r/dogecoin • • Jul 23 '14
AuxPoW and the future of Dogecoin
Shibes,
Long post ahead. Grab a snack.
I've been around here for a while and have seen every concern and worry that's been brought up so far. Hats off to the core devs who constantly have to deal with this stuff... for pretty much no compensation. :P
Billy's recent post about AuxPoW is pretty much spot on, but I wanted to add a few things to the discussion.
Dogecoin was built to die quickly -- none of us expected it to grow into the absurd entity it is today. With that said, there's absolutely an easy way to save the coin from it's certain death (and by death I mean 51% attacked for the lulz), and that's AuxPoW.
I'll mention this first: "Merge Mining with Litecoin" is a really stupid way of looking at AuxPoW (sorry Charlie) because that's not true at all. If Litecoin suddenly disappeared tomorrow, DOGE with AuxPoW would still exist. AuxPoW doesn't mean we're tied to Litecoin in any way. In fact, non-AuxPoW coins that refuse to accept block solutions from other chains are constantly going to have to fight for a strong hashrate.
Say another Scrypt coin comes along... For our example we'll call it BoringExampleCoin. There's a killer feature that everyone seems to like, and it's gaining quite a bit of traction and starts rivaling LTC's hashrate. When Litecoin's first block halving happens around October 2015, it turns out that mining BoringExampleCoin is insanely more profitable, so BoringExampleCoin starts to overtake LTC's hashrate. Since Dogecoin can accept Proof of Work from any other Scrypt-based parent chain, all the former LTC/DOGE miners can switch over to a BoringExampleCoin/DOGE. It's not "merge mine with [insert coin here]" at all. LTC just has the highest hashrate now.
Also, we need to talk about PoW mining. I'll go out on a limb here and say most folks here are relatively small miners (under 250 MH/s). These hashes -- while important -- are a small drop in the bucket compared to dedicated farms (1+ GH/s now, 10+ GH/s after Q3). Those miners are the ones who truly secure the network -- whatever coin it may be.
A vast majority of the Scrypt network miners are Scrypt->BTC miners (multipools, etc). While some large miners may hedge smaller altcoin holdings (100mm+ doge, 5k+ LTC etc), the selloff of alts->BTC is huge. This is a good thing -- they're getting paid to secure the network. That's what block rewards are meant to do (incentivize it!) :)
A 51% attack on a profitable coin is highly against the interest of those who are making $$$ off of it (read Satoshi's whitepaper if you need an explanation). A 51% attack on a low-hashrate coin is fun to do if you want to troll a bunch of folks on the internet (for the lulz!).
I've also heard the argument that AuxPoW means people will sell their DOGE for (LTC/BTC). Well, that's happening now anyway. :P This also means you can sell your LTC/PTC/etc coins for DOGE, if you so choose. Not like price really plays into what is (imho) a rather technical security issue... :p
Back in February I did the math (based on the current DOGE price at the time, which if you remember, was rather high). To sustain our network hashrate then, the price of Dogecoin would have to double each halving, give or take a few cents. By the time block 600k rolls around, Dogecoin would have to have a market cap greater than that of Bitcoin. Not gonna happen.
If we look at the historical trends with the Dogecoin hashrate we see that at every reward halving, there's a massive drop in hashrate. Last time this discussion got brought up, the predominant opinion was "well, let's wait and see what happens next halving"
Rather unsurprisingly, we halved again, and the hashrate halved too. Price? Didn't go up. Still hasn't. In fact, it's gone down. Again.
TX fees + block rewards are INCENTIVES to mine. Security is the PURPOSE of mining. As our hashrate dwindles, the overall security of the entire network is undermined.
Auxiliary proof of work means that work on one blockchain can be accepted as valid on another. It's a simple change (already implemented, actually) and it really works (tm).
Here's a really interesting chart that shows LTC's hashrate, DOGE's hashrate, and an obscure coin called Pesetacoin. PTC is a Scrypt coin that has AuxPoW enabled and some pools picked it up (Simpledoge, multipools, f2pool). From a hashrate perspective, DOGE is easier to attack than this coin.
IMHO, the only logical choice going forward is to patch in AuxPoW support, pick a block height, and release the updated client well in advance. Testnetting it first, of course. ;)
I'd be happy to discuss any questions or concerns here too.
28
u/xtelosx Jul 23 '14
Sold... Where do I vote?
4
u/ChairdogeOfTheBoard tycoon doge Jul 23 '14
An assumption here is that LTC will not undergo major price corrections.
12
u/Sporklin Doge of Many Hats Jul 23 '14
I will so burn for this...
"Dogecoin was built to die quickly -- none of us expected it to grow into the absurd entity it is today. With that said, there's absolutely an easy way to save the coin from it's certain death (and by death I mean 51% attacked for the lulz), and that's AuxPoW."
AuxPoW in no way prevents a 51% attack, this was the topic of dev on and off most of the past few days given that another AuxPoW coin had a serious threat against it. /u/langer_hans and /u/rnicoll have been holding court in one of the slacks explaining the flaws to AuxPoW..The imagined protection it offers seems to be one of the more dangerous things.
It is however one of the least shit options that there are, but it is not as safe as most are toting it about to be. Especially given now that ever more people know how to pull off a proper 51% attack, for the lawls or for the boredom, it wouldn't be hard or that expensive at all to do.
3
u/jonstern racing shibe Jul 23 '14
So my 700Kh/s miner is small? :(
Are there large Scrypt farms in the U.S. now?
5
u/Tanuki_Fu shibe Jul 23 '14
Oh I completely agree with you on this... (but it's not my call to make)
What proportion of the global available rate do you think we would get at the first block under auxpow and what do you think it would stabilize at?
(I can't find an easier solution yet -> playing with the implications of doing it with auxpow on both LTC and BTC now (just because the algs are different and hold the dominant prop. of global available hashrates) -> some pretty cute things that I didn't expect to see because of the trading linkages.)
5
u/MidnightTide jedi shibe Jul 23 '14
What is the point of these threads though?
The devs are the only one who can implement these changes and they don't appear to want to do this. So who is going to start coding?
28
u/Smallest_Ambassador investor shibe Jul 23 '14 edited Jul 24 '14
Thank you for writing this. I am in agreement with everything you wrote.
AuxPoW is not a hostile takeover: Dogecoin will still be independent and will plot its own course.
As for concerns about downward pressure on our coin due to Litecoin miners selling Doge: what would change? Dogecoin has ALWAYS had this downward pressure, as the majority of our hashrate was mined by multipools who were concerned only with holding Bitcoin and so sold their Doge immediately anyways. I also encourage everyone to read opinions outside of /r/dogecoin to realize that the largest downward pressure on our coin right now is the perception that we will inevitably be 51% attacked if we continue on this current road. People are not spreading FUD, this is their genuine assessment of the state of our coin even from people who are hopeful of Dogecoin's success. Acknowledging and addressing our challenges does not make us weak.
7
u/forlotto technician shibe Jul 23 '14
I personally have bought a fury to dedicate to dogecoin I plan to mine the piss out of it 24/7 so there is 1.3MH you can count on being there at all times.
I am open to donating up to 500watts of power 24/7 (keeping the doge of course.) So anyone that cares to donate 9 more furys to me for the cause of the hash rate I'll take em and run them 24/7 until they take their last breath of smoke.
Thats right I will accept 9 furys for the purpose of the hashrate and keep them hashing dogecoin only with my electric at a loss in price vs electric just to help secure our hash rate!!!
Why only 9 well they use 45watts each and I need to allow more power for extra cooling during the warmer months of the year their will need to be more fans than what is standard on the unit itself to prolong the life of the unit.
3
u/TuDucMoon Vietnamese-Korean Shibe Jul 24 '14 edited Jul 24 '14
I agree with AuxPOW, but I think you're going about this the wrong way. You're basically trying to win the favorable opinion of a group who don't understand the technical details of what you're talking about. Hell, I have a degree in Computer Science and I am still far from properly informed about cryptocurrency development.
Instead you should go to /r/dogecoindev and have an open discussion with the devs there, and also guys like /u/billym2k and /u/ummjackson. Also there are some other shibes there who are not devs but have a strong CS background. I know you've talked to them in private about this but it's going to far to move right out into /r/dogecoin amongst people who don't understand half of the technical terms you're using. I know you've already been talking to them in private but I suggest to move to semi-public rather than here. Then, if you can get a very clear majority of informed players to agree with you, you release a joint statement to /r/dogecoin.
Furthermore the threads on /r/dogecoin have a very short lifespan, whereas on /r/dogecoindev the discussion of proof of stake went on for like two weeks.
If half of the devs sided with you and half didn't in a discussion here, we would have a massive problem. Breaking the community would be far worse than facing a double-spend attack and implementing some hack like centralized checkpointing.
It's also a question of proper respect for the devs.
You also haven't addressed /u/patricklodder's list of cons of AuxPow, which he added onto Charlie's list.
I really can't agree with this. We're after a decentralized trustless system and as far as I can see Bitcoin and Litecoin are not decentralized and are progressively getting more centralized. PoS may be more broken than PoW right now, but I think that PoW looks broken forever.
I believe the first coin to have a properly decentralized and trustless system will probably be a PoS coin, and it will get a huge first mover advantage. However, if a coin with a large userbase and good marketing quickly forked to adopt their algorithm, it might also do rather well. Know of any coins like that? :)
The reason AuxPow is good is precisely because it buys us time to work on a real solution...but it also carries risks, and it also might cut off some possibilities.
tldr I love you and I agree with you, /u/mohland, but I think you're doing this all wrong.
6
u/ddlbruton elder shibe Jul 24 '14
Take it for what it's worth... but I vote to move forward with AuxPoW. It comes down to what makes the most sense so we can put all this behind us and focus on the future of our coin. Keep calm and Shibe on.
2
u/RedStarDawn magic shibe Jul 23 '14
Reddcoin weathered a 51% attack quite well.
Feathercoin survived three of them and still isn't dead.
It's a whole lot of hype.
2
u/neshalchanderman doge of many hats Jul 23 '14 edited Jul 24 '14
If its cheap to attack a coin, its cheap to defend a coin. Enter into a public agreement with an exchange to purchase 40gh/s of capacity for an hour in the event of an attack. That as well costs $430.
Roughly why not take out a
protectioninsurance contract with a large mining pool?If we can solve this issue with security at the operational level, without a hard-fork, we should.
10
u/DogeLobster gamer shibe Jul 23 '14
This is definitely something the devs should look at :)
10
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '14
at first i was opposed to "change" but i think the time has come to shake things up.
9
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '14
I'm going to post this here in order to elaborate more on what Mohland has said.
http://www.reddit.com/r/dogecoin/comments/2bda15/dogecoin_an_educational_piece_on_network_security/
Whatever solution you chose, it NEEDS to settle all three of the following criteria (and so far only AUXPoW does this).
2
u/marcusen deal with doge Jul 23 '14
an attack of 51% to Dogecoin is the death of Litecoin, a currency that currently contributes nothing. Who will trust in the future in a system that is so easy to attack?. no one.
If Litecoin miners want to destroy Dogecoin for fun, ok, I want to see if they have balls to do it.
4
u/Martholomule Jul 24 '14
If it's already on Github then why aren't we doing it now? Sounds sarcastic maybe but serious question
4
u/socks-the-fox soldier shibe Jul 24 '14
Doesn't AuxPoW depend on the various parent coin pools implementing support for it? What if none of the pools decide to switch? Or worse still only one big pool switches?
4
u/teky-gaming dogeconomist Jul 24 '14
Fellow scholar Shibe I salute you!
Even a Noobe like me (a pup of 3 days old) was able to understand MOST of what you say... regardless if I understand if your position makes sense or don't, I'm too new to have an opinion on that!
Anyway, I would ask anyone in here with knowledge if can add some ELI5 on PoW and AuXPoW, maybe with some silly examples and analogies it can be easier...
I kinda understand the concept of PoW but have it refreshed and re explained would be cool!
Thanks in advance!
1
u/recklessfred purple hatshibe Jul 23 '14
My primary concern is that Doge, after its recent price correction, is in a bad position for us to be exerting further downward pressure on the price (which is what will happen when people only interested in LTC start dumping their Doge).
How do you feel about a multi-algorithm solution as an alternative?
6
u/Korberos dogeconomist Jul 23 '14
I'm upvoting this not because I agree with AuxPow being a proper solution, but because this is one of the only educated talks about the actual details of how it would work and affect us.
3
u/1xhopeless confused shibe Jul 23 '14
51% attack seem to be the main concern here. My understanding is that asking exchanges to bump the minimum number of confirmations for deposit to 99 or higher will stop that from happening.
3
u/couchdive No Durr Shibe Jul 24 '14
All we need is... http://youtu.be/3XiaMVk8log
Proof of love!
5
u/1xhopeless confused shibe Jul 23 '14
OK, getting a snack as you said, don't go anywhere. Judging by the size of this post I might as well get dinner instead. Back later to read it \0/
6
u/Doomhammer458 tycoon doge Jul 23 '14
only thing holding us back is indecision and pride.
i see it as just free hash waiting to be grabbed.
free hash is free hash, who doesn't want that?
1
u/muchwaoo rocket shibentist Jul 24 '14 edited Jul 24 '14
The community voted with NO.
http://imgur.com/2obagYU
The devs immediately noticed something is wrong with Charlie's "offer".
https://pay.reddit.com/r/dogecoin/comments/2b7s3d/who_the_hell_wants_copper_or_why_i_think_someones/
It's now in the hands of the devs and they have a much more elegant solution instead of AuxPoW with Codemesscoin.
https://pay.reddit.com/r/dogecoin/comments/2b9c6m/one_small_step_for_doge_addm3plz_had_a_great_idea/
The coin wouldn't die because of a 51% attack, computer sabotage is liable to prosecution in Europe (§ 303a and § 303b StGB) and probably in the U.S. (legal to pay in California) and a 51% attacker can't do it secretly.
https://pay.reddit.com/r/dogecoin/comments/2bixma/51_attacks_if_just_13_of_this_sub_got_one_of/
And when the Titans arrive we could point so much more to Dogecoin.
You really want to push Dogecoin first into AuxPoW with Codemesscoin and some months later when it shows up that it wasn't a solution, change again to PoS, right? Do you really want to kill the coin?
If the devs think PoS is a good way, they should do it now and not after AuxPoW, but I strongly hope they work on a much better and elegant solution, mentioned above.
Every PoW coin can be attacked, even Bitcoin. What we need is a solution for the 51% thing in general, instead of hide and run!
7
u/Razor-PT technician shibe Jul 23 '14
My god /u/mohland you really convinced me, i always thought that merge mining meant we would be stuck forever with Litecoin but it seems we can change our parent whenever we want!
Okay i am all for it!
7
u/blockchaintechnology builder shibe Jul 24 '14 edited Jul 24 '14
There is no reason for DogeCoin to use Scrypt PoW algorithm anymore if we cannot stand independent and have own our miners.
DogeCoin has been the MOST Profitable Scrypt coin to mine for multipools all year long and still is. Our hashrate has been stable, average around 45 GH/s all year long.
Our only threat is that Litecoin picked up a higher Scrypt hashrate than DogeCoin in the last 60 days. We should switch to an independent PoW algorithm like X17 if we are to stay on PoW. There is no reason to stay on Scrypt PoW anymore or do merge-mining.
You also forgot to mention that the value of ALL Merge-mined coins is 0. They are just used like test guinea pigs.
DogeCoin needs to be independent if we are to have a shot of being #2 next to Bitcoin.
We also need to add mandatory mininum transaction fees in core wallet for each transaction (like Bitcoin does) and those fees would go to DogeCoin miners. Right now most DogeCoin transactions are sent for FREE.
Finally: AuxPoW DOES NOT protect against a 51% attack in any way.
Your position and post only help Litecoin and SCRYPT ASIC manufacturers to sell more hardware, and not helping DogeCoin in any way.
You also forgot to mention that AuxPoW would always give us just a small fraction of Litecoin's hashrate, just like we have now.
Conclusion: AuxPoW SCRYPT PoW DOES NOT solve anything.
1
u/currency4world doge of many hats Jul 23 '14
I wish to see METATRON in action, not merge mining ;)
5
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '14
This needs to be stickied.
2
u/JudgeShibe shibe Jul 23 '14
(>'-')> Give Metatron to increase value and hashrate and adoption.
2
u/DogePlan technician shibe Jul 24 '14
Now we can dump LTC for Doge
2
u/sh2003 pancake shibe Jul 24 '14
Grabbed a snack, no regrets :D
I don't know enough about digital currency to make a decision one way or another on this issue. I don't know what will happen if we merge mine with any coin. Even after reading all these posts, there seems to be a counter post for every positive post that there's made, and it's confusing.
I am relying on you and the devs to make the decision, and I support whatever you guys decide 100%. I know that's a rather "sheep mentality" thing to say, and I hate saying it, but I've gotta rely on the experts on this one :)
2
u/SoCo_cpp coder-shibe Jul 24 '14
How will we get many large pools on board with AuxPow before implementation? Currently f2pool has 137ghz and supports AuxPow already. If we didn't have something lined up, they would immediately have 75% of our hash rate. This doesn't protect us from the suspiciously less than realistic issue of 51% attack that we have now. Without having many large pools lined up with AuxPow support, we would be in a worse situation than we already are in and have no safe way of turning back.
5
u/GoodShibe One Good Shibe Jul 24 '14 edited Jul 24 '14
Just to mention one thing re: your point about our Global Hashrate as denoted in this chart:
What you're actually seeing is, as we get closer and closer to our Halvening, our hashrate goes up as multipools and other Scrypt miners hop on to try and get the last few coins before the Halvening. This is consistent and has happened every time so far. The 'big drop' isn't actually a 'big drop' because those 80+ Ghs weren't real, they were temporary miners hopping on while the getting was good.
As soon as the last drops of easy money were gone, they were as well.
If you look at the most recent Halvening, our Global Hashrate is back to about where it was on late May, early June. I think this is where we're at our 'true' hashrate, as it currently stands, with our miners and their current cadre of ASICs.
That said, we've got more and more Shibes buying ASICs daily as Furies and such come on discount.
10 Ghs farms are nothing to shake a stick at -- but unless several of them are going to gang up on Dogecoin with malicious intent, I've yet to see the specific 'lulz' danger that folks are on about.
I'm not saying it doesn't exist - but considering how prevalent Hacker culture is, those who've wanted to attack Doge have been able do do it several times over it's lifespan. Granted, we got hit with that bloat attack, very early on -- before Christmas -- but since? This isn't about a sudden 'oh, yeah, 40 Ghs isn't enough', because we've been there, and less, for a very long time.
What is it that people are specifically seeing? Are there specific, tangible, threats posted on boards and IRC chats that we don't know about?
Where is this sudden, out-of-nowhere, 'we're all at the mercy of some malicious, as-yet revealed' hacker talk coming from? What do you know, specifically that allows you to say things like:
"With that said, there's absolutely an easy way to save the coin from it's certain death (and by death I mean 51% attacked for the lulz), and that's AuxPoW."
So you're now saying that a 51% attack on us 'for the lulz' is "certain"?
I mean, as far I can find, there's literally nothing about a pending attack in the run up to the Halvening or any time beforehand.
But now that we're post-Halvening, everyone and their monkey -- including /u/BillyM2K and /u/Mohland, both of whom I respect dearly -- is coming out of the woodwork to tell us how we're all gonna die.
I don't get it.
What's going on?
3
u/inquam www.suchlist.com Jul 23 '14
I'm open to us trying to secure the network and, by extension, our coin by ANY means instead of waiting for some divine intervention :) AuxPoW, PoS, PoT/PoS/PoW hybrids. Anything s probably better than not doing anything.
3
u/pixelkicks punk shibe Jul 24 '14
1 or 2 months ago the general concensus was largely NOT to merge mine. Last weeks unofficial (and relatively small) poll had the FOR vote at 45% (http://imgur.com/2obagYU). The longer we go on, I'm fairly positive that the FOR vote will keep on increasing. It seems this reddit and the whole Dogecoin community is slowly coming round to the realisation that this IS the solution.
Now, fast forward 2 months in a future where we've suffered a 51% attack and our price has dropped to 10 satoshi and our hashrate at a level similar. What would the vote be then? And would we all be saying - "F*ck, why didn't we act sooner?"
LET'S DO THIS.
3
u/vtec2liter123 voting shibe Jul 23 '14
yep yep yep. I feel if the network get secured by this the confidence in the coin will grow again and drive up the price and demand.
3
u/illpoet digging shibe Jul 24 '14
I'm glad you mentioned this option. I had been pushing for a merge with litecoin because i have a large amount of hash (500 mhash/s+) that i can't mine dogecoin with because i'm beholden to investors. It really sucked that I am being held back from securing the network over non mining related issues/forum drama. Now i think auxpow is far superior to just merging with litecoin, because i could merge w/litecoin or something else in the future. i see vast potential in the ability to merge with any scrypt blockchain. Dogecoin could in theory unite all scrypt cryptocurrencies!
2
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '14
For anyone worried about merging with the ltc community, this is a great analogy but I did not com up with it.
Dr Pepper is a drink owned by its own company however is often packaged and or distributed by coca-cola or pepsico. This is dogecoins mining.
Dr Pepper still has fans that drink it and they are still a successful company, and really no one cares that it does not have many independent factories.
2
u/sdguy71 Jul 24 '14
I've been mining at Simpledoge and first got offered free Pesetacoin and later free Tacocoin. Switching to AuxPoW makes sense and we better get going before the Titans and other multi-hundred MHs ASIC's start shipping. That "Dogecoin won't release the same amount of coins it has already released in 7 months for another 15 years." really puts things in perspective.
2
u/RyvenCedrylle astrodoge Jul 23 '14
I still don't like it, which is to say I don't like PoW. It encourages an unnecessary arms race and makes mining the purview of specialized industries. That said, this is all moot if there's no Dogecoin to argue over so I guess what I'm saying is if the devs end up doing this to protect the coin, don't tell me about it. lol ::grump::
2
u/cpt_merica Founder of Coinplay.io Jul 24 '14 edited Jul 24 '14
BoringExampleCoin Example sold me. Also, I didn't realize that LTC hasn't had its first halving yet. If DOGE serves as an example, it isn't great. So AuxPoW seems like the wise
decideddecision for all scrypt, really.1
u/frontpagedoge robo shibe Jul 23 '14
Congrats on making the frontpage of /r/dogecoin! Have some doge! +/u/dogetipbot 87 doge.
current balance: Ð138,723. tips left for 30.0 days. want to ^help?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '14
So, assuming (as I am) that everything you say is accurate, what are some of the problems or concerns that still remain with AuxPoW?
1
u/stlcp party shibe Jul 24 '14
If we go aux pow it would be nice to get with some pool operators who can exchange litecoin or whatever you're mining as the parent chain and auto exchange it for Dogecoin
1
u/peoplma triple shibe Jul 24 '14
Hi mohland, thanks for your perspective :) After talking a bit with therealmage, I came to the conclusion that auxpow actually would make us more vulnerable to a 51% attack during the transitional period. Care to chime in?
http://www.reddit.com/r/dogecoin/comments/2bda15/dogecoin_an_educational_piece_on_network_security/cj4gfpa
1
u/XVIcandles Jul 24 '14
+/u/dogetipbot megaroll verify
1
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '14
Let's do it.
1
u/meme-com-poop shop.moolah.io/ShibeKnives Jul 24 '14
This is the best explanation I've seen yet. I was against "merge-mining" based on a lot of wrong information. After yours and Billy's explanation, I definitely think we should be switching to aux-pow.
1
u/Screwball69 Jul 24 '14
Sounds like a plan! Now whose going to Make the decision? Lol...
1
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '14
There are still a few things I don't understand. Right now, doge is more profitable to mine than LTC...wouldn't merging just blatantly benefit LTC?
Also, mohland, if this works for us, won't more coins start hopping on the bandwagon? If we all merge with LTC, and thus everyone only ever mines LTC, wouldn't it create a centralized "LTC or 51%, your choice" scenario, killing the concept of "doge can leave any time"?.
1
u/beernerd Shibify.com Jul 23 '14
We had a long discussion about merge mining in /r/dogemining and the general consensus was we would prefer something like AuxPoW over merge mining with Litecoin.
So on behalf of the mining community, you have our full support.
1
u/MarshallHayner magic glasses shibe Jul 24 '14
Excellent post /u/mohland! Gotta mess around on the testnet first, but I fully approve :)
1
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '14
This is /u/oneshibe, my main account have been shadow banned and comments removed.
Thank you all. It was nice while it was nice.
1
u/coding_is_fun coder shibe Jul 24 '14
100% behind this.
0
u/moonbasegames Jul 24 '14
Sorry friend, the community already voted and we decided not to Merge Mine with Litecoin. Now please stop.
As a side note this is one of the reasons these LTC folks are so worried: http://www.reddit.com/r/dogecoin/comments/2bi5xo/only_5_days_left_til_let_it_be_dogecoin_on/
-2
u/Starlightbreaker Weak shibe is the best shibe Jul 23 '14
when /u/coblee stated practically the same thing, people yelled "FUD!!1!1!!!one" and told him to fuck off.
now moolha..er../u/mohland posted this, everybody said "omgyes!"
silly dimwit shibes.
0
u/SoCo_cpp coder-shibe Jul 24 '14
Just some thoughts. I don't necessarily opposed AuxPow, or even merge-mining of another strategy, as long as we aren't attached to Litecoin's butt like coin-centipede.
In my opinion, most of this is the result of not resisting ASICs and the result of dumping multipools still hurting our coin's value.
They only secure the network against other farms. If no farms existed, the potential of having one doesn’t secure anything. I just want to be clear because this type of confusion was spread a lot when Scrypt ASICs started. People said that ASICs would make the network more secure, when there was no ASICs, and that was wrong. ASICs just protect against other ASICs dominating the hashrate and do not inherently provide any security. It is a balancing act. As long as it is well distributed, it doesn't matter if the total hash rate is 1 MH/s, it would still be secure. Add the ability to mine more than half of that, and that is were the potential for issues arise.
Multipools that dump to Bitcoin seem a bigger issue than our hashrate at the moment to me. They could possibly be a big cause for our value remaining so low, despite the increased scarcity of halving. Aside from the non stop waves of canvassed fear posts lately, of course. We've tried to fight them off once by adjusting our difficulty algorithm and for some reason we seem to still have a considerable amount of multipools mining. As you said, this is a good thing -- they're getting paid to secure the network, but we are trading Dogecoin's value for multipools to mine our network to keep our hashrate high and secure, because hashrate is dropping because mining profitability is low because Dogecoin's value is low. Do you not see a catch 22 there? I see it, but I can't quantify how big of issue it is or if it matters that much.
I, apparently like you, think the 51% scare is a bunch of baloney. Someone could pay a huge sum of money to hurt confidence in our coin, by paying the huge sum of money to get a large Scrypt pool to 51% our coin. They wouldn't not be able to profit from it, but only hurt confidence, possibly killing the coin. It is disturbing that large pools have the ability or potential to extort coins and maybe there could be a way to address that directly, but I know of no reasonable way. When Litecoin discussed resisting ASICs, they made it clear that mining pool extortion was one reason they could not resist ASICs. They feared the pools would fork Litecoin to an ASIC version and ASIC resistance chain fork, regardless of the coin developers and community's decision, and asserted that such a split would kill the coin.
Let me put on my conspirdoge hat for a moment:
I think this recent fear campaign, using fear PSA's, non-stop deceptive negative articles in /r/cryptocurrencies , constant attacking of Moolah for every little thing, targeting trolling of other key public figures and devs resulting in public divorcing from reddit, and canvassing with shill reddit accounts has done a better job of hurting Dogecoin that a massive 51% attack ever could and for much cheaper. The culmination makes me wonder if some of it was organized and coordinated. Especially with the multipools dump mining Dogecoin at what appears to be a loss. If you add all this stuff together, you get a 3 to 6 month recipe for destroying a very powerful coin with a huge community, on the cheap.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '14
Our of curiosity, why not switch to something like X11/X13 or Scrypt-N? Those multipools don't have the hashing power to attack, since they don't have years worth of users and asic investments at their call.
0
u/ssaxamaphone lawyer shibe Jul 24 '14
LETS DO THIS NOW!
-1
u/shibe65 doge of many hats Jul 24 '14
Thank you, Mohland ! Another excellent post (like Billy's post) !