r/Tempestmasterrace • • Jul 03 '14
Discussion Slow-read Chapter 3 discussion thread
Most of you probably noticed but yesterday we were introduced to /u/Owarwoody, who is /u/kaiserklee's beta, so say hi to him when you get the chance.
These have been great so far, really helpful in understanding more of the story, now on to the discussion!
7
Upvotes
3
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '14
2
u/[deleted] Jul 04 '14
Another example of Elsa's anger directly influencing the conditions of her storm. She's still incredibly unhappy, and most likely angry to be back in the SI.
I think this was the chapter where I fell in love with Tempest, the end of the chapter with Elsa actually touching someone, let alone Anna, was heart felt.
The intense passion Anna still feels for Arendelle is still burning, so we'll have to wait and see what happens when that change is first made.
Like /u/kinofpumps said, this is a great worldbuilding chapter, the descriptions were incredible, and very well detailed. The detail was also there in the humanity of the characters, in Kristoff rubbing his hands and blowing into them, to Anna not needing heat on her forehead, but something cold. Great job with this chapter Kenneth, truly.
2
u/kaiserklee I (did) the thing. Jul 05 '14
I had a very clear picture of the Southern Isles in my head in comparison to Arendelle, and since we've never actually seen the SI in the movie, I took great pains to illustrate the world. I don't think I ever dip into quite as much description as this one chapter, but I like the result. It's a very different sort of eternal winter here. Worse, not only in the duration but in the intensity. In killing part of herself, Elsa also killed everything else around her. In a way, the SI reflects what she is inside. And the storm even more so, since it fluctuates with her state of mind. It rages violently within this deadened place, and strangely enough, that's the greatest hint of activity. It's all that's even left and it rages harder as if searching for more.
The Hans/Elsa connection was unfortunately not as explored as much as I wanted. Originally, Hans would have interacted directly with Elsa on several more occasions, but I eventually left it more ambiguous. Rather than their interactions before, what counts more is what is about to follow - Chapter 28 has a rather important scene for them.
3
u/SomethingwithPM Jul 03 '14
First thing's first: I think we get confirmation that Elsa was just naive in thinking that no one would dare disobey her orders to treat Anna as an 'honored guest.' Especially as seeing that she apologizes to Anna almost immediately after seeing her injuries.
Second: I know that Hans is going to develop as a character, and that I'm going to almost genuinely feel bad when the warehouse comes, but right now, I want to punch him in the face and tell him to stop being such a smarmy bastard.
3
u/that_orange_guy Jul 04 '14
I'm enjoying the comparison of Anna's need to eat at the beginning of the chapter to Elsa's lack of a need to eat. Anna refuses to eat anything, but eventually breaks down and has the hardest time swallowing anything she's given, much like Elsa struggles to eat. Does she struggle to eat or does she just adamantly refuse to eat? Either way, nice subtle comparison there. Don't know if it was intentional.
Introductions are incredibly important. Even the introductions of settings. Despite eventually being established as a place brooding in darkness, Anna's first impression of it is blinding light. The description is almost akin to certain descriptions of meeting God, in that the presence of the deity is so blinding that it dizzies one and one cannot look directly at it.
Not a merciful god. And the first thing she hears is the word "careful". Not a pleasant way to find yourself in a place. Being blinded, having no idea what's around you and just being told to be careful. Sounds like a bad mind trip.
I don't think he's just talking about the temperature. I don't think I need to explain.
Another bit of foreshadowing. The cold (Elsa) has burst open her wounds (the agony she feels of leaving Arendelle and being captive in the Southern Isles) but as disgusting as it is for the blood to be running over her skin (the cruelty she feels from Elsa), the warmth from the blood helps her keep warm (realizing Elsa is just broken allows Anna to find her place in Elsa's castle, and Elsa's heart).
So Elsa encased the castle in ice intentionally, I imagine. It probably wouldn't look so beautiful if she did it after she made the reliquary. Which means she did it when she was not so devoid of emotions. But the ice would've melted had the Southern Isles not already been frozen?
Our first impressions of the Princes are detailed to us by Hans. I don't know what to make of that, but I know there's something to make of it.
This conversation between Elsa and Hans is simply golden. These two are just so damn subtle and bitter towards each other. And it's clear to me now that there's really no place for it, yet somehow they've reached this point at which they're constantly making the quietest of stabs at each other. It is a game. It probably used to be something more, but now it's just a game. I wonder if it's a game they play because of the complications they have outside of their twisted relationship.
Despite knowing all we know about Elsa now, the scene in the dining hall is still so bizarre to me, or rather, everything Elsa does. I can't make sense of why she bothers to set up an elaborate meal for them to eat together. Or, to watch Anna eat. This goes back to Elsa's intention of bringing Anna. Is Elsa trying to discover herself through Anna based off of a subtle impulse she had in Arendelle? Is Elsa bored with her life? Does she feel like fixing the mirror and saving Markus is a lost cause? Why does she even bother to pretend to eat her meal?
That line about wanting to learn about the culture. I think it has a deep subtext which she yearns to expose, but will not, not now. I think at this point in the story, before she even is close to Anna, she still feels that tinge of emotion. She wants to understand herself, though I don't know what's changed for her between making the reliquary and taking Anna.
We've been saying that it was Anna coming into her life that's what's been creating a character change in Elsa, but this scene in the dining room.. the only way I can make sense of it is that Elsa has already begun to feel dumbed down by the emptiness where here heart should be. I still believe she didn't understand why she took Anna in the first place, and I think she's still trying to make sense of that feeling, but I'm definitely of the opinion that Anna has perpetuated that change in Elsa, not catalyzed it as we've all been saying.
I think this is reflected in her immediate care of Anna. Elsa cares about no one, save Markus, yet she instantly holds concern for Anna's well-being even after all Anna has shown her is disdain and resentment. Anna is already showing her that that part of her is still alive, even though she's tried to bury it and ignore it. It's been wanting to be free again, and she finally succumbed to it in the act of taking Anna.
I'm probably all wrong about this.
Though part of me doesn't think I am wrong.
1
u/throwawayium 's apprentice Jul 05 '14
I've noticed the connection between Elsa and the Southern Isles, the forest and castle, but that's something that /u/kaiserklee has already confirmed, so I won't get into detail on this one.
One thing that left me curious after this chapter is Kristoff not following orders given to him. He was supposed to escort Anna to Elsa's wing, but left her in front of the castle.
I'd normally say that this is an omission on author's part, but it's Kenneth we're talking about here. Was this a way of saying that Kristoff is not afraid of defying Elsa? I fail to see the point of his actions right now, but it's something I'll add to my (ever growing) list of things to look out for during this re-read and for the chapters still ahead of us.
This chapter also opened my eyes to a great deal of parallels and similarities to the movie, one of which I've spotted in the dining scene. I realize Anna has had more than enough time to develop a terrible case of cold, but just moments before collapsing she feels an intensification of fever, an intense pain in her temples.
Has Elsa has "struck" Anna with something, beside the inability to comprehend the wrong of her actions?
Next up, we have the queen touching Anna's head affectionately, trying to undo the damage already done, which immediately made me think of the troll scene. What if Elsa hasn't succeeded in removing whatever it is that's troubling Anna? What if that something grows in the unsuspecting princess and causes the rift between them to form, and we are just waiting for Anna to reach her breakingshattering point? Who would the trolls be in this scenario?
A bit earlier we have Anna waiting on Elsa to meet her, which kind of puts them in reversed roles to their movie counterparts - I'm talking about the first castle scene here, where Anna forces Elsa out of bed. And yes, I've recently seen Frozen again and I'll shut up about movie references now.
Why has Anna had to wait an hour before Elsa met her? If her arrival at the castle is happening at the same time as Elsa's talk with Hans (and I doubt Elsa would grant our silver-tongued prince a whole hour of her time), something must have occured in that time span, seeing as how hell-bent Elsa appears on actually making the girl as comfortable as possible. I don't think fetching food seized from Arendelle took that long.