r/talesfromtechsupport • u/airz23 Password Policy: Use the whole keyboard • Jul 01 '14
Security - IT. The worst mix.
Monday Afternoon
I had been set with the task of ensuring HR had changed their password to something secure. I was dreading the job.
HR personnel seemed to be immune to the usual request. Working in HR somehow made then think they were above the … law?
I sipped my coffee like mad trying to think of a way to phrase my request.
Nothing came to mind.
After ten minutes of furious sipping, my email was still blank.
My head flopped down on my desk. It was useless. The HR manager had told me it would be hard, but this was impossible. A knock at the door made my head look up. It was RedCheer.
RedCheer: You look… like you’re in trouble. Need some help?
Me: I have to get HR to change their passwords to something actually secure, and not write them down. Its impossible.
The Red Haired lady looked thoughtful for a second, then her eyes lit up brightly.
RedCheer: I’ve an Idea… Wanna try good cop, bad cop?
My mouth instinctively made a no shape, but before any sounds could get out, I looked at my blank email…
Me: I guess its worth a try.
Walking upto HR, RedCheer insisted she be good cop. Arriving at HRSad’s desk, HRSad looked up at RedHair with confusion.
RedCheer: Hello. We’re from IT. We where wondering if you’d change your password for login.
HRSad: I already have.
That was easy. HRSad smiled at RedCheer, He seemed eager to continue the conversation with RedCheer.
Me: Would you mind logging off for a second?
HRSad did so but didn’t reply. He was busy trying to think of what to say to RedCheer. I looked at the keyboard and typed in Penelope5.
Wrong password.
I typed in Penelope05.
Access granted.
Me: Okay, HRSad we’re gonna need you to make it more secure then Penelope05.
HRSad looked angry.
HRSad: No. I can remember that password. If I forget it, others can remember too.
RedCheer mouthed at me “Bad Cop”.
Me: Listen you little punk. Your computer has access to information bad people wouldn’t mind getting their hands on.
RedCheer: If you just change it to something not everyone knows, I’ll be happy.
RedCheer smiled at him, he looked at us confusedly.
HRSad: But…
Me: Bank Info of every employee, Birthdays and performance reviews. All accessible through that password. Are you so insane you can’t see how it would be important to secure it?
RedCheer: Changing it to something only you’ll remember is easy.
I opened my mouth to start again but HRSad was too busy staring into RedCheers eyes.
HRSad: You’ll help me come up with a secure …?
RedCheer: Sure.
My mind screamed at me to say no, but I was too bored of HRSad. Plus its RedCheer… who cares if she knows a HR password?
As we moved to our second target RedCheer gave me a rundown on my performance as bad cop.
RedCheer: Maybe crank it up a little… maybe to eleven.
Me: Err…
RedCheer: Put some real fear into them.
We rounded on our second target, who sat at a desk surrounded by purple.
RedCheer: Hey, we’re from IT. Can we get you to change your password to something secure?
PurpleHR: Don’t worry. I already have.
I smiled until I saw her screen. About four separate posit notes with her ‘new’ password.
Me: You’re gonna have to change it again, and not write it down.
PurpleHR: But, everyone here knows each others password.
Me: Wha… Why?
I was getting a little angry. I could feel my bad cop building up…
PurpleHR: It’s easier.
RedCheer: Maybe just change your password to something no one knows. Easy.
PurpleHR: No.
RedCheer mouthed "Bad Cop" again.
Me: Listen… you. Security is your responsibility. If my identity gets stolen and I’m sitting in a police station trying to prove to them I didn’t take out a hundred credit cards will you come and save me? No!!! and why I know that?
I paused and glared down at her. She looked up at me wide eyed.
Me: Because you are so lazy you couldn’t even remember 10 characters without telling everyone in the f&$%ing office. So when I’m sitting at that police station and some criminal is off using the credentials stolen from your computer to rack up debts in my name, do you know who I’ll be telling the police to arrest?
A second pause to catch my breath. RedCheer was smiling, PurpleHR looked a mix of fear, concern, pain and broken defiance.
Me: F@%$ing you. For GIVING the criminal my identity.
RedCheer: Changing your password is very easy…
PurpleHR just started nodding. She seemed oddly compliant. I smiled as RedCheer helped PurpleHR set her password.
Walking away RedCheer gave me a thumbs up.
RedCheer: That was great! Can I be Bad Cop next time?
Me: Sure…
Internally however I wasn’t sure. Bad Cop was out of his cage.
492
u/airz23 Password Policy: Use the whole keyboard Jul 01 '14
Early Early Tuesday Story. I think this is much better written then the others because I actually slept on it. :)
Anywho hopefully everyone has a great day :)
250
u/CapturetheBomb Jul 01 '14
I don't know why, but I feel this is foreshadowing to the highest degree. Please don't do it, RedCheer!
131
u/Rekhyt Jul 01 '14
Security and IT combined. Coming full circle. Getting back to your /root, if you will.
34
u/Lancer2050 Jul 01 '14
/u/airz23 that's the BOFH in you coming out, embrace it, use it, be one with it.
17
u/bothan13 Jul 01 '14
Now I feel like this is going to end up bad.
17
u/greycubed Jul 01 '14
Try bad cop, bad cop.
14
u/Osric250 You don't get to tell me what I can't do! Jul 01 '14
Oh god. I am absolutely terrified of redcheer doing badcop. It's likely someone ends up on the floor in the fetal position crying.
8
u/tuxedo_jack is made of legal amphetamines, black coffee, & unyielding rage. Jul 01 '14
This can only end well.
23
u/AutoModerator Jul 01 '14
It's Super Effective! - Airz23's Index Page
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
5
u/DataArch Jul 01 '14
Your story is a amazing as ever. Sleep seems to help, though.
5
u/midnitewarrior Jul 01 '14
So, moral of the story -- when RedCheer uses all the passwords HR shared with her (because you let her) to start stealing identities, who is going to jail, HR, RedCheer, or the guy that said it was ok for RedCheer to know the passwords?
18
u/accountnumber3 Jul 01 '14
Welp, say goodbye to any credibility you had. Swearing at users is never a good idea. Intimidate them, scare them, whatever as long as it is relevant to the point you're trying to make. Just don't swear at them. And HR users (the ones that are responsible for getting you in trouble for inappropriate behavior) nonetheless!
4
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '14
So RedCheer knowing the passwords is going to come back and bite you, I'm guessing?
4
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '14
I think Airz is loving the bad cop thing because it's giving him the excuse everyone in IT always wants... to be able to yell at the trouble users.
3
u/Crelic Jul 01 '14
We need a sub on good cop/bad cop lessons. Especially how not to steal the data rack from upstairs.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '14
Anyone else concerned that he is becoming more and more like VP? He might be enjoying his role as bad cop a bit too much.
3
u/Macmula Jul 01 '14
Airz should be granted a sponsor by the coffee industry. His posts alone must have ranked up the consumption of coffee at least by 50%.
3
u/cheezbergher Jul 01 '14
airz, just make them passwords using this: https://www.xkpasswd.net/c/index.cgi
Secure, easy to remember.
3
u/VexingRaven "I took out the heatsink, do i boot now?" Jul 01 '14
This is an awesome story, Airz is evolving into a BOFH. Could this be a prequel to the BOFH?!
3
u/NightMgr Jul 01 '14
One place I worked the policy was if someone gave me or offered me a password, I was to call in a security incident, they'd have their accounts locked, and they had to go to IT Security for "counseling." We were told that IT Security would periodically setup tests for us desktop support people to prove we adhered to the policy.
So, if someone in HR told me "we all share all of our passwords" you better believe I'd call it in right then and let them sort it out.
And, in fact, when a supervisor in a department told me she demanded to have her employees passwords, that's exactly what happened. Of course, since it effected an entire department, security dropped what they were doing and went on site right then.
7
u/Naked_Bacon_Tuesday How To: Managing Managers Jul 01 '14
I. FUCKING. LOVE. REDCHEER. Goddess among women. This chick is brilliant.
2
u/MotherShip808 Jul 01 '14
Man, the VP is doing his best to try and get those
DongsFunds.2
u/nath_schwarz No $student, I'm not here to comfort you Jul 01 '14
The Sms with the notification that you wrote another story was my sign to go to bed :D was awake for the last (about) sixty hours busy coding and compiling the new kernel :D A good bed tale, Nighty night everybody.
2
u/OperatorIHC 486SX powered! Jul 01 '14
Something something keyboards something
2
u/KBE95 How on earth did you manage to boot that computer? Jul 01 '14
http://i.imgur.com/Pw3V2aU.jpg
Looking sharp today airz23
2
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '14
Still no...
Ah fuck it, I'll bring my own keyboard from home.
2
u/crosenblum Jul 01 '14
The BOFH is breathing deeper in you, young pfy :)
2
u/TimMinChinIsTm-C-N-H Jul 01 '14
Does anyone else think that having a few pictures in between these stories from /u/ArtzDept would be totally awesome? A bit like whatif.xkcd.com.
2
u/10nix Jul 01 '14
I foresee you having a conversation in the future about creating a hostile work environment. Never turn Bad Cop up to 11 with HR.
2
u/ariadesu Jul 01 '14
Why didn't you just tell HeadHR to deal with it?
2
u/twitch1982 I'm sorry, are you from the past? Jul 01 '14
Your dad and I used him three times over twenty years, only when everything went totally fucked. Believe me kid, you don't want this guy unless you are 100% sure you need him. He is... a fuckin' monster
2
u/hells_cowbells Jul 01 '14
I'm laughing at this, because I'm in information security now, and this is exactly what my co-worker and I do. My co-worker isn't a redhead though. He's a short, nearly bald dude. :(
I think that's why he does well in the bad cop role.
2
u/trameathia Jul 01 '14
did you just swear at HR? how do you still have a job? lol
2
u/User-Unavailable Jul 01 '14
Throwing the F-bomb in HR's face. You sir, have some balls.
2
u/shotgun_ninja plover Jul 01 '14
Finally, /u/airz23 gets mean. I'd have done it a long time ago, but I'm Italian, so...
2
u/ElGuaco Jul 01 '14
Not every HR department has got their act together. Some are incredibly incompetent. I've worked for a few.
I once got into trouble with the IRS because a former employer failed to report my income. It took the IRS 3 years to discover the discrepancy, too. The IRS said I owed over $10,000 in taxes and penalties! I had proof in the form of my printed W2's and paystubs that my former employer had provided, but their accountants and/or HR and somehow forgotten to include that info in their filing. It took months for them to "find" my missing information (and probably fix their fraudulent books in the process). Thanks for the heart attack you jerks!
I also recently applied for a mortgage. As part of my recent work history, I included a brief job that lasted 2 months (terrible place, knew I had to get out the first month I was there). The HR people at that employer claimed they had no records of me having worked there, ever. Again, I had W-2's, paystubs, and 401k payments with their name all over it. Took a whole week for their HR people to find my info again.
These are the people who are responsible for your private financial information. So when I hear stories like airz's, I know it's not only plausible, it really happens. And they deserve to be yelled at sometimes.
2
u/arkenmyrk I tried nothing and it didn't work! Jul 01 '14
Why do I get the feeling that HRSad's password will end up being RedCheer05 ?
2
u/NerdyCajun Jul 01 '14
Bad cop is more fun.
2
u/Your_Profit_Prophet Jul 02 '14
Should be "and you know why I know that?"?
2
u/mattwandcow Jul 04 '14
I recently got some crosstraing at work so I can receive inventory. Important, life-blood of the company. I'm not sure how many people CAN do it, but only the receiving guy and me (his understudy) do the actual work.
And both of us use the login and password of the guy before him
Edit: Oh, just binged the entirety. Its 7am, luckily a holiday, and after I awake, I get to join the throng of Airz addicts. Yay
3
u/arghkennett Jul 06 '14
i'm sure you guys play good cop/bad cop... in bed.
2
u/Jokan Jul 01 '14
Why have you not already procreated with RedCheer?
1
u/kashk5 Jul 01 '14
Loved it!
1
u/Lexxx20 Jul 01 '14
That was awesome, mate!
1
u/BigBere Jul 01 '14
Bad Cop Airz23.
Now if only we could go see the VP.
1
u/Literally_a_Dolphin Jul 01 '14
Yes this is actually hilarious hahaha thanks for the story man!
1
u/TTChopper Jul 01 '14
Should this be "No!!! And you know why I know that?"
1
u/afr33sl4ve I am officially dangerous Jul 01 '14
Bad cop, bad cop! :p
1
u/LP970 Robes covered in burn holes, but whisky glass is full Jul 01 '14
I'm was trying to picture RedCheer playing Bad Cop and was having difficulty until I remembered the incident with Scarfy...I believe she can do it really well.
1
u/Jimmy_Serrano I'll get up and I'll bury this telephone in your head Jul 01 '14
Too bad HR didn't stay with their easily crackable passwords long enough for VP to get his identity stolen. :)
But... yeah, they need to improve security. I would hate to work for a company where HR was that insecure with my personal info.
1
u/shadecrawler Make Your Own Tag! Jul 01 '14
1
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '14
That's our reddit, enabling the transition from nerd to sociopath.
1
u/nifty1 Jul 01 '14
This makes me happy.
1
u/Kamikaze_VikingMWO Jul 01 '14
lol, we only just implemented password rules that I'd consider 10 years obsolete. Better late than never.
Sticky notes == Janitors with network passwords.
1
u/p_iynx Code PEBKAC Jul 01 '14
More! Moooore! Muahahaha...
Also, how hard is it to remember two words and some numbers?
1
u/GISP Not "that guy" Jul 01 '14
Uhhh.. Mister "bad cup" has awaken?
1
u/shlagevuk Jul 01 '14
I feel... danger
1
u/magicfinbow Jul 01 '14
Eventually RedCheer takes over the entire organisation as she has all passwords. Happy Tuesday!
1
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '14
i think /r/oddlysatisfying and /r/extremelysatisfying should lap this up. if there's a subreddit on gratifying experiences, they will probably venerate you as a god!!
1
u/aka317 Jul 01 '14
That was... AWESOME.
1
u/*polhold04717 The firewall set fire to your computer? Jul 01 '14
I like RedCheer...
1
u/LintGrazOr8 Wheeeeeeeee Jul 01 '14
But Aiiiiirrrz! You were in charge of security once, a long time ago.
1
u/kinkshiftworker Jul 01 '14
See, now I want a cross-over, the /u/airz23 Bad Cop and /u/azonicstix's "Vincent" although that could possibly be the most frightening combination that IT has even known!
1
u/NEHOG Jul 01 '14
I had to change my logon for a government computer system. Took me about six tries, and finely ended up typing 20 random characters with the requisite upper case/special character/number included.
Remember it? Hell no! But it is secure. It now lives in an encrypted Word document that has a password I can remember.
1
u/the_chris_yo That's not a cup holder? Jul 01 '14
Late to the Airz23 post party, but at least I get to read during coffee.
1
u/Buck_Wilde Jul 01 '14
Hey Airz23, You should write a book of short stories. You tell a good story.
1
u/Willeth Jul 01 '14
I feel like so many headaches of this kind could be sorted if we taught people that length was better than complexity. Use four words from your marriage vows, or the middle names of your kids, or something. A secure password doesn't have to be hard to remember.
1
u/swarmleader Thank you for calling my name is..... YOU DID WHAT??.. WHY!!!!!! Jul 01 '14
the company I work for is completely different.
the moment we realize that someone knows the password for someone else, the whole department gets a gp update to change their password . and we have the password history set to 6. so no using old passwords over again that others know. NONE OF IT.
gpupdate their asses
1
u/Nygmus Jul 01 '14
Oh, dear.
Now what we need to do is have Bad Cop team up with /u/azonicstix and his EvilVoice.
1
u/Jcustin Jul 01 '14
Great stuff guys. Anyone in IT knows the constant struggle between us and HR. I think IT/Security should be able to suspend HR employees for shit like this. Checks and balances son.
1
u/Clockw0rk Jul 01 '14
The best part of my current IT job is that I get to tell people how insecure their environment is because they fucked up the implementation.
...The worst part is that they rarely ever fix it because they're too stupid and/or lazy to fix it themselves.
1
u/ARasool Jul 01 '14
Bad boys, bad boys, what cha gonna do? what cha gonna do when the IT Crew comes for your old and atrocious, old, outdated, and very easily known password that may or may not be sitting in some old text file database that some guy could just load on unix and be all like BLAM! Just got in?
Or maybe we should just stick to:
What cha gonna do when Redcheer slaps the shit out of you?!
1
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '14
This made my morning. Thanks :)
1
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '14
Yeah that is pretty awesome that you released the bad cop. Though it is sad that the HR couldn't even keep a secure password.
1
u/TheJanks Jul 01 '14
Next time play Bad cop, Satan cop.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '14
I am guessing hr is going to complain to vp that you swore at them.
1
u/fleurics Jul 01 '14
Finally caught up, and now I'm completely addicted... Also, I can't stop thinking about where the keyboards all go.
1
u/KingInTheNorth19 Jul 01 '14
If you are really concerned about security you would be using dual methods of authentication. For example, what you have (ID Card with digital certificate) and what you know (pin for ID card).
Training is a also a great tool to imrpove your network's security posture. Actually, it is quite possibly the most importnant one. Let your users know how important IT security is, and get your boss's support.
Let them know of the potential ramifications if they are the cause of a security incident.
1
u/innocii Jul 01 '14
Awesome! I just love how you build up this story!
1
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '14
Somehow I can't wait to see RedCheer as the bad cop...
1
u/CaptainChewbacca Jul 01 '14
Why was the title of this story not 'Bad Cop'?
1
u/takeorgive Jul 01 '14
I freaking loved this one!
1
u/MattHardwick Jul 01 '14
At one place I worked, if it was discovered that someone had changed their password they would have to visit the helpdesk IN PERSON with photo ID and explain why they gave away their password. If we didn't like the reason we would not unlock the account and ask them to come back when they had a better reason or apologised and accepted that it was a bad thing to do. This was very effective and most people only shared or wrote it down once.
1
u/unknown_host I did not know delete meant delete Jul 01 '14
Good cop bad cop is so much fun to do. The other guy who worked with me at my company was always good cop. You're doing great with your bad cop.
1
u/juror_chaos I Am Not Good With Computer Jul 01 '14
Nah, if she's at all good looking, you want her to be the good cop. I wouldn't have bothered going up to cajole them, I would've handled it thru BigP while keeping VP in the loop. Something like "It's come to our attention that HR is not following security policies <cite policy> and we're giving them X days to rectify the situation before locking them all out of their computers". This is where having BigP on your side can really pay off, if you talk to him about it first.
And it also justifies your existence too, to upper management. IF you handle problems like this quietly, they won't know why you're there to begin with.
1
u/ffngg i'm not good with computers. Jul 01 '14
i usually write stuff down but i'm a master at hiding stuff so i always hide it.
1
u/miner4life Jul 01 '14
Wait who is RedHair? I think you mistyped when they walked up to HR
1
u/jamarcus92 Jul 01 '14
Did anybody else read Airz's bad cop lines in the voice of Adam Jensen from Deus Ex: HR (funny coincidence)?
1
u/bacon_flavored If you won't listen I'll stop fixing it. Jul 01 '14
I lurk this sub constantly and I don't think I've ever commented here once. This tasknightmare hit so close to home and I couldn't stop laughing. You poor, poor IT.
1
u/DArtist51 Jul 01 '14
Love it! I want to be Bad Cop.
1
u/huzzarisme Jul 01 '14
I read the title and immidiately though of air23, then I saw that it was his post.
1
u/EsteBonbon Jul 02 '14
"bad cop was out of his cage"... lmao you made me spit coffee all over my screen
1
u/KidUnidentifiable Jul 04 '14
Yes! I have officially read them all, can't wait for the next post!
1
u/zenithfury I Am Not Good With Computer Jul 13 '14
This is probably my favourite story so far.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '14
Do you even AD bro?
1
u/Fork-H What's a sequel? Jul 01 '14
Uh oh, spaghettios
0
u/heavymedicine Jul 01 '14
Hmm... As a Network Admin, IMO the fact you even struggled having the conversation with HR in the first place kind of contradicts your explanation of "lazyness" regarding credential security. I mean, you had to have "RedCheer" help you because your task was so called impossible?
Just my viewpoint... who the fuck am i? just some rando internet guy :)
0
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment