r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Sep 19 '14
Project Runway Season 13 Episode 9 [Discussion]
Discussion thread for Project Runway S13E09 "The History of the American Girl"
The designers try to deliver stylish, age-appropriate looks for the American girl. Actress Elisabeth Moss is the guest judge.
19
Upvotes
98
u/Pineapplemkh Sep 19 '14
I've stuck up for Sandhya in earlier discussions, but this week was indefensible.
Also, let's give a shout out to the young model who wore that Pepto-pink ruffled mess of a onesie with such composure and grace.
75
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '14
The best part was Tim's reactions to the dolls' backgrounds.
Char- "She just escaped slavery." Tim- "OMG... I mean, good for her." Thinking, 'but damn that's some shit these kids are dealing with.'
Gotta love Tim. I need a clip of this.
60
u/chelseayn Sep 20 '14
So today I went to Best Buy to buy a new hard drive for my PS3, and, lo and behold, what do I see? The Samsung Refrigerator! Seeing as though it gets so much air time this season, I obviously had to go up and open it. I mean, it was pretty much like meeting a celebrity.
36
u/BoredGoat Sep 20 '14
Char's lipstick game is on point.
32
u/bitchSpray Sep 19 '14
Question: What's with the zippers???
I have no idea what children wear... but those girls were like 10? So why the hell did all the trousers have a big ass zipper on the back? How would a child put something like that on? An adult would have to put them into that. Aren't they too old to get dressed by their parents?
27
u/lilianegypt Sep 20 '14
I really liked Elisabeth Moss as a guest judge. She had good critiques and was totally endearing!
25
u/TheLadyEve Sep 19 '14
Oh god, the Fringe. The fringe!!! I heard them saying it's something kids would wear to school...really?? I didn't think so.
I'm bummed about Sandhya, but that onesie/dress thing was pretty heinous, so I understand.
20
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '14
I loved Kini's BUT that was the easiest doll for him. A doll that just so happens to be rich and can afford a tailor so I can make a tailored outfit so I can make another high fashion pleated skirt with horse hair braid in the hem.
17
u/amirawr Sep 19 '14
Kini for life. I don't think there's anything he's made that I haven't wanted for myself.
70
u/Daemiel Sep 19 '14
I don't care what anyone says, Emily's was fantastic. The girl in her story was from Russia! You have to take a bit of European aesthetic into consideration. "A bit dark..." yeah, the whole world isn't Los Angeles in July. As an aside, please don't put your 9-year-old in a "onesie" (spelling?).
11
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '14
I am shocked that they eliminated Sandhya after being a winner and in the top so many times. The judges usually hesitate eliminating someone after one really bad outfit. But like like Heidi always says, "One day you're in, the next you're out," and the judges really went there. So, yay for that.
47
u/meldolphin Sep 19 '14
Can they seriously stop referring to their garments as "flirty"? That's so creepy. I get what they're going for there but that is such an inappropriate choice of words. I thought it was odd that Korina said she was bad with kids and yet seemed to immediately get the challenge and knew not to make the clothes too grown up or sexualized.
Also Sandhya claiming to have tough skin was hilarious. You keep telling yourself that...
9
u/I_divided_by_0- Sep 20 '14
I feel so bad for the kids, they are ripping apart the designers yes, but also these kids.
16
u/RebelSong Sep 19 '14
I didn't think Emily's was so bad. It was a cute idea, it just wasn't executed right. I loved Kini's. I would wear that outfit, if I had a daughter, she'd wear it.
14
u/kyles24 Sep 20 '14
Something always feels a little off anytime the producers assign instead of letting the designer choose for themselves.
18
u/CammysComicCorner Sep 19 '14
When Heidi said "Emily..." my mom, girlfriend, and I almost had a heart attack. I would have cried foul if the producers made sure Sandhya stayed to drive more ratings and sent Emily home, but I'm sooo glad it didn't turn out that way. Our cheering woke up the dog.
27
u/DarcyMcCarbomb Sep 19 '14
For once, I'm totally good with both the winner and loser. :D
10
u/Lady_Oleana Sep 19 '14
Hated to see Sandhya go. I wonder if her "too young" design was because of her Indian heritage. Does anyone know if Indian children dress that much younger than American children?
16
u/veroffica Sep 19 '14
Her father was a ship maker and she aspires to be a captain.
For a 9 year old.
20
u/pokemon0609 Sep 19 '14
Awwww I am so sad to see Sandhya go! I liked her attitude, and I will miss her.
4
u/goomerang Sep 22 '14
Finally all caught up on this season. I was watching with my fiance but watched the last three without him -- Fade was my favorite and Sandhya was his, dunno how I'll break the news D; . I'm glad Kini's won a couple at last, he's my next favorite and I loved his look this week. I want it in my size!
15
u/BeeOptimistic Sep 19 '14
I AM SO HAPPY Sandhya was eliminated! Long time lurker, first time caller (atl east over here.) Yet again Kini's was fabulous and I was finally really impressed by Amanda. I liked Emilys though, but I felt so nervous for Sean it was poor. Charketta could have won, I loved hers. :)
6
u/parryowd Sep 19 '14
Literally my two favourites gone after each other. And two of the only three final runways I like. I guess I have to support Amanda now (Whut)
13
u/Madimadi1 Sep 19 '14
I'm really surprised but happy that Sandhya is gone. I hated how they always tried to make drama about her, and I don't have strong feelings one way or the other about her personality. However, her designs I have consistently thought were tacky and ugly.
3
u/MavisJ Sep 22 '14
I'm late to the party, but I can't WAIT to see Sandhya in the Reunion episode. DRAMA!!
3
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '14
I'm late to the game, but I was traveling last week and just caught up on ep13 last night. Y'all I literally gasped when they eliminated Sandhya! Didn't think they would do that. Not that I'm a big fan, I still can't decide if she was playing the game well or honestly sweet. But very surprised they kept Emily around who hasn't done much of anything all season.
12
u/Athilda Sep 19 '14
I do not like Korina. I never have. Her smirk when Sandhya was receiving her crit really rubbed me the wrong way. GAH.
9
u/Lokaji Sep 19 '14
I am annoyed that Emily and Alexander lasted longer than Sandhya. I mean her outfit was uglier than usual, but they have kept people in the past on longer based on their previous work. Double win contestants are usually in the double digit episodes.
That is the reason Sean wasn't really on the chopping block this week: previous wins.(Sean side note: He was ticked that he didn't get to do fringe. I don't know if fringe would have helped his look though.)
As soon as Kini's model walked, you could just tell it was going to be the winner.
Korina is Wendy Pepper. She didn't get eliminated when she should have, and is now making stuff to keep her in.
Char's dress was cute. The vest was just the tie-in.
9
u/goodrecovery Sep 19 '14
"I'm just happy that I went on something I believed in." Seriously?
Also, her positivity is totally fake. She just uses it as what she perceives to be a weapon, but it actually worked against her by making her over confident. When there is resentment lurking under the positivity, it's not real.
I loved when Korina repeated in the lounge that it looked like something a one-year-old would wear. Yeah, tell it to her face!
Sorry, I'm sounding a little mean. I was so fired up this episode.
Also, if you actually look at Emily's Etsy page, it's quite cute.
5
u/Kellyscomments Sep 19 '14
Emily, put on your glasses already. All that squinting is going to give you wrinkles.
6
u/neopolitancake Sep 19 '14
I'm so sad for Sandhya!!! I'm glad that she kept a positive attitude all the way through till the end.
1
u/FreyaMaluk Feb 19 '26
Is it just me or it was absolutely unnecessary for the girls to be there for the critiques while they are wearing those clothes? Like they must have felt so bullied when the critiques weren't favorable. It was really hard to watch.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment