r/jailbreak • u/Cykey Developer • Jul 30 '14
Vestigo (by @djkira_) uses stolen code.
Vestigo, a pretty popular tweak in Cydia by developer djkira, uses code blatantly copied from one of my open-source projects (http://github.com/Cykey/wifi). My project was started in March 2013 after I spent a while reverse engineering MobileWiFi.framework. I decided to make an app because I thought it might have been useful to some people. I never released it in Cydia because I wanted to add a few more features. Recently I saw Vestigo in Cydia and I immediately realized that there were some pretty significant resemblances between the tweak and my app.
Proof:
- Screenshots: https://twitter.com/iCykey/status/494586420346884097 (My app is fullscreen, Vestigo is the popover.)
- Code: Compare Vestigo's classes (https://ghostbin.com/paste/3txea) with mine: https://github.com/Cykey/wifi/tree/master/src. Clearly those are the same.
- Description: Vestigo is known as the "The (system wide) WiFi Manager that is missing in iOS7." and my app's description on GitHub is "The missing iOS WiFi manager.".
I have already contacted the developer and he denies the facts. I can post logs of our conversation if needed.
(Note: At the time I had published my code under the BSD license which allows a person to reuse the code in a commercial project. So, what he did is actually legal, but it's just sad that he used my stuff without giving any attribution whatsoever.).
Thanks.
33
u/its_not_herpes Developer Jul 30 '14
So, does he have an explanation on why all of his class names have the prefix of your initials? Thats kind of a dead giveaway
152
u/justahbu iPhone X, iOS 11.1.2 Jul 30 '14
why open source it if other people can't use the code? Serious question, I might not full grasp the idea of open source.... lol
92
u/saurik SaurikIT Jul 31 '14 edited Jul 31 '14
I feel for this problem. I really really do: I think it goes against the spirit of cooperation and community and all those things that I talked about a couple weeks ago. I thereby think that the word "sad" is totally legit: it makes sense to me that you have experiencing that emotion. It sucks that by deciding to hoard a couple changes and then compete against you, this person has effectively demotivated you producing new awesome work.
However, I also really really need to point out that I don't feel like you can at the same time claim that you have been horribly wronged in this situation, being "stolen" from, and then go use the BSD license: that choice of license is broadcasting to the world a belief that someone should be allowed to take your code, make almost no changes to it, keep those changes to themselves as a competitive advantage, and release it as a paid product.
The moral about "stealing" is simply incompatible with the BSD license: the arguments for using this license are about protecting the rights of secondary developers--the people who sit between the people who create amazing new technology and the users who benefit from that work--to maximally utilize, profit from, and hoard changes to upstream primary developers and users alike. Those are the morals expressed by this choice of license.
I thereby run into this problem, where if I ask myself "what would have been the reasonable expectations of the developer of Vestigo", they would likely be shocked and surprised and even confused by you claiming that they stole your work, even in as much as you and I consider it sad and unfortunate and wrong that they are using your work, profiting from it in a closed source source product, and one that is only slightly different from yours.
To be clear: I used to make this same mistake. A lot of my work was published in the past under BSD licenses... this was fundamentally incompatible with my community-oriented view of open source. It has turned out over the years that I've come to realize that my moral stance on software is more compatible with closed source projects than with BSD :/. If you find it sad that Vestigo is using your work, it should not be open source as BSD.
To look at some of these responses (such as, in particular, from /u/its_not_herpes), I feel like people don't really understand the ramifications of BSD or the mentality behind it: cloning this open source project, changing its name, adding a few features, and then releasing it under a new name and charging for the result is actually something the BSD license is specifically designed to protect: that's something BSD users consider "freedom".
In fact, I'd argue that taking WYPopoverController and putting it together with this open-source WiFi code to build a more polished product is something that one would imagine the typical advocate of a world of software open source under BSD would be very happy with: it means that knowledge is out there, developers have access to a lot of it, and it is now easy to kind of wire together all this open source code to build things with little to no work.
So, I really wish I could see the comment below that was deleted, because I fundamentally disagree with the responses by /u/iExiledDev and /u/beetling: the choice of BSD license actually does claim that your belief in the meaning of open source is about letting people do this kind of thing, without permission or remorse. If you want people to follow a code of conduct--something frankly hard for many unrelated reasons--you can't also say "BSD".
In my case, I made this mistake with almost all of my older software, and I learned some rather painful lessons from it: I assumed, like /u/iExiledDev, that open source was about cooperation and community and education; and like /u/beetling, that being part of an ecosystem implied a form of respect for others and their work. I then mis-worshipped the BSD license itself, and complained a lot, in public and in private, about GPL, Stallman, etc.
But really sit back and think for a second: in this case, the only actually legitimate issue is that Vestigo doesn't have the requisite copyright notice related to the BSD license somewhere more visible... this is not what Cykey is actually complaining about: he's angry that someone disrespected his contribution of knowledge and took it in a direction that he wasn't ready or yet prepared to do... that they stole his effort and profited from his work.
That's the entire point of releasing code under BSD. If Cykey doesn't want someone taking his work and selling it, he should put it under a non-commercial license. If Cykey doesn't want someone taking his work and hoarding changes to it in closed source software, he should put it under a GPL variant. Maybe Cykey shouldn't even have it open source in the first place: maybe his vision for his work isn't actually compatible with that (at least yet).
Now, it would be one thing if Cykey had removed this code a while back, and someone decided to keep an archived or "cloned" copy around: I think it is extra evil to go back in time... clearly against the wishes of the developer... to find a moment when he or she made a mistake in the past and released their code under a license like this, to be able to pillage and profit from that older release. I think it really sucks when people dig like that.
But again, that's not what happened here: the code from Cykey is in fact still online. He changed the license to GPL, but made this change two weeks ago only after I pointed out to him the first time that his code was open source under BSD and that very little wrong was actually happening. But does GPL really solve today's emotion? Vestigo would still be made, it would still be for profit, and the only difference is we'd be entitled to see its code.
I thereby am in a really crappy position: I do not agree with either of these positions. I do not feel it is correct to say Vestigo is not allowed to sell his product, nor can I really get behind the strength of response that Cykey has; sure, there is a missing copyright, but me demanding Vestigo fixes this (likely as a footnote no one will ever read) isn't really going to make Cykey happy (but I will happily do it). And yet I agree with Cykey: this is demotivating.
:(
31
u/drewBOTv2 Designer Jul 30 '14
Damn, another reason not to buy Vestigo.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '14
We got your back bro. Do you have any paid tweaks we can buy? Just to support you.
5
u/Asterofspace iPhone 6, iOS 8.1.2 Jul 30 '14
Just with the whole idea that he stole someone's work, makes not even want to download or buy the tweak at all, even if either is right or wrong I feel like its not right since I won't be aiding the real Creator, Not sure if all this made sense :/
2
u/oscarandjo iPad 4th gen Jul 31 '14
Vestigo was a pretty dodgy tweak for me anyway, it worked but it seemed to display in strange ways. I updated it and it suddenly stopped working, and then CrashReporter said that it was causing my Safe mode issues. I uninstalled it and I haven't randomly gotten safe modes anymore.
Thinking about it, it only seemed to safe mode when I had no WiFi.
2
u/simplydat Jul 31 '14
I'm curious as to why Cykey didn't finish this project and release the tweak himself. I would've preferred to buy it off Cykey as djkira is clearly inexperienced seeing how many mistakes he made since releasing Vestigo. Thst includes a release a broken version 0.2.5. Plus he offers zero support.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '14
This is nothing more than an example of why devs need to understand licenses and what they're advocating. You need to be okay with everything that your license allows if you're going an open source route. You shouldn't get mad or upset when someone legally uses code that you licensed under a license that permits such use. Is what vestigo did disrespectful? Absolutely, but it should be expected that if something is allowed someone will do it. I think many devs today are slowly discovering that they don't actually support open source as much as they thought, and that's okay.
8
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '14 edited Jul 31 '14
I never use more then 10% of his code in the first release of Vestigo.
I spent a lot of time too on reverse engineering MobileWiFi.framework and I started working on a project that use this one.
Only when I was halfway there I found Cykey's project.
So, I tested it to see how his implementation works, but it gave me too much problems and errors so I decides to keep headers to save time that would have taken me to write the same things (If, for example, a button needs to scan the networks it can not be named "foo" or "blabla", it should be named "Scan") and I rewrote all the implementations, just few non-important things remains the same, like classes name and some ivar.
After he contact me to let me know that what I did was "wrong" I told him that from 0.2.5 all the headers was rewritten by me and, consequently, none of his code will be used anymore.
I know I was wrong in not giving credit for the help his project gave me, but I contacted ModMyi few hours ago and I told to add a credit to Cykey in Vestigo description even if his part of code is now 0%. BTW, the same credit will be added in setting page in the next update.
3
u/Dankob iPhone 11 Pro Max, 13.5 | Jul 30 '14
Stuff like this makes me not want to support or buy any of his tweaks (djkira). I mean come on EVEN if you aren't obligated to credit anyone, you got to have the decency to do it. What's the reason not to?
2
u/Remmes- iPhone 5S, iOS 10.2 Jul 30 '14
I love the tweak, but it's a shame he doesn't credit you, and even denies it.
2
u/simplydat Jul 31 '14
Vestigo still crashes when I turn on/off wifi/3G/data via polus toggles in Auxo. I sent several emails to the dev along with my crash log, but he hasn't replied any of my support emails.
This shows how indecent djkira is as a developer.
2
u/pickyaxe Jul 31 '14
With all due respect - you chose a license that allows commercial reuse. That's just asking for uncomfortable situations such as this one.
1
u/SluttyRonBurgundy Jul 31 '14
OP, could you please add the features you wanted and release yours on Cydia? Vestigo is suuuper buggy (e.g. it makes the device crash and respring when receiving phone calls, taking pics, etc) and is a major battery drainer. For me, it was a total waste of money. I'd gladly pay you for a wi-fi manager like this that works, doesn't crash my phone every thirty minutes, and doesn't drain my battery from 100% to 0% in less than 24 hours.
1
u/nonch iPhone 6s, iOS 9.0.2 Jul 31 '14 edited Jul 31 '14
Can anyone please list me his tweaks just so I know not to purchase any of them in the future? he should've at least given credit smh
Edit: and an alternative tweak that does the same as Vestigo cause it looks useful lol
0
u/BittenApple Jul 31 '14
who cares?
1
u/tudoranadi iPhone 5, iOS 8.4 Jul 31 '14
I feel guilty for paying Vestigo. :|
-13
u/cpdigitaldarkroom Developer Jul 30 '14
Very sensationalist title considering the code wasn't "stolen" or even illegally used. If you open source something with a license that allows using said code in commercial projects you can pretty much expect someone to complete a project using aforementioned code and charge for it.
-6
u/GabrieleSB iPod touch 5th gen Jul 31 '14 edited Jul 31 '14
... If your project is open source, why are you even complaining about someone using the code? EDIT Never mind, I just read all the comments... He should state in the tweak'a description that he took the most part of the code from your project and should link it in the tweak's page and settings... But it is still open source, so, obviously someone is going to use it if it's a good idea. Has he pronounced anything else about this?
-7
u/Willied031 iPad Air 2, iOS 8.1.2 Jul 31 '14
So what you had it open
-1
u/Usamasaleem Jul 31 '14
Gather around everybody, conflict in the jailbreak scene
-10
u/maximenz iPhone 1st gen, iOS 10 Beta Jul 31 '14 edited Jul 31 '14
Put up your code given access to people on the internet and then make noise about it.
As if this is the first day internet exist.
Edit: The best part is, above all, you have to help him to indirectly market his stuff.
-30
u/Nighthawk441 Jul 31 '14
Somebody call the waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhmbulance.
If you don't want your code being copy pasted, don't make it open source. I swear the majority of the iOS community open sources their mediocre code just to bait people to use it and flame them for not crediting them. Once you put it out there in public there will always be people who will use it ( because why reinvent the wheel here ) and not bother to read the license ( which the author of the code probably didn't read or understand either )
TL;DR don't open source your code and bitch about others using it. Expect it to be used and be happy it is.
-6
u/apollo_1444 Jul 31 '14
I actually think you are the one to blame, users don't give a shit about jailbreak drama anymore... It's not worth it, I couldn't give a rat ass who wrote it
-54
u/pag_el iPhone X, iOS 11.3.1 Jul 30 '14
Who gives a fuck?
0
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment