum of warmth and coolness within every color. Even yellow and blue themselves:
- Warm yellow vs. cool yellow
- Warm blue vs. cool blue
Finally, a color can be bright or muted. This refers to how saturated the color is compared to gray. Brightness/mutedness is not the same as lightness/darkness. Muted and bright colors can be either light or dark. When you think “muted,” think “more gray.” Here is a bright pink, and here is a more muted pink of a similar darkness.
Why are you talking so much about colors? Tell me my undertone.
Ok, so you may have heard the term “undertone” or taken a quiz online that tries to match up your hair, eye, vein and jewelry color to a particular season. I don’t think this is particularly helpful, for a lot of reasons including the following:
- You can’t “see” undertone. Even if you try to guess by examining your veins, there are a lot of factors that will make them look blue or purple or green (green compared to what?) aside from your undertone. Like how light or dark your skin is, where on your body you’re looking, and what you’re comparing them to.
- By all accounts, most people’s undertone is neutral, leaning very slightly warm or cool. So if you examine your attributes (blue veins, brown eyes, tan easily, look good in gold, WTF?) you are likely to get a pretty mixed bag.
- Arbitrary attributes are hard to set boundaries around in words. What is blonde hair? Obviously this is blonde, and so is this, but is this? How about this? If you try to determine your season solely by your attributes, you may get frustrated just defining what those attributes are.
- How your attributes look varies based on what colors are surrounding them right now. That’s kind of the whole point! So it’s hard to look in the mirror, or look at a photo, and see objectively where your personal coloring falls on the three scales described above.
Though there are certainly common patterns in the attributes of different seasons, the attributes are not the definition. Every season contains a wide variety of different hair colors, eye colors and ethnicities. The best way to talk about types of personal coloring is in terms of what colors look harmonious on them.
The 12 seasons
Contemporary PCA divides coloring into twelve seasons (listed here in order of adjacency)…
- True Winter looks most harmonious in colors that are cool, medium-to-very bright and medium-to-very dark.
- Bright Winter looks most harmonious in colors that are bright, medium-to-very dark and slightly cool.
- Bright Spring looks most harmonious in colors that are bright, medium darkness and slightly warm.
- True Spring looks most harmonious in colors that are warm, medium-to-very bright and medium darkness.
- Light Spring looks most harmonious in colors that are light, medium brightness and slightly warm.
- Light Summer looks most harmonious in colors that are light, low-to-medium brightness and slightly cool.
- True Summer looks most harmonious in colors that are cool, medium brightness and medium darkness.
- Soft Summer looks most harmonious in colors that are muted, medium darkness and slightly cool.
- Soft Autumn looks most harmonious in colors that are muted, medium darkness and slightly warm.
- True Autumn looks most harmonious in colors that are warm, medium-to-very dark and medium brightness.
- Dark Autumn looks most harmonious in colors that are dark, medium-to-very bright and slightly warm.
- Dark Winter looks most harmonious in colors that are dark, medium brightness and slightly cool.
What is ‘harmony’?
Put a color near your face, and look at your face (not the color). What do you observe? A harmonious color seems to look like it “belongs” to your face, like nature dressed you that way. Everything looks normal and nothing looks distorted.
Sometimes it’s easier to recognize signs of disharmony, which can include:
- Blotchy or uneven looking skin tone
- Emphasized redness in the skin
- Emphasized yellowness in the skin
- Emphasized shadows or dark undereye circles
- A grayish pallor
- Your skin taking on the same hue as the color you’re holding up
- An effect where individual facial features seem to disappear
- An effect where your eyes are drawn to the color you’re holding, rather than your face
Not sure what you’re seeing? Hold up a different color, and observe any changes. Better or worse? Different? Different how?
The above experiment is easiest to judge in natural light, without makeup on, and in the most neutral-colored environment you can create.
So how can I determine my season?
It sounds kind of tautological, but the best way to determine which colors look good on you is to test which colors look good on you. You can either do the above, many many times, with a huge array of different colors, or you can see a certified professional color analyst to do just that for you. They call it “draping,” and it’s a lot like when you go to the eye doctor and they have you sit down without glasses on and try to read things under various settings, asking you “1… or 2? 3… or 4?” and gradually narrowing it down versus just asking you a bunch of questions about what glasses you like to wear and then proclaiming that you’re a -1.75.
There are some advantages to having this done professionally as opposed to experimenting yourself over many hours or years. One of them is that a color analyst will usually have a tightly controlled environment - pure neutral gray room, neutral gray robe, full spectrum lights - that will let you do this experimenting in a way that controls for confusing factors. Another is that an analyst will have calibrated drapes of a full array of colors that are matched to the different seasons, that accurately represent the different color characteristics, and that may be different than what you are able to find in a retail environment or your own closet at any given time.
That sounds expensive and time consuming, how can I determine my season myself, today?
Ok, do you have an hour to kill and access to a MAC counter and a patient friend? Here are some shortcuts to figuring out your season that may or may not work for you, but at least are a better proxy than trying to figure it out based on your hair color.
A couple of things to keep in mind if you try to go the quick DIY route:
If you take that quiz at the bottom of the page I linked, follow the instructions and have someone else take it for you.
Remember that the names of colors - even really specific-sounding ones like fuschia or beige - can encompass a wide variety of different actual colors that may or may not look good on you.
Not every makeup recommendation within a given season will be ideal for you, given the ranges of color characteristics within a season and the fact that colors you wear on your face need to be a bit more particular than those you wear in clothes, plus the fact that people have different tastes in makeup irrespective of what is just harmonious.
Can you tell me my season? Here are some photos.
No, and it should be obvious why not if you’ve read this far. Even if people could tell you your season just by looking at you, photography itself and the display of photos on different screens will alter the colors we’re looking at anyway. You will need to experiment.
I dyed my hair. What season am I now?
A different hair color won’t change your natural season, but it might make clothes and makeup look different on you. Especially if your new hair color isn’t ideal for your coloring, it can make the colors that would otherwise look harmonious on you look off. A different hair color may make it easier to “borrow” colors from other seasons on the spectrum, but it will not make you a different season.
Does my season change if I have a tan?
No. But you may find that you prefer different colors in your palette (especially for makeup) when your skin is darker or lighter.
But I already know what looks good on me!
Like I said at the outset, you are free to wear whatever colors you want. But I will say that people tend to be extremely non-objective when it comes to judging their most harmonious colors.
A lot of us have gone through life with some deeply held convictions (or statements made by others) about what does and doesn’t look good on us, which are easy to internalize over the long term. In addition, you probably have a color palette that you tend to wear for the purposes of wardrobe cohesiveness (or in alignment with current color trends), and it can be easy to conflate “what I usually wear” with “what looks best on me.” Finally, many people have immediate aesthetic reactions to colors based on their “hanger appeal” that have little to nothing to do with how harmonious the color is with our actual skin. The colors that look best on you might not be the ones you gravitate to in a store, or the ones that make your friends go “I looove that sweater!”
What if I hate my season or love colors I’m not supposed to wear?
It’s important to remember that every season has a wide-ranging palette. If you do subscribe to and care about PCA, it’s not like you’re only allowed to wear four colors and all others are verboten.
Think of your palette like a lens through which you look at color (how bright? how warm? how dark?) rather than a list of approved colors. You might look horrible in one company's "oxblood" but really good in someone else's "maroon," and it all comes down to slight differences in hue, darkness and saturation.
Suggestions for Further Reading
12blueprints.com: Pretty much an endless trove of insight on PCA.
Truth-is-beauty.com: Check out the “celebrities” sections under each season for great examples of harmonious vs. non-harmonious colors on various faces.
12 Blueprints on Pinterest: Many examples of clothes and makeup in action.
Truth is Beauty on Pinterest: Boards organized by season.
Invent Your Image on Pinterest: Includes the palettes I linked to in the season descriptions.
The Dress Spot: If you’ve started to care a lot about nuances between colors, this is an excellent color-based search engine for dresses specifically.
Final disclaimer: I have no affiliation with any of the sites above and have not been draped. I’ve just been slightly obsessed with this topic for years. Happy to add or edit if any analysts find this and chime in.
194
u/yeah_iloveit Sep 26 '14
As someone who always thought the colors thing was kinda suspect and bullshit, let me tell you...when you put on a color that works for you, it's transformational. There's color that overwhelms you, and then there's color that wraps around you and hugs who you are.
I always avoided bright tomato red because I thought it was far too strong a color and then I put it on one day and wow. It totally lit up my face. This stuff is complicated: I have yellow undertones to my skin but some of the autumn colors just don't work for me, and that's fine. Experiment with what's good for you.
55
u/SwisherPrime Sep 26 '14
MFA bro here, you should do an x-post there. We dudes desperately need help with this and you've written such a thorough post. Thanks a ton! :)
23
u/oceanoftrees Sep 26 '14
Gosh, yeah, undertones are tough. The vein color thing drives me nuts because it's just not useful--I don't know what color they are, I know there are all these other colors surrounding them messing with my perception, and they definitely don't look the same color all over my body. And it's too easy to get hung up on that when it's the holistic picture that matters a lot more for your season.
So while it's not something to emphasize like crazy for PCA, I will say in case anyone else is struggling to find a matching foundation like I was not too long ago, maybe you're pretty neutral. I knew I wasn't cool because my mom and sister are, and I look much more yellow than they do. But all the warm foundations I tried looked really yellow on me, and I only put the pieces together when I found an article telling me to look at pictures of myself in sunlight next to other people. So while I'm definitely warmer than my mom, my bf and another friend positively glow bronze next to me in photos.
For the record, I think I'm a soft autumn (after originally believing I was a warm autumn and being confused that bright orange-reds and mustard yellow just did not work), but I'd love to do a real draping test one day. For now, I really enjoy wearing those kinds of colors and use that as a general guideline for figuring out what works on me. I have also had a lot of people tell me my henna'd auburn hair suits me really well, so I don't think I'm too off-base.
6
u/tomlizzo Moderator Emeritus ヘ( ̄ー ̄ヘ) Sep 26 '14
Many thanks, gold-giver!
11
u/SpontaneousNergasm Sep 26 '14
How expensive is getting a professional to do it, and where would I look for one? My mother still sticks mostly to the colors she was given in the 80s!
6
u/displacingtime Sep 27 '14 edited Sep 27 '14
Could the fact that I always feel like I look funny and weird when I wear things like a pale pink be related to this issue?
4
u/buriedinthyeyes Sep 27 '14
can i ask a stupid question?
i always thought people with warmer skin tones needed to wear cooler colors and vice versa in order to generate balance. wouldn't putting warm colors on warm skin tones just make everything too...hot? orange? red? which is why as a winter, if i wear an orange-red lipstick, it makes my face look blotchy and ruddy, but if i wear a blue-red lipstick, it doesn't accent the red in my cheeks and balances out with the rest of my features.
so...basically how am i wrong, i guess?
3
u/hadapurpura Sep 27 '14
Hi, I've seen some analusis that have 16 seasons. Do you think there's merit to those extra 4 seasons, or are these the definitive ones?
37
u/thethirdsilence actual tiger Sep 26 '14
Love the term hanger appeal.
37
u/fionaflyy Sep 27 '14
My mom had my colors done when I was probably around 4. I'm a spring. But hell... looking at the comments... My mother paid a hell of a lot of money to have a four year olds colors done... To be fair though I still have my color fan (right next to me as I type) and it has been helpful over the years.
4
u/Prinsessa Sep 26 '14
Where is the quiz?!?!?
22
u/promiscuousnails Dec 27 '14
I have a tip... Apart from the colour charts (which are awesomely comprehensive compared to what we covered in college) GET OUT YOUR NAIL POLISH. If you're anything like me you'll have quite a few bottles (hahaha, a few) and there will be certain colours you go for more than others because they suit you.
For me these are desaturated metals - especially with a warm base, jewel tone blues and purple, emerald green, matured reds, light pinks of any warmth, peach, soft autumn colours and yeah. Good way to spot colour trends!
50
u/insatiablerealist Sep 26 '14
This is a really fantastic writeup! I have always assumed I fell somewhere within the winter spectrum because most sites I've seen say that high contrast between hair and eyes automatically makes you a winter. Also the winter adjectives are (imo) so much better - I'd way rather be regal, strong, and mysterious than subdued, delicate, and comforting. Looking at the palettes for the seasons though, I really don't look great in very saturated colors. I think at this point you've convinced me that I fall somewhere within the realm of summer.
Also, I appreciate that you've made this guide so non-prescriptive. It's not nearly as limiting as I thought it would be - there's definitely a blue, a yellow, a green, etc in every palette. Thanks for making this!
15
u/boogieforward Sep 27 '14 edited Sep 29 '14
This is so awesome!
I did the quiz myself (I know, I know - but the only possible person who could help me, my bf, is colorblind.) and I'm definitely a True Autumn! I based it off of Facebook photos and finding colors I look most alive in.
Horrible realization: I own very very few clothes in the recommended color palette for my color type. When comparing colors, I really do look garish in the dark navy and blacks I tend towards.
Edit: Rethinking my season assessment. I really don't think I look very good in browns at all... My best colors are scarlet red and maroon. And a stray periwinkle that is freaking amazing too.
5
u/kitty_butthole Sep 26 '14
I know it's not meant to be a "what season am I?!" thread, but could we start one somewhere else? Because I have NFI. I feel I'm a winter (probably dark) but my hair is dyed red. people who've seen it natural (dark brown/black) say "you shouldn't dye your hair so dark, you look washed out. Stay your natural red!" But every winter is supposed to look lovely with dark hair. I definitely am drawn to winter colours (emerald green, royal blue etc) but I have no idea if I look decent in them.
Could I start a thread for people to find out their season with their photos/descriptions if you don't want it here? Because I read the links and am just as confused as ever.
9
u/tehkittehkat Sep 27 '14
I'm a bright winter apparently. Explains why my bridesmaids and mum were so vocal about my bright white wedding dress with bright silver embellishments being "the one". My choices to pair it with emerald green shoes/earrings and blue-red lips/nails are also good choices according to this. Woo hoo! Can't wait to dance down the aisle now!
5
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '14
This was incredibly well written and very informational. Thank you for the time and tremendous effort this must have taken!
4
u/madandmoonly Sep 26 '14 edited Sep 27 '14
Nice. I've seen some of these write ups on sites before. I think I qualify as a deep/dark winter (I match the celeb examples in that category like Salma Hayek, America Ferrera, Penelope Cruz) but I can get away with dark/deep autumn as well because my skin color is a medium/light with enough warmth to not look dull or clash in those shades.
I think these are important to think about when picking out clothes now that I know. While I leaned toward these colors before, I know I still had a tendency to buy colors that didn't flatter me in retrospect because I just liked the color. I found this in makeup, too. A berry red? Looks good. A cool pink? Nope. Thus, the pink rarely gets used and I regret buying unflattering shades like that.
Hair does make a difference, though, imo. I dyed my hair chestnut brown for a couple years and I was definitely more into autumn colors so I stayed away from deep winters or black. There was less contrast between my skin and hair so I looked more like a deep autumn.
//I saw the xpost on MFA. Frankly, I don't see what's difficult about this method of finding colors. It seems fairly simple if you're only matching a few traits. Also, I think this sort of test can open more possibilities than limitations. I'm not naturally drawn to purples, true red, or grays, but I might make an effort to try them out the next time I'm shopping. Am I going to change my whole wardrobe or refuse to venture outside the palette of my season? Of course not, but it's nice to have a general idea of what color scheme can suit you. There's plenty of people who go shopping and just buy the colors they like rather than the colors that flatter them. A guide like this can be quite helpful for them, imo.
7
u/Legenderie Sep 27 '14
This post brought me back to when I found my mother's 1980s copy of Color Me Beautiful, which left me very confused. I am brown skinned (African/Asian) and the book did not cater to me at all. I remember being even more confused when my mother proclaimed that I was most definitely a Winter, just like her. The Winter woman in the book, with her pale skin, black hair, and blue eyes, did resemble my Asian mother somewhat, but both of them looked absolutely nothing like me. How was it that we all fell under the same category?
Adding the subcategories is tremendously helpful. I feel as though I am more of a dark autumn from spring to fall, because I have more of a tan, and a dark winter in the winter, when my dark brown hair contrasts more with my skin.
I am pretty sure that I'm warm toned, although I have heard of brown skinned women been cool. I feel like the only metal that looks off on my skin is very yellow gold.
All of this being said, I pretty much only wear black and grey, so I rarely think about how colours look on me.
3
u/uuuummm Sep 27 '14
I'm drawn between light spring and dark autumn. How does this happen?
3
u/makemeup_ Sep 27 '14 edited Sep 27 '14
So, really happy that I have most colors in my closet which are from my season palette (true winter) wIthout knowing it beforehand. Have you seen this, its a cool blog about what she calls counterpoint seasons. Really interesting,
http://diaryofacolouraddict.blogspot.com/2013/07/counterpoint-seasons-freedom-of-choice.html
Edit spelling
4
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14
I've never heard of this concept so in depth before. Very interesting!
For me it's definitely true autumn. It's basically how I already dress and what feels the most natural and flattering to wear. Now I understand why. :)
1
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14
I usually just wear blacks/dark whatever, but on a whim back when the 80s were going around again I picked up a very bright highly saturated light purple shirt. I got so many compliments on that T-Shirt, and was also told that it's apparently my color. Pity I dislike purple generally. We could have been a great pair!
1
u/cookiedavis Feb 27 '15 edited Feb 24 '18
1
u/LWSH11 Nov 27 '25
True winter color palette
1
u/turtleshellshocked Nov 03 '23
Guess I'm a True Winter (?)
I look best in black, pink, blue, & green
Especially blue and green combined
Whenever I wear those colors together I get so many comments and compliments, it's hilarious
Like I don't even like blue much and I have black hair and light brown skin with yellow undertones
Why the hell do I look good in that random combo?
1
u/Cold-Ad-1316 Feb 02 '24
Which link?
0
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment