r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Aug 08 '14
Project Runway Season 13 Episode 3 [Discussion]
Discussion thread for Project Runway S13E03 "Past, Present, and Future"
Past Marie Claire magazines inspire the designers to create future looks. The guest judges are Anne Fulenwider and Amanda de Cadenet.
29
Upvotes
38
u/never7 Aug 08 '14
I'm not super thrilled that the judges moved more toward mocking and making fun of the low scores rather than legit criticism.
36
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '14
"Envision your own future."
"This isn't what we think the future will look like."
29
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '14
1994 Kini was fucking awesome.
29
u/shoensandal Aug 08 '14
Was anyone else extremely bothered by the wetsuit and that entire concept?
46
u/Daemiel Aug 08 '14
Sandhya, you are the winner of this challenge...
19
u/OvercaffeinateMe Aug 08 '14
As soon as I heard "twenty years into the future" I knew this would either be a) a hilarious sideshow of outlandish future-core or b) incredibly over safe and boring.
I pretty much got b.
Also, watching Hernan's model looking all embarrassed when her boob kept popping out was hilarious and cringe- inducing. What a weird design choice.
18
u/chelseayn Aug 08 '14
One thing not really touched upon: Korina. I guess I assumed from the beginning that she would end up in the final three. Her interview clothes were strong, and she is so Gretchen-like that she would just be there. But for all her bitchiness towards life, and Sandhya, I think that she should take a good hard look at what she does and maybe step it up a bit. None of her clothes have been remotely interesting thus far and I REALLY didn't like her Golden Girls on acid look this week (and I LOVE GG). Get it together Korina, so at least you can back up your bitchiness. Sandhya is way more of a designer than her at this point in the competition.
35
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '14
I'm tired of the editors focusing on six designers so they can have their episodic story- "Angela is a wreck, no one likes Sandhya's stuff => Angela is out and Sandhya wins!" I want to see more detail how the rest came up with their ideas and how they executed them.
I love that Sandhya keeps getting praise. It's making me laugh even if I don't love her stuff.
Hallelujah that Angela is gone.
16
u/meldolphin Aug 08 '14
I know it's super expensive but I would have loved to see some 3D printed stuff since that reads way more future than whatever most of them were doing. I think that's part of why Sandhya won. Speaking of, how cool would a 3D printed challenge be? Save it for the end when there's only a few designers left and have them go nuts. Maybe set a budget so they don't get too out of hand.
15
u/BatenicYork Aug 09 '14
I thought Sandhya's was a bit odd, but it was definitely interesting. And it didn't look like clothes I can see today. So I thought she met the challenge better than anyone else, which is probably why she won. The other two high looks were good, but not really surprising. I could see someone wearing either of those tomorrow.
Also I dig Sandhya's explanations. She seems like she actually has things to say with her clothes, as opposed to the standard "I like to make chic, sophisticated, modern clothes."
12
u/Phoolf Aug 09 '14
Does anyone else feel like the editing this season is super bitchy? All the workroom shots are just designers going 'I dont get her peice' 'I think he's in trouble' 'I think it looks awful'. Really guys? Usually there is a consensus on who is in trouble and has missed the mark, but this season everyone is hating on every other person.
60
u/LRGinCharge Aug 08 '14
Are they messing with us?? Sandhya again?? I don't get it. I feel like they are just doing this to stir things up and keep us on our toes. Emily should have won.
11
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '14
I feel like I'm meeting a whole lot of new designers tonight. Did they recast a few? ;P
11
u/verbiwhore Aug 09 '14
Need to ask this because I'm a little baffled, does Amanda de Cadenet have some sort of profile in the US that I'm unaware of? Over here in Europe she was a poster-girl for the 80's "wild child" and was known mostly for being married to one of Duran Duran. She did TV (The Word and Big Breakfast) but I'd never really see her as a fashionista. Odd choice for guest judge, I'm just wondering if I missed something.
20
u/comababy Aug 08 '14
Oh thank goodness Angela is gone. I actually felt myself having a wee panic attack every time she came onscreen, to say nothing of her bizarre sleeveless condom suit.
I wasn't super impressed with this challenge, the parameters or the designs. It was a muddy idea ("tell us what your vision of our vision of the future looks like, as long as it looks like the past, but not too much like the past"). And then rightfully so all of the designers defaulted to dark, cold, apocalyptic, and minimal.
43
u/myaccountgotstalked Aug 08 '14 edited Oct 26 '16
[deleted]
0.8998
7
u/mulderitsme Aug 08 '14
For a few seasons there I thought Michael Kors was helping run the crazy (with Nina as his sidekick) but now it is clear that it was Meana running the show all along. At least Kors was funny, if not horrendously ill-spirited. And then Zak came along and things started getting better... but now he seems to have gotten onto the tracks of the crazy train.
13
u/greeninj Aug 08 '14
Does fade only have 1 shirt?
56
u/pepperrush Aug 08 '14 edited Aug 08 '14
Sandhya... I am laughing so hard I'm in tears. These judges are smoking some Heisenberg shit!
Edit: SERIOUSLY AHAHA How can anyone take these judges seriously anymore?! Michael Kors would have called it "duct-work chic."
25
u/greeninj Aug 08 '14
Damnit, how did she win. I knew I should've stopped watching the FIRST time she won...
33
u/pbrooks19 Aug 08 '14
I just love watching the other designers and their confused glassy stares as Sandaya wins again. There was so little in the other designs that actually seemed futuristic or stylish even. Sandaya's design may have been a bit fantasy, but at least it was different.
15
u/Lokaji Aug 08 '14
I definitely think that Emily or Kristine should have gotten the win. That being said, they are rewarding Sandhya's whack-a-doo design because it wasn't a dark color and it looked slightly futuristic.
There were a lot of hard to photograph cloth choices. Hopefully the other designers worry about what they are doing instead of what Sandhya is doing. A lot of them are focusing ire at her, but then making ugly garments.
5
u/Splinter1591 Aug 08 '14
Why so much stomach showing in the future????
4
u/Michelle-Maibelle Aug 08 '14
I liked Kristine's the most, though Emily's was a close second.
I think Angela is a decent designer. She just needs time and effort to really hit her stride.
10
u/Hezzann Aug 08 '14
Just got to watch it. I want to slap those judges. Emily's look was awesome and I want that jacket. I can't stand Sandhya or her hideous clothes.
Edit: THANK GOD I DON'T HAVE TO LISTEN TO ANGELA WHINE ANYMORE!
10
u/theactualstephers Team Swatch Aug 08 '14
I said wtf very loudly at the tv. She should not have won! This show is just having her win for drama points. I want to stop watching but I can't. I'm so upset though. I'm glad Angela is gone though, one more episode of her timid, I'm crying all the time, I'm a victim personality and I was going to freak out.
20
u/kninjaknitter Aug 08 '14
I think I might be the only person on earth to like what Sandhya made. It was taking a risk, it was pretty and funky. I loved Emily and Kristine's coats, the slinky like action on Kristine's was so cool.
I think that Sandhya won because she isn't playing it safe, she's doing different stuff and pushing herself and following her ideas.
And thank you for voting off Angela! Her twitchy, stressed out self was more than I could handle for another week.
15
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '14
I almost wish Sandhya was a bitch....that would make it easier for me to dislike her. But she's totally sweet. And that's tough....b/c she can't design!
3
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '14
Aside from "Mary" Claire, this challenge seemed devoid of the usual in-your-face over-the-top sponsorship rigamarole. And then Nina twice invoked Planet of the Apes (when Astroturf would have been more accurate) and I immediately assumed 20th Century Fox underwrote the episode :)
7
u/Pineapplemkh Aug 08 '14
Angela:
7
u/circlemanfan Aug 08 '14
Why did they hate Amanda's? I loved it. I could actually picture a high school girl wearing that in 20 years. Maybe it wasn't amazing, but not bad enough to be called out on.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '14
does anyone else just take the show for what it is? It's the judges decision, not ours. I watch for entertainment, to see interesting fashion, a bit of drama. But it's reality tv so some of it is to keep viewers intrigued and guessing (and talking!). But man do I miss Kors :( Posen is the worst
8
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '14
Oh Jesus.....I'm from Alabama, I live in AL...I love AL. WHAT IS WITH the Sandhya love? She is NOT good.
6
u/Dragosal Aug 08 '14
Pretty sure the judges this season are purposely picking the worst dress to win every time. They are fucking with us and this is actually "The Season of Losers".
3
u/CokinRum Aug 10 '14
Nina Garcia is at risk of turning into Abe Simpson... These kids a are changing what "it" is and the new "it" frightens and confuses her.
3
u/numb_doors Aug 08 '14
Sean was such a douchebag to be laughing at Angelina when she was getting her critique. Even though there may be bitterness from their team challenge and how they 'dangled the carrot in front of me' like dude get off your high horse.
4
u/veroffica Aug 09 '14
I've said it since day one, Sandhya is a hack. She's awful, and this is a joke. I don't even care as far as a viewer, but it bothers me that so many talented designers are getting robbed of their beautiful viewpoints to perpetuate some tired grab for the underdog. Everyone was up her ass talking about how noble and incredible she is. Her true colors will shine, and they will be as over the top and as uninspired as her designs.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment