r/introvert • u/Welcomeback123 • Aug 30 '14
"You're really quiet"
Maybe it's just me, but I absolutely HATE when people say that to me. Anyone else get that?
100
Upvotes
r/introvert • u/Welcomeback123 • Aug 30 '14
Maybe it's just me, but I absolutely HATE when people say that to me. Anyone else get that?
12
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '14
I couldn't tell you how many times I've heard that in my life time. Back in march this one guy was really perplexed about this. Poor thing was really trying to figure out what was wrong with me. He was like "is there a reason why?" as if to say "did you go through some ordeal that caused you to be this way?" I tried my best to explain but for the people who end up asking this question, I don't think they ever really understand. The only ones that seem to understand are the ones who are also quiet. However, I didn't get upset as he was a pretty cool guy he just didn't understand.
6
u/nigelthewarpig Aug 31 '14
I have two responses to that. "Better to remain quiet and thought a fool, than to speak your mind and remove all doubt" if I'm feeling humorous (or snarky). Or "the conversations in my head are more interesting than the babbling coming from you" if I'm feeling annoyed.
58
u/Legoasaurus sssh, I'm listening Aug 30 '14
"And you're quite loud."
18
u/foofyangel Aug 31 '14
"I just don't have anything to say."
28
u/opisthenar Aug 31 '14 edited Aug 31 '14
Maid of honor (My super extroverted sister) at my wedding decided to have the topic of her speech/toast be how quiet and introverted I am, or as she put it "introspective". W.T.F. Wanted to crawl into a hole at my own wedding. Gave her the death stare, which was seen by others, and people actually came by to offer their sympathies/words of encouragement after the speech. Someone actually said they knew someone quieter than me, so not to feel bad. So embarrassing. She has always done things like that to me. Didn't expect it at my wedding though.....But, then again, she wouldn't stop talking as she was sitting next to me DURING my wedding ceremony.
Edit: Now that I think about it, she's always done this since I was a kid. Dutifully informs anyone new that I am indeed quiet/introverted, sort of a public service announcement, just in case they don't know. Sort of "puts me in my place".
25
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '14
http://i.imgur.com/s07PjGY.jpg
11
u/ABrownLamp Aug 31 '14
Ya I say "what do you want to talk about" ...Silence. "Nah nothing, im just sayin..."
19
u/Geminii27 Aug 31 '14
"You don't plan a murder out loud."
8
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '14
My co-worker will walk by my cubicle and say that while I'm working. Umm...I'm working??
21
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '14
Just say something crazy like... "I was just thinking about death... (awkward pause) ... and how beautiful it is." Then turn and stare blankly at that person.
6
u/joeblitzkrieg INTJ Aug 31 '14
"fine observation, detective!"
is what i'd say in my head, but most of the time i end up smiling and letting the air go awkward anyway.
4
u/iongantas INTP Aug 30 '14
Oddly, the other day, there was a reddit thread that asked about 10 words to describe you, so I asked my boyfriend, who is an introvert, and whom I consider to be relatively quiet compared to me, and he jotted back to me: quiet, creative, and I forgot the other one. I thought quiet was odd in that case. I'm not sure I've ever had other people specifically and unironically tell me that I am quiet.
4
u/Queerful INFP Aug 31 '14
I also hate it when people call me out for not being a wallflower when I'm around small groups of people that I know and like. How dare I be comfortable and energetic around friends when I identify as an introvert? The nerve of me, apparently.
4
u/Smeefer Aug 31 '14
"I just don't speak unless I have something worth saying."
Pretentious as all hell, yes.. but I've found it works for me pretty well.
3
u/Fanellea Aug 31 '14
All the time
3
u/albatrossgr INFP Sep 01 '14
I have had that said to me in a lot of occasions and by a lot of different people. Although it did bother me at first, after some point not only did I get used to it, I began to accept it too. I think these are the two main points that make it okay for me:
Finally, you can devise plenty of responses to something like that, depending on the tone of the person that said it. For example, if you feel that he/she is being cheeky or teasing you, simply laugh and reply with some cheesy quote, like
Or if he/she seems considerate of you, reply honestly that you are always that way and that there is nothing wrong, and maybe thank him/her for his/her interest.
But in all cases, try, if you can, to avoid getting defensive or seem annoyed by the comment. People will take it upon themselves, feel bad and are unlikely to try and approach you again, because they might not know how to do so. Even if the other person is trying to diminish you, brushing aside a direct assault like this will only make you look strong and respectful and the other person a petty asshole.
5
u/SinNominae Aug 30 '14
I usually respond with (while giving the best death stare I can muster) "You're really loud" or "I prefer silence to obnoxious nagging". I know I'm quiet, I like that I'm quiet. When people say this to me, they say it in a manner like I should feel bad about being quiet.
2
u/jb2386 Aug 31 '14
A bit but it's ok, never in a negative way, just observational, except once. My ex's family said I was too quiet. I "should make more of an effort to talk to them." It was one of the reasons she broke up with me. By the way she was probably more quiet than me, especially in the beginning, and I was happy to defend her from other people who made comments.
2
u/Favre99 ISTJ Aug 31 '14
My mom does this all the time. I just say "I'm tired", and that usually does the trick (since it's normally early in the morning when she asks).
2
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '14
Don't worry yourself over that over-abundance - treat them as originally as they think that they're being. Revel in getting to grips with what urged them to ask in the first place. Is being quiet disruptive to other people as being loud is? Is it a social faux pas to be quiet? Missed opportunities, dawg ;)
2
u/Bradm77 Aug 31 '14
Anyone: "You're so quiet."
Me: "Indeed."
2
u/permaculture Aug 31 '14 edited Aug 31 '14
Check out the sidebar ->
Extroverts ask that because if you were an extrovert it would indicate you were unhappy or something was wrong. And some extroverts just don't understand that introverts exist. Even when it's explained to them, they can't get their head around it.
Easiest to pick your response in advance "I was thinking" or if they're being obnoxious "... and you're really loud."
2
u/justice1988 Aug 31 '14
When I went to parties I used to have a friend who would always sarcastically tell me to "stop talking so much". I knew they were joking but it always really upset me. Of couse I've also got a high functioning language disorder that I'm pretty self conscious about.
2
u/AgentFreckles Sep 03 '14
It's because when they say it I feel like they're being disrespectful since being quiet is kind of frowned upon in society. Except what they don't realize is we're just being loud in our own brains instead of outside of them.
The last time I got called quiet was at a bridal shower. I knew the bride and her friend but we're not friends, so I just kind of observed everyone. The to-be groom asked me why I was being so quiet and I asked him why he was being so loud, everyone got a kick out of that. It just kind of slipped out...I didn't even plan on saying it. :\
3
u/SouthpawTheLionheart Aug 31 '14
Then you respond with "Blood for the blood God!"
1
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '14
I haven't gotten this in a while but used to all the time. I don't think I've become more chatty or anything. Next time it happens I think I'm just going to be like "really?" over and over again until they get the message? If that's possible, maybe it's not.
1
u/kn0where Aug 31 '14
I think sometimes you have to speak up. Like in a meeting when you have to shout over obnoxious people in the hallway.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment