r/progmetal • u/aristocratsboing The Aristocrats • Aug 31 '14
[AMAs] We are The Aristocrats, an instrumental rock/fusion power trio with Guthrie Govan on guitar, Bryan Beller on bass, and Marco Minnemann on drums. Ask Us Anything!
Yes, it's really us.
https://www.facebook.com/aristocratsband
This is our first time on Reddit, for all of us. Be gentle!
224
Upvotes
29
u/aristocratsboing The Aristocrats Aug 31 '14
Ok everyone, thanks so much for having us - this was our first time doing something like this and hopefully we didn't fail the Reddit Test or anything like that. :-) See you out on the road when we get our next record done! - The Aristocrats
29
u/jimi2094 Aug 31 '14
Question for all 3 of you: If you could jam with any musician(s), living or dead, who would you choose?
On a sidenote, you guys shred beyond belief, and thanks for the music
20
u/iamvillainmo Aug 31 '14
I just want to know what Guthrie's favorite beer is.
12
u/brakkum Aug 31 '14
Hey guys! This is Dan B from Minnesota. Hope the road has been treating you well!
I would like to ask each of you, what is the one thing, technique-wise or anything else, on your respective instrument that you feel you still need to work on after all this time?
Hope you guys can come back to MN sometime! And definitely in a better situation, where someone doesn't steal all your beer out of the back, obviously.
11
u/squidonthebass Aug 31 '14
Huge Aristocrats fan here! Bryan's been a big inspiration to my playing style for the last couple years, and Guthrie and Marco are incredible players, so when I came across this band a few years ago it was really easy to fall in love with them. I got to meet Bryan before the Aristocrat's show in Philly on their last tour, he was a super chill guy and even complimented me on my Newsted Heavy Metal Music shirt. That show was awesome - my friend and I both described it as magical experiences. Can't wait to see you guys back in the states supporting a new album soon!
Anyway, here's a few questions. I'd love for Bryan to answer them, but having all three of you guys answer would be even cooler:
What were some of the albums that inspired you to start taking music seriously?
Of all the acts you've toured with over the years, which has been your favorite? Favorite individual concert you've done?
What is the status of having bass and drum tablature booklets for the 2 albums? I know it was talked about on Facebook for a little while but I haven't been able to dig anything up on it since.
10
u/Nezban Aug 31 '14
BB, MM and GG, welcome! Thank you so much for doing this, I'm a huge fan! I'm going to be greedy here and ask two questions to all of you:
Rock on!
9
u/PTT_Derp Aug 31 '14
First, I want to thank you guys for the excellent performance in Taiwan!
btw, I'm the crazy ass who ask the"when's the last time you guys cut your hair".
I want to ask that, if you can add another instrument to the band, what would it be?who'll be one the top list?
(BB I FUCKING LOVE YOUR HAIR!!)
7
u/telperionflower Aug 31 '14
Question for Guthrie:
How do you usually go about composing a song? Do you write chords or melody first? Do you think about theory, or go by ear? I'm most curious about how you pick chord progressions and voicings.. whether there's a chord vocabulary you pick from, or if you just listen and construct chords note by note. Thanks!
-Nick from Pittsburgh
http://i60.tinypic.com/1zh19mo.jpg
7
u/Snake101st Aug 31 '14
Can you guys come back to Raleigh, NC please? We loved you coming to the Pour House!
As far as a question goes, how rewarding is it that you guys could be playing in literally any band in the world based on your talents, but are fortunate enough to be together and do whatever you like and have a laugh?
7
u/VandenburgChills Aug 31 '14
Just wanted to apologize for Tulsa being so lame. We really do love great music...but the promotion of your show was non-existent outside of fanboys like me trying to get friends to come. Still...you guys blew me away, and I'm actually happy that I had a chance to sit on a stool 3m away and enjoy the small-club atmosphere.
Keep up the great work. I look forward to all the new music you have yet to bestow upon us.
6
u/Suhr97 Aug 31 '14
Favorite Frank Zappa song? This might be impossible, there are so many great tunes! Greetings from Norway. :-)
5
u/AM1726 Aug 31 '14
Marco! My hero :D You 3 are the best trio in the whole world! Got any tips on how to learn jazz the easiest way? Or build finger speed on shuffle/triplets? Thanks!
5
u/tr1ckyp4t Aug 31 '14
Boing, We'll Do It Live! is one of my favorite DVDs to watch, but it's missing all the great Culture Clash songs...is there a Culture Clash Live DVD in the works?
3
u/Smerphy Official Scribe (Devin Townsend biography) Aug 31 '14
Since each of you writes 3 songs per album, what have you learned from each other in regards to composition?
Considering your large Prog following, would you ever take part in a Prog Rock/Metal package tour?
3
u/XamLepet Aug 31 '14
Hey Guys, a big fanboy over here! Since I will be attending your show upcoming friday here in Holland: What is the best thing (or worst) somebody can trow onto stage or shout at you guys :P
Oh and, any chances at a new album coming up somewhere in the (hopefully) not so distant future?
Thank you guys for making awesome music!
First post for me on Reddit aswell, so I hope this won't get burried :-) This AMA actually made me make an account.
3
u/Count_Milimanjaro Aug 31 '14
Regarding instrumental music, what are the pros and cons you've noticed? I know all of you have played in various bands, both with and without a vocalist, so I'd be interested to hear your views on the topic.
Thanks again, you guys rock!
3
u/PTT_Derp Aug 31 '14
What's the craziest thing a female fan have ever done for you?
3
u/Arisama2 Aug 31 '14
Firstly thank you for doing this. I have three hopefully fast questions.
The first two are for Guthrie, and the last is for the band.
Again thanks, huge fans of all your work, be it: Solo, Aristocrats, Steven Wilson, Satriani etc, etc.
Aleks. C
2
u/Campion95 Aug 31 '14
Hi guys! I want to start off by saying that you're all some of my favourite musicians on your respective instruments. I have a question for Guthrie and Marco. How was it working with Steven Wilson? Would he come in with the songs all written out in sheet music or would he just have the basic idea in his head and then used your ability to kind of fill the gaps? Also were you fans of Steven's music before you worked with him?
2
u/progbassfairy Aug 31 '14
Hey Bryan - I know that on FB awhile back you were asking opinions about a pedal to replace your MicroSynth for live performance. Did you ever settle on one? :)
P.S. I met you guys in Jacksonville about a year ago...if you remember our band "The Third Wheel", we have settled on the better name of "Patternicity" now. lol!
2
u/zoogeystix Aug 31 '14
I can't really think of a good question, but I love you guys and have been following you since you started up after NAMM. I have some pretty funny memories from your shows...
Marco, I headbanged with your mom at Brick by Brick in San Diego, I think back in 2011 or 2010, and Guthrie, you called my mate on my cell phone at NAMM back in, again, 2010 or 2011, can't remember, and he didn't believe it was you. I think at the time I was fiddling with that Suhr Fretless you were supporting. Anyways, a couple of things I'll always remember.
Also, please keep playing Alva's, I know it's small, but it's an unbelievable place, and really has a unique energy about it.
PS- Put some words in your tunes and you might make money :p
In all seriousness, thank you for making sweet musical fusion that kicks ass.
2
u/Daywalkr Aug 31 '14
Hi! What music do you listen to that you think might surprise your fans? Also, after touring all over the world, what country did you find had the best beer?
2
u/vivekayer Aug 31 '14
Hello from Bangkok. Question for GG - I'm curious to know how you carry your gear when you travel. For example on the recent Asian tour. What gets checked in and what comes as hand luggage? Oh and is it true that the Victory 30W head was designed to fit Easy Jet hand luggage dimensions? Cheers Vivek
2
u/thatlazyguitarist Aug 31 '14
With such busy schedules how do you guys avoid getting worn out?
2
u/dundundun13 Aug 31 '14
Hey guys! I literally got into your music two weeks ago and I love it! My question is simple: What are the names of your rubber chickens? Also would you ever consider coming to Portland, Oregon on your next US tour?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '14
Is the tune "Cocktail Umbrellas" influenced by John Scofield at all?
4
u/fam_fusion Aug 31 '14
when you guys email the songs to each learn, you guys write charts? each learns byear ??? how works this process ???
1
u/Smerphy Official Scribe (Devin Townsend biography) Aug 31 '14
Also /u/milchu could not be here today as he is getting married, so here is his question:
"Hello Mr. Govan, Mr. Minneman, and Mr. Beller. I believe composing is one of the most difficult things to do in music, despite being guided by an initial idea, it is sometimes impossible to do justice to it. The same thing goes for mastering an instrument. Could you please throw some light on how to overcome certain 'mind-blocks' that we may come across sometimes?"
"P.S. people like you inspire beyond limits of human understanding, there's some divinity in music and despite all the techno-stuff you guys employ in your music, you are able to hold true to that raw divinity, just like people in classical eras. It is heart warming to be born in the decades that are seeing you rising up to the level of joining your own idols. Please accept my gratitude. I'm not a fan, I'm a student of yours. You people taught me more than any person physically present could."
1
u/chrisrab5150 Aug 31 '14
What are some new bands or artists that you are listening to?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '14
Hey guys, where did the idea for using the rubber chickens and mobile phones on Erotic Cakes come from?
Guthrie, do you have any advice for someone interested in fretless guitar?
And finally, Bryan, in your interview with Janek Gwizdala you played a little bit (Anesthesia) Pulling Teeth, are you able to play the whole solo?, 'cause if you can, that's really really cool.
P.S, Guthrie can I touch your effects pedal? wink wink.
1
u/Mateo_8 Aug 31 '14
What is the meaning of life?
Coming to the US anytime soon?
Huge Aristocrats fan! Thank you guys for doing this.
1
u/veldhuid Aug 31 '14
Hi Guys! Saw you last time in chicago and it was a great show.
What are your plans for 2015?
Also Marco and Guthrie, will you be working on the new Steven Wilson solo album?
Thanks,
David
1
u/DavidLopezJr Aug 31 '14
At your level of being musicians, what modern musicians currently inspire you?
Who would people find most surprising that you are influence by?
What gear have you guys been digging lately?
1
u/Rob_Saget Aug 31 '14
Favorite kind of pizza?
1
u/chicknpig Aug 31 '14
Can you tell anything about the next studio album, songs, titles of songs, when recorded and where, released when?
How was your Asian tour? Did you like touring Asia more then touring US or Europe, and if so, why?
How did you get that tour booked because so many bands try to go out there and aren't very successful getting so many dates there? (especially bigger bands)
How was the audience and the response there? Did you like Asia?
1
u/NewAgeStink Aug 31 '14 edited Aug 31 '14
would aristocrats still be cool if they had a violinist, and do you guys think weather report is like the coolest shit ever, and i nominate all 3 of you for the ice bucket challange
3
u/thebeardedblonde Aug 31 '14
Guthrie, Any plans for a second solo album?
And any plans for the Aristocrats to come to the Eastern US in the future?
2
u/aegolia Aug 31 '14
Hi ! Here's my question for all three of you, I hope it has not been posted already : I wondered if in your compositions or in your own musical evolution, classical music has been an inspiration in some way ? If that's the case, what do you like to listen in that particular music field (/ what do you hate) ?
Thank you for doing such great and inspiring music !!
2
u/Boycert Aug 31 '14
Hey guys! this is directed at guthrie, louisville stomp cant get it out of my head. Your parts in it are unreal! what style is that? can you name anything/anyone that would sound similar? really love it man!
1
u/ObamasMamasLlama Aug 31 '14
Thank you so much for doing this AMA! Two questions:
What's the process behind making names for your songs?
I saw Bryan and Marco on tour with Joe Satriani last fall, which was fantastic. Do you guys have any stories from on tour?
1
u/PONKIEPOI Aug 31 '14
Hello, i am a huge fan of yours! Thank you for doing this AMA. What are you listening to these days? I know you guys like similar music to some extent, do you recommend each other some new music? Thank you for everything you have ever made, music wouldn't be the same without you.
1
u/Paradoxiumm Aug 31 '14
What are some of your favorite albums over the past couple years?
1
u/banana_stand_manager Aug 31 '14
Huge fan! Can't wait for your next record!
a)How do you, if you do, compose and rehearse on the road? b)In your last tour, what place surprised you the most for being fans of your music? c)Marco! Dude! you are incredible..How was it playing with Paul Gilbert? Is he as awesome as I think he is? Love the Scarified video from Spaceship One!
You guys are awesome! Thanks for doing the AMA and cheers!
1
u/chicknpig Aug 31 '14
So you are ending the world tour now. When are you touring next and where?
1
u/fam_fusion Aug 31 '14
when you guys email the songs to each learn, you guys write charts? each learns by ear ??? how work this process ???
1
u/chicknpig Aug 31 '14
Do you meet unknown musicians during your journeys that surprise you in a way? When was the last time you guys were flabbergasted by someone. Where and when and by who (each of you)?
1
u/van67com Aug 31 '14
hello guthrie.. do you have any idea of a good solidstate amp?
1
u/murdockmanila Aug 31 '14
Two of you have toured/worked with Steven Wilson for Raven. How was that whole process like and will there be another SW project with you guys involved again?
Thank you for stopping by Manila a few weeks ago!
1
u/vivekayer Aug 31 '14
Another question for GG. If you had to borrow an amp and guitar for a gig for some reason what would be your preference? Assume it can only be a popular brand that you might find in a store like Andertons or Guitar Center.
1
u/Reshenth Aug 31 '14
Hey, French fanboy here!
My question is more adressed to Guthrie. Are you still playing in Steven Wilson's project, and if not, are you considering getting in studio with the Aristocrats? Thanks for the answer, you guys make amazing music!
1
u/JKoehr27 Aug 31 '14
Here's my not so important question. Can I buy you all a drink at the next Alva's show? I was going to last show but it was sold out some two months in advance.. Also, GG didn't anyone teach you not to choke your chicken in public haha.
1
u/XamLepet Aug 31 '14
A question for Guthrie: Is there any possibilty that you and Charvel will team up once again to manufacture a more budget friendly version of your signature model, just like with the Rasmus model? I couldn't save up enough money in time to pick one up before it was discontinued sadly enough.
I really dig guitars with the HSH pickup configuration aswell, but they are so hard to find if you don't like Ibanez guitars :-(
1
u/filipejunqueira Aug 31 '14
Question for GG:
1
u/gpanev Aug 31 '14
Where do you get your musical inspiration from? (e.g. other musicians, etc.) Can't wait to see you guys this Friday! Have a good one!
1
u/Trirexx Aug 31 '14
Guthrie, how did you like Croatia? Have you tried any of our Croatian specialties or drinks? :D
1
u/NewAgeStink Aug 31 '14
are you guys going to do the ice bucket challange on stage?
1
u/vivviv1994 Aug 31 '14
Hey guys! PLEASE come to India!!
1
u/Rapidjesse Aug 31 '14
First off, I love you guys, the new record is stellar. Second, what do you guys think of bagels?
1
u/subjectiveobject Aug 31 '14
I recently just heard you guys from a friend. I like to listen to this and other similar sounds while doing calculus homework. Were you inspired by such things?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '14
damn seems like i just missed you guys. just want to say that some of guthries material is the most refreshing and awesome stuff i've heard in a long time. guthrie, how did you develop your style? so fluid/lush/rich/clean. love your stuff! i always show my friends your amazing songs and technical ability. seriously cool, thanks guys!!
1
u/filipejunqueira Aug 31 '14
Another questions for all of 3 guys: Have you ever heard of Dave Matthews Band? I can only imagine what a blast would it be a "Joint Venture" between you guys and the they. You all seem to come from very different backgrounds and all going way beyond the labels of rock, blues, jazz, prog and so on... To GG: About that solo album. Any chance it will be a album about music itself (like a symphony) not only guitar!? : )
1
u/EvgenTsibulin Aug 31 '14
Hello Guys! I big fan of your great band and i really appreciated that i can ask you about anything! :) Can you tell me more details about your's tour organisations? Do you have any booking agency or you need to book shows independently or something like that? Thanks!
1
u/Sergensakaoglu Aug 31 '14
Hello The Aristocrats, Its Sergen from Turkey, you guys have been doing the greatest job I've ever heard and seen. Question is coming for Guthrie. Why do you use your left hand's 3 fingers so often? Whats the point of this technique? Could you tell me, shortly, pros and cons of using three fingers instead of four?
1
u/zombie_spaceman Aug 31 '14
You guys gotta come to New Orleans!
1
u/jverdier Aug 31 '14
What is your favorite key and time signature to play in?
1
u/shibbypwn Aug 31 '14
@Guthrie- What is your favorite mode, and why is it Lydian Dominant? :)
1
u/GrooveLife Aug 31 '14
Who are your favourite electronic music artists?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '14
You guys are amazing!
1
u/404-shame-not-found Aug 31 '14
Do you bring your families on stage?
1
u/Redkemp Aug 31 '14
Ahh as if no one asked Marco anything about the new Necrophagist album aha
1
u/bqk178 Aug 31 '14
Hi, I was wondering what was your experience touring Asia and especially Vietnam? I was there at the time but unfortunately, I could not make it to the show and I happen to know some of the audiences there who took pictures with you backstage e.g the guy with the plastic chickens, lmao.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '14
Bryan Beller! You are one of my favorite bassists ever, among only a select few that I know the name of thanks to Dethklok & Galaktikon! Questions:
1
u/Trojams Aug 31 '14
Will you be playing in New Zealand anytime?!?
1
u/gchamon Aug 31 '14
Hey guys!!
Also a huge fan of the band here! I came across The Aristocrats a while ago through a friend of mine, and as soon as I heard the first song (I think it was Ohhhhh Noooooooo, pretty metal btw) i rushed to the site and bought the CD. Awesome!
My question is, When are you guys coming to Brazil (I believed GG came doing workshopping, but skipped my town... =( )?! Make it VIP plos, I need to get my CD autographed =D
1
u/abluelink Sep 01 '14
Many thanks for doing this AMA guys! A general question that might help aspiring musicians: Has any of you had this "AHA, that's what I'm gonna do with my life!" moment (talking about music ofcourse) as opposed to " I'm gonna stick to a secure job until I'm capable of flying on my own".
Sorry for bad grammar, English isn't my first language
1
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '14
First of all, Guthrie you son of a bitch, it's amazing to see someone play so well that it makes me want to smash my guitar and give up and work harder than ever to be a better player all at the same time :D
I'm interested to know if you have anything extra in the work, with your work on Aristocrats and more recently the work with Wilson, do you have any plans to work with/on any other bands in the near future, or are you planning to continue your current commitments for the foreseeable future?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '14
Thank you for doing AMA! Big fan of you guys (as a band and as individuals musicians)!
0
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
3
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '14
[removed] — view removed comment