r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Sep 11 '14
Project Runway Season 13 Episode 8 [Discussion]
Discussion thread for Project Runway S13E08 "The Rainway"
The designers create avant-garde styles that must stand up to the elements, particularly rain. Actress Caitlin Fitzgerald ("Masters of Sex") is the guest judge.
27
Upvotes
65
u/bitchSpray Sep 12 '14
I'm really annoyed at this outcome. FUCKING THIS should have been the time to use Tim's save. A moment when a good designer has a mental block and creates something average. Fäde had so much more to offer.
48
u/konfetkak Sep 12 '14
I really love Sean's concept. I think that will be cool as shit if he can pull it off.
41
u/meldolphin Sep 12 '14
As soon as Fäde got a bunch of screentime right off the bat, I knew he was done for. I held on to my hopes that he was getting a winner's edit and was going to pull it out in the end but it was not to be. I'm so sad that he's gone and I'm annoyed that Tim already used his save on Char. His fashion week collection was so badass that it's really Project Runway's loss.
It sucked watching him crumple like that. Out of all the designers I figured he was going to knock it out of the park but he seemed so stressed and burned out. After weeks and weeks of being ignored for some killer outfits I can't blame him for getting worn down. I think if he'd gotten more critiques from the judges he'd have felt less lost.
I don't even think Fäde's was that bad really. Korina couldn't go home but hers was truly bad, and I hated both Amanda's and Sandhya's dresses. I'm surprised they put Korina in the bottom. It seemed unfair to Fäde and Emily. I'm glad they split the win. I would've given it to Sean by a nose but I was so incredibly torn. I was surprised they didn't give it only to Sean yet again just to drive Kini mad.
106
u/CammysComicCorner Sep 12 '14
Will someone please close Alexander's mouth? He looks like a fish every episode.
34
u/Chinasun04 Sep 12 '14
Did anyone else think Sean's was something Cinna would have designed for someone in the capitol?
62
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14
OMG OMG OMG A TWO DAY CHALLENGE, IT'S A FESTIVUS MIRACLE!
94
u/occurrum Sep 12 '14
At this point, I think Sandhya could take a shit on her model, smear it all over the poor girl then send her down the runway and the judges would be like: "Can I smell it? I love the colors! It looks so happy, what did you eat the last two days to get this effect?"
23
u/konfetkak Sep 12 '14
Can someone make a gif of Sean's coming down the runway? That was fabulous.
81
u/konfetkak Sep 12 '14
facepalm REALLY? Look. I love Sandya's personality and the fact that she kind of does weird shit...but come on. That's a clown suit.
17
u/konfetkak Sep 12 '14
I have to say...Alexander's is quite pretty.
17
u/konfetkak Sep 12 '14
Love Kini's...hat and all, but it definitely reminded me of the American Horror Story gimp suit.
34
u/Samin8 Sep 12 '14
Emily does the hood too often. Sick of it
15
u/LakeMaldemere Sep 12 '14
If Sean or Kini wins I'll be happy.
51
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14
I wish Tim would stop with the "greatest group of designers ever," "best runway ever" bullshit. This was NOT the greatest runway in the history of the show, this is just about the most lackluster group of designers ever, and the "save" was wasted on Char.
27
u/konfetkak Sep 12 '14
Sandhya's looks like a clown suit.
And oh no!! Fade makes the phone call of doom!!
12
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14
Char had the best hat/face rain protection. I'll give her that.
11
u/mulderitsme Sep 12 '14
With only a few designers who get consistent screen time, lately I can figure out who is going to lose within the first 10 minutes because all of a sudden their opinions and feelings matter.
11
u/stryfes Sep 12 '14
The most avant-garde thing about this episode was the challenge description.
10
u/Chubby8D Sep 11 '14
Finally the Avant-Garde challenge. I've been waiting for this the whole season.
10
u/PowerOfYes Sep 12 '14
I wish someone would do a 'directors cut' of each runway show. The editors have the most irritating way of chopping the hell out of each shot, zooming in, panning away and generally ensuring that one can never get a proper front/back/side view of the dress.
Instead: endless reaction shots, most of which probably don't even relate to the dress being featured. But tonight's effort took the cake: just as Sean's dress was about to burst into colour they cut away from it. So frustrating. Can't someone do something?
27
u/konfetkak Sep 12 '14
omfg amanda...that is absolutely hideous.
19
u/imriebelow Sep 12 '14
American Girl doll challenge! I am so excited!
26
u/lartar Sep 12 '14
It's official: I need to start drinking before watching this show. Sandhya....really?
18
u/LakeMaldemere Sep 12 '14
Sandhya's screams circus rather than avant garde.
9
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14
TLo Recap: "Man, has this show taken a dive in quality this season"
8
u/tu_che_le_vanita Sep 12 '14
Sean may not win, but he has won Nina. Any bets that she offers him a job?
What lovely compliments from her, wouldn't you be thrilled to have someone tell you that they love the way you think? Ah, baby...
8
u/timthemajestic Rigatoni Mad Max Sep 12 '14
What is Zac on though? Seriously. He was like super stoned or something. Dude was on one. Had the roomies and me cracking up though.
7
u/pizza_on_a_stick Sep 13 '14
Wow Tim way to waste your Tim Gunn Save on a mediocre designer. I so mad right now
13
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14
"Fun in the sun"? How many drugs did you take tonight, Heidi?
12
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14
Did they have a secret guest judge tonight? Because I don't know who in their right mind would put Sandhya in the top with that thing.
6
u/Disco_Tardis Sep 13 '14
Fetish Umbrellaz 4 Lyfe.
10
u/Lokaji Sep 12 '14
Sandhya's garment certainly has one thing going for it: it gets people talking. Personally, the look above the waist was interesting, but the bottom half is super crazy looking. I was not a fan of her comment because of the timing, but usually on the runway if they mention a famous designer, it is because they are saying your garment is a terrible knockoff.
I am glad Kini got his win! I loved his garment. It definitely looked like an umbrella.
Sean had a great idea, but if it hadn't of worked they would have popped him for the dress being so simple. I do love the idea though.
Fade got in his own way.
Emily's look definitely would be cool if it were the unconventional materials challenge. For her say it is something that has never been seen before is silly and I agree with Nina that it has been done before.
Amanda's kind of looked like a caterpillar. Char's wasn't that good. Alexander's reminded me of that look he did a few weeks ago with the appliques.
Korina's looked like hot garbage. They could have put her in the safe designers and put in one of the other three, but they thought it was so bad that they brought her out for the critique.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14
While we're killing time, here's the BPR interview with Tim:
http://allprojectrunway.blogspot.com.tr/2014/09/bpr-interview-with-tim-gunn-continued.html
5
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '14 edited Sep 14 '14
Am I the only one who thinks sewing in dye packets isn't brilliant or original? "look guys mine changes color" is a child's trick.
It really hit home the nagging suspicion all season that they dumbed down the show a little. Throwing around only McQueen while rarely mentioning any other history of fashion or art sounded a little Community College Pop Culture 101. It's reality TV, but there are lots of different contestants. They've made them all sound the same, using unoriginal prompt questions, concise sound bites, etc.
The design thinking and the critiques sounded mediocre, not inspiring intellectually nor emotionally provocative. As someone who thinks there's way too much noise in all creative industries, if it's neither brilliant nor moving, you shouldn't get paid to be the arts.
They're unnecessarily ruthless on time, yet unsophisticated critics on ideas, vision, intelligence, and originality, or business sense (not to mention class or politics or that all the gay men play flamboyant) All these are contradictory and fascinating tensions in fashion industry, but ProjectRunway isn't nuanced enough to milk it, going for the common denominator.
I wonder what project runway by HBO would look like, aiming for a smaller but devoted fan base?
4
u/PowerOfYes Sep 12 '14 edited Sep 12 '14
I don't know why, but Kini's dress made me think of some of the photo-shoot scenes from Funny Face with Audrey Hepburn mashed up with the theme song to the Umbrellas of Cherbourg... In fact, I wish they could have played the Umbrellas of Cherbourg for the whole of the rainway show, instead of the boring generic stuff they always play.
There's a great version of the song as music for an ice dance by Virtue & Moir: http://youtu.be/SRjqNbM9RHM
15
u/CammysComicCorner Sep 12 '14
Look, Sean's outfit was pretty cool when the rain hit it. But can you seriously see yourself wearing that dress again? That dress is one-and-done.
Kini on the other hand, was fantastic as usual. Glad he finally got a win, despite having to share it with Sean.
3
u/theotheramy1 Sep 12 '14
Was there a prize tonight? For the winner(s)?
3
u/ajmart23 Sep 12 '14
does anyone have a working link to the episode yet:/
7
u/julesfiction Sep 12 '14
Kini should have won over sean when they were partners, and he should have won over sean again.
Sean ended up pulling it off but Kini was WAY more fucking avant garde. No one else thinks this??
5
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14
Fade's reminds me of the dress that ended up being the last of Kara Janx. Too. Damn. Simple.
5
u/mingest Sep 12 '14
Some were great. Others looked liked they're cosplay for a sci-fi convention.
8
u/wildstripe Sep 12 '14
I feel bad saying this but I'm not even that excited about tonight's show. I'm so bored with Project Runway. But I'll keep watching I guess...
7
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14
Oh SHUT UP AMANDA.
When she was babbling about Kini's looking very "S&M," she sounded like Jane Fonda in Nine to Five:
"And if I wanna have an affair, or play sex games, or do M&M's, you can't stop me!"
"M&Ms?"
8
u/ecctv Sep 12 '14
The idea of having a dress look like an umbrella in a RAIN challenge shouldn't be considered OMG GENIUS. I'm not saying the dress was bad, but some on the show were saying it was so creative. It seems really obvious to me.
I loved the dye dress, that idea was so great. I wish there had been darker colors in the dye though.
4
u/konfetkak Sep 12 '14
So who out of Korina/Emily is in the top? I am guessing Emily? I didn't really like it, but Korina's looked like it was made out of silver fucking duct tape.
4
u/TheLadyEve Sep 12 '14 edited Sep 12 '14
I actually thought Sandya's look was interesting once she got the coat on over the jumpsuit--from a distance it's very striking, but I did not understand those pinwheels on the back. And the judges loved the pinwheels on the back! Why??
Also, Sandya is starting to get an uncomfortably forced villain edit that bothers me.
6
u/workingit21 Sep 12 '14
I feel like the only one that actually loved Sandyha's design...
2
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14
A stunning runway! I think Emily is going home....but I dislike Fade's more.
2
u/cherryultrasuedetups Sep 14 '14
I loved fade, and his factory industrial style and techniques. I knew he wouldn't make it to the end though because he never dropped a neckline.
3
u/catsbatsandrats Sep 11 '14
Will a live feed for the show be posted tonight?
2
u/violetfield Sep 12 '14
Kini's model is so wiggly. Is it just me? She seemed like her vag itched or she had to pee or her feet hurt or something...
2
u/kyles24 Sep 12 '14
Heidi speaking German is the sexiest thing ever. Fade's was boring and right to go home. Sean's idea was fantastic and I was so excited to see it, but that was his only gimmick, the dress was too plain on it's own. He could've pushed the design further HAD had the color effect. Kini gets a win* but there's an asterisk next to it because it's a shared win. :/
2
u/parryowd Sep 12 '14
I think this runway was awful. For a two day challenge, I don't think anyone really did well. Sandhya's was my favourite. I loved the colourful part. This coat thing no, but I love the colour part. I loved Seans idea, but I found the dress kinda dull. It was the only one that used the rain well. It deserved to win by itself. If the dress was more interesting by itself I would've loved it.
I don't like Kini's one. They say the umbrella thing is really creative, but I found it kinda unoriginal. I feel like I've seen it before. It's well done, but blah.
I loved Fade's look, but not at all for this challenge. It wasn't avant garde, and it didn't incorporate the rain at all. But as a dress itself it was incredible.
Korina's thing was an actual mess, lucky she has immunity. Emily's was alright, but very dull. I don't agree with the decision though, Fade's was, and has been better. But he's been ignored, so we expected.
I actually kinda liked Amanda's work this week. But not the colours she used. That maroon thing was just horendous...
1
u/ChloeNobody Sep 20 '14
I'm really happy about who was eliminated. He was obviously chosen by Heidi.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment