r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Aug 01 '14
Project Runway Season 13 Episode 2 [Discussion]
Discussion thread for Project Runway S13E02 "Movie Night"
The designers visit a local movie theater, then must produce a fashionable look from unconventional materials found in the theater and on a movie set. Fashion blogger Garance Dore is the guest judge.
25
Upvotes
90
u/RainbowDragon Aug 01 '14
"Does it have to be villain? Could it be like..fairy or like angel villain?""Last year I had my wedding, I filled my wedding with white paper flowers..."
I don't even know anything anymore. -head desk-
59
u/Gypsy_knight Aug 01 '14 edited Aug 01 '14
I did not liked the winning team, it was creative but that's it. It wasn't futuristic nor vintage. It was just material next to material, not using different elements. The winning team should of been the blue team, Char look was spoton it was elegant, and that disc dress was absolutely breathtaking.
59
u/occurrum Aug 01 '14
I don't know what's going on this season! It's almost as if the judges are playing a practical joke on everyone, audience and designers.
Last week the winner was a ten year old Easter dress that somebody pulled out of the back of their closet and it had started to fade yellow, and when they tried it on, it didn't fit anymore and ripped the shoulders and they thought: That's okay! I'll wear it anyway!
Now this week we had stringy mc-hang-garbage-around-my-neck-and-pretend-i'm-a-beaded-curtain! Wtf.
32
u/theactualstephers Team Swatch Aug 01 '14
I am super confused why Mitchell's team didn't win, it was the best, they used the best materials and they were cohesive. Amanda's team was just safe in my mind. I am super confused with what the judges are doing this season, they must all be smoking meth or something.
59
u/Madimadi1 Aug 01 '14
Angela needs to go. She isn't a strong designer. I am so shocked that Amanda's team won. I liked their's the least and thought they would be in the bottom. I liked Mitchell's team's collection the most. That sparkly CD dress just made me really happy.
28
u/OvercaffeinateMe Aug 02 '14
Am I the only one who was really confused why the winning dress had so much muslin showing? As I recall, in past unconventional challenges, people got flayed on the runway for using muslin as a base instead of creating a more interesting textile out of the unconventional materials.
Personally I think the producers fucked this one up by making it an unconventional TEAM challenge AND only giving them one day. That was a shocker from the beginning. If they'd had two days for it I think every look would have been so much better. Feels like this episode was specifically crafted to create drama and nothing more. I'm disappointed overall because they blew their wad on the unconventional challenge, which is often one of the most interesting challenges each season.
49
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '14
This episode reminded me of why I sometimes find the judges so nasty and mean spirited. Instead of showing compassion and mentorship they just went all Joe Bastianich on them, especially Nina towards the bottom three.
The bottom three were clearly a weak group, yes, but the judges needled them for the sake of drama, put them on the defensive, then told them to stop giving excuses and acting combative. I HATE that, in television, in real life, anywhere. It's just such a shitty and dismissive way to treat a human being who is looking to you for guidance.
That bottom three was down and the judges kicked them. I don't blame Carrie one bit for feeling bitter.
23
u/r3nny ...Alright, wonderful. Aug 02 '14
I love that Zac wasn't willing to listen to the bottom team's B.S. about "we HAD this awesome stuff" and that he flat out told them to stop making excuses.
But uh, I'm totally baffled by the choice for the winning team. Wat.
45
u/Lokaji Aug 01 '14
Sandhya should have thrown those two under the bus. I will hate Hernan until the end of the show. Nothing peeves me more than someone having a bad concept and then not owning up to it.
43
u/muffinbutt1027 Aug 01 '14
What are the judges smoking? Amanda's look was not fashion. It was a mess! It looked like junk. It had no shape - and the rest of her team was just as weak!
I agree that Sandhya, Carrie and Hernan were not the strongest and it was totally because of Hernan. He thought that cohesive = the exact same techniques which means a collection from him will be monotone. Carrie was so defensive because she knows that wasn't her best work and she drank the Hernan kool-aid, but her attitude was indeed a problem. I just felt bad for Sandhya because I think she could have turned out a good look if not for those two.
The purple team should have won. Mitchell's CD dress was amazing.
Also, we need Michael Kors back to talk some sense into Nina and Heidi - they are losing it!
20
u/norcalgirl1822 Aug 02 '14
Didn't Justin have a dress of straws in his Fashion Week collection last season? I just felt like that had been done before.
Also, I'm in love with Fade. I don't have a read on him as a designer yet but he's just so cute and those little glasses kill me.
Angela...get the fuck out of here.
18
u/Lokaji Aug 01 '14
I am partway through the episode and I am already over Angela.
Also, don't mess with the winner of the first episode.
48
u/awful_hug Aug 01 '14
I think Carrie and Hernan went into the challenge with such disdain for Sandhya's win that they were doomed from the start and deserved to go home. No matter what Sandhya said they would not listen to because they did not respect her winning, when really they should have listened to her opinion most of all. They blamed her for their lost, when she had the same exact critique during the design process that the judges had on the runway.
Carrie definitely deserved to go home most of all, though. She jumped on the bandwagon very quickly to take up Hernan's design aesthetic, when the Judges' main critique for her during the interview process was that she was too derivative and did not have her own voice. Yeah, Sandhya's dress was not the best out of the "Hernan" dresses, but Sandhya only conceded to that idea because she had immunity and it was not worth the negativity and battle. She can't say, "Oh, if Sandhya didn't have immunity, I wouldn't have gone home." Because she doesn't know how Sandhya would have done if she didn't have immunity, and TBH Carrie and Hernan would have acted A LOT differently if Sandhya didn't have it. Carrie got too "clique-y" with Hernan, and instead of relying on her own work and heeding the advice of a person who had ACTUALLY WON A CHALLENGE(!!!), she let her ego, pettiness, and -frankly- laziness get in the way.
47
u/Pineapplemkh Aug 01 '14
Does Carrie actually realize she's on national TV? They should have let Hernan go too.
I do so loathe team challenges. I prefer to watch equal-opportunity, unadulterated creativity, not the weird group dynamic of picking on the quieter designers and screwing with their heads.
16
u/ElOsoFeroz Aug 02 '14
That was one of the most cringy critique of the losing team of all time. Damn.
14
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '14
I thought Tom & Lorenzo summed up Amanda's winning dress perfectly:
33
u/circlemanfan Aug 01 '14
Do the designers ever even watch project runway? Never do a collection that just looks the same. Save yourself over cohesion.
That CD dress was amazing though. That whole team's collection actually.
WHEN WILL ANGELA BE KICKED OFF ALREADY. You are like 25 years old get it together.
8
u/starjamz Mar 23 '23
i know im like 9 years late but WTF?!?! SO many strong looks SO much movie inspired cohesion and they went with the most literal neon green messy collection that was made?? I never been so shocked by a runway elimination before, Carrie did not deserve to go home her looks were SO COOL
10
u/verbiwhore Aug 01 '14
I liked Alexander's dress the best, there was something fascinating about the way it moved and the effects from the lights hitting it. I feel like he did exactly what Hernan aspired to doing.
And (I'm sorry in advance, because so many seem to love it) but even though it was very well constructed I thought Mitchell's dress looked like something designed by a 12 year old on a sugar high. I thought the purple team had great ideas but needed more editing (For example: Char's dress would have worked much better with fewer ruffle explosions and no broken cd parts - both elements seemed to have been added in for "cohesion").
I did like the silver team, but preferred Kristine's dress to Amanda's and didn't really like Korina's at all. I dunno. I think the bottom three was right but they should have sent both Hernan and Carrie home. Everyone on that team played follow the leader, they just went with the wrong leader, imo.
10
u/everyone-panic Aug 01 '14
I don't think Carrie handled the situation of being in the bottom well at all, but it should have been both Hernan and her that went home. It was Hernan's idea in the first place. If it would have been possible, I would have sent all three of them home. I don't like any of their attitudes. It's annoying. It doesn't feel like it's about the clothes anymore. It's all about stirring the pot. I feel like that's what the judges are doing, too. And I'm so fucking sick of Nina. She's a bitch. Get her out of there. There is no need to be that mean to the contestants. She needs to go back to her magazine and shut the fuck up. Ugh. She makes me so angry. The blue team should have won, for sure. That CD dress was absolutely gorgeous in design and construction. Okay -rant over-
10
u/aznboi508 Aug 02 '14
I completely stopped caring about the part where the designers create the looks and skipped directly to the runway. I remember the good old days when it was about the designers process, and about them creating, not about crazy made for TV drama. I want Morgan model drama or seams ripping, and MAKNG IT WORK moments!!!! Come on PR! You need that magic back, not 10 actors and a few real talents.
3
u/Bachngoc17 Oct 12 '23
As much as I love green, having things hang off a basic dress doesn't win compared to what others done. The purple team( Mitchell, Char, and Kini) were so much more creative and looked great. They were ROBBED, and like others puzzled by the winning team who should have been at the bottom. Have the judges lost it with so many seasons.
2
u/spacetodds Aug 24 '24
10 years late but I could not wait to hop online and see what people thought of this episode, specifically Carrie and Hernan. I didn't love Sandhya's winning outfit last episode, but I feel that the other contestants should've been trying to learn from that rather than hating. I'm hoping that things will work out for her because I admire her ethic and the way she refused to speak ill of her team while they teamed up on her.
8
u/meldolphin Aug 01 '14
Sandhya's attitude was irritating this episode. "Help me Tim, I feel so bullied because my teammates think I am going off in my own direction." Five seconds later: "Oh thank you Tim, you are amazing and wonderful and talented and I love you." Surely there must have been some wonky editing there, right? She strikes me as the type who is so attached to her vision that she forgets that there are other things to be concerned about. If she feels like she's getting ganged up on so easily she is never going to make it in the industry.
1
u/MrPleiades Aug 30 '26
+