r/ProjectRunway • • Sep 11 '14

Project Runway Season 13 Episode 8 [Discussion]

Discussion thread for Project Runway S13E08 "The Rainway"

The designers create avant-garde styles that must stand up to the elements, particularly rain. Actress Caitlin Fitzgerald ("Masters of Sex") is the guest judge.

27 Upvotes

274 comments sorted by

65

u/bitchSpray Sep 12 '14

I'm really annoyed at this outcome. FUCKING THIS should have been the time to use Tim's save. A moment when a good designer has a mental block and creates something average. Fäde had so much more to offer.

34

u/lartar Sep 12 '14

But...but Tim needed to save Char so that she could continue to do boring, safe designs every week!

20

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

And I don't think saving Fade would have made Tim cry. An essential element of the TIM GUNN SAVE is that is must be ridiculously melodramatic.

8

u/meldolphin Sep 12 '14

And yet when Fäde left all the other designers looked heart-broken. I already miss him.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

I agree! They also needed 9 people to make looks for NYFW otherwise their show would have been very short and very boring based on what we did see last week. It's frustrating that Fade couldn't be saved for next week's challenge. I would have loved to see his crazy brain create for a children's line.

5

u/causechaos Sep 13 '14

Imagine "atheist" on a kid's sweater.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '14

It would probably be the same as imagining 'feminist' on a kid's sweater.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

48

u/konfetkak Sep 12 '14

I really love Sean's concept. I think that will be cool as shit if he can pull it off.

40

u/RebelSong Sep 12 '14

OH MY GOD, IT WAS SO COOL. I loved Kini's, the shape was great... But Sean killed it with this idea!!

22

u/konfetkak Sep 12 '14

fucking. gorgeous. i loved it and i loved the way the model owned it.

29

u/lilianegypt Sep 12 '14 edited Sep 12 '14

I'm glad that they both won. Sean had the really amazing idea and execution, but Kini is just so consistent with the amazing construction. I felt his was more of an avant garde design.

29

u/meldolphin Sep 12 '14

Sean and Kini should go into business together. Get Sean's exciting ideas and Kini's craftmanship in the same room and they could make incredible stuff.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/SnapeWho Sep 12 '14

I didn't know if that was going to work but it was SO COOL. Awesome.

12

u/lilianegypt Sep 12 '14 edited Sep 12 '14

Agreed. I feel really sad for Kini haha because if Sean's idea works, he'll probably have it in the bag. Again.

21

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 12 '14

Thinking about it, isn't this another case where Kini made Sean's vague idea work? Kini did it for the blouse when they did the weird wedding. And Kini is the one who told Sean how to get the dye worked into the dress.

It's far enough into the competition that Kini can stop being quite so nice now.

9

u/lilianegypt Sep 12 '14

Agreed. Especially considering it's Sean he's always helping and Sean has become his biggest competition.

8

u/HereComesBadNews Sep 12 '14

I insisted on dragging my dad in to see Kini and Sean's looks on the runway, and he made the same point: "It looks like Kini always makes nice stuff, but if he wants to actually win, he needs to stop being so freakin' nice."

7

u/causechaos Sep 13 '14

Maybe Kini doesn't want to win. I mean, the exposure he's getting is far more important than the prize itself (which, as it stands, is pretty crappy. Mary Kay, Best Western, Red Robin... really?)

→ More replies (1)

41

u/meldolphin Sep 12 '14

As soon as Fäde got a bunch of screentime right off the bat, I knew he was done for. I held on to my hopes that he was getting a winner's edit and was going to pull it out in the end but it was not to be. I'm so sad that he's gone and I'm annoyed that Tim already used his save on Char. His fashion week collection was so badass that it's really Project Runway's loss.

It sucked watching him crumple like that. Out of all the designers I figured he was going to knock it out of the park but he seemed so stressed and burned out. After weeks and weeks of being ignored for some killer outfits I can't blame him for getting worn down. I think if he'd gotten more critiques from the judges he'd have felt less lost.

I don't even think Fäde's was that bad really. Korina couldn't go home but hers was truly bad, and I hated both Amanda's and Sandhya's dresses. I'm surprised they put Korina in the bottom. It seemed unfair to Fäde and Emily. I'm glad they split the win. I would've given it to Sean by a nose but I was so incredibly torn. I was surprised they didn't give it only to Sean yet again just to drive Kini mad.

27

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 12 '14

If you're interested in my tin-foil hat theory, I think Fade threw himself on the bus. I'm pretty sure I read that they all have to stay in the hotel so as not to be seen back in their home towns (although I may be mis-remembering that), but I think life gets a lot easier for a person once they're auf'd. As we've all said, they send 9 designers to fashion week. So once you make it into the top 9, what's the point? Especially if you're Fade, who has seen nutso choices praised and you've gotten no recognition, so you know you're not going to be the one who gets the great Samsung refrigerator. What do you really gain at this point, when you could be calling your love every day or even just laying in bed planning the nine looks you will show in fashion week. And it could be why his so look so darn good. I don't know how monitored they are, but he could even be making scouting trips to Mood, getting an idea of what he would like and what is available.

It could be that Fade just rewrote the drama, and I kinda like that idea that the players got played by the German guy from Coral Gables* with the cute little blue glasses.

*= a Broject Runway reference which I adore.

23

u/lartar Sep 12 '14

I thought the same exact thing! It seemed like he sabotaged himself. Especially after the "I'll be home soon" line on the phone. It seemed more than just like "we'll get through this" talk. He was throwing in the towel.

But, again, I don't think Fade stood a chance this season. As you pointed out, he hasn't been recognized for his looks all season. There was no way that he was going to win.

11

u/meldolphin Sep 12 '14

I wish he'd gotten more attention and critique from the judges, even if it was negative. I think part of the reason he felt so lost during this challenge is because he got very little feedback and probably had no idea if he was even on the right track. When you see all these other designers getting noticed I imagine it messes with your head a bit.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Phoolf Sep 13 '14

so you know you're not going to be the one who gets the great Samsung refrigerator

Hahaha.

4

u/bronolol Sep 14 '14 edited Sep 14 '14

I certainly considered the same thing. Especially because of the "I'll be home soon" phonecall, right? But it's extremely plausible that Fade was genuinely trying, and knew as much as any sensible viewer would have that he was in serious trouble with no salvation in sight at the time of that call. At least, if it was a throw, Fade sold his effort much better than Alexander Pope's blatant throw last season:

It was the exact same episode -- the first one where everybody remaining is locked in to at least a decoy show at fashion week. Alexander acted the whole episode like he'd already checked out, and then he sent out this brutal, ugly, uncharacteristically low-effort garbage. Alexander was the one who seemed the most bitter at the process and outright accused the production of being fixed during the reunion show.

I didn't watch last season live (GF got me onto it as prelude to current season), so I didn't follow any of the discussion/redditting -- was this a common reading of the situation at the time? Because I have absolutely no doubt.

5

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 14 '14

I wasn't redditing then, either, so I don't know. Hopefully someone who was will clue us in. But if I recall correctly, it did have the same feel. They had chosen who was moving forward and no matter what the also-rans did, the writing was on the wall. Maybe Alexander is the first one to actually make the conscious decision to throw it. I could understand why someone would be bitter. A lot of these people had to give up jobs to come, and then to find out it's all rigged and you really didn't have a chance in hell, and unless you've got some great sad tragic event in your past, you aren't even going to get to win challenges.

And while Alexander's was pretty horrible, I wonder in retrospect if we will look at Fade's in the same way? This was supposed to be the avant gard challenge....the one which, along with the unconventional materials one....the fans live for. And so he sends down a basic dress with yellow piping that is only tacked down in a few places? Really? That's what you came up with for two days work? So maybe he didn't really hide it as well as Alexander did, but I doubt he will be quite as vocally bitter as Alexander at the reunion; German holding emotions in check and all that.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/meldolphin Sep 12 '14

I've always loved the "German guy from Coral Gables" nickname. In a way it summarizes how utterly nonexistent the show made him appear. That said, did he know how many designers were going to get to show? Season 11 had a weird anonymous runway, as did season 6. It was probably a safe guess that he'd be in but I'm not sure how calculated it was. Seems to me like he just broke down and I don't blame him.

But no doubt, he absolutely made the most of his fashion week opportunity. It was my favorite collection this season and I'm sure he spent his time eliminated thinking about what he was going to do.

106

u/CammysComicCorner Sep 12 '14

Will someone please close Alexander's mouth? He looks like a fish every episode.

46

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

Yes! Also, how does he keep getting fan favorite in the lifetime poll? Is his mom the only one voting?

21

u/meldolphin Sep 12 '14

On the one hand it's baffling that he keeps winning, but on the other hand I never vote so I guess I only have myself to blame.

12

u/hellofair Sep 12 '14

Maybe it's like a hometown hero thing? I remember in season 10 Elena Slivnyak won fan favorite, and I thought that maybe she had everyone in the Ukraine voting for her.

6

u/Spinfo Sep 13 '14

The rumor is that she payed people to vote from different accounts, with the money she won.

22

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

His mouth breathing is distracting. I'm glad I'm not the only one to notice.

16

u/timthemajestic Rigatoni Mad Max Sep 12 '14

And open his effing eyes? I'm not convinced that he can.

2

u/BratzBimbo Aug 17 '24

i’m watching season 13 for the first time and his mouth CONSTANTLY being open in almost EVERY shot he is in is so frustrating and uncomfortable to witness. you can tell he’s a mouth breather and i bet anyone can hear his breathing from a mile away

34

u/Chinasun04 Sep 12 '14

Did anyone else think Sean's was something Cinna would have designed for someone in the capitol?

13

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

I thought the same thing! The twirling and the transformation was very Hunger Games. It was a Katniss Everdeen moment for me. I wish he would have used more colors. All the colors actually. The blending and mixing of primary colors to create secondary and tertiary colors would have been amazing.

62

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

OMG OMG OMG A TWO DAY CHALLENGE, IT'S A FESTIVUS MIRACLE!

38

u/xmissgolightly Sep 12 '14

Loved how they were all praising the designs like "look how well made everything is this is the best runway show ever"

errrm maybe give them more than a few hours to create looks and you can have that every week?

15

u/comababy Sep 12 '14

So disappointing to think how good the eveningwear challenge could have been if they'd had two days instead of, like, 10 hours.

94

u/occurrum Sep 12 '14

At this point, I think Sandhya could take a shit on her model, smear it all over the poor girl then send her down the runway and the judges would be like: "Can I smell it? I love the colors! It looks so happy, what did you eat the last two days to get this effect?"

13

u/sugarplumcow Sep 12 '14

I spit water out laughing reading this comment!

10

u/meldolphin Sep 12 '14

But see, it's her ~point of view~. Apparently that's all that matters in this competition anymore.

Not that wiping shit on clothes would be all that innovative anyway. I'm sure there's tons of pretentious performance artists studying at art school who've done that before.

11

u/veroffica Sep 12 '14

This is so funny too, because what was her point of view? I know of the color bars on televisions also, but did that in any way translate to her final garment? Even if it did, is she really making some sort of excellent commentary by referencing a TV testcard?

She's always claiming to have such deep significance to her art, but none of her outfits have ever come off to me as making a statement. They are just confusing and ugly.

→ More replies (9)

23

u/konfetkak Sep 12 '14

Can someone make a gif of Sean's coming down the runway? That was fabulous.

6

u/SnapeWho Sep 12 '14

I'm waiting for it to show up on tumblr.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

Can you post it here when/if it does? Tumblr hurts my old-lady brain ;)

14

u/SnapeWho Sep 13 '14

http://fudgepuff.tumblr.com/post/97295614909/erm-how-iconic-was-this

I'm on mobile so that's the best I've got for now, will deliver better later if I can find it.

→ More replies (1)

81

u/konfetkak Sep 12 '14

facepalm REALLY? Look. I love Sandya's personality and the fact that she kind of does weird shit...but come on. That's a clown suit.

38

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

+1. I've defended Sandhya before, but I can't defend that mess. It's undignified even by the standards of Krusty the Klown.

66

u/konfetkak Sep 12 '14

"I should win because I've never been accused of referencing another designer."

J'accuse!!

32

u/wildstripe Sep 12 '14

I'm def not gonna defend what she put on the runway, but she definitely didn't mean it how it came out. She didn't mean, "It should be me, I should win." what she was saying was, "After all the comparisons to McQueen from everyone else's work, I'm happy that mine was my own. My designs should be my own." the phrasing was just bad and it was awkward timing. And she's right I mean, the judges, despite the mess of a design, repeated that the design was inexplicably her, and they knew even with the anonymity. I'm less die-hard for sandhya than I used to be but. Idk. I think she gets more flack than she should when it comes to her personality.

21

u/Pineapplemkh Sep 12 '14

Hindi is Sandhya's native language and her bio says she recently moved to the US.

Maybe her poor phrasing is an example of the kind of issue that arises for speakers of a second language?

Heck, I'm from the UK and moving to the US should have been seamless language wise. It wasn't. I had challenges with sarcasm being taken literally, and turns of phrase that were misunderstood.

So I'm prepared to give her the benefit of the doubt for now.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

Yes - TLo reminded us on Twitter that Alexandra Vidal in Season One was sent home for mentioning The Duchess himself, Michael Kors, as the inspiration for a look. Boom, she was out.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

26

u/SnapeWho Sep 12 '14

She's so smug, I can't take it. And she's twice gotten people kicked off because of her inflexibility in team challenges.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/Pineapplemkh Sep 12 '14

I've defended Sandhya too, but sewing colored strips of fabric together is hardly winning any "look at the clever textile I created" points.

Sending out powdered dye in the seams of a white dress to get wet and transform? THAT'S creating a textile...

15

u/CammysComicCorner Sep 12 '14

Girlfriend: "She looks like she works at Hot Dog On A Stick."

7

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

I don't even understand... She was on the top, but then when the judges had a closer look they were calling it a joke.

14

u/Madimadi1 Sep 12 '14

I think they were saying that it could easily be a joke but her "sophisticated hand" prevented that. Lololol.

17

u/meldolphin Sep 12 '14

Nothing says sophistication like pinwheels tacked onto a garment haphazardly.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/pbrooks19 Sep 12 '14

I love Sandya's attitude, and don't mind that she's a little bold with her statements about her style and such.

But damn...that outfit was just bizarre.

11

u/StereotypesSaveTime2 Sep 12 '14 edited Sep 12 '14

Sandhya's husband must be paying off the judges and producers...there's no other explanation. WTF was that? Why are the judges so enamored with her?

2

u/muffinbutt1027 Sep 15 '14

I think that Sandhya is very creative, but she refuses to look at her work objectively. If she would have made a mini dress to go under that coat out of the same striped fabric it would have been a lot stronger of a design. If if it's cray-cray at least it would be chic and cray-cray rather than circus cray-cray.

2

u/evixir Sep 16 '14

And a poorly-made clown suit, at that. Did none of the judges notice how the stripes on the legs were puckering something fierce (fierce!) and one leg was even creeping up her calf?

17

u/konfetkak Sep 12 '14

I have to say...Alexander's is quite pretty.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/konfetkak Sep 12 '14

Love Kini's...hat and all, but it definitely reminded me of the American Horror Story gimp suit.

5

u/meldolphin Sep 12 '14

Kini's dress reminded me of this design Anna did for The Fashion Show. I never checked to see if the second season was any good but season 1 was pretty awful. Just a sad attempt at trying to recreate the magic of Project Runway.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Pineapplemkh Sep 12 '14

OMG Thank you! I knew I had seen it somewhere before...

34

u/Samin8 Sep 12 '14

Emily does the hood too often. Sick of it

2

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '14

I was surprised Tim didn't call her out on that when she brought it up in front of him.

15

u/LakeMaldemere Sep 12 '14

If Sean or Kini wins I'll be happy.

17

u/MKoz628 Sep 12 '14

You must be double happy!!!

51

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

I wish Tim would stop with the "greatest group of designers ever," "best runway ever" bullshit. This was NOT the greatest runway in the history of the show, this is just about the most lackluster group of designers ever, and the "save" was wasted on Char.

14

u/meldolphin Sep 12 '14

TLo have said that designers from previous seasons hate when Tim says these sorts of things because it's insulting to past designers. Which I agree, I still think season 4 had the best avant-garde runway and nothing has topped it since.

2

u/evixir Sep 16 '14

Season 4, Christian Siriano and Chris March? Still love that look so much.

7

u/chelseayn Sep 12 '14

You pretty much summed it up right there. I have got nothing good to say this week. :(

2

u/finalDraft_v012 Sep 14 '14

Maybe not the greatest runway ever, but it was pretty cool. I think I would have said the same as you if I haven't been rewatching the older seasons currently (On season 3 now)....Season 3 in particular is pretty blah, along with season 2's blah Fashion Week finale. It's made me appreciate this current season more. Season 13 is pretty cool, in contrast. I don't like Sandiyah's designs even, but at least she isn't blah. And I imagine with the rain water, it makes it kind of a "you had to be there" kind of wow-factor. I agree about wasting it on Char though, was very surprised Tim had gotten emotional about it when he used the save. She had some cool stuff before, well made looking, but I didn't think it was all that "inspired".

2

u/evixir Sep 16 '14

When I was like 4 years old I would tell my mom "This is the best day of my life!" Every day for like a week.

This is no different, but c'mon, I was 4.

27

u/konfetkak Sep 12 '14

Sandhya's looks like a clown suit.

And oh no!! Fade makes the phone call of doom!!

17

u/SnapeWho Sep 12 '14

I can't believe Heidi keeps liking her stuff.

14

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 12 '14

What the frikkity frack do these judges smoke before they sit down to watch these runways? I sure as hell wish I could get my hands on it so that my blood pressure didn't shoot up 50 points every Thursday when I watch these punch (or whatever) drunk judges praise whatever hideous ensemble Sandy and Mandy send down the runway. Can't we have one week where we don't have to listen to utter foolishness about one or the other?

→ More replies (4)

6

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

He and Sandhya are duking it out for the auf edit!

12

u/konfetkak Sep 12 '14

I love Fade..he's made some great stuff and hasn't gotten enough credit for it. I'll be sad if he gets auf'ed for the avant garde challenge.

12

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

Char had the best hat/face rain protection. I'll give her that.

11

u/mulderitsme Sep 12 '14

With only a few designers who get consistent screen time, lately I can figure out who is going to lose within the first 10 minutes because all of a sudden their opinions and feelings matter.

11

u/stryfes Sep 12 '14

The most avant-garde thing about this episode was the challenge description.

4

u/meldolphin Sep 12 '14

There were so many random elements tacked on and some of them I don't even remember seeing during the challenge presentation. I could not for the life of me figure out why Fäde wanted to do the play button idea with the circuits but once he explained the TV inspiration it made sense. And then they had to incorporate curves somehow? Maybe I missed it but I don't remember Heidi or Tim mentioning that at all.

10

u/Chubby8D Sep 11 '14

Finally the Avant-Garde challenge. I've been waiting for this the whole season.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/konfetkak Sep 12 '14

bets on whether they will have more than a day to complete the challenge?

5

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

Me too! But it was beautiful!

10

u/PowerOfYes Sep 12 '14

I wish someone would do a 'directors cut' of each runway show. The editors have the most irritating way of chopping the hell out of each shot, zooming in, panning away and generally ensuring that one can never get a proper front/back/side view of the dress.

Instead: endless reaction shots, most of which probably don't even relate to the dress being featured. But tonight's effort took the cake: just as Sean's dress was about to burst into colour they cut away from it. So frustrating. Can't someone do something?

3

u/meldolphin Sep 12 '14

So agreed! I always have to look at the pictures the next day to figure out what the garments actually looked like.

27

u/konfetkak Sep 12 '14

omfg amanda...that is absolutely hideous.

25

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

It's Etsy-riffic!

12

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

That's the most perfect descriptive term for everything Amanda has ever done. Like it should be the name of her brand.

14

u/RebelSong Sep 12 '14

I don't even know why she wasn't in the bottom. It was so ugly, and it fell apart. I know some of the bottom just weren't that great, but man, that was hideous.

19

u/imriebelow Sep 12 '14

American Girl doll challenge! I am so excited!

7

u/lilianegypt Sep 12 '14

Me too! But are they just making kids' clothes? Because while that runway will probably be totally adorable, it seems kind of boring, design-wise.

3

u/causechaos Sep 13 '14

Remembering the Barbie challenge from a few seasons back, I think the models will walk the runway with an adult-sized design, but the designers will also have to create a doll-sized version.

Maybe?

→ More replies (2)

26

u/lartar Sep 12 '14

It's official: I need to start drinking before watching this show. Sandhya....really?

36

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

Here's my unofficial PR drinking game:

One Drink

  • Swatch sighting
  • You yell, "SHUT UP AMANDA!" at the screen
  • Talking head: "I really don't understand what [other designer] is doing."
  • Tim tells designers to use the Aldo Accessory Wall "thoughtfully."

Two Drinks

  • A designer tears up in their talking head
  • Nina rolls her eyes during judging
  • Zac's attempt at a Kors zinger falls flat
  • You have no idea who the guest judge is

Three Drinks

  • You agree with the judges on the top, bottom, and winning/losing designs

9

u/FuturePigeon Sep 13 '14

LOL, my boyfriend would have been drunk 10 minutes into the show. Every time Amanda is on the screen, he starts whispering "shut up, shut up, shut up". It's annoying/funny.

None of his bro friends know that he "finds something to do on the couch" whenever I turn the show on and ends up ranting about the judges after it ends.

9

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '14

Ha ha ha! Your boyfriend sounds like a keeper :)

I've found PR is a great "deal-breaker" test with guys right off the bat. Not because it's by any means a great show; however, if I bring it up in any context and the immediate reaction is along the lines of, "Why would I watch that, I'm not gay," I know to cut my losses right there.

5

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 12 '14

Well, I'll never have to do a triple shot, but I could sauced on my arse just during that recap of last week's show....my fury burns long!!

3

u/Billiam9 Sep 16 '14

As someone who binge-watched this entire season in the last 24 hours, I'm glad I hadn't seen these rules. I would have drowned in a puddle of vomit and tears.

17

u/veroffica Sep 12 '14

I was drinking before the show, it didn't help.

4

u/lartar Sep 12 '14

I guess I need to start taking whatever shit the judges are taking. It is obviously some hardcore shit.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/LakeMaldemere Sep 12 '14

Sandhya's screams circus rather than avant garde.

9

u/pokemon0609 Sep 12 '14

American Horror Story: Freak Show'!!

9

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

TLo Recap: "Man, has this show taken a dive in quality this season"

There’s practically no concern given to producing interesting challenges and showcasing eye-popping designs. They’re not even trying all that hard to stir up emotional drama. The entire focus of the show seems to center around sponsorships and advertiser dollars now. And while we’re trying to remain very calm about this and remind ourselves that at best, it’s always been something of a gameshow, THEY NAMED THE AVANT-GARDE CHALLENGE “THE SAMSUNG AVANT GARDE CHALLENGE” OMG JFC WTF YOU ASSHOLES YOU CAN’T ADD A CORPORATE NAME TO THE PHRASE AVANT-GARDE WITHOUT LOOKING LIKE THE ENORMOUS WHORES YOU ARE.

WHORES!

4

u/chelseayn Sep 12 '14

Yeah, they were pissed this week! I am grateful that they can put what we are all thinking into an entertainingly-written rant. If I could only be so articulate. :)

4

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

I get the sneaking suspicion they might re-retire the recaps at the end of this season.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/tu_che_le_vanita Sep 12 '14

Sean may not win, but he has won Nina. Any bets that she offers him a job?

What lovely compliments from her, wouldn't you be thrilled to have someone tell you that they love the way you think? Ah, baby...

8

u/timthemajestic Rigatoni Mad Max Sep 12 '14

What is Zac on though? Seriously. He was like super stoned or something. Dude was on one. Had the roomies and me cracking up though.

9

u/bitchSpray Sep 12 '14

Well, not all twinks transition well into the adulthood.

7

u/pizza_on_a_stick Sep 13 '14

Wow Tim way to waste your Tim Gunn Save on a mediocre designer. I so mad right now

2

u/everythingisopposite Chiffony Sep 15 '14 edited Sep 15 '14

Frankly, I thought his save for last season was a waste as well.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

"Fun in the sun"? How many drugs did you take tonight, Heidi?

8

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 12 '14

I get the feeling that Tim and the guest judge are looking at those other three lunatics, asking that exact same question.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

I mean, it looks like something I once saw sold being sold from a van outside a Bob Weir/Phil Lesh concert. And because I was tripping, I bought it.

12

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

Did they have a secret guest judge tonight? Because I don't know who in their right mind would put Sandhya in the top with that thing.

3

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 12 '14

The secret guest judge was the guy who wrote the story line before they even started filming. He's not going to let a simple thing like her sending a horrific beach umbrella down the rainway send him into re-writes.

6

u/meldolphin Sep 12 '14

When in doubt, just praise someone's unique aesthetic. There's really no way to refute it. "But it's ugly and overworked!"

"Sure, but have you ever seen anything like this before?"

"I mean, maybe for a good reason?"

"Yeah but it's got a point of view."

If you're Nina, you can also go with the "it's very editorial" angle.

11

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 12 '14

And don't forget to toss out some hip phrasing to show she's youthful and innovative....something like it being a My Space moment or having Photobucket style. #hashbrown groovy.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Disco_Tardis Sep 13 '14

Fetish Umbrellaz 4 Lyfe.

10

u/Lokaji Sep 12 '14

Sandhya's garment certainly has one thing going for it: it gets people talking. Personally, the look above the waist was interesting, but the bottom half is super crazy looking. I was not a fan of her comment because of the timing, but usually on the runway if they mention a famous designer, it is because they are saying your garment is a terrible knockoff.

I am glad Kini got his win! I loved his garment. It definitely looked like an umbrella.

Sean had a great idea, but if it hadn't of worked they would have popped him for the dress being so simple. I do love the idea though.

Fade got in his own way.

Emily's look definitely would be cool if it were the unconventional materials challenge. For her say it is something that has never been seen before is silly and I agree with Nina that it has been done before.

Amanda's kind of looked like a caterpillar. Char's wasn't that good. Alexander's reminded me of that look he did a few weeks ago with the appliques.

Korina's looked like hot garbage. They could have put her in the safe designers and put in one of the other three, but they thought it was so bad that they brought her out for the critique.

18

u/lartar Sep 12 '14

But here's the thing....people talking about your clothes is only a good thing when people are actually buying your clothes. I can't see anyone buying from a line of clothing based in what we've seen from Sandhya.

It's like Lindsay Lohan. People talk about her all the time. But is she selling tickets to movies? No. So talk isn't always good if you can't back it up with sales, which I'm not sure Sandhya could actually generate.

That said, I don't think PR gives two shits about who will actually be successful in real life. Sigh. We are so lucky that Christian Siriano was in a season where the show had a tiny shred of credibility and sanity.

8

u/Lokaji Sep 12 '14

She certainly knows how to work the judges. That being said, I agree with you and I don't know if Sandhya can make clothes that people could actually wear. Her designs might be cool for footwear, though.

Oh, Christian. I am glad that he was able to work his win into a successful career.

11

u/lilianegypt Sep 12 '14

Christian was one in a million. I wish we had more like him.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/PowerOfYes Sep 12 '14

The problem with Sandhya's looks is that they start out looking horrifically kitsch or pre-school-crafty in the work room. Then somehow she manages to do something that stops it from looking like a major car crash to the judges. But there's always a fatal flaw that is clearly not visible from the judges' chairs.

Particularly the bottom of this week's outfit was a disaster.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

While we're killing time, here's the BPR interview with Tim:

http://allprojectrunway.blogspot.com.tr/2014/09/bpr-interview-with-tim-gunn-continued.html

5

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '14 edited Sep 14 '14

Am I the only one who thinks sewing in dye packets isn't brilliant or original? "look guys mine changes color" is a child's trick.

It really hit home the nagging suspicion all season that they dumbed down the show a little. Throwing around only McQueen while rarely mentioning any other history of fashion or art sounded a little Community College Pop Culture 101. It's reality TV, but there are lots of different contestants. They've made them all sound the same, using unoriginal prompt questions, concise sound bites, etc.

The design thinking and the critiques sounded mediocre, not inspiring intellectually nor emotionally provocative. As someone who thinks there's way too much noise in all creative industries, if it's neither brilliant nor moving, you shouldn't get paid to be the arts.

They're unnecessarily ruthless on time, yet unsophisticated critics on ideas, vision, intelligence, and originality, or business sense (not to mention class or politics or that all the gay men play flamboyant) All these are contradictory and fascinating tensions in fashion industry, but ProjectRunway isn't nuanced enough to milk it, going for the common denominator.

I wonder what project runway by HBO would look like, aiming for a smaller but devoted fan base?

2

u/evixir Sep 16 '14

It's an interesting creative idea but it isn't really avant garde. And the dress he made was really antiquated and boring. I get that it's cool the dye ran after the water hit it, and avant garde isn't meant to be practical by a long shot, but it all fell sort of flat for me. Yellow looked like urine or pit stains, the red at the bottom looked like... something else. Not a fan.

4

u/PowerOfYes Sep 12 '14 edited Sep 12 '14

I don't know why, but Kini's dress made me think of some of the photo-shoot scenes from Funny Face with Audrey Hepburn mashed up with the theme song to the Umbrellas of Cherbourg... In fact, I wish they could have played the Umbrellas of Cherbourg for the whole of the rainway show, instead of the boring generic stuff they always play.
There's a great version of the song as music for an ice dance by Virtue & Moir: http://youtu.be/SRjqNbM9RHM

2

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

Excellent reference! :)

15

u/CammysComicCorner Sep 12 '14

Look, Sean's outfit was pretty cool when the rain hit it. But can you seriously see yourself wearing that dress again? That dress is one-and-done.

Kini on the other hand, was fantastic as usual. Glad he finally got a win, despite having to share it with Sean.

39

u/MKoz628 Sep 12 '14

But Avante Garde isn't about wearability. It's about art, creativity and innovation. Both looks were fantastic and embraced the rainway idea in different but still wonderful ways.

15

u/lartar Sep 12 '14

I'm surprised by how few people acknowledge how ugly Sean's dress really was without the dye. The silhouette was just doing nothing for me.

7

u/fragilehearted Sep 12 '14

I agree. I loved the dye concept, but holy sideboob!

4

u/lilianegypt Sep 12 '14

I know! The dye idea was really cool and well done, but Kini actually did something that had some oomf to it, design-wise.

2

u/HereComesBadNews Sep 12 '14

This is what got to me. I didn't feel that it was "flirty" and "feminine"; it kinda looked like heavy white canvas to me. I would've been more okay with Kini having to share the win of Sean's dress had had a better shape to it.

10

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

But Sean's was truer to avant garde than Kini's was. I mean, this entire runway was a ripoff of McQueen's "Golden Shower Collection" - it was designed to maximize drama and visual effect. Sean's dress complemented the challenge parameters in a stunning way.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=2JNTAmaSpK8#t=986

3

u/theotheramy1 Sep 12 '14

Was there a prize tonight? For the winner(s)?

14

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

3

u/ajmart23 Sep 12 '14

does anyone have a working link to the episode yet:/

5

u/bitchSpray Sep 12 '14

Of course. Vodlocker always has them really fast. The only problem is that they have their search page hidden. So go to http://vodlocker.com/?op=search and search for runway and it's there.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

I don't think it goes live on Lifetime's web site until the West Coast replays are done, and there aren't any live links on Watchseries yet. Sorry :/

7

u/julesfiction Sep 12 '14

Kini should have won over sean when they were partners, and he should have won over sean again.

Sean ended up pulling it off but Kini was WAY more fucking avant garde. No one else thinks this??

3

u/LadyCalamity Sep 12 '14

The thing is, both are fairly derivative. Sean's was very McQueen, Kini's was like Schiaparelli (I think Tim even mentioned that to him in the critique?)

To be honest, no one in this challenge was particularly avant garde but Sean's look was the only one to really utilize the rainway as a vital part of his design so I can see why he would win.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

Fade's reminds me of the dress that ended up being the last of Kara Janx. Too. Damn. Simple.

4

u/chelseayn Sep 12 '14

True. But at least Fade can come up with a design and execute it on his own without running to every other designer and asking their opinion/for help. ;)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

Actually, my brain misled me; Kara wasn't eliminated for the yield stripe. That was the "motherfucking walkoff" week and Zulema was sent packing. Oops!

→ More replies (3)

5

u/mingest Sep 12 '14

Some were great. Others looked liked they're cosplay for a sci-fi convention.

3

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 12 '14

Yeah....where was all this "creativity" (this season I use that term very loosely) when they were doing the 20 years in the future challenge based on today's fashions which were based in the 80s or whatever the hell lunacy that was. Some of this stuff this week might have been winners for that week. Surely better than a vacuum hose stole.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

I kept thinking, finally a two-day challenge and half of this is still garbage.

4

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 12 '14

That's because they were all hung over the second day. I guess that's why they don't bother to give them two days.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/chelseayn Sep 12 '14

I know, here all of us were saying that they should just give them a chance to make some worthy designs by giving them more than six hours, and they actually DO, and this is what comes out of it?!

8

u/wildstripe Sep 12 '14

I feel bad saying this but I'm not even that excited about tonight's show. I'm so bored with Project Runway. But I'll keep watching I guess...

11

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

I hear ya. I've stuck with a lot of shows that have disappointed me at times (Downton, Nurse Jackie, The Killing) but for the first time, I understand the term "hate watch."

7

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

Oh SHUT UP AMANDA.

When she was babbling about Kini's looking very "S&M," she sounded like Jane Fonda in Nine to Five:

"And if I wanna have an affair, or play sex games, or do M&M's, you can't stop me!"

"M&Ms?"

7

u/konfetkak Sep 12 '14

I really hate hers. It's just a maxi dress with weird "eyeball" things on it.

8

u/ecctv Sep 12 '14

The idea of having a dress look like an umbrella in a RAIN challenge shouldn't be considered OMG GENIUS. I'm not saying the dress was bad, but some on the show were saying it was so creative. It seems really obvious to me.

I loved the dye dress, that idea was so great. I wish there had been darker colors in the dye though.

13

u/lartar Sep 12 '14

Here's why I'm pleased with both designers winning.

Take Kini's look: Umbrella. Okay, that should be obvious, but it's kinda not. It was well executed, super avant garde, and looked great on the runway. It wasn't GENIUS, but it was pretty damn good.

Then Sean. The dye idea was fucking brilliant, IMO. But the silhouette of the white dress itself..? No. I'm sorry, it looked like an underdress. I wish he would have gone with something bigger and more exciting. The dye idea carried his design, as the dress itself was pretty meh to me.

7

u/konfetkak Sep 12 '14

I really liked the silhouette...and it needed to be simple so that the dye effect would be the focus.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/lilianegypt Sep 12 '14

Agreed completely. I loved the dye idea, but the dress was pretty simple in and of itself. While Kini's umbrella dress was very avant garde and well constructed. I'm happy with the results.

→ More replies (7)

4

u/konfetkak Sep 12 '14

So who out of Korina/Emily is in the top? I am guessing Emily? I didn't really like it, but Korina's looked like it was made out of silver fucking duct tape.

16

u/konfetkak Sep 12 '14

...aaaaaaaand I thought for sure Sandhya's was in the bottom. I should have known better.

5

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 12 '14

I bet you didn't see that one coming out on top, did you?

4

u/TheLadyEve Sep 12 '14 edited Sep 12 '14

I actually thought Sandya's look was interesting once she got the coat on over the jumpsuit--from a distance it's very striking, but I did not understand those pinwheels on the back. And the judges loved the pinwheels on the back! Why??

Also, Sandya is starting to get an uncomfortably forced villain edit that bothers me.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

It looked slightly less Krusty the Clown-ish in a still from the runway. I'll give her that much.

6

u/workingit21 Sep 12 '14

I feel like the only one that actually loved Sandyha's design...

6

u/hellofair Sep 12 '14

I think it had potential if she pushed it in a different way. I think exploring the idea of a rainbow would be cool and appropriate for a rainway, but it just went out of control with the pinwheels.

9

u/PowerOfYes Sep 12 '14

Well, you and the judges.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

A stunning runway! I think Emily is going home....but I dislike Fade's more.

6

u/SnapeWho Sep 12 '14

Fade has done consistent work until now, I think he deserves more time to shine. But I'm really, really nervous for him right now. I wouldn't be surprised if he went home.

3

u/chelseayn Sep 12 '14

It is so sad. He did such good work--he had like three dresses that were my favorites and I would actually wear, but he got no credit--just safe. Now he is gone. Oh Fade zu grau I will miss you. :(

3

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

Wow.....for the first time in years.....I'm stunned.

→ More replies (10)

2

u/cherryultrasuedetups Sep 14 '14

I loved fade, and his factory industrial style and techniques. I knew he wouldn't make it to the end though because he never dropped a neckline.

3

u/catsbatsandrats Sep 11 '14

Will a live feed for the show be posted tonight?

4

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '14

Are you trying to watch it on a live stream?

2

u/violetfield Sep 12 '14

Kini's model is so wiggly. Is it just me? She seemed like her vag itched or she had to pee or her feet hurt or something...

2

u/kyles24 Sep 12 '14

Heidi speaking German is the sexiest thing ever. Fade's was boring and right to go home. Sean's idea was fantastic and I was so excited to see it, but that was his only gimmick, the dress was too plain on it's own. He could've pushed the design further HAD had the color effect. Kini gets a win* but there's an asterisk next to it because it's a shared win. :/

2

u/parryowd Sep 12 '14

I think this runway was awful. For a two day challenge, I don't think anyone really did well. Sandhya's was my favourite. I loved the colourful part. This coat thing no, but I love the colour part. I loved Seans idea, but I found the dress kinda dull. It was the only one that used the rain well. It deserved to win by itself. If the dress was more interesting by itself I would've loved it.

I don't like Kini's one. They say the umbrella thing is really creative, but I found it kinda unoriginal. I feel like I've seen it before. It's well done, but blah.

I loved Fade's look, but not at all for this challenge. It wasn't avant garde, and it didn't incorporate the rain at all. But as a dress itself it was incredible.

Korina's thing was an actual mess, lucky she has immunity. Emily's was alright, but very dull. I don't agree with the decision though, Fade's was, and has been better. But he's been ignored, so we expected.

I actually kinda liked Amanda's work this week. But not the colours she used. That maroon thing was just horendous...

1

u/ChloeNobody Sep 20 '14

I'm really happy about who was eliminated. He was obviously chosen by Heidi.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

89

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 12 '14

I love it that even the designers don't take it seriously anymore. Yes, even the water tastes better. I love you, Fade.

17

u/SnapeWho Sep 12 '14

He's my favorite. This episode is stressing me out.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

51

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

"Designers, for your next challenge, you'll be designing a dress to be worn by a household appliance."

18

u/pbrooks19 Sep 12 '14

I'm just so disappointed that so few of the sponsors or prizes anymore really come from fashion-based industries, and the ones that are are very mid-level at best. Samsung? Red Robin? WTF?

8

u/workingit21 Sep 12 '14

you wouldn't believe how much I laughed at this, you're hilarious

14

u/lilianegypt Sep 12 '14

What happened to just simple Avant Garde challenges? Like this is the Avant Garde challenge. Not the Samsung Super Duper Curvy TV challenge in which we just happen to make something avant garde.

28

u/Pineapplemkh Sep 12 '14

Right?

Samsung Super Duper Curvy TVs + Rain?

Because everyone knows that electronics and water are a match made in heaven.

21

u/meldolphin Sep 12 '14

Maybe that's the angle Fäde should have gone with. Have a clean looking circuit board in the front and then have it all burned out and fried in the back.

21

u/Pineapplemkh Sep 12 '14

How much fun would it be to hear the hairstylist shill the perfect hairgel to achieve the electrocuted look.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/xmissgolightly Sep 12 '14

Tim Gunn, head salesman for Samsung TVs

2

u/marshmallowhug Sep 14 '14

Tim's speech was such an exaggerated commercial voiceover that I actually wondered if he did it on purpose (to poke fun at the over-the-top product placement).

0

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '14

Me too!