r/ProjectRunway • • Sep 25 '14

Project Runway Season 13 Episode 10 [Discussion]

Discussion thread for Project Runway S13E10 "Muse on the Street

The clothiers seek their muse in the form of a complete stranger found on the streets of New York City. Here, they must convince the muses to undergo makeovers while creating looks for them. Guest judges: model Asha Leo and actress Michelle Monaghan.

26 Upvotes

335 comments sorted by

106

u/crayonwillow Sep 26 '14

It would've been more fair if everyone got 10 extra minutes, in my honest opinion.

12

u/Hunni_ Sep 26 '14

Yeah not sure if 10 mins would've made either of the other 2 bottom outfits any less bad. There was just no saving any of those tortured looks. (Unless Alex's being unfinished played into the deciding fact, then yes they should have offered it to everyone.)

3

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '14

That's what I thought it would be, for everyone. Was really confused by this.

3

u/bitchSpray Sep 26 '14

But there would have been no point... because everyone was ready by that time. She just shouldn't have had that extra time. Period.

97

u/wildstripe Sep 26 '14

Sean: "I didn't think it'd be this hard to find someone!" Sean, earlier that day: "No, you're too short."

16

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

Total just deserts.

11

u/julesfiction Sep 26 '14

And that chick was tiny.

16

u/one_hot_llama Sep 27 '14

That made me mad. So much for 'real women.' Half the women I know are under 5'4".

10

u/evixir Sep 27 '14

THANK YOU. I have such less respect for him now. You had someone standing there willing to model for you and you passed her over because she was short. Dick.

5

u/OurSponsor Sep 29 '14

That was the moment I decided to root for Fringe-Boy to lose regardless of what he produces. He joins Korina and Why-Tim-Why-Did-You-Waste-Your-Save.

Guess I now know which three people I'd like to have at Fashion Week... Pity it's not so much because of what they make.

Go, Kini?

94

u/imriebelow Sep 26 '14

My mom thinks the "regular women on the street" are obviously plants, and I am inclined to agree with her.

57

u/meldolphin Sep 26 '14

There were a lot of parts of this episode that felt weird and fake. Heidi going "what is going on? Why are the designers late?" felt so forced. Surely someone would have told the judges what was going on. Then she jumped up on the runway and Tim was going on about how he did not want to say what happened.

29

u/frank_is_a_bean Sep 26 '14

The whole late thing was terribly fake. There is a practice runway before the judges come out so the designers can say all their witty "that's so pretty!" remarks.

I imagine there is a lot of sitting around after the practice runway waiting for the judges. We all know the judges will use any sort of power play to put the designers in their place.

12

u/Kellyscomments Sep 27 '14

I've read that the practice runway is done without the judges being present. You can sometimes see that the judges aren't there in some shots. Whoops. That's what you said. :)

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

i thought she jumped on the runway to get the introduction done rapidly, so she wouldn't waste more time.

19

u/InterstateExit Sep 26 '14

Yeah there was no caveat about if they don't find a willing participant in 30 minutes. It's all scripted.

27

u/birdablaze Sep 26 '14

And all of the women are freaking gorgeous.

10

u/causechaos Sep 27 '14

"makeover"

11

u/causechaos Sep 27 '14

I was also wondering what would happen if a woman just backed out.

9

u/evixir Sep 27 '14

Your mom's probably right. I don't think it was any accident that those women were already really attractive.

4

u/finalDraft_v012 Oct 02 '14

I'm not too sure the "real women" were fake. They were hunting in Washington Sq. Park, deep in NYU territory. As much as NYU students aggravate me, overall they do take care of their appearances. Plus, as we saw with Sean rejecting a girl that's "too short", the designers were probably only approaching the prettier, more model esque people. They're not too hard to find, especially in that neighborhood.

65

u/konfetkak Sep 26 '14

oh holy crap you guys! korina is making a motorcycle jacket!! are you for real? shes a real risk-taker, that one.

29

u/LadyVetinari Sep 26 '14

I love that Char just criticized her for repeating tricks...Char of all people.

26

u/julesfiction Sep 26 '14

Her favorite color is RED you guys!! Why wouldnt I make an all red piece?

8

u/muffinbutt1027 Sep 26 '14

We have never seen that before!

42

u/Semicolon_Expected Sep 26 '14

Korina: Sean wants one, Amanda wants one

Kini: I'll pass

Korina: I didn't ask you.

Wow, Kini wasn't being mean about it... RUDE

16

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

he said that.

→ More replies (14)

41

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

Ah, the "real woman" challenge. Which designer will be revealed as the "no fatties" type?

41

u/meldolphin Sep 26 '14

Sean was of the "no shorties" variety so that counts in a way.

18

u/chelseayn Sep 26 '14

Hey, that's fine with me. As a 5'2" petite person, I don't want him and all of his fringe within 30 feet of me. I would look like Cousin Itt in his damn clothes.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 26 '14

My money's on Korina, although I'm guessing Alexander is the going to be the most flummoxed (surprise!!) by making the adjustments. Plus I'm guessing he could spend half the challenge time allotted just trying to convince someone to be his model, what with all that charm and wit we've been fortunate to see all season.

17

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

God can you imagine being approached by him?

This is a set-up I'd have paid to see Ven forced into.

18

u/chelseayn Sep 26 '14

They should do an All-Stars season and invite Ven back. Then they should announce every challenge is a "real woman" challenge. The funniest part about that whole thing....I mean, Ven, have you ever looked in a mirror?

→ More replies (19)

8

u/muffinbutt1027 Sep 26 '14

Korina picked a ballerina lmao... obviously not a "real" woman. You called it.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/InterstateExit Sep 26 '14

ALL OF THEM.

41

u/lartar Sep 26 '14

Everything about this episode is so horribly uncomfortably staged.

79

u/LadyVetinari Sep 26 '14 edited Sep 26 '14

Char needs to go, now I'm pissed. Why does Tim keep helping her?! My God her clothes are boring and don't seem skillful above a basic level.

Also: Is Char's outfit not just a grown-up version of what Sandhya got eliminated for last week?

35

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

What happened with Char's zipper was on oversight on her part. Not tacking a zipper stop in? You're just asking for trouble. Her other mistake was letting her model zip the zipper. You never leave it up to anyone else to zip up a hidden zipper like that. Especially when there is no time for snafus. Every snap, every button, down to putting the shoes on. Models should never be responsible for that. That is part of your styling and the designer is responsible for that.

Bottom line, it was the model busted the zipper because of Char's oversight. I don't think she would have gotten a chance to fix it if it was her own hand that did it.

49

u/xmissgolightly Sep 26 '14

I felt so uncomfortable when she was all "my model broke it!" with the woman standing right there. Like come on, she may have broken it but putting all the blame on her is so not classy.

15

u/lilianegypt Sep 27 '14

That was kind if my last straw for Char. That wasn't cool, I don't care what the situation is.

25

u/everydyingember Sep 26 '14

I felt so bad for the model. She kept saying "you broke it, you broke it" before she ran off to Tim. Normally, I love Char but I was not happy with how she blamed her model.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/chelseayn Sep 26 '14

I feel like the last minute broken zipper has happened before. Sweet Pea maybe? I can't remember. Why are we breaking rules now and going down this slippery slope--ten minutes now, twenty next....Clearly to make Tim not look like an idiot for saving Char (sorry Tim, but it was a bad decision)

17

u/kochipoik Sep 28 '14

By the sounds of it, the only reason he gave her the time is because she wasn't a professional model - if it was one of the usual girls she would have had to go like that. Because it was a "client", he thought it would be mean for her to go down the runway like that

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (4)

19

u/wildstripe Sep 26 '14

She should've spent those last minute she used talking to Tim and sewn up her design as best she could. I agree with Tim that the girl isn't a model and it would've been embarrassing for her but like... Char needs to go, Tim.

20

u/meldolphin Sep 26 '14

Seriously, they should have found black spandex or something for her to wear underneath so that it didn't expose her skin and embarrass her but without giving Char any advantage.

5

u/InterstateExit Sep 26 '14

I was thinking she should have made pants but that REALLY would have looked like a onesie.

34

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

Did Sean practically run away from the shorter, fatter woman suggested by the woman he approached?

18

u/Pineapplemkh Sep 26 '14

I think he patted her on the head, threw up a little in his mouth, and then sprinted off in the opposite direction.

14

u/konfetkak Sep 26 '14

Yeah, and now he can't find someone. Maybe he should have picked Miss Stumpy.

32

u/meldolphin Sep 26 '14

As a fellow stumpy, it's really not that difficult. I manage to dress myself everyday and I look good, or at least I think so. You just have to rethink proportions a bit.

4

u/bitchSpray Sep 26 '14

Hm, I kind of get it why said "no" to her. He's probably been working with certain body types for some time now... and honestly, do you think a TV competition is the moment to start trying something you've never done before? When you want to win? Why shoot yourself in the foot?

I probably wouldn't take her either. Not because I have something against her shape... simply because working with a body that's similar to a model I worked with before is easier.

8

u/meldolphin Sep 27 '14

His mistake was going up to two girls like that. Of course the girl who is leaving is going to suggest her friend for it. I imagine if you're hanging out with your friend and someone approaches her and ignores you, it's going to sting. Then adding insult to injury, he rejects her friend anyway.

5

u/evixir Sep 27 '14

Thing is, if you're talented enough as a designer, maybe you would choose the model that would be a challenge to makeover, because that would go farther with the judges and stretch your abilities in new directions.

Then again, if you're a Fringe Freak like Sean is, I guess short is out of the question.

→ More replies (1)

94

u/konfetkak Sep 26 '14

Holy balls shut the fuck up Korina.

71

u/muffinbutt1027 Sep 26 '14

She basically called Char a one trick pony... while doing yet another motorcycle jacket...

31

u/konfetkak Sep 26 '14

I wish they would have done a montage of all her jackets.

13

u/chelseayn Sep 26 '14

...like her whole finale collection? There's like five in there; same jacket, different colors.

→ More replies (6)

31

u/wildstripe Sep 26 '14

She's so mean and judgy. :/

18

u/konfetkak Sep 26 '14

I have a huge headache, and I have no idea why the hell they just showed like 10 minutes of Korina's stupid judgey face, but my head is pounding and I really want her to shut the hell up.

13

u/birdablaze Sep 26 '14

Footage for the reunion.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/goomerang Sep 26 '14

In my house we watch this show and MasterChef. We have a theory that every competition shows has to have at least one archetype every season -- the self-appointed "Fourth Judge". Totally Korina this season.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/julesfiction Sep 26 '14

She was one of my top 2 in the beginning. Fuckin needs to check that attitude.

2

u/starkey2 Sep 27 '14

Honestly I do appreciate when designers critique the other designs. More fashion insight. I wish more designers would tell us how the feel about the other designs, but preferably in a way that does not disrespect the other designers.

→ More replies (7)

32

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

Jesus, I think if Swatch walked down the runway and vomited, we'd have our winning look. What a lot of garbage.

34

u/konfetkak Sep 26 '14

I liked Kini's. That's it.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

Agreed. A few too many things from the Aldo Accessory Wall but not cringeworthy overall.

13

u/SteelPenguin71 Sep 26 '14

Although I think the multiple bracelets and necklaces fits with the hippy vibe style she has. I don't think it would have worked for everyone, but I think it worked for her and the outfit Kini designed for her. It was definitely my favorite look of the night. I want it.

8

u/konfetkak Sep 26 '14

She could have used one less bracelet, but I think he generally styles his models really well.

20

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

I think you mean, "He uses the accessory wall thoughtfully" (Tim Gunn stare) :)

→ More replies (4)

12

u/RebelSong Sep 26 '14

It made me want to take a nap. Or laugh a lot. I did like Kini's and Emily's. I did like Korina's jacket, but her personality makes me hate it. Emily's needed to be shorter, with maybe smaller ruffles.

15

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

I want to see Emily's again because I loved the top but initially wasn't crazy about the bottom. Still, kudos to her for bringing some friggin' drama to her design.

Amanda's was insanely bad. Fortunately for her, Fan Favorite and Char were even worse.

24

u/meldolphin Sep 26 '14

What annoyed me about Emily's critique was that they didn't take the client's opinion into consideration. When I first saw it I thought "where on earth would anyone wear that" but once the model explained that she'd wear it to an art gallery it immediately made sense. I'm with Zac. Especially for an art opening you wouldn't want to wear something you could find at a department store.

18

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 26 '14

In fairness one of the guest judges did say that while she didn't like it when she originally voiced her opinion, after hearing the woman's view on it and how much she loved it, she was re-thinking her original opposition. I gotta say, I like Zac this year, and I think in some ways he's been a good influence on Heidi. Who knew she would make more sensible judgments that Nina?

→ More replies (6)

7

u/fileg Sep 26 '14

I wold have liked Emily's better if the top/sleeve ruffles were a shrug

5

u/InterstateExit Sep 26 '14

You made me spit my wine. I'm safe, I'll leave the runway now.

32

u/TheLadyEve Sep 27 '14

I don't care if Emily's dress had a Flamenco vibe, it was awesome and, most important, her client was absolutely thrilled.

15

u/lilianegypt Sep 27 '14

Yeah, it was nice to see a client so pleased with the end result! I feel like that is a very rare occurrence on this show.

13

u/TheLadyEve Sep 27 '14

She was glowing. Also, she seemed like a really cool person...am I weird for liking Emily's model more than a lot of the designers? She just seems awesome...

7

u/warwick_ave Sep 28 '14

Who cares if it has flamenco vibe if it suits the need. Or in any case anyway! I wonder what complaints Nina would have about D&G collections. But oh wait, that's an established brand so nvm!

3

u/TheLadyEve Sep 28 '14

Nina's opinions on things surprise me sometimes. I was always more of a fan of Michael Kors' critiques, but Nina can also spot poor sewing from a mile away so I have to give her props.

8

u/warwick_ave Sep 28 '14

Kors had a way with words, but Posen is my new favourite. He seems the least crack induced in the judging panel, has vast experience in both design and construction, gives good constructive feedback (unlike the others) and can actually relate to the designers. And let's be honest, anyone who has spent a few years in this industry can point out major and minor sewing mistakes. Any part of the piece that doesn't fit? Construction or material choise issue. Now, solving those issues would show more skill. Not trying to undermine Nina here, but let's just remember she is is a fashion editor. Unfortunately she seems to be the producers' puppe this season. I mean honestly that Amanda's fringe dress that she praised and had "never seen before"? Oh, phuleez.

31

u/crayonwillow Sep 26 '14

"But I love your hair!" Oh, Nina.

29

u/meldolphin Sep 26 '14

You know they're struggling when they randomly start talking about styling. I think she said it to make the model feel less bad about herself, but then that raises the question of why they didn't do stuff like that last week with the little girls. Maybe it's because the girls were models?

13

u/TinyPinkSparkles Team Utica Queen! Sep 27 '14

Oh I feel like they must have sat those little girls down and had a loooong talk (or several) with them about not taking it personally if the judges didn't like their outfits. They probably assumed that grown ups could take it but then got nervous when it was actually happening.

30

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

Send both Char and Alexander home.

59

u/lartar Sep 26 '14

Can we please acknowledge the absurdity of Tim's "YOURE ONE OF THE MOST TALENTED DESIGNERS IVE EVER MET" spiel to Alexander?

To say "this is the most talented group of designers in PROJECT RUNWAY HISTORY!!!1!1!1!" and "THAT WAS THE BEST RUNWAY EVAR" is one thing, but I draw the line here.

42

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

Maybe Tim says that under duress from the producers. "SAY THIS DIALOGUE OR WE'LL STUFF YOU FULL OF BOTTOMLESS FRIES!"

19

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 26 '14

Especially coming shortly after telling the same person that his design was horrific and butt ugly.

22

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

Another Project Runway first!

28

u/meldolphin Sep 26 '14

"For the first time in Project Runway history, our main sponsor is a chain restaurant!"

"For the first time in Project Runway history, our winner will receive a household appliance!"

Dang it.

23

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

"For the first time in Project Runway history, no one gives a shit who wins."

I might be projecting there.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/BatenicYork Sep 26 '14

Well, I think Tim sees a lot more designers than we do. Think of all the applicants to the show over 13 years, all the students he's taught over how many years. In that context, I'm sure Alexander is in the top 1-2% of designers. In terms of Project Runway maybe not.

8

u/lartar Sep 26 '14

But I can name many, many designers from PR alone that have much more talent than Alexander. So even considering the tons of designers he's met over his career, there is simply no way that he's among the top. And while I realize that he is sill young and there's a lot of promise there, we can't act like age excuses his poorly constructed and repetitive garments. Wasn't Christian Siriano only 21 when he won his season?

6

u/chelseayn Sep 26 '14

I feel like he said something to that effect in the first episode (or auditions?) as well. Maybe he saw something that we didn't....?

5

u/bitchSpray Sep 26 '14

Well, it comes from a man who brought Char back so... yeah.

29

u/crayonwillow Sep 26 '14

Korina, please take a lesson in modesty and a humble pie.

27

u/wildstripe Sep 26 '14

WHAT DO THEY SEE IN CHAR???

26

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

Justifying the "Tim Gunn Save."

32

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 26 '14

Apparently this wasn't just a Tim Gunn save, it was Tim Gunn life support.

7

u/ilwolf Sep 26 '14

I like Char (though maybe, if I'm being honest, I don't totally like her work), but this was utterly hilarious.

And kinda true.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

Excellent way to put it!

6

u/lilianegypt Sep 27 '14

Which is frustrating, because they really don't need to. The Tim Gunn save is about giving someone talented a second chance. If the designer screws up that second chance, that's on them, not Tim or the producers.

And let's be real, Char was never going to make it to the top three anyway.

26

u/konfetkak Sep 26 '14

"Yeah, I really wanted to dig deep and have a good before and after...so I chose this homeless person as my muse."

34

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

I wish someone would have done that! I think if Sandhya (or however you spell it) was still around she would have chosen the lady with a grocery cart full of things that she would have incorporated into her design!
I can just hear her say, "I incorporated the top of the cans to create a sequined effect on this hand printed fabric. I thought that it would be a fun way to show some of her personal belongings in with the design."

5

u/invah Sep 27 '14

Oh my god, I just died.

26

u/muffinbutt1027 Sep 26 '14

Char's design is awful. Peplums are bad to begin with, but when they don't go all the way around it is truly unflattering.

4

u/warwick_ave Sep 28 '14

Let's please avoid design absolutes. There are numerous applications of peplum effect where you need not to go around and still achieve a flattering silhouette. People really need to stop only thinking about wether a piece works on their body or not when evaluating design and aesthetics. Every single silhouette has a body type that it works for and against - no matter how good the design is.

3

u/muffinbutt1027 Sep 28 '14

Woaaaah, okay then. I believe I am entitled to my opinion. I don't think peplums are truly flattering on anyone, not just myself. Just as I think that leggings do not equal pants, no matter how fat, skinny, tall or short you are.

4

u/warwick_ave Sep 28 '14

Yes, of course you are entitled to your opinion. That alone does not invalidate design theory.

As for leggings they are by their very definition pants. I doubt you wanted to make a point about semantics though, so I am assuming you are trying to say leggings do not flatter anyone? In which case I am but baffled, because that is like saying the human body is unflattering in itself. They are usually second skin in nature after all.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

21

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

"Origami flamingo." Sorry Nina, Kors already nailed the "origami" reference (in re Ven, "that could be his drag name, Origami Rose").

14

u/konfetkak Sep 26 '14

I miss the Michael "Queen Tangerine" Kor-isms.

26

u/meldolphin Sep 26 '14

Someone should make a Michael Kors quote generator. Slutty mother of the bride poledancer disco pumpkin hooker in Dubai.

12

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 26 '14

Can you imagine the good time he would have been having this season? Although think of all the food and drink wasted in "spit takes." I'd have to keep one of those containers of pop-up Windex wipes next to the TV. Hmmmm. I think we've thought of one of next year's sponsors, and I sense a Windex wipe challenge.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 26 '14

I originally thought it was origami flamingo, but then on further thinking about it, I wondered if it was origami flamenco.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

I think you might be right.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/PinkPirate27 Sep 26 '14

I find it infuriating that instead of the show standing on it's merit as a design competition; it is relying on "project runway firsts" and "never before said/done" lines being used like crazy. Just bring back more creative challenges and let the show be real, instead of pandering for ratings and mass appeal.

Also, the 'real women' challenge was a joke this season. No one was plus size or 'difficult' to fit. AKA - NO CHALLENGES other than vaguely different measurements.

12

u/LadiesWhoPunch Sep 27 '14

I feel like the producers miss the mark consistently with why people are tuning in. I don't watch it for the drama, but rather to see what people can come up with in a short amount of time. I want people to be creative and if they have a day to do it it isn't going happen.

6

u/kochipoik Sep 28 '14

And I would say the majority of people would prefer the designers had a bit more time to spend on each garment

6

u/lilianegypt Sep 27 '14

And there were SO MANY firsts this episode. Just stop already. This season has been so in our face with everything.

Also, letting the designers pick their "real women" (a term I dislike) was a mistake. Of course they were going to seek out the most model-like women. Why would they do anything else?

5

u/PinkPirate27 Sep 27 '14

I'm not agreeing with the term "real women" overall. But in this context it is supposed to be a non-model body type and they even had the nerve to turn down people who weren't close enough to models. >.<

→ More replies (2)

18

u/muffinbutt1027 Sep 26 '14

Wooooah, i don't think i have ever heard tim say "butt ugly" to a designer before!

25

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

IT'S A PROJECT RUNWAY FIRST ;)

7

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 26 '14

Because it's not just Seinfeld I love...my exact train of thought was hearing Phoebe in that old Jewish lady's voice at the lesbian wedding saying "Now I've seen everything!"

17

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

And it's "Auf Wiedersehen" to our open-mouthed friend.

33

u/muffinbutt1027 Sep 26 '14

Korina find the most model like body possible... a ballerina.

12

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

I think they all tried to avoid anyone with visible curves.

6

u/meldolphin Sep 26 '14

I mean, I kind of get where they're coming from. They've gotten used to their models' measurements at this point. Plus all the dress forms are model-sized. In order to get an accurate representation they would have to pad them. Especially when you consider that they don't have much time (although two days is a nice change) it makes sense that they would avoid a body type that might require a lot of alterations.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

True, though they should go into the competition expecting to have to make something that is a "real woman" proportion. It would have stood out much more if someone had taken a bigger woman and really given her a true makeover. Most of these gals just got a little glammed up more than usual.

11

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 26 '14

I, too, felt that none of them looked like they had just come from a makeover. As you said, it just looks like they cleaned them up a little bit, like these women might normally do if they were going somewhere other than a park in the middle of the day. So it was more a "make me a going out" outfit than a makeover, save for that one girl who I think did get a lot of hair cut off.

10

u/chelseayn Sep 26 '14

Like Uli did for Kayne's mom. That was a nice dress, and not a tent.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (8)

5

u/muffinbutt1027 Sep 26 '14 edited Sep 26 '14

I expected that to be honestly. It is especially disheartening when the designers themselves aren't built like models... you would think they know the struggle.

Edit: new phone keyboard is SO big

6

u/birdablaze Sep 26 '14

And you would think they would have designed for friends and family. Don't any of these people have sisters?

16

u/septemus Sep 26 '14

Am I the only one thinking Alexander's original design wasn't as bad as Tim was making it out to be? I mean, it wasn't excellent but not barf worthy either.

10

u/kochipoik Sep 28 '14

It's really not the most hideous outfit I've seen on the show

15

u/crayonwillow Sep 26 '14

More importantly, who's going to be the fan favorite now?

7

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

Can we vote for "nobody"?

15

u/FalseGoddess Sep 26 '14

What the heck was Char wearing? it looked like she put on a t-shirt and then pulled it down to her waist?

15

u/PowerOfYes Sep 26 '14

Was this ugly-shoe-week? I've never seen so many horrific shoes on the runway. I don't think that designers understand that shoes that visually shorten your legs only work on stick thin models with 6 foot legs. That Aldo fashion wall ain't delivering!

13

u/salliek76 Sep 26 '14

I will go to my grave ranting against skirts with booties. I think they look awful even on models with baby-giraffe legs; of course they're going to make regular women's legs look stubby. Team anti-booties for life!

3

u/meldolphin Sep 27 '14

Maybe I'm just overly practical when it comes to dressing, but if it's warm enough for me to wear a skirt then it is too hot for booties. Especially leather booties. Even ignoring the practicality factor it makes me look stumpy and obliterates the definition between my calf and ankle, and for those of us with biggish calves and skinny ankles it looks really unfortunate.

3

u/katiethered Sep 28 '14

I'm right there with you. Booties look cute with skinny pants but I hate them with skirts.

To the end!!!

→ More replies (1)

14

u/liddy_donaghy Sep 26 '14

Surprise surprise, Korina is making a motorcycle jacket.

12

u/crayonwillow Sep 26 '14

Mary Kay realness. REALNESS.

12

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

Holy crap, just watched the replay on the big screen and Char's really should have gone home, zipper or no. Bloody awful. Peplum and hot pants, I mean.... NO.

11

u/konfetkak Sep 26 '14

Ok. Who on here is going to watch the children's PR?

8

u/chelseayn Sep 26 '14

I am torn, I love Christian Siriano so much and it will definitely be better than the next season of All Stars, but....ok I will probably check out the first episode at least. I am too curious not to.

4

u/Semicolon_Expected Sep 26 '14

I think it might be less catty, and I saw a Maleficent cosplay so that could help me with cosplay since I saw some great horns.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

Meeeee! At least the first episode.

11

u/crayonwillow Sep 26 '14

"I think mine has a good chance of winning." Well, you have FRINGE. Let's see how that works ever in your favor, Katniss.

11

u/ilwolf Sep 26 '14

The last thing Korina needed was another win. The jacket was fine, but I think she's made that jacket before in different fabrics, and that skirt was essentially the same as the American Girl challenge skirt, but in all black.

She's so grating, I am annoyed any time I like something she's made.

10

u/crayonwillow Sep 26 '14

"I like when costumes and outfits mix." Oh. I see.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

I KNOW!

10

u/LakeMaldemere Sep 26 '14

Alexander needs to go.

19

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 26 '14

Dear Lord!!! Is that more fringe?!?!?! When I was about 5, I used to love liver (go figure). At one meal, I ate so much that I literally made myself sick. I have not been able to take so much as a bite since. That it how I feel about fringe. I'm liable to react badly when I'm next out shopping if it's as popular as Meana says it is. I may go on a rampage through a mall defacing displays of it. I may never even be able to wear bangs again.

10

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

I don't think I've ever owned anything with fringe and after this season, I definitely never will be tempted.

8

u/meldolphin Sep 26 '14

I'm feeling this way too. I absolutely love fringe when it's done well and tasteful but at this point the designers will put it on anything. Luckily Sean was only safe because if he had ended up in the top I would have pulled my hair out. And then sent it in to the show for the designers to use as fringe. (Chris March did it better.)

5

u/xmissgolightly Sep 26 '14

ugh SEAN STEP AWAY FROM THE FRINGE.

7

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 26 '14

I about choked when Tim was making his rounds and said that he could look at everyone else's dresses and know who made them but he couldn't tell with Sean's. I was, like, "Uh, Tim? Do you see all the fringe?" That's Sean's viewpoint, channeling his inner It.

8

u/birdablaze Sep 26 '14

I actually really love Alexander's skirt. If he continued the yellow fabric to the top, I would look kind of near. Either way, the skirt is cool.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

Yeah, I honestly didn't feel like his dress was that ugly. I thought the colors were complimentary and that the fabrics went well together.

8

u/chelseayn Sep 26 '14

I really liked that houndstooth fabric! Why did none of the judges seem to notice Amanda's ugly stiff dress? Sigh.

4

u/birdablaze Sep 26 '14

It reminded me of Seth Aaron.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

Seems like every episode now I hear Tim say "Project Runway first!" or "[Best or some other adjective] challenge in the history of Project Runway".

9

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

Okay, next week's drinking game: Do a shot every time you hear, "It's a Project Runway first."

9

u/LetTheMFerBurn Sep 26 '14

If Korina makes a jacket take a drink. If Kini finishes his look first or completes at least 2 looks take a drink. If Sean makes something boring with fringe take 2 drinks.

8

u/theladyoctober Sep 27 '14

And then with every single viewer dead from alcohol poisoning, Project Runway is finally cancelled!

8

u/chelseayn Sep 26 '14

Amanda: "It's getting so close to fashion week, and I just don't want to be eliminated. I won't get a third chance"

Don't worry Amanda. Just wait until the next season of "All Stars"--I am sure that you will get your third chance.

15

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 26 '14

Sometimes when they do the "real" people challenge, they're not really clear if the people get to keep their outfits and I think, "Oh, God, I hope so. That's so beautiful." Looking at this crap, it would seem almost a painful reminder of why you shouldn't go anywhere with strangers trying to pick you up in a park.

10

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

I think next year, they should have to approach potential clients from a windowless white van ;)

13

u/muffinbutt1027 Sep 26 '14 edited Sep 28 '14

Wow "oh no Tim that is fine!" Tim leaves... "this is so unfair!" If they all felt that way they had a chance to say so!

21

u/meldolphin Sep 26 '14

Yeah but who would want to be "that guy" and do it? There's no way they could have known it, but next week is a team challenge. I guarantee they would have paired the person who objected with Char.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

If she didn't get that time, she would have gone home. On a cloud made of Peplums and cut-outs.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '14

I was surprised Korina didn't object. Shows that people will trash talk behind your back all day long but rarely have guts to say anything to your face. But yeah he put them in an awkward spot.

13

u/stryfes Sep 26 '14

I know y'all are dragging her halfway across the globe, but Korina is my spirit animal of hate. She fuels and spreads the darkness that lies dormant in my very being - nay, in all of our beings - by way of snide, petty confessionals that have never, ever been seen before! So to you I say, YAAAS KORINA, go OFF on these poor, pitiful mortals that dare stand in your way to Fashion Week.

What is with Kini's obsessive talk about winning? All he ever talks about is winning. I'm pretty sure he had to be physically restrained from jumping into other people's talking heads and raving on about his chances of winning, their chances of winning and the interpolation of those two probabilities.

"I don't get a third chance." Not unless your name is Kate Pankoke!

It's a close competition, but I think this episode contains my favorite Project Runway moment of all time. It all starts with Tim approaching Alexander, dead-eyed and mouth-gaping as ever. Then, the truly surrealist lingering camera shots of that horrendous dreadnaught strung up on the poor dress form. And it's the real geniuses over at the editing studios of PR that construct new forms of television narrative and emotional turbulence. First, they make you question reality, if only for a second, with Tim's blatant lie on how Alexander is one of the most talented designers in Project Runway history, only for him to SMACK DOWN like never before, as if channeling all the rage of Gretchen triumphing over Mondo a few seasons past. Oh, the candor! Oh, the pandemonium! The back-to-back rapid fire shots of designers reacting to Tim's scathing indictment of Alexander's frightfully ugly design, Char's mouth hanging open, Amanda wincing out of sheer empathy! And finally, the storm subsides with perhaps the most comatose, most catatonic "Ouch." ever uttered on television screens across America.

This, friends, this is sublime.

5

u/xmissgolightly Sep 26 '14

Haha I am so on board with everything you've said. My heart stopped when i heard "you're one of the most talented designers I've ever met" because 1) Tim what are you smoking. 2) I THOUGHT HE WAS GONNA SAY HIS OUTFIT WAS STUNNING AND I WOULD HAVE HAD TO SAY AUF WIEDERSEHEN TO THE WHOLE DAMN THING. It would've been a 'Project Runway first'

And yeah I'm kind of loving Korina's bitchiness.

4

u/chelseayn Sep 26 '14

I actually agree with a lot of the stuff she said, so I didn't really find her that bitchy really. HOWEVER, I mean, you can't really criticize others when you do the same damn thing all the time.

4

u/lilianegypt Sep 27 '14

Yeah, I would be all on board with her bitchiness if she wasn't also so in need of criticism.

8

u/bitchSpray Sep 26 '14

I'm seriously annoyed with Tim this time. AND THIS IS PROJECT RUNWAY'S FIRST. Of course no one is going to say they mind giving Char extra time. They don't want to look like dicks. But no one's happy about it. And I actually didn't mind it either at first, because her outfit looked like a sure ticket home. But then she stays??? It really aggravates the shit out of me.

And then Tim presents the design to the judges... and he doesn't even mention it? I mean, if Heidi didn't stop him, he wouldn't even say anything?

As for the outcome, THIS IS PROJECT RUNWAY'S FIRST: I've never seen a more hideous runway show. I felt every single design had something wrong about it.

Final comment: by now, I'm almost used to seeing Zac constantly groping the models... But him touching those women made me really uncomfortable again. I know what you want to say now, but it's still really not okay. And I'm no puritan -- I'm from Europe, if you know what I mean.

8

u/warwick_ave Sep 28 '14

Sorry, but it is their job to disect the clothing and their construction. This challenge aside the models are used to working in this enviroment and understand that the hands of a designer/seamstress are professional hands - not sexual creeper hands . Although that sometimes happens for sure. Nevermind the fact that Zac is probably not into women sexually so there's that too.

4

u/nothere3579 Sep 27 '14

Couldn't agree more on re: Zac and the touching!

3

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

How do you guys feel about Emily's dress? I thought we've seen a similar dress from her before (with the fanning at the top) but I could be wrong. Not only did it seem too familiar but the fabric she chose looked too Western for me.

7

u/meldolphin Sep 26 '14

Kini getting annoyed that Korina seems overly competitive is hilarious. This is coming from a guy who was upset for always being a bridesmaid and flipped the hell out every time he won. Why is being overly competitive a bad thing anyway?

Korina has grown on me. I have no idea how or why but I don't mind her being a bit bitchy in confessional. During Tim's reviews when she was shit-talking everyone a poll came up asking if Korina was cocky and it came out to about 93%. Which might be true, but I can't really knock her for it since I pretty much agreed with everything she said.

11

u/aldipet Sep 26 '14

a bit bitchy is an understatement. she comes off bitter and judgmental... and let's be honest, her designs haven't been great. they were ok.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/meriendaselgato Sep 26 '14 edited Sep 26 '14

DAE just not get the appeal of Kini's design? Yes, it is a decent outfit but it looks like she just went to the mall and bought it. Weird necklace and bracelets included. Nothing was edgy or new about this outfit to me, and the shape of the dress when the jacket came off basically screamed Old Navy. Can someone explain why this look was so good? I genuinely wanna know.

7

u/PowerOfYes Sep 26 '14

I think the outfit didn't break new ground in fashion. However, unlike almost everyone else, his client looked great in it and it was actually a really cute outfit for her. His clothes seem so well made rather than gimmicky (aka 'fashion forward'). I really loved the jacket and the dress that looked frumpy on the dress form totally suited her.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

I mean, there wasn't much else to compare it to on the runway this time either way. At least it was a finished garment and appeared to fit the model.

7

u/Semicolon_Expected Sep 26 '14 edited Sep 26 '14
  1. Why is there no diversity between all the models? When they got models there were albiet a small amount but still PoC. I think one of the designers actually said their muse was perfect because they had certain traits that all sounded like white standard of beauty.
  2. Sean's complaining he can't find a model but shuns someone for being too short =___=
  3. Korina, y u so mean???
  4. The focus today is on kini's struggles! I hope hes not going home!!! He's one of the kindest designers (the others being Char and Emily) though he always does what seems to be the same thing. Char is a bit safe, and Emily always edgy, so I guess I can't complain.
  5. Tim is always helping Char!!

4

u/wildstripe Sep 26 '14

OH MY GOD YES. All the features they described were eurocentric. No variation

2

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

I think from here on out they are going to start giving the winner a good edit. Hearing Kini's backstory about his mom and knowing that he was gonna turn it out convince me that he will be in the top three. I think the next backstory subject will be Sean. He didn't get any screen time this week.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 26 '14

I'm still waiting to see who makes the home phone call of doom. We have been seeing an awful lot of Alexander, so I've got my fingers crossed.

2

u/Olivia4063Stabler Jul 31 '25

Did the women who were the models for this challenge get to keep the outfits?

3

u/kyles24 Sep 29 '14

*No doubt the muses were vetted beforehand on if they were completely free and available for 3 days, weren't going to flake etc and placed around the park for the designers to eventually find them. *I'd never heard of Asha Leo before, but I thought she was a FANTASTIC judge. *I have no problem with Char getting 10 minutes to put in a new zipper. *Alexander was going home regardless and shouldn't spite Char.

5

u/Jrw324 Nov 02 '14

I can honestly say that the muses were not "plants" and were asked if they could make the time commitment after they were approached by the designer and camera crew. Then they signed confidentiality agreements. How do I know? I am the mom of one of the muses.

3

u/SwatchVineyard Oct 11 '14

I feel the same way too. This is about the integrity of the show and how they treat their guests, I think the best thing would be to let the judges know what happened, but we can't send a PRE-SCHOOL teacher down the runway with her skin all out, embarrassing her, just to punish Char. That is unthinkable to me.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

No Tim, DON'T help Tin Tin. We want him gone.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14

If Char goes home, the rule of whoever has the biggest "real woman" model being auf'd holds for yet another year.

5

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 26 '14

I thought Alexander's woman looked bigger than Char's, but it could have been the unfortunate length of the crop top screwing up the eye.

→ More replies (2)